  Beamforming is the primary technology to overcome the high path loss in
millimeter-wave (mmWave) channels. Hence, performance improvement needs
knowledge and control of the spatial domain. In particular, antenna structure
and radiation parameters affect the beamforming performance in mmWave
communications systems. In order to address the impairments such as beam
misalignments, outage loss, tracking inability, blockage, etc., an optimum
value of the beamwidth must be determined. In our previous paper, assuming a
communication system that creates a beam per cluster, we theoretically
investigated the beamwidth-received power relation in the cluster level mmWave
channels. We used uniform linear array (ULA) antenna in our analysis. In this
paper, we revisit the analysis and update the expressions for the scenario
where we use rectangular uniform planar array (R-UPA) antenna. Rectangular beam
model is considered to approximate the main lobe pattern of the antenna. For
the channel, we derive beamwidth-dependent extracted power expressions for two
intra-cluster channel models, IEEE 802.11ad and our previous work based on
ray-tracing (RT-ICM). Combining antenna and channel gains, in case of the
perfect alignment, we confirm that the optimum beamwidth converges zero.
Performing asymptotic analysis of the received power, we give the formulation
and insights that the practical nonzero beamwidth values can be achieved
although sacrificing subtle from the maximum received power. Our analysis shows
that to reach 95% of the maximum power for a typical indoor mmWave cluster, a
practical beamwidth of 3.5 deg is enough. Finally, our analysis results show
that there is a 13 dB increase in the maximum theoretical received power when
UPA is used over ULA. We show that an 8 x 8 UPA can reach 50% of that maximum
received power while the received power is still 10 dB larger than the ULA
scenario.
