Fancelli maintains homes in Lakeland and Longboat Key, Florida; and Florence, her primary residence. Fancelli is the president of the George Jenkins Foundation; in 2020, the foundation reported net assets of $27.7 million, and gave more than $3.3 million to charities that provide education, health care and social services to poor children and the elderly. Fancelli has also been praised for her commitment to the elderly.
