So it needs the 2nd edition version of the game... why? So far the comments all say 2e was just new art and 2 new jobs. Why would that require owners of the original version to get the replacement pack? So it needs the 2nd edition version of the game... why? So far the comments all say 2e was just new art and 2 new jobs. Why would that require owners of the original version to get the replacement... » Read More So it needs the 2nd edition version of the game... why? So far the comments all say 2e was just new art and 2 new jobs. Why would that require owners of the original version to get the replacement pack? « Show Less
315313
But the replacement cards that can be purchased at zman for ten bucks gives you the two new roles and all the expansions will fit in, the in the lab box, if you sleave it will not fit
315314
The new expansions have the new card backs which can be easily fixes with card sleaves
2205995
If you buy this version you won't need the regular version because this will have the regular version plus all expansions plus add-on made for this game. So you can give away your regular version or trade it in since you won't really need it unless you want to keep it and buy all the expansion online but I think that would cost more in the long run. Unless you wait till they have a sell on them. I bought this version because I never had the regular version so I paid for it one time in one package. It's like buying The Elders Scrolls: Oblivion game of the year edition & The Elders Scrolls 5: Skyrim the Legendary Edition which includes everything in one package no need to buy any expansions or add-on's. If you buy this version you won't need the regular version because this will have the regular version plus all expansions plus add-on made for this game. So you can give away your regular version or trade it in since you won't really need it unless you want to keep it and buy all the expansion online but I think that would cost more in the long run. Unless you wait till they have a sell on them. I bought this version because I never had the regular version so I paid for it one time in one package. It's like buying The Elders Scrolls: Oblivion game of the year edition & The Elders... » Read More If you buy this version you won't need the regular version because this will have the regular version plus all expansions plus add-on made for this game. So you can give away your regular version or trade it in since you won't really need it unless you want to keep it and buy all the expansion online but I think that would cost more in the long run. Unless you wait till they have a sell on them. I bought this version because I never had the regular version so I paid for it one time in one package. It's like buying The Elders Scrolls: Oblivion game of the year edition & The Elders Scrolls 5: Skyrim the Legendary Edition which includes everything in one package no need to buy any expansions or add-on's. « Show Less
980922
For new players, it's a breeze, but for new GMs (Game Master, as opposed to DM for Dungeon Master) it's essential to give the Adventure book a pre-game read-through (this is typical for RPGs). The way the text is spread about (between descriptions, GM and NPC notes, and rule blocks), it doesn't lend towards as fast and loose a play session without preparation. Thankfully, the mechanics aren't difficult so much as plentiful. That's the only caveat to note for an otherwise wonderful game.
724630
You don't need 1st edition. The 2nd edition is a complete stand-alone replacement. There are a few mistakes in the rules regarding victory cities and scoring (at least in my copy). Avalon Hill has the errata posted online; I'm not sure if the corrections actually made it to print.
2000758
The expansion packs are just more cards to add to the main game. I didn't notice a change in subject matter so to speak, just more cards to add more opportunity's. The cards have a tendency to be vulgar just like the main game.
1172859
I don't know what the deal is with the 2nd edition.. it says Copyright 2004 on the box.. but the other catch phrase game doesn't say 2nd edition, yet it says Copyright 2009.
182319
I don't quit get what you mean by buying the newest 1. Did you mean the if there were expansions you need to get along with the base game or did you mean if you have to start from lvl 1 ??
743048
That's kind of a messy question. They are redoing a Dark Vengeance for 7th edition, but this listing appears to be the one for 6th. So, it exists, but I'd be careful on where you buy it from.
1519317
Hey this is not the D&D 4th edition, it is a separate game of its own with few elements from the D&D series, much easier to play because you don't need a DM or make character sheets. Every player controls the monsters and every player controls their own hero's.
1535316
I have both editions and the second edition added the 2 other characters. Also the cubes in the first edition are wood and a little larger. The cubes in the new edition are translucent plastic and slightly smaller. There are other minor component differences as well.
2225501
This is the base game. There is an expansion but it isn't needed in order to play. I would actually suggest getting familiar with the base game before getting the expansion, if you even want to, later. The expansion gives you these neat petri dishes to hold some of the game pieces in and has a few more job titles and such.
516951
With the limited edition, you get a few more add-ons. Other than that, there is not a difference. Also, we have not had any problems with the game other than it takes awhile to install because of the size. It is a lot more realistic than it use to be.
724631
You do not need the first edition to play the second edition =) Both are 100% stand alone games.
126148
You need the original game, unfortunately. Sorry for my late response, this one got lost in the mail.
407917
Yes, generally there is a noticeable difference between the 3rd and 4th editions of Catan in two ways: 1) The artwork is very different so your tiles will not look the same, depending on how much that matters to you. Personally, I'd rather have them match. 2) And this could present a more series problem. The 4th ed. of the base game has a different border which locks together. I know it doesn't work well with the 3rd ed. of the base game so I'm guessing you could have some problems here as well. It is a nice improvement to the game in that it holds things together nicely, but it does present compatibility problems with earlier editions. Hope this helps! Yes, generally there is a noticeable difference between the 3rd and 4th editions of Catan in two ways: 1) The artwork is very different so your tiles will not look the same, depending on how much that matters to you. Personally, I'd rather have them match. 2) And this could present a more series problem. The 4th ed. of the base game has a different border which locks together. I know it doesn't work well with the 3rd ed. of the base game so I'm guessing you could have some problems here as well. It is a nice improvement to the game in that it holds things together nicely, but it does... » Read More Yes, generally there is a noticeable difference between the 3rd and 4th editions of Catan in two ways: 1) The artwork is very different so your tiles will not look the same, depending on how much that matters to you. Personally, I'd rather have them match. 2) And this could present a more series problem. The 4th ed. of the base game has a different border which locks together. I know it doesn't work well with the 3rd ed. of the base game so I'm guessing you could have some problems here as well. It is a nice improvement to the game in that it holds things together nicely, but it does present compatibility problems with earlier editions. Hope this helps! « Show Less
1535318
no differences in gameplay. just the design. it's an update from the company. that's all. the first edition will be some sort of an collector's edition now since it's out of print.
1879260
My guess is that this is the R&R; version. If you want a specific version, you can probably find someone selling it on BGG.