Love this boot, just not my style
925564
Everything is perfect for this pair. Although I loved and wanted to keep them, they were just not my style. If a combat type is yours, this boot should be perfect for.
63362
Fell in love with these boots online, but when I got them, I was a bit disappointed. First off, it's a great boot and looks exactly like the picture, but I'm a pretty athletic size 6 with some decent thighs and these boots just ended up making me looker thicker than I am. I could never find the right outfit to make them work so I ended up returning them. If you've got stick legs, these are the boots for you!
693942
I loved the look of this boot: classic style and terrific brown/black combination.  The leather was a bit shiny, I think that would have aged over time.  However the boot was too narrow for my foot and was uncomfortable.  My foot is fairly narrow and I tried them on with thin socks.  I probably should have ordered a half size or whole size larger.  Return went smoothly, received credit right away.  Decided to shop for boots in stores so I can try them on for fit and comfort.
4507206
These are my first Frye boots, and they were exactly the look I wanted - casual, distressed, nice color (dark brown) what will go with everything.  They are really gorgeous, and the leather is rich and luscious, even with the beautiful distressing.  This dark brown has a slight dark red tinge to it, and it's beyond gorgeous.  The fit is weird, as many have described.  Overall the length is too long.  I wear usually a 6.5 and sometimes 7.  In these I ordered a 6.5, and they are tight at the widest part of my foot, but they are also loose in the heel, and they are long.  I had a 3/4 orthotic lying around, so I inserted those, and the boot feels much better, although the heel in both still slip a bit. Thus I am wearing a slightly heavy sock.  I usually purchase Born boots, which are comfortable always, right out of the box without all these issues (!).  These Fryes are made in Mexico, and they are obviously not designed for my feet, so I have to make adjustments.  OR it could be that these boots are newly made in a factory that has a sizing mold that's not well refined yet.  Born brand boots are extremely comfortable and fit almost everyone!  ANYWAY...  These were not that comfy, and the tightness (even without orthotic) was a bummer.  By afternoon, it did feel like they had stretched out a little bit and were less uncomfortable.  I had hoped to wear them in warmer weather, but with the thicker socks, I'm not so sure anymore.  Still, I will rate it a 4-star because of the obvious quality, the stunning color, and the style.
3540803
These boots are gorgeous and very high quality. The leather is very soft and they are comfortable the moment you put them on. I didn't care for the long look of the toe of the boot though. It reminds me too much of a man's shoe. I knew they were going to be masculine and I might have gotten used to that but the right boot was really tight across my toes and instep. It really felt smaller overall compared to the left boot. I tried on the left boot first and it fit fine with room to spare so I was really surprised the right one was so tight. I know one foot can be a little different in size but I've never had this problem to this extreme. I think it may be a defect in the sizing of this particular pair. These are going back unfortunately. I'm sure someone else will love them! I've ordered the Melissa Tall Lace up, hopefully those will work for me.
4970336
This boot was very cute, but in the end, just not what I was looking for.  I would go up a full size as mentioned.  I am usually a 7 and the 8 worked just fine, although it was not as comfortable as I had hoped.  I am a sucker for ergonomically correct shoes (earth, dansko, merrell) and these just felt like they wouldn't have the same support.  The quality of the leather wasn't as good as I had hoped for either.  In the end, I think the style didn't match mine so I decided returning them would be my best bet.
1123519
Love the design, but the boot was too stiff and gaped around my ankles when I walked, so I returned.
3751811
These boots are awesome. The look, and the quality were great. They just felt weird when I put them on. Snug in some places and loose in others. I really wish I could have kept them.
2889025
Not as comfortable as the Manchester motorcycle boot, and oddly more moto. Definitely not a sleek-looking riding boot for a classic look. Still, nice thick sole for walking. Like most bed stu, fits big. I'm 8 to 8.5, and the 8 was quite roomy.
1294306
I really like the styling on this boot. The heel is interesting and high enough to wear with some of my longer pants as well as dress up a bit. I plan to wear these boots not only to work with pants but also with dresses and tights for a change in the winter. The toe appears pointy but actually gives you more toe room than a pointy-toed shoe or boot might give you. Just hoping that the leather doesn't rub off the pointy tip too fast. Overall this is a pretty comfortable boot. I got these in a wide and found them to be true to size. I also got them a half size up as my foot is wider than most and I wanted to wear a sock with them. Hoping they stretch just a smidge and being leather, I think they will. I found these to be prettier than expected and love that the zipper is on the outside, adding a touch of edginess.
2243207
This boot is beautiful and a nice quality leather.  The buckles are really nice...they look like a brushed pewter instead of a shinny silver or black.  Rich looking boot.  I love the style, heel and shaft length.  The name of this boot is misleading because it's not really what I'd call a tall boot.  I'm 5'8" and it hits me mid-calf which is what I wanted as I don't look good in tall boots.  The description of this boot is a 13' shaft.  Perfect for me. The boot has good arch support.  Most boots are not comfortable on me as they always rub somewhere.  These boots rub my heels but not enough to send them back and I think I can fix it and overall these boots are more comfortable than most.  They are more loose than snug but I don't think I'd want them any smaller which is why I rated them fit as expected.  This is my second pair of ECCO boots and I love their quality and comfort.
4569806
Great looking boot, beautiful leather with a nice lining, but I also found them to run 1/2 size small.  I wanted to love them, but I decided to send them back after feeling pinched in the toe box and struggling to zip up the back with heavy socks on.  I also agree with the other reviewers that they look great with jeans but are heavy on the feet.
2503501
I really wanted to love this boot, the leather is soft and gorgeous, and the wide shaft would look great with leggings and skinny jeans. My only problem was that the boot was too narrow. I ordered half a size up, I wear an 8 1/2 normally, and they were still too tight. I wanted to love this boot, but ladies with wider feet this boot may not be for you.
49037
On the positive end, the rich, smile inducing color is awesome on dreary Northwest mornings. On the downside, the sizing is awkward for me and they're not that comfortable. Based on other reviews and my experience with rain boots in general (Kamik and other brands), I ordered a half size up from my typical shoe size. Unfortunately, I find these boots too long in length, yet too tight around the ankle to slip on & off easily. I have to shoe-horn my feet in, only to feel like I'm wearing clown shoes. I was hoping the Low style would enable me to slip them on & off without hands (as mine are usually filled with a toddler going out and with fresh eggs coming in!). but it's impossible to go hands-free with such a constrained ankle area. It's worth noting I have a high arch & high instep, so others may not experience this issue. Sadly, I wore them around the mini-farm for a couple hours the day they arrived, and now they're too dirty & banged up to return. They'll become my Plan B boots, and I'll return to soft-sided Bogs ankle boots for my go-to work boot.
4636269
I liked this boot, it fit well and was very comfortable. However, I am unstylish and had to send these back.
57846
Fit well and was comfortable, but disliked the style of the boot. Felt like it lacked personality or elegance. Overall though, really nice, well constructed, comfy boot.
4328838
I really love this boot, it is absolutely beautiful, but the problem is they feel like they are almost a full size too large. My foot slides around inside the boot and I can pull on and off without unzipping the side zipper. I typically wear a size 5.5 to 6 and I even have a wide-ish foot and even with wearing 2 socks my feet still slide around on the inside of the boot and can easily pull out. I like a boot to fit snug but not overly tight and this one is just too big. And, I don't want to have to wear 2 pairs of socks to make them halfway fit. Unfortunately, I will be returning the boot which makes me sad, I really love the look of the boot.