They do not sit comfortably around your ankle
938090
This shoe looks fabulous. My only pet peeve, which is a major one, is that the straps are too wide. They do not sit comfortably around your ankle. There was at least 3/4 inch of space between my ankle and the straps. I have not used it and may not use it at all because of that. May just give it away. Other than that the construction was well done, the shoe fit was true to size (size 7 for me) and the shoe felt very sturdy and of great quality overall. Really wanted to love this shoe.
1115623
The shoe sits low on the ankle, which can cause raw spots to form at the lower ankle, requiring band-aids.  Other than that, comfy.
3007940
Do not find these comfotable - expensive but not comfortable.
1800018
They feel good on the bottom of your feet. But I don't like that there are to wide on your ankles. They look too bulky
2034845
Unfortunately the areas around my ankle bones are too high and cause discomfort.  I'm hoping they will soften as I wear them more.
4276055
In general I wouldn't recommend these. The foam is very stiff, even after reguly (2-3 times per week) for 18 months, making some movements awkward. The design really limits movement at the ankle, and the piece that goes behind the heal tends to slip off.

The boots do give good protection for the tops of the feet and the ankles, but not so much better than other standard boot designs that it's worth it to me to lose the flexibility and range of movement.
1962076
It asks me to click on a choice from too small to too large, and I really don't know. I was unable to get my feet in them.

The ankle is stretchy, and I'd have to fight with them to get them on, but the harness around the ankle doesn't stretch at all, and it's just not big enough around to get my heel through it.

They look spiffy, and like they're solidly made, but if they won't go on my feet, they're useless to me.
2612707
These booties are soft and comfortable but they don't stay on unless I'm sitting still.  The ankle section is too big and there is no fastener/elastic to snug them onto your feet.
3804847
If you have an athletic build (smaller waist with larger legs), these do not fit well.
3338134
These boots are so wide in the ankle area it causes the boots to bunch up in the ankle area and are just extremely loose in the ankle.  Bummed because they were cute otherwise
419158
they are really cute on, but the part around the ankle hurts when you walk. I've let them all the way out and I don't have fat ankles, but I think it is just too high up, really hurts driving a car
2511903
I like these except they rub your ankles where the buckles are inside your boots.
243658
These are great for bed or in the house but do NOT wear them outside for more than a block of fast paced walking. They will fall to your ankles and you WILL be embarrassed.
2459697
These are a good quality but if you have large calves the tops are entirely too tight to be comfortable after a few hours. The shoe and ankle fit are appropriate, but as you move up the leg above ankle they are no where near as comfortable/wearable or sized as several other brands I have tried. Not the fault of the sock, but if you are short and stocky vs tall and skinny...  go bigger or look elsewhere
271841
They do not fit around the hips and waist properly.  Keep falling down.
3137214
Let me start by saying that I have other Dr Scholl's booties that are super comfortable. I purchased these because of my past experience with the brand. The color is a great warm brown. They look very well made. The biggest con for me is where the top of the boot hits my ankle. While the footbed of the shoe is very comfortable, the ankle part of these booties aren't very forgiving. They hit me at an awkward place and when I walk, they are uncomfortable because my ankle feels like it can't bend. It isn't so bad that I don't wear them but they are no where near as comfortable as other booties made by Dr. Scholl's.
4769477
Material is very cheap. Upon trying them on I found my ankle somewhat drowning in these adorable sandals. Was really hoping to wear these daily for work but found myself not even able to take one step in them.

If you do have a wider ankle these may fit wonderfully for you, but I unfortunately didn't have that luck!