Great warm boot with one problem
929529
This is a fantastic boot.  It fits great and most of all it is so warm.  The only problem is that it is so warm that my foot got so sweaty (with socks on) the insole fell apart fairly quickly and I had to replace it with a gel sole.  If Totes could do something about strengthening the insole I think it would be the perfect winter boot.
2091629
I was looking for a great and comfortable pair of lined boots that I could wear with jeggings and skirts to keep my feet warm in this cold weather and that wouldn't cost me a fortune.  The BEARPAW boots definitely fit the bill and they do look amazing.  I treated them right away with a waterproof product for suede so that I could wear them outside without ruining them.  Overall, they look great and are holding out well which would typically lead to a 5 star review, the reason I dropped to a 4 star is that the bottoms are wearing quickly which surprises me. Years ago I bought a cheap pair from Payless and while the rest of the boot was falling apart, the bottom was holding up well - I want a pair that will do BOTH and feel great.  Although, the price is good enough that I would buy them again and since they are comfortable and warm, I love them and am more like a 4.5 stars.
1606202
The Good:  I love the look and feel of these boots.  They fit exactly as they should.  Not too tight, too loose, or too long.  The inside of the boots are lined with a faux fur that feels luxurious on my feet and ankles. I am hopeful they will be great to wear when snow starts falling this winter as the treads look good, plus these boots are waterproof.  They are very flexible and comfy so there is no break-in period.

The Not So Good:  I am concerned that the sole might be a bit thin. However, it could be that they are so flexible it just seems that way. I have decided to get a really good pair of insulated insoles from a sporting goods store to put inside them and they should be fine.  I have to loosen the laces all the way down in order to get my feet into and out of the boots.  They would be much easier to put on if they had tabs (loops) at the top, in the back, so I could pull them onto my feet easier.

So, if these boots had thicker soles, were easier to get on and off, and had loops to help in pulling them on, they would be perfect.  Overall, for they money, these boots are a good buy and I am happy with my purchase.
4653330
The boots are very well made and they're very warm twist perfect for the kind of cold that we live in ....the size fits good ..but the whole boot itself is a very big heavy boot.. it almost makes you look like your feet are two times as large as they are .. the part that goes around your calf is very wide it looks kind of like they're too large... if they had put the lacing all the way up to the top then you could have pulled that in ...but all in all I say they are good boot just maybe a little bit of a better design on the calf part.
3571420
I've only used these boots on two occasions now, however they are warm and comfortable but the top stays open, no adjustment.  Also very easy to acquire crease marks at the top of shoe that stays permanently in.
3179433
They shipped as expected from seller.

Pros
~ Love that these boots are adjustable and are warm and comfortable

Cons
~ Zipper on the side doesn't go to top making the tongue and sides to flop downward.
~ The Velcro strap that is used to close the area where the zipper doesn't go won't last long.
~ The tongue is narrow so even if you adjusted the boot to your calf and pants you're wearing it's possible to have a gap and thus no water/snow protection.
430147
These boots are very warm but they don't breathe well, so my feet were cooking when I was driving. Great traction, and comfortable to walk in, easy to put on. Recommend wearing socks that really breathe, and if on a long road trip, maybe drive wearing something else. Color is as depicted.
1137414
I wanted to love these, but the calf is just too narrow for me. I can tell that these would be very comfortable. They seem extremely warm and the pattern is so fun and cheery. The boot shaft is extremely flexible and really moves with you. I know I could get the short version, but I really want a tall boot for snowstorms.
1598082
I would have given these boots a higher rating if not for the breaking in period.  I took a chance and bought my typical size (7.5) rather than a half size down as recommended by others.  The top fits fine although the ankle is a little loose and tends to bunch and dig into the back of your leg until the boots are broken in.  The foot is definitely not as snug as my 7.5 regular Ariat paddock boots, although it did not slide around.  They are more difficult to take off then put on.  I have poor circulation in my feet and these boots are significantly warmer, sturdier and have better traction for winter barn chores than my cheap rubber boots.  This winter has been particularly cold and snowy in southern New England and these boots have truly been put to the test.  My toes are cold when outside at temperatures below 20 for long periods of time (2-4 hours.)  For quick trips in temperatures between -10 and 10 F, the cold won't even touch my feet.  The boots are beautiful, however the leather is more distressed than I had expected.
1839857
I love the boots and they are very warm.  However, they are tight around the tops, but I can still get them over jeans.
1307079
I couldn't give these 5 stars because of two problems, both can be overcome, but that should not necessary  There is no insole inside this boot, the felt inserts are right on the bumpy rubber sole.  I fixed this by buying some of the gel inserts, but don't feel this should be necessary in a new product.  The fit seemed to me to be a little large, after a little trial and error I discovered they were more comfortable if the strap across the front is a little loose, when pulled tight it cuts into my ankles.  They do keep my feet warm!
4775332
I live in the Colorado mountains, and I love these boots!  First, they are really warm and comfortable. Second, I felt a lot better about walking on icy sidewalks in these than any other boot or shoe I have- the traction is exactly what I needed. Third, they look as nice in person as they do in the picture, which is always good.

My only complaint is that I REALLY had to break these in before they were comfortable. I wondered at first if I would have to return them because they were initially so uncomfortable, but I am glad I gave it more time. Because of that, I would really give them 4.5 stars, but I do love them now, so I'm giving 5.
3316621
I want to start by saying these are a great men's winter boot!! I purchased these for my husband for a winter boot primarily for shoveling and playing outside with our kids and for ice fishing/trekking around at our cabin in the winter. I ordered a half size larger for my husband based on the many Amazon reviews I read stating they ran somewhat small -- and they fit perfectly, plenty of room for a warm sock as well.

We are sending these boots back because these boots do not cinch tight enough around the top per my husband's comfort level--had he been able to tighten them more he would have kept them... Although these weren't the winter boot that worked for us, I have to say that I was pretty impressed with how warm these boots. I did a l lot of research to find a really warm, waterproof, comfortable, good traction, etc. pair of boots and, in my opinion, these boots are all of these things and more.

Kamik makes really good, warm, long lasting winter boots. I have always bought this brand for my kids and been really happy them.
736825
These boots are great- they are warm and comfortable and fit just right. I gave it 4 stars rather than 5 because I will need to get insoles if I walk in them longer for distances because the arch and heel support isn't quite there. Lighter weight boots than my others which is definitely favorable too.
702483
Lovely warm boots and comfortable when they're on. The difficulty is getting them on and off again! Very small opening gives my son huge difficulties getting in and out of these boots.
3709111
I ordered the Joan of Arctic after trying on a friends Kate the Great boot, also by Sorel, which I loved! I have huge calf muscles, so was very excited to find a boot that fit!!! I like these boots, however the function of the snaps on the liner is kind of annoying. The snaps are always coming undone and do nothing to help keep the liner in the boot when removing the boot. That being said, it kept my feed dry and warm through the winter and I look forward to colder weather so I can wear them again!
3074426
These are almost great boots and I was really excited when I first got them.  Great tread, comfortably wide toe box that still looks slick, good leather, smooth lightly padded inside for comfort, nice bit of roll to the sole for easy walking, lightweight but clearly well-made.  But after wearing them around the apartment for a bit I found that the cursed inner ankle zipper is their downfall.  It's very sturdy, which would be great if it didn't bend inwards to press so strongly against my ankle that I'm forming a bruise.  It doesn't even seem like a necessary zipper, I can get them on fine without it.  I'm heartbroken that what could have been the perfect boots are unwearable for me because of this one thing.  Despite the fact that I have to return them I'm still giving them 4 stars because aside from that one fatal flaw they're great.