Went down a half size
926818
A little big but very comfortable and cute!
4035369
I had to size down a full size, from 13 to 12, since at my normal shoe size my heel was slipping horribly.  With a size 12 I needed to break them in a bit but now they seem molded to my foot and are some of the most comfortable shoes I've worn.
1870842
I would recommend buying a half size down! Ordered a size 8 and they were literally slipping off my feet, had to put extra soles to make them fit better.  Other than that, they are very comfy.
2884138
I actually went a half size down because they looked wide in the toe area.  I have a very narrow foot and the half size worked well.  I wore them to work today and received several complements from different ages of friends. The colors work very well together. . I'm considering going back and purchasing another color.
2904188
I used the size guide but now I wish I had gotten a half size larger
211408
I'm a half size so went a size up to be safe, could probably have gone down size with my narrow foot and they would have stretched a little
4758724
It seems Sperry has changed their sizes since the last time I bought this shoe. I had a size 9M so I re-bought these shoes I got the same size, but the shoes were slightly larger (it's clearly noticeable holding the shoes against each other that there is a size difference). I tried to order a size 8.5M thinking that Sperry changed their sizes by half a size, but these were too small for me. So I'm stuck with the size 9M shoes that my heel comes out of slightly when I walk. With that said, I find it hard giving these shoes below 4/5 stars. Only issue is this slight size change.
FYI- I bought my previous pair which are now falling apart about 2 or 3 years ago.
3786825
Feel a bit big and I ordered half size down I think it's width Im going to try thicker socks
917547
I really love the look of these shoes, they're really comfortable and look cute with everything. Definitely order at least a half size down. I ordered my regular shoe size, and even after putting in thick insoles, they are at least a half size too big. Without the insole I might even go a full size down.
488053
I suggest you order 1/2 size down as they stretched a little after wearing a few days.
1510365
I ordered the wrong size. Although the shoe was comfortable it was just too big. I need to go a half size down.
1874277
I would suggest ordering a half size smaller.  I started with a 9.5 and they were too big.  I got the size 9 and they seem to fit much better.
1032084
After reading the other reviews about them running small I ordered half a size bigger and feel that now they are too big.
30399
I read that the crochet Toms don't stretch like the regular canvas ones, but they do. I recommend going a half size down. I got my regular size and they were too tight at first and now slip off my heel a little bit when I walk.
4480277
Super comfortable but had to get a half of a size smaller. They were slightly big to begin with and I knew the fur inside would pack down a bit after wearing them a couple of times.
4852353
Love these shoes but I suggest getting a half size down of your usual size! I ordered another pair in a half size down of my typical 9.5 shoes size so the 9's were a perfect fit and are much more comfortable. I still love and wear my 9.5's that I ordered cause they're only just a little bit larger.
998381
Great boots. But i normally wear an 11 and had to down size by a half