Open-bottom design Does this product really not have an enclosed base? It would be nice if it could be turned on its side and rolled--giving it the advantage of a tumbler--but it sounds like the material would fall out of the bottom (and possibly the top, as well, depending on exactly how that is secured). The security of the bottom and lid would also be a concern vis-a-vis small animals. It would be great to have these questions answered, because overall the unit sounds promising. Open-bottom design Does this product really not have an enclosed base? It would be nice if it could be turned on its side and rolled--giving it the advantage of a tumbler--but it sounds like the... » Read More Open-bottom design Does this product really not have an enclosed base? It would be nice if it could be turned on its side and rolled--giving it the advantage of a tumbler--but it sounds like the material would fall out of the bottom (and possibly the top, as well, depending on exactly how that is secured). The security of the bottom and lid would also be a concern vis-a-vis small animals. It would be great to have these questions answered, because overall the unit sounds promising. « Show Less
1966650
Does anyone know that with an open bottom if I could lift the composter away from the pile to a new location next to the old location, and shovel it back in.?
1966651
I have one of these, it is made of mesh, so it is not a rollable product. and yes, it has an open bottom which is wonderful to allow worms to migrate in and help with the composting process.I haven't had any animals get into it that I know of, but it is sitting away from the house and I don't monitor it that closely. I am ordering another one or two to use closer to the house, and I'll see then if the squirrels take a liking to it. I really like it because it is small enough to be manageable, big enough to hold a decent quantity, has great air flow and a lid. And I can move it to the most convenient spot easily. I have one of these, it is made of mesh, so it is not a rollable product. and yes, it has an open bottom which is wonderful to allow worms to migrate in and help with the composting process.I haven't had any animals get into it that I know of, but it is sitting away from the house and I don't monitor it that closely. I am ordering another one or two to use closer to the house, and I'll see then if the squirrels take a liking to it. I really like it because it is small enough to be manageable, big enough to hold a decent quantity, has great air flow and a lid. And I can move it to the... » Read More I have one of these, it is made of mesh, so it is not a rollable product. and yes, it has an open bottom which is wonderful to allow worms to migrate in and help with the composting process.I haven't had any animals get into it that I know of, but it is sitting away from the house and I don't monitor it that closely. I am ordering another one or two to use closer to the house, and I'll see then if the squirrels take a liking to it. I really like it because it is small enough to be manageable, big enough to hold a decent quantity, has great air flow and a lid. And I can move it to the most convenient spot easily. « Show Less
1150871
There is no top when it's flipped over it acts as a lid to the unit. It is open to the air but I use one whole container so there isn't ussually water sitting in it.
781849
I haven't used it in this fashion but it's big enough for a 10 lb dog although I'm not sure how safe it would be. It's not really deep. If I were you I'd get a basket with more depth so that the dog wouldn't fall out while riding.
1646395
I would think it would be perfect if you are not in a high wind area or if you are in an area were you can use posts in the ground so it does not roll off with your Morkie. It has loops for posting. Loose sand would not work for posting it down. Half of the top provides shade and the other is open to full sun. There is a lot of opened mesh for air. Also the mesh is strong. I love mine. My Yorkie sleeps in it every night. His little bed fit nice with all his little toys and his blanket. If necessary I could put food and water bowls in it, as well. I hope this helps you make a decision. I would think it would be perfect if you are not in a high wind area or if you are in an area were you can use posts in the ground so it does not roll off with your Morkie. It has loops for posting. Loose sand would not work for posting it down. Half of the top provides shade and the other is open to full sun. There is a lot of opened mesh for air. Also the mesh is strong. I love mine. My Yorkie sleeps in it every night. His little bed fit nice with all his little toys and his blanket. If necessary I could put food and water bowls in it, as well. I hope this helps you make a decision.
1538750
The whole top comes off, from the bottom of the design. I usually twist slightly as I pull. It won't have any grooves or anything so twisting isn't 100% necessary but it makes it a little easier. It really shouldn't be that hard to open.
