Only complaint is the rubber seal comes off too easily when removing the lid
920821
Very stylish, delivery comes quickly. Only complaint is the rubber seal comes off too easily when removing the lid.
3119878
The lid stays on, and the rubber flaps are sturdy, yet soft.  The whole design is great EXCEPT for the small canister size, although some may prefer it.

Since I need these in the deep door pockets of my SUVs, double or triple height would be preferable.  After trying various canisters, I've found empty&nbsp;<a data-hook="product-link-linked" class="a-link-normal" href="/Kleenex-Perfect-Fit/dp/B00TZ9JFD0/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_rvw_txt?ie=UTF8">Kleenex Perfect Fit</a>&nbsp;canisters of tissues to indeed be perfect even with Rubbermaid's lid and car cup holders, with a Ziploc sandwich bag as disposable liner.  If you don't like the grandma-style designs on the Kleenex, wrap and tape colored construction paper.

Can you just use the Kleenex canister as garbage holder even with this Rubbermaid lid?  Sure, but its small removable lid opening is cumbersome (take a look at the store).

I also have flip-lid style and push-door style garbage cup holders, but they're either cumbersome, have sharp edges, or have lids constantly pop off.  This Rubbermaid design is ideal.
810858
Works perfectly. Had a minor leaking issue with this one. I ordered two, one for me and one for my gf. The top lid somehow came apart from the screw on part of the lid. We just used some glue, and it's working fine again. My black one hasn't had any issues.
1064207
I've been saying that a certain company needed to come out with a lid like this for months because being able to close the lid with kids is amazing. My husband has actually stolen this lid from me and has taken it to work. He loves it. It fits nicely on to an 20 oz Yeti cup (and probably and similar companies). I would recommend every few day taking the black part off to wash with warm water and soap because if not mold will build up. I found out that the hard way and that's why I'm giving it only 4 stars.

Disclaimer: I received this product for free or discounted for my honest and unbiased opinion. I only review items that I've tried and would recommend.
1318669
I use this a lot to seal our mason jars with lettuce, juice or smoothies. It's a great overall product and would recommend.

The only reason for 4 stars being the blue rubber on the inside comes off when I take it off the can and I have to put back in every time. It's a very easy fix, but annoying.
709882
Ok, but the rubber seals around the lens keep coming off?
4331073
Cons:
-The metal-on-metal sound when opening and closing really is noticeable.  It does not bother me, but if you are in a classroom, library, meeting, or near people who are sleeping, there is a chance it will be too loud.
-I was loving its look until about a month in, when I dropped it from 4 feet up onto a sidewalk.  It made two small dented regions (each ~1 mm deep with area ~1 cm^2) that are peppered with small nicks, which from up close spoils its otherwise pristine looks.  From 3 ft away it's not as noticeable.
-Also, after about 6 months of constant use, the metal ring has popped off the cap a couple of times, but I got it back in pretty easily by hand.  There are also a couple dents now on the bamboo of the lid.

Pros:
The seal is always airtight when closed.  I think I read that for other bottles that the silicone gasket can pop out, but that has never happened for me.  It's not clear from the pictures, but the handle on the lid can move.  I really like that the entire interior is stainless steel (as opposed to many with plastic lids, which defeats the entire purpose).  I figure it's the safest material, except glass, until we figure out biochemistry well enough to know which plastics are truly safe.

I've had it for about six months now and FYI I've only ever used it it for water at room temperature.  Overall I'm still content with it.
2238047
I had a vacuum packed large jar that was difficult to open with this product.  I rated it 4 stars instead of 5 because the grip was not tight enough to break the vacuum seal without additional hand pressure.  The gripping surface should have been more tactile so the lid could be removed without added hand pressure.  I purchased this product to give a solid grip for removing large lids off jars. The gripping surface should tightly grip lids so minimum force is required to remove lids.
4354823
One of the lids was a bit loose and would drip when drinking if not positioned a certain way. Plastic edges were a little rough, but not where you'd put your mouth. Rubber around inside of lids did mold a bit, so keep an eye out for that. However, rubber ring does come out easily with a toothpick and can be cleaned without issues. Clean rubber ring, and lid, then let both air dry before reassembling and you're good to go again. Had no worries about them tipping over because the bottom is nice and wide. Will NOT fit in most car cupholders.

Not top notch mugs, but good for the price and keeps drinks warm or cold for a couple hours, if the lid is on.
4917741
I love this lid.  It has a silicon seal ring which makes for a perfect watertight fit with my Kleen Kanteen.  I don't believe I've ever had leakage when the lid is screwed on tight.

The D ring is nice for carrying, but the edges are a little sharp and not so comfortable when a finger s looped through.

IMPORTANT!!: The main irritation I've had is that the silicone sealing ring sometimes slips out of it's groove in the lid and ends up falling in the bottom of my Kleen Kanteen.  If this happens to you, be sure the ring is perfectly dry when you reinsert it into the lid.  If you put it back wet, it will work its way out again very quickly.
4751167
Love this Drinking Bottle except for one thing.  Personally, I just don't like the feel of the rubber straw on my mouth so I cut a plastic straw into 2" and inserted it into the rubber straw.  I like the way the rubber straw seals the top so that if it does fall over, it does not leak.  I just wish OXO would make it with a plastic tip.
3601666
I've owned several of these, and if I rated after first purchasing, I would've given 5 stars.
One large problem occurs after heavy use- The lid insides are very hard to clean, where the rubber seal fits to the sip hole.  And after a year of use, the rubber starts disintegrating.
If it wasn't for the lid design being hard to clean and the rubber disintegrating, this cuip would be absolutely perfect.
4733304
I'm very pleased with the performance of the cleaner.  It is very easy to use and clean after.  My only negative is when I removed the lid from the dirty water tank the FIRST TIME, the rubber seal broke.  So far no leaking, but really??
582374
The stainless steel thermos is of quality and helps in keeping the food or water hot for several hours.  The only complaint is the inner plastic part of the lid peeled off from from the stainless part after the use of 1 years.  But I guess this could be fixed easily by a good glue.
591051
Works as described. My son was excited to add this to his Star Was collection. The only issue I have with it is that the hinge for the lid is too loose. When any bump or slight pressure is applied to the lid when open, it just pops right off the hinge. Its easy to put back on but it really shouldnt be snapping off in the first place.
213577
Fits perfectly, seal is great.  Less spills with this lid!
4225134
Actually I DO like it, or at least I did until the rubber gasket decided to detach from the inner part of the lid and disappear up inside it. Because of how complicated the lid is, there's no way to grab the gasket and pull it back down, so about 25% of the lid no longer forms a leakproof seal.

There's an easy way to see if this has happened to your bottle -- just fill it full of a liquid and then shake it back and forth vigorously as if you believe the bottle is still leakproof. If you spray the contents of the bottle all over your kitchen, office desk, gym, etc., you'll know the gasket has detached.