  For the spectral fractional diffusion operator of order $2s\in (0,2)$ in
bounded, curvilinear polygonal domains $\Omega$ we prove exponential
convergence of two classes of $hp$ discretizations under the assumption of
analytic data, without any boundary compatibility, in the natural fractional
Sobolev norm $\mathbb{H}^s(\Omega)$. The first $hp$ discretization is based on
writing the solution as a co-normal derivative of a $2+1$-dimensional local,
linear elliptic boundary value problem, to which an $hp$-FE discretization is
applied. A diagonalization in the extended variable reduces the numerical
approximation of the inverse of the spectral fractional diffusion operator to
the numerical approximation of a system of local, decoupled, second order
reaction-diffusion equations in $\Omega$. Leveraging results on robust
exponential convergence of $hp$-FEM for second order, linear reaction diffusion
boundary value problems in $\Omega$, exponential convergence rates for
solutions $u\in \mathbb{H}^s(\Omega)$ of $\mathcal{L}^s u = f$ follow. Key
ingredient in this $hp$-FEM are boundary fitted meshes with geometric mesh
refinement towards $\partial\Omega$.
  The second discretization is based on exponentially convergent sinc
quadrature approximations of the Balakrishnan integral representation of
$\mathcal{L}^{-s}$, combined with $hp$-FE discretizations of a decoupled system
of local, linear, singularly perturbed reaction-diffusion equations in
$\Omega$. The present analysis for either approach extends to polygonal subsets
$\widetilde{\mathcal{M}}$ of analytic, compact $2$-manifolds $\mathcal{M}$.
Numerical experiments for model problems in nonconvex polygonal domains and
with incompatible data confirm the theoretical results.
  Exponentially small bounds on Kolmogoroff $n$-widths of solutions sets for
spectral fractional diffusion in polygons are deduced.
