  Modular graph functions (MGFs) are $\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z})$-invariant
functions on the Poincar\'e upper half-plane associated with Feynman graphs of
a conformal scalar field on a torus. The low-energy expansion of genus-one
superstring amplitudes involves suitably regularized integrals of MGFs over the
fundamental domain for $\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z})$. In earlier work, these
integrals were evaluated for all MGFs up to two loops and for higher loops up
to weight six. These results led to the conjectured uniform transcendentality
of the genus-one four-graviton amplitude in Type II superstring theory. In this
paper, we explicitly evaluate the integrals of several infinite families of
three-loop MGFs and investigate their transcendental structure. Up to weight
seven, the structure of the integral of each individual MGF is consistent with
the uniform transcendentality of string amplitudes. Starting at weight eight,
the transcendental weights obtained for the integrals of individual MGFs are no
longer consistent with the uniform transcendentality of string amplitudes.
However, in all the cases we examine, the violations of uniform
transcendentality take on a special form given by the integrals of triple
products of non-holomorphic Eisenstein series. If Type II superstring
amplitudes do exhibit uniform transcendentality, then the special combinations
of MGFs which enter the amplitudes must be such that these integrals of triple
products of Eisenstein series precisely cancel one another. Whether this indeed
is the case poses a novel challenge to the conjectured uniform
transcendentality of genus-one string amplitudes.
