text: This work investigates the emergence of oscillations in one of the simplest cellular signaling networks exhibiting oscillations, namely, the dual-site phosphorylation and dephosphorylation network (futile cycle), in which the mechanism for phosphorylation is processive while the one for dephosphorylation is distributive (or vice-versa). The fact that this network yields oscillations was shown recently by Suwanmajo and Krishnan. Our results, which significantly extend their analyses, are as follows. First, in the three-dimensional space of total amounts, the border between systems with a stable versus unstable steady state is a surface defined by the vanishing of a single Hurwitz determinant. Second, this surface consists generically of simple Hopf bifurcations. Next, simulations suggest that when the steady state is unstable, oscillations are the norm. Finally, the emergence of oscillations via a Hopf bifurcation is enabled by the catalytic and association constants of the distributive part of the mechanism: if these rate constants satisfy two inequalities, then the system generically admits a Hopf bifurcation. Our proofs are enabled by the Routh-Hurwitz criterion, a Hopf-bifurcation criterion due to Yang, and a monomial parametrization of steady states.
  @cite_26: Multisite phosphorylation plays an important role in intracellular signaling. There has been much recent work aimed at understanding the dynamics of such systems when the phosphorylation dephosphorylation mechanism is distributive, that is, when the binding of a substrate and an enzyme molecule results in the addition or removal of a single phosphate group and repeated binding therefore is required for multisite phosphorylation. In particular, such systems admit bistability. Here, we analyze a different class of multisite systems, in which the binding of a substrate and an enzyme molecule results in the addition or removal of phosphate groups at all phosphorylation sites, that is, we consider systems in which the mechanism is processive, rather than distributive. We show that in contrast to distributive systems, processive systems modeled with mass-action kinetics do not admit bistability and, moreover, exhibit rigid dynamics: each invariant set contains a unique equilibrium, which is a global attractor. Additionally, we obtain a monomial parametrization of the steady states. Our proofs rely on a technique of Johnston for using “translated” networks to study systems with “toric steady states,” recently given sign conditions for the injectivity of polynomial maps, and a result from monotone systems theory due to Angeli and Sontag.
  @cite_28: 
  @cite_9: In this paper, we prove the global asymptotic stability of a class of mass action futile cycle networks which includes a model of processive multisite phosphorylation networks. The proof consists of two parts. In the first part, we prove that there is a unique equilibrium in every positive compatibility class. In the second part, we make use of a piecewise linear in rates Lyapunov function in order to prove the global asymptotic stability of the unique equilibrium corresponding to a given initial concentration vector. The main novelty of the paper is the use of a simple algebraic approach based on the intermediate value property of continuous functions in order to prove the uniqueness of equilibrium in every positive compatibility class.
  @cite_3: Multi-site phosphorylation is ubiquitous in cell biology and has been widely studied experimentally and theoretically. The underlying chemical modification mechanisms are typically assumed to be distributive or processive. In this paper, we study the behaviour of mixed mechanisms that can arise either because phosphorylation and dephosphorylation involve different mechanisms or because phosphorylation and or dephosphorylation can occur through a combination of mechanisms. We examine a hierarchy of models to assess chemical information processing through different mixed mechanisms, using simulations, bifurcation analysis and analytical work. We demonstrate how mixed mechanisms can show important and unintuitive differences from pure distributive and processive mechanisms, in some cases resulting in monostable behaviour with simple dose–response behaviour, while in other cases generating new behaviour-like oscillations. Our results also suggest patterns of information processing that are relevant as the number of modification sites increases. Overall, our work creates a framework to examine information processing arising from complexities of multi-site modification mechanisms and their impact on signal transduction.
  @cite_16: Abstract The multiple futile cycle is an important building block in networks of chemical reactions arising in molecular biology. A typical process which it describes is the addition of n phosphate groups to a protein. It can be modelled by a system of ordinary differential equations depending on parameters. The special case n = 2 is called the dual futile cycle. The main result of this paper is a proof that there are parameter values for which the system of ODE describing the dual futile cycle has two distinct stable stationary solutions. The proof is based on bifurcation theory and geometric singular perturbation theory. An important entity built of three coupled multiple futile cycles is the MAPK cascade. It is explained how the ideas used to prove bistability for the dual futile cycle might help to prove the existence of periodic solutions for the MAPK cascade.
  @cite_12: Abstract Phosphorylation, the enzyme-mediated addition of a phosphate group to a molecule, is a ubiquitous chemical mechanism in biology. Multisite phosphorylation, the addition of phosphate groups to multiple sites of a single molecule, may be distributive or processive. Distributive systems, which require an enzyme and substrate to bind several times in order to add multiple phosphate groups, can be bistable. Processive systems, in contrast, require only one binding to add all phosphate groups, and were recently shown to be globally stable. However, this global convergence result was proven only for a specific mechanism of processive phosphorylation dephosphorylation (namely, all catalytic reactions are reversible). Accordingly, we generalize this result to allow for processive phosphorylation networks in which each reaction may be irreversible, and also to account for possible product inhibition. We accomplish this by first defining an all-encompassing processive network that encapsulates all of these schemes, and then appealing to recent results of Marcondes de that assert global convergence by way of monotone systems theory and network graph reductions (corresponding to removing intermediate complexes). Our results form a case study into the question of when global convergence is preserved when reactions and or intermediate complexes are added to or removed from a network.
summary: As mentioned earlier, there has been much interest in the dynamics of phosphorylation systems @cite_28 . The mixed-mechanism network fits into the related literature as follows. The mixed network is a dual-site network situated between two extremes: the fully processive dual-site network -- in which the phosphorylation and dephosphorylation mechanisms are both processive -- and the fully distributive dual-site network. One might therefore expect the dynamics of the mixed-mechanism network to straddle those of the two networks. This is indeed the case. As summarized in Table , and reviewed in @cite_28 , fully processive networks are globally convergent to a unique steady state @cite_26 @cite_12 @cite_9 , while mixed-mechanism networks admit oscillations but not bistability @cite_3 , and fully distributive networks admit bistability @cite_16 (and the question of oscillations is open @cite_28 ).