  The objectives were to develop a novel three-dimensional technology for
imaging naturally occurring shear wave (SW) propagation, demonstrate
feasibility on human volunteers and quantify SW velocity in different
propagation directions. Imaging of natural SWs generated by valve closures has
emerged to obtain a direct measurement of cardiac stiffness. Recently, natural
SW velocity was assessed in two dimensions on parasternal long axis view under
the assumption of a propagation direction along the septum. However, in this
approach the source localization and the complex three-dimensional propagation
wave path was neglected making the speed estimation unreliable. High volume
rate transthoracic acquisitions of the human left ventricle (1100 volume/s) was
performed with a 4D ultrafast echocardiographic scanner. Four-dimensional
tissue velocity cineloops enabled visualization of aortic and mitral valve
closure waves. Energy and time of flight mapping allowed propagation path
visualization and source localization, respectively. Velocities were quantified
along different directions. Aortic and mitral valve closure SW velocities were
assessed for the three volunteers with low standard deviation. Anisotropic
propagation was also found suggesting the necessity of using a
three-dimensional imaging approach. Different velocities were estimated for the
three directions for the aortic (3.4$\pm$0.1 m/s, 3.5$\pm$0.3 m/s, 5.4$\pm$0.7
m/s) and the mitral (2.8$\pm$0.5 m/s, 2.9$\pm$0.3 m/s, 4.6$\pm$0.7 m/s) valve
SWs. 4D ultrafast ultrasound alleviates the limitations of 2D ultrafast
ultrasound for cardiac SW imaging based on natural SW propagations and enables
a comprehensive measurement of cardiac stiffness. This technique could provide
stiffness mapping of the left ventricle.
