  Vehicles with a safety function for anticipating crashes in advance can
enhance drivers' ability to avoid crashes. As dashboard cameras have become a
low-cost sensor device accessible to almost every vehicle, deep neural networks
for crash anticipation from a dashboard camera are receiving growing interest.
However, drivers' trust in the Artificial Intelligence (AI)-enabled safety
function is built on the validation of its safety enhancement toward zero
deaths. This paper is motivated to establish a method that uses gaze data and
corresponding measures to evaluate human drivers' ability to anticipate
crashes. A laboratory experiment is designed and performed, wherein a
screen-based eye tracker collects the gaze data of six volunteers while
watching 100 driving videos that include both normal and crash scenarios.
Statistical analyses of the experimental data show that, on average, drivers
can anticipate a crash up to 2.61 seconds before it occurs in this pilot study.
The chance that drivers have successfully anticipated crashes before they occur
is 92.8%. A state-of-the-art AI model can anticipate crashes 1.02 seconds
earlier than drivers on average. The study finds that crash-involving traffic
agents in the driving videos can vary drivers' instant attention level, average
attention level, and spatial attention distribution. This finding supports the
development of a spatial-temporal attention mechanism for AI models to
strengthen their ability to anticipate crashes. Results from the comparison
also suggest the development of collaborative intelligence that keeps
human-in-the-loop of AI models to further enhance the reliability of AI-enabled
safety functions.
