Does the job, but the insole came loose very ...
921953
Does the job, but the insole came loose very quickly. Given the fact that it's in water, however 2 hours seem a bit too soon to come loose.
2595873
Would have given it 4/5 Stars. Shoes themselves are nice. But the insoles leave one wanting. Very thin, flimsy and not much support. So again, they  could do ALOT better for the insoles. Not enough cushioning and you would need to get new ones with good support. For memory foam insoles they are almost paper thin.
1686584
Super cute and easy to get on and off. Took a star off because the Insoles came apart and I had to glue them back together
2568529
These shoes are okay. They definitely fit too large (I bought a six and was actually worried they might be too tight). They definitely need insoles and are somewhat cheaply made. The shoe itself is adorable and holds well enough, I'm just worried it'll fall apart from walking.
2348855
Insoles do not stay in place, only wore once so far for few minutes.  Would need to reglue insoles if going to wear again.
3766641
Fits true to size, and looks cute.  However the insoles detached themselves from the shoes within an hour of my putting them on.
206556
They do their job. One of the pairs kept slipping off, but I think it was a one-off case. These are bigger than expected though, there is excess sock coming above the shoe, even though I have a size 11 foot.
1378628
Overall does the job, my foot does comenout after a while as there is no strap to support the back of the foot so naturally my foot slides out(cause one of the pins to bend too).
4696908
For the price, very good shoe. The insole did not last too long though. But I also do a lot of walking for work. But for the price, they did there job.
2452864
The insole came unglued after an hour. Than it would keep rolling around under the feet and became uncomfortable, so had to remove the insole and use it without for the rest of the trip. Discarded it after the first use.

Good as a disposable item I suppose.
2457186
When I received the shoes, they looked decent enough. It won't turn any heads; it's not handsome enough to stand out as an expensive-looking pair of shoes, but it won't stand out as a pair of cheap discount store shoes either. Unfortunately, the quality is that of a pair of cheap discount store shoes.

The shoes arrived with a nick on the tongue of one of the shoes - a 2mm torn flap of leather. Whether it's damage in the warehouse, during shipping or off the assembly line, I don't know. But it may speak toward the shoe's durability. I should point out that a delivery guy ran his bike over my foot the first day I had the shoes on and the shoe came out just fine. Next, I noticed the insoles were completely separated from the bottom of the shoe. They don't look like they are meant to be removable, since there is a big, uneven splotch of dried, no-longer-adhesive glue that was supposed to keep the insole in place.

The sizing is a bit larger than the Bostonian shoes I am used to, but it's close enough such that a thicker pair of socks makes up for it. The insole feels fine at first, but after walking for 15 minutes and it flattens out, you realize the cushioning is temporary. At least the dried glue means you can replace the insoles easily. Heh. After about an hour or so in the shoes, the top of my heel started to blister.

At full price, it's not worth it. But I got it at one-third of the regular price. This makes it worth the effort to get new insoles to give it another shot.
1540558
This shoe is comfortable. I bought it to work in and have been wearing them five days a week since may 7th. The reason for the single star is the insole is already starting to come apart.
4504914
The insole came out easily, got all bunched up. Pulled it out and wore them without it. Really comfortable, good value
4767104
I normally wear size 10 women's shoes. These were the right size.  I wore these for a 4 day weekend at a lake in New Mexico.  They worked well to protect my feet from rocks when I went in the water.  However, they filled with sand quickly and I had to keep removing them to dump and rinse it all out.  The light foam inserts look like they were glued in but they came loose the first time they got wet.  It's not necessarily a bad thing because it makes it easier to get all the sand out from under them.  Other than that the construction held together just fine.  I will probably use them until they tear and then look for higher quality replacements.
4875310
I had to replace the insole because it was too flat. It seems to me that shoes in the hundred dollar range would be available with a choice of arch support.
740808
I love the way these fit, but  was not happy when my 2nd pair arrived with the sole completely loose.  I just glued it down, but these are not inexpensive shoes and that is a quality check issue.  It was obvious because the whole insole just fell out.  But the fit is amazing.  I hope the construction holds up and the poor quality was an anomaly.
973880
Lost a star from its rating due to the insole wearing out under the ball of the foot before the first 100 miles!