  Gravity is commonly thought of as one of the four force fields in nature.
However, in standard formulations its mathematical structure is rather
different from the Yang-Mills fields of particle physics that govern the
electromagnetic, weak, and strong interactions. This paper explores this
dissonance with particular focus on how gravity couples to matter from the
perspective of the Cartan-geometric formulation of gravity. There the
gravitational field is represented by a pair of variables: 1) a `contact
vector' $V^A$ which is geometrically visualized as the contact point between
the spacetime manifold and a model spacetime being `rolled' on top of it, and
2) a gauge connection $A_{\mu}^{\ph\mu AB}$, taken to be valued in the Lie
algebra of SO(2,3) or SO(1,4), which mathematically determines how much the
model spacetime is rotated when rolled. By insisting on two principles, the
{\em gauge principle} and {\em polynomial simplicity}, we show how one can
reformulate the standard matter field actions in a way that is harmonious with
Cartan's geometric construction. This yields a formulation of all matter fields
in terms of first order partial differential equations. We show in detail how
the standard second order formulation can be recovered. Furthermore, the
energy-momentum and spin-density three-forms are naturally combined into a
single object here denoted the spin-energy-momentum three-form. Finally, we
highlight a peculiarity in the mathematical structure of our first-order
formulation of Yang-Mills fields. This suggests a way to unify a U(1) gauge
field with gravity into a SO(1,5)-valued gauge field using a natural
generalization of Cartan geometry in which the larger symmetry group is
spontaneously broken down to $SO(1,3)\times U(1)$. The coupling of this unified
theory to matter fields and possible extensions to non-Abelian gauge fields are
left as open questions.
