  We introduce a conservational and constitutive framework for a closed and
isothermal two-phase material system consisting of a deformable porous solid
matrix and a fully saturating, single-phase, and compressible pore fluid
without inter-phase mass exchange. We re-derive a generalized fluid mass
balance law using fundamental transport rules. We also summarize from the
literature a fundamental force balance law for the fluid-solid mixture that
does not require any effective stress law a priori. We show that the two
conservation laws are coupled naturally to second-order without any
constitutive prerequisites. This differs from Biot poroelasticity, which first
postulates first-order fluid-solid coupling as two linearized constitutive
relationships and then enforces them into simple Eulerian form of conservation
laws. Next, we examine a limiting-case unsaturated soil mechanics framework
implemented in Abaqus, by assuming isothermal conditions, full saturation, and
no adsorption, and then relate it to our framework. We prove that (1) the two
mass balance laws are always equivalent regardless of fluid constitutive
behaviors, and (2) the two force balance laws are equivalent in their specific
forms with a linearly elastic solid skeleton. Finally, taking advantage of a
fundamental pore constitutive law, we show how our framework, and by extension
the limiting-case Abaqus framework, naturally gives rise to the distinction
between drained and undrained settings, and reduces to Biot poroelasticity
under simplifying conditions. Notably, our framework indicates the presence of
an additional solid-to-fluid coupling term when the solid particle velocity is
non-orthogonal to the Darcy velocity.
