  Organisms across all domains of life regulate the size of their cells.
However, the means by which this is done is poorly understood. We study two
abstracted "molecular" models for size regulation: inhibitor dilution and
initiator accumulation. We apply the models to two settings: bacteria like
Escherichia coli, that grow fully before they set a division plane and divide
into two equally sized cells, and cells that form a bud early in the cell
division cycle, confine new growth to that bud, and divide at the connection
between that bud and the mother cell, like the budding yeast Saccharomyces
cerevisiae. In budding cells, delaying cell division until buds reach the same
size as their mother leads to very weak size control, with average cell size
and standard deviation of cell size increasing over time and saturating up to
100-fold higher than those values for cells that divide when the bud is still
substantially smaller than its mother. In budding yeast, both inhibitor
dilution or initiator accumulation models are consistent with the observation
that the daughters of diploid cells add a constant volume before they divide.
This adder behavior has also been observed in bacteria. We find that in
bacteria an inhibitor dilution model produces adder correlations that are not
robust to noise in the timing of DNA replication initiation or in the timing
from initiation of DNA replication to cell division (the C + D period). In
contrast, in bacteria an initiator accumulation model yields robust adder
correlations in the regime where noise in the timing of DNA replication
initiation is much greater than noise in the C + D period, as reported
previously [1]. In bacteria, division into two equally sized cells does not
broaden the size distribution.
