at almost 4 times the cost of those $20 butane stoves, is this Iwatani stove safer than those cheap stoves?
191030
I'm not really qualified to answer which is safer. I do however think Iwatani stoves are safe because there is an auto-shutoff feature if there is a pressure increase in the butane canister. There is a cheaper Iwatani stove about $35 with the same feature and puts out 12k BTU. I have both stoves and the cheaper one is built better.
191031
Not sure it's safer it's an open flame, it is certainly better built and gets MUCH hotter. If safety is a concern get an inductive burner.
191032
Mostly stainless steel, raised rim making it a bit better in the wind, higher BTU output. 3X the cost. Safer, NO.
191033
Yes a great burner with Morr BTU's to use safely indoors.its used by professional Chefs at the table or to teach . I love mine
191034
NO. (Read my review.) The reason to get this one is the higher output. That said, there's nothing particularly dangerous about those cheap stoves. Butane is pretty kidsafe.
191035
The manufacturer states "CSA Commercial indoor approved." The majority of other Butane Stoves carry "For Outdoor Use Only" or similar warnings. CSA - Canadian Standards Association - is accredited by the American National Standards Institute. The real concern can be Carbon Monoxide - and the design of the regulator & air mix into the burner unit can make a big difference that shows up in the price.
191036
The unit is well made. Is it safer than the less expensive unit? That is hard to tell. However, inspite of the warning from want anti, other brand butane canisters with UL listing worked probably just as safe.
191037
I do not see anything that tells me the Iwatani stove (model - Iwatani 35FW Portable 15,000 BTU) is any safer than others. They are all made the same way. All brands perform on a similar mechanism. I purchased this model for a few reasons. The brand is reputed to be dependable. It performs well in windy conditions. Lower-priced stoves have a power output of 7,500 - 8,000 BTU. The Iwatani model has a power output of close 15,000 BTU. It is designed to perform even in breezy conditions. This model comes with a wind shield. But, realize that the stronger the flame output the more the butane gas canister is used up. The 8 ounce canisters burn for 55 minutes. That said, if you are purchasing a stove as part of emergency preparedness program (earthquake zone, flood zone) or you camp outdoors you might as well get this model. Do not forget to consider the amount of butane canisters you would need to stack up. (There is a cheaper way depending on where you live.) Count 1 canister for 55 minutes. 50 hours of cooking requires 55 canisters, just a rough estimate.
191038
I can't speak to the safety issue, but the quality of this stove is excellent. It is very well made and should last a long time if taken care of properly.
1685352
Yes, it is, Dorothy, and the ATK's conclusion was that there is no reason to pay more for the All-Clad tri-ply skillet. I've used it almost daily for almost a year, and it would not be an exaggeration to say that it's changed the way I cook. It's made me more willing to experiment with new techniques and recipes, and improved the quality of my cooking. I chose the flared-edge model to make it easier to pour liquids from my pan, and I recommend this feature. It's even made my lean-up easier. I'm considering buying a second one, since the pan is oven-safe to 500 degrees F, I can finish a dish in the oven and still have a skillet for stovetop. Yes, it is, Dorothy, and the ATK's conclusion was that there is no reason to pay more for the All-Clad tri-ply skillet. I've used it almost daily for almost a year, and it would not be an exaggeration to say that it's changed the way I cook. It's made me more willing to experiment with new techniques and recipes, and improved the quality of my cooking. I chose the flared-edge model to make it easier to pour liquids from my pan, and I recommend this feature. It's even made my lean-up easier. I'm considering buying a second one, since the pan is oven-safe to 500 degrees F, I can finish a dish... » Read More Yes, it is, Dorothy, and the ATK's conclusion was that there is no reason to pay more for the All-Clad tri-ply skillet. I've used it almost daily for almost a year, and it would not be an exaggeration to say that it's changed the way I cook. It's made me more willing to experiment with new techniques and recipes, and improved the quality of my cooking. I chose the flared-edge model to make it easier to pour liquids from my pan, and I recommend this feature. It's even made my lean-up easier. I'm considering buying a second one, since the pan is oven-safe to 500 degrees F, I can finish a dish in the oven and still have a skillet for stovetop. « Show Less
35254
I don't leave the butane canister in the stove for safety reasons. I only use the burner outdoors. Hope this was helpful.
1444260
This one is fine. You can adjust the flame up and down. This is the best portable stove that I have used. It won't rust and very easy to clean.
1415476
I would not recommend any stove, including this one, be used inside a tent for warmth. There is a large flame generated.
1302932
I took mine up last summer and didn't have any problems, I want to say my camp was was just over 10,000. I had a propane stove as well, this year I am replacing my propane with this one, it's just so light weight and small, and nothing lacking in performance.
186358
The guality was very surprising for the price. I have another gasone stove as well and it also works great
1522277
I'm using a different butane burner, which has a small flame directly under the glass. Your gas stove may melt the handle.
164007
As long as you are using a gas stove and the burner is off, I don't think you would have a problem. Try it once and pay close attention :) Bamboo is an amazing tough wood.
1250209
This is a propane stove and a joy to use. The only problem I've had was the safety valve in the hose was tripping and would allow almost no gas to go through. It was largely due to living in a higher altitude which makes them trip more easily. Open your propane tank valve slowly to avoid this problem.
579742
Yes, I have one and you can use iwatani fuel cartridges but you can use any that are intended for a portable gas camping stove like the GasOne cartridges (12 for $13.50), that are much cheaper.
1275667
I have used it indoors, but well ventilated. Naturally care should be taken to fuel the stove outside and to leave the spare fuel outside. For many years people cooked on indoor kerosene stoves that had an order all it's own. This fuel is more flammable. Use caution.
2023442
I bought the Chinese one linked above, worked great in home tests, clogged the first time I took it into the field. I can't rely on it one bit.I don't want to carry four stoves (re: Stan in St Louistan) into the backcountry. I want to carry one, that will work, period. Is it worth $25 to have a failed stove halfway into a through hike? At least if the MSR stove had quit working, I would have been able to get it replaced.
458252
As other reviewers have said, it's nearly impossible to find these butane canisters except online. I suggest ordering the Gasone 12-pack from Amazon. Despite brand names, all these $15-$30 butane stoves use the same type of canister. Hope this helps.
1735610
FYI, using a windscreen around a butane mix canister can direct heat down to the canister, causing it to overheat and explode. That's a bad thing. A partial windscreen, that blocks the wind, but does not fully surround the stove/canister is safer, but the canister temp should still be monitored in this case.
1998493
While the output from butane isn't equal to propane these units are more than capable of that temp in my opinion. I can get a 5 gallon pot of water to a boil pretty quickly. For emergencies, camping and remote use you can't beat them for the $.
380756
Actually Butane fuel is the same as the fuel used on the gas stoves especially the portable ones. Its must better than the regular lighters.