  Chlorine isotopologues of polychlorinated organic compounds are usually
recognized to follow binomial distribution. Is this recognition exactly true?
This study presents a solid theoretical derivation to prove whether the
isotopologue distributions of organochlorines are binomial or not, and
investigates the implications of the distributions to relevant experimental
studies. During synthetic reactions, the C-Cl bonds with stronger strengths are
more readily to be formed with heavy isotopes. The chlorine KIEs are higher
during the breakages of the stronger C-Cl bonds than during the breaking of the
weaker ones. For a synthetic organochlorine, if the rate-limiting step during a
chlorination reaction is the formation of C-Cl bonds, then chlorine KIE takes
effect in the reaction, resulting in always higher chlorine isotope ratio on
the reaction position than that of the initial chlorine atoms from the chlorine
source. Chlorine KIEs vary during different chlorination reactions, leading to
inconsistent chlorine isotope ratios on different reaction positions of
asymmetric reaction intermediates and final products. If the rate-determining
step is the generation of reactive chlorine atoms and the initial isotope ratio
of the chlorine source is constant, then the chlorine isotope ratios on the
reaction positions of all intermediates and final products are equivalent,
demonstrating that the isotopologues follow binomial distribution. After
physical changes and dechlorination reactions, organochlorines in the
environment are unlikely binomially distributed. Experimental data show that
the detected isotopologues of all the investigated organochlorines disobeyed
binomial distribution. This study may bring a new perspective about the
chlorine isotopologue distributions of organochlorines, and the proposed
solutions may help to obtain better data for quantification and CSIA-Cl of
organochlorines.
