  The tetraaza [Co$^\text{II}$N$_4$H]$^{2+}$ complex (\textbf{1}) is remarkable
for its ability to selectively reduce CO$_2$ to CO with 45\% Faradaic
efficiency and a CO to H$_2$ ratio of 3:2. We employ density functional theory
(DFT) to determine the reasons behind the unusual catalytic properties of
\textbf{1} and the most likely mechanism for CO$_2$ reduction. The selectivity
for CO$_2$ over proton reduction is explained by analyzing the catalyst's
affinity for the possible ligands present under typical reaction conditions:
acetonitrile, water, CO$_2$, and bicarbonate. After reduction of the catalyst
by two electrons, formation of [Co$^\text{I}$N$_4$H]$^{+}$-CO$_{2}^{-}$ is
strongly favored. Based on thermodynamic and kinetic data, we establish that
the only likely route for producing CO from here consists of a protonation step
to yield [Co$^\text{I}$N$_4$H]$^{+}$-CO$_{2}$H, followed by reaction with
CO$_2$ to form [Co$^\text{II}$N$_4$H]$^{2+}$-CO and bicarbonate. This
conclusion corroborates the idea of a direct role of CO$_2$ as a Lewis acid to
assist in {C-O} bond dissociation, a conjecture put forward by other authors to
explain recent experimental observations. The pathway to formic acid is
predicted to be forbidden by high activation barriers, in accordance with the
products that are known to be generated by \textbf{1}. Calculated physical
observables such as standard reduction potentials and the turnover frequency
for our proposed catalytic cycle are in agreement with available experimental
data reported in the literature. The mechanism also makes a prediction that may
be experimentally verified: that the rate of CO formation should increase
linearly with the partial pressure of CO$_2$.
