  Bitcoin introduced delegation of control over a monetary system from a select
few to all who participate in that system. This delegation is known as the
decentralization of controlling power and is a powerful security mechanism for
the ecosystem. After the introduction of Bitcoin, the field of cryptocurrency
has seen widespread attention from industry and academia, so much so that the
original novel contribution of Bitcoin i.e. decentralization, may be
overlooked, due to decentralizations assumed fundamental existence for the
functioning of such cryptoassets. However recent studies have observed a trend
of increased centralization in cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin and Ethereum.
As this increased centralization has an impact the security of the blockchain,
it is crucial that it is measured, towards adequate control. This research
derives an initial taxonomy of centralization present in decentralized
blockchains through rigorous synthesis using a systematic literature review.
This is followed by iterative refinement through expert interviews. We
systematically analyzed 89 research papers published between 2009 and 2019. Our
study contributes to the existing body of knowledge by highlighting the
multiple definitions and measurements of centralization in the literature. We
identify different aspects of centralization and propose an encompassing
taxonomy of centralization concerns. This taxonomy is based on empirically
observable and measurable characteristics. It consists of 13 aspects of
centralization classified over six architectural layers Governance Network
Consensus Incentive Operational and Application. We also discuss how the
implications of centralization can vary depending on the aspects studied. We
believe that this review and taxonomy provides a comprehensive overview of
centralization in decentralized blockchains involving various
conceptualizations and measures.
