Clash magazine said in its review that "Until Spring is a romantically epic album, lovingly pieced together by a compelling band." Parts of the album were characterised as "murky, overcast and at times tedious" by Loud and Quiet review. A review by musicOMH referred to lead singer "Hill's voice [a]s a continual point of interest" but also said the album "suffers from falling short in execution of [its] idea[s]."
