  It is shown that traditional estimates of the pore diameter in the porous
silica material MCM-41-S15 (of order 15\AA) are too small to allow the amount
of water that is absorbed by these materials (around 0.5gH2O/g substrate) to
occur only inside the pore. Either the additional water is absorbed on the
surface of the silica particles and outside the pores, or else the pores are
larger than the traditional estimates. In addition the low Q Bragg intensities
from a sample of MCM-41-S15 porous silica under different dry and wet
conditions and with different hydrogen isotopes are simulated using a simple
model of the water and silica density profile across the pore. It is found the
best agreement of these intensities with experimental data is shown by assuming
the much larger pore diameter of 25\AA (radius 12.5\AA). Qualitative agreement
is found between these simulated density profiles and those found in recent
empirical potential structure refinement simulations of the same data, even
though the latter data did not specifically include the Bragg peaks in the
structure refinement. It is shown that the change in the (100) peak intensity
on cooling from 300K to 210K, which previously has been ascribed to a change in
density of the confined water on cooling, can equally be ascribed to a change
in density profile at constant average density. It is further pointed out that,
independent of whether the pore diameter really is as large as 25\AA\ or
whether a significant amount of water is absorbed outside the pore, the earlier
reports of a dynamic cross-over in supercooled confined water could in fact be
a crystallisation transition in the larger pore or surface water.
