  The traditional power law model, W(L) = aL^b, is widely applied to describe
weight (W) vs. length (L) in fish. The model, W(L) = (L/L1)^b, is proposed as
an improvement. The Levenberg-Marquardt non-linear least squares technique is
used to determine the best-fit parameters L1 and b. This model has the
advantages that L1 has the same units (length) independent of the value of the
exponent and has an easily interpreted physical meaning as the typical length
of a fish with one unit of weight. This proposed model is compared with the
traditional model on length-weight data sets for black crappie, largemouth
bass, chain pickerel, yellow perch, and brown bullhead obtained from Stilwell
Reservoir, West Point, New York. The resulting best-fit parameters, parameter
standard errors, and covariances are compared between the two models. The
average relative weight for these species is determined, along with typical
meat yields for four species. For the five species, using the logarithmic
approach and a linear least-squares, standard errors in the coefficient, a,
range from 60.2% to 136.5% for the traditional model. Using a non-linear least
squares technique to determine best fit parameters, the standard errors for the
coefficient, a, range from 68.5% to 164.0% in the traditional model. In the
improved model, standard errors in the parameter L1 range from 0.94% to 15.0%.
The covariance between a and b in the traditional model has a magnitude between
0.999 and 1.000 in both linear and non-linear parameter estimation methods. In
the improved model, the covariances between L1 and b are smaller. The improved
model, W(L) = (L/L1)^b, is preferable for weight vs. length in fish, because
the estimated parameter uncertainties and covariances are smaller in magnitude.
Furthermore, the parameters both have consistent units and an easily
interpreted physical meaning.
