The next year, StarKid later livestreamed Nightmare Time 2, the second season of the series. Four performances took place virtually on October 23 & 30 and November 6 & 13, 2021. The entire cast from the first season returned with the exceptions of Robert Manion & Kendall Nicole Yakshe. The series was also the StarKid debut of Bryce Charles and Jae Hughes. The episodes were released weekly on StarKid's YouTube channel between May 20, 2022 and June 10, 2022.
