  The purpose of this study is to determine whether organ sparing and target
coverage can be simultaneously maintained for pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton
therapy treatment of thoracic tumors in the presence of motion, stopping power
uncertainties and patient setup variations. Ten consecutive patients that were
previously treated with proton therapy to 66.6/1.8 Gy (RBE) using double
scattering (DS) were replanned with PBS. Minimum and maximum intensity images
from 4DCT were used to introduce flexible smearing in the determination of the
beam specific PTV (BSPTV). Datasets from eight 4DCT phases, using +-3%
uncertainty in stopping power, and +-3 mm uncertainty in patient setup in each
direction were used to create 8X12X10=960 PBS plans for the evaluation of ten
patients. Plans were normalized to provide identical coverage between DS and
PBS. The average lung V20, V5, and mean doses were reduced from 29.0%, 35.0%,
and 16.4 Gy with DS to 24.6%, 30.6%, and 14.1 Gy with PBS, respectively. The
average heart V30 and V45 were reduced from 10.4% and 7.5% in DS to 8.1% and
5.4% for PBS, respectively. Furthermore, the maximum spinal cord, esophagus and
heart dose were decreased from 37.1 Gy, 71.7 Gy and 69.2 Gy with DS to 31.3 Gy,
67.9 Gy and 64.6 Gy with PBS. The conformity index (CI), homogeneity index
(HI), and global maximal dose were improved from 3.2, 0.08, 77.4 Gy with DS to
2.8, 0.04 and 72.1 Gy with PBS. All differences are statistically significant,
with p values <0.05, with the exception of the heart V45 (p= 0.146). PBS with
BSPTV achieves better organ sparing and improves target coverage using a
repainting method for the treatment of thoracic tumors. Incorporating
motion-related uncertainties is essential in maintaining marginal coverage and
homogenous dose of treatment targets.
