From jono at jcarroll.com.au  Fri Mar 17 01:03:19 2017
From: jono at jcarroll.com.au (Jonathan Carroll)
Date: Fri, 17 Mar 2017 10:33:19 +1030
Subject: [Rd] RFC: (in-principle) native unquoting for standard evaluation
Message-ID: <CAAjDRii1dPxNMTn9TSgReooOry2omQg9GCmXYDDFc99qv=F+7A@mail.gmail.com>

(please be gentle, it's my first time)

I am interested in discussions (possibly reiterating past threads --
searching didn't turn up much) on the possibility of supporting standard
evaluation unquoting at the language level. This has been brought up in a
recent similar thread here [1] and on Twitter [2] where I proposed the
following desired (in-principle) syntax

    f <- function(col1, col2, new_col_name) {
        mtcars %>% mutate(@new_col_name = @col1 + @col2)
    }

or closer to home

    x <- 1:10; y <- "x"
    data.frame(z = @y)

where @ would be defined as a unary prefix operator which substitutes the
quoted variable name in-place, to allow more flexibility of NSE functions
within a programming context. This mechanism exists within MySQL [3] (and
likely other languages) and could potentially be extremely useful. Several
alternatives have been incorporated into packages (most recently work
on tidyeval) none of which appear to fully match the simplicity of the
above, and some of which cut a forceful path through the syntax tree.

The exact syntax isn't my concern at the moment (@ vs unquote() or other,
though the first requires user-supplied native prefix support within the
language, as per [1]) and neither is the exact way in which this would be
achieved (well above my pay grade). The practicality of @ being on the LHS
of `=` is also of a lesser concern (likely greater complexity) than the RHS.

I hear there exists (justified) reluctance to add new syntax to the
language, but I think this has sufficient merit (and a growing number of
workarounds) to warrant continued discussion.

With kindest regards,

- Jonathan.

[1] https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-devel/2017-March/073894.html
[2] https://twitter.com/carroll_jono/status/842142292253196290
[3] https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.7/en/user-variables.html

	[[alternative HTML version deleted]]



[Rd] RFC: (in-principle) native unquoting for standard evaluation
Jonathan Carroll