  For $p,q\in [1,\infty)$, we study the isomorphism problem for the $p$- and
$q$-convolution algebras associated to locally compact groups. While it is well
known that not every group can be recovered from its group von Neumann algebra,
we show that this is the case for the algebras $\mathrm{CV}_p(G)$ of
$p$-convolvers and $\mathrm{PM}_p(G)$ of $p$-pseudomeasures, for $p\neq 2$.
More generally, we show that if $\mathrm{CV}_p(G)$ is isometrically isomorphic
to $\mathrm{CV}_q(H)$, with $p,q\neq 2$, then $G$ must be isomorphic to $H$ and
$p$ and $q$ are either equal or conjugate. This implies that there is no
$L^p$-version of Connes' uniqueness of the hyperfinite II$_1$-factor. Similar
results apply to the algebra $\mathrm{PF}_p(G)$ of $p$-pseudofunctions,
generalizing a classical result of Wendel. We also show that other
$L^p$-rigidity results for groups can be easily recovered and extended using
our main theorem.
  Our results answer questions originally formulated in the work of Herz in the
70's. Moreover, our methods reveal new information about the Banach algebras in
question. As a non-trivial application, we verify the reflexivity conjecture
for all Banach algebras lying between $\mathrm{PF}_p(G)$ and
$\mathrm{CV}_p(G)$: if any such algebra is reflexive and amenable, then $G$ is
finite.
