The Grand Lodge had outgrown the structure by 1874 and had started meeting elsewhere due to its dilapidated and neglected state. Other venues in the city had become more fashionable for performances. In 1876, it was sold to the Raleigh Primitive Baptist Church, who dismantled the building by 1880. The cornerstone was recovered from the site and is currently on display at the current Grand Lodge office museum. The Norman Adrian Wiggins School of Law of Campbell University and its parking structure now occupy the site.
