  BICEP2 has reported the detection of a degree-scale B-mode polarization
pattern in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and has interpreted the
measurement as evidence for primordial gravitational waves. Motivated by the
profound importance of the discovery of gravitational waves from the early
Universe, we examine to what extent a combination of Galactic foregrounds and
lensed E-modes could be responsible for the signal. We reanalyze the BICEP2
results and show that the 100x150 GHz and 150x150 GHz data are consistent with
a cosmology with r=0.2 and negligible foregrounds, but also with a cosmology
with r=0 and a significant dust polarization signal. We give independent
estimates of the dust polarization signal in the BICEP2 region using four
different approaches. While these approaches are consistent with each other,
the expected amplitude of the dust polarization power spectrum remains
uncertain by about a factor of three. The lower end of the prediction leaves
room for a primordial contribution, but at the higher end the dust in
combination with the standard CMB lensing signal could account for the BICEP2
observations, without requiring the existence of primordial gravitational
waves. By measuring the cross-correlations between the pre-Planck templates
used in the BICEP2 analysis and between different versions of a data-based
template, we emphasize that cross-correlations between models are very
sensitive to noise in the polarization angles and that measured
cross-correlations are likely underestimates of the contribution of foregrounds
to the map. These results suggest that BICEP1 and BICEP2 data alone cannot
distinguish between foregrounds and a primordial gravitational wave signal, and
that future Keck Array observations at 100 GHz and Planck observations at
higher frequencies will be crucial to determine whether the signal is of
primordial origin. (abridged)
