  Knowledge about the exact positioning of aircraft is crucial in many
settings. Consequently, the opportunistic and independent localization of
aircraft based on their communication has been a longstanding problem and
subject of much research. Originating from military settings, the capability to
conduct aircraft localization has moved first towards the institutional civil
aviation domain and can now be undertaken by anyone who has access to multiple
cheap software-defined radios. Based on these technological developments, many
crowdsourced sensor networks have sprung up, which collect air traffic control
data in order to localize aircraft and visualize the airspace. Due to their
unplanned and uncontrolled deployment and heterogeneous receiver technology
traditional solutions to the Aircraft Localization Problem (ALP) can either not
be applied or do not perform in a satisfactory manner. In order to deal with
this issue and to find novel approaches to the ALP itself, we have designed and
executed a multi-stage open competition, conducted both offline and online.
  In this paper, we discuss the setup, experiences, and lessons learned from
this Aircraft Localization Competition. We report from a diverse set of
technical approaches, comprising 72 participating teams over three stages. The
participants reached a localization accuracy of up to 25 meters in a setting
with fully GPS-synchronized receivers and 78 meters in a largely unsynchronized
receiver setting. These results constitute a significant improvement over the
previous baseline used in the OpenSky research network.
  We compare the results of the study, discuss the current state of the art,
and highlight the areas that, based on our experience from organizing a
competition, need to be improved for optimal adoption of the competitive
approach for other scenarios.
