Tuca and Bertie was nominated for three awards, winning one, at the 47th Annie Awards, all for the episode "The Jelly Lakes". It was nominated for Best General Audience Animated TV/Film and Outstanding Achievement for Voice Acting (for Ali Wong), and Outstanding Achievement for Writing (for Shauna McGarry). On January 25, 2020, McGarry won the Outstanding Achievement for Writing for "The Jelly Lakes". The episode "Planteau" won the Animation category at the 74th Writers Guild of America Awards. The episode "The Pain Garden" was nominated for Best TV/Media - Mature at the 2023 Annie Awards.
