dina édisi 2019, US News & World Report ngaréngking Colgate minangka 16th-best liberal arts college in the country (dipasing jeung Hamilton College). Kampus universitas ieu ngaréngking minangka nu paling éndah ku The Princeton Review dina édisi 2010. Dina Juli 2008, Colgate ngaranna kalima dina daptar Forbes's Top Colleges for Getting Rich, hiji-hijina non-Ivy League college di luhur 5. Colgate didaptarkeun salaku salah sahiji 25 "New Ivies" Amérika ku majalah Newsweek.
100 kampus pangalusna pikeun siswa LGBT