In a mixed review, Abby Jones, writing for Pitchfork said that Kiss My Super Bowl Ring is "proudly defiant; the title, Wyatt has clarified, essentially means “kiss my ass.” But where deviation from the norm has spawned countless artistic geniuses, Super Bowl Ring too often comes off as just a hodgepodge of ideas. “Vada vada,” it seems, has hurt the Garden as much as it's helped them." Jones ultimately gave the album a 6.4 out of 10.
