  As discussions around 6G begin, it is important to carefully quantify the
spectral efficiency gains actually realized by deployed 5G networks as compared
to 4G through various enhancements such as higher modulation, beamforming, and
MIMO. This will inform the design of future cellular systems, especially in the
mid-bands, which provide a good balance between bandwidth and propagation.
Similar to 4G, 5G also utilizes low-band (<1 GHz) and mid-band spectrum (1 to 6
GHz), and hence comparing the performance of 4G and 5G in these bands will
provide insights into how further improvements can be attained. In this work,
we address a crucial question: is the performance boost in 5G compared to 4G
primarily a result of increased bandwidth, or do the other enhancements play
significant roles, and if so, under what circumstances? Hence, we conduct
city-wide measurements of 4G and 5G cellular networks deployed in low- and
mid-bands in Chicago and Minneapolis, and carefully quantify the contributions
of different aspects of 5G advancements to its improved throughput performance.
Our analyses show that (i) compared to 4G, the throughput improvement in 5G
today is mainly influenced by the wider channel bandwidth, both from single
channels and channel aggregation, (ii) in addition to wider channels, improved
5G throughput requires better signal conditions, which can be delivered by
denser deployment and/or use of beamforming in mid-bands, (iii) the channel
rank in real-world environments rarely supports the full 4 layers of 4x4 MIMO
and (iv) advanced features such as MU-MIMO and higher order modulation such as
1024-QAM have yet to be widely deployed. These observations and conclusions
lead one to consider designing the next generation of cellular systems to have
wider channels, perhaps with improved channel aggregation, dense deployment
with more beams.
