Cute and warm, despite overly large hood.
925073
Reviews saying it runs small taken into account, I got a Medium and am glad I did. I'm 5'1" 125lbs and it fits just right. It's all felty polyester so it could probably stretch to additional shape or pounds. Being short I was surprised at how long it is, closer to my knees that top of thighs. (Model in product picture has longer torso and legs than I.)
Super warm!! This is now my at-home snuggy.
My *only* complaint is the hood: it's huge, and could cover all of Barbarella's hair. It's deep and the eyeball things are kind of heavy, so I have to balance it carefully on the top of my head lest it fall down back, or forward so much that half my vision is obscured. I'll consider sewing straps or ties into the hood so I can hook it around my hair or neck instead of dealing with the weight.
Regardless, I'm very happy with the purchase.
3850159
Pros: Cute, as far as Balaclavas go; looks like a hoodie top. Nice convertible capabilities with many alternative ways of wearing it. The fleece material is soft and comfortable to touch. Easy to take off, just pulls smoothly up off the head (but does cause friction and static cling for an electrified look.) Drawstrings help keep the cold wind out; when pulled tight it provides a good seal against the cold.
Cons: Tight fit over my head and I have a small head. Required face squishing to pull over my pony tail (my hair is NOT voluminous), but once over the bump it fits well. Definitely will mess your hair up and makeup with the tightness it takes to put on and friction to take it off. Not very warm; probably more suitable for no colder than 30-40 degree F temps.
2166437
Good looking warm hoodie.  Love the mock neck zip up.  Carhartt just fits a bit large. I usually wear a L or XL, but I had to return a large to get a medium. keep size in mind when ordering.
4118648
I just received my jacket.  It's a nice gray plaid, very warm and stylish.  The fur on the hood zips off of the hood.  I'm happy about that, as the fur annoys me, but I can use the hood.  Fits comfortably.
1865818
I searched a lot for a warm, but thin, coat for my almost 1 yo.  This is it!  It is very cute and she can wear it while strapped in to the car seat.  The hood is really nice because it stays up/is snug in her head when the coat is zipped, so when it's not too cold she doesn't need a hat.
1807317
I am a 6ft 145lbs female and the Large fit me well it wasn't too big or tight only issue the sleeves are about 2 inchs  too short for me. It is lined with a white sherpa making it really warm and the hood has a fluffly grey fur edge. It is removable. I haven't worn it outside yet but it seems it is good quality and would be great for winter.
1857400
It is really long... and the hood is huge.  It is made to fit over a huge hat that some orthodox Jewish men wear on Sabbath.  Huge hood.  Other than that it seems ok.
2842181
It is warm and I like the grey in the hood, but it fits slightly smaller than expected. I wear a size 12-14 and got a large. It has barely any stretch to it like most hoodies. If you like your hoodies to fit a little on the larger size I'd suggest you go a size or 2 up.
4208660
This is a very cute jacket and the fabric is substantial and soft. I wish I could keep it but the XL felt like at least an XXL. If you want to be able to wear sweaters under it, the extra roominess might be nice, but I was looking for something a little more tailored. If all the sizes fit this way, I encourage you to order a size down. For now, I've decided to continue my jacket search.
4713477
The hood is a little small with ears sewed on it, but the sweater fit my daughter well. It's really cute!
2923181
Per the reviews posted here, I bought a size up than my normal jacket size.  It still fits a bit tighter than I'd prefer.
Seems to keep out the wind, Have not been in it during rain or extremely cold weather, but seems warmer than what I was wearing.

As others have mentioned, the hood rolled up into the collar is bulky and annoying, but easily removed.
157540
It is large but that's because I ordered an extra large due to the fact I assumed it would be in Asian size and those sizes are typically made very small (Im very small, 5'2" 110lbs, but this XL size is not very XL). Ive had this coat for a couple weeks and its warm and soft and super adorable and I love it. I love the big pockets, although the insides are a bit worn out and the seams are tearing already. Like it was made from cheap material. But you get what you pay for. Overall I love this coat and it's great if you like to wear sweaters/sweatshirts underneath. Big hood and lots of flexible room inside the coat.
1019546
I read reviews and sized up and found that to be a mistake in an otherwise perfect purchase.  This coat is so warm, looks great and has a wind blocking effect inside the hood that saves your ears.  I really must say my expectations were surpassed.  IM 5'7 155 lbs and the large is way to big.  I would've ordered a medium regularly so be wary of reviews depending on your size.  The Large would be better for 170lbs plus is my estimate.
1997110
The good: very warm (and heavy!) and mostly well-made. I ordered a 2xl after looking at their size charts - available here: http://www.deergear.com/custserv/custserv.jsp?pageName=SizeChart . I'm a 12/14 in most things, and could have made an XL work, but prefer to have room for sweaters without feeling constricted. It's longer than expected, but then, I'm 5' tall. :) Right below hip for me, and the sleeves tighten and have thumb holes so being long is no big deal.

The not-so-good: the hood is huge... I had to carefully sew in a drawstring in the back. Tightening pulls it around your face, but doesn't help you see (I was doing a great Arrow impression...). The other thing is that the thumb holes are coming unstitched above the thumb (towards fingers where admittedly it does get a lot of pressure) after about a week of daily use. It'll be easy to fix, but wish I didn't have to. For a coat that's actually warm enough for my odd sense of temperature, fits, and looks pretty good doing it I'm only taking off one star.
1885198
I ordered this for my mother in a large, but the jacket was still about 2 sizes too small for her.
I'm a petite small, but prefer my items a loose to accommodate layering and large just fits me.  It's cute, lightweight and lined.  I love the deep pockets and the pattern on the hood.  I do wish they would offer it in larger sizes, X-large, XX-large.  A true medium might fit in the large, but the large did not fit my mom and she is a true size 12-14.
919837
I Love the color and softness of the scarf. The hood part was big for me. I have to either fold it over or push it back. Overall it's very warm and I like it.
58844
After reading all the reviews, I took the advice of other people and ordered what I figured would be 1 size above my normal sizing (I'm about a US6 in dress sizes, 5'6", 34 B-C, and about 120lbs for reference, and usually wear a Medium in shirts). I like the jacket very much, but it is WAY too big for me! I'll be returning it for a small or medium, which I should have gotten in the first place, as I wanted it to be much smaller and more form-fitting. I like the material, as it's about the same as a thicker sweatshirt, but not quite as heavy as a canvas jacket. I love the moto-jacket style neckline, and the snaps seem strong without breaking your fingers to separate them. The hood is smaller than the usual, giant hoods I am accustomed to, but still covers the head well and is accommodating if you're wearing a hat and/or scarf.
I love my other Doublju products as they have good thickness and warmth for brisk but not quite cold weather, good for chilly days where you want the warmth of a heavy jacket but not the burden, and far more stylish. Growing up in Alaska makes you a bit of a coat and jacket snob. I hate that other people have had such bad luck with the sizing issue, as I've found them personally to be true to size. Online shopping is unfortunately always a crapshoot with clothing and shoes.