Home    Subscribe    Write for Us    FAQ    Contact    HubGarden    Login

Can you say you've read a book if you listened to the audio book version?

by Lydia C. Lee (follow)
Question (173)      Reading (53)      Books (29)      Audio Book (6)      Semantics (2)     


Confederacy of Dunces & Blossoms and Shadows
Penguin Edition Confederacy of Dunces & ABC audio book Blossoms and Shadows


To solve an argument, can you say you've read a book, if you listened to the audiobook version? Is there a difference, and do you need to specify which you did?

#Reading
#Audio Book
#Books
#Semantics
#Question
I like this Question - 7
[ Submit an Answer ]
Top Answers
I think so, yes, provide you are really listening to it, not just letting it play without paying attention. Most of the books I "read" these days are in audiobook format. With two small children and a household to run I just don't have the time to sit down and read as much as I used to. I keep track of the books I've read in a reading journal and I always make a note when they are audiobooks, not because the "count" any less but so that if I go looking for the book again I know what kind it was.
You are so organized Jennifer, keeping a journal of books you read. I would love to do that, and even though I have thought about doing it, I never really got down to implementing the journal/diary. Hats off to you!
I would say yes, it counts, because it's the words you're engaging with, and the story you're relating to etc. Some of the arguments against is that (1) you don't even have to be able to read (??) (2) the reader is interpreting the book for you - (that one I will accept to a point). One person thinks you should specify you listened to it, not read it. I don't really see how that is relevant if you are arguing plot or discussing phrasing etc. Interestingly, there is a study that you are more easily distracted when reading than when listening, so in actual fact, the audio book process has a longer attention span...
Excellent points. Never really thought about it before.
You can't say you've 'read' it, but you can say you've 'listened' to it. Some audiobooks read out the story word for word, where as others abridge, or change bits slightly.
Personally, I think listening to a book requires a lot more concentration and focus than actually holding a book and reading it. Let me explain. If I was listening to a book, I am bound to be multi-tasking, even if it means I am listening while driving. I am sure that my thoughts will go astray, and I will need to re-listen to bits and pieces if I lose track of the plot. However, if my focus goes adrift while reading a book, all I need to do is just shift my eyes two paras up, and I'll have reached the parts my brain actually registered.
Anyhow, I think there is a difference, but if you are good at listening to books, then the main point is that you know what the book is all about - doesn't matter whether you read it or listened to it.
Yes, hearing a book on audio is the same as reading a book, as the end result is the same -you know the story!
by Finy
No difference.
Aim of the game is to know a story.
Whether you read or listen to it is irrelevant, you get the same outcome.

More Articles by Lydia C. Lee
view all articles by Lydia C. Lee
Articles by Lydia C. Lee on Other Hubs
Address:Level 1, 37 Bligh Street Sydney, NSW 2000 At a Glance: Great fun for the whole family...
8 likes
ID: 17607
Trending Articles
Categories
Fiction (329)
Question (173)
Writing (22)
Comics (44)
Poetry (16)
Essay (8)
Humour (72)
Fantasy (66)
Romance (25)
Lesbian (15)
LGBT (13)
Zombies (10)
Sex (2)
Gay (2)
Food (2)
Myth (1)
Action (1)
 
Copyright 2012-2017 On Topic Media PTY LTD. ABN 18113479226. mobile version
http://acomfychair.com/can-you-say-youve-read-a-book-if-you-listened-to-the-audio-book-version/
acomfychair.com
crawl=CC-MAIN-2017-39
48678
application/http; msgtype=response
sha1:UMPMKCLBYC6J4YBD2W2PKIUJS2PNIMST
<urn:uuid:6a422795-d69f-4ff4-a9af-837d58e5bf90>
2017-09-19T17:12:38Z
107.21.125.103
text/html
sha1:4HDCYCYFKYVUZRF4AKFQAWIK5G2URZQ5
<urn:uuid:76eabcf4-db35-4362-b72a-38d58693ffba>
http://acomfychair.com/can-you-say-youve-read-a-book-if-you-listened-to-the-audio-book-version/
response
<urn:uuid:07b0affb-ddf5-42d6-a4ba-d9e188e316f0>
robots: classic
hostname: ip-10-142-185-151.ec2.internal
software: Nutch 1.6 (CC)
isPartOf: CC-MAIN-2017-39
operator: Common Crawl Admin
description: Wide crawl of the web for September 2017
publisher: Common Crawl
format: WARC File Format 1.0
conformsTo: http://bibnum.bnf.fr/WARC/WARC_ISO_28500_version1_latestdraft.pdf