  In their article [arXiv:1705.03394], 'That is not dead which can eternal lie:
the aestivation hypothesis for resolving Fermi's paradox', Sandberg et al. try
to explain the Fermi paradox (we see no aliens) by claiming that Landauer's
principle implies that a civilization can in principle perform far more
(${\sim} 10^{30}$ times more) irreversible logical operations (e.g.,
error-correcting bit erasures) if it conserves its resources until the distant
future when the cosmic background temperature is very low. So perhaps aliens
are out there, but quietly waiting. Sandberg et al. implicitly assume, however,
that computer-generated entropy can only be disposed of by transferring it to
the cosmological background. In fact, while this assumption may apply in the
distant future, our universe today contains vast reservoirs and other physical
systems in non-maximal entropy states, and computer-generated entropy can be
transferred to them at the adiabatic conversion rate of one bit of negentropy
to erase one bit of error. This can be done at any time, and is not improved by
waiting for a low cosmic background temperature. Thus aliens need not wait to
be active. As Sandberg et al. do not provide a concrete model of the effect
they assert, we construct one and show where their informal argument goes
wrong.
