Süperstar '83 received positive reviews from music criticism and was considered Pekkan's return to the pop music scene after a few years in crisis. Hey magazine gave the album a grade of 5/5, appreciating the singer's vocals and the new arrangements of the cover songs made by Garo Mafyan. It considered Pekkan's decision to use foreign compositions on this album as an appropriate step, and added, "Ajda has a dress that has been compiled from foreign compositions so far. And when she takes off this dress and throws it away, she gets naked. The Arabesque clothing worn on her also does not suit her. In Ajda's [previous] LPs released by other labels, the 'domestic composition, domestic artist' mindset made this mistake bigger and the singer became distanced from the pop source that had created her. ... Pekkan's international platform pushes the artist to find foreign pieces that will maintain their [quality] level." Gündüz Tuna from Milliyet newspaper, on the other hand, said "This last album is the opposite of the previous records smells very Western." Because of the newly tested 16-channel system, he found the record's sound quality "low enough to [make you] search for the previous albums".
