Knapp moved back to Western Canada, and formed a new team in 2016 with Stephanie Schmidt, Brooklyn Lemon and Cori Debert. This lineup lasted just one season, and Knapp joined the Briane Meilleur rink, playing third one the team for the 2017-18 season. The team played in the 2017 Canadian Olympic Pre-Trials, losing in both the A and B finals, just missing out on qualifying for the main event. The team had less success at the 2018 Manitoba Scotties Tournament of Hearts, finishing with a 3-4 record. After the season, Knapp joined the Kristen Streifel rink at third. The team, which was based in Saskatchewan played in the 2019 Saskatchewan Scotties Tournament of Hearts. There, they made the playoffs with a 5-3 record. In the playoffs, they made it as far as the semifinal, where they lost to Team Sherry Anderson. In February 2019, Team Streifel announced that Knapp would be leaving the team after the season and taking a break from curling.
