Comfortable footbed, uncomfortable toe area
931920
I have to return these. They squeeze the outside of my toes just trying them on and walking down the hall to the mirror. The laces are a very poor quality and can't be used to tighten the shoe. The footbed seemed to have nice support and cushioning, but the toe box is hard, turns up, and is very short and rounded so it rubs the outside of my toes. My foot measures a 6.5 but I always buy 7. Ordering a size up would not have helped I don't think. It's the way the shoes are made that is the issue. I also thought they looked cute in the picture, but they were not that cute once I put them on. They looked cheap and kind of clunky. For the price they should have had higher quality functioning laces.
3365876
The design of this shoe is puzzling.  The best feature of these sandals is the footbed.  It has a great arch support.  The other features don't seem to make sense though.  I have a narrow foot, so the straps are too loose, but the odd part is the toe area is too long.  I do not have short toes.  Why create a shoe with a long toe area and a loose strap?  Why would anyone design a shoe that way?  Who could wear a shoe like that?  I don't know anyone who has a foot shaped that way.  The fit in the heel area is fine.  I could not wear a smaller size, because my heel would hang off the back.  So, while I wanted to like these shoes for the good footbed, the out of proportion design of the rest of the shoe prevented it.  I will have to return them.
4698855
I bought these sandals based on the reviews.  I bought them a half size big, which was the perfect size.  My problem is that the toe strap is angled a bit toward the outside of the sandal.  Not a whole lot but enough to put pressure on my second toe making them a bit uncomfortable.  I'm hoping that breaking them in will stretch the straps enough to make them more comfortable.  I'm also not to keen on the hard plastic soles.  Other than that the sandals look great and appear to be high quality.

Edit:  I'm sending them back.  After a few days of wearing them and breaking them in, the toe strap is still very uncomfortably pressing against my second toe.  Such a shame too.  Other than that they are comfortable and very good looking sandals.
1585530
These are very well sized, very roomy in the toe, and comfortable.  There is no arch support and they have a stiff upper, so tying them on tightly is difficult.  I walk a lot, and had very sore feet after walking about a mile to the store.
4964327
I actually tried this in the store and although my shoe size is 8, it was tight, so I ordered a half size up and it's ok. Although one foot is a little loose in it. It is very comfortable for walking, but when I use it on the elliptical my feet slide in it (the pedals on the machine do not tilt and are parallel to the ground) and I wear athletic socks which are totally fine in my other shoes.
The other thing is that the fabric inside where my little toe goes is totally worn out and gone and that is strange because with this brand I didn't expect it and in such a short time too. It is bothering me as if there is someyhing in my shoe. Also my second toe  got hard tissue on its side since wearing this so if I could I would return it. It feels comfortable but has its hidden problems.
3401985
These sandals have a very comfortable footbed, but the straps could use more Velcro for a tighter fit and the straps also rub funny on the tops of your feet! I got red sores from wearing them. I donated them, but hope the new owner doesn't have the same issue! Consider Skechers Sport Men's Wind Swell slide sandals! I love those and considering buying a second pair!
3090247
These are really comfortable. I've only been using them for a couple of weeks, and only when I wear my running shoes.  However, I think that maybe since my feet are on the smallish side - I'm a size 6 - the actual piece that fits between the great toe and second toe may be a little too big for me. I got these because my great toe was actually starting to overlap over my second toe.  When wearing these, I've noticed that with the repositioning of the toes, I'm getting some pain on the balls of my feet.  However, I think that this pain should disappear with constant use of the separator.  Otherwise, the price is right!
536222
Toe rubbed against the rubber end of the shoes and became uncomfortable after a while.  Arch fit my arch in the right place.  Would have been a comfortable shoe if the toe was open, although I'm not sure I like the rubber-type bed of the shoe.
2983279
Very comfortable around the foot and very responsive impact-cushioning, but the leather flap that covers the inside of the zipper can rub on your leg and cause a sore if your socks aren't high enough. The tread is very grippy and can squeak on high-polish floors.
2413404
I don't have wide feet, but it hurt to get my feet into them first thing in the morning. And forget walking. Plus, the material looks kind of cheap. Such a shame because the footbed is well padded!
2722903
These were very comfortable to stand in. The footbed was like a pillow.  But the heel was too narrow and rubbed terribly.  I put in my orthotics for support and they were even more comfortable but the heel still rubbed.  Since I wanted these to walk around Europe in , I decided to send them back.  (On the right foot, they'd be heavenly.)
1800511
These boots are so cute and more comfortable than the other regular boots. However, the way it is designed is not comfortable for my big toes which end up being squished by the weight of the rest of my feet as i walk. The toes hit the front end of the boot and at the end of the day/night, they are very uncomfortable. I am trying to think of a way to avoid this problem since i do enjoy wearing these boots, but so far all i've done is avoid the boots altogether.
2545785
I love the foot bed! Really comfortable for walking and absorbing shock. After a year of use, I noticed they starting to rub and blister my toes which did not happen when I first received them. I note the metallic material is flaking off, making the sandal look dull. Very disappointing for the amount of money invested for a good sandal. I have small feet, size 6, with very narrow heels. I would recommend these sandals with caution on the braided straps rubbing.
1108686
I decided to keep these, but as the weeks go by, I can only wear them for an hour or two at a stretch before I have to switch shoes.  This shoe has a hard sole and footbed.  I'm not a hiker.  I'm a cooker and dish do-er.  These sandals are not particularly comfortable for standing around in.  I've read that the hard sole is better for some people who go on long walks.  Anyway, the upper part of the shoe is fairly comfortable, and I'm not sorry I have the shoes.  The Noat Climb feel pretty good to me, I've had them for three weeks, and I like that they have a replaceable cork footbed.  I can wear them for a longer period of time than the Yucatans.  I'm currently testing out the Teva Toachi 2.  The upper is not well padded, but the footbed and sole are really well designed (soft yet supportive).  I expect I will be keeping these if I can get the straps adjusted "just so."
2012350
Bought this for my mother with plantar fascitiis. She finds them very comfortable on the bottoms of her feet; however, the thong part between the toes is way too thick and irritates the skin between the toes. They should have made this thinner and/or with softer material.
2356882
I like the look of these shoes, but I find them uncomfortable to wear for more than a few hours and they definitely are uncomfortable to wear if I'll be doing a lot of walking. I am thinking of removing the elastic lace from them so that I can loosen them across the top of my feet. I have feet of normal width. I liked the design of these shoes because they had ample room for my toes and looked cool, but the pressure over the top of my foot bothers me after a while and walking more than a few blocks in them becomes painful. For shoe experts, my most comfortable shoes are Doc Martens and Redwings, which have more pronounced arch support. I attribute my discomfort to the lack of arch support coupled with the pressure across the top of my foot.

When I am going to be mostly stationary, I like wearing them because they are stylish and well-constructed, but these boots aren't made for walking, as Nancy Sinatra never didn't say the opposite.
2627220
I can see where these sandals would be comfortable.  However I usually wear a 6.5 and after reading other reviews I was convinced to round down to the smaller size, a 6.  The foot bed itself was the correct length for my foot, but the thong part that goes between your toes was placed too far back for me.  Maybe I have really short toes :)  Anyway my heal was so close to the back edge and I had too much room at the front.  Sadly, they had to be returned.