God of Every Story garnered positive reception from music critics to critique the album. Grace S. Aspinwall of CCM Magazine felt that "the album emanates from a place of vulnerability". At Worship Leader, Jeremy Armstrong felt that "On the congregational front, the songs are a bit hidden, but a little digging will find some true gold." Kevin Davis of New Release Tuesday called this "a Spirit-filled and emotional listening experience." At Cross Rhythms, Joanna Costin noted this release as "an uplifting and beautiful album."
