is a sand filter better or worse than a cartridge sand filter? trying to determind which to buy
1969813
I have had a sand filter for last 15 years and on my second sand filter, I thank they do a better job long term and cheaper especially on larger pools.
1969814
I've had cartridge filters and sand filters and I prefer sand filters. They are much simpler to clean - simply backwash - and you don't have to replace cartridges. Technically cartridge filters take out smaller particles than sand filters, but they are more of a hassle to clean and more expensive to use as they have to be replaced often, and I honestly didn't see much difference between the two as far as cleaning the water in my pool. You can also mix sand and DE in a sand filter for removing even tinier particles that using sand alone. Here is a short article discussing both sand and cartridge filters. http://www.poolsupplyworld.com/blog/choosing-between-a-sand-filter-and-a-cartridge-pool-filter/ I've had cartridge filters and sand filters and I prefer sand filters. They are much simpler to clean - simply backwash - and you don't have to replace cartridges. Technically cartridge filters take out smaller particles than sand filters, but they are more of a hassle to clean and more expensive to use as they have to be replaced often, and I honestly didn't see much difference between the two as far as cleaning the water in my pool. You can also mix sand and DE in a sand filter for removing even tinier particles that using sand alone. Here is a short article discussing both sand and... » Read More I've had cartridge filters and sand filters and I prefer sand filters. They are much simpler to clean - simply backwash - and you don't have to replace cartridges. Technically cartridge filters take out smaller particles than sand filters, but they are more of a hassle to clean and more expensive to use as they have to be replaced often, and I honestly didn't see much difference between the two as far as cleaning the water in my pool. You can also mix sand and DE in a sand filter for removing even tinier particles that using sand alone. Here is a short article discussing both sand and cartridge filters. http://www.poolsupplyworld.com/blog/choosing-between-a-sand-filter-and-a-cartridge-pool-filter/ « Show Less
1969815
Cartridge filter cleans better. Sand filter does a nice job and over all its cheaper
2083289
Regular sand filter sand. Can be purchased on Amazon. Takes little over 50lbs. I bought 2 50lbs bags from Amazon.
1644059
I had to purchase filters separately. You need 4 cartridges so read the fine print carefully. Some vendors ship individual cartridges and some ship 4 packs. I have tried every kind of filter, and I would say get the Hayward ones. They cost more but they last a long time and work well.
440865
I live in Madison Wi, and I do take it down each year. I also ditched the cartridge filter for a sand filter. Cleaning is soooooo much easier.
1692152
It should, check the Haywood website they have specs for filter in pdf form. It does work much better than sand.
672894
Hey Tim my pool is 26x18 33,000 GL. The C1200 is overkill for my pool but that's not a bad thing. I went from an old Hayward S200 sand filter to the C1200. Right off the bat I could tell the motor wasn't straining to push the water through the cartridge verses the sand. I think bigger is better in this aspect. I would recommend this filter to anyone.
692049
Bought the filter for sanding project- haven't started project or used filter yet.
1379463
The glass is considerably more expensive and really doesn't improve filtration that much in my opinion. Properly maintained and replaced when it should be sand media filtration does a great job.
1568923
I prefer the black berkey filters. Everything I read about the ceramic is they are not as good as the black filters. Though, should research yourself by reading up on what they do and don't do prior to purchase to make sure the filter you want to purchase is best for your needs.
1580753
I bought mine several years ago and it did not come with a filter cartridge. There are several filter options available. I'm using the R50-BBSA Level 1 50 Micron HD filter and it works well for my application. I replace it approximately three times a year.
488258
yes...I am getting sand in my pool even though I do not have a sand filter????? That is one of the reasons I bought it!
986007
The filter, not the motor, will limit your length of use. It's a powerful motor, and completely removes all trace of fine wood ash. It would do the same for sandblast dust. You'll need to stop periodically to empty the canister and clean the filter.
864421
our manual says 1 year from date of purchase. but we have found that haywards are a very good filter. we are currently using a de filter. we switched from a sand filter. Our 24 round above ground pool was put in 1997. And this is our third filter, but the de filter was our choice we still have the sand filter as a back up. originally the sand filter was a 2hp the de is a 1 1/2 hp. I hope this helps you.
857173
From my experience it has both the particulate filter that will take care of the sanding dust and the organic type filter worked well for me while I was painting snowmobile hoods. Friend of mine runs an automotive restoration business and said this is the exact same model they use in his business.
1068344
I personally love it. I think the quality is great. you can use Zeolite in there to filter to even smaller microns instead of sand. i currently use sand and it is amazing. Easy to maintain. Just backwash. No hassle like DE or Cartridge. I am convinced cartridge systems are there just to sell you replacement filters. I don't even have a screen and pool is crystal clear.
1352247
Sand is either to high in the filter, to much sand, or the tube inside the filter isnt seated correctly or possibly damaged. But it needs to be in the filter possision
2181880
I do not know sorry, I took the model number of the sand filter went to heywards website looked up the part number and ordered it. It was easy to install. Sorry I can't help you.