If the boot fits, then it's a hit!
919618
I love my new boots. They fit perfectly and they go good with any outfit I wear! They also make great for wearing on the winter season, and you can wear them on the dance floor!
540972
Beautiful Boot!
As others commented this boot runs small. The 8 I ordered for my 8-sized foot hurt like heck when I put it on, but quickly relaxed and ALMOST fit.  I wore it around on the carpet for about an hour and after that I determined I  needed a half size larger, because there were pressure points that were not going to ease up.  I returned them and I just got my size 8 1/2.  Upon putting them on there was a little discomfort in the heel which immediately relaxed.  These fit much better, though maybe just a little loose at the heel, which will snug up once I put on thicker socks.  Lovely color and texture. The sweep of the arch and heel togetger look very sexy, as does that nice V-notch in front.  The perforations in the yoke add a very nice contrasting texture, and the soft fabric around the ankles is very comfy. I am not a western or cowgirl boot lover, but I did want a boot with a little hint of cowgirl in it, which these do! These boots look great and feel great!
1780278
I got these in the mail a couple of weeks ago, and while I haven't worn them out yet (it won't be "fall" here for about another two months), I have worn them around the house to make sure they fit and are comfortable, and I really, really like them! I am an exact 9.5 and I ordered a 9 as most other reviewers said they run a bit big, and they were right. I think a few others had commented to order up, but the 9 fits just fine...I even think I could wear some thick socks with them and still have some toe room. This is my first pair of FitFlop brand anything, but the "wobble board" sole is easy and comfortable to walk around in, and it's cleverly concealed in the design so it doesn't LOOK like a toning shoe. I don't kid myself expecting any super-great butt toning as a result, but I guess every little bit helps! The picture doesn't really do the shoe justice--the sole isn't as obvious in person as it is in the 3/4 view online. From the side, it's pretty incognito, or at least I think so. I think these are much cuter than Uggs since they are a bit more streamlined in fit.

The tops can either be folded down to show the shearling lining or left up, which I like very much. The best thing about these is that they still came most of the way up my calf--sometimes, "tall" boots and I have issues since I have very long legs. I am guessing on a shorter person (I'm 5'10") they would probably be knee-height, but they come to approximately two or three inches below my knee, which is fine with me--they don't cut my calf off at the middle, which is a very unfortunate look (I know from experience, sadly!).

I think these are going to be perfect with some skinny jeans, but would also look right with a corduroy or tweed skirt. The reason they don't get the full five stars is because the sides around the ankle are so soft, I am worried that they may get too soft and permanently crease there, causing them to droop or sag around that area. Also, as another reviewer noted, the sole isn't lined with shearling like an Ugg-type boot is, so you must always wear socks with these, but that's not really too big of an issue. All in all, I'm very pleased with my purchase.
4793446
When I received this boot and tried it on..I was surprised to see not only was it wide enough for my foot, but there was plenty of room for my calf...my calves are 18" wide.  Most of the time, I can't even zip up the boot, but these I was able to put them in and not only fit but fits a little too big...rather than sent them back, I bought some inserts for the shoe part to make them more fitted and that worked out well.  I was going to exchange them, but I would rather have them be a loose fit than fit with a zipper and having to squeeze my calves into it.  I would love it if you come out with an all stretch leather high healed boot as well.  i would certainly buy them.

Here's hoping for an all leather boot, with a wider foot and calf.  Great boot....looks great with my jeans tucked inside them.
2670249
I did months of research trying to find the right pair of knee boots. I'm only 5'3 so I have shorter legs but also have somewhat wider feet. A lot of the boots I tried were much too narrow in the foot bed and finding a boot with a wide foot but narrow shaft was quite difficult. I decided to purchase these boots as the styling of the boot shaft would allow me to have a cobbler cut it down if it was too tall. Indeed it is about half an inch too tall but I am hoping that with wear the leather will sink and soften, as any good real leather boot should. The foot bed fits rather well but I would say it is still a bit narrow for a size 9, feels more like an 8.5 (which may not seem like much of a difference but to me it is). I do wish that my boots looked more like the photo with stiffer, smoother leather in the shaft (it would have been easier to 'dress up'). However, these are much more worn-in and casual than the image depicts. Regardless, I still love these boots! I was surprised at the type of sole though, there is very little grip to them. They are wearing down pretty well though so I think that they will gain enough roughness to gather more traction soon. These are super comfy, all things considered, but do not have any type of cushioned sole inside (no biggie, I can buy my own inserts), just keep this in mind if standing or walking for long periods of time. Also, the circumference is a little larger than I would have liked for my narrow legs but the buckle on top helps draw the boot in a bit. It looks like I may even be able to punch an extra hole in it to gather it a tiny bit more. Overall, I am super pleased (and excited that my hubby let me splurge!) with these boots.
40664
I adore this purchase.  It looks fabulous on, and it was wearable for a long time even on the first day -- no break in period needed.

