  Using the same measurement techniques as those of Saket et al. (2017), we
have investigated the breaking threshold proposed by Barthelemy et al.
(arXiv:1508.06002v1, 2015b) but for different classes of unforced
unidirectional wave groups in intermediate water depths in the laboratory. The
threshold parameter $B_x = U_s/C$ (where $U_s$ is the horizontal surface water
particle velocity at the wave crest and $C$ is the wave crest point speed)
which distinguishes breaking from non-breaking waves was found to be 0.835
$\pm$ 0.005 with the experimental uncertainty of each data point of $\pm$
0.020. This threshold is applicable to water depth to wave length ratios as low
as 0.2 including the deep water conditions investigated by Saket et al. (2017).
No dependence on peak spectral wavenumber was found at the scales achievable in
a large-scale laboratory.
  The present study provides more robust and universal characterisation of
breaking in transitional water than the empirical non-dimensionalisation of
Nelson (1994). The limiting wave height to water depth ratios of marginally
breaking deep and intermediate water waves remain within 10 % of Nelson's
values. However, it is shown that the effect of wave grouping can produce waves
in shallower water that are at least 30 % greater in height than the limit
proposed by Nelson (1994). The present study supports use of limits based on
McCowan (1894) and Miche (1944) for coastal engineering design for marginal
breaking waves. Three-dimensional and more strongly breaking waves in shallower
water may yield wave heights higher than those measured during this study.
