  Using a Hilbert space framework inspired by the methods of orthogonal
projections and Hodge decompositions, we study a general class of problems
(called Z-problems) that arise in effective media theory, especially within the
theory of composites, for defining the effective operator. A new and unified
approach is developed, based on block operator methods, for obtaining solutions
of the Z-problem, formulas for the effective operator in terms of the Schur
complement, and associated variational principles (e.g., the Dirichlet and
Thomson minimization principles) that lead to upper and lower bounds on the
effective operator. In the case of finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, this
allows for a relaxation of the standard hypotheses on positivity and
invertibility for the classes of operators usually considered in such problems,
by replacing inverses with the Moore-Penrose pseudoinverse. As we develop the
theory, we show how it applies to the classical example from the theory of
composites on the effective conductivity in the periodic conductivity problem
in the continuum (2d and 3d) under the standard hypotheses. After that, we
consider the following three important and diverse examples of discrete
electrical network problems in which our theory applies under the relaxed
hypotheses. First, an operator-theoretic reformulation of the discrete
Dirichlet-to-Neumann (DtN) map for an electrical network on a finite linear
graph is given and used to relate the DtN map to the effective operator of an
associated Z-problem.\ Second, we show how the classical effective conductivity
of an electrical network on a finite linear graph is essentially the effective
operator of an associated Z-problem. Finally, we consider electrical networks
on periodic linear graphs and develop a discrete analog to classical example of
the periodic conductivity equation and effective conductivity in the continuum.
