The first purpose-built Anglican church in the area was the Church of All Saints, located on All Saints Road, just off the south side of Falsgrave Road built in 1868. The rising population of the suburb prompted the vicar of St Mary's Church in Scarborough to build a daughter church in Faslgrave. The church was built in 1867, consecrated in 1868 by the archbishop of York, but it was not the seat of an ecclesiastical parish until 1875. The population of the ecclesiastical parish in 1881 was 7,650. All saints was demolished in 1975.
