It is a good shoe while it lasts
924793
I have had this item for 6 months now. It is a good shoe while it lasts. The section where my heel sits has torn apart on both shoes. Other than that. These shoes have done the job for me but be ready to buy a pair every 6 months. The steel toe. You don't even notice it. The shoe is very well engineered. But it seems like the company picked the wrong material to do the job.
1558027
Comfortable and good working shoe, but just did not last.  Really liked the shoe but within a year the glue holding the "shoe" to the sole pulled loose and the shoe became worthless for ongoing use.  I am not an everyday water person but fairly persistent on weekends and though the shoe would last longer.  Not anywhere near industrial-strength
343142
Looking at my Amazon purchase history, they used to last about one year until 2013, and since then they have been value engineered to only last six months.  The soles seem to wear quicker than they used to and the holes the laces go thru stretch and eventually tear out.  Also sometimes the padding perma-fails around the heel.  Oh and the internal fabric falls apart in wear areas.  Oddly enough I'm OK with $100/yr for shoes... its still less than my wife or daughter spend.  I feel it would be much more fair if they sold "half life" shoes for half price.  The fit is perfect, the comfort is excellent, the shipping is fast, just go into it with the expectation that the shoes won't last more than six months.

Interestingly, I'm spending more on shoes than car tires, which somehow seems wrong.
863827
I feel like over time the shoes broke in. They are soft on top, comfortable all day show, breathable. But after maybe a year or so the the sole had started coming undone.  I'd had them for a while and ran in them, hiked, walked, in rain or shine, in the mud, in the yard. They gave me what they had to give. Years later they're still in good condition except for the one shoe where the sole is coming apart. For the price I was satisfied.
1929458
I like this shoe very much. The only downside is the quality: if you are riding heavily I don't think this product will live long and the locking mechanism doesn't seem to be high quality.
4249677
So I had originally tried these shoes at sports authority. I wanted to get the new colors at the store and figure out my size so I can get an all black one on Amazon. At first I loved these shoes. I stand all day and move around a lot and they are really comfortable. My feet doesn't ache in them like my other few shoes. They have good cushion and support ass well.  But now after wearing them for 6 months, I would say 2-3 times a week. They bottom part of my shoe is coming apart! I don't wear them a lot so I don't I understand why that is happening. So therefor the price and how long it has last I am only giving 3 stars. Also after I bought these shoes the price went down!  Anywho I only recommend these shoes for work if it's for short term.
165003
The shoes are very comfortable and well suited for gym training, which is how I intended to use them.  The 3-star rating has more to do with size and durability.  After about 3-4 months, the mesh lining around both my pinky toes started to tear.  I don't have wide feet, so whether it was due to improper sizing or poor durability, I'm not sure.  The holes in the shoes have continued to grow rendering them unwearable after about 6 months.  I do love the look and feel of the shoe.  Perhaps recommending a half size bigger would be helpful
2274426
Very nice shoe, comfortable and stylish. I just like all the Mizuno I had. Those are great from my purposes, good cautioning, fit well, but unfortunately as all running shoes they do not last too long if they are exploited. Lasting few months of intensive use, is too little I think as for pricey shoes
2604434
This would be a great shoe if it didn't fall apart after only 2 months of normal use. Judge for yourself whether you'd tolerate the wear and tear that my pair has.
751610
It's a good looking comfortable shoe. Like others say, buy a half size to a size down. I notice the sir splitting after only the second wear, which concerns me about the overall durability.
2703948
These clogs are very comfy. They are warm without being too hot, and a good shoe to throw on in the winter if it isn't wet out. I also like wearing them around the house. The down side is they are not as high quality as they seem. I have had mine for less than 4 months, and the cork soles are already starting to crumble and show signs of wear near where it bends on the toes when I walk. I've never had any shoes start to fall apart so quickly, and I certainly didn't expect it from what appears to be a quality brand. For that reason, although they are comfortable and cute, I would not recommend them. They cost way too much to be falling apart after only a few months of use.
4816429
I'll keep it somewhat brief, the durability of these shoes is well below the previous CAT & other brand shoes I have used in the past which lasted 1-3 years depending on use (Typical replacement reason being the soles simply wore down too much for safe traction.)  To start with after just a couple months I noticed that the soles of the shoes had started to crack and break apart in some spots though it didn't seem enough to really worry about.  Some 6-7 months after purchase I noticed parts of the shoe's interior would sometimes break free and jab into my feet causing discomfort till I removed the debris.  Now looking at between 8-9 months after purchase an odd bump formed in one of the insoles causing pain, discomfort, and strain from just in front of the arch up to my knee.  While attempting to remedy the situation I found that it couldn't be done as the insoles are glued to the shoe and can't simply be replaced like most shoes can.  I'll be moving along to another brand as clearly CAT is just riding on its brand name rather than quality.
1148516
The shoe fits well, and is more comfortable than the standard pair of Chucks I have enjoyed in the past, but this is the second pair I've had which, in less than a year, the orange/tan sole came loose from the white outer band around the sole and has allowed water to be sucked up into my socks. Silicone and Shoe Goo do not seem to fix the problem. Good while it lasted, though.
1018047
This shoe fits fine and looks great (gloss finish is a bit too shinny) but needs a few days to break it in. This is my second pair because the first
pair only lasted for roughly a year; the front tip of both shoes split open.
350647
It feels good to support your feet. The only problem is that it doesn't last long. The pair I had gets badly worn in about 3-4months.
2009585
Like a couple other reviews there are qualities of the shoe I love; but hard to deal with its poor durability. Love the fit and feel of the shoe right out of the box. Initially got quite good water protection from just walking on a damp lawn. Easy on and off, good looks but blah on the durability. In less than a year, mine have worn through the fabric where the waterproof lower is stitched to the upper at the forefoot flexion. Both shoes! bye bye waterproof! These are not the most expensive utility mid-boot out there, nor are they the cheapest. Mine began to split at about the 6 - 7 month mark. I do not wear them regularly as I like to mix up my shoes based on conditions. I guess I'd be happy if they lasted a year and half / two years. I don't normally write reviews. My hope is Salomon might re-engineers this shoe and applies more durability. If they do let me know and I will buy two pair.
3685090
I purchased a pair of these shoes about a year ago, and at this point they're worn to the point of replacement. They're quite appealing, and the craftsmanship is definitely appreciative (they're noticable, but not overtly so; Italian is probably a good one word description.) However, the soles weren't very durable, and a small hole developed within 6 months of usage on the left and then right shoe.

The leather is of decent quality.

For the cost on Amazon, they're a worthwhile purchase. Mind, however, the expected life of the shoe.