one shoe was larger than the other, they were ...
932765
one shoe was larger than the other, they were not made in the USA as advertised. I have worn these shoes for years, all USA made, but these shoes do not come up to Sebago quality.
2275854
Ordered a size 6, recieved 1 shoe that was a 6 and one shoe that was a size 7.
407898
one sock was longer and larger than the other on the black pair with flash on it.. clearly two different socks were shipped. not very happy, but she already wore them
1678342
One shoe is larger than the other. I have to wear a thick sock on one foot and a thin sock on the other. Would not buy again.
4651263
I was very disappointed that two pairs of the same style and size would be so different in actual size and fit; one fitting, one clearly not.
2455291
One shoe was bigger than the other.  The right shoe was sewn tighter than the left and rubbed my toe, so I gave them away because I had worn them outside, and they hurt my feet.
1475482
The heel on the right shoe was wider than the left and gapped.  I've had this brand shoe before and never encountered this problem.
1864257
I received the boots which both had stickers on the heels saying they were 9.5's however it was obvious they were two different sizes. Turns out one was a 9.5 and the other was a 7.5.
They had to be returned which was disappointing.
23225
These shoes were interesting to say the least.  The front of the shoe fit very tightly across the toe box of the shoe.  But the heel of the shoe was huge, flopping around.  It was like wearing two different shoes at the same time.
3317585
These were different lengths, one was about 3" longer than the other.
2258179
the right shoe is an entirely different fit.  I had to place an insole to make it not feel so big.  Left one is great!
509520
One shoe seems to be bigger than the other, but they matched my outfit perfectly and I kept them anyway.
739205
One shoes was much tighter than another. So they are miss-sized! I wore it so I thought I could stretch it but it did not. Now I am stuck with a pair of shoes that do not fit!
262828
One shoe is smaller than the other so I can't wear them. I bought them in the summer, planning to wear them in the fall (my previous pair had worn out), but when I actually put them on, one was fine but the other was so tight I couldn't get my foot inside.  And it was past the return date!  Ugh!
1034363
One boot fit fine. The other boot seemed like it was a size smaller. Not at all like all my other ariats
1615579
It was larger than size indicated and did not fit my shoes.
1789886
One foot seems bigger than the other as it slides only on one foot. Only pair of shoes I have had this problem with.