  As a new tool in the NextGen portfolio, the Collaborative Trajectory Options
Programs (CTOP) combines multiple features from its forerunners including
Ground Delay Program (GDP), Airspace Flow Program (AFP) and reroutes, and can
manage multiple Flow Constrained Areas (FCAs) with a single program. A key
research question in CTOP is how to set traffic flow rates under traffic demand
and airspace capacity uncertainties. In this paper, we first investigate
existing CTOP related stochastic optimization models and point out their roles
in CTOP flow rate planning, and their advantages and disadvantages in terms of
model flexibility, performance, practicality and Collaborative Decision Making
(CDM) software compatibility, etc. CTOP FCA rate planning problem has been
split into two steps: traffic flow rate optimization given demand estimation,
and flow rate adaptation when flight rerouting is considered. Second, we
discuss in detail a class of models called FCA-PCA (Potentially Constrained
Area) models, which are extended from GDP models to solve the first step of the
problem, and were considered promising as they are designed to be consistent
with current CTOP software implementation. We will reveal one inherent
shortcoming suffered by FCA-PCA models and show that how this deficiency can be
addressed by the PCA model family. We will talk about the problems that prevent
stochastic programming being optimal in the second step of the problem. Third,
we discuss the applicability of simulation-based optimization, combine it with
stochastic programming based heuristics and test the resulting new model on a
realistic use case. The results are very encouraging. The models and
discussions in this work are not only useful in more effectively implementing
and analyzing CTOP programs, but are also valuable for the design of future air
traffic flow program.
