They're too hard, my cat can't chew them
934673
I wish I could say I like this product, but the treats are so hard that my old cat cannot chew them. I try to crumble them but I have arthritis in my fingers and so that job is painful and also is, I believe, an unnecessary extra step.  They are hard to cut with a knife also. Maybe if they had small crumbles and you measured out a half-teaspoon or whatever I would like them better. Like another reviewer posted, my cat was rather enthusiastic at first but within days he didn't want them and I was forced to try breaking them up. I'm still giving them to him in canned cat food, but this morning he wouldn't eat it at all. When I gave him some more canned in a different dish without the bits in it, he gobbled it down. I wish I had heeded the other reviewer's advice and not bought them.
Sorry!
4866644
I think these are way too hard of a treat for my dogs. They choke on them because they break apart in sharp pieces. They aren't like jerky.
I won't buy them again.
2246014
These are soft (freeze-dried?) but not wet/mushy treats, so if you have a kitty who has trouble eating hard treats, you may want to try these. My kitty has some dental issues right now and can't (won't) eat the standard hard/crunchy treats, so these were a nice (and apparently tasty!) alternative.
2247102
Too hard for my cat.  This clip is very strong and I think it will hurt my cat.
3153760
If your cat only likes crunchy treats, they will not like these.  I couldn't even get my cat to eat half a treat.
4353460
I am disappointed to say that my cats looked at me like I had lost my mind when I first presented these chews to them !  They refused to eat them, so I tried cutting them into smaller pieces....... one cat ate one little bite, but refused to eat the rest.  I am gonna try again tomorrow, but I don't have high hopes........ one of my cats is pretty picky, but the other one loves almost everything !  I think the product idea is good...... maybe needs a little more tweaking.......  ;-(
1673750
These would work really well, if my cat didn't remove them one by one with his teeth! The other cat, who doesn't really scratch the furniture, totally ignores them and on him they last quite a bit! Unfortunately it doesn't help me.
238661
My cat did not like these at all. I tore them into little pieces and she still refused so I gave them to a neighbor who has three cats, one of whom eats everything, and none of them would eat these either. She gave them back and my dog is eating them instead. She seems to like them fine.
2761365
These are not soft, and my 3 cats don't like the flavor. Unfortunate because I was looking for something soft for my cat who had 3 teeth pulled - besides wet food.
4967100
They are too hard for your dog's teeth.  If you cannot make an indentation with your thumb on the chew, it is too hard and could break your dog's teeth.
86272
My cat won't touch it. I tried mixing it with other treats she will eat, but she picks all the other treats but these.
2972249
My cat had no interest in these at all. They were too hard for her to eat...too large and even when broken down, too chewy
1522570
The nuggets are really hard and difficult to break up (need a knife to cut them into small shavings) and then take a long time to dissolve. Stella and Chewies is sooooo much easier to use. The cat liked eating primal, though.
4394438
My cat loves mylar crinkle balls, or at least the "Pet Favorites" ones I've bought previously.  I thought I was just getting more of those, but these are different.  They are thicker, stiffer and a heavier weight, and my cat doesn't like them.  But cats are weird- another cat might likes these and not the lighter "Per Favorite" ones.
3425443
These treat strips have texture of very hard rubber.  I can't recommend them.
679086
My most finicky cat eats them, which assures she's getting a nice nutritional supplement.  My other cat refuses them, so they're not for every cat.
4913856
I ordered these on a whim since my cats get both Nature's Variety hard, soft and raw foods.
My kitten mostly eats the frozen raw pellets (both rabbit and duck) and the grain-free kibble.
The older cat most eats the canned Instinct (rabbit and duck) and grain-free kibble also.

Neither one of them will touch these.  I have tried as a random treat, as an add-on to another meal, mixed with other treats they like to see if they would gobble everything down, coated in Florti-Flora, as-is/dry, reconstituted with water, etc.  No configuration of serving registers to either cat as an item of food.
The older cat walks away and the kitten knocks them around as if they were toys, so neither of my cats view this as edible.

I suppose every cat is different and you should always try something once, but personally I would not recommend these as treats.