  In the studies of piezoelectric energy harvesting (PEH) systems, literature
has shown that circuit advancement has a significant effect on the enhancement
of energy harvesting capability in resonance. On the other hand, some recent
studies using the phase-variable (PV) synchronized switch technologies have
found that the advanced circuit solutions can also broaden the harvesting
bandwidth. However, the available span of the electrically induced dynamics by
the existing energy harvesting circuits was not properly defined and
demonstrated. Performance comparison among different circuits cannot be fairly
achieved without using a common theoretical language. Given these, this paper
provides an impedance-based analysis and comparison on the electromechanical
joint dynamics of the PEH systems using different interface circuits. Given
that the resonance tunability by circuit solutions has received no attention in
the conventional ideal model of kinetic energy harvester, we firstly propose a
more inclusive ideal model for better generalization. In practice, it was
proven that the attainable dynamic ranges of the practical energy harvesting
circuits are only some subsets of the ideal realm. A detailed quantitative
study on the attainable ranges of the PV circuit solutions is provided after
the introduction of the ideal target. Simulation and experimental results of
different interface circuits show good agreement with the theoretical analysis.
It can be concluded that the resonance tunability strongly depends on the
achievable extent in the reactive direction of the equivalent impedance plane.
In practice, the electromechanical coupling conditions and dielectric loss
might also influence the resonance tunability. The general ideal model and
quantitative impedance analysis provided in this paper help guide the future
design effort towards high-capability and broadband PEH systems.
