  We investigate the variational formulation and corresponding minimizing
energies for the detection of energetically favorable magnetization states of
thin cylindrical magnetic nanodots. Opposed to frequently used heuristic
procedures found in the literature, we revisit the underlying governing
equations and construct a rigorous variational approach that takes both
exchange and demagnetization energy into account. Based on a combination of
Ritz's method and a Fourier series expansion of the solution field, we are able
to pinpoint the precision of solutions, which are given by vortex modes or
single-domain states, down to an arbitrary degree of precision. Furthermore,
our model allows to derive an expression for the demagnetization energy in
closed form for the in-plane single-domain state, which we compare to results
from the literature. A key outcome of the present investigation is an accurate
phase diagram, which we obtain by comparing the vortex mode's energy minimizers
with those of the single-domain states. This phase diagram is validated with
data of two- and three-dimensional models from literature. By means of the
phase diagram, we particularly find the critical radius at which the vortex
mode becomes unfavorable with machine precision. All relevant data and codes
related to the present contribution are available at
http://dx.doi.org/10.18419/darus-3103.
