This thing looks identical to the Aquasana filters. Are they the same? Aquasana site has cheaper housings, JP has cheaper replacement filters
882577
I no longer remember why I chose Jonathan over Aq but I've had it for two years and it's great -- no leakage...notice the difference in my hair and skin...only had to change the filter once in all that time (but I'm the only person using that shower and I also shower at a gym about twice a week).
882578
The Aquasana filter uses a different filter system "copper-zinc oxidation media and coconut shell carbon". I tested the Aquasana filter and found it added more copper to the water than using no filter. I'm trying the Jonathan filter to see if it does any better.
882579
I started out with the Aquasana - and saw no improvement in my hair. I googled around to see which filter got good reviews and Jonathan got the best. I ordered it, despite my fear that it might be an aquasana in disguise. I can't say enough good about the Jonathan filter. My hair showed an immediate improvement.
1197382
This is a subjective question, but in my opinion it works just as good and costs significantly less. We used to use the GE brand filters, our water tastes and smells the same since we've switched to Pentek filters.
1304487
It worked for me and I have been using it with no problems. Water taste taste exactly the same as it would with the original filter. Why spend more, just use generic filter and save few bucks. Just make sure you follow instruction showed in the manual.
1062389
You have received the correct filter. They have upgraded the housing. The JG fittings are now sonically welded to the housing.
2211820
All I know is Kinetico in southern MN put a blue 20 inch prefilter on my water line and the filters they sold me had no id on them. I bought these as they were same size. They work well, but must change them more often as they filter out more stuff. They seem to be a better filter and cost much less.
1696851
Greetings, do a search on Amazon for: ASIN #B002XJHGA8. I recommend the Honeywell brand filter over the generic one.
1408694
You might want to order one of these to see if they are the right one? The originall one you listed was a direct replacement for my Hayward 48sq ft filter but the Titan appears to be made by Pentair? Hope this helps!!
104311
I have used this type of replacement filter for about six months. Each filter seems to work as well as the name brand. I see no difference - except price.
1907745
Its the same filter just different name. Ive had mine running no problem for quite some time now. Not to mention they will replace any part without hasitation.
1740015
Yes they are the same filter. We use the smaller one for our fifth wheel. The water tester they send with the smaller one is a bit chincey. It does pour better than the larger one though. Irregardless of the size, the water tastes great.
1963617
I have used the 40043 for several years then bought the 40042 four pack this year. The only difference that I can tell is that the 40043 comes with a flexible hose, and I have several, so I use them with these filters. There is no difference in the quality of the water that I can tell! The 4 pack is a great buy.
1581948
I ordered the "SunSun 3-Pack PLUS Coarse Fine Filter Pad for Aquatop CF300 and SunSun HW302 Canister Filters". I can report that while the major dimensions of these pads are compatible, they are obviously made for a different canister filter. The hole is smaller and in the wrong place. You can flip them them any which way and it will not help. If you tried to cut them to fit, the original hole will be about 80% intact and allowing the flow to bypass the filtration. These might work in a pinch but they are not the correct filter.
925152
I have one of each and they are both the same except for the color. Both of them came with a filter.
1002838
Looks like this company sent me the wrong filters also, I orderd Jura clearyl (64553) but they sent Jura claris. There is no model number on the packaging. This is exactly why I hate ordering online.
404748
This looks like the filter I got with my aquarium starter kit. One of the reviews said the replacement is the Tetra Whisper Bio-Bag Cartridge small, 2-Pack, available on Amazon if you can't find it in your local store.
334646
I believe I ordered the Epica filters, but what I received was the Norpro set of two , said to last six months. They appear similar, so I believe they will fit and work the same. The package was labeled #93F.
2185829
I don't think they are compatible. You may want to look it up on the web, because the pictures of these two filters don't match.