  In this paper we address the question of the existence of a model for the
string 2-group as a strict Lie-2-group using the free loop group $LSpin$ (or
more generally $LG$ for compact simple simply-connected Lie groups $G$).
Baez-Crans-Stevenson-Schreiber constructed a model for the string 2-group using
a based loop group. This has the deficiency that it does not admit an action of
the circle group $S^1$, which is of crucial importance, for instance in the
construction of a (hypothetical) $S^1$-equivariant index of (higher)
differential operators. The present paper shows that there are in fact
obstructions for constructing a strict model for the string 2-group using $LG$.
We show that a certain infinite-dimensional manifold of smooth paths admits no
Lie group structure, and that there are no nontrivial Lie crossed modules
analogous to the BCSS model using the universal central extension of the free
loop group. Afterwards, we construct the next best thing, namely a coherent
model for the string 2-group using the free loop group, with explicit formulas
for all structure. This is in particular important for the expected
representation theory of the string group that we discuss briefly in the end.
