Tuhia he tomokanga mō tēnei wāhanga - I Te Hononga o Amerika, ka wehe a Dwight Macdonald i a Trotsky, ka wehe i te rōpū Trotskyist Socialist Workers Party mā te whakaara i te pātai o te rerenga o Kronstadt
, i tino tukinotia e Trotsky hei kaiārahi o te ope Whero o te Soviet me ētahi atu Bolsheviks. Katahi ka neke atu ia ki te hapori manapori me te anarchism. He whakahē ōrite i runga i te tūranga o Trotsky i runga i nga kaupapa a tawhio noa te tutu Kronstadt i whakaarahia e te Lithuanian-American anarchist Emma Goldman. I roto i tana tuhinga "Trotsky Protests Too Much", ka mea ia: "E whakaae ana ahau, ko te mana whakahaere i raro i te mana o Stalin kua tino kino. Heoi anō, e kore e whakaiti i te hara o Leon Trotsky hei tētahi o nga kaiwhakaari i roto i te whakaari o te hurihanga o Kronstadt ko tetahi o nga whakaaturanga toto rawa". I tiakina e Trotsky nga mahi a te ope Whero i roto i tana tuhinga "Hue and Cry over Kronstadt".