I realize no feeder is entirely squirrel proof..but, does this one do better than the plastic ones ?
841167
This is a nyjer seed feeder. Squirrels not much interested in nyjer. Very popular with finches and redpolls though.
841168
yes it is- and squirrels don't care for thistle which is what this feeder is designed for.
841169
We have no trouble with squirrels so I really can't honestly give an answer.
1823339
I had a issue with squirrels chewing through although it is still useable. I have not had a issue with rats or mice that I am aware of - I use lots of garden clippings and leaves as well as food scraps. Overall I am not sure about this bin just because it is so flimsy.
662492
I honestly don't know---I don't have squirrels where I live. Maybe a metal one would serve you better.
908271
I've never bothered with a rain cover and the birds don't seem to mind. Because of the open screen, it dries out if the birds haven't eaten it all up first. As to the squirrels, as long as I keep the feeder on a tight rope line and out of jumping range, the squirrels don't bother it. BTW, I am a huge fan of this feeder. Tried many others, but this one is the best in regard to wasted seed and invaders.
1122570
If you can operate a #3 Phillips screw driver you can tighten down the lid so a squirrel can't get in. If you want a squirrel proof feeder get one of those cylinder mesh feeders inside a cage. I have one and after one try the squirrels just totally gave up on it. But, the Cardinals were too intimidated to feed inside the cage. Hundreds of wrens and the usual suspects, but no Cardinals. So I bought a no-no Cardinal feeder and hung it right next to my squirrel proof cylinder cage, and whithin an hour the cardinals started feeding at it. To get to the no-no cardinal feeder the squirrels have to first jump on the cage feeder and they have just given up. If you can operate a #3 Phillips screw driver you can tighten down the lid so a squirrel can't get in. If you want a squirrel proof feeder get one of those cylinder mesh feeders inside a cage. I have one and after one try the squirrels just totally gave up on it. But, the Cardinals were too intimidated to feed inside the cage. Hundreds of wrens and the usual suspects, but no Cardinals. So I bought a no-no Cardinal feeder and hung it right next to my squirrel proof cylinder cage, and whithin an hour the cardinals started feeding at it. To get to the no-no cardinal feeder the squirrels have... » Read More If you can operate a #3 Phillips screw driver you can tighten down the lid so a squirrel can't get in. If you want a squirrel proof feeder get one of those cylinder mesh feeders inside a cage. I have one and after one try the squirrels just totally gave up on it. But, the Cardinals were too intimidated to feed inside the cage. Hundreds of wrens and the usual suspects, but no Cardinals. So I bought a no-no Cardinal feeder and hung it right next to my squirrel proof cylinder cage, and whithin an hour the cardinals started feeding at it. To get to the no-no cardinal feeder the squirrels have to first jump on the cage feeder and they have just given up. « Show Less
256597
It's only squirrel-proof because you attach it to a glass window, and unless the squirrel can climb on glass, it's safe. :) If the window is small, though, a squirrel could jump from the window frame to the feeder. At that point it would be fair game. I don't think the feeder itself is squirrel-proof, just the location. Any overhanging tree limbs or shrubs might be a problem, too.
2179465
I have had mine for over a year and have noticed just a corner starting to rust. I believe I will wash it and apply rust-oleum and that thick coating should protect it for a long time. This is the most durable type of squirrel feeder I have discovered.
989008
It's not a feeder that will sit on top of a pole. It hangs and is somewhat hard to pu the lid on tight when you fill it. Not squirrel proof.
1735644
I have a round feeder which is a cage that encloses a feeder that is also in a wire enclosure. This lets the small birds get into the cage to eat seed, but keeps the squirrels and large birds out. I believe it is also a perky pet feeder. I also have feeders that look just like the one pictured but they close up the feeding holes when a squirrel gets on them because of the weight of the squirrel and these work very well. Good luck!
1071620
So far I haven't really cleaned it. Dust does accumulate in the bottom area below the main seed chamber and it looks like it would be a pain to try to disassemble for actual cleaning. So that's a downside. On the upside, it has been squirrel proof, unlike other feeders I have used. A similar suet feeder has also proved squirrel proof as well.
1859278
Yes. It has a rod that hangs up from each end and goes across the top. The top lid also swings up to add food easily. I love it and it is really squirrel proof.
1156060
They managed to knock down and badly damage by gnawing on the edges, two of them! I gave up on this design. Amazon does have a pricey vertical "squirrel proof" feeder I bought 4-5 years ago (around $65), and it IS totally safe from squirrels. I've watched squirrels on it several times, totally frustrated and defeated. Worth the money.
1450818
No. I only use it for black oil sunflower seed. If you use mixed bird seed then the seed will all fall out from the large holes.Several times the squirrels will climb onto the top and tilt it but the sunflower seed will not fall out. Also, it really is squirrel-proof cause the squirrels can only get one seed at a time since the top locks.I love this feeder - it is the best for all birds!
637032
I'm surprised to hear people say this is squirrel proof, because it certainly is not in my case. In fact the squirrels often take the top off and eat right out of the top. Even when they don't take the top off they will cling to a branch upside down to pull seeds out of the sides (I only put black oil sunflower seeds in here). I don't mind as it doesn't seem to deter the birds from sharing, but if you are looking for a squirrel proof feeder this is not it.
277436
certainly this is better than a flat feeder. The top is well protected from rain, but the bottom where the birds sit and feed is open somewhat to rain. We have little to no rain in LA, but tons of squirrels. The Squirrels never get on it. you might want to look for a feeder with a large canopy.
1128480
No problem... It has a plastic insert-it might get slightly wet, but the birds don't seem to mind. I live in PA if that helps & I've had this feeder for several seasons & it's the best I've owned.
2246698
Not at all. You need a squirrel-proof feeder - there are many good ones on the market...