She reprised her role as Lucy Gennero-McClane in A Good Day to Die Hard (2013) and returned to television with roles in the supernatural drama series The Returned (2015), the political satire science fiction comedy series BrainDead (2016), the period medical drama series Mercy Street (2016–17) and the black comedy crime drama anthology series Fargo (2017). Her other roles include the comedy drama All About Nina (2018), the action thriller film Gemini Man (2019), and as the Huntress in Birds of Prey (2020).
