  An investigation of optimal feedback controllers' performance and robustness
is carried out for vortex shedding behind a 2D cylinder at low Reynolds
numbers. To facilitate controller design, we present an efficient modelling
approach in which we utilise the resolvent operator to recast the linearised
Navier-Stokes equations into an input-output form from which frequency
responses can be computed. The difficulty of applying modern control design
techniques to complex, high-dimensional flow systems is thus overcome by using
low-order models identified from these frequency responses. The low-order
models are used to design optimal control laws using $\mathcal{H}_{\infty}$
loop shaping. Two distinct control arrangements are considered, both of which
employ a single-input and a single-output. In the first control arrangement, a
velocity sensor located in the wake drives a pair of body forces near the
cylinder. Complete suppression of shedding is observed up to a Reynolds number
of $Re=110$. Due to the convective nature of vortex shedding and the
corresponding time delays, we observe a fundamental trade-off: the sensor
should be close enough to the cylinder to avoid any excessive time lag, but it
should be kept sufficiently far from the cylinder to measure any unstable modes
developing downstream. It is found that these two conflicting requirements
become more difficult to satisfy for larger Reynolds numbers. In the second
control arrangement, we consider a practical setup with a body-mounted force
sensor and an actuator that oscillates the cylinder according to the lift
measurement. It is shown that the system is stabilised only up to $Re=100$, and
we demonstrate why the performance of the resulting feedback controllers
deteriorates much more rapidly with increasing Reynolds number. The challenges
of designing robust controllers for each control setup are also analysed and
discussed.
