Has anyone tried putting the S5 in this case while still in a OtterBox Commuter case? Wil it fit? Or will i have to remove the Otterbox first?
28780
I bet it wouldn't fit with the Otterbox on. I have a case on mine, and it is tight but I don't have to remove it. But the Otterbox would be larger, therefore I don't think you would easily be able to fit it in. It might stretch out the opening quite a bit.
1617785
I am using an otterbox symmetry case on it now, and have had no problems with the commuter line either. Pretty sure the defender will work just fine, but I haven't that one myself.
1322084
Well i bought it for my S3 and i put it in a otterbox commuter case and it still fits so i think it can hold in it. The S4 is bigger so i think it can hold in it for sure as it would be as big as the my s3 with the otterbox case.
7621
That's based entirely on your preference. I myself have the OtterBox commuter case and it fits perfectly. I couldn't be happier.
2223673
So when I owned the S5, it fit, even with the spigen case I had for it. Not sure what kind of a case you are getting, but that would really depend on how wide it will make the phone. The wiring on the rear interface takes the new standard Sony harness (I am aware of at least 2 different Sony harness types).
860318
Yes it will fit with the commuter but just a tad roomy but not much. I have the defender but used and returned the otter box commuter case for more protection.
1494671
I have an S5 SPORT it does fit (barely) with out the case on. With the case it is pretty tight and my case is slim. But there are not many options for the S5 Sport so I guess you take what you can get.
1331098
I have the same phone and Defender Commuter Case. Did this case fit with the Defender? Would you recommend it? Many of these cases lack dimensions so it's a guess as to whether they'll work properly. Will appreciate learning of your experience.
79983
I have the Galaxy Note 3 with a case and it fits perfect... the s5 is smaller even with the Otter box...you might have a little extra space, but it should fit just fine.
646999
I honestly do not know if it can be used with the Otterbox Commuter case on it. However, I will tell you that I have my Galaxy S4 in a white wallet-type holder (which also has side pockets inside of it where I keep my driver's license and a couple of credit cards). Even in this white wallet-type holder, it fits perfectly inside of this black-leather belt holder. When I ordered this black holder, I was like you and did not know if my white wallet-type holder would fit inside of it. But I figured, for the price, even if it did not fit inside of it, I would just take my Galaxy S4 out of the white wallet and use the black holder by itself. I truly love this black holder, and I don't regret ordering it :) Good luck deciding what to do!
150292
You will not be able to fit any phone with an otterbox case. It will be too bulky. You can take it out of the case and put it back on when done riding
777374
The case is 6"x 3.25"x .56". The S5 Active is 5.69"x 2.94"x .38". I'm not sure how much bigger the OtterBox makes the phone, but I can't imagine it being any smaller.
1955354
I have the otterbox commuter case and it does not work with that. But the case is pretty easy off and on so I don't mind. It does have a snap out plastic section so I think it is designed for a slim case. I friend of mine down the hall has this case: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00DCIZMEQ/ref=oh_details_o02_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 and with the plastic section out this dock connected to the phone with the case on without a problem.
1123168
I have the Otter box series above the commuter and it fits fine. It's tight but fits.
777368
The case is 6"x 3.25"x .56".The S5 Active is 5.69"x 2.94"x .38".I'm not sure how much bigger the OtterBox makes the phone, but I can't imagine it being any smaller.
243155
Not yet on commuter. And had about 4 weeks and all is good with my case.but did on my defender about two years ago. Call otter box and sent them a pic of it and they sent me a new case, so either way your good.
206124
I don't have an Otterbox case for my S4 but I do have this cradle. My S4 just fits into the charger, so anything that makes the S4 thicker will cause it not to fit. One of my cases, similar to an Otterbox, makes mine not fit in the cradle, and the other case is a leather pocket.