Jump to content






Photo

This Would Be Better As A Poll

Posted by -Sidorak- , Apr 26 2009 · 37 views

BIONICLE and BZPower
As per Omi's suggestion, I am posting this here. It will be interesting to see who replies to this. Personally, I'm expecting more blog people to read/comment on it, but we'll see.

- - - - -

I have been thinking about this idea for some time. Please carefully read and consider this post. smile.gif

Instead of locking them, the staff should leave some of the topics that would normally be closed in favor of a poll open to encourage discussion.

Before you get ahead of me, I am NOT suggesting that all topics in GD that have less than 10 possible answers should be left open. Topics like this should indeed be closed. Those kinds of topics that ask simple questions really are best as polls.

Polls are good because they give a visual representation of how the choices break down; it's easier to see how popular one option is compared to another. And polls automatically calculate the percentage of members that voted for each choice. That kind of data is useful when you're dealing with those types of straightforward questions.

However, topics such as this provide plenty of opportunity for meaningful discussion. Look at the variety of replies in the topic; they aren't yes or no answers, there are many different viewpoints that can't really be captured in a poll.

Sure, you can water any question down by phrasing it in a way that creates "Yes" or "No" answers, but that's not always the best choice.

If you look at the poll that was made for that topic, the discussion has been stifled and the number of replies have been reduced. That's because the "Voting Booth mentality" is to click on a topic, vote, and maybe write a short answer. Leaving topics that have discussion potential in GD open would encourage in-depth discussion. cool.gif

Also, when there is an important topic or a particularly interesting question, it also attracts more attention in GD than it would in the Voting Booth.

Word to the GD staff: Please consider leaving a few potential poll-topics open to promote discussion: it doesn't hurt to leave one open now and then!

Word to the regular members: Is each topic with less than 10 theoretical answers always better as a poll? No. Please remember this and use your judgment decide whether the question really would be better in the form of a normal topic before suggesting that the topic starter PM a member on the poll-making team.

To summarize:
  1. Some topics should be locked in favor of a poll.
  2. HOWEVER, leaving some of these topics open encourages discussion. Remember, BZPower: BIONICLE News, Reference, and Discussion.
And before you tell me that all suggestions for the site should be PMed to Black Six - this isn't just a suggestion. I want to open it up for discussion and hear what other members have to say about it.

I look forward to hearing the views of both staff members and normal members.





Photo
Spoony Bard
Apr 26 2009 11:53 PM
Wow, you actually did what I said.

Now make me a sandwich!

-Omi
QUOTE(Son of a Submariner @ Apr 26 2009, 09:53 PM)
Wow, you actually did what I said.

Now make me a sandwich!

-Omi

Split it with me kthxbai
To stimulate discussion...
Maybe members in addition to asking yes/no questions should ask why they choose this or that for more discussion. shrugs.gif
QUOTE(Erebus @ Apr 26 2009, 10:02 PM)
QUOTE(Son of a Submariner @ Apr 26 2009, 09:53 PM)
Wow, you actually did what I said.

Now make me a sandwich!

-Omi

Split it with me kthxbai
To stimulate discussion...
Maybe members in addition to asking yes/no questions should ask why they choose this or that for more discussion. shrugs.gif

I love sandwiches!

Uh... yeah. tongue.gif I think it would be a good idea for topics starters to ask that.

Anyone else have thoughts on this?
Posting a topic in the Voting Booth shouldn't mean that a topic doesn't get discussion. Unfortunately, members are generally more interested in posting where they can get a post count. rolleyes.gif
This would be better as a poll.

Also, I think that it should just be up to whatever staff member sees it to decide whether to turn it into a poll or not. It would be good if the new rule was that if a Staffer saw a topic the would be BETTER as a poll, then he can proceed with the operation.

Just my five cents...

55555
QUOTE(SPIRIT @ Apr 27 2009, 07:56 AM)
Posting a topic in the Voting Booth shouldn't mean that a topic doesn't get discussion. Unfortunately, members are generally more interested in posting where they can get a post count. rolleyes.gif


It's not about post count, it's about making your posts count!


QUOTE(Zeddy @ Apr 28 2009, 06:42 AM)
QUOTE(SPIRIT @ Apr 27 2009, 07:56 AM)
Posting a topic in the Voting Booth shouldn't mean that a topic doesn't get discussion. Unfortunately, members are generally more interested in posting where they can get a post count. rolleyes.gif


It's not about post count, it's about making your posts count!


It's not about post count, it's about making your posts count toward your post count!

cool.gif

user(s) viewing

members, guests, anonymous users

December 2013

S M T W T F S
12345 6 7
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

Recent Entries

Famous Quotes

QUOTE(bohrok invasion)
Apparently 92% of teens have moved onto rap, and 8% of teens still listen to "real" music...so I guess that means there are absoloutely no deaf teenagers.
QUOTE(Screenguy)
I also look forward to the day when chickens can travel freely without having their motivations questioned...
QUOTE(Xarok in the Pics of Yourselves Topic)
To keep all the girls on this site from making out with their computer moniters, I'd rather not post a picture of myself. You just wouldn't be able to handle my good looks.
QUOTE(Covenant Grunt on the November 4th @ 2008 election results)
I myself was disappointed that Bahn McBama didn't win, and that the Proposition Infinity, which banned gay divorce, passed.
QUOTE(Parugi on Do You Believe In Santa Claus)
QUOTE(Motago's Signature)
This is my signature. It links to nothing. It shows nothing. It says nothing. It is within guidelines. Thanks for watching.
QUOTE(Vitruvius)
Beauty sleep in a Toa canister: 1000 widgets.

Energized protodermis spa (and subsequent transformation): 2000 widgets.

Adaptive armor from Artahka: 3000 widgets.

The look on Gali's face when she got transported into a swamp after that: priceless.
QUOTE(Planetperson on If Fish Should Be Called "Sea Kittens")
They're going in my stomach either way.
QUOTE(Omi)
So the next time you complain about how Mega Bloks rips off Lego, I want you to think of this entry and eat your words. With a side of bacon.
QUOTE(Dokuma)
*tosses bacon in microwave*

Mmmm... bacon goes great with hypocrisy!
http://www.bzpower.com/board/index.php?app=blog&module=display&section=blog&blogid=598&showentry=63164
www.bzpower.com
crawl=CC-MAIN-2013-48
76504
application/http; msgtype=response
sha1:MZFSOSB3JC5KBH3SILAIJ6CE6YHUFC5L
<urn:uuid:e2d073af-5fc8-4b26-a6dc-0bcca4c499a8>
2013-12-06T14:33:51Z
141.101.116.83
sha1:5WP3B2AXHHDCYUSXWWNGYEUYP4YQGCQ5
<urn:uuid:85a822c6-0ac7-40ef-9eea-f592b1cfef4c>
http://www.bzpower.com/board/index.php?app=blog&module=display&section=blog&blogid=598&showentry=63164
length
response
<urn:uuid:b6ada6e6-e661-4a7f-bbc9-f016bc1e53d3>
robots: classic
hostname: ip-10-33-133-15.ec2.internal
software: Nutch 1.6 (CC)/CC WarcExport 1.0
isPartOf: CC-MAIN-2013-48
operator: CommonCrawl Admin
description: Wide crawl of the web with URLs provided by Blekko for Winter 2013
publisher: CommonCrawl
format: WARC File Format 1.0
conformsTo: http://bibnum.bnf.fr/WARC/WARC_ISO_28500_version1_latestdraft.pdf