Good quality, but there are two buttons on the collar that make this look weird
922443
I love the quality of this sweatshirt, but there are two buttons and a little strap near the collar that you can't really see in the pictures.  If you leave it unzipped like in the pictures, then the strap just kinda hangs near your neck.  It's just kind of weird looking.
4616114
Great quality, but side buttons seem loose and jiggle. Otherwise, fits nicely on my iPhone 6s that I've already dropped a couple times. So far it seems to add a nice layer of protection for my phone.
543821
This collar is great quality, but it's pretty heavy and thick. I guess I should have expected that with it being genuine leather, but it did surprise me. It has held up very well and is working great for our fur baby.
3013370
I love the shirt and how it fits but I wish it would be two buttons in the front instead of three.
2686340
Very nice vest. Quality is great. I love everything about it EXCEPT the buttons. The picture shows dark bronze buttons and snaps but the one I received has super cheap shiny plastic gold buttons. Makes it look cheap. I am going to try and distress the buttons myself or change them out. I love the vest, just not the buttons.
744483
The light grey collar with the dark grey body to the coat, makes this pop. Wear a light/dark grey or black hat; and you have a nice, well dressed ensemble. CONS: Sleeves had to be hemmed, as they were unusually long.  Threading for the buttons should have been a LOT stronger at the factory. If you have a shop hem the sleeves, a wise idea would be to have the buttons re-enforced, as well. PROS: Excellent material, craftsmanship, and with a few alterations, will look like you paid 3 or more times the price. If you prefer to wear a suit-jacket, blazer or sweater underneath, as I do; then the sizing is fine. All tolled, for the price, this product is a very good deal. Cheers.
4262830
Its not all bad: this is a really warm and comfortable jacket, much moreso than I expected.  It zips all the way up from about the lowest buttons, and it feels layered and definitely keeps you snug and warm.

That being said, its got what I'd say is a pretty aggressive big collar, and its like, a really strong light grey.  I don't know a ton about the fashion or style its supposed to express or what have you, but I felt like I was making a bit of a statement wearing it in NY.  I dealt though, because I was very warm and it felt good.  Plus the pockets are absolutely on point.

It got a lot worse though.  The buttons really have left me asking some questions about the quality of manufacturing here.  From day one I was worried they weren't too durable, and then today, one of the buttons by my left shoulder/pec that pins the collar down inexplicably came off.  For some context, I only got this jacket on December 5th, all of 13 days ago.  Pretty disappointed, and not even going to try and return it because according to other reviewers its just the worst and really expensive.
3545706
I really want to give this a higher review. The shirt looks nice and is comfortable... with one pretty notable exception. Why on earth wouldn't you adjust the buttons and neck based on the size of the shirt? When I button the second button, the diameter of the neck line is nearly as small as any of my other polo shirts with the top button closed. The result is that it wants to lift the collar points up. It is a flaw in an otherwise great shirt.
355421
nice quality button on top is a little loose however over all I'd say that its of good quality!
2712983
I was a little disappointed that the buttons were just regular buttons and not typical pea coat buttons with an anchor. Otherwise, it's a great coat.
3030641
The quality is very good.  Appearance is classy.  BUT -- the stiff rubber covers the volume and on/off switch making it difficult to push the buttons. Since the phone goes to sleep mode a lot to save power, it means I hit on/off button A LOT.  I was determined to use it so I cut out the area around the buttons and it works just fine now.  Would have rated it a 5 if not for the dumb design that took time to work around.
828549
This is a nice shirt.  The sleeves are fairly long, which is fine.  The one thing that my husband didn't like was that there are only two buttons.  He likes to leave the top button undone and when he did this the shirt opened up and exposed too much of his chest (he does not like undershirts).  Would be much better with three buttons.  He really likes Columbia, but was somewhat disappointed in this only because he has to return it.  Returning and will look at other Columbia polo shirts.
4524654
i like this vest but the collar is weird.  i have a short neck and it just gets in the way of my hair.  makes me look like a turtle who has not fully extended his neck!!!  i'm going to do surgery on this and try and get rid of the floppy collar.  love the hood though.
4534532
There are buttons that cant really be seen in the picture :/ Disappointed with that and the design/cut of the shirt. The material is nice though!
4364227
Honestly, I wouldn't buy this top again, for the sole reason that I don't like that the navy and red pinstripes show when worn - the collar naturally lays open, if you leave the first button unbuttoned, and the stripes show. If you don't mind that, though, this is a good quality shirt. Good quality, breathable fabric, washes well, no stains visible after a summer's worth of weekly washings. I got the juniors-size version for myself, and my daughter and I have fun wearing matching shirts. The cut runs slim. I had to exchange both for larger sizes.
3968630
I first ordered this one, and when it arrived, it had three spots of white...  closer looking and it was loops of white thread at those spots...  hastily added? as they seem to be unwraveling...  but I checked the picture online and it had them too on two of their shirt varieties...  I'd have loved another inch extra length on the buttons and collar, but it does fit nicely...
3553553
Okay, so this shirt IS comfortable, but I have two main problems with them.

1) I ordered a large thinking these are made to fit snuggly (my chest is about a 44 right now. Large is 42-44). And I'm realising I should've bought the medium size since it is very stretchy and doesn't feel tight in the slightest.

2) The natural neckline in the collar goes too low and plainly shows through my shirt even though the sand color one matches my skin tone almost perfectly. If I readjust the collar up higher and allow it to go down further on my back, it looks better and it seems to disappear.

I would recommend trying out the ALBERT KRUEZ men's invisible sleeveless shirt as that has a better collar and being that it's sleeveless, you never have to worry about wearing it underneath a t-shirt or short-sleeved button-front /button-up shirt.

(Fun fact: button-down shirts are actually the ones that have the buttoned collars)