Nothing wrong with the shoe, it just is too ...
919786
Nothing wrong with the shoe, it just is too snug and we will need to return it for a larger size. Husband has worn this style and size before but something has changed. No biggie.
815587
The shoe is cut too short around the top of the toe, and along the side of the foot. It needs more coverage.
904336
My only issue I have is that the instep it's a little too high, it is uncomfortable to wear. It also causes me pain when in not wearing out it.
1578841
The leather is hard and stiff, they become uncomfortable after wearing them for a couple of hours. It's a well made shoe its just too bad they didn't use a softer leather.
2313525
I like the shoe very much.  iI seems to be comfortable and I would rate it highly if it fit.  The shoe size was too large.  I am hoping that I can return them for the next smaller size.  So far I have not heard back about this matter.
2536808
One shoe is too short, and the shoe looks very nice except that there is a strap across the ankle that is almost twice the size of the others and is not-adjustable.because it has no buckle.. So this looks very weird with this big oversized strap floating around.  Unless you have very large anklees this will not make you happy.  It also is not good for people with high arches.
2003578
The tongue pad of the shoe is too thin, resulting in uncomfortable pressure on top of my foot, even after the break-in.  The manufacturer should put a thicker tongue pad.  Otherwise, the shoe is reasonably well built.  I have not hiked yet.  more comments to follow later.
2181681
So the leather on the shoe is a comfortable and the look is nice but there is something strange with the heel.  It is I think 1) too tall and 2) too soft.  The reason I say this is I was fine walking in it until I got to the airport and had to walk the long walk to and from the plane.  it felt like I was almost going to roll my ankle which is not a great feeling.  I think if they decreased the heel by 1/4 or so inch and increased the hardness of the heel it would be a perfect shoe.  now I have invested in a shoe I have to give to Goodwill...
3007754
I need more of a rounded front and shoe is too narrow around the toe area.  The shoe itself is fine it is simply the shape in the front that is an issue for me
1437427
It's not that it's too small as much as the toe box isn't large enough.  The front of the shoe comes down too tightly causing the seam that goes over the top to come down onto the toes.
4875902
Not the right shoe for me, but it's a nice shoe. It's just that my feet are shaped so that these shoes keep feeling like they're going to slip off.
3967302
The shoe has a nice look to it, seems to be comfortable, and is reasonably priced. However, I'm dinging it a star or two due to the fact that it runs large.

I wear a size 10D and these shoes barely fit me.  I can wear them, but they are quite large for a 10D.  Wearing thicker socks helps a lot.

Would I be better off with a size 9.5D?  No idea, but they ought to make these shoes in a more standard sizing.

Otherwise, they seem like very good shoes, but again, I'm hitting their rating a bit due to the aforementioned sizing issues.
1492041
The width of the shoe fits fine, but it is a bit too long.
2567653
for me it is not as comfortable fit. It  is advertised as an athletic shoe but has little arch support.
2042108
I'm still a fan of Clark's but I guess this was just one shoe that I'm not too fond with. When looking at it in person, it looks like a pair of rubber shoes rather than leather. I also found that the fit is a bit too large.
4343017
As a few of the reviews state, the back of the shoe is too high, and digs into your skin.
3029930
There is nothing wrong with the item, but it was sent in the wrong box. The shoebox had my size on it but the shoes themselves were two sizes too small.