would this case fit reliably over an otterbox case if I removed the Otterbox rubber outer skin and just kept the inner rigid case on an IPhone 4?
12138
I love this setup, but I doubt if it will work in combo with the Otterbox; that said it actually makes the Otterbox superfluous. and keeps the phone secure and handy at the same time. I am 76 and no longer worry about where my phone is. It's right there, around my neck, and/or in my shirt pocket. Hope this helps. John
2191266
Mine is an iPhone 4, and my case is slim hard plastic, and it fit wonderfully. If a 4S has the same plug as my 4, I would think it would be just as good, but I don't know for sure. Sorry it's not a better answer.
1844453
I've got an iPhone 5 in an Otterbox Commuter case, and it fits. I have to put my iPhone 5 in a slightly different way than I did when I had an iPhone 4 b/c of the position of the volume buttons. However, overall, I'm still happy with it and use it every time I go biking. FYI, the Otterbox Commuter is a slimmer case than some other Otterboxes, so I would use caution.
420975
My phone with the otter box case on fits inside smoothly. The otterbox case dimensions are: 4.76 in x 2.53 in x 0.56 in, so in my opinion I would say no. The sides are elastic but not sure it will stretch that much too fit your phone with that case. Hope thhis helps.
100339
nope, its a pretty tight fit, the tempered glass wouldn't fit inside with the otterbox; a thinner screen protector might though.
304602
I have a thin hard shell case (Elago) on my 4 and it still fits with a little bit of room. A normal otter box case will not fit.
1136534
It should be used without your Otterbox. It fits on your Iphone like an Otterbox. Just know that it did not fit at all with my Iphone 4. It said it would but it did not. It's made for an Iphone 5.
56503
Your asking if the iPhone 4 fits in this case? No only the iPhone 5, but this case isn't water proof like the one from the otterbox website, it isn't the same case. I recommend springing the extra money and getting the one directly from otterbox, this one doesn't work the same.
6892
I would think so. My iphone 4 with an otterbox commuter case will fit, aren't iPods generally smaller than iPhones?
848673
I agree that if it would fit over the glass screen protector, it would be very, very snug. Even though the case isn't super tight, the lip that goes over the very edges of the phone sits close enough to the glass that it takes a little force to push it outward (to expose the side bezel). I remember having to sort of pull the edges up and over a little bit the first time I put the case on.
921266
The rubber casing I very difficult to put onto the phone but it will fit. Put the phone into one side of the case then open each of the other corners with your fingers and let it close over the edge. As I have said, it is difficult, but it will go on tightly.
1939522
An iPhone 4 will fit just fine. I would say that the phone with an Otterbox on it will be VERY TIGHT in the pouches. Wish they made different sizes of this case because I think alot of people could use it. Hope this helps.
1683369
Well I have the otterbox commuter & it fits snug , something thinner may not do to it being thin.
1119010
It is a very tight fit, but mine does fit. I have an Otter Box Commuter case on my phone.
660525
I am able to keep my case on, but my case is very thin. If you have an otter box, I'm not sure if it would fit without removing the case.
188929
Otterbox will probably be to thick. I have a very think case and it was snug.
1567556
yes! I just took mine off of my 4 and put it on my 4S and it fit perfectly.