Sizing incorrect, leather treatment odd
925990
Too tight and an odd 'aging' of the black leather.  Not a traditional or classic boot, but highly stylized and looks cheap.
4127356
I wear a 10.5, and I bought a pair in 10 in oakwood. They look great, but they were still a little too big, so I decided to exchange them for a 9.5.

When the new boots arrived, I compared them to the original ones I received and there were many differences. First of all, it seems like the new ones they sent me were used. The leather is scuffed, and it looks like it has gotten wet before, and there are also marks along the sides of the outsole. On the heel, there are indentations which lead me to believe that this is a returned product, but someone must have been wearing these for a while before they decided to return them.

Furthermore, there are variations in the leather used, the stitching, and the soles are different colors. Also, when I compared the 10 and the 9.5, they were literally the same size, both measuring 12 inches exactly (11 inches on the inside).

I have a suspicion that they sent me two different generations of boots.
2531584
A great looking shoe with thick, soft leather and excellent quality. The only oddity was the sizing. I wear a 10 about 95% of the time, can wear a couple of brands' 10.5, and I can't remember the last time I actually wore a 9.5, but that was what I ordered in my exchange and they DO fit beautifully now.

Very nice shoe, very happy with the price. By the way, Amazon's return/exchange process is the gold standard. Nice job, Amazon! Another disappointment turned into jubilation, all because of your fast service! Thanks for existing in my lifetime!

Laurie Hunchar
2816160
I wear a 9.5 in normal shoes, but the 10 fit me much better. I bought 2 pairs of these (half size apart.) Both pairs were shipped in a shoe box but one pair came in a typical amazon box and the other in a large gray plastic. The one in the amazon box was brand new, I could smell the leather, the laces were done all neat and every thing was great. The other appeared to be a return. The leather was slightly scuffed and the rubber had visible mud residue all over it. I assume someone returned them and they sent them straight to me without looking at them. My brother ended up using the other pair but kind of felt ripped off because both pairs cost the same when one clearly had already had a few days of use.
2395521
strange odor, not like the smell of nice leather
3859221
nice leather,fits a bit small, but overly satisfied with this boot.
1526887
The leather has a distressed finish, which I didn't expect.  I ordered a 7.5  (my son wears a 7 in nikes)  I should have ordered a 6.5.  Definitely order a size down.  I'll keep and wait till he can wear them.
4112455
I was disappointed in this shoe, which is unusual since this brand/style has always been PERFECT in every regard.
I believe the problem I have is actually the leather and not the shoe itself. There isn't any GIVE and therefore they feel too snug and very warm to the foot. I would like to return and select another Go-walk product. Please send return instructions, and thank you.
3712980
After reading the reviews I was afraid the shoe would be too small - but it was too big!  I got a wide, which was the correct width, but the length was too big and shoe slipped off my heel when walking - even with an insert.

The shoe itself is gorgeous - very classy and it doesn't have that "comfort shoe" look.  AND, the black leather really is leather - not synthetic as the description states.  I am bummed they don't fit becasue they were an incredible bargain!!
4610345
What a great shoe; nice leather, well made, etc, however the sizing is more like European sizing with 8-81/2.  My husband is a true size 8 and we unfortunately had to return these.
It is very disappointing, although I would recommend them to anyone who does well with the 1/2 sizing.
938425
Seemed like a long, narrow shoe vs. a more rounded top shoe.  I felt the width was a bit narrow.  I also was not happy with the quality of the leather on this shoe in brown.  I thought it looked more like vinyl than the leather I have on my other Clarks shoes.  It does have a bit of shine to it.  I will not reorder this shoe in a bigger size.  I really didn't like them much when I tried them on.
1336175
Nice leather, nicely lined as well. Unfortunately the difference between the two gloves is insane (see picture), and the thumbs are too big (at least for my hands) and awkwardly shaped as rectangles.
3621258
"Leather" upper is not top quality.
sole stretched during first wear
instead of just imported, should indicate source of import
3635896
Overall the shoes are nice and very comfortable.  The sizes are way off though.  You may need to order a size or more smaller than you true size.  Like another reviewer my toe had a large dark spot.  If I had paid full price I would have returned them.  Ive been using a leather saddle product that darkened these quite a bit and eliminated sone of the concerns I had over the creasing in the leather.  I hope the fabric piping holds up...using a shoe horn might help Around the heal.

On a side note I have the Comstock as well, which is the boot version.  All the same issues apply.

I'm also concerned about re soling.  They are not goodyear welted.
941829
First off, this appears to be a well-constructed, nice looking, quality leather shoe.  I was super excited to get them and really wanted them to work.  I have high arches and love the idea of a good supportive shoe.  I normally wear a size 8 or sometimes a 7 .  Based on the reviews, I first ordered these shoes in a size 7 . The width of the 7  was good for me (I have narrow feet), but the length, while fine when standing, was just a bit short while walking.  Also, as another reviewer mentioned, the toe box is not very deep, so I felt like the tops of the shoe were pressing on my toes a bit.  This may have broken in over time, but since the leather is quite thick and stiff I didn't want to chance it.  I then ordered the size 8 hoping that would solve the problems.  Unfortunately, the 8s were so big that my heel would slip out while trying to walk in them, plus they seemed too wide and my feet felt like they were sliding around. I was surprised at the big difference between the two sizes.  So, no luck for me, but still a great shoe if the fit is right for you.
1863429
These are tough to review because they are adorable and seem well made BUT the EU conversion was not correct. I ordered what was listed as a US size 11, and what I received was a EU size 42 which is about a size and a half smaller that what I need. Unfortunately, when they arrived, I was desperate and they are super cute, so I decided to keep them. Since they are leather, I was able to wet them and hopefully stretch them enough for my event this weekend, but they are definitely not something I'll be able to wear often. It's a shame because, IF they fit right, I would be totally in love with them. Including extra heel tips and cushions was a nice touch too. If only they understood size conversion =(
4943191
Nice leather, sized weirdly...Edward Scissorhands would have room in any of this glove's fingers....