  Seismic imaging of the mantle has revealed large and small scale
heterogeneities in the lower mantle; specifically structures known as large low
shear velocity provinces (LLSVP) below Africa and the South Pacific. Most
interpretations propose that the heterogeneities are compositional in nature,
differing in composition from the overlying mantle, an interpretation that
would be consistent with chemical geodynamic models. Numerical modeling of
persistent compositional interfaces presents challenges, even to
state-of-the-art numerical methodology. For example, some numerical algorithms
for advecting the compositional interface cannot maintain a sharp compositional
boundary as the fluid migrates and distorts with time dependent fingering due
to the numerical diffusion that has been added in order to maintain the upper
and lower bounds on the composition variable and the stability of the advection
method. In this work we present two new algorithms for maintaining a sharper
computational boundary than the advection methods that are currently openly
available to the computational mantle convection community; namely, a
Discontinuous Galerkin method with a Bound Preserving limiter and a
Volume-of-Fluid interface tracking algorithm. We compare these two new methods
with two approaches commonly used for modeling the advection of two distinct,
thermally driven, compositional fields in mantle convection problems; namely,
an approach based on a high-order accurate finite element method advection
algorithm that employs an artificial viscosity technique to maintain the upper
and lower bounds on the composition variable as well as the stability of the
advection algorithm and the advection of particles that carry a scalar quantity
representing the location of each compositional field. All four of these
algorithms are implemented in the open source FEM code ASPECT.
