is the scent in the brown box the same as the scent in the white box?
187073
yes it is the same i have been buying this perfume for 25 years it is so good
187074
Yes, as long as the brown box and the white box are both After Shave Lotion.
1693378
Yes its the same smell but to me not as strong as it use to be but yes the same smell and it was sent safe strong packing and it was ship very fast so if you is going to get it get the 3.4 oz not the small one
1547685
I have compared the ingredient list on both and it looks the same to me. I'm guessing that the company changed the packaging and the yellow box is older stock while the blue and white box is newer stock.
412788
Not sure how fresh the product you had is/was but this smells very similar to brown sugar and vanilla...a scent similar to the one carried in that major chain of bath and beauty products.
1323869
No, the packaging is completely different. However, the contents are identical.
1693377
I've not noticed a huge difference. This is totally my favorite scent, but tends to smell differently on each person. I honestly don't think new packaging makes a difference.
1267682
Yes they are very similar. Do you find that the scent goes away pretty fast ? After about half an hour I don't really smell anything. Except for patchouli which isn't my favorite. I expected it to really fill my home with fragrance
997136
I bought one of each. The Green one is rougher and did not have as strong a mothball smell. Green one had a stain and old illegible stamp marks on it. They both smelled, but the brown one, man you could smell it through the box it was shipped in. The brown one looked brand new. The seller that sent me the Brown one is Bike1guy Sports.
1940452
No one in my family has complained about a scent. We perfer to use items with little to no scent. The box does smell good but the scent from the soap is the same. perhaps the box smells different because the seller has it stored with other products. Hope this helped
2152707
Out of curiosity, I ended up ordering both a few months ago, & they were exactly the same. Same box...same everything.
2104627
It has a nice fresh scent, not strong. I am not familiar with the other ones you mentioned, so I can't compare.
1807272
No difference. It is the same fragrance. I think it depends on where and/or when it is packaged.
821170
Yes, I've been using this product for many years, it is the same stuff, just an updated look to the packaging. I'm male, but my wife uses it occasionally, and the scent could go either way, not strongly masculine or feminine.
1410580
to be honest i don't know, all i can say is that I bought this one as a gift for someone who uses Giorgio Beverly Hills and he did not say anything about the scent being any different. i think would have noticed as well.
1940454
The box looks the same as ours. I'm not sure about the scent but it disappears after opening the box...or we just don't smell it in the shower...We do not like heavily scented items!....Sorry I could not be more helpful.
370161
It differs totally, except taht both scents are 'clean' smelling.But for me, the big difference is that the earlier cologne stayed with you a long time. THis doesn't.
273033
I dont know, but I also have same from Macys department store. The look, packaging, color and smell the same... I find the scent light pleasent and long lasting.... Hope this helps.