Great shoes, misleading color
930080
I love Jack Rogers and have a few pairs so I'm familiar with the size and feel of the shoes. I generally go a half size up. The only problem I had with this order is that the color was misleading. I thought these would be very light and bright, but they're actually quite subdued and a lot darker than the photo. I still like them, but would have definitely liked the lighter color as pictured better.
4465173
I really like the shoes from a fit and comfort perspective.  My complaint is with the red/construction-zone-orange-cone color.  The orange area near the collar of the show is bright neon-orange.
3605439
Love these shoes. Sized up 1/2 size and they fit perfectly.  They sent the wrong color!
669461
Great pair of shoes out of the box, however, I just can't get over the color.  I purchased the Iguana Green/Black/Seaweed Green, which from the product photo, appears to be more of a tan than a OD green.  Hopefully the attached picture will help future buyers.

I will be purchasing the same style in a different color!
3407495
These shoes are extremely comfortable.  However, I would describe these as more pink than orange.  If these were more orange I would give 5 stars.
4615888
The shoes are gorgeous and I received many compliments on them throughout my work day.  I sit most of the day so they are comfortable enough but I can tell if I was on my feet a lot they would not be my first choice for comfort.  Rubber soles provide nice traction outside and on slippery flooring.

I didn't give 4 or 5 stars due to the color.  The picture clearly shows a pair of black and white shoes.  These are black and soft pink. I was VERY disappointed when I opened the box.  I very nearly returned them.  Luckily they went over well or else they would have for sure.  I still have severe limitations on outfits I can wear them with because I'm not much of a pink person.  Seriously, Hot Chocolate, update your photos!!!!
436936
I thought from the picture that the shoes were black with baby blue on the inside lining; I guess I wasn't paying a lot of attention to the description, as I had been looking at several different pairs.  I was going to return them, but was in desperate need of tennis shoes, so I decided to keep them anyway-- not that they're ugly, I just usually go for black or brown shoes.  They are quite comfortable and fit as I expected!
362207
The shoes shipped on time and were well packed. The fit is good the only gripe I have is the color. The color of the shoes I received is not even close to the corresponding picture on the Amazon site. Since I plan on ordering another pair similar to these I decided to keep them. Beware of the Sahara coloring on the web site the shoe is significantly lighter like sand on the dessert.
3504357
Correct size given and the shoes are very comfortable. However, the color is not as I expected it to be. I hoped it was a bit darker.
39081
True to size (keep in mind, they're leather and they'll stretch out a little. Use a shoe horn the first few times you wear them and you'll be fine).
The color of these 'tan' loafers is much lighter and redder than it appears online. The HTML color code 'Mahogany' (Google #C04000) seems to match these shoes the best.
I was hoping they'd be darker, so I bought the Sambra Brown model instead. Those fit my needs much better.
That being said, the styling of these shoes is great.
2841463
These shoes are sexy and fit correctly per the size chart (according to the length of you foot). My only complaint is that the color was different than the picture. The picture looks much lighter, almost pink in color. My shoes are basically tan. I was hoping the'd be pinkish like the picture, but it's ok, I'll wear them.
4663170
Love the shoes, very confortable. The only issue that I have is that I ordered them in black and I got a greenish grey. The picture looks black but the actual shoe is not.  I kept them because I can use that color but I wish they would've been black.
4392440
Excellent shoes, but the color is not true to the picture - it is much lighter and looks a bit cheap. I wish the color was as shown on the pic.
Also, because of inner-lining, the shoes are too warm for all day indoor use. (I'd describe it as an urban winter show.)
1149251
I love these shoes but my only complaint is that they say they are Navy Blue but believe me they are BLACK &  white.  Disappointed as I already have the black ones and it was too late for the purpose I needed them for.
233180
These shoes are very comfortable.  I am a little disappointed in the color....I thought they would be gray, but they are actually more silver.  Guess Im going to have join that Silver Sneakers program Ive been avoiding!
1636396
The shoes are beautiful and the sizing is true to fit. My issue is with the color of the of the shoe. It is not black and gold like in the picture above! The sandals are black and silver. I uploaded a picture.

*Edit*  4/19/15
Amazon updated the image. The current picture (black and silver) is accurate.
292165
Very nice shoes, fit as expected, but I have another pair (I believe from same manufacturer) called salmon color which is virtually identical. I don't need two pair so similar in color. Wish they were actually pink.