  Given a random sample from a multivariate population, estimating the number
of large eigenvalues of the population covariance matrix is an important
problem in Statistics with wide applications in many areas. In the context of
Principal Component Analysis (PCA), the linear combinations of the original
variables having the largest amounts of variation are determined by this
number. In this paper, we study the high dimensional asymptotic regime where
the number of variables grows at the same rate as the number of observations,
and use the spiked covariance model proposed in Johnstone (2001), under which
the problem reduces to model selection. Our focus is on the Akaike Information
Criterion (AIC) which is known to be strongly consistent from the work of Bai
et al. (2018). However, Bai et al. (2018) requires a certain "gap condition"
ensuring the dominant eigenvalues to be above a threshold strictly larger than
the BBP threshold (Baik et al. (2005), both quantities depending on the
limiting ratio of the number of variables and observations. It is well-known
that, below the BBP threshold, a spiked covariance structure becomes
indistinguishable from one with no spikes. Thus the strong consistency of AIC
requires some extra signal strength.
  In this paper, we investigate whether consistency continues to hold even if
the "gap" is made smaller. We show that strong consistency under arbitrarily
small gap is achievable if we alter the penalty term of AIC suitably depending
on the target gap. Furthermore, another intuitive alteration of the penalty can
indeed make the gap exactly zero, although we can only achieve weak consistency
in this case. We compare the two newly-proposed estimators with other existing
estimators in the literature via extensive simulation studies, and show, by
suitably calibrating our proposals, that a significant improvement in terms of
mean-squared error is achievable.
