  Reddit's WallStreetBets (WSB) community has come to prominence in light of
its notable role in affecting the stock prices of what are now referred to as
meme stocks. Yet very little is known about the reliability of the highly
speculative investment advice disseminated on WSB. This paper analyses WSB data
spanning from January 2019 to April 2021 in order to assess how successful an
investment strategy relying on the community's recommendations could have been.
We detect buy and sell advice and identify the community's most popular stocks,
based on which we define a WSB portfolio. Our evaluation shows that this
portfolio has grown approx. 200% over the last three years and approx. 480%
over the last year, significantly outperforming the S&P500. The average
short-term accuracy of buy and sell signals, in contrast, is not found to be
significantly better than randomly or equally distributed buy decisions within
the same time frame. However, we present a technique for estimating whether
posts are proactive as opposed to reactive and show that by focusing on a
subset of more promising buy signals, a trader could have made investments
yielding higher returns than the broader market or the strategy of trusting all
posted buy signals. Lastly, the analysis is also conducted specifically for the
period before 2021 in order to factor out the effects of the GameStop hype of
January 2021 - the results confirm the conclusions and suggest that the 2021
hype merely amplified pre-existing characteristics.
