Writing for Heavy Mag, Carl Neumann summarized the album as "essentially a mix of all Helloween albums in one. You have classic power metal, hard rock, speed metal and good ‘ol rock n roll all mixed into 12 songs within a duration of 65 minutes. It would be impossible for 'Helloween' to be a flop. It has EVERYTHING that is Helloween. Therefore it is aptly titled."
