  A PV number is an algebraic integer $\alpha$ of degree $d \geq 2$ all of
whose Galois conjugates other than itself have modulus less than $1$. Erd\"{o}s
\cite{erdos} proved that the Fourier transform $\widehat \varphi,$ of a nonzero
compactly supported scalar valued function satisfying the refinement equation
$\varphi(x) = \frac{|\alpha|}{2}\varphi(\alpha x) +
\frac{|\alpha|}{2}\varphi(\alpha x-1)$ with $PV$ dilation $\alpha,$ does not
vanish at infinity so by the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma $\varphi$ is not
integrable. Dai, Feng and Wang \cite{daifengwang} extended his result to scalar
valued solutions of $\varphi(x) = \sum_k a(k) \varphi(\alpha x - \tau(k))$
where $\tau(k)$ are integers and $a$ has finite support and sums to $|\alpha|$.
In (\cite{lawton3}, Conjecture 4.2) we conjectured that their result holds
under the weaker assumption that $\tau$ has values in the ring of polynomials
in $\alpha$ with integer coefficients. This paper formulates a stronger
conjecture and provides support for it based on a solenoidal representation of
$\widehat \varphi,$ and deep results of Erd\"{o}s and Mahler
\cite{erdosmahler};Odoni \cite{odoni} that give lower bounds for the asymptotic
density of integers represented by integral binary forms of degree $> 2;$degree
$ = 2,$ respectively. We also construct an integrable vector valued refinable
function with PV dilation.
