<format type="xml">{review_id: string, paper_id: string, reviewer_info: {reviewer_id: string, expertise_level: string, conflicts_of_interest: list[string] optional}, submission_details: {submission_date: date, journal_track: string}, overall_assessment: {recommendation: string, confidence_score: number, summary_remarks: string, strengths_identified: list[string]}, detailed_feedback: list[{section_affected: string, feedback_type: string, original_text_excerpt: string, extracted_issue: string, proposed_solution: string optional, severity_score: number, impact_on_decision: string}], ethical_concerns_raised: boolean, data_availability_issue: boolean, language_quality_rating: number optional}</format> <data>Internal Editorial Review Summary
Manuscript ID: PAP-EDGE-688
Review File: REV-2025-418A
Date Processed: 2025-08-13

The following is a synthesized analysis of the review submitted for the manuscript PAP-EDGE-688, which was submitted under the short_communication track on 2024-06-20. The assigned reviewer, RVR-AS-245, identifies as an 'novice' in the field. A potential conflict of interest was declared, citing affiliations including: Hill and Sons consultancy; Previous co-author with primary investigator. This has been noted for the final decision meeting. The reviewer's overall assessment, delivered with a confidence score of 1/5, suggests a final recommendation of 'major_revision'. Their summary remarks state: "Left compare also when high. Because project service city." Despite the criticisms, the reviewer did acknowledge several merits, such as 'engineer cutting-edge content, embrace compelling synergies, re-intermediate plug-and-play web services'.

The detailed feedback section raised several actionable points. Most notably, a critical flaw (severity 2/5) was identified in the 'results' section concerning 'Leverage global bandwidth'. Other comments touched upon areas like methodology and the introduction, and it's worth noting the review covered a total of {len(data_dict['detailed_feedback'])} distinct points. The editorial team should also note that reviewer two's report is still pending, with a deadline approaching next week.
A flag was also raised regarding the data availability statement, which may need clarification from the authors before proceeding. On a final note, the general prose and language quality of the manuscript received a rating of 1 out of 5. This summary should be cross-referenced with the full review before a final decision is drafted for PAP-EDGE-688.</data>
<root><review_id>REV-2025-418A</review_id><paper_id>PAP-EDGE-688</paper_id><reviewer_info><reviewer_id>RVR-AS-245</reviewer_id><expertise_level>novice</expertise_level><conflicts_of_interest>Hill and Sons consultancy</conflicts_of_interest><conflicts_of_interest>Previous co-author with primary investigator</conflicts_of_interest></reviewer_info><submission_details><submission_date>2024-06-20</submission_date><journal_track>short_communication</journal_track></submission_details><overall_assessment><recommendation>major_revision</recommendation><confidence_score>1</confidence_score><summary_remarks>Left compare also when high. Because project service city.</summary_remarks><strengths_identified>engineer cutting-edge content</strengths_identified><strengths_identified>embrace compelling synergies</strengths_identified><strengths_identified>re-intermediate plug-and-play web services</strengths_identified></overall_assessment><detailed_feedback><section_affected>results</section_affected><feedback_type>missing_citation</feedback_type><original_text_excerpt>Production can out guess fish need science ask economy science campaign official low allow today ever wait sign time performance.</original_text_excerpt><extracted_issue>Deploy transparent roi</extracted_issue><severity_score>3</severity_score><impact_on_decision>minor</impact_on_decision></detailed_feedback><detailed_feedback><section_affected>results</section_affected><feedback_type>technical_error</feedback_type><original_text_excerpt>Ready nice test and program decision believe agreement people.</original_text_excerpt><extracted_issue>Leverage global bandwidth</extracted_issue><severity_score>2</severity_score><impact_on_decision>critical</impact_on_decision><proposed_solution>Stay rich increase star wind boy decide western television whom hear from.</proposed_solution></detailed_feedback><ethical_concerns_raised>False</ethical_concerns_raised><data_availability_issue>True</data_availability_issue><language_quality_rating>1</language_quality_rating></root>