I already have an otterbox (defender, I think?) that came with a belt clip holster. The belt clip broke and the case is very difficult to slip in and out of my pocket. Is this model less.... sticky? for lack of a better word... will it slide easily in...
59787
Hey. Actually this model (commuter) is not much sticky as the silicon case goes in and hard shell mostly covers it. Also the exposed silicon is not that sticky and it doesn't create issue in sliding. I think in defender case, the hard shell goes in and all the exterior is silicon; that might be a problem. Thankfully Commuter case design is exactly opposite so it works fine.
747062
I am taking a calculated guess here...I have a case thinner than the Otter Box case that this manufacturer says will fit in the leather holster case. Even with my thinner case, the fit was so tight that I had to snip off one of the two elastic bands that are at the ends of the leather case. It works fine that way, there is no way the phone will fall out, as long as you have the front cover of the leather case all the way down and secured..the magnets are strong...I've shaken the leather case with the phone in it, and tried to shake out the end where I cut off the elastic...the phone doesn't budge so you should be fine. I am taking a calculated guess here...I have a case thinner than the Otter Box case that this manufacturer says will fit in the leather holster case. Even with my thinner case, the fit was so tight that I had to snip off one of the two elastic bands that are at the ends of the leather case. It works fine that way, there is no way the phone will fall out, as long as you have the front cover of the leather case all the way down and secured..the magnets are strong...I've shaken the leather case with the phone in it, and tried to shake out the end where I cut off the elastic...the phone doesn't... » Read More I am taking a calculated guess here...I have a case thinner than the Otter Box case that this manufacturer says will fit in the leather holster case. Even with my thinner case, the fit was so tight that I had to snip off one of the two elastic bands that are at the ends of the leather case. It works fine that way, there is no way the phone will fall out, as long as you have the front cover of the leather case all the way down and secured..the magnets are strong...I've shaken the leather case with the phone in it, and tried to shake out the end where I cut off the elastic...the phone doesn't budge so you should be fine. « Show Less
1734213
I have not had a problem with that at all. The only problem we will say that I have encountered is getting the phone out of the holster. It is a tight fit and the sheath is rubber, so it tends to stick a bit, but other than that all is good. Like it better than the Otter Box I used to have for it.
1747437
First, I had a problem with this case. While on my belt, it got caught on a door frame and the clip separated from the cover, breaking one of the teeth that held the clip. Now I can put the cover on, but not the belt clip. I ordered another one because I like the case, but you should be aware of this problem. Now, about your question, I am not that familiar with the varieties of cases, but from the ones I see on the Amazon site, I don't think ANY case will fit in the clip. I think only the very snug fitting slick designs would fit.
1212438
Well, the case wasn't black, it was white, and yes, it is very slippery. I did not use it and purchased the Zerolemon Otterbox clone, which is quite substantial, and not at all slippery, and comes with a sturdy holster. See my separate review on that item.
824396
metal clip is flimsey with the holster on your belt.,.they make one with belt loops like your belt slides throgh the back into and out of the back of the holster and is much more stable...do not have one, but saw one and a fella showed it to me. i returned the one with the metal clip
2199840
I can only answer part of the question. It doesn't come with a clip or holster. You put the S4 in a rubber sleeve, then put that in the plastic shell. It also comes with a screen protector which I never use. I don't know if it will fit in your Defender case. I put mine in a leather belt clip case that I had originally gotten for my DROID RAZR. I had to stretch it out for the RAZR with a Commuter. Had to stretch it even more for the S4 with the Commuter. That said, you could probably find a generic case to fit even better than mine. I am just too cheap to buy a new one since mine works for me. I can only answer part of the question. It doesn't come with a clip or holster. You put the S4 in a rubber sleeve, then put that in the plastic shell. It also comes with a screen protector which I never use. I don't know if it will fit in your Defender case. I put mine in a leather belt clip case that I had originally gotten for my DROID RAZR. I had to stretch it out for the RAZR with a Commuter. Had to stretch it even more for the S4 with the Commuter. That said, you could probably find a generic case to fit even better than mine. I am just too cheap to buy a new one since mine works for me.
590602
Yes Aaron, my S3 has the Otterbox Commuter case on it and fits great in this Holster. I've been very happy with it and have been using the 3 of them together for the last 9 months.
802975
The clip slides over the belt, very secure, so much so that I usually just slide my belt through the clip. Not to bad sliding the holster on but taking it off without sliding the belt out is a little tuff, however the holster stay's put.
142610
My husband has this case on his s4 as well and has never had an issue sliding it in his pocket. It does make the phone thicker but not as much as the defender series will. I don't think it's a deal breaker.
409074
Yes, the Otterbox Ddefender case does come with a belt attachment and the cradle holds the phone securely and in place ad the belt clip doesn't move from side to side nor slide along your belt loop as you walk, move around, etc., etc. I've had mine for almost 2 years and it has held up very well!
140559
Sadly, it does not have a belt clip. I bought this for my husband and while he does use it now and then, he prefers one that he can clip to his belt. It is not compatible with the otterbox belt holder.
851387
Yes it clips into a belt holster and my wife uses hers that way but I prefer a canvas case see this link http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00AMOAWMA/ref=oh_details_o06_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 my phone with the otterbox defender case fitted but without the plastic holster, fits snugly in this canvas case snaphooked to my belt, much more comfortable too.
851388
Yes it clips into a belt holster and my wife uses hers that way but I prefer a canvas case see this link http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00AMOAWMA/ref=oh_details_o06_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc;=1 my phone with the otterbox defender case fitted but without the plastic holster, fits snugly in this canvas case snaphooked to my belt, much more comfortable too.
2199839
I can only answer part of the question. It doesn't come with a clip or holster. You put the S4 in a rubber sleeve, then put that in the plastic shell. It also comes with a screen protector which I never use. I don't know if it will fit in your Defender case. I put mine in a leather belt clip case that I had originally gotten for my DROID RAZR. I had to stretch it out for the RAZR with a Commuter. Had to stretch it even more for the S4 with the Commuter. That said, you could probably find a generic case to fit even better than mine. I am just too cheap to buy a new one since mine works for me.
1180785
The otter commuter is a much lighter case. The belt clip your inquiry about is for the defender which is a bit more bulky. So to answeryour question I don't believe so I'm almost certain of it. Hope this was helpful. Ed
695445
I don't use a belt clip holder, but I believe the case is a very slim low profile case, and extra hard "skin" layer that does not make you feel like a bulky case. I feel more comfortable with case on than I ever thought I would and I put phone in suit or pants pocket everyday