  The key objective of this study is to investigate the interrelationship
between fuel economy gaps and to quantify the differential effects of several
factors on fuel economy gaps of vehicles operated by the same garage. By using
a unique fuel economy database (fueleconomy.gov), users self-reported fuel
economy estimates and government fuel economy ratings are analyzed for more
than 7000 garages across the U.S. The empirical analysis, nonetheless, is
complicated owing to the presence of important methodological concerns
including potential interrelationship between vehicles within the same garage
and unobserved heterogeneity. To address these concerns, bivariate seemingly
unrelated fixed and random parameter models are presented. With government test
cycle ratings tending to over-estimate the actual on-road fuel economy, a
significant variation is observed in the fuel economy gaps for the two vehicles
across garages. A wide variety of factors such as driving style, fuel economy
calculation method, and several vehicle specific characteristics are
considered. Drivers who drive for maximum gas mileage or drives with the
traffic flow have greater on-road fuel economy relative to the government
official ratings. Contrarily, volatile drivers have smaller on-road fuel
economy relative to the official ratings. Compared to the previous findings,
our analysis suggests that the relationship between fuel type and fuel economy
gaps is complex and not unidirectional. Regarding several vehicle and
manufacturer related variables, the effects do not just significantly vary in
magnitude but also in the direction, underscoring the importance of accounting
for within-garage correlation and unobserved heterogeneity for making reliable
inferences.
