A four-time All-SEC selection, Brombacher also received All-America honors in 2009, 2010, and 2011. In addition to being a three-time member of the SEC Academic Honor Roll and a three-time Academic All-American, Brombacher was also named a candidate for the Senior CLASS Award for softball in 2011. Brombacher would go on to help lead the Gators softball teams to four SEC Eastern Division titles, two SEC championships, and SEC tournament titles in 2008 and 2009. She was part of the first senior class in SEC history to make four consecutive Women's College World Series appearances (2008-2011). Her Gators team garnered national runner-up finishes to Washington in 2009 and Arizona State in 2011.
