  Magnetic field fluctuations in MHD turbulence can be viewed as current sheets
that are progressively more anisotropic at smaller scales. As suggested by
Loureiro & Boldyrev (2017) and Mallet et al (2017), below a certain critical
thickness $\lambda_c$ such current sheets become tearing-unstable. We propose
that the tearing instability changes the effective alignment of the magnetic
field lines in such a way as to balance the eddy turnover rate at all scales
smaller than $\lambda_c$. As a result, turbulent fluctuations become
progressively less anisotropic at smaller scales, with the alignment angle
increasing as $\theta \sim (\lambda/\lambda_*)^{-4/5+\beta}$, where
$\lambda_*\sim L_0 S_0^{-3/4}$ is the resistive dissipation scale. Here $L_0$
is the outer scale of the turbulence, $S_0$ is the corresponding Lundquist
number, and {$0\leq \beta <4/5$} is a parameter. The resulting Fourier energy
spectrum is $E(k_\perp)\propto k_\perp^{-11/5+2\beta/3}$, where $k_\perp$ is
the wavenumber normal to the local mean magnetic field, and the critical scale
is $\lambda_c\sim S_L^{-(4-5\beta)/(7-{20\beta/3})}$. The simplest model
corresponds to $\beta=0$, in which case the predicted scaling formally agrees
with one of the solutions obtained in (Mallet et al 2017) from a discrete
hierarchical model of abruptly collapsing current sheets, an approach different
and complementary to ours. We also show that the reconnection-mediated interval
is non-universal with respect to the dissipation mechanism. Hyper-resistivity
of the form ${\tilde \eta}k^{2+2s}$ leads (in the simplest case of $\beta=0$)
to the different transition scale $\lambda_c\sim L_0{\tilde S}_0^{-4/(7+9s)}$
and the energy spectrum $E(k_\perp)\propto k_\perp^{-(11+9s)/(5+3s)}$, where
${\tilde S}_0$ is the corresponding hyper-resistive Lundquist number.
