  LTE-Licensed Assisted Access (LAA) networks are beginning to be deployed
widely in major metropolitan areas in the US in the unlicensed 5 GHz bands,
which have existing dense deployments of Wi-Fi. This provides a real-world
opportunity to study the problems due to hidden-node scenarios between LAA and
Wi-Fi. The hidden node problem has been well studied in the context of
overlapping Wi-Fi APs. However, when Wi-Fi coexists with LAA, the hidden node
problem is exacerbated since LAA cannot use the well-known Request-to-Send
(RTS)/Clear to-Send (CTS) mechanism to resolve contentions, resulting in
throughput degradation for Wi-Fi. In this paper, we describe detailed
measurements and conclusions from experiments on the campus of the University
of Chicago which presents a perfect hidden node scenario where Wi-Fi access
points (APs) controlled by us and an LAA base-station (BS) deployed by AT&T are
hidden from each other, but the clients are not. We performed careful
experiments in three different regions of the coexistence area: (i) clients
midway between LAA & Wi-Fi; (ii) clients close to the Wi-Fi AP; and (iii)
clients close to the LAA BS. Our results show that in a situation where LAA
uses an aggregate of three unlicensed channels (60 MHz bandwidth) which overlap
with an 80 MHz Wi-Fi transmission, the Wi-Fi throughput at client devices
suffers considerably. Overall, Wi-Fi performance is impacted by the hidden node
problem more severely than LAA. In the best outdoor conditions, the throughput
of LAA and Wi-Fi is reduced by 35% and 97% respectively when coexisting with
each other as compared when the other system is not present. Furthermore, we
conclude that when both LAA and Wi-Fi use multiple 20 MHz channels and there
are multiple Wi-Fi APs coexisting with LAA on the same set of channels, the
choice of Wi-Fi primary channels can have a significant impact on LAA
throughput.
