  Given a chemical reaction going from reactant (R) to the product (P) on a
potential energy surface (PES) and a collective variable (CV) that
discriminates between R and P, one can define a free-energy profile (FEP) as
the logarithm of the marginal Boltzmann distribution of the CV. The FEP is not
a true free energy, however, it is common to treat the FEP as the free-energy
analog of the minimum energy path on the PES and to take the activation free
energy, $\Delta F^\ddagger_\mathrm{RP}$, as the difference between the maximum
of the FEP at the transition state and the minimum at R. We show that this
approximation can result in large errors. Since the FEP depends on the CV, it
is therefore not unique, and different, discriminating CVs can yield different
activation free energies for the same reaction. We derive an exact expression
for the activation free energy that avoids this ambiguity with respect to the
choice of CV. We find $\Delta F^\ddagger_\mathrm{RP}$ to be a combination of
the probability of the system being in the reactant state, the probability
density at the transition state surface, and the thermal de~Broglie wavelength
associated with the transition from R to P. We then evaluate the activation
free energies based on our formalism for simple analytic models and realistic
chemical systems. The analytic models show that the widespread FEP-based
approximation applies only at low temperatures for CVs for which the effective
mass of the associated pseudo-particle is small. Most chemical reactions of
practical interest involve polyatomic molecules with complex, high-dimensional
PES that cannot be treated analytically and pose the added challenge of
choosing a good CV, typically through heuristics. We study the influence of the
choice of CV and find that, while the reaction free energy is largely
unaffected, $\Delta F^\ddagger_\mathrm{RP}$ is quite sensitive.
