In 2011, Rogers began performances in the West End production of The 39 Steps, as Annabella Schmidt, Margaret and Pamela (succeeding well-known Wicked actress Dianne Pilkington).(31 January 2011). The 39 Steps cast change at Criterion Theatre, londontheatre.co.uk In 2014, she played the role of Kay Summersby in the play Pressure at the Royal Lyceum Theatre in Edinburgh and the Chichester Festival. She later joined the play's touring revival in 2018.
