text: This paper introduces a novel algorithm for cardinality, i.e., the number of nodes, estimation in large scale anonymous graphs using statistical inference methods. Applications of this work include estimating the number of sensor devices, online social users, active protein cells, etc. In anonymous graphs, each node possesses little or non-existing information on the network topology. In particular, this paper assumes that each node only knows its unique identifier. The aim is to estimate the cardinality of the graph and the neighbours of each node by querying a small portion of them. While the former allows the design of more efficient coding schemes for the network, the second provides a reliable way for routing packets. As a reference for comparison, this work considers the Best Linear Unbiased Estimators (BLUE). For dense graphs and specific running times, the proposed algorithm produces a cardinality estimate proportional to the BLUE. Furthermore, for an arbitrary number of iterations, the estimate converges to the BLUE as the number of queried nodes tends to the total number of nodes in the network. Simulation results confirm the theoretical results by revealing that, for a moderate running time, asking a small group of nodes is sufficient to perform an estimation of 95 of the whole network.
  @cite_13: Sampling from large graphs is an area of great interest, especially since the emergence of huge structures such as Online Social Networks (OSNs) and the World Wide Web (WWW). These networks, when viewed as graphs, often contain hundreds of millions of vertices and billions of edges. The large scale properties of a network can be summarized in terms of parameters of the underlying graph, such as the total number of vertices, edges and triangles. The large size of these networks makes it computationally expensive to obtain such structural properties of the underlying graph by exhaustive search. If we can estimate these properties by taking small but representative samples from the network, then size is no longer such a problem. In this paper we present a general framework to estimate network properties using random walks. These methods work under the assumption we are able to obtain local characteristics of a vertex during each step of the random walk, for example the number and labels of the neighboring vertices of a specific vertex These assumptions are relatively reasonable in practice, but may add some additional query cost to each step of the random walk. We also present some practical methods to estimate the total number of edges links m, number of vertices nodes n and number of connected triads of vertices (triangles) t in graphs with degree distributions which follow a power-law and higher number of triangles higher than expected in random graphs. We use these graphs since they tend to better correspond to the structure of large online networks, and in fact some of the data used are taken from such a network. Additionally we present experimental estimates for n, m, t we obtained using our methods on real or manufactured networks. In order to make the methods practical, the total number of steps made by the walk was limited to at most the size n of the network. In fact the results appear to converge for a lower number of steps, indicating that our proposed methods are feasible in practice.
  @cite_18: Networks are characterized by nodes and edges. While there has been a spate of recent work on estimating the number of nodes in a network, the edge-estimation question appears to be largely unaddressed. In this work we consider the problem of estimating the average degree of a large network using efficient random sampling, where the number of nodes is not known to the algorithm. We propose a new estimator for this problem that relies on access to node samples under a prescribed distribution. Next, we show how to efficiently realize this ideal estimator in a random walk setting. Our estimator has a natural and simple implementation using random walks; we bound its performance in terms of the mixing time of the underlying graph. We then show that our estimators are both provably and practically better than many natural estimators for the problem. Our work contrasts with existing theoretical work on estimating average degree, which assume that a uniform random sample of nodes is available and the number of nodes is known.
  @cite_8: We prove the following inequality: for every positive integer n and every collection X 1 ,..., X n of nonnegative independent random variables that each has expectation 1, the probability that their sum remains below n+1 is at least α > 0. Our proof produces a value of α = 1 13 ≅ 0.077, but we conjecture that the inequality also holds with α = 1 e ≅ 0.368.As an example for the use of the new inequality, we consider the problem of estimating the average degree of a graph by querying the degrees of some of its vertices. We show the following threshold behavior: approximation factors above 2 require far less queries than approximation factors below 2. The new inequality is used in order to get tight (up to multiplicative constant factors) relations between the number of queries and the quality of the approximation. We show how the degree approximation algorithm can be used in order to quickly find those edges in a network that belong to many shortest paths.
  @cite_3: Despite recent effort to estimate topology characteristics of large graphs (i.e., online social networks and peer-to-peer networks), little attention has been given to develop a formal methodology to characterize the vast amount of content distributed over these networks. Due to the large scale nature of these networks, exhaustive enumeration of this content is computationally prohibitive. In this paper, we show how one can obtain content properties by sampling only a small fraction of vertices. We first show that when sampling is naively applied, this can produce a huge bias in content statistics (i.e., average number of content duplications). To remove this bias, one may use maximum likelihood estimation to estimate content characteristics. However our experimental results show that one needs to sample most vertices in the graph to obtain accurate statistics using such a method. To address this challenge, we propose two efficient estimators: special copy estimator (SCE) and weighted copy estimator (WCE) to measure content characteristics using available information in sampled contents. SCE uses the special content copy indicator to compute the estimate, while WCE derives the estimate based on meta-information in sampled vertices. We perform experiments to show WCE and SCE are cost effective and also asymptotically unbiased ''. Our methodology provides a new tool for researchers to efficiently query content distributed in large scale networks.
  @cite_10: Networks are a popular tool for representing elements in a system and their interconnectedness. Many observed networks can be viewed as only samples of some true underlying network. Such is frequently the case, for example, in the monitoring and study of massive, online social networks. We study the problem of how to estimate the degree distribution - an object of fundamental interest - of a true underlying network from its sampled network. In particular, we show that this problem can be formulated as an inverse problem. Playing a key role in this formulation is a matrix relating the expectation of our sampled degree distribution to the true underlying degree distribution. Under many network sampling designs, this matrix can be defined entirely in terms of the design and is found to be ill-conditioned. As a result, our inverse problem frequently is ill-posed. Accordingly, we offer a constrained, penalized weighted least-squares approach to solving this problem. A Monte Carlo variant of Stein's unbiased risk estimation (SURE) is used to select the penalization parameter. We explore the behavior of our resulting estimator of network degree distribution in simulation, using a variety of combinations of network models and sampling regimes. In addition, we demonstrate the ability of our method to accurately reconstruct the degree distributions of various sub-communities within online social networks corresponding to Friendster, Orkut and LiveJournal. Overall, our results show that the true degree distributions from both homogeneous and inhomogeneous networks can be recovered with substantially greater accuracy than reflected in the empirical degree distribution resulting from the original sampling.
summary: The authors in @cite_13 @cite_18 propose a model for estimating the network parameters using random walks in graphs. In particular, by sampling from the graph, they propose a method to determine the average edge degree rather than the individual node degree. The problem of estimating the mean degree of a graph is first suggested by @cite_8 . The authors in @cite_10 present a sampling method for node degree estimations in a sampled network and the authors in @cite_3 show a way to obtain content properties by testing a small set of vertices in the graph.