  We consider a system of spins on the sites of a three-dimensional pyrochlore
lattice of corner-sharing tetrahedra interacting with a predominant effective
$xy$ exchange. In particular, we investigate the selection of a long-range
ordered state with broken discrete symmetry induced by thermal fluctuations
near the critical region. At the standard mean-field theory (s-MFT) level, in a
region of the parameter space of this Hamiltonian that we refer to as
$\Gamma_5$ region, the ordered state possesses an accidental $U(1)$ degeneracy.
In this paper, we show that fluctuations beyond s-MFT lift this degeneracy by
selecting one of two states (so-called $\psi_2$ and $\psi_3$) from the
degenerate manifold, thus exposing a certain form of order-by-disorder (ObD).
We analytically explore this selection at the microscopic level and close to
criticality by elaborating upon and using an extension of the so-called TAP
method, originally developed by Thouless, Anderson and Palmer to study the
effect of fluctuations in spin glasses. We also use a single-tetrahedron
cluster-mean-field theory (c-MFT) to explore over what minimal length scale
fluctuations can lift the degeneracy. We find the phase diagrams obtained by
these two methods to be somewhat different since c-MFT only includes the
shortest-range fluctuations. General symmetry arguments used to construct a
Ginzburg-Landau theory to lowest order in the order parameters predict that a
weak magnetic moment, $m_z$, along the local $\langle 111 \rangle$ (${\hat z}$)
direction is generically induced for a system ordering into a $\psi_2$ state,
but not so for $\psi_3$ ordering. Both E-TAP and c-MFT calculations confirm
this weak fluctuation-induced $m_z$ moment. Using a Ginzburg-Landau theory, we
discuss the phenomenology of multiple phase transitions below the paramagnetic
phase transition and within the $\Gamma_5$ long-range ordered phase.
