How does Nellie's compare with Charlie's soap? I'm looking for a "bad chemical free" detergent and I am debating between Nellie's & Charlie's Soap.
1815518
Both Nellie's and Charlies fit the bill as far as bad chemicals. I am EXTREMELY sensitive and have been able to use them. I used Charlies quite awhile ago and I think I changed because it faded colors a bit. I am now using Country Save and find that it is very chemical free, although I don't use it for heavy dirt. Good luck on your quest. It is very difficult for all of us who are so sensitive.
1937594
I've never tried Charlie's, but we have used Nellie's for three years. My husband (a traditional detergent fan) is thrilled with the way it cleans and I amhappy with no harsh chemicals or scent.
1937595
Personally I have never used Charlies but did almost buy it. However nellies is very good I think. It does everything it says. The clothes come out clean and soft and fluffy. Very happy with nellies. Hope this helped
1937596
I have used them both. Although Charlie's is fine, I think Nellie's performs better!
603024
I have only used the adult shampoo but if you find out if anyone uses the baby shampoo, I would love to know. While I like t his shampoo, my favorite fragrance is lavender which only comes in the baby shampoo. Sorry I can't be of more help.
291955
I started using Charlie's Soap about 6 months ago because of the reviews. I haven't used anything else since and have saved myself a tremendous amount of money. I never use fabric softener, but I still use liquid bleach with the whites.
875793
I wouldn't use it as my daily detergent, but I have when I'm in a pinch. It would be too expensive for me to use all the time, although I love the smell so much I wish I could! Last time my husband bought laundry soap for me, he bought the unscented, so I just added 4 or 5 drops of "forever" to each load to make my clothes smell good.
970180
Eco Sprouts worked better for us than the bumGenius detergent... but neither worked as well as Rockin Green Hard Rock. I think a good wash routine is equally important as which detergent you use! I tried a bunch of stuff, and what I finally settled on is: initial "express" wash on HOT (no detergent), then a "heavy soil" cycle (with detergent).
1241956
No issues with soap here. We use 7th generation dish soap. I did notice that one of them is a bit stained from spaghetti sauce.
647954
I have tried many different "fragrance free" shampoos because my fiance is hyper sensitive to all chemical fragrance. This is the only shampoo that I have found that he does not have any reaction to. I really like this shampoo and conditioner! We have also asked any overnight guests to use these products and they have liked them too. That being said, there is a slight soapy smell to it... but I would suggest that you try it.
1735154
I used body wash from the 99 cent storeSoft soap. I originally purchased the gallon of bubbles. We were having a party and ran out. My friend grabbed body wash and it worked just as good. Have continued.
1290746
I had some trouble in the beginning and wrote to the company. It was the dishwasher soap, don't use any lemon scented. I know use Cascade with Dawn and all is well.
798133
Well, oxyclean did not soften my wash load. Nellies did and cleaned clothes better. I have hard water and would recommend it as great product. I tried it, I liked it!
669581
Dr. Bronner's is a great soap but is way too strong for children. It doesn't actually "sting" - it tingles and would not be pleasant for children I would think. Try Shower 2000 which is a mild and pleasant soap/shampoo and has no "tingle."
250682
Wow, Teri I never knew... I used this because it's better than antiperspirants and all the deodorants/crap you find at walmart...I will look for something without it for sure. Thanks buddy I would have never known! Thank you!Below is what research I just found... disturbing...Reduced heart function by 25%endocrine disruption (bad for the skeletal system)Triclosan is clearly listed on product ingredient labels, so you can easily check to see if it's there before deciding on a purchase. This chemical is not only in soaps but also body washes, toothpaste, shampoo, and other personal care and home products. Wow, Teri I never knew... I used this because it's better than antiperspirants and all the deodorants/crap you find at walmart...I will look for something without it for sure. Thanks buddy I would have never known! Thank you!Below is what research I just found... disturbing...Reduced heart function by 25%endocrine disruption (bad for the skeletal system)Triclosan is clearly listed on product ingredient labels, so you can easily check to see if it's there before deciding on a purchase. This chemical is not only in soaps but also body washes, toothpaste,... » Read More Wow, Teri I never knew... I used this because it's better than antiperspirants and all the deodorants/crap you find at walmart...I will look for something without it for sure. Thanks buddy I would have never known! Thank you!Below is what research I just found... disturbing...Reduced heart function by 25%endocrine disruption (bad for the skeletal system)Triclosan is clearly listed on product ingredient labels, so you can easily check to see if it's there before deciding on a purchase. This chemical is not only in soaps but also body washes, toothpaste, shampoo, and other personal care and home products. « Show Less
849160
It is a detergent/soap. I think Nellie's also has a separate booster product you can buy.
1415856
I'm very unhappy too. I ordered and found a very strong unpleasant odor to the soap. I have one box (1 bar) left that's labeled 'original.' It's ok. Have you tried specifying 'original'? Anyone? I have ordered from American Soap Company. They're in Evergreen, CO. (888) 909-SOAP) I like their soaps ok, but I'd like the old Pears soap back! @rol
1003185
This is the answer from the company: Are there animal-based raw materials in Charlie's Soap, and are any of the ingredients tested on animals? We do not have any animal-based raw materials. However, we cannot be absolutely sure of the total history of all of our raw materials. But, to the best of our knowledge and sources of information, the answer is No. We have not performed any in-house, nor paid for any animal testing of our products.Source: http://www.refreshinglyfree.com/Charlies-Soap-FAQs
1100239
I don't recommend this soap. It smells good but i don't notice any acne or oil improvement :)
1275766
I don't know why Yardley stopped making April Violets perfume,I was very upset when they did and I also used to love the soap. I think it is a little weaker,the fragrance doesn't seem to last as long but i'm very glad its back on the market anyway--perhaps they will now start making it a little stronger (but not too much!!) Marion Lipscomb.