  This paper offers an independent assessment of certain key economic effects
of the Iberian Exception (IE). Their stated aim was to reduce the major
component of electricity prices for most Iberian consumers, a component which
was indexed to Iberian wholesale power market spot prices power market prices
that were rising alarmingly due to extremely tight international markets for
natural gas. The Spanish Government estimates that, during its first 100 days,
the IE provided substantial benefits for consumers affected by the IE, which
included over 10 million small consumers as well as many large ones, but the
authors of this study question that estimate. The authors of this paper argue
that the estimated effect of the IE on retail prices depends critically on the
assumptions about what would have occurred in the absence of the IE, i.e., in a
counterfactual scenario. Although counterfactuals are always difficult to
construct, the government s counterfactual ignores demand elasticity, and this
inflates their estimate of immediate consumer benefits. Using hourly data on
the wholesale electricity market for the first 100 days of the IE, this paper s
analysis of alternative counterfactuals that reflect the effects of demand
elasticity shows substantially lower benefits of the IE for consumers than the
Spanish government estimates. Indeed, this paper s analysis suggests that
affected consumers would have paid somewhat less for electricity in the first
100 days of the IE had it not been introduced. The authors identify several
other potential short and longterm effects of the IE that deserve further
study. These include increased margins for fossil fired generators, reduced
margins for some decarbonized inframarginal plant, heightened investor
perceptions of regulatory risk, weakened incentives for efficient consumption,
and higher carbon emissions and gas prices.
