  Quantification of heritability is a fundamental desideratum in genetics,
which allows an assessment of the contribution of additive genetic variation to
the variability of a trait of interest. The traditional computational
approaches for assessing the heritability of a trait have been developed in the
field of quantitative genetics. However, the rise of modern population genomics
with large sample sizes has led to the development of several new machine
learning based approaches to inferring heritability. In this paper, we
systematically summarize recent advances in machine learning which can be used
to infer heritability. We focus on an application of these methods to bacterial
genomes, where heritability plays a key role in understanding phenotypes such
as antibiotic resistance and virulence, which are particularly important due to
the rising frequency of antimicrobial resistance. By designing a heritability
model incorporating realistic patterns of genome-wide linkage disequilibrium
for a frequently recombining bacterial pathogen, we test the performance of a
wide spectrum of different inference methods, including also GCTA. In addition
to the synthetic data benchmark, we present a comparison of the methods for
antibiotic resistance traits for multiple bacterial pathogens. Insights from
the benchmarking and real data analyses indicate a highly variable performance
of the different methods and suggest that heritability inference would likely
benefit from tailoring of the methods to the specific genetic architecture of
the target organism.
