Exploring the island, the survivors witness a stranger running through a wood and find a cave on a cliff which they make their new home. While out collecting food, Helen encounters Blake - a pirate left behind during an earlier raid - and shelters from a storm with him. He declines the offer to join the group due to his past, and advises Helen to conceal her medallion. She is later captured by a giant raven, but is rescued by Blake and the stranger. Blake recognizes him as Atherton, a former member of Harvey's crew who was abandoned after a mutiny.
