  We consider the problem of evaluating the quality of startup companies. This
can be quite challenging due to the rarity of successful startup companies and
the complexity of factors which impact such success. In this work we collect
data on tens of thousands of startup companies, their performance, the
backgrounds of their founders, and their investors. We develop a novel model
for the success of a startup company based on the first passage time of a
Brownian motion. The drift and diffusion of the Brownian motion associated with
a startup company are a function of features based its sector, founders, and
initial investors. All features are calculated using our massive dataset. Using
a Bayesian approach, we are able to obtain quantitative insights about the
features of successful startup companies from our model.
  To test the performance of our model, we use it to build a portfolio of
companies where the goal is to maximize the probability of having at least one
company achieve an exit (IPO or acquisition), which we refer to as winning.
This $\textit{picking winners}$ framework is very general and can be used to
model many problems with low probability, high reward outcomes, such as
pharmaceutical companies choosing drugs to develop or studios selecting movies
to produce. We frame the construction of a picking winners portfolio as a
combinatorial optimization problem and show that a greedy solution has strong
performance guarantees. We apply the picking winners framework to the problem
of choosing a portfolio of startup companies. Using our model for the exit
probabilities, we are able to construct out of sample portfolios which achieve
exit rates as high as 60%, which is nearly double that of top venture capital
firms.
