On the opening day of the 2011–12 season, the side lost 3–1 against newcomers Bulolo United, a result which would reflect another semi-consistent season, in which clubs faced each other three times over the course of the season, rather than twice. The side ended up in fifth place in the regular season table, but entered the knockout stages nevertheless, although it is unclear why. The side came up against reigning champions and Minor Premiers Hekari United, and despite fighting hard, went down 3–1. In the third-place playoff, the side took Besta PNG all the way to a penalty shoot-out before losing 4–3 after the spot kicks.
