Do the lids screw on tightly without the shaker? Or is the shaker needed for the lid to close?
218533
YES. I did not use the shaker thing at all and they seem to fit fine. I did tighten only one too tight and cracked the plastic. That was my fault. The rest are fine and I LOVE having them all the same! They are better than I had before with dozens of different size containers! :-)
1086233
The lid screws on and has a tab the tightly snaps shut when you are not sipping on your coffee. I have three of these mugs
1800045
Mine does not close completely. There is a noticeable gap between the movable part and the screw-on part of the lid. When it is in the 'closed' position there is still salt leaking out when I shake.
765308
The lids push on and seal quite tightly. They're very handy to use just be sure you put them in the upper rack of the dishwasher
964660
the lid is hinged but it dosen't snap shut.I love mine it's small but not to small
1772556
The Open and Close buttons require the item to also have working batteries. Without batteries, you must manually open and close the lid.
2160326
The lids come off, but they are very poor quality. Once you use the shaker part of the lid, it does not close properly.
512245
The lid screws on. My lids do not leak. You need to he sure your lid has the washer ring on the inside. This prevents leaks
2108485
Owen, I believe Janice answered your question correctly. This is the second shaker set I have owned and they are both the same, no top. However, the first set I had came with a rubber gasket for the glass, which created a better seal. Good luck.
95749
Ok here's the deal...the lid screws off but the shaker top does not screw off it pulls out. It took me a while to figure out myself. I hope you enjoy the product as much as I have!!
600636
Short answer is no, they are not leak proof. There is no "gasket" in the lid and so when laid on its side, liquid will slowly leak out. With the shaker in, it seemed leak proof, but who would store liquids in a bottle with a shaker top?
2268973
These screw on but you do feel a click when the lid is secure. I have never had one of these leak and my child is rough on them. Just make sure that the valve is in tightly.
1400471
The lid does not rattle. It has a rubber gromet around it that keeps it snug.
9493
Yep! Ran mine through, no troubles. I put them on the top rack, and the stainless shaker balls over one of the tines on the rack.
937596
The lid locks very securely shut. It will not pop open if it is latched, and you can hear the latch engage when closing it.
1785997
The lid screws on tightly. The lip you drink out of snaps. I carry it around in a bag...even when its full and it has never spilled.
569401
my set closes pretty tightly, just held one up side down and shook it pretty hard. Didn't move a notch.