You can't see it in the picture, but there is a zipper on the inner side of this boot.  As a bonus, the laces are also adjustable, and it has a working tongue.
3316585
I should begin by stating that I received these boots overnight - even with 3 day shipping.  Thanks for the fast shipping - it was a pleasant surprise!

The unboxing:
I was nervous about this purchase, as buying shoes/boots without actually trying them on or seeing them in person is hit an miss.  As stated, they showed up at my door much sooner than expected, and I was not quite over my buyer's remorse, so I was afraid to open the box.

After waiting 20 minutes or so, and having a cup of tea, I decided to dive in.

The first thing I noticed when opening the box was the fine leather aroma, and the sheer weight of them (2 lbs!).  I took one out of the tissue, and took a good long look at it.

The structural seams are all double-sewn.  The strip of webbing that runs from the heel to the laces across the ankle is firmly attached, and the grommets do not go through the leather.  The tongue is fully attached to above the ankle bone, making these water proof up to 6 inches deep. The toe and heel leather is quite thick and rigid, making for possibly a longer breaking in period, but much longer wear.

The sole is a little strange - it almost looks pre-worn at the heel and sides of the foot.  I suspect this is by design, to prevent that 'new-boot catch' that can happen with lug soles.

The lacing down the back of the boot is purely decorative, although it could be cut and replaced with an actual lace for a customized fit - i am a little narrow through the ankles and could use the extra tightening to keep the boots snug around my ankle and lower calf.

Now for the fit:  These boots are true to size - I bought a size/size and a half up so I could wear super thick socks with them.  Perfect.  The insole is a little too willing to move around, and may end up being replaced with custom insoles.  The heel bracing rests a little too close to the bottom of my ankle bone for me - I will definitely want to break them in well before doing any extended walking/hiking with them, and driving for the first day or so felt strange.  Even with them laced VERY tightly the ankle is fairly supple, and so far no pressure or discomfort anywhere.

Overall I am extremely pleased with these boots - they are stylish and very well made.  An exceptional bargain, and a must buy for any tough girl's wardrobe.
663094
I ordered the Sequoia color in size 9.5 - Cole Haan tends to run a bit small on me so I size up 1/2 a size (I normally wear 9 in other brands).  The 9.5 fit perfectly.  The leather appears to be of high-quality, with an elastic fabric on the sides of the boot to ensure calf fit.  I have fairly wide calves and have trouble finding a zip-up boot that fits, so this was a huge plus to me.  The boot comes up to just below the knee and I think it will work great with jeans or a skirt and tights.  The sole is rubber, which helps with ice or slippery winter sidewalks.  My only slight negative is that the ankle and heel seem a bit loose and my heel slips a little when walking; likely a byproduct of being able to slip your foot in without a zipper.  Not enough to merit a return, but I may add heel cup insert to reduce the slippage.
112373
I am normally a size 7.5 regular, and I have 14.5" muscular calves. Based on the 120 reviews I read of this boot before I ordered it, I ordered a 6.5 Wide--a major departure for me, and I was nervous. Turns out, the foot fits very well, and it's maybe even a half size still too large, but they feel great, and it may be the way they are designed to fit. As for my calves,it was a tight squeeze over my bare naked legs the first couple of times I wore them, but I was able to stuff a pair of skinny jeans in them and still get them zipped with a little shoe-horn action with my finger; they are tight but comfortable over these jeans, and they've definitely stretched out some as other reviewers have mentioned. Overall, a great boot: the footbed feels well made, the leather is very nice, the look is beautiful and classic, and I'm in love. Good luck.
4836548
While this boot is cheaply made, it does look absolutely fabulous on! I was looking for a flat stylish boot that was somewhat flexible with good traction. The traction on the bottom is acceptable, I've seen better and worse. it does seem to flex a bit to allow for my foot to bend as needed. I try to buy footwear that feels like I'm walking barefoot, and this is as close to a stylish boot as I'm going to get. I wear a 10 normally, and the 11 fits me perfectly.  I might add, I am 5'10.5 and slim with a slightly narrow foot. I flip the tops down to cuff them just below the knee. LADIES..Amazon is offering FREE RETURNS..so what are you waiting for?
2590440
If you have larger sized feet like I do, you'll do well with these boots. My exact measured size is 10 1/2 wide, impossible to find, so I usually order up to 11. They had 10 in stock, and it looked round-toed so I took a chance. They fit just fine! And wide enough too which is my usual problem. Also I like that the shaft of the boot is not super wide as I find most boots to be--I'm not overweight, I just have big feet!
The weather has been unseasonably warm here in SC so I haven't had a chance to "road test" them, but for rather inexpensive boots I think they'll hold up for at least a couple of seasons.
153927
In my opinion, these are a little on the expensive size for a 9 year old who isn't even a 'cowboy'.  He just wanted them because his friend is a cowboy, and they seemed cool.  That said.  I would buy them over and over.

