Sanford's name came up in trade rumors early in the season, as the Yankees were in need of left-handed pitching. He responded to these rumors by getting off to a 4–0 start; shortly after which, the Yankees acquired left hander Joe Ostrowski from the Browns without departing with Sanford. From that point forward, Sanford's record fell to 1–4 with a 5.40 ERA. Having been a starter in the early part of the season, Sanford was demoted to the bullpen in June, making just one spot start in August. The Yankees returned to the World Series in , however, Sanford was once again kept out of all four games with the Philadelphia Phillies. The Yankees won the World Series both seasons Sanford was with the club, but he did not make a postseason appearance.
