  We report on a number of careful numerical experiments motivated by the
semiclassical (zero-dispersion, \epsilon\downarrow 0) limit of the focusing
nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation. Our experiments are designed to study the
evolution of a particular family of perturbations of the initial data. These
asymptotically small perturbations are precisely those that result from
modifying the initial-data by using formal approximations to the spectrum of
the associated spectral problem; such modified data has always been a standard
part of the analysis of zero-dispersion limits of integrable systems. However,
in the context of the focusing nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation, the
ellipticity of the Whitham equations casts some doubt on the validity of this
procedure. To carry out our experiments, we introduce an implicit finite
difference scheme for the partial differential equation, and we validate both
the proposed scheme and the standard split-step scheme against a numerical
implementation of the inverse scattering transform for a special case in which
the scattering data is known exactly. As part of this validation, we also
investigate the use of the Krasny filter which is sometimes suggested as
appropriate for nearly ill-posed problems such as we consider here. Our
experiments show that that the O(\epsilon) rate of convergence of the modified
data to the true data is propagated to positive times including times after
wave breaking.
