  It is well known that the visual information represented in the simple cells
of the primary visual cortex V1 is spatially localized, orientation-sensitive
and bandpass-filtered. In addition, the visual information represented is
subsampled. On the other hand, the methods used to assess image quality of
x-ray systems performing detectability tasks are usually carried out in the
spatial or image domain. This study examines the behavior of two observers, IBO
and NPW, employed in the evaluation of imaging systems, in a domain that
simulates the representation of visual information in V1 to gain a better
understanding of the degree of optimization in human observer detectability
tasks. The comparison of the two observers is conducted on images of a
contrast-detail phantom and is performed in both the spatial and the wavelet
domains. Furthermore, the study examines the covariance matrices of the noise.
The strong covariance exhibited in the noise among neighboring pixels in the
spatial domain results in covariance matrices with relatively high values
outside the main diagonal, leading to significant differences between the NPW
and IBO observers. In the transformed domain, the band-pass decimated filters
have substantially reduced the covariance between neighboring pixels, resulting
in the convergence of the detectability indices of both observers. The vast
amount of information captured by the retina necessitates an optimization of
informational nature. This strategy eliminates low-frequency correlations in
the image, after bandpass filtering carried out by simple cells in V1. This
loss of information could contribute to the suboptimal performance of the human
observer. Interestingly, in V1 the differences between IBO and NPW observers
are very small. Therefore, either NPW does not accurately represent the human
observer in V1, or the human observer is close to optimal in this domain.
