  With today's technologies it seems easier than ever to augment everyday
things with the ability to perceive their environment and to talk to users.
Considering conversational user interfaces, tremendous progress has already
been made in designing and evaluating task oriented conversational interfaces,
such as voice assistants for ordering food, booking a flight etc. However, it
is still very challenging to design smart things that can have with their users
an informal conversation and emotional exchange, which requires the smart thing
to master the usage of social everyday utterances, using irony and sarcasm,
delivering good compliments, etc. In this paper, we focus on the experience
design of compliments and the Complimenting Mirror design. The paper reports in
detail on three phases of a human-centered design process including a Wizard of
Oz study in the lab with 24 participants to explore and identify the effect of
different compliment types on user experiences and a consequent field study
with 105 users in an architecture museum with a fully functional installation
of the Complimenting Mirror. In our analyses we argue why and how a "smart"
mirror should compliment users and provide a theorization applicable for
affective interaction design with things in more general. We focus on
subjective user feedback including user concerns and prepositions of receiving
compliments from a thing and on observations of real user behavior in the field
i.e. transitions of bodily affective expressions comparing affective user
states before, during, and after compliment delivery. Our research shows that
compliment design matters significantly and using the right type of compliments
in our final design in the field test, we succeed in achieving reactive
expressions of positive emotions, "sincere" smiles and laughter, even from the
seemingly sternest users.
