  The question of finite time singularity formation vs. global existence for
solutions to the generalized Constantin-Lax-Majda equation is studied, with
particular emphasis on the influence of a parameter $a$ which controls the
strength of advection. For solutions on the infinite domain we find a new
critical value $a_c=0.6890665337007457\ldots$ below which there is finite time
singularity formation % if we write a=a_c=0.6890665337007457\ldots here then
\ldots doesn't fit into the line that has a form of self-similar collapse, with
the spatial extent of blow-up shrinking to zero. We find a new exact analytical
collapsing solution at $a=1/2$ as well as prove the existence of a leading
order complex singularity for general values of $a$ in the analytical
continuation of the solution from the real spatial coordinate into the complex
plane. This singularity controls the leading order behaviour of the collapsing
solution. For $a_c<a\leq1$, we find a blow-up solution in which the spatial
extent of the blow-up region expands infinitely fast at the singularity time.
For $a \gtrsim 1.3$, we find that the solution exists globally with
exponential-like growth of the solution amplitude in time. We also consider the
case of periodic boundary conditions. We identify collapsing solutions for
$a<a_c$ which are similar to the real line case. For $a_c<a\le0.95$, we find
new blow-up solutions which are neither expanding nor collapsing. For $ a\ge
1,$ we identify a global existence of solutions.
