A great shoe for the price
936304
I confess to being a shoe challenge. I have flat feet and bunions, and some knee issues, like a large runner, but don't weigh a lot and tend do distances from two-milers to half-marathons at varying speeds. It is hard for me to find a decent shoe. I have had some luck with Asics in the past, the old GEL-Foundations and GT-2170, but of course once you get used to a certain shoe they tend to discontinue it. While I was on vacation recently I visited a shoe store and was trying on various shoes. If you are runner you know when a shoe is right or wrong from the instant you put your foot down in it; when the shoe is right it seems like there should be a beam of light shining down accompanied by a heavenly chorus. Putting my feet in the GEL-Exalt was like that. I was a little skeptical because they were a lot cheaper than some of the other Asics running shoes, but these felt so good on my feet that I decided to give them a chance.
Later that same day I took them on a short, easy run of about 4 miles and they felt perfect, like they were already broken in. Over the next week I increased the distance of my runs and at no time did my feet or knees hurt. I liked them so much I decided to order a second pair from Amazon just to keep on hand for when I wear out my first pair. I ordered the black/silver/red shoe which even more affordable than my original pair. For the record I am more concerned about how a shoe fits and feels, not how it looks.
Like I mentioned before, I don't have typical feet, but for the runner with flat feet who needs some support accompanied by a bit of cushioning, these just might be the shoes for you. For me this shoe ran true-to-size.
For the price you can't beat the GEL-Exalt running shoe, they offer good support and cushioning and look great, like a much more expensive shoe.
529711
These shoes are a great value for the price, they are constructed well, the sole is like a shoe and not a slipper so you can wear these all day and walk comfortably without the heel rubbing.
4618085
I purchased the J&M Melton's five months ago.  For the price they are one of the better dress shoes available.

I purchased in my typical size, 11D, and they fit as expected.  When compared to Allen Edmonds shoes like the Strand that I own the fit is very similar.  Also good quality of the leather and the craftsmanship.  The classic cap toe will never go out of style.  The biggest plus for these shoes is that they have a lot of the qualities you would expect in a much more expensive shoe for less than half of the price.

A few things to note:
The other reviewers are correct that these shoes will take some breaking in.  They are much stiffer than Allen Edmonds.  I don't wear these shoes all that often (probably once every other week) and there is still some work to do.

The leather is very shiny.  This could be a pro or con depending on what you are looking for.  For me they would look odd to wear with anything other than a suit.  Not great for jeans or chinos.  But on the positive side they are formal enough that you could rock them with a tux if needed and they would not appear out of place.

Overall, these are a good quality shoe for the price.  I would recommend to anyone that they spend their money on these rather than buying a cheaper throwaway shoe (and they don't want to drop over $300 on the AE Park Aves).
483126
I love these shoes.  They are very very nice for the price.
2746036
I bought this shoe at a great price and have been very happy with the purchase.  Now it is even cheaper and I will buy another pair and be even happier!
3967738
Excellent shoe for the price. My feet are comfortable and well supported. I would buy them again as well as recommend them to family.
890375
It's a great shoe for the price, so far. I've probably put about 100 miles into them, in some pretty stressful running conditions. They've been holding up well and keeping they're shape. They're size is consistent with other New Balance shoes. For the price, the shoes have performed as expected.
190739
I love the look and comfort of these shoes. A great value.
97613
A great shoe for the price, though it feels like a few trips to the dance floor would be the extent of use.  I'm good with that.
3995125
Great shoes for the price! Very comfortable for walking.
131957
I like this shoe not only for its style and comfort, but for the fact that it has a nice grip on the sole. I don't like a shoe that make alot of noise when walking. Nice shoe for the price.
3946512
Great shoe for the price and very comfortable to wear all day.
2572601
Great shoe for the price.  I used to always be a solid 9.  As I get older I find that a 9.5 is a better fit.  This shoe is a nice solid forest green patent leather (not sure it's actually leather) but the price is right and the shoe is comfortable.
3716661
I really love these shoes. They're comfortable and appear to withhold wear and tear well. My only issue was they looked slightly different than the picture; however, for the price I can not complain. They are a good deal.
2676503
For the price it is hard to find fault with these shoes for their intended purpose. I will buy another pair as long as they hold up reasonably well over time.
351923
Great shoe for the price. The shoes fits just as expected. I would recommend these to a friend. Now I need to get a black pair.
4663291
Shoe is a good value, very comfortable, good looking, and fits as expected.
It is lightweight but has good cushion and support.