  We examine the theoretical motivations for long-lived particle (LLP) signals
at the LHC in a comprehensive survey of Standard Model (SM) extensions. LLPs
are a common prediction of a wide range of theories that address unsolved
fundamental mysteries such as naturalness, dark matter, baryogenesis and
neutrino masses, and represent a natural and generic possibility for physics
beyond the SM (BSM). In most cases the LLP lifetime can be treated as a free
parameter from the $\mu$m scale up to the Big Bang Nucleosynthesis limit of
$\sim 10^7$m. Neutral LLPs with lifetimes above $\sim$ 100m are particularly
difficult to probe, as the sensitivity of the LHC main detectors is limited by
challenging backgrounds, triggers, and small acceptances. MATHUSLA is a
proposal for a minimally instrumented, large-volume surface detector near ATLAS
or CMS. It would search for neutral LLPs produced in HL-LHC collisions by
reconstructing displaced vertices (DVs) in a low-background environment,
extending the sensitivity of the main detectors by orders of magnitude in the
long-lifetime regime. In this white paper we study the LLP physics
opportunities afforded by a MATHUSLA-like detector at the HL-LHC. We develop a
model-independent approach to describe the sensitivity of MATHUSLA to BSM LLP
signals, and compare it to DV and missing energy searches at ATLAS or CMS. We
then explore the BSM motivations for LLPs in considerable detail, presenting a
large number of new sensitivity studies. While our discussion is especially
oriented towards the long-lifetime regime at MATHUSLA, this survey underlines
the importance of a varied LLP search program at the LHC in general. By
synthesizing these results into a general discussion of the top-down and
bottom-up motivations for LLP searches, it is our aim to demonstrate the
exceptional strength and breadth of the physics case for the construction of
the MATHUSLA detector.
