Monteith meunangkeun Teen Choice Award 2011 dina kategori Choice TV: Actor Comedy pikeun ngagambarkeun Finn, sarta jadi anggota "Glee" cast ensemble dibéré Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series award di 16th Screen Actors Guild Awards
. tapi Manéhna narima sababaraha nominasi séjénna pikeun peran, kaasup Teen Choice Awards dina 2009 pikeun Choice TV: Breakout Star Male jeung dina 2010 pikeun Choice TV: Comedy Actor, jeung nominasi ensemble 17th Screen Actors Guild Awards pikeun Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series.