  We mine the leaked history of trades on Mt. Gox, the dominant Bitcoin
exchange from 2011 to early 2014, to detect the triangular arbitrage activity
conducted within the platform. The availability of user identifiers per trade
allows us to focus on the historical record of 440 investors, detected as
arbitrageurs, and consequently to describe their trading behavior. We begin by
showing that a considerable difference appears between arbitrageurs when
indicators of their expertise are taken into account. In particular, we
distinguish between those who conducted arbitrage in a single or in multiple
markets: using this element as a proxy for trade ability, we find that
arbitrage actions performed by expert users are on average non-profitable when
transaction costs are accounted for, while skilled investors conduct arbitrage
at a positive and statistically significant premium. Next, we show that
specific trading strategies, such as splitting orders or conducting arbitrage
non aggressively, are further indicators of expertise that increase the
profitability of arbitrage. Most importantly, we exploit within-user (across
hours and markets) variation and document that expert users make profits on
arbitrage by reacting quickly to plausible exogenous variations on the official
exchange rates. We present further evidence that such differences are chiefly
due to a better ability of the latter in incorporating information, both on the
transactions costs and on the exchange rates volatility, eventually resulting
in a better timing choice at small time scale intervals. Our results support
the hypothesis that arbitrageurs are few and sophisticated users.
