r; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Scott Bales, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur<br/><br/></span></td>
                </tr><tr id="dnn_ctr9904_ViewAOC_Opinions_gvList_ctl03_trSummary">
                    <td colspan="4">&nbsp;</td><td colspan="3"><b><span style='color:DarkRed'>Constitutionality Decision</span></b><br /><p style="margin: auto 0in;">Holding that SB 1609 (2011) violates Article 29, Section 1(C) of the Arizona Constitution by diminishing and impairing public retirement 