  While learning analytics dashboards (LADs) are the most common form of LA
intervention, there is limited evidence regarding their impact on students
learning outcomes. This systematic review synthesizes the findings of 38
research studies to investigate the impact of LADs on students' learning
outcomes, encompassing achievement, participation, motivation, and attitudes.
As we currently stand, there is no evidence to support the conclusion that LADs
have lived up to the promise of improving academic achievement. Most studies
reported negligible or small effects, with limited evidence from well-powered
controlled experiments. Many studies merely compared users and non-users of
LADs, confounding the dashboard effect with student engagement levels.
Similarly, the impact of LADs on motivation and attitudes appeared modest, with
only a few exceptions demonstrating significant effects. Small sample sizes in
these studies highlight the need for larger-scale investigations to validate
these findings. Notably, LADs showed a relatively substantial impact on student
participation. Several studies reported medium to large effect sizes,
suggesting that LADs can promote engagement and interaction in online learning
environments. However, methodological shortcomings, such as reliance on
traditional evaluation methods, self-selection bias, the assumption that access
equates to usage, and a lack of standardized assessment tools, emerged as
recurring issues. To advance the research line for LADs, researchers should use
rigorous assessment methods and establish clear standards for evaluating
learning constructs. Such efforts will advance our understanding of the
potential of LADs to enhance learning outcomes and provide valuable insights
for educators and researchers alike.
