  Black hole and neutron star environments often comprise collisionless plasmas
immersed in strong magnetic fields and intense baths of low-frequency
radiation. In such conditions, relativistic magnetic reconnection can tap the
magnetic field energy, accelerating high-energy particles that rapidly cool by
inverse Compton (IC) scattering the dense photon background. At the highest
particle energies reached in bright gamma-ray sources, IC scattering can stray
into the Klein-Nishina regime. Here, the Comptonized photons exceed
pair-production threshold with the radiation background and may thus return
their energy to the reconnecting plasma as fresh electron-positron pairs. To
reliably characterize observable signatures of such Klein-Nishina reconnection,
in this work, we present first-principles particle-in-cell simulations of
pair-plasma relativistic reconnection coupled to Klein-Nishina and
pair-production physics. The simulations show substantial differences between
the observable signatures of Klein-Nishina reconnection and reconnection
coupled only to low-energy Thomson IC cooling (without pair production). The
latter regime exhibits strong harder-when-brighter behaviour; the former
involves a stable spectral shape independent of overall brightness. This
spectral stability is reminiscent of flat-spectrum radio quasar (FSRQ) GeV high
states, furnishing evidence that Klein-Nishina radiative physics operates in
FSRQs. The simulated Klein-Nishina reconnection pair yield spans from low to
order-unity and follows an exponential scaling law in a single governing
parameter. Pushing this parameter beyond its range studied here might give way
to a copious pair-creation regime. Besides FSRQs, we discuss potential
applications to accreting black hole X-ray binaries, the M87$^*$ magnetosphere,
and gamma-ray binaries.
