  Direct numerical simulations, performed with a high-order spectral-element
method, are used to study coherent structures in turbulent pipe flow at
friction Reynolds numbers $Re_{\tau} = 180$ and $550$. The database was
analysed using spectral proper orthogonal decomposition (SPOD) to identify
energetically dominant coherent structures, most of which turn out to be
streaks and quasi-streamwise vortices. To understand how such structures can be
modelled, the linear flow responses to harmonic forcing were computed using the
singular value decomposition of the resolvent operator, using the mean field as
a base flow. The SPOD and resolvent analysis were calculated for several
combinations of frequencies and wavenumbers, allowing to map out the
similarities between SPOD modes and optimal responses for a wide range of
relevant scales in turbulent pipe flows. In order to explore physical reasons
behind the agreement between both methods, an indicator of lift-up mechanism in
the resolvent analysis was introduced, activated when optimal forcing
represents quasi-streamwise vortices and associated response corresponds to
streaks. Good agreement between leading SPOD and resolvent modes is observed in
a large region of parameter space. In this region, a significant gain
separation is found in resolvent analysis, which may be attributed to the
strong amplification associated with the lift-up mechanism. For both Reynolds
numbers, the observed concordances were generally for structures with large
energy in the buffer layer. The results highlight resolvent analysis as a
pertinent reduced-order model for coherent structures in wall-bounded
turbulence, particularly for streamwise elongated structures corresponding to
near-wall streamwise vortices and streaks.
