With Brenda in Paris, Dylan starts spending a great deal of time with Kelly, helping her babysit her little sister and entering a doubles beach volleyball tournament with her. The two have a strictly physical affair, but Kelly ends it out of loyalty to Brenda. Upon Brenda's return from Paris, she and Dylan reunite. This doesn't last long though, as Brenda (who also had an affair) runs into the man she was seeing in Paris at a video store and starts seeing him behind Dylan's back. Dylan and Brenda break up, and Dylan heads straight for Kelly. This doesn't last long either, however. After Brenda sees them on a date and gets angry at them, they take a step back from their potential relationship. Dylan, confused about his relationships with both women, takes a road trip to get away from them. When he returns, Kelly and Brenda tell him to make a choice. When Brenda is unable to show up when he invites both girls to see his father, he decides to choose Kelly.
