  Determining the development of Germany's energy system by taking the energy
transition objectives into account is the subject of a series of studies. Since
their assumptions and results play a significant role in the political energy
debate for understanding the role of hydrogen and synthetic energy carriers, a
better discussion is needed. This article provides a comparative assessment of
published transition pathways for Germany to assess the role and advantages of
hydrogen and synthetic energy carriers. Twelve energy studies were selected and
37 scenarios for the years 2030 and 2050 were evaluated. Despite the
variations, the two carriers will play an important future role. While their
deployment is expected to have only started by 2030 with a mean demand of 91
TWh/a (4% of the final energy demand) in Germany, they will be an essential
part by 2050 with a mean demand of 480 TWh/a (24% of the final energy demand).
A moderately positive correlation (0.53) between the decarbonisation targets
and the share of hydrogen-based carriers in final energy demand underlines the
relevance for reaching the climate targets. Additionally, value creation
effects of about 5 bn EUR/a in 2030 can be expected for hydrogen-based
carriers. By 2050, these effects will increase to almost 16 bn EUR/a. Hydrogen
is expected to be mainly produced domestically while synthetic fuels are
projected to be mostly imported. Despite of all the advantages, the
construction of the facilities is associated with high costs which should be
not neglected in the discussion.
