  Recently, there have been considerable efforts to use online data to
investigate international migration. These efforts show that Web data are
valuable for estimating migration rates and are relatively easy to obtain.
However, existing studies have only investigated flows of people along
migration corridors, i.e. between pairs of countries. In our work, we use data
about "places lived" from millions of Google+ users in order to study migration
"clusters", i.e. groups of countries in which individuals have lived. For the
first time, we consider information about more than two countries people have
lived in. We argue that these data are very valuable because this type of
information is not available in traditional demographic sources which record
country-to-country migration flows independent of each other. We show that
migration clusters of country triads cannot be identified using information
about bilateral flows alone. To demonstrate the additional insights that can be
gained by using data about migration clusters, we first develop a model that
tries to predict the prevalence of a given triad using only data about its
constituent pairs. We then inspect the groups of three countries which are more
or less prominent, compared to what we would expect based on bilateral flows
alone. Next, we identify a set of features such as a shared language or
colonial ties that explain which triple of country pairs are more or less
likely to be clustered when looking at country triples. Then we select and
contrast a few cases of clusters that provide some qualitative information
about what our data set shows. The type of data that we use is potentially
available for a number of social media services. We hope that this first study
about migration clusters will stimulate the use of Web data for the development
of new theories of international migration that could not be tested
appropriately before.
