I am trying to decide between the rat 5 and the bk10 Crewman. They are similar in size nad weight. Which is the better knife?
278476
RAT5 has a finger choil if you want to get in and do close work but Becker makes good blades too. At this point its preference on mfr, handle, and feel.
278477
I don't know about the bk10 personally, but the RAT-5 is a great knife for the money.
278478
I'd go with the Ontario rat 5. The micarta scales are much better in my opinion. They're both great blades. Depends on your preference.
278479
I dont own a bk 10 but I do have a bk2 which has the same handle design and the handle ergonomics are much better than the rat5. As far as the blade itself I really couldnt tell you. If you cant get your hands on both to get a feel for them before purchasing one or the other Id say just watch as many youtube reviews as you can on the both of them.
211653
I own this SOG knife and a SEAL PUP and the Bear Grylls knife, (I bought for my son). The SOG's are much more sturdy and if I had to pick one to take, it would be this one, because of length and weight and strength of the blade. In a knife fight this is the winner. The Gerber is fine though, and is enough for most people. This is a longer knife, that's why they made the PUP it's a lot smaller and it's great and just as durable and is permanently attached to my hiking pack.
468617
I would suggest the full grind BK-16 instead if your looking for a short knife. The BK-15 is more of a camp kitchen, butchering, or meal preparing knife.
1941258
Actually this knife is the largest fixed blade survival knife that I would carry. The BK 9 is definitely too heavy to carry on your belt for a long journey. But, I have walked 5 miles or more with this on my belt and I wasn't feeling like I wished I hadn't. I feel that It isn't too heavy or long to use on a decently long journey. That being said I think the BK 16 is a little lighter, but isn't as good for batoning or other tasks where the longer blade on the BK 7 is better suited, it does however have it's place also though. Take care and go ahead and get it or better yet, get both the BK 7 and 16 ! :) CDR Actually this knife is the largest fixed blade survival knife that I would carry. The BK 9 is definitely too heavy to carry on your belt for a long journey. But, I have walked 5 miles or more with this on my belt and I wasn't feeling like I wished I hadn't. I feel that It isn't too heavy or long to use on a decently long journey. That being said I think the BK 16 is a little lighter, but isn't as good for batoning or other tasks where the longer blade on the BK 7 is better suited, it does however have it's place also though. Take care and go ahead and get it or better yet, get both the BK 7... » Read More Actually this knife is the largest fixed blade survival knife that I would carry. The BK 9 is definitely too heavy to carry on your belt for a long journey. But, I have walked 5 miles or more with this on my belt and I wasn't feeling like I wished I hadn't. I feel that It isn't too heavy or long to use on a decently long journey. That being said I think the BK 16 is a little lighter, but isn't as good for batoning or other tasks where the longer blade on the BK 7 is better suited, it does however have it's place also though. Take care and go ahead and get it or better yet, get both the BK 7 and 16 ! :) CDR « Show Less
1537921
I would say they are very similar. Same handle materials & finish. I bought the BK22 Companion and the only difference is the blade shape & it is a little bit thicker & heavier. I hope this helps. Both knives I bought are great.
565976
it does resemble the bk2 in size and blade shape the bk2 is far better materials but for the money the rodan will get the job done all week and twice on sunday! killer knife that should last forever!
2277463
Yes it is and I am very pleased with the Bk 7 . Very happy with this knife, would recommend this to everyone
9629
BK2 is a drop point, with a 1/4" blade thickness. BK10 is a clip point, with a thinner blade (I dont remember how thick).
2133746
I own both. I prefer the BK2. I don't think anyone would dispute the differences in terms of quality. That being said the Schrade is really quite nice for the money. This Schrade is full tang .25" thick 1095 steel. Really can't go wrong for $40 bucks.
2191602
I have both. If I had to choose, I would pick this one. Love the assisted open, easy to find with the color, blade lock, very sharp out of the box. The scout is a great little knife for around the house, but for the outdoors, this is the one I always carry.
1603318
Well, these two knives are basically the same. They have slightly different designs (in regards to the grip). But overall, their functionality is the exact same. I would go with the cheaper priced knife. This knife was once thirty dollars. Now that they are popular (and in my opinion a must have for anyone!!), they have gone wayyy up in price. This knife is a must for your pack, vehicle and as a gift for any loved one.
474721
Hello Ryan, The Ontario Rat II with the black handle comes in two blade styles. A satin finish (OK8860) and the black finish (OK88601). The geometry of the blade is less important on how it holds an edge than what kind of steel it is made of. They are both made of AUS 8 steel. The AUS series stainless steel contains vanadium, unlike the 440 series steel, which increases its wear resistance and edge retention. The vanadium allows a sharper edge to be put on the blade. The hardness of the steel in the Rat II is HRC 55-56. I believe the description on Amazon is wrong. It says the hardness is 58-60. There is a tradeoff (inverse proportion) between hardness and toughness. The harder a blade is, the more brittle (less tough) it will be. A hard blade will hold an edge longer, but will be more susceptible to breaking. A blade with an Rc hardness less than 52 is considered soft. A blade with an Rc hardness greater than 60 is considered very hard (brittle). So the Rat II with a hardness of Rc 56-58 is a good mix of toughness and edge retention. You can checkout my article on knife blade steel at www.glenscampingtips.com/?page_id=42. The clip is pretty standard as far as folders with clips. I believe it sticks out about an eighth of an inch. Thanks, Glen from CampingStuff
2200551
I am not familiar with the ontario Rat 1 because I do not own one(I cannot give an opinion on any knife that I have not used as per its quality or ease of use).. I do know that I love my thermite for many reason. it has a deep pocket clip w/ tip up option, the assist detent keeps the blade very secure from accidently opening in my pocket, it has g10 grip on one side really helps for a good grip and light-weightness, the Spanto tip makes it very hardy for tip strength. The only thing that makes me a little worried about the thermite as my EDC. The chinese steel used for the blade seems to loose its edge fairly fast compared to others knives that I own...but for the price I think that anyone who owns knives would be foolish not to buy a Thermite, Tenacious, or a "Rat 1..for its entry level price point! Hope this helps
1859887
The 119BR is a heavier knife also the handle is of exotic wood. The 119 BR is 10.5 oz and the BKS is 7.5 oz.
2200553
ONTARIO RAT 1...for the win. It's easier to draw from the pocket, light, and the dual handle slabs make it a hand-filling tool. Moreover, you may like the added grippiness afforded by having a slab on each side as opposed to only the one on the Thermite. I have both and prefer the RAT 1 to the Thermite, which I must add is a really good knife but the RAT 1 just works better for my needs.
10797
The blade is slightly longer (than the BK) but the handle is a bit crowded, for larger hands. ... The flare, at the rear, tends to make my meaty mits feel a bit "bunched". ... Just fine if your hands are thinner (more narrow). ... There ARE better options and I think that the BK16 is one of them. ... If you can afford it, nothing beats the TOPS BoB Fieldcraft Knife. ... The Mora Bushcraft Black (with or without the enhanced sheath) is a great option. ... The Condor Bushlore and the Condor Basic-5 Inch are both very adequate. ... I carry the TOPS BoB Fieldcraft and the Mora Black as a reserve knife but, to be totally honest, I use my Spyderco Endura4 FFG or my Mora 840MG Companion for any tasks which they can handle. This saves my better blades for the things that ONLY they can handle.
232689
Get a military knife instead if its for personal safety. Most people favour 7" plus blades with more weight for tactical tasks rather than shorter and lighter knives like this Kabar.