Monday, September 19, 2011

Guest Post: Karen Blumenthal on the Power & Challenges of Using Photos & Cartoons in Nonfiction

By Karen Blumenthal

As a nonfiction author, I've come to appreciate that powerful photographs and cartoons of the day can truly help bring a time period alive for a young reader. But finding and acquiring those images from recent decades can be surprisingly difficult.

I ran into the problem headfirst working on two books that have just come out--Bootleg: Murder, Moonshine, and the Lawless Years of Prohibition (Roaring Brook, 2011), about the prohibition era, and Mr. Sam: How Sam Walton Built Wal-Mart and Became America’s Richest Man (Viking, 2011). Somehow, I nearly drowned in the potential images from the early 1900s, when photography was relatively new--and I struggled to find material for Mr. Sam, though he built his business after World War II.

How do you figure that?

It appears that the folks who commission and collected photographs, cartoons and other images were much more thorough and thoughtful about taking care of their collections when photographs were expensive and precious than they were when they became more common.

Decades-old magazine and newspaper photos, for instance, often have been turned over to libraries like the Bentley at the University of Michigan, historical societies or the Library of Congress, which had an extensive collection of Anti-Saloon League propaganda. Or they can be found in huge photo houses, like those at the Associated Press, Corbis and Getty Images, where I found a fabulous New York Daily News image of children trying to scoop up wine poured into the street.

But fantastic photos of Sam Walton that appeared in Fortune magazine in the late 1980s were nowhere to be found. A woman at the magazine--who had been laid off and was in her last few days--informed me that copies weren't kept and I'd need to find the photographer. Unfortunately, his last known phone number was disconnected and letters I sent to two previous addresses, including his current driver’s license address, were never answered. I never located him or his photos.

A search for 30- and 40-year-old BusinessWeek photos hit a similar dead end. A Forbes photo was a particular favorite, but Forbes didn't return emails or phone calls. Based on some threads on the Internet, I concluded the photographer, Bill Batson, had worked for a Kansas City newspaper. A helpful person in the photo department couldn't find the image, but told me Batson had left Kansas City to work for the paper in Omaha, Nebraska. Sadly, a former Omaha colleague informed me, Mr. Batson died in 2002 and the whereabouts of his photos the late 1970s were unknown.

Luckily, the University of Missouri had run the image in an alumni magazine, and I was able to use it from a scan, crediting the photographer.

Several people I spoke to told bone-chilling stories of librarians tossing old photos and negatives during one clean-up or another.

Contemporary cartoons are almost as hard to find. Outside of Doonesbury, finding a comprehensive electronic archive is almost impossible; you need to find some kind soul who has kept a file of favorites or call the artists directly.

Eager to find Wal-Mart cartoons from the 1980s, I emailed a half-dozen or so long-time editorial cartoonists whose information I found through the National Cartoonists Society and other searches. I came up empty--until Pulitzer Prize winning cartoonist Paul Szep wrote back that he hadn't done a cartoon, but he would happily draws a caricature of Sam Walton. A wonderful cover design grew out of that email exchange.

From about the mid-1990s on, images and cartoons commonly have been kept in digital form and increasingly are searchable. But too many contemporary images from the decades just before are being lost to budget cuts and general sloppiness.

Even if the images are donated to libraries or archives, budgets are so tight that they may languish in boxes for years before they can be catalogued, let alone digitized.

I don’t have a simple answer. But as a believer in the importance and power of history to educate and enlighten us, I can only hope that today’s photographers, cartoonists, archivists and librarians will make an effort to preserve these important images for the benefit of generations to come.

Karen's Tips for Image Research
  • Start early. This work takes times, so don’t wait til the end to do it.
  • Be persistent. If you love an image, keep looking. After searching several photo archives for a congressional photo, I found it in a university library, in the papers of a former Congresswoman.
  • Three words: Library of Congress. The photo collection is amazing, but you can also order scans of almost anything it has, such as long-defunct magazines.
  • Tap historical societies, local museums and university archives. WorldCat.org, a giant library catalog, can tell you which libraries have historical papers.
  • Go beyond photos. Advertisements, cartoons and political “ephemera” can add a lot of flavor to the page.
  • Buy it. eBay can be great for old magazines and knickknacks. Old books may have valuable illustrations.
  • Negotiate. The cost of permissions really adds up. Plead, beg, grovel and remind everyone that this is for a children’s book.
Cynsational Notes

Karen Blumenthal is the author of two new nonfiction books for young people, Bootleg: Murder, Moonshine, and the Lawless Years of Prohibition (Roaring Brook, 2011)(excerpt) and Mr. Sam: How Sam Walton Built Wal-Mart and Became America’s Richest Man (Viking, 2011). She lives in Dallas.

4 comments:

Stacy S. Jensen said...

You raised some issues that never crossed my mind. Thank you for sharing your hard researched experience. I grew up in photojournalism and the filing systems varied with each new staffer. I hope digital archives are better.

Cynthia Leitich Smith said...

So glad you found the post thought-provoking, Stacy! Thanks for chiming in.

gerkman said...

I just finished reading a non-fiction book that was loaded with photographs. I never really thought about the power of photographs and cartoons of the day help really bring a time period to life until taking this college class. After reading how much time it takes to research all of the pictures, I have a new appreciation to completing a non-fiction book.

Cynthia Leitich Smith said...

So glad to hear that Karen's post made you view them in a new way.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
http://cynthialeitichsmith.blogspot.com/2011/09/guest-post-karen-blumenthal-on-power.html
cynthialeitichsmith.blogspot.com
crawl=CC-MAIN-2016-07
207339
application/http; msgtype=response
sha1:CPNIETD2BDZ5UUGQDG3IYFTWBY3FOM3O
<urn:uuid:4e295ab3-a76f-4d5a-81a5-1daaa284332c>
2016-02-14T16:53:53Z
74.125.22.132
sha1:MC6XTEY77RHIFZICLFSD5ZSSVMORQ4J7
<urn:uuid:94c65034-f25a-485f-af51-1d512efc3fb4>
http://cynthialeitichsmith.blogspot.com/2011/09/guest-post-karen-blumenthal-on-power.html
response
<urn:uuid:3dc40090-d975-4bdf-9962-b9d649b42c9b>
robots: classic
hostname: ip-10-236-182-209.ec2.internal
software: Nutch 1.6 (CC)/CC WarcExport 1.0
isPartOf: CC-MAIN-2016-07
operator: CommonCrawl Admin
description: Wide crawl of the web for February 2016
publisher: CommonCrawl
format: WARC File Format 1.0
conformsTo: http://bibnum.bnf.fr/WARC/WARC_ISO_28500_version1_latestdraft.pdf