Sattler joined FC Tampa Bay of the North American Soccer League in 2010. In January 2012 he signed with expansion side San Antonio Scorpions FC in the NASL who would go on to win the Regular Season Title in their Inaugural Season with Sattler as their starting GK, winning the NASL Golden Gloves Award. He signed with expansion side Minnesota United FC in 2013, but was injured early in the season. In 2014, he re-signed with San Antonio and became NASL Champions.
