  The (Perfect) Matching Cut problem is to decide if a graph $G$ has a
(perfect) matching cut, i.e., a (perfect) matching that is also an edge cut of
$G$. Both Matching Cut and Perfect Matching Cut are known to be NP-complete. A
perfect matching cut is also a matching cut with maximum number of edges. To
increase our understanding of the relationship between the two problems, we
introduce the Maximum Matching Cut problem. This problem is to determine a
largest matching cut in a graph. We generalize and unify known polynomial-time
algorithms for Matching Cut and Perfect Matching Cut restricted to graphs of
diameter at most $2$ and to $(P_6+sP_2)$-free graphs. We also show that the
complexity of Maximum Matching Cut differs from the complexities of Matching
Cut and Perfect Matching Cut by proving NP-hardness of Maximum Matching Cut for
$2P_3$-free quadrangulated graphs of diameter $3$ and radius $2$ and for
subcubic line graphs of triangle-free graphs. In this way, we obtain full
dichotomies of Maximum Matching Cut for graphs of bounded diameter, bounded
radius and $H$-free graphs. Finally, we apply our techniques to get a dichotomy
for the Maximum Disconnected Perfect Matching problem for $H$-free graphs. A
disconnected perfect matching of a graph $G$ is a perfect matching that
contains a matching cut of $G$. The Maximum Disconnected Perfect Matching
problem asks to determine for a connected graph $G$, a disconnected perfect
matching with a largest matching cut over all disconnected perfect matchings of
$G$. Our dichotomy result implies that the original decision problem
Disconnected Perfect Matching is polynomial-time solvable for $(P_6+sP_2)$-free
graphs for every $s\geq 0$, which resolves an open problem of Bouquet and
Picouleau (arXiv, 2020).
