Medium Tall was insane!
937471
I purchased the medium tall.  I am skinny and 6 foot 2 inches tall.  The shirt was literally to my knees.  Very disappointing.  When worn with pants I could not tuck all of it in.  Returned.
1166138
I love how high these go on me. I am over 6 feet tall with long legs and these hit me mid knee. I was so excited! First time ever!
607332
My husband took one look at me in this thing and had to brace himself on the sink, he was laughing so hard.  I don't know if I've ever seen him laugh like that.  I couldn't help but join in, parking the, "what was I thinking?", in the back of my mind so as not to spoil the moment.  When he could finally speak he said I looked like a miniature matador, whereupon we both collapsed all over again.

I can't imagine who could wear a size small in one of these, except maybe a 6 year old girl.  I got a medium and I'm little.  I'd say if you are over 120 lbs., don't even think about it, even in the largest size.
3501943
Loved the cape and the material was great, but it was huge. I am about 5'7" and this cape went all the way to the ground. I actually tripped over it several times (which in turn also choked me). It is definitely made of high quality material, though it is definitely a little heavy to have pulling at your neck. It looked great with my costume, but ended up being a bit dangerous.
1084161
This thing is pretty amazing :) It's HUGE though. I got the standard size, and I'm 5'9", 195. The legs are way too long, and the whole thing is very wide. If you're a fairly small person, just get the youth size. Other than it being huge, it's awesome. It's not even Halloween yet and I've already gotten compliments.
977044
ridiculous is about the best way to describe these freak'n awesome shoes!  the colors are awesome...what are you wasting time reading this for?  go buy 'em!
1355487
I bought medium tall and it fits very well.
2272460
HUGE!! The 41 (billed as a 7) was more like a 9 or 9.5. Immediate return.
759823
This was listed as a Medium Tall, and I would estimate that it is an almost perfect 41Long. High quality, perfect fit. Looks fantastic. Well made with welt pockets, fully backed buttons and interior pockets in the lining. My husband is a perfect size Medium Long and it fits like it was custom made. Surprised at the quality for the price!
4447580
Beware. The size medium is way too big. Bigger than 95% of medium shirts commonly available.
I actually compared it to more than ten short sleeve shirts that I have and it's ridiculously bigger than all of them.
I am 5 ft 11 inches tall and this shirt was way too long (it looked silly how long it was).
I am also a normal size (weight 172) and the shirt around my waist and chest was so big I could fit another person in it.
So, for this shirt to fit well you have to be more than 6 feet tall and clearly on the chubby side.
In short, my advice is to pick another shirt from a brand you are familiar with in terms of sizes.
4297600
It was a HIT!! I'm six foot tall, so I expected it to be short and wore it as a shirt with jeans. Very fun
2238357
I'm 5'0 and 125lbs, on the curvy side but still petite - size Xs top and size medium bottom. I got this in an XS and it was huge. Not even cute, trendy big, but like I was in my dad's coat big. Such a bummer cause it was super warm and looked great. Material didn't look cheap or anything. Very well made. I suggest this for taller women. Ladies, even if you're 150lbs, I think you'll be able to fit in the size xs or small.
400817
This tall was REALLY tall.  I could roll up the legs a few inches, but the length from waistband to legs -belly and hips - swamped me too.

They must be great for someone about 6 ft. tall
2302587
I ordered a tall medium just from guessing at the picture. It's actually an inch too tall, but my bad. It works well nonethless. Better than paying over twice the amount for the same pair!
2621301
The helmet fit ok... but the helmet itself was just exaggeratedly HUGE! I looked like the mushroom from Mario Bross !
3831082
Fantastically tall.  Super easy to put together.  It's great.
2179903
I knew when I opened the box for this hat that my life had just been altered in a profound way. As I pulled it out of the box I could barely contain my awe. Upon slipping the supple, sun-dried straw onto my head it was almost as if I grew six inches taller. The doorbell rang. I opened the door to find Selma Hayek, Jessica Biel, Megan Fox, Milla Jovovich, and Rachel McAdams standing on my porch. "Hello?" I asked, with a slight tremor. Turns out, they somehow knew I got this hat. We're all dating now. I need a bigger house!