Following Randleman's CBS interview, Miami's Athletic Director announced that they had found zero evidence and were concluding their investigation after "a school review of multiple videos and social media posts and interviews with possible witnesses revealed no evidence of wrongdoing by (Miami) players." Appalachian State subsequently closed their investigation as well after it was unable to find any credible evidence backing up Randleman's claims. Appalachian State's Associate Athletics Director Zeke Beam noted that "the University of Miami went above and beyond to review the incident."
