On another fansite, ESCXtra, it was ranked 6th out of the 41 songs with 156 points (2 gave it the maximum 12, but one gave it a low of 2) from the 19 reviewers. Reviewer praises included that "All the big touchpoints are here: vocals, song quality, authenticity, and a strong reason to vote.", and "We know that Destiny has the pipes to sing any you song you giver to her. ‘All of My Love’ did not disappoint and was the appropriate choice for the contest. The song suits her voice and I cannot wait to hear Destiny sing this song live, whenever that may be.", though some critics felt that the song was dated.
