Tuhia he haere tonu mo tenei irava - I muri i te wa i runga i te ara motuhake me te tau i muri i te huihuinga o te whare, ka hoki mai a Finlay ki WWE i te 11 o Hurae 2012 hei kaihanga o muri. I whakawhitiwhiti korero nga taha e rua mai i te WrestleMania XXVIII, engari i reira nga ahuatanga i whakaroa ai te kirimana. I roto i nga tau e whai ake nei, i puta mai a Finlay i etahi ahuatanga, i te nuinga o te wa e wehe ana i nga kaiwhawhai whawhai. Ko ia hoki tetahi o nga kaiwhawhai e wha i whakawhiwhia ki a Tyler Bate me te WWE UK Championship i muri i te wikitoria a Bate i te whakataetae e pa ana ki a ia i te Hanuere 2017. I muri i te kore e taea e Lana te whakataetae i te whakataetae Royal Rumble wahine 2019
I muri i te whakaekenga a Nia Jax i tana urunga, ka whakaaetia e Finlay te hoa whawhai Irish a Becky Lynch ki te whakakapi i a Lana; Ka wikitoria a Lynch i te tukinga, ka mutu ko WrestleMania 35, i reira ka wikitoria ia i te Raw Women's Championship me te SmackDown Women's Championship i roto i te Winner Takes All triple threat match ki a Ronda Rousey me Charlotte Flair.