It says tin in the title and stainless in the description. Which one is it?
864637
i'd say it was tin...just like the old fashioned ones. i keep mine in a ziploc bag to avoid a flour mess, but it also prevents the tin from rusting. for the money...one is all you will ever need in a lifetime.
864638
It's tin. Maybe they mean "stainless" as in doesn't stain, not as in stainless steel. I am quite happy with it although initially I did not like the wobbliness of the turn handle relative to others I have had. But it works very well despite that and I feel I got my money's worth.
864639
Jack: Since I have no way to be sure, I had to research to find a way to determine if the sifter is made of stainless or tin. I don't own it long enough to see if it is rusting, which tin would do. See http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/874463 the second reply, which says that stainless attracts a magnet and tin doesn't. I tried that and yes the sifter attracts a magnet. I can tell you that the sifter is made of heavy gauge metal, holds up to five cups at the top line that you see in the photo, the fixed handle is very strongly attached, and the sifter handle moves easily. I'm happy with it for the time-to-time baking that I do. I hope this was helpful. Best wishes. Jack: Since I have no way to be sure, I had to research to find a way to determine if the sifter is made of stainless or tin. I don't own it long enough to see if it is rusting, which tin would do. See http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/874463 the second reply, which says that stainless attracts a magnet and tin doesn't. I tried that and yes the sifter attracts a magnet. I can tell you that the sifter is made of heavy gauge metal, holds up to five cups at the top line that you see in the photo, the fixed handle is very strongly attached, and the sifter handle moves easily. I'm happy with it... » Read More Jack: Since I have no way to be sure, I had to research to find a way to determine if the sifter is made of stainless or tin. I don't own it long enough to see if it is rusting, which tin would do. See http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/874463 the second reply, which says that stainless attracts a magnet and tin doesn't. I tried that and yes the sifter attracts a magnet. I can tell you that the sifter is made of heavy gauge metal, holds up to five cups at the top line that you see in the photo, the fixed handle is very strongly attached, and the sifter handle moves easily. I'm happy with it for the time-to-time baking that I do. I hope this was helpful. Best wishes. « Show Less
864640
Jack: Since I have no way to be sure, I had to research to find a way to determine if the sifter is made of stainless or tin. I don't own it long enough to see if it is rusting, which tin would do. See http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/874463 the second reply, which says that stainless attracts a magnet and tin doesn't. I tried that and yes the sifter attracts a magnet. I can tell you that the sifter is made of heavy gauge metal, holds up to five cups at the top line that you see in the photo, the fixed handle is very strongly attached, and the sifter handle moves easily. I'm happy with it for the time-to-time baking that I do. I hope this was helpful. Best wishes.
864641
When I read this, I went and checked my sifter. I have to admit I haven't used it very often. It says "made in China", so it probably isn't stainless steel, but it is very sturdy. Much better than the last sifter I had which lasted for many, many years. Still nice and shiney and looking brand new. I would definitely buy another one if ever necessary, but I expect this one to last the rest of my life.
864642
I think it's tin but not entirely sure. I know it's not rusted since I've had mine and works very well to this day. It gets used probably 3 to 4 times a week for making pizza dough. Hope this helps you out.
864643
I have one and I think it's tin-very sginy but tto light for Stainless. Best guess
864644
I have one, and I am not sure. It is stamped "made in China" and in the crevices of some of the seams there is a tiny bit of rusting after 20 or so washings/air dry. The 'wand' that you turn seems galvanized, but there are no markings to depict the type of metal. However, it is magnetic- which suggests tin covered steel (tin can composite).
1686549
I have had both. After having an aluminum one for years, I splurged and bought the stainless steel and was so disappointed in the performance that I bought a new aluminum one. I have had it for 10 years and am very pleased with it.
632544
Derek, It says carbon steel (not stainless). It is very high quality. Hope this helps. Ron
1892522
I'm not 100% sure, but the outside is definitely stainless steel. The inside isn't shiny like the outside so maybe that means it's aluminum. Also, the whistling mechanism isn't all that great. It seems to have lost most of the whistling noise, so you may want to get something else. Hope this helps!
222259
No markings for stainless steel. Have had it for several months and no corrosion. Best can opener I've ever used.
378557
The only difference I can see between the two are maybe the finishes. One looks like it has a matte finish, while the other one is just the standard stainless steel.
2082568
Stainless, but I replaced it with glass. Further, the pan does a nice job and cleans up easily, but the handle is too slim and is attached by one little screw that keeps getting loose, and I have to keep a screwdriver at hand to correct it, every few days. I can't recommend it.
1909602
For the one I ordered at least (which very clearly stated "Stainless steel for even cooking" on multiple parts of the package), it was not stainless steel. It would not work with an induction oven, was non-ferrous (non-magnetic) and felt incredibly thin and cheap. 99% sure that it was aluminum, despite the fact I ordered the stainless steel one and the package said it was stainless steel (not just the stirrer, but the whole pot). I sent it back. It just felt cheaply constructed and didn't work with my stovetop anyway. Would not purchase from Great Northern again.
1118026
It is definitely stainless. This saute pan is absolutely great! It is a versatile, well-constructed and beautiful. An incredible and indispensable addition to a kitchen. Don't look at a gift horse in the mouth. You better snap this one up because it is an absolute steal!
638260
The one I received are stainless steel and red plastic around it. Mine haven't leaked and the ducks and chickens are using it.
245336
My guess is stainless steel, but if it's allergy related I think you can email the company
637161
I don't know but it is shiny (and shows no sign of rust) and appears to be stainless steel
2112599
It is stainless steel. But the product is not very satisfactory. it is impossible to clean and looks very bad after a few days of use. None of my other stainless products look like this.
1540005
When I purchased mine over a year ago, it was the 'tin can' version. In my humble opinion, you should ONLY purchase the tin can version.
857453
The reason it is called "stainless"is because of the fact that the alloy is impervious to oxidation (rust)........must be a counterfeit! Mine is awesome and is as advertised.Love using the set.
540044
I think it's brushed aluminium or stainless steel. I don't think it's nickel.
1289171
It is basically stainless--the little circle of plastic/rubber/whatever is hardly worth mentioning. I love mine and am so glad I chose to get this one over all the others. It is really, really nice and of good quality and has a sleek design which makes it easier to clean. It heats up quickly and the dial/level lights up in blue which is actually quite helpful. I am more than totally satisfied with it.