  For civil structures, structural damage due to severe loading events such as
earthquakes, or due to long-term environmental degradation, usually occurs in
localized areas of a structure. A new sparse Bayesian probabilistic framework
for computing the probability of localized stiffness reductions induced by
damage is presented that uses noisy incomplete modal data from before and after
possible damage. This new approach employs system modal parameters of the
structure as extra variables for Bayesian model updating with incomplete modal
data. A specific hierarchical Bayesian model is constructed that promotes
spatial sparseness in the inferred stiffness reductions in a way that is
consistent with the Bayesian Ockham razor. To obtain the most plausible model
of sparse stiffness reductions together with its uncertainty within a specified
class of models, the method employs an optimization scheme that iterates among
all uncertain parameters, including the hierarchical hyper-parameters. The
approach has four important benefits: (1) it infers spatially-sparse stiffness
changes based on the identified modal parameters; (2) the uncertainty in the
inferred stiffness reductions is quantified; (3) no matching of model and
experimental modes is needed, and (4) solving the nonlinear eigenvalue problem
of a structural model is not required. The proposed method is applied to two
previously-studied examples using simulated data: a ten-story shear-building
and the three-dimensional braced-frame model from the Phase II Simulated
Benchmark problem sponsored by the IASC-ASCE Task Group on Structural Health
Monitoring. The results show that the occurrence of false-positive and
false-negative damage detection is clearly reduced in the presence of modeling
error. Furthermore, the identified most probable stiffness loss ratios are
close to their actual values.
