  X-ray scattering is a weak linear probe of matter. It is primarily sensitive
to the position of electrons and their momentum distribution. Elastic X-ray
scattering forms the basis of atomic structural determination while inelastic
Compton scattering is often used as a spectroscopic probe of both
single-particle excitations and collective modes. X-ray free-electron lasers
(XFELs) are unique tools for studying matter on its natural time and length
scales due to their bright and coherent ultrashort pulses. However, in the
focus of an XFEL the assumption of a weak linear probe breaks down, and
nonlinear light-matter interactions can become ubiquitous. The field can be
sufficiently high that even non-resonant multiphoton interactions at hard
X-rays wavelengths become relevant. Here we report the observation of one of
the most fundamental nonlinear X-ray-matter interactions, the simultaneous
Compton scattering of two identical photons producing a single photon at nearly
twice the photon energy. We measure scattered photons with an energy near 18
keV generated from solid beryllium irradiated by 8.8-9.75 keV XFEL pulses. The
intensity in the X-ray focus reaches up to 4x20 W/cm2, which corresponds to a
peak electric field two orders of magnitude higher than the atomic unit of
field-strength and within four orders of magnitude of the quantum
electrodynamic critical field. The observed signal scales quadratically in
intensity and is emitted into a non-dipolar pattern, consistent with the
simultaneous two-photon scattering from free electrons. However, the energy of
the generated photons shows an anomalously large redshift only present at high
intensities. This indicates that the instantaneous high-intensity scattering
effectively interacts with a different electron momentum distribution than
linear Compton scattering, with implications for the study of atomic-scale
structure and dynamics of matter
