I did purchase a horgan harness and found it did work for my pulling problem. However the cord at shoulders quickly frayed. I did sent it back and the cord was replaced. It quickly happened again. I wondering if you have change the material to something more sturdy as I have just been told by vet my dog cannot wear a collar only harness due to neck issues. I did purchase a horgan harness and found it did work for my pulling problem. However the cord at shoulders quickly frayed. I did sent it back and the cord was replaced. It quickly happened again.... » Read More I did purchase a horgan harness and found it did work for my pulling problem. However the cord at shoulders quickly frayed. I did sent it back and the cord was replaced. It quickly happened again. I wondering if you have change the material to something more sturdy as I have just been told by vet my dog cannot wear a collar only harness due to neck issues. « Show Less
1509485
We received the Horgan harness as a Christmas gift for our lab puppy. After 3 months of use, it's clear that those straps that connect the legs to the leash are going to be the failure point of the harness. I am starting to see wear, but it is not yet to a point where it cannot be used. I hope in the next iteration they make these straps of a more durable material since it is the point that experiences the most stress in the system.
1509486
I have a golden doodle and she ripped it apart in three walks.Also did nothing to stop her from pulling. I NOW USE A TRAINERS COLLAR WHICH HAS STOPPED ALL PULLING.
1450951
I've had to adjust my harness several times. My dog was able to pull one of his front legs through the front of the harness until I figured out how to adjust it. I have it tighter on front with a little more give around the chest. My dog is still growing and I've noticed the chest strap getting snug so I'm going to adjust again. Play with the tightness of the straps and see if that helps. Hopefully the harness will work for you... I've just kept adjusting til I found what works!!!
1907389
If you are asking about collars that go around the neck as opposed to a harness, yes, the Sporn Double Dog Leash works fine without tangling. It is adjustable and the swivel works well. If you are referring to the "Gentle Leader", I would assume you would not have a problem there either.
375045
I only used the collar for about a month and then I stopped putting it on my dog. He still obeys perfectly some 3 months later. I have heard from others that sometimes it is necessary to use the collar again as a "refresher." I'm keeping mine handy, but so far I haven't needed to use it.
1873135
I love these harnesses, but one of my dogs did the same thing. This has only happened once. Do you have the soft part of the harness in the back? You should be able to tighten both sides enough so he can't pull out. I usually hold the leash up a bit so he can't pull backwards. I do love the quick release.
1131081
This dog collar has changed my dog. He respects me when we are walking. He does not jump on small children or elderly people when we walk by them anymore. He is respectful, because he NOW understands his limitations. Positive training with lots of treats does not work on my dog. He is nearly 55 lbs, I am 120...and I HAVE to control my animal or worse ..he could get hurt or hurt someone accidentally. Now, when I take a walk he is not panting dearly for his breath. He has a strong "opposition of pulling" instinct....even if he is choking himself. He now seems to enjoy walks, looks me in the eye and just hangs out without being overly stressed to pull. This works and it works instantly. PERIOD... This dog collar has changed my dog. He respects me when we are walking. He does not jump on small children or elderly people when we walk by them anymore. He is respectful, because he NOW understands his limitations. Positive training with lots of treats does not work on my dog. He is nearly 55 lbs, I am 120...and I HAVE to control my animal or worse ..he could get hurt or hurt someone accidentally. Now, when I take a walk he is not panting dearly for his breath. He has a strong "opposition of pulling" instinct....even if he is choking himself. He now seems to enjoy walks, looks... » Read More This dog collar has changed my dog. He respects me when we are walking. He does not jump on small children or elderly people when we walk by them anymore. He is respectful, because he NOW understands his limitations. Positive training with lots of treats does not work on my dog. He is nearly 55 lbs, I am 120...and I HAVE to control my animal or worse ..he could get hurt or hurt someone accidentally. Now, when I take a walk he is not panting dearly for his breath. He has a strong "opposition of pulling" instinct....even if he is choking himself. He now seems to enjoy walks, looks me in the eye and just hangs out without being overly stressed to pull. This works and it works instantly. PERIOD... « Show Less
1401042
I bought it for a dog that won't lead, at all,, he just lays down,, this lead only made him lay down faster. I put it on another of my dogs and she was distracted by the new straps, that may be why it keeps them from pulling
110116
I have labs that pull also. This collar prevents the dog from backing out of it and getting loose. Mine still pulled with this collar. My vet recommended the easy walk harness and it works like a charm. It makes it difficult for them to pull because the strap crosses over their front legs. Amazon has the best prices!!
259
My thought is by the time the pup is full grown you'd want a new collar. Because even though they last months and you can wash them in the dishwasher, it's just nice to get another one in a different color. My full grown Pyrenees has had hers over a year and the color doesn't bleed into her fur, the color is still as intense, and the locking mechanism is still working great, the collar is still like news. But still. Nice to have a change in fashion statements -- And have an extra when one is in the wash.
