  The identification of cancer stem cells in vivo and in vitro relies on
specific surface markers that should allow to sort cancer cells in
phenotypically distinct subpopulations. Experiments report that sorted cancer
cell populations after some time tend to express again all the original
markers, leading to the hypothesis of phenotypic switching, according to which
cancer cells can transform stochastically into cancer stem cells. Here we
explore an alternative explanation based on the hypothesis that markers are not
perfect and are thus unable to identify all cancer stem cells. Our analysis is
based on a mathematical model for cancer cell proliferation that takes into
account phenotypic switching, imperfect markers and error in the sorting
process. Our conclusion is that the observation of reversible expression of
surface markers after sorting does not provide sufficient evidence in support
of phenotypic switching.
