  When estimating a phylogeny from a multiple sequence alignment, researchers
often assume the absence of recombination. However, if recombination is
present, then tree estimation and all downstream analyses will be impacted,
because different segments of the sequence alignment support different
phylogenies. Similarly, convergent selective pressures at the molecular level
can also lead to phylogenetic tree incongruence across the sequence alignment.
Current methods for detection of phylogenetic incongruence are not equipped to
distinguish between these two different mechanisms and assume that the
incongruence is a result of recombination or other horizontal transfer of
genetic information. We propose a new recombination detection method that can
make this distinction, based on synonymous codon substitution distances.
Although some power is lost by discarding the information contained in the
nonsynonymous substitutions, our new method has lower false positive
probabilities than the comparable recombination detection method when the
phylogenetic incongruence signal is due to convergent evolution. We apply our
method to three empirical examples, where we analyze: 1) sequences from a
transmission network of the human immunodeficiency virus, 2) tlpB gene
sequences from a geographically diverse set of 38 Helicobacter pylori strains,
and 3) Hepatitis C virus sequences sampled longitudinally from one patient.
