  We consider time-harmonic acoustic scattering by planar sound-soft
(Dirichlet) and sound-hard (Neumann) screens embedded in $\mathbb{R}^n$ for $n
= 2$ or $3$. In contrast to previous studies in which the screen is assumed to
be a bounded Lipschitz (or smoother) relatively open subset of the plane, we
consider screens occupying an arbitrary bounded subset of the plane. Thus our
study includes cases where the screen is a relatively open set with a boundary
that is fractal, or indeed has positive surface measure, and cases where the
screen has empty interior and is fractal, or indeed has positive surface
measure. We elucidate for which screen geometries the classical formulations of
screen scattering are well-posed, showing that the classical formulation for
sound-hard scattering is not well-posed if the screen boundary has Hausdorff
dimension greater than $n-2$. We also propose novel well-posed boundary
integral equation (BIE) and boundary value problem (BVP) formulations, valid
for arbitrary bounded screens. In fact, we show that for sufficiently irregular
screens there exist whole families of well-posed formulations, with infinitely
many distinct solutions, the distinct formulations distinguished by the sense
in which the boundary conditions are understood. To select the physically
correct solution we propose limiting geometry principles, taking the limit of
solutions for a convergent sequence of more regular screens, this a natural
procedure for those fractal screens for which there exists a standard sequence
of prefractal approximations. We present examples exhibiting interesting
physical behaviours, including penetration of waves through screens with
"holes" in them, where the "holes" have no interior points, so that the screen
and its closure scatter differently. Our results depend on subtle and
interesting properties of fractional Sobolev spaces on non-Lipschitz sets.
