 your caricatures.

SS: No mechanism, no phenomenon.

JA: Another oldie but goodie from Aristotle.

SS: I hope you are able to afford all these snide putdowns.
    Otherwise you may go the way of Peirce himself (and
    probably like it too!).

I cannot imagine how &quot;oldie but goodie&quot; can be taken as a put-down,
but then, how could know what's in my record collection?  Anyway,
I was only remarking on Aristotle's fundamental insight about
the demarcation of science from many other things with which