142335
Is it safe to use for tethering a dog to a seatbelt using the back ring? I don't believe this product was ever designed for that purpose. The straps are not that wide, so if the dog were to be restrained during an accident, I don't imagine that it would feel too good for the dog. My answer for that would have to be NO. I will say, that the intended purpose for use with dogs that pull has worked wonderfully for my 9 month old boxer dog. Of course, having an excellent trainer direct us didn't hurt either, but this harness is comfortable for dogs and works. I would definitely recommend this harness and proper positive reinforcement techniques together to correct pulling. Is it safe to use for tethering a dog to a seatbelt using the back ring? I don't believe this product was ever designed for that purpose. The straps are not that wide, so if the dog were to be restrained during an accident, I don't imagine that it would feel too good for the dog. My answer for that would have to be NO. I will say, that the intended purpose for use with dogs that pull has worked wonderfully for my 9 month old boxer dog. Of course, having an excellent trainer direct us didn't hurt either, but this harness is comfortable for dogs and works. I would definitely... » Read More Is it safe to use for tethering a dog to a seatbelt using the back ring? I don't believe this product was ever designed for that purpose. The straps are not that wide, so if the dog were to be restrained during an accident, I don't imagine that it would feel too good for the dog. My answer for that would have to be NO. I will say, that the intended purpose for use with dogs that pull has worked wonderfully for my 9 month old boxer dog. Of course, having an excellent trainer direct us didn't hurt either, but this harness is comfortable for dogs and works. I would definitely recommend this harness and proper positive reinforcement techniques together to correct pulling. « Show Less
1070752
I worry about ALL prong collars falling off, they tend to twist and release themselves. I put a short rope connecting the round ring on the prong collar to another collar (flat buckle or nylon choke) this way If the prong comes loose, the dog will still be connected to the leash. Photo is on the Amazon site for Herm Springer prong collar. Best of luck with your lab! :)
1196580
They have their own brand of no-pull harness which I have had great success with. I too didn't like explaining that the leader wasn't a muzzle. A no-pull harness isn't the solution for every dog. I tried this brand of harness on 6 dogs (I foster) and it was not effective on any of them. 5 of them respond well to the Premier no-pull harness (same brand as gentle leader). Every dog is different. I would suggest going to the place you bought the gentle leader and looking at alternatives. Good luck! Also keep in mind that this style of harness can rub on the armpits of some dogs. I recommend no-pull harnesses to all of our adopters and one adopter used it on the dog they got from me and it rubbed his armpits raw after one walk. Another friend had this happen as well. These have all been dogs with very short coats (Boxer, Pointer). The freedom harness does have padding so should reduce this, but again, it did not work to help reduce pulling for me.
1076927
Hi there! We looked into this too.....we had no choice but to buy the matching collar for our two doggies. Btw - this rock isn't very strong for boundary issues - it's more like a "training tool" to keep dogs out of certain areas.
763665
this has happened to me 4 times and I kept buying new collars. finally a few weeks ago, I called the customer service number and asked if I could buy a couple and they sent them to me free of charge. the customer service agent was very helpful and pleasant.
1196581
It depends of the reason that you are using the Gentle Leader. If it is to keep your dog from picking things off the ground then I don't feel that the no-pull harness will work. However, if it is just to keep your dog from pulling then this harness is a good alternative.Our 9month old Samoyed is very, very, hyper and this harness works well. She still pulls but we can control her using this harness. It also looks good, easy to put on, and she does not seem to mind having it on.
1450952
It took me several adjustments to get it to fit right. Try letting out on the front adjustment and tightening the one that goes around the chest to see if that might move the straps back . That worked on mine . you could probably make some fleece pads if that doesnt work and than readjust . Remember that this halter isnt meant to be that total answer to pulling. They also still need training as well. It just throws them a bit off when they try to pull. Before our Poodle got the hang of the harness and training he sort of learned to walk sideways to make the harness not work the way it should lol! It took me several adjustments to get it to fit right. Try letting out on the front adjustment and tightening the one that goes around the chest to see if that might move the straps back . That worked on mine . you could probably make some fleece pads if that doesnt work and than readjust . Remember that this halter isnt meant to be that total answer to pulling. They also still need training as well. It just throws them a bit off when they try to pull. Before our Poodle got the hang of the harness and training he sort of learned to walk sideways to make the harness not work the way it... » Read More It took me several adjustments to get it to fit right. Try letting out on the front adjustment and tightening the one that goes around the chest to see if that might move the straps back . That worked on mine . you could probably make some fleece pads if that doesnt work and than readjust . Remember that this halter isnt meant to be that total answer to pulling. They also still need training as well. It just throws them a bit off when they try to pull. Before our Poodle got the hang of the harness and training he sort of learned to walk sideways to make the harness not work the way it should lol! « Show Less
85607
I'm sorry to hear about that! Amazingly, my pup still has his and no issues. If it were me, I'd head out to the craft store or fabric store with the velcro and tag in hand and tell the clerk what I wanted to do and ask for their ideas. I've purchased velcro separately in the past for other projects, so I know it's available. Good luck!