From therneau at mayo.edu  Mon Mar  9 19:32:43 2009
From: therneau at mayo.edu (Terry Therneau)
Date: Mon, 9 Mar 2009 13:32:43 -0500 (CDT)
Subject: [Rd] Package issue
Message-ID: <200903091832.n29IWhg03500@hsrnfs-101.mayo.edu>

Duncan,
  When    
   The generic solve method has "(a, b, ...)"
   I have "solve.gchol(a, b, full=TRUE, ...)"
   
I was assuming that I would still get an error from CMD check.  These are the
ones that I argued as "unavoidable".  
But... I just checked, and none of those were the squawkers, only the few where
I negelected to put the ... in my function.
  So I stand corrected again. Your argument for inclusion of ... when the 
generic contains it is persuasive.
  
  
  Undocumented objects: I have messages about %*%, ], dim, dimnames, and diag; 
all of which did not have optional arguments.  I wrote manual pages for those 
generics that did, like solve, but see less use for those that don't.   I could 
add them to the class definition page though.
  
  
  Again, thanks to all for their help.
  
  	Terry T.



[Rd] Package issue
Terry Therneau