  We estimate the error in the semiclassical trace formula for the Sinai
billiard under the assumption that the largest source of error is due to
Penumbra diffraction, that is diffraction effects for trajectories passing
within a distance R O((kR)^(-2/3) to the disk and trajectories being scattered
in very forward directions. Here k is the momentum and R the radius of the
scatterer. The semiclassical error is estimated by perturbing the Berry-Keating
formula. The analysis necessitates an asymptotic analysis of very long periodic
orbits. This is obtained within an approximation originally due to Baladi
Eckmann and Ruelle. We find that the average error, for sufficiently large
value of kR, will exceed the mean level spacing.
