I love these shoes...but
928405
This is my second pair of Gel-Kayano 19.  They are very cushioned in my opinion and I love that, but my first pair got little holes in the inside of the heels that caused blisters on my heels.  I am hoping that was a fluke and that won't happen with my new pair.  I usually run between 4 or 6 miles, 4 days a week, and my feet appreciate these cushioned shoes.  I have been running for 17 years and these have been my favorite shoes so far and I have bought hundreds of different brands and styles. Do not hesitate trying these for your run, walk, or just getting around.
3132595
I love love these shoes.. if these shoes were any more comfortable it would be a crime.. super model of shoes - Clarks Oxford are going to take Rockport out of business. OMG I, want to buy another pair of these but I have only had them for a day.
2290988
I love them and I am disappointed at the same time. I first ordered these sandals in a 7 and 7.5.  I'm usually a size 7, spot on.  But, I knew with summer heat and painted toe nails, I might want a little extra wiggle room.  The 7.5 is the right fit and even a little snug around the toes.  I LOVE them, when they stay on.  My heel is just not the right shape to keep the strap on for more than a few yards.  I have tried tightening the heel strap and it has nice elastic, too. The sandals are super cushy insoles and if the heel strap would stay on, I think I could wear these all day.  But, since I already wore them outside and got the soles dirty, I feel like I own them.  Even though I ordered both sizes and both sizes were said to have come in the same shipment, the size 7 did not arrive in the shipment .  I was able to stop it being shipped when I realized the error, as the 7.5 was the right fit.  However, I did not realize until I wore them outside that my heel just is too flat to hold a grip on these sandals.
1031031
I love, love, love these shoes! They are really cute and the size is perfect! I normally compare sizes with popular brands but I rarely wear heels. I wear a 6.5 or 7 and I ordered a 6.5 and the size is perfect. It's not too big that causes rubbing and we know what happens then. Blisters...

As I said, I rarely wear heels. You can always find me in flats or tennis shoes. So I wore these today at school/work. I work at the university I attended and I run errands, so I walk around a lot. The shoes are very comfortable, however they can be slick on certain tiles. My face almost met the floor when leaving my house this morning.

**UPDATE**
I've worn these shoes three times already and the rubber sole is starting to come apart, on both shoes! Ugh! Very disappointed...
1007701
I watched these shoes hoping to get them for at least a year.  I love them.  They are more narrow than my other OTBT shoes and my feet are trying to stretch them to fit.  I'll probably break down and have a shoemaker help me with that.. I love them though
135178
I love these shoes! I bought them for my wedding and chose size 9.5 after doing tons of research on how this brand fits true to size. The advice I got was to get a half size too big - I'm regularly a size 9. I got the shoes and fell in love with them, but after a few weeks I realized that I'd probably fit into a size 9 more comfortably, since my heels were slightly slipping out of the shoes as I walked in them. So I returned these for the same shoe in the proper size, and I love them!
1255270
I love the look of these shoes,  but they destroy the sides of my feet.  Perhaps I just have wide feet...  But I can't wear them for more than a few hours without developing blisters.  I love aerosoles because they tend to last,  and get more comfortable with wear.  I haven't managed to break these in,  as I've only worn them twice.
2801236
I LOVE these shoes....however, I had to return them because the strap was very uncomfortable. I was extremely disappointed because I looked around for a long time for the perfect summer wedge, and this was my favorite.
188220
Don't get me wrong, I love these shoes. They are incredibly light and they make me stand out anywhere. However, if I wear them for several hours at a time, then I begin to have some comfort issues. Nothing major, but I become very aware of the arch and I end up wanting to take them off. Overall, I'm very pleased with these shoes despite my minor comfort issues.
4395717
I really really want to love these shoes, but I have wide feet and they kill my feet. It honestly breaks my heart because I bought these for a very special occasion when money was tight (college graduation). I got a $5 dress at the thrift store and thought I'd splurge on the shoes. I looked super cute, but my toes turned a scary dark red. I stretched the band that goes across the toes and that helps a little, but I'll probably still never be able to wear them again. But I won't give up on Steve Madden, I love this brand!! And these shoes are so freaking cute, I guess I just should never order shoes online again though.
2226465
I love these shoes and get lots of compliments when I wear them. They are made of a stiff canvas.  I wear a size 11 and was a little worried about the way the shoe would fit. My foot is slightly wide so sometimes a b width fits to snug not the case with these. I would buy others colors if it were possible. Did I say I love these shoes
3684980
I love these shoes!  They are super comfortable and stylish.  My only issues are they are hard to keep clean due to the light suede color and the laces are positioned where I can't tighten the shoe enough.  This last issue is both a positive and negative....the shoes are lose fitting but this adds to the comfort factor as long as you do not need them to be super secure.  Also, they do run at least a size bigger than normal.
130580
Love these shoes - my absolute favorite. Too bad I wear them out in 3 months with the mileage that I put on them :(
1343870
I love the way these shoes look.  I actually own 3 pairs of Irregular Choice shoes, and I will likely buy more.  The quality of Irrregular Choice is high.  These uppers are leather, not plastic.  They are not hard as they appear to be in the photo, and conform to the foot

Narrow heel women, beware - they are a bit wide in that area.  However, they are true to size.

Unfortunately, I have a problem with front of the shoe.  It is, just as the picture shows, very straight across.  As time passes, the shoes begin to cause pain in the toes.  They cannot be worn the entire day and cannot be worn if standing up for long periods of time.  Going out to dinner or to a few-hours event, though, they should not be a problem.
2943462
i love these shoes but when i took them out of the box and was ready to try them on they were a little tight on top the length was fine, it was just on the stretchy bands they have on the sides, so i would recommend to wear these with thin socks..really thin..overall i really love them , but i guess i just have to break them in or maybe my feet might be the problem...
3928934
Love them...too soon to give 5 stars, need to break them in
1272458
I LOVE these shoes, but I had to return them to this seller, and go buy them elsewhere as they were too large.