… My heart’s in Accra Ethan Zuckerman’s online home, since 2003

May 3, 2007

Everything is Miscellaneous

Filed under: Berkman,Geekery,Media — Ethan @ 6:14 pm

One of the central ironies of David Weinberger’s new book, “Everything is Miscellaneous”, is that a book about classification is bound to suffer from classification problems. Reviewers and bookstore owners are inclined to think of David as a business writer because his previous books – The Cluetrain Manifesto and Small Pieces Loosely Joined – were profoundly useful in helping businesspeople understand what this World Wide Web thing was really all about. But it’s a mistake to consider David’s new book solely as a business book.

Which isn’t to say that reading Everything is Miscellaneous won’t help you make a buck in world of Web 2.0. It probably will, as the issues David explores are core to any business that deals with information and knowledge… which is to say, virtually every industry you can think of. But “Everything is Miscellaneous” is also a philosophy book. It’s about the shape of knowledge, and how moving information from paper to the web changes how we organize and how we think. And this means that David’s book crosses from territory like Wikipedia and Flickr into Aristotle and Wittgenstein.

This would be a dangerous path for a lesser author to take, but David grounds his explorations in examples and interviews that are, as Cory Doctorow puts it, wonderfully miscellaneous. We bounce between the lives and ideas of taxonomers past – Linneaus, S.R. Ranganathan, and the wonderfully strange Melvil Dewi – and the librarians and software developers who are making sense of today’s digital disorder.

At its heart, David’s book is about what happens when we liberate knowledge from the world of atoms. In the physical world, we can only organize books on a shelf in one way or another – books can’t be in multiple places at once. Frequently we find ourselves reduced to ordering information in arbitrary ways as a result – AAAAA Towing Service gets more business through the phonebook than Mike’s Wreckers through the unfairness of alphabetization (a phenomenon that anyone named Zuckerman is deeply familiar with from elementary school…)

Adding a layer of metadata to the physical world helps somewhat – card catalogs allow us to put multiple pointers to a single physical location so we can file a single book on Military Music under both “Music” and “Military”. But card catalogs pale in comparison to the wonders of “third-order” metadata, the sorts of organization we’re capable of in a digital age. A book listed by Amazon can be filed in any number of categories. It can be annotated with reader reviews, added to reading lists, enhanced with tags or statistically improbable phrases. The “card” in the card catalog can be larger than the book itself, and the full text of the book serves as metadata, as the book itself is searchable.

David argues that the fact that we tend to organize data in terms of its physical placement has consequences for how knowledge works. We tend to think in Aristotelian terms – objects are members of a categories, and share the same traits as other members of that category. We can organize these categories into trees: a robin is a bird, which is an animal. We can expect the leaves of trees to share the attributes of their branches, and we expect each leaf to fit onto only one, specific branch.

But that’s not knowledge works in a digital age. When I bookmark a webpage through del.icio.us, it’s to my benefit to add many tags to it, both because it makes it easier for me to find it again, and because it helps other people find it as well. Weinberger advises us to “put each leaf on as many branches as possible”, building a tree that looks more like a hyperlinked pile of leaves.

This suggestion, along with advice to use everything as a label, to filter only when we need outputs, and to give up the idea that there’s a “right way” to order things, serve as a roadmap for how to build tools and services in a digital age. But the magic of David’s book is that this practical advice is also an invitation to explore categorization, language and knowledge itself. If knowledge is a pile of leaves instead of a tree, how does the shape of our knowledge change?

It’s questions like this that make “Everything is Miscellaneous” deceptively deep. One moment, we’re thinking about how we organize photographs in shoeboxes or on our hard drives, and a moment later we’re asking whether we understand “shoebox” in terms of definitions, family resemblances or exemplars. It’s a little like drinking a mojito – smooth going down, but deceptively powerful, and slightly staggering when you get up to buy the next round.

I’ve read the book twice now, and am looking to my third pass through it. David’s done something rare and admirable here – he’s written about a world I thought I knew well in a way that makes me realize that there are innumerable depths and implications left to explore.


Disclaimers: David is a friend, a colleague, someone I deeply admire, and someone I aspire to write and think like. There’s no doubt that these facts influence my judgement in writing about his book, but hey, there it is.