I have had adult women's western boots in the past that I spent less on, and they were nightmarish on my feet.  These boots, that I bought for my son are easy on and off because of the finger holes on the sides of the boot, true to size, soft and comfy to start, and make me wish I had a pair!

My daughter currently wears the same size, so I had her try on the boots to see if my son was just 'messing' with me about the quality for fear I would send them back :)!  She claims they are everything he says they are.

Now for a few specifics.  Both of them (my son and daughter) have true Medium width feet.  I'm not sure how the fit and feel would be if they were ordered for a child with a narrow or wide foot.  They are genuine leather, so I am sure there would be a little stretch.  The color we chose has the 'worn in' look which I really like because I do not have to be neurotic about scuffs and dust.

Worth the money and the happiness of my son.  I know, 'son happiness' is really not a reason to spend a lot of money! Ha!
1674429
A very nice-looking, quality boot. I wear a size 10 and they fit just right. I haven't worn them yet so I'm not sure how comfortable they will be. My guess is that they will be fine. My only complaint, and it is small, is that the top of the boot around the calf is a bit large for me -- maybe a 1/2 to 3/4-inch gap. I would say I have average-size calves for my height of 5'10". This isn't enough to make me want to send them back, though.
2444114
The boot is a bit different from what I already had but it is very similar. Also the fit is exact (although we thought it was going to be too small)! Very happy with the purchase!
1120299
I love these boots! They are so cute. I really feel great wearing them. The left boot fit perfectly, the right boot is still pretty tight after 3 wears. I think my right instep is higher. I stretched the boot with a jelly jar and that helps a bit. I think it will fit better and better after more and more wears it will fit more comfortably. The color is really cool and unique!
227484
These boots are SUPER CUTE and my 3.5 year old daughter had absolutely no trouble putting them on.  Like, I was worried about some of the reviews that mentioned they were difficult to put on, but these aren't remotely harder to put on than any other pair of boots that she has.

Note - she's only put them on with socks.  I could see how it wouldn't be as smooth without socks, but that would be true of any plastic/etc sort of boot.

Anyway, I've got no complaints.  The price is great.  Comfort too.  And looks-wise, they look right out of a 1950's children's story. So so cute!
1549051
Boot fits perfectly! Can wear with a trouser or heavy sock. Boot looks WAAAYYY better in person; have received many unexpected compliments. Fur is just for design; don't expect your foot to stay warm in the cold unless you are wearing a heavy sock. No fur in the foot of the boot. I guess I have narrow calfs because the boot does not fit snug to my leg, but that doesn't bother me because I can wear a boot cut regular jean and fit the excess material comfortably in the boot without it looking bulky. Would buy again if it came in different colors!