  The $\alpha$ and $\beta$ subunits comprising the hexameric assembly of
F1-ATPase share a high degree of structural identity, though low primary
identity. Each subunit binds nucleotide in similar pockets, yet only $\beta$
subunits are catalytically active. Why? We re-examine their internal symmetry
axes and observe interesting differences. Dividing each chain into an
N-terminal head region, a C-terminal foot region, and a central torso, we
observe (1) that while the foot and head regions in all chains obtain high and
similar mobility, the torsos obtain different mobility profiles, with the
$\beta$ subunits exhibiting a higher motility compared to the $\alpha$
subunits, a trend supported by the crystallographic B-factors. The $\beta$
subunits have greater torso mobility by having fewer distributed, nonlocal
packing interactions providing a spacious and soft connectivity, and offsetting
the resultant softness with local stiffness elements, including an additional
$\beta$ sheet. (2) A loop near the nucleotide binding-domain of the $\beta$
subunits, absent in the $\alpha$ subunits, swings to create a large variation
in the occlusion of the nucleotide binding region. (3) A combination of the
softest three eigenmodes significantly reduces the RMSD between the open and
closed conformations of the $\beta$ subnits. (4) Comparisons of computed and
observed crystallographic B-factors suggest a suppression of a particular
symmetry axis in an $\alpha$ subunit. (5) Unexpectedly, the soft intra-monomer
oscillations pertain to distortions that do not create inter-monomer steric
clashes in the assembly, suggesting that structural optimization of the
assembly evolved at all levels of complexity.
