is the cityscape an old version compared to the manhattan version?
1525304
Both fashions are from the same time period. Cityscape was only available in limited quantities. Manhattan will continue to be an available fashion.
652072
I think the newer version is simply rectangular but much the same. This is not THAT noisy and very comfortable in large size. 25 vs 20 inches wide.
407916
Yes, generally there is a noticeable difference between the 3rd and 4th editions of Catan in two ways: 1) The artwork is very different so your tiles will not look the same, depending on how much that matters to you. Personally, I'd rather have them match. 2) And this could present a more series problem. The 4th ed. of the base game has a different border which locks together. I know it doesn't work well with the 3rd ed. of the base game so I'm guessing you could have some problems here as well. It is a nice improvement to the game in that it holds things together nicely, but it does present compatibility problems with earlier editions. Hope this helps!
2221403
I like the newer version better. It's more interesting and somehow simpler than the previous version. i do understand how expecting one thing & getting another is disappointing.
747578
The current version looks identical to the one pictured here on its product page. It not longer resembles the Phoenix version (presumably because they have some sort of design agreement in place now for US distribution).
524303
I have been using these for years but I didn't know there was an old version or a new version. What makes you think there is?
1842509
Yes. You can read the street names - almost better on the B/W printed version than on the color screen.
30524
yes this is the old version, but still works. but i prefer the now formula now.
2172378
I'm not sure that there is a difference. I have never purchased a residential version because I am purchasing for a commercial building. Sorry I couldn't help.
953660
I am not sure what the old version was but my grandkids played it a very short time and have not requested to play again...maybe they were to old for it.11, 10, & 8
155158
It's the older version. My son received the new version for Christmas and I couldn't stand it so I bought him the same one I played as a child.
696577
I never tried the old version, but based on reviews it does seem less potent. I was also disappointed that it wasn't splittable. Then again with its weaker ability you really can't split it.
513920
the two main buttons on top (left and right click) of the old version have a matte finish that feels very high quality, almost metallic like a media-blasted aluminum. The new ones are shiny plastic and feel MUCH cheaper. Yes they may both function the same, and are both incredibly durable (I travel with mine and drop them constantly), but I'd pay double for the old version over the new. It just FEELS so much nicer to me.
637008
It's just a more comprehensive version. There are more features in the ex version. I was iffy too until I found out about the 3D poser and perspective features. They are worth the money for the upgrade alone.
902456
I THINK they're the same unit. It's just that the "base" model comes with the latest map revision ... and no more. When the maps are revised ( updated ) you'd be notified that a revision is available but you'd need to buy the revision to download and install it in your unit. The alternative, "with lifetime maps" purchase costs a little more, but subsequent updates are provided at no further charge for the unit's "lifetime" (or for yours). I think the latter was a better buy and so that's what I chose. Happy trails!
690716
I don't know since I don't have the older version. The new one is very efficient.
1967487
I believe the earlier one did not have presets and there may be more differences.