compared to other collars this style which is better for lab that pulls?
110115
I bought this for my 9 month yellow lab. He was backing out of his collar. This has been the perfect solution. When he pulls, it tightens around his neck like a chocker.
110116
I have labs that pull also. This collar prevents the dog from backing out of it and getting loose. Mine still pulled with this collar. My vet recommended the easy walk harness and it works like a charm. It makes it difficult for them to pull because the strap crosses over their front legs. Amazon has the best prices!!
110117
This style (all fabric Martingale) is good for preventing the dog from backing out, and it is comfortable. A similar construction has the small loop in the front made of chain. It is a little noisy when the chainrattles past the rings, and so gets the dog's attention a bit more. Also, if the collar is adjusted loosely on the dog, the small fabric loop hangs down in sort of a circle. For a strong pulling dog, a better choice, in my opinion, is a prong collar. From all that I've read, the prong collar, despite its looks, is not harmful to the dog. I use one on my dog. I hope that when he matures and is fully trained, I can go back to a full fabric Martingale. This style (all fabric Martingale) is good for preventing the dog from backing out, and it is comfortable. A similar construction has the small loop in the front made of chain. It is a little noisy when the chainrattles past the rings, and so gets the dog's attention a bit more. Also, if the collar is adjusted loosely on the dog, the small fabric loop hangs down in sort of a circle. For a strong pulling dog, a better choice, in my opinion, is a prong collar. From all that I've read, the prong collar, despite its looks, is not harmful to the dog. I use one on my dog. I hope that when he... » Read More This style (all fabric Martingale) is good for preventing the dog from backing out, and it is comfortable. A similar construction has the small loop in the front made of chain. It is a little noisy when the chainrattles past the rings, and so gets the dog's attention a bit more. Also, if the collar is adjusted loosely on the dog, the small fabric loop hangs down in sort of a circle. For a strong pulling dog, a better choice, in my opinion, is a prong collar. From all that I've read, the prong collar, despite its looks, is not harmful to the dog. I use one on my dog. I hope that when he matures and is fully trained, I can go back to a full fabric Martingale. « Show Less
110118
This collar would not be the best for a dog that is pulling all the time. This type of collar works best for a dog that is spooked, it cannot back out of this type of collar.
110119
I recommend something with a chain- not completely chain, so they can hear the sound of it pulling closed. Also the harnesses that pull their noses down seem to work for big dogs that already pull. Another bit of advice, don't let them pull you. If the dog is hell bent on going one direction change course with a firm NO. When they quit pulling then they are allowed to make decisions on where the walk will go.
110120
This is much gentler than a prong collar...it tightens only when pulled. It has worked well for training my large puppy.I would give this a try before going to the more restrictive prong collar.
110121
It works great. My dog is 90lbs and likes to pull and this keeps him in check. It's nice because you can slip it right over their heads and they cant get out of it.
110122
We've had 2 labs. I'm not sure this would break them of pulling but it certainly wouldn't hurt.
110123
For a big dog that pulls, I really like the Gentle Leader, but for general purposes, the martingale is my pick. I used the Gentle Leader to teach my GSD to heel but he always has on the martingale (shown).
418700
Not sure which collar you are referencing as I only used the Big Dog Bark Control Collar, with which we were very pleased. Since your dog is basically a large dog, like our dobie, I would think your dog may respond well to it. Good luck!
597524
All pincher collars do (or should) have the option of buying additional clips to expand the size. The collar should be close to, but not tight around the dog's neck. Too loose can hurt the dog. The object is to stop the pulling, not punish for it. Put it around your wrist taught and sqeeze. That is all that should happen. Put it around your wrist loose and yank. You will understand how tight it should be.
1555860
Looks like they are different material. I am not sure which one is stronger but stronger is better unless you want more flexible. My dog used it for off lead and recall training and dragged it around so a stronger one wasn't really necessary. If your dog is large then best to go heavier duty.
985186
The small also fits my 35 lb. labradoodle. His is neck is about 15" around. I have adjusted the collar to almost the largest it will go. I first ordered the medium collar based on his weight... and it was big and heavy! I would have had to adjust the medium-sized collar to the smallest it would go... then there would have been a lot of extra strap just hanging there. SO, I am really happy with the small (and almost the biggest it will go)! I'm not familiar with a Shiba Inu, but I hope you find this helpful! PS. I also have free shipping/returns w Amazon Prime... It really comes in handy when there is any doubt when placing an order with Amazon. The small also fits my 35 lb. labradoodle. His is neck is about 15" around. I have adjusted the collar to almost the largest it will go. I first ordered the medium collar based on his weight... and it was big and heavy! I would have had to adjust the medium-sized collar to the smallest it would go... then there would have been a lot of extra strap just hanging there. SO, I am really happy with the small (and almost the biggest it will go)! I'm not familiar with a Shiba Inu, but I hope you find this helpful! PS. I also have free shipping/returns w Amazon Prime... It really comes in... » Read More The small also fits my 35 lb. labradoodle. His is neck is about 15" around. I have adjusted the collar to almost the largest it will go. I first ordered the medium collar based on his weight... and it was big and heavy! I would have had to adjust the medium-sized collar to the smallest it would go... then there would have been a lot of extra strap just hanging there. SO, I am really happy with the small (and almost the biggest it will go)! I'm not familiar with a Shiba Inu, but I hope you find this helpful! PS. I also have free shipping/returns w Amazon Prime... It really comes in handy when there is any doubt when placing an order with Amazon. « Show Less
1666466
If having to choose one over the other, I would think the collar's good, since its closer to their face, but didnt hurt to do both, in our case, as we had 2 dogs, and diffusing into the room, made sense for me to do.
