The quality of the boots seem good. The main issue I have with these boots ...
919784
The quality of the boots seem good.  The main issue I have with these boots is the seams come together right on top of my fibula bone.  This makes them somewhat uncomfortable to wear.

Update:  The seams stopped rubbing after an uncomfortable two week break in period.  The boots were comfortable and waterproof from that point on.  The downside is that one of the heel seams blew out after 91/2 months.
4046921
Boots seem to be of quality material but the build not so much. The waterproofing is awesome I have wore them through practically the entire Colorado winter so far and my socks haven't gotten wet from the snow once. I haven't noticed any peeling or pulling away from the soul and the laces haven't started to fray or tear.

Now for the bad. The first day that I wore them it was snowing outside and there was quite a bit of snow on the ground. Ever since then there has been an insane squeaking with every step that I take and I have not been able to get it to go away no matter what I try. Short of putting it in the dryer I have tried practically everything. I am a medical courier and spend most of my time walking around on tile floors in labs and hospitals and I must say I am definitely without a doubt the loudest person in the building. To the point where people are turning and looking. Even outside the squeak is so bad people from across the street can hear it.  There seems to be something wrong with the soul on the right foot as its pushes into one spot at the front of my foot and hurts quite a bit. I even went and replaced the insoles thinking that would fix the problem and it did not. The left foot seems to come up too high on the arch or just isn't made wide enough as it feels like I'm standing on the side of the boot.

I have owned several pairs of shoes expensive and budget prices as well as boots. Never before have I experienced these issues.  I really wanted to love these boots and I could probably get used  to the squeaking but the arch problem on the left foot and the feeling like I've got a rock stuck in the right foot is just unbearable after a few hours  and if it wasn't for the fact that half my work day is spent driving to and from locations I probably couldn't even wear them. Again the waterproofing is amazing and if this is a pair of boots you're looking to just wear for a few hours a day to keep your feet dry I would say go for it but if you're looking to buy a pair of boots that you can wear for 8 hours or more a day I would definitely steer clear. I will unfortunately be needing to look elsewhere for another pair next season.
1739395
After reading previous reviews regarding the quality of the boots, I did a thorough check of stitching and construction and luckily, the boots seem to be well put together! I have an old pair of Steven Madden fold-down combat boots with the zipper in the back that have been worn into the ground, and hope that this pair will be a good replacement for them. The leather has a good leathery smell, and the zipper zips smoothly. I only gave them 4 stars, though, because the laces are awful (round and stiff and yuck!) and there is a spot on the heel of one of the boots where the seam on the inside is really hard and rubs really badly just under my ankle bone. Hopefully as they continue to break in that will improve!
310508
With all of the things you'd expect to get in a good quality shoe I would have loved to have given them a better review. My review has specifically to do with the quality of the boots. I expected these boots, well taken care of, to last for a long time. I figured the soles would be the first to go. Unfortunately, these boots were a big let down. In shortly over 1 year the inside padding of both boots began peeling up. Now the right boot, despite my attempts to "go easy" on them, has a large enough gauge in it that I can't wear them anymore. I feel that I am rather gentle on these boots. I don't work on a construction site or anything. I basically just walk in these boots. Approximately 12K steps per work day. (Thank you smart phone) I got terrible blisters on my foot when I tried to give it a go even with the innerds wearing away. I expected more from the Timberland name.
1155435
They seem good quality and I do like them, however the leather is very stiff compared to other desert boots I have, including some that are clarks. Hoping with time they'll soften up some.
3453017
First of all, these are exceedingly warm and should come in handy this winter.  I don't regret purchasing them.  The memory foam adds a nice layer of comfort.

There are a couple of issues, however.  First, it's a bit misleading to call these 'snow boots' as there is almost no traction in the sole.  If anything, they look like they'd be actually quite slick in snow or ice.  I'll wear them on cold days and skip them on snowy days, which seems odd for something sold as a snow boot.  Will wear my Skecher Chugga boots on snowy days as they actually provide quite a bit of good traction.

I ordered a half-size up which was perfect - I have lots of room in the toe box and they don't slip off.  I'll need that extra room to put in
an arch support as this boot offers none at all.  Also, even with a half size larger I'm having a bit of the same issue as other reviews mention with the top and side seams pressing in a bit on my foot.  If I'd purchased my regular size this would be a deal-breaker.  Hopefully with wear the seam issue won't continue.

Still, it's a nice looking boot and the construction quality seems good.  The price was certainly reasonable.
3729891
Quality feels good. The boots feel heavy and are super stiff even past the break in period. And so far I am not really liking the inner bootie, kind of a pain in the butt to get on and take off and just adds more weight.
4522201
The overall quality of this boot seems to be good, but they run very large and the styling was not quite what I had expected.  I wear a size 11-1/2 D in dress shoes and tennis shoes.  When I tried them on there was way too much room  in the 11D that I ordered.  I did some research on fitting western boots properly and most of what I read suggested ordering a 1/2 size smaller than your normal shoe size.  I did that and these boots were still way too big, probably due to the square toe which was wider than expected.  I knew that I was not ordering a snip toe boot, but the width of the square toe on this boot is massive.  Approximately 3" or more which provides a lot more room in the foot bed. That may actually be helpful if you plan on wearing heavy athletic socks and, in that case, the 11D would have probably worked for me.
2304765
I like these boots. The are solid and the soles make them quite heavy. The rubber soles also make them quiet to walk on which is nice after the noise leather soled boots make. They do run narrow. I got a full size up after reading the reviews. I probably would have been better with a half size up. I have normal to slightly wide feet. (I usually buy the normal width not wide shoes). I'm keeping them and will wear with woolly socks. If you have narrow feet get your normal size otherwise think about a half size up.

