  We investigate the relevance of dynamic quantum coherence in the energy
transfer efficiency of molecular aggregates. We contrast the dynamics after
excitation of a quantum mechanical system with that of a classical system. We
demonstrate how a classical description of an ensemble average can be
satisfactorily interpreted either as a single system driven by a continuous
force or as an ensemble of systems each driven by an impulsive force. We derive
the time evolution of the density matrix for an open quantum system excited by
light or by a neighboring antenna. We argue that unlike in the classical case,
the quantum description does not allow for a formal decomposition of the
dynamics into sudden jumps in the quantum mechanical state. Rather, there is a
natural finite time-scale associated with the excitation process. We propose a
simple experiment how to test the influence of this time scale on the yield of
photosynthesis. Because photosynthesis is intrinsically an average process, the
efficiency of photosynthesis can be assessed from the quantum mechanical
expectation value calculated from the second-order response theory, which has
the same validity as the perturbative description of ultrafast experiments. We
demonstrate using typical parameters of the currently most studied
photosynthetic antenna, the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex, and a typical
energy transfer rate from the chlorosome baseplate, that dynamic coherences are
averaged out in the complex despite excitation proceeding through a coherent
superposition of its eigenstates. The dynamic coherence averages out even when
the FMO model is completely free of all dissipation and dephasing. We conclude
that under natural excitation conditions coherent dynamics cannot be
responsible for the remarkable efficiency of the photosynthesis even when
considering the dynamics at a single molecular level.
