text: Three approaches to content-and-structure XML retrieval are analysed in this paper: first by using Zettair, a full-text information retrieval system; second by using eXist, a native XML database, and third by using a hybrid XML retrieval system that uses eXist to produce the final answers from likely relevant articles retrieved by Zettair. INEX 2003 content-and-structure topics can be classified in two categories: the first retrieving full articles as final answers, and the second retrieving more specific elements within articles as final answers. We show that for both topic categories our initial hybrid system improves the retrieval effectiveness of a native XML database. For ranking the final answer elements, we propose and evaluate a novel retrieval model that utilises the structural relationships between the answer elements of a native XML database and retrieves Coherent Retrieval Elements. The final results of our experiments show that when the XML retrieval task focusses on highly relevant elements our hybrid XML retrieval system with the Coherent Retrieval Elements module is 1.8 times more effective than Zettair and 3 times more effective than eXist, and yields an effective content-and-structure XML retrieval.
  @cite_4: This paper reports on the CSIRO group's participation in INEX. We indexed documents and document fragments using PADRE, the core of CSIRO's Panoptic Enterprise Search Engine. A query translator converts the INEX topics into queries containing selection and projection constraints for the results. Answers are extracted from ranked documents and document fragments based on the projection constraints in the query.
summary: The CSIRO group participating in INEX 2002 proposed a similar XML retrieval approach where PADRE, the core of CSIRO's Panoptic Enterprise Search Engine http: www.panopticsearch.com is used to rank full articles and elements within articles @cite_4 . Unlike many full-text information retrieval systems, PADRE combines full-text and metadata indexing and retrieval and is also capable of indexing and retrieving more specific elements within articles. A post processing module is then used to extract and re-rank the full articles and elements within articles returned by PADRE. However, unlike our CRE retrieval module, the above approach ignores the structural elements within articles that contain the indexed element. Less specific and more general elements are therefore not likely to appear in the final answer list.