  Symmetry breaking, a central principle of physics, has been hailed as the
driver of self-organization in biological systems in general and biogenesis of
cellular organelles in particular, but the molecular mechanisms of symmetry
breaking only begin to become understood. Centrioles, the structural cores of
centrosomes and cilia, must duplicate every cell cycle to ensure their faithful
inheritance through cellular divisions. Work in model organisms identified
conserved proteins required for centriole duplication and found that altering
their abundance affects centriole number. However, the biophysical principles
that ensure that, under physiological conditions, only a single procentriole is
produced on each mother centriole remain enigmatic. Here we propose a
mechanistic biophysical model for the initiation of procentriole formation in
mammalian cells. The model faithfully recapitulates the experimentally observed
transition from PLK4 uniformly distributed around the mother centriole, the
"ring", to a unique PLK4 focus, the "spot", that triggers the assembly of a new
procentriole. This symmetry breaking requires a dual positive feedback based on
autocatalytic activation of PLK4 and enhanced centriolar anchoring of PLK4-STIL
complexes by phosphorylated STIL. We find that, contrary to previous proposals,
in situ degradation of active PLK4 is insufficient to break symmetry. Instead,
the model predicts that competition between transient PLK4 activity maxima for
PLK4-STIL complexes explains both the instability of the PLK4 ring and
formation of the unique PLK4 spot. In the model, strong competition at
physiologically normal parameters robustly produces a single procentriole,
while increasing overexpression of PLK4 and STIL weakens the competition and
causes progressive addition of procentrioles in agreement with experimental
observations.
