From kcrisman at gmail.com  Thu Apr 21 17:47:15 2011
From: kcrisman at gmail.com (Karl-Dieter Crisman)
Date: Thu, 21 Apr 2011 11:47:15 -0400
Subject: [Rd] How to get R to compile with PNG support
In-Reply-To: <19888.16821.533699.499469@max.nulle.part>
References: <BANLkTinAtiXhxhSRhEEu0aDZsZuELOQu+g@mail.gmail.com>
	<19888.6629.380047.505281@max.nulle.part>
	<BANLkTinfcQJtotd4macXNjfmOxfekaDDEA@mail.gmail.com>
	<19888.16821.533699.499469@max.nulle.part>
Message-ID: <BANLkTi=uRmogmfLyRj0LMWoweSEVn=61hw@mail.gmail.com>

Thanks for all the feedback.  First, our update, then two responses.

>From Jason Grout:
+++
I finally got it working.  After mucking around in the R configure
file a bit and trying out some of the different tests, as well as
comparing a working system with our broken system, I realized that
`pkg-config --exists pangocairo` was working on the good system and
not working on the broken system.  So I installed libpango1.0-dev, and
now R picks up the cairo package, which in turn means that my
capabilities is now:

> capabilities()
   jpeg      png     tiff    tcltk      X11     aqua http/ftp  sockets
   TRUE     TRUE    FALSE    FALSE    FALSE    FALSE     TRUE     TRUE
 libxml     fifo   cledit    iconv      NLS  profmem    cairo
   TRUE     TRUE     TRUE     TRUE     TRUE    FALSE     TRUE

So in short, I think what I did was install libcairo-dev and
libpango1.0-dev.  There might have been other stuff in there that was
needed; I'm not sure.  When I build a new system again, I'll try just
installing those packages and see if it is sufficient.  For the
record, I had also installed xorg-dev as well.

+++
My comment: As someone who didn't know what configure scripts were a
couple years ago, this is maddening; I don't see anything about
libpango or whatever in the FAQs.  Luckily, Jason knows a lot more
than I do!

@Dirk:

> | Note that we have installed the cairo devel package on this very
> | machine, but it's not being picked up - maybe it's looking in the
> | wrong place? ?That is one of the reasons this is confusing.
>
> You have to understand that even though this problem may seem urgent and
> novel to you and the Sage team,

Novel, yes; urgent only to us, certainly we don't assume it's urgent to you :)

> it is actually about as old as the web and R
> itself. ?In a nutshell, we all (in the people reading r-help and r-devel
> sense) have been explaining to folks since the late 1990s that in order to
> run png() to 'just create some charts for a webserver' ... you need an X11
> server because that is where the font metrics come from. Or else no png for

It's true this is findable, but the difference between having X11 on
the system and having the display is arcane for those who just want to
use R.  But I understand your point.

> is life. ?System such as Sage become so large because having things like this
> around on all deployment systems implies (at least to some degree)
> replicating fundamental OS level features because they unfortunately have
> supply things missing or broken across OSs.

Yes, that is true.  We know of many people who download Sage because
it's the easiest way to install Z, where Z is some specific
mathematical program that is impossible to configure properly without
special knowledge.  Or, until fairly recently, to get Cython.

@Simon:

That's new to me that X11 is installed by default now, but it looks
like you are right.  However, we don't rely on this for Mac; we make
sure to configure for quartz when we build - which I assume is
separate from the other stuff?  But updating the FAQ about this would
be really great for future users :)

Also thanks for the hint on all the other (possibly) needed stuff.
Yikes!  AFAIK this is an Ubuntu machine we're talking about.

To all - if we come up with any more reliable way to make this work
universally, i.e. with *exact* instructions for what to download, we
will definitely pass that upstream. Thank you.



[Rd] How to get R to compile with PNG support
Karl-Dieter Crisman