974511
I think the "stubborn" dog one would be wayyyyyyyyyyy too powerful for a 7lb dog. I used the regular collars on all my other Labs, but I had this one who was 100lbs & was very stubborn, so that's why I got the beefier one. I think they have one for small breeds though.
876126
I tried to find out as much information about these collars as possible. There is one school of thought that says do NOT get a quick release fastener if you have a strong/aggressive dog cuz it's possible for them to tug so hard that this release comes open. It surely makes putting the collar on and taking it off MUCH easier, I can say for sure. Look at some videos on YouTube for great information. Just measure the dogs neck for sizing. It's no problem to take some links out if it's too large. If you choose too small, you can order extra links as well. I've tried other collars and, believe me, this one has no competition. I tried to find out as much information about these collars as possible. There is one school of thought that says do NOT get a quick release fastener if you have a strong/aggressive dog cuz it's possible for them to tug so hard that this release comes open. It surely makes putting the collar on and taking it off MUCH easier, I can say for sure. Look at some videos on YouTube for great information. Just measure the dogs neck for sizing. It's no problem to take some links out if it's too large. If you choose too small, you can order extra links as well. I've tried other collars and, believe... » Read More I tried to find out as much information about these collars as possible. There is one school of thought that says do NOT get a quick release fastener if you have a strong/aggressive dog cuz it's possible for them to tug so hard that this release comes open. It surely makes putting the collar on and taking it off MUCH easier, I can say for sure. Look at some videos on YouTube for great information. Just measure the dogs neck for sizing. It's no problem to take some links out if it's too large. If you choose too small, you can order extra links as well. I've tried other collars and, believe me, this one has no competition. « Show Less
1451712
The prongs work on my 90lb lab who has a lot of loose neck skin. I think some people are scared of tightening it down too hard. You need to tighten it to where you can barely get your finger between the prong and neck. When their heads are down sniffing the ground the collar will succumb to gravity and not make contact otherwise. You can buy longer prongs from the company later if the ones on there are too short. The collar and remote have worked great for us for over a year now.
1481106
I have a boxer/pit/beagle mix. this works because you can adjust it and there's NO pulling. but practice in an enclosed area first to be sure you have it properly adjusted. if not, it can be shaken off. it's still attached to the collar, but your control will be gone and if you have a hard puller, it can be a sudden yank.
1814358
We actually returned it because it was too strong and purchased the older model 400. He is now used to it and could probably handle the difference without a problem. We have a male mini-doodle that weighs around 35lbs. With the collar on loosley we almost never go above a 2 or 3 out of 8 on the strength settings. I would consider the 425 now primarily because of the faster recharging and the fact that he is used to the collar. I recharge almost every night because it would run out late on the second day. I hope this helps. Good Luck. FYI Our trainer first recommended the 425 and had us get the 400 because it has a lower low for our drama queen dog.
420130
I have a 100+ lb 7 month old Dane. I love this collar. It is the only thing I can use to walk him. It helped with pulling significantly. He still does pull a little, but once it gets a little tight he slows down. I do not have a problem with it fitting, but he isn't full grown yet either. I am not sure how much larger his neck will get.
1070752
I worry about ALL prong collars falling off, they tend to twist and release themselves. I put a short rope connecting the round ring on the prong collar to another collar (flat buckle or nylon choke) this way If the prong comes loose, the dog will still be connected to the leash. Photo is on the Amazon site for Herm Springer prong collar. Best of luck with your lab! :)
1907196
I would think that a medium would be the size you would use on your Labradoodle. I have a German shorthair pointer and that is the size I use on her. Nice thing with these collars you can take links out or add. Very easy to do! Great collar! Hope this helps you!
1380971
Thank you for your question! This collar is lighter and the contact points are closer together to help better fit a small breed.
1534444
The collar is heavy and I have shelties they don't have a problem with the weight. My littlest one is only 16 pounds. Don't know the difference between the two collars. They do work its really reduced the amount of barking the dogs do.
104150
I hsve goldens, medium length hair, and they do fine. but for long haired dogs I think rolled leather collars are the best for their coats. the large will comfortably fit your 15" dogs' necks. I have 12 dogs and this is the only collar I use! I love them!