  We present a different symplectic point of view in the definition of weighted
modulation spaces $M^{p,q}_m(\mathbb{R}^d)$ and weighted Wiener amalgam spaces
$W(\mathcal{F} L^p_{m_1},L^q_{m_2})(\mathbb{R}^d)$. All of the classical
time-frequency representations, such as the short-time Fourier transform
(STFT), the $\tau$-Wigner distributions and the ambiguity function, can be
written as metaplectic Wigner distributions $\mu(\mathcal{A})(f\otimes
\bar{g})$, where $\mu(\mathcal{A})$ is the metaplectic operator and
$\mathcal{A}$ is the associated symplectic matrix. Namely, time-frequency
representations can be represented as images of metaplectic operators, which
become the real protagonists of time-frequency analysis. In [E. Cordero and L.
Rodino (2022) "Characterization of Modulation Spaces by symplectic
representations and applications to Schr\"odinger equations",
arXiv:2204.14124], the authors suggest that any metaplectic Wigner distribution
that satisfies the so-called "shift-invertibility" condition can replace the
STFT in the definition of modulation spaces. In this work, we prove that
shift-invertibility alone is not sufficient, but it has to be complemented by
an upper-triangularity condition for this characterization to hold, whereas a
lower-triangularity property comes in to play for Wiener amalgam spaces. The
shift-invertibility property is necessary: Ryhaczek and and conjugate Ryhaczek
distributions are not shift-invertible and they fail the characterization of
the above spaces. We also exhibit examples of shift-invertible distributions
without upper-tryangularity condition which do not define modulation spaces.
Finally, we provide new families of time-frequency representations that
characterize modulation spaces, with the purpose of replacing the
time-frequency shifts with other atoms that allow to decompose signals
differently, with possible new outcomes in applications.
