  The Dynamic Decode-and-Forward (DDF) protocol and the Hybrid DDF and
Amplified-and-Forward (HDAF) protocol for the multiple-access relay channel
(MARC) with quasi static fading are evaluated using the Zheng-Tse
diversity-multiplexing tradeoff (DMT). We assume that there are two users, one
half-duplex relay, and a common destination, each equipped with single antenna.
For the Rayleigh fading, the DDF protocol is well known and has been analyzed
in terms of the DMT with infinite block length. By carefully dealing with
properties specific to finite block length, we characterize the finite block
length DMT which takes into account the fact that the event of decoding error
at the relay causes the degradation in error performance when the block length
is finite. Furthermore, we consider the situation where the destination does
not have a priori knowledge of the relay decision time at which the relay
switches from listening to transmitting. By introducing a decision rejection
criterion such that the relay forwards message only when its decision is
reliable, and the generalized likelihood ratio test (GLRT) at the destination
that jointly decodes the relay decision time and the information message, our
analysis show that the optimal DMT is achievable as if there is no decoding
error at the relay and the relay decision time is known at the destination.
Therefore, infinite block length and additional overhead for communicating the
decision time are not needed for the DDF to achieve the optimal DMT. To further
improve the DMT, we propose the HDAF protocol which take advantages of both the
DDF and the Amplified-and-Forward protocols by judiciously choosing which
protocol to use. Our result shows that the HDAF protocol outperforms the
original DDF in the DMT perspective. Finally, a variant of the HDAF protocol
with lower implementation complexity without sacrificing the DMT performance is
devised.
