Lynn attends her mother's Halloween party. While there, Lynn listens as her mother recounts the story of Mary Bailey, a girl who was mocked all her life for her disfigured physical appearance. As a ghost, Mary rises from the grave every Halloween to laugh at people's appearances behind their backs, as well as take the eyes of those who turn around to look at her. On her way home, Lynn's old car breaks down in the middle of the road. She attempts to fix the engine herself, but in the process, slams the car's hood on her phone, breaking it and leaving her unable to call for help. Forced to finish her trip home on foot, Lynn soon hears sinister cackling in the distance. It is gradually revealed that a shadowy figure, possibly Mary Bailey's ghost, is following her. Terrified, but also remembering her mother's story, Lynn makes a run for it to evade the spirit, and manages not to turn around to see who might be following her. Lynn manages to reach the safety of her house, whereupon she turns around to see nothing, leaving her to believe the spirit has not followed her. As Lynn settles onto her couch to watch a movie, her dog suddenly gets nervous and leaves the room. Not minding her dog's behavior, Lynn smiles and leans back to the couch in satisfaction, only to find Mary Bailey sitting beside her.
