  Potassium-40 is a widespread isotope whose radioactivity impacts estimated
geological ages spanning billions of years, nuclear structure theory, and
subatomic rare-event searches - including those for dark matter and
neutrinoless double-beta decay. The decays of this long-lived isotope must be
precisely known for its use as a geochronometer, and to account for its
presence in low-background experiments. There are several known decay modes for
$^{40}$K, but a predicted electron-capture decay directly to the ground state
of argon-40 has never been observed, while theoretical predictions span an
order of magnitude. The KDK Collaboration reports on the first observation of
this rare decay, obtained using a novel combination of a low-threshold X-ray
detector surrounded by a tonne-scale, high-efficiency $\gamma$-ray tagger at
Oak Ridge National Laboratory. A blinded analysis reveals a distinctly nonzero
ratio of intensities of ground-state electron-captures ($I_{\text{EC}^0}$) over
excited-state ones ($I_{\text{EC}^*}$) of $I_{\text{EC}^0} /
I_{\text{EC}^*}=0.0095\stackrel{\text{stat}}{\pm}0.0022\stackrel{\text{sys}}{\pm}0.0010$
(68% CL), with the null hypothesis rejected at 4$\sigma$ [Stukel et al.,
DOI:10.1103/PhysRevLett.131.052503]. This unambiguous signal yields a branching
ratio of
$I_{\text{EC}^0}=0.098\%\stackrel{\text{stat}}{\pm}0.023\%\stackrel{\text{sys}}{\pm}0.010$,
roughly half of the commonly used prediction. This first observation of a
third-forbidden unique electron capture improves understanding of low-energy
backgrounds in dark-matter searches and has implications for nuclear-structure
calculations. A shell-model based theoretical estimate for the $0\nu\beta\beta$
decay half-life of calcium-48 is increased by a factor of $7^{+3}_{-2}$. Our
nonzero measurement shifts geochronological ages by up to a percent;
implications are illustrated for Earth and solar system chronologies.
