This is a quality boot although there was a defect ...
936746
This is a quality boot although there was a defect it seemed, in the back of the boot that pushed my left foot forward and made it uncomfortable to wear. I sent them back but didn't order a replacement because I thought Id run across the same thing. I gave 4 stars because of the defect as Im sure not all boots have that. I just got the pair that were defective. Return and refunded without an issue.
3271503
Not the greatest quality control, I noticed the stitching on one of the boots was offset causing the boot to fit a bit tighter than the other one. This also made the gap between the laces appear smaller than the other. The boots fit good other than that and offer great support for your ankles. I got a great deal on Amazon ($60.00 shipped) so very pleased with the boots for the price...would have been upset if I had paid full price. These will work for the light hiking and camping that I do.
911800
I wear 10.5 to 11 in shoes and I ordered a 10 with these and they fit well. The boot itself is nice looking(though I wish the stitching contrasted a bit more with the rest of the boot) and I like that it has the hooks at the top. I am pretty frustrated with the condition that mine came in. Based on the stock photo online and the condition of my boots I would say they were stored poorly. It looks as if some one had been wearing their jeans tucked into them for weeks before shipping them off to me. I may or may not send them back and get some Volcom Sub Zero's.

Pros:
feels durable
fits well if you understand sizing differences

Cons:
Already looks worn around the ankle

EDIT: It seems that the stitching around the ankle of the left boot is gone, I don't know if this is intentional or not but I am not satisfied with this purchase
also after editing this post my pics were some how removed
4593800
I really like the boots themselves, nice thick warm lining. And the velcro will help keep snow out. However, the pull cord at the top of the boot was sewn into the seam so I can't pull it. So I've placed an order to replace with another pair.
1986590
These are great boots but i think i got a defected one. My one boot had an inside overlap of leather and it kept rubbing on my foot which hurt until i cut it out. Also kne of the soles are mis shaped.
4287417
Nice quality boot.  I have a wide foot and I normally wear a size 11.  For this boot, a size 11 had the right width, but the heel was very loose.  I had to buy stick in pads to make the heel less loose.  That's the reason I gave only 3 stars.  But now that I've adjusted them, they're great.  I'm waiting for a big heavy snow so I can go work outside!
4627939
Lovely Boot, however toes were cramped and one fit slightly
differently than the other.
3607153
This is a beautiful boot - the second pair I have.  The lining was loose and the inner flap was unglued but I can fix that easily with E6000 glue so I definitely won't return them.  Easy fix to a beautiful pair of boots.  The color is darker than shown.
3392018
Nice boot but one of the rivets was missing. Didn't have time to return them and no cobbler has the piece.
4735057
I was initially satisfied with the quality of these boots, but after 3 months a few rubber pieces on the sole of my left boot have fallen off and the heel is starting to separate from the body of the boot. These boots are ok, but the build quality seems to be lacking in several area.

Quality aside, they are comfortable and easy to wear. I can wear them comfortably all day.
4731218
Stylish looking boot that appears well made except for one lump in the sole right on the ball of my foot.  This causes some discomfort during the day if wearing them for many hours.
764902
Great looking boot for great price. Only problem was that the lining in the right boot was not attached to the actual boot causing my husband's foot to get stuck in the boot. Would exchange for a non defective pair but that option isn't given when trying to return so we are going to try to figure something out to prevent getting foot stuck
3380433
The upper nylon shoe lace eyelet pulled loose after using the boot one time. It looks as if someone or something missed stitching that particular eyelet as I've had no problems with any of the other eyelets. This is otherwise a very nice boot. Very warm and comfortable. I would buy again, but would look at a different manufacturer if I encountered another problem the second time around.
1205711
this is a quality boot. i purchased it from REI in December 2015 for $340 (400 minus 60 in store credit). i got the 27.5, relatively comfortable for my size 11.5 D feet. warm, and thermoform liner fits nicely. easy to get in and out of. decent control on groomers and in pow. only complaint, is that after the liner warms up after about 30 minutes skiing, my foot shifts forward or back when I change my stance, e.g., leaning forward while on a hard pack groomer to leaning back in pow in the glades.
1993677
First of all, these boots are quite comfortable, have excellent traction in snow/ice/slush, and are nice and toasty warm (but not too warm to wear at work all day, provided you have good socks on). HOWEVER, after just a couple of weeks of very light wear the sole on my right boot began to separate right at the toe. This was very surprising to me as I have been buying Keens for years now and have never had a pair that suffered from a material defect like this. I sincerely hope that this defect does not affect ALL of boots of this style, because I am planning to exchange my pair for another. Also very hopeful that Keen is not going the way of many of my favorite brands and attempting to cut costs by manufacturing products with inferior materials. I'll give them another chance, but if this is the quality of product they are selling from here on out they've lost me as a customer.
1364933
Quality. However, the foot portion of the boot was very large in comparison to the shaft. I would have needed 3 wool socks on to fill the foot of the boot. I didn't want to end up having creases and dents where it would cave in due to the voids... Not natural creases in other words. I returned them sadly.
1927850
I would've given these boots a solid five stars but for one FATAL flaw: a manufacturer's defect that shocked and disappointed me!

First let me say that these boots are fabulous in every other way. The fit, the quality of the leather, and foremost, the design. You just can't beat Doc Martens. That sole, that look, the instant comfort. Normally, these boots are an amazing value.

This time, however, I noticed a problem right away; these boots are designed to fold down, securing at the back with a buckle. On the right boot, the buckle had been affixed backwards, making it useless. I'm glad I noticed before I spent the money to ship them to my daughter at college! Now I have to go through the tedious process of returning them for exchange, which may take some time. Initial shopping estimates were way off; I didn't receive this pair in the expected amount of time.

One further note: as others have commented, these boots run large. I'd estimate as much as a half size or more. Don't be afraid to order down.