  A central challenge in the study of protein evolution is the identification
of historic amino acid sequence changes responsible for creating novel
functions observed in present-day proteins. To address this problem, we
developed a new method to identify and rank amino acid mutations in ancestral
protein sequences according to their function-shifting potential. Our approach
scans the changes between two reconstructed ancestral sequences in order to
find (1) sites with sequence changes that significantly deviate from our
model-based probabilistic expectations, (2) sites that demonstrate extreme
changes in mutual information, and (3) sites with extreme gains or losses of
information content. By taking the overlaps of these statistical signals, the
method accurately identifies cryptic evolutionary patterns that are often not
obvious when examining only the conservation of modern-day protein sequences.
We validated this method with a training set of previously-discovered
function-shifting mutations in three essential protein families in animals and
fungi, whose evolutionary histories were the prior subject of systematic
molecular biological investigation. Our method identified the known
function-shifting mutations in the training set with a very low rate of false
positive discovery. Further, our approach significantly outperformed other
methods that use variability in evolutionary rates to detect functional loci.
The accuracy of our approach indicates it could be a useful tool for generating
specific testable hypotheses regarding the acquisition of new functions across
a wide range of protein families.