2004635
It will close easier if you run the rubber ring under cold water for a few seconds for it to retract. The lips on the top of the lid for the purpose of catching your thumb and finger in twisting the lid open or close are tiny and hurt when trying to turn the darn thing when it's difficult to turn. Bottom line is cheap rubber lid ring for a design of having to deal with hot liquid that will cause it to expand?!?! Makes no sense.
590761
Hi, I found this item to be made cheaply?? Like on top there is no safety so I used wired to stop it from maybe caving in. Also it doesn't close very well either, so you may want to use a back up clip. For a 5 lb dog might be fine but, For a few more dollars you can get either a Midwest or another brand. Hope this helps
1798776
There will always be a bad apple whether its the product or the person reviewing it. Sometimes people just have bad luck with products. But we haven't regretted our purchase for even a second. We love it. Good luck with yours if you get it. Just be sure to do the support on the bottom the proper way and I think you'll be really pleased with it. We may have gone a little overboard on the framing of the base but that's how we roll. Lol
69732
Hello A. Rodriguez, and a wonderful moment by moment to you and yours. You are correct, there is no lid on the bottom of the container - only the tray or bowl from which the dogs/kitties eat. The only lid is on top and is for filling the container when it is empty. Actually, this is a gravity fall devise which works wonderful - ask my 3 fabulous-felines...so go ahead, attach the container to the bowl by lining up the slots and when it seats properly, twist/turn it until it locks in place. Remove the lid from the top-fill it with your food, and sit back and relax, the doggie/kitty will do the rest...clean the bowl after a couple rounds of filling, and it will serve you well. May The Highest and Best always flow to You and Yours...YOU/YOURS DESERVE IT!
2023086
Good call, but no. It is open at the top, and the material is thin. I've never been able to see inside from the outside, but from the inside, there are small light leaks that come through. However, if you can't find anything better, I bet the material could be reinforced, and a top could be made to make it light tight if you wanted to put a little DIY into it.
437343
I am talking about when it is in the slot for use in the vertical position, which I think it was intended. If the slot was magnetic or thinner it would not come out as easy. As long as I use it on a desk (flat area) it stays put. When I close it for storage it dose not open unless I make so. This is a great product but it could be improved if for example you want to use it while in bed or on the go in a car, plane etc.
1645669
The feeder is fairly heavy for its size. Our dog doesn't even try but a determined dog could turn it over if it were on a carpet because it wouldn't slide, otherwise it's more likely to be pushed around. Ours stays shut and even if it were turned over, I don't believe the lid would come open.
1415349
In regard to outside use...it is very sturdy but if it would be exposed to extreme cold it would freeze up, if exposed to extreme heat(which I hope your dog would not be exposed to either) it would have to be cleaned out very frequently due to moisture being inside the main bottle/seals all the time. If it would be used outside on occasion and the temps were moderate it would be fine. In regard to the second question: You have to unscrew the lid to change the water and fill it up...you could add ice cubes to cool the water down if you wanted to the main bottle. I am not sure how long they would keep it cool however if the temps were elevated nor am I aware of how it would affect the flow. I have never tried it outside as our dog is strictly an inside dog. I love this system and do highly recommend it. We have had it for nearly a year and we are very pleased with it. I hope this helps.
1914629
I purchased my tumbler last August through Gardener's Supply. That model does not have the screens. The current Amazon product description would suggest it still does not. Truly, for me, the open holes have not been a problem at all.
904532
I actually bought them for gifts & specifically bought the kind without an automatic shutoff so a drink would stay hot till they turned them off. I am told they keep a ceramic mug filled with coffee very hot. If your tumbler is not heat resistant... like plastic or even some glass, I would think this item would not be for you. If you want something that keeps a drink HOT, use a different drink container because this item works really well. Hope that helps.
871898
Agreed - the doors slide but also the tumblers roll so an animal couldn't stand on the tumbler and also slide the door, even if they could figure out how to slide it. They'd roll right off.
1866145
It might be ok to keep outside. The top is just a flip top however there is another plastic piece that seals the the inside bag area and it has to he pushed down to dump the waste in. Also I'm not sure how much waste there is with a dog and maybe how big your dog is. I use it for my cats litter clean up and I can go more than a week before having to dispose of it. I'm not sure how much help this was.