Does this fit a Galaxy S4 with an Otterbox Commuter case?
206123
Don't think so.. It's a small cradle, so you'd have to take it out of the Otterbox to charge it.
206124
I don't have an Otterbox case for my S4 but I do have this cradle. My S4 just fits into the charger, so anything that makes the S4 thicker will cause it not to fit. One of my cases, similar to an Otterbox, makes mine not fit in the cradle, and the other case is a leather pocket.
206125
The otterbox case would probably be too big. It would probably work with a slim case
206126
I'm not sure since I don't have one. I'm using a Spigen Neo Hybrid and I had to do some grinding with a dremel to make it seat properly so it would charge. The Neo Hybrid has rather sharp edges though.
218880
It fits a Galaxy S4 with defender otter box, and still has a little space, so I would say 99% chance it does!
1120186
*shakes head* No. It is a snug fit with the Otterbox Commuter case. There's no way the bulkier defender will fit.
1477212
I know it fit the S4 with an otterbox very tight, if I had to guess I would probably say no, I threw mine away after about a month of use, the threads are all plastic and poor quality
1865466
I would think it would. If you look at the official specs for both phones, you get this: Galaxy S3 - 136.6 x 70.6 x 8.6 mm Nexus 4 - 133.9 x 68.7 x 9.1 mm I say this based totally off the specs. I can fit my S3 in the Otterbox Commuter case into the armband, so as long as whatever case went on the Nexus 4 was similarly tight, then it should fit. But it WILL BE TIGHT. It is almost a paint to get it in and out of the arm band, but the aggravation in doing so is less than the aggravation of taking my otterbox off. The only concern I have is the extra .5mm in thickness but I think the width would be the bigger difference and that is smaller on the Nexus 4. Hope that helps.
974935
No it will not. My S4 fits perfect with a very slim case. I know Otterbox cases and they tend to be very bulky, well they're suppose to I think they're the best with ultimate protection for your devices but nope, It will not fit in this pouch, plus the strings and small clasps that hold the pouch in place aren't durable enough for an otterbox enclosed gadget. I suggest using this for light stuff if you want it to last. Then again the iPhones are smaller than the S4 but I guess it depends on the type of otterbox case you're using and you've stated "thick" so I still think not.
1513006
I have a Samsung Galaxy S4 with an Otterbox case and it fits easily into that conpartment.
1249628
I don't have the Otterbox Commuter but I can confidently say that it won't fit with this back cover.
647001
This belt case is perfect for the Samsung Galaxy s4 with the Otterbox. Plus it gives you comfort and keeps your phone secure. Hope this helps
1439689
I use it with a droid maxx with the commuter otterbox case. Its a little snug, and the top sticks out just a bit. But it fits.
7621
That's based entirely on your preference. I myself have the OtterBox commuter case and it fits perfectly. I couldn't be happier.
1753496
Don't know; I have an Otterbox case that is pretty heavy duty and it was a snug fit at first but has loosened up a little. I am very satisfied and it is serving me well.
998003
Yes. I have the Commuter and it fits. That being said, I do opt to take the case off, since I was wearing down the protective rubber flap that covers the port on the phone since it has to be bent back all the way.
718847
It will fit a Galaxy S4. I have been using mine with my Galaxy S4 since August and have been very happy with it. I also have an Otter Box cover on my phone and there is room for the phone with that cover on it. I did not like the belt clip that came with the Otter Box so I bought this and have been very happy.
925246
It does fit, but just. You're better off with otterbox commuter case if it's for an iphone 5
1195958
It won't fit at all. I have an Otterbox Commuter case which is another 2-part case, and there is no chance of it fitting with the case on.
529008
I do not have an otterbox, but I have seen them on display. If you are not planning on including belt clip, it should fit. This case is build for samsung galaxy phones, thus you can compare it to your friends Samsung.