Incompatible with Otterbox commuter series.
925861
Rubber edge on face of Otterbox  keeps wedging under screen protector and lifting it up
1608774
I have had OtterBox Defender cases on my iPhones for the past three or four years. This one was a big disappointment because the screen protector does not lay flush with the phone glass. It is so annoying that I returned it for a refund. I could have removed the plastic altogether, but I don't feel like I should have to do that on a quality case. I don't know if OtterBox knows about this and doesn't care, or if this one was defective. I can't imagine anyone putting up with this. It makes using the phone more difficult and I can only imagine how dirty it would get once pocket dust made it's way into the 1/4 inch of space in between the phone screen and the plastic cover. This is a fail big time. It's a shame too, because the rest of the case felt like the heavy duty quality that I know and love in OtterBox cases.
4030410
I would like to add a picture to this item that is the most important photo when buying these iPhone cases. That would be the bottom of the case where you charge the iPhone. The charging part is not Dock compatible if your Dock is not adjustable vertically with the 8 pin connector as it is not completely open in that area so if using a fixed Dock you would not want this case. I went to YouTube and watched a video on this that actually showed this area which Otterbox does not. I can not find a place to insert a picture which would explain this better.
2234281
Having used Otter boxes for my phones almost from the first, I was very prepared to like this. Ordered it to use on tour with the Square; asked Otter if it was the correct item and was told "yes". So I'm sorry to report that:
1. It took two of us almost half an hour just to get the darned thing apart, and another half hour to get it on.
2. More important, once the Otter is on (and looks great btw), there's no way to fit anything into the headphone jack except a tiny earbud jack, defeating the whole purpose of using it with the Square.
I'm hoping they fix this, or at least come up with an adapter. Meanwhile, I've returned mine. Sad about it, because I like the protection.
4834172
Does not fit an IPhone 7plus with an Otterbox case (says in description it will).  Not eligible for return.
4854955
ORIGINAL REVIEW:  The teal Otterbox Defender looks really cool, but it's useless.  I followed the installation instructions from the Otterbox website and had no difficulties putting on the inner and outer cases.  But it's made my new iPhone 4S unusable.  As best I can tell, the flap covering the charging port interferes with the microphone.  People can't hear me, or I sound garbled, and eventually the call drops.  Didn't have this problem during the two days I used the phone without a cover.

Can't return the Otterbox because I didn't keep the packaging.  <dope slap>

SUBSEQUENT COMMENT:  I contacted Otterbox, and they immediately sent me a replacement.  That one had the same problem, so I just used a razorblade to cut off the cover flap of the charging port.  Problem solved.
4789136
The OtterBox Commuter case is a nice alternative to the bulky Defender series. It offers good protection from damage due to fumbles over hard surfaces.
But the unit I have has an annoying defect. The clear plastic that protects the screen is  inch too narrow and leaves a 1/8 inch gap between the side of the case and the edge of the plastic. This makes the process of swiping from side to side on the screen annoying and somewhat painful. I would expect a quality company like OtterBox to be able to make a product with closer tolerances.
4976855
Disappointed with otterbox defender for iPhone 6. Built-in screen protector is less than useless. Can't see the screen thru it; Renders finger print reader useless; Can't use swipe typing thru it. Finally removed and replaced it. Dust covers are misaligned and difficult to open. Finally cut these off so I could use my headphones and charger. Finally, the case is a little too big for the phone... it has room to rattle around inside the case so I padded it worth some gauze. For the price these cost, not worth it.
2949372
I really wanted to like this case, but I was forced to return it.  The materials used are solid.  Overall the case secures the iPhone; however, two flaws make it unusable.  The top of the hard plastic outer case needs to extend over the top of the phone to hold the outer case more securely.  The top of the case that I received did not extend over the top of the phone and as a result the upper right portion of the outer case warped outward by several millimeters.  More significantly, the bottom of the outer case does not extend over the bottom of the phone where the speakers, earphone jack and lightning port are located.  The soft inner case is terribly flimsy at the bottom and does not hug the phone.  There is nothing to keep the rubber in place and nothing to protect the phone if it is dropped.  This case needs an extension to the hard plastic outer case that wraps over the rubber inner case to protect the bottom of the phone.  They did a terrific job at designing the way the outer case hugs the inner case on both sides, but unfortunately, not on the top and bottom.  Every other aspect of this case is terrific and could be a real competitor in the market at nearly half the price of the market leader if the manufacturer fixes these flaws.
4020317
This cord will not work if you use an Otterbox Defender case on your iPhone. The plastic surrounding the plug in portion is too wide and you won't be able to plug in the phone without removing the case. BOO!
4389133
I bought this case because I've had great experiences with Otterbox Defender series for years.  However, after upgrading to an iPhone 6 Plus I opted to purchase an Otterbox Defender series case to protect my new phone and I was disappointed to learn that the screen protector on the case is raised (however slightly) above the phone screen making it difficult to use touchscreen.  When you press on the screen you hear a "pop" sound of the plastic being pressed.  Sometimes it registers your input, but not most.
Otterbox has brought us many wonderful products, but this issue needs to be addressed, as evident of the many reviews stating same issue.  One option I hope Otterbox considers is making the screen protector removable so you can use your own screen protector with their case.  And YES, they can do this if they are willing!  It'll show the public they are committed to addressing this issue and open a market to those who wouldn't otherwise purchase this product based on reviews such as this.
Again, Otterbox is a great product, but this one fell by the wayside.
1300543
Going from otter box defender to this commuter case in ink blue was such a big dissapointment in quality.

Both pieces of the case don't fit snug (pictures included). Tried for countless minutes to fix this defect on the edges not melding together right.

The screen protector was a joke. Just pick up another screen protector.
4200112
Screen protector seems ok but does not work with many cases to include otterbox commuter.  I need to find a case that will work but it appears options are limited. Screen cracked after only using it one week.
2748222
Doesn't work with an Otterbox Defender case! Never tried it without, so 1 star is all I know to give.
4253890
I purchased the protecotor to be used with my OtterBox Symmetry case.  The initial installation was fairly easy; however, once I tried to put the phone into the case, a significant bubble would appear somewhere.  I carefully took it out of the case, and tried over and over again.  Each time a significant bubble would appear in some spot.  After an hour, I have pretty much concluded this item simply can't be used with this particular case.  If the case touches the protector at any point, which is inevitable, a bubble instantly appears.  In hopes that I simply received a defective one, I'm going to exchange it for another.  I will provide a follow up when I receive my replacement.  For now, I would not recommend purchasing this item to be used with an OtterBox Symmetry case and likely many other well fitting cases.
683857
The write up says "made for Otter Box cases" then when you get the product you find out that it does not fit Defender or Preserver series OB cases. This should be clearly noted in the description.  Fooled me once, but I will not be ordering any phone accessories from Amazon again.
2331136
If you've got an OtterBox on your phone, you'll have to remove it to get this thing to plug in. Not practical.