text: Deep convolutional neural networks are being actively investigated in a wide range of speech and audio processing applications including speech recognition, audio event detection and computational paralinguistics, owing to their ability to reduce factors of variations, for learning from speech. However, studies have suggested to favor a certain type of convolutional operations when building a deep convolutional neural network for speech applications although there has been promising results using different types of convolutional operations. In this work, we study four types of convolutional operations on different input features for speech emotion recognition under noisy and clean conditions in order to derive a comprehensive understanding. Since affective behavioral information has been shown to reflect temporally varying of mental state and convolutional operation are applied locally in time, all deep neural networks share a deep recurrent sub-network architecture for further temporal modeling. We present detailed quantitative module-wise performance analysis to gain insights into information flows within the proposed architectures. In particular, we demonstrate the interplay of affective information and the other irrelevant information during the progression from one module to another. Finally we show that all of our deep neural networks provide state-of-the-art performance on the eNTERFACE'05 corpus.
  @cite_37: With rapid developments in the design of deep architecture models and learning algorithms, methods referred to as deep learning have come to be widely used in a variety of research areas such as pattern recognition, classification, and signal processing. Deep learning methods are being applied in various recognition tasks such as image, speech, and music recognition. Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) especially show remarkable recognition performance for computer vision tasks. In addition, Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) show considerable success in many sequential data processing tasks. In this study, we investigate the result of the Speech Emotion Recognition (SER) algorithm based on CNNs and RNNs trained using an emotional speech database. The main goal of our work is to propose a SER method based on concatenated CNNs and RNNs without using any traditional hand-crafted features. By applying the proposed methods to an emotional speech database, the classification result was verified to have better accuracy than that achieved using conventional classification methods.
  @cite_62: The automatic recognition of spontaneous emotions from speech is a challenging task. On the one hand, acoustic features need to be robust enough to capture the emotional content for various styles of speaking, and while on the other, machine learning algorithms need to be insensitive to outliers while being able to model the context. Whereas the latter has been tackled by the use of Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks, the former is still under very active investigations, even though more than a decade of research has provided a large set of acoustic descriptors. In this paper, we propose a solution to the problem of ‘context-aware’ emotional relevant feature extraction, by combining Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) with LSTM networks, in order to automatically learn the best representation of the speech signal directly from the raw time representation. In this novel work on the so-called end-to-end speech emotion recognition, we show that the use of the proposed topology significantly outperforms the traditional approaches based on signal processing techniques for the prediction of spontaneous and natural emotions on the RECOLA database.
  @cite_41: We present a deep convolutional recurrent neural network for speech emotion recognition based on the log-Mel filterbank energies, where the convolutional layers are responsible for the discriminative feature learning. Based on the hypothesis that a better understanding of the internal configuration within an utterance would help reduce misclassification, we further propose a convolutional attention mechanism to learn the utterance structure relevant to the task. In addition, we quantitatively measure the performance gain contributed by each module in our model in order to characterize the nature of emotion expressed in speech. The experimental results on the eNTERFACE'05 emotion database validate our hypothesis and also demonstrate an absolute improvement by 4.62 compared to the state-of-the-art approach.
  @cite_52: Both Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) have shown improvements over Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) across a wide variety of speech recognition tasks. CNNs, LSTMs and DNNs are complementary in their modeling capabilities, as CNNs are good at reducing frequency variations, LSTMs are good at temporal modeling, and DNNs are appropriate for mapping features to a more separable space. In this paper, we take advantage of the complementarity of CNNs, LSTMs and DNNs by combining them into one unified architecture. We explore the proposed architecture, which we call CLDNN, on a variety of large vocabulary tasks, varying from 200 to 2,000 hours. We find that the CLDNN provides a 4–6 relative improvement in WER over an LSTM, the strongest of the three individual models.
  @cite_34: 
  @cite_20: Learning an acoustic model directly from the raw waveform has been an active area of research. However, waveformbased models have not yet matched the performance of logmel trained neural networks. We will show that raw waveform features match the performance of log-mel filterbank energies when used with a state-of-the-art CLDNN acoustic model trained on over 2,000 hours of speech. Specifically, we will show the benefit of the CLDNN, namely the time convolution layer in reducing temporal variations, the frequency convolution layer for preserving locality and reducing frequency variations, as well as the LSTM layers for temporal modeling. In addition, by stacking raw waveform features with log-mel features, we achieve a 3 relative reduction in word error rate.
summary: Recently, proposed the CLDNN architecture for speech recognition based on the log-Mels @cite_52 and the raw waveform signal @cite_20 , in which both models have been shown to more competitive than a LSTM and a CNN model alone or combined. They also demonstrated that with a sufficient amount of training data (roughly @math hours), a CLDNN trained on the raw waveform signal can match the one trained on the log-Mels. Moreover, they found the raw waveform and the log-Mels in fact provide complementary information. Based on the CLDNN architecture, @cite_62 published a model using the raw waveform signal for continuous emotion tracking. @cite_41 trained a CLDNN model on the log-Mels for speech emotion recognition and quantitatively analyzed the difference in spectrally decorrelating power between the discrete cosine transformation and the convolutional operation. @cite_37 repeated the comparison between CNN, LSTM and CLDNN for speech emotion recognition using spectrograms. @cite_34 applied the CLDNN architecture to classifying depression based on the log-Mels and spectrograms. They employed the full-spectrum temporally convolutional operation on the log-Mels but the temporally-only convolutional operation on the spectrograms.