I te 8 o Hānuere 1909, ka mutu a Hatch i te tuatoru i muri i a Matthew Maloney raua ko James Crowley i roto i te marathon o roto i mua i te 5,000 nga kaimātakitaki "whakamoemiti" i tu i roto i te Madison Square Garden tuarua
(3:03:29.4) Ko te tikanga, ko te mea nui. I ripoatahia a Maloney i whakatakoto i tetahi rekoata hou mo te huihuinga (2:54:45.4).