  Terrains are visually important and commonly used in computer graphics. While
many algorithms for their generation exist, it is difficult to assess the
realism of a generated terrain. This paper presents a first step in the
direction of perceptual evaluation of terrain models. We gathered and
categorized several classes of real terrains and we generated synthetic
terrains by using methods from computer graphics. We then conducted two large
studies ranking the terrains perceptually and showing that the synthetic
terrains are perceived as lacking realism as compared to the real ones. Then we
provide insight into the features that affect the perceived realism by a
quantitative evaluation based on localized geomorphology-based landform
features (geomorphons) that categorize terrain structures such as valleys,
ridges, hollows, etc. We show that the presence or absence of certain features
have a significant perceptual effect. We then introduce Perceived Terrain
Realism Metrics (PTRM); a perceptual metrics that estimates perceived realism
of a terrain represented as a digital elevation map by relating distribution of
terrain features with their perceived realism. We validated PTRM on real and
synthetic data and compared it to the perceptual studies. To confirm the
importance of the presence of these features, we used a generative deep neural
network to transfer them between real terrains and synthetic ones and we
performed another perceptual experiment that further confirmed their importance
for perceived realism.
