  The use of head-mounted display technologies for virtual reality experiences
is inherently single-user-centred, allowing for the visual immersion of its
user in the computer-generated environment. This isolates them from their
physical surroundings, effectively preventing external visual information cues,
such as the pointing and referral to an artifact by another user. However, such
input is important and desired in collaborative scenarios when exploring and
analyzing data in virtual environments together with a peer. In this article,
we investigate different designs for making spatio-temporal references, i.e.,
visually highlighting virtual data artifacts, within the context of
Collaborative Immersive Analytics. The ability to make references to data is
foundational for collaboration, affecting aspects such as awareness, attention,
and common ground. Based on three design options, we implemented a variety of
approaches to make spatial and temporal references in an immersive virtual
reality environment that featured abstract visualization of spatio-temporal
data as 3D Radar Charts. We conducted a user study (n=12) to empirically
evaluate aspects such as aesthetic appeal, legibility, and general user
preference. The results indicate a unified favour for the presented location
approach as a spatial reference while revealing trends towards a preference of
mixed temporal reference approaches dependent on the task configuration:
pointer for elementary, and outline for synoptic references. Based on immersive
data visualization complexity as well as task reference configuration, we argue
that it can be beneficial to explore multiple reference approaches as
collaborative information cues, as opposed to following a rather uniform user
interface design.
