  Surface graphs have been used in many application domains to represent
three-dimensional (3D) data. Another approach to representing 3D data is making
projections onto two-dimensional (2D) graphs. This approach will result in
multiple displays, which is time-consuming in switching between different
screens for a different perspective. In this work, we study the performance of
3D version of popular 2D visualization techniques for time series: horizon
graph, small multiple, and simple line graph. We explore discrimination tasks
with respect to each visualization technique that requires simultaneous
representations. We demonstrate our study by visualizing saturated thickness of
the Ogallala aquifer - the Southern High Plains Aquifer of Texas in multiple
years. For the evaluation, we design comparison and discrimination tasks and
automatically record result performed by a group of students at a university.
Our results show that 3D small multiples perform well with stable accuracy over
numbers of occurrences. On the other hand, shared-space visualization within a
single 3D coordinate system is more efficient with small number of simultaneous
graphs. 3D horizon graph loses its competence in the 3D coordinate system with
the lowest accuracy comparing to other techniques. Our demonstration of 3D
spatial-temporal is also presented on the Southern High Plains Aquifer of Texas
from 2010 to 2016.
