  This paper questions some current ideas about the practice of specific
capital market operations - the so-called day trading operations. The text
advanced from theoretical propositions to a detailed analysis of the study
entitled "Is it possible to live by day-trading?" (CHAGUE and GIOVANNETTI,
2019), to which it offers a counterpoint. This investigation reveal the
existence of important elements that are not yet properly weighed in the
treatment of the current theme, leading to loss of dimensions that are - or
should be - inseparable from this type of research. The conclusion reached is
that the existing scientific evidence does not show that the adoption of the
day trade as an occupation is economically unsustainable, nor does it prove the
impossibility of evolution of the day traders' operational performance over
time.
  -----
  O presente trabalho coloca em questionamento algumas ideias atualmente
difundidas sobre a pratica de operacoes especificas do mercado de capitais - as
chamadas operacoes day trade. Partindo de proposicoes teoricas, o texto avanca
a uma analise detalhada do estudo intitulado "E possivel viver de day-trading?"
(CHAGUE e GIOVANNETTI, 2019), ao qual oferece contraponto. Essa investigacao
revela a existencia de importantes elementos que ainda nao estao devidamente
sopesados no tratamento do tema em voga, acarretando perda de dimensoes que sao
- ou deveriam ser - indissociaveis desse tipo de pesquisa. A conclusao
alcancada e de que as evidencias cientificas ate entao existentes nao
demonstram que a adocao do day trade como profissao seja insustentavel
economicamente, nem comprovam a impossibilidade de evolucao da performance
operacional dos day traders ao longo do tempo.