ETA I've worn these for a couple of weeks now and the rubber tread on one heel is starting to fall off. Not happy at all!  Very disappointed with the quality.
2086639
I
I purchased these in hopes to receive somewhat good quality boot for the price. What I found, is that the leather feels very thin, but the craftsmanship and construction is good. These boots are made in China.
The foot fit true to size, but the boot is too loose at the ankle, making your leg look like a tree trunk, the calf was way too loose for me too, and I wish the maker/seller would list the circumference for each size. It looks like the maker adds an extra inch of circumference for next size up, making the boot in size 9 circumference over 16, resulting in the look on 13.5 calf like rain boots.
4188337
Purchased these boots for my son.  They appear to be a nice boot.  I think they will stand up to wet, slushy weather.  Unfortunately, the boots seemed to be covered in an oily residue when they came out of the box.  This made them very difficult to try on.  I now have oily footprints all over my kitchen floor.  We took a chance and had my son wear them outside to get the oil off as they were his usual size and we assumed they would fit.  Unfortunatey about half way down the street, it became obvious that the boots are actually pretty snug and my son will probably will not get more than a couple of months out of them.  If he could have walked around in the boots a little more inside the house, we might have caught the mistake and exchanged for a bigger size, but they have already been outside so I guess we are stuck with them.
3073920
I very much want to like these work boots. They fit everything I've been looking for in a well-fitting, well made steel toe boot. There's only 1 problem, and it's a deal breaker for me.

The tongue of this boot has a seam that runs horizontally just under the top of the laces. That in itself isn't a problem. The fact that the seam is perfectly aligned to hit against the inside bony part of my ankle IS a problem. Thick socks aren't even helping. The part where all 4 pieces of material meet is pretty hard and knobby. It just keeps knocking and digging into my ankle bones over and over again, causing pain and bruising.

I'm sad to say, these are being returned.
973666
I got these boots for my 21 month old daughter and they just arrived today. She is a size 5 in Nike shoes and the Baby Bog 5 seems a tiny bit large. She isn't tripping in them though, so we will keep them. They seem to be good quality and my daughter won't let me take them off of her feet. The sole is sturdy but flexible. The fur lining is only on the ankle part and it isn't too thick. I am hoping to use these on an upcoming trip to the Hoh Rainforest (crossing my fingers that they keep her dry). I'm not in love with the handles, but I think they are meant for older kids to put the boots on themselves. Overall, a quality purchase and for $30 I am very happy.
3664791
The padding on them is decent but the boots aren't very well finished. The are spots where the glue has leaked and dried up and it just doesn't feel like the good quality product.
The biggest issue is that there is only one size, the boot is way too wide and spins freely around my ankle (I'm 5'10" with relatively thick ankles I think). I could hang on them but it felt like foot would slide through if I pointed (Although I didn't have the courage to try).
230307
The boots themselves seem to be of good enough quality, but they fit like a size too large. Didn't want to bother having to exchange them. Disappointing.
434663
As others have said, the foot portion is extremely small and stiff, making it difficult to get your foot in. I was able to, and the soles seem comfortable, but I'm worried that these will hurt my feet if they swell at all during the day. The shaft is perfect for my 15" calves, I have just enough room to comfortably wear socks or pants over my calf. The same can NOT be said about the foot though. I'm not sure I'll be able to wear these in enough to be comfortable. One of the boots is also slightly taller than the other due to the stitching, which is super noticeable because it rubs against my knee. I also worry about the zipper, as it seems pretty flimsy.

Only pros: The leather is nice quality and the color is perfect. If they were sewed correctly, they'd be the perfect length for me.
1606202
The Good:  I love the look and feel of these boots.  They fit exactly as they should.  Not too tight, too loose, or too long.  The inside of the boots are lined with a faux fur that feels luxurious on my feet and ankles. I am hopeful they will be great to wear when snow starts falling this winter as the treads look good, plus these boots are waterproof.  They are very flexible and comfy so there is no break-in period.

The Not So Good:  I am concerned that the sole might be a bit thin. However, it could be that they are so flexible it just seems that way. I have decided to get a really good pair of insulated insoles from a sporting goods store to put inside them and they should be fine.  I have to loosen the laces all the way down in order to get my feet into and out of the boots.  They would be much easier to put on if they had tabs (loops) at the top, in the back, so I could pull them onto my feet easier.

So, if these boots had thicker soles, were easier to get on and off, and had loops to help in pulling them on, they would be perfect.  Overall, for they money, these boots are a good buy and I am happy with my purchase.