  Durable interfacing of hard and soft materials is a major design challenge
caused by the ensuing stress concentrations. In nature, soft-hard interfaces
exhibit remarkable mechanical performance, with failures rarely happening at
the interface but in the hard or soft material. This superior performance is
mechanistically linked to such design features as hierarchical structures,
multiple types of interlocking, and functional gradients. Here, we mimic these
strategies to design efficient soft-hard interfaces using voxel-based
multi-material 3D printing. We designed several types of soft-hard interfaces
with interfacial functional gradients and various types of bio-inspired
interlocking mechanisms. The geometrical designs were based on triply periodic
minimal surfaces (i.e., octo, diamond, and gyroid), collagen-like triple
helices, and randomly distributed particles. We utilized a combination of the
finite element method and experimental techniques, including uniaxial tensile
tests, quad-lap shear tests, and full-field strain measurement using digital
image correlation, to characterize the mechanical performance of different
groups. The analysis of the best performing designs (i.e., the gyroid,
collagen, and particle designs) suggests that smooth interdigitated
connections, compliant gradient transitions, and either decreasing or
constraining the strain concentrations regions between the hard and soft phases
led to simultaneously strong and tough interfaces. Increasing the gradient
length was only beneficial when the resulting interface geometry reduced strain
concentrations (e.g., in collagen and particles). Combining the gyroid-based
architecture with a random distribution of particles yielded the
best-performing soft-hard interface, with strengths approaching the upper limit
of the possible strengths and up to 50% toughness enhancement as compared to
the control group.
