  Homozygous mutations in the progranulin gene (GRN) are associated with
neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis 11 (CLN11), a rare lysosomal-storage disorder
characterized by cerebellar ataxia, seizures, retinitis pigmentosa, and
cognitive disorders, usually beginning between 13 and 25 years of age. This is
a rare condition, previously reported in only four families. In contrast,
heterozygous GRN mutations are a major cause of frontotemporal dementia
associated with neuronal cytoplasmic TDP-43 inclusions. We identified
homozygous GRN mutations in six new patients. The phenotypic spectrum is much
broader than previously reported, with two remarkably distinct presentations,
depending on the age of onset. A childhood/juvenile form is characterized by
classical CLN11 symptoms at an early age at onset. Unexpectedly, other
homozygous patients presented a distinct delayed phenotype of frontotemporal
dementia and parkinsonism after 50 years; none had epilepsy or cerebellar
ataxia. Another major finding of this study is that all GRN mutations may not
have the same impact on progranulin protein synthesis. A hypomorphic effect of
some mutations is supported by the presence of residual levels of plasma
progranulin and low levels of normal transcript detected in one case with a
homozygous splice-site mutation and late onset frontotemporal dementia. This is
a new critical finding that must be considered in therapeutic trials based on
replacement strategies. The first neuropathological study in a homozygous
carrier provides new insights into the pathological mechanisms of the disease.
Hallmarks of neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis were present. The absence of TDP-43
cytoplasmic inclusions markedly differs from observations of heterozygous
mutations, suggesting a pathological shift between lysosomal and TDP-43
pathologies depending on the mono or bi-allelic status. An intriguing
observation was the loss of normal TDP-43 staining in the nucleus of some
neurons, which could be the first stage of the TDP-43 pathological process
preceding the formation of typical cytoplasmic inclusions. Finally, this study
has important implications for genetic counselling and molecular diagnosis.
Semi-dominant inheritance of GRN mutations implies that specific genetic
counseling should be delivered to children and parents of CLN11 patients, as
they are heterozygous carriers with a high risk of developing dementia. More
broadly, this study illustrates the fact that genetic variants can lead to
different phenotypes according to their mono- or bi-allelic state, which is a
challenge for genetic diagnosis.
