  Industrial coating processes create thin liquid films with tight thickness
tolerances, and thus models that predict the response to inevitable
disturbances are essential. The mathematical modeling complexities are reduced
through linearization as even small thickness variations in films can render a
product unsalable. The signaling problem, considered in this paper, is perhaps
the simplest model that incorporates the effects of repetitive (oscillatory)
disturbances that are initiated, for example, by room vibrations and pump
drives. In prior work, Gordillo and P\'erez (Phys. Fluids 14, 2002) examined
the structure of the signaling response for linear operators that admit
exponentially growing or damped solutions, i.e., the medium is classified as
unstable or stable via classical stability analysis. The signaling problem
admits two portions of the solution, the transient behavior due to the start-up
of the disturbance and the long-time behavior that is continually forced; the
superposition reveals how the forced solution evolves through the passage of a
transient. In this paper, we examine signaling for the linear operator examined
by King et al. (King et al. 2016, Phys. Rev. Fluids 1(7)) that governs varicose
waves in a thin liquid sheet and that can admit solutions having algebraic
growth although the underlying medium is classified as being neutrally stable.
Long-time asymptotic methods are used to extract critical velocities that
partition the response into distinct regions having markedly different
location-dependent responses, and the amplitudes of oscillatory responses in
these regions are determined. Together, these characterize the magnitude and
breadth of the solution response. Results indicate that the signaling response
in neutrally stable flows (that admit algebraic growth) is significantly
different from that in exponentially unstable systems.
