  Complex adaptive systems have been the subject of much recent attention. It
is by now well-established that members (`agents') tend to self-segregate into
opposing groups characterized by extreme behavior. However, while different
social and biological systems manifest different payoffs, the study of such
adaptive systems has mostly been restricted to simple situations in which the
prize-to-fine ratio, $R$, equals unity. In this Letter we explore the dynamics
of evolving populations with various different values of the ratio $R$, and
demonstrate that extreme behavior is in fact {\it not} a generic feature of
adaptive systems. In particular, we show that ``confusion'' and
``indecisiveness'' take over in times of depression, in which case cautious
agents perform better than extreme ones.
