Has Citadels stood up to the test of time? Have other games built on its core strengths surpassed it?
1536416
It continues to be a great family game. I have a short attention for inactivity, and with exception of choosing which character, it continues to move. It is full of change and the dark city expansion offers more capabilities. The larger the group, the better the game.
1536417
I don't know what the newer games are that the asker is referring to. But I would say that any game that depends as much on the players' personalities and strategies as this one does will always be popular and successful. It changes based on the number of players, who you are playing with (relative strangers or your closest friends) and which version of the deck you decide to use. So its level of replay-ability is very high.
1536418
The great aspect of this game is you have to customize each game you play with the resource cards you have and don't have and the role cards that are in play. If a player doesn't adapt their game play there are plenty of opportunities to derail their plans. 2 and 3 player games tend to get lobsided as two roles are in play each round, but plays very well 4-6 players. Still trying to get a 7 or more together. The more players however the longer time needed. Also some of the cards rules aren't clear and if misinterpreted can offset the balance of the game. Same with switching in the wrong expansion cards. The great aspect of this game is you have to customize each game you play with the resource cards you have and don't have and the role cards that are in play. If a player doesn't adapt their game play there are plenty of opportunities to derail their plans. 2 and 3 player games tend to get lobsided as two roles are in play each round, but plays very well 4-6 players. Still trying to get a 7 or more together. The more players however the longer time needed. Also some of the cards rules aren't clear and if misinterpreted can offset the balance of the game. Same with switching in the wrong... » Read More The great aspect of this game is you have to customize each game you play with the resource cards you have and don't have and the role cards that are in play. If a player doesn't adapt their game play there are plenty of opportunities to derail their plans. 2 and 3 player games tend to get lobsided as two roles are in play each round, but plays very well 4-6 players. Still trying to get a 7 or more together. The more players however the longer time needed. Also some of the cards rules aren't clear and if misinterpreted can offset the balance of the game. Same with switching in the wrong expansion cards. « Show Less
699318
The game has great replay value. The combination of characters and number of encounter cards ensure that no two games are alike, keeping things different and unpredictable from one round to the next. The many different expansions, which you can play in any combination also keep things interesting. My friends and I have gotten together regularly over many years to play Talisman. We started with one of the original games but have all re-purchased the newer editions since the boards were bigger and more detailed. Hope this helps in your decision making process.
458048
I think so - I'm in my late 40s, and I play this game with other adults in the same age range. The game rewards strategy and cooperation and is in no way childish.
1861888
Yes it's still worth playing. Graphics are obviously a bit old but consider that it's got a great story and the combat in the game is great. I do recommend playing these games. Totally worth it.
195281
Yes I am pretty sure it does have a tutorial for game mechanics. This is a great game! I finished it in a couple days. :)
9534
I found this post at Board Game Geek to be particularly insightful and would probably follow his guide.http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/592228/so-im-considering-getting-into-agot-lcg-your-compr
1022176
If you're looking to buy one or the other, I'd recommend going with Avalon. Simply because you can take out all the extra character cards and the lady of the lake and play it just like the original resistance. I also recommend playing it that way until everyone is comfortable with the original concept before adding in the extra stuff from Avalon. Avalon just offers so much more variety to the game. If you start getting bored with the original there's always a new character to add in that will spice the game back up.
319066
Yes. While there are some references to older games, none of it is required to understand the story to this game. Also, there is a very good tutorial and different difficulties you can use. Whether you enjoy the game is if you like strategy games in general, where you have to plan out your moves instead of relying on quick reflexes.
690031
No. :-( It should and they should have the 10th anniversary components or even better, one full sized board for the roles, ships, and buildings with colored buildings tiles, etc. They could easily get ~$50 from me.If it sounds like I dislike the game I don't. On the contrary, a classic like that doesn't need substandard components to keep it down, even if it is at a good pricepoint.
219026
I bought this in 2013 so I assume so. It's very thick stock like you find on most quality board games. If you're saying it was a mat or something before, it's definitely not that. No complaints about the board.
1142472
To be honest this one, I have played two out of the three and drizzt is by far the best.
1685537
The game plays well in its own. Try a few games just using the core rules. If you find you like it, you can purchase more ships later. A second core set is a good place to start, since it gives you three more ships and extra dice (which are a necessity) for fairly cheap.
1807496
yes! it's definitely a good 2-player game, though I enjoy it more with 3-4. If I can make a recommendation for another one as well then check out Citadels. Citadels is great with 2-4 players as well, and though it isn't co-op I really enjoy it. Additionally, Pandemic is an excellent choice of boardgames for a 2-player game as well and is co-op.
2137268
The graphics are slightly different than I remember. For instance, the ghost looked more like a torso attached to a giant foot in the version I had a long time ago. Also, I don't remember if the original had things on the back of some of the tiles, but in this one there are symbols that can be used for more complex game play. And the player pieces are more detailed. If memory serves, they were a lot like 'Sorry!' pieces, but in this one they are wizards/sorcerers and a sorceress. And of course, this version comes in a nice tin box as opposed to a cardboard one.
413730
Definitely. In fact, especially the original played with the 2-player rule (playing 2 actions each turn), is deeper strategically and a quick (half hour or less when played with familiarity) game that is so good it is addictive. The first expansion, which I thought would add a lot because the goals idea is good, does not really improve the 2-player game.
305927
We bought our base game at Christmas, then bought the seafarers a couple months later. It fits. I think the game boards made five years ago are the same as the ones made currently.
958306
Yes this should include the expansion Citadels The Dark City. This pitcher of the box art has the purple circle in the bottom left hand corner that says Includes The Dark City Expansion. The pitcher links right to the exact same game that I bought off of Amazon, and my game has the expansion. So to answer your question yes it should be.