  Acoustic reflector localization is an important issue in audio signal
processing, with direct applications in spatial audio, scene reconstruction,
and source separation. Several methods have recently been proposed to estimate
the 3D positions of acoustic reflectors given room impulse responses (RIRs). In
this article, we categorize these methods as "image-source reversion", which
localizes the image source before finding the reflector position, and "direct
localization", which localizes the reflector without intermediate steps. We
present five new contributions. First, an onset detector, called the clustered
dynamic programming projected phase-slope algorithm, is proposed to
automatically extract the time of arrival for early reflections within the RIRs
of a compact microphone array. Second, we propose an image-source reversion
method that uses the RIRs from a single loudspeaker. It is constructed by
combining an image source locator (the image source direction and range (ISDAR)
algorithm), and a reflector locator (using the loudspeaker-image bisection
(LIB) algorithm). Third, two variants of it, exploiting multiple loudspeakers,
are proposed. Fourth, we present a direct localization method, the ellipsoid
tangent sample consensus (ETSAC), exploiting ellipsoid properties to localize
the reflector. Finally, systematic experiments on simulated and measured RIRs
are presented, comparing the proposed methods with the state-of-the-art. ETSAC
generates errors lower than the alternative methods compared through our
datasets. Nevertheless, the ISDAR-LIB combination performs well and has a run
time 200 times faster than ETSAC.
