  There exist three main approaches to reduction associated to canonical Lie
group actions on a symplectic manifold, namely, foliation reduction, introduced
by Cartan, Marsden-Weinstein reduction, and optimal reduction, introduced by
the authors. When the action is free, proper, and admits a momentum map these
three approaches coincide. The goal of this paper is to study the general case
of a symplectic action that does not admit a momentum map and one needs to use
its natural generalization, a cylinder valued momentum map introduced by
Condevaux, Dazord, and Molino. In this case it will be shown that the three
reduced spaces mentioned above do not coincide, in general. More specifically,
the Marsden-Weinstein reduced spaces are not symplectic but Poisson and their
symplectic leaves are given by the optimal reduced spaces. Foliation reduction
produces a symplectic reduced space whose Poisson quotient by a certain Lie
group associated to the group of symmetries of the problem equals the
Marsden-Weinstein reduced space. We illustrate these constructions with
concrete examples, special emphasis being given to the reduction of a magnetic
cotangent bundle of a Lie group in the situation when the magnetic term ensures
the non-existence of the momentum map for the lifted action. The precise
relation of the cylinder valued momentum map with group valued momentum maps
for Abelian Lie groups is also given.
