  It was recently shown that the Carath\'eodory and Teichm\"uller metrics on
the Teichm\"uller space of a closed surface do not coincide. On the other hand,
Kra earlier showed that the metrics coincide when restricted to a Teichm\"uller
disk generated by a differential with no odd-order zeros. Our aim is to
classify Teichm\"uller disks on which the two metrics agree, and we conjecture
that the Carath\'eodory and Teichm\"uller metrics agree on a Teichm\"uller disk
if and only if the Teichm\"uller disk is generated by a differential with no
odd-order zeros. Using dynamical results of Minsky, Smillie, and Weiss, we show
that it suffices to consider disks generated by Jenkins-Strebel differentials.
We then prove a complex-analytic criterion characterizing Jenkins-Strebel
differentials which generate disks on which the metrics coincide. Finally, we
use this criterion to prove the conjecture for the Teichm\"uller spaces of the
five-times punctured sphere and the twice-punctured torus. We also extend the
result that the Carath\'eodory and Teichm\"uller metrics are different to the
case of compact surfaces with punctures.
