In 1876 the architect T. H. Wyatt restored the building at the expense of the Earl of Macclesfield. In 1943 All Saints' parish was combined with that of St. Mary's, Pyrton. The combined parish is now part of the Benefice of Icknield.The Benefice of Icknield: All Saints Church, Shirburn All Saints' Church became redundant in 1995 and now belongs to the Churches Conservation Trust.
