  Accreting X-Ray Binaries display a wide range of behaviours. Some of them are
observed to spin up steadily, others to alternate between spin-up and spin-down
states, sometimes superimposed on a longer trend of either spin up or spin
down. Here we interpret this rich phenomenology within a new model of the
disk-magnetosphere interaction. Our model, based on the simplest version of a
purely material torque, accounts for the fact that, when a neutron star is in
the propeller regime, a fraction of the ejected material does not receive
enough energy to completely unbind, and hence falls back into the disk. We show
that the presence of this feedback mass component causes the occurrence of
multiple states available to the system, for a given, constant value of the
mass accretion rate dot{M}_* from the companion star. If the angle chi of the
magnetic dipole axis with respect to the perpendicular to the disk is larger
than a critical value chi_crit, the system eventually settles in a cycle of
spin-up/spin-down transitions for a constant value of dot{M}_* and independent
of the initial conditions. No external perturbations are required to induce the
torque reversals. The transition from spin up to spin down is often accompanied
by a large drop in luminosity. The frequency range spanned in each cycle and
the timescale for torque reversals depend on dot{M}_*, the magnetic field of
the star, the magnetic colatitude chi, and the degree of elasticity regulating
the magnetosphere-disk interaction. The critical angle chi_crit ranges from
\~25-30 deg for a completely elastic interaction to ~40-45 deg for a totally
anelastic one. For chi ~< chi_crit, cycles are no longer possible and the
long-term evolution of the system is a pure spin up. We specifically illustrate
our model in the cases of the X-ray binaries GX 1+4 and 4U 1626-67.