8 Comments

  1. Interesting – thx for sharing this!

    Comment by JKE — May 3, 2007 @ 8:19 pm

  2. […] [Source: Ethan Zuckerman: My heart’s in Accra » Everything is Miscellaneous] […]

    Pingback by Metadataethics And Mobchaos « Hic Sunt Dracones — May 4, 2007 @ 9:04 am

  3. […] Ethan Zuckerman has posted a review of Everything is Miscellaneous. He thinks reading it is like drinking a mojito: Towards the bottom you always end up with leaves in your teeth. Ok, so maybe that wasn’t the point of his metaphor, but Ethan does a great job explaining what the book is about. [Tags: ethan_zuckerman reviews] […]

    Pingback by Everything is Miscellaneous » Blog Archive » Ethanz’s review — May 4, 2007 @ 10:44 am

  4. Wow, that’s a review! After reading your post, someone can do nothing but to buy the book and read it.
    I wonder if you know why David didn’t release this book under a Creative Commons license.
    And even more I wonder “when shall we wait a book from you?” I think it would be an highly interdisciplinary success with unexpected points of observation on our reality! (but please release it under Creative Commons)

    [There is a small typo in your post, I think.
    “But that’s not knowledge works in a digital age” –> “But that’s not how knowledge works in a digital age”. ]

    Comment by paolo — May 4, 2007 @ 4:51 pm

  5. a tree that looks more like a hyperlinked pile of leaves

    You mean a mycelium. Let’s get our biological metaphors straight here. ;-}

    Comment by quixote — May 4, 2007 @ 7:46 pm

  6. […] That’s not enough to serve as a full book review, and I apologize for what may seem like extreme haste on my part. But I know, from several other books that I’ve only gotten halfway through at this point, that it may be weeks or even months before I’ve consumed all of David’s new book. If you want a more complete book review, take a look at this one by Cory Doctorow, or this one by Ethan Zuckerman, or this review from Publishers Weekly, or this review from Karen Schneider at the American Library Association — who says, “This is, I repeat, a dangerous book. Ban it, burn it, or take it to heart.” […]

    Pingback by The Yourdon Report » Blog Archive » David Weinberger’s “Everything is Miscellaneous” — May 5, 2007 @ 9:28 pm

  7. […] 閱讀 Ethan Zuckerman 撰寫書評介紹 The Cluetrain Manifesto 的共同作者、Small Pieces Loosely Joined（中國譯名為《小塊鬆散組合》） David Weinberger 的新書：《一切都是混雜》（暫譯）（Everything Is Miscellaneous），讓我很想瞬間拿到這本書然後一睹為快。 […]

    Pingback by ilyagram » Blog Archive » 「一切都是混雜」 — May 9, 2007 @ 8:59 pm

  8. […] Great review by Ethan Zuckerman […]

    Pingback by David Weinberger on the Miscellaneous — everwas — August 12, 2007 @ 3:05 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Powered by WordPress
http://www.ethanzuckerman.com/blog/2007/05/03/everything-is-miscellaneous/
www.ethanzuckerman.com
crawl=CC-MAIN-2015-27
63073
application/http; msgtype=response
sha1:G4JV5KCEMZCYB23XOV7Y6VWRCXG6SU6T
<urn:uuid:542a4eb1-eebe-41ae-ba97-961f874464ed>
2015-07-06T17:48:33Z
72.249.123.152
sha1:3TIDBXABZSK7F3VVCWIPC3RHSWXVHVMS
<urn:uuid:b99867d2-c7c0-4a7e-9de8-74177e90d309>
http://www.ethanzuckerman.com/blog/2007/05/03/everything-is-miscellaneous/
response
<urn:uuid:ec8d300d-a047-41e7-afde-196b67035b66>
robots: classic
hostname: ip-10-179-60-89.ec2.internal
software: Nutch 1.6 (CC)/CC WarcExport 1.0
isPartOf: CC-MAIN-2015-27
operator: CommonCrawl Admin
description: Wide crawl of the web for June 2015
publisher: CommonCrawl
format: WARC File Format 1.0
conformsTo: http://bibnum.bnf.fr/WARC/WARC_ISO_28500_version1_latestdraft.pdf