  We consider the spectrum of anomalous dimensions in planar $\mathcal{N}=4$
supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory and its $\mathcal{N}=1$ super-conformal
Leigh-Strassler deformations. The two-loop truncation of the integrable
$\mathcal{N}=4$ dilatation operator in the SU$(2)$ sector, which is a
next-to-nearest-neighbour deformation of the XXX spin chain, is not strictly
integrable at finite coupling and we show that it indeed has Wigner-Dyson level
statistics. However, we find that it is only weakly chaotic in the sense that
the cross-over to chaotic dynamics is slower than for generic chaotic systems.
For the Leigh-Strassler deformed theory with generic parameters, we show that
the one-loop dilatation operator in the SU$(3)$ sector is chaotic, with a
spectrum that is well described by GUE Random Matrix Theory. For the
imaginary-$\beta$ deformation, the statistics are GOE and the transition from
the integrable limit is that of a generic system. This provides a weak-coupling
analogue of the chaotic dynamics seen for classical strings in the dual
background. We further study the spin chains in the semi-classical limit
described by generalised Landau-Lifshitz models, which are also known to
describe large-angular-momentum string solutions in the dual theory. We show
that for the higher-derivative theory following from the two-loop
$\mathcal{N}=4$ SU$(2)$ spin chain, the maximal Lyapunov exponent is close to
zero, consistent with the absence of chaotic dynamics. For the
imaginary-$\beta$ SU$(3)$ theory, the resulting Landau-Lifshitz model has
classically chaotic dynamics at finite values of the deformation parameter.
