7.5 fit me just fine, though soles showed signs of wear.
922508
I was slightly worried about fit, but decided to go with my regular side of 7.5. I noticed most everyone with size 7.5 said the shoes fit fine, and everyone else with sizes larger said they were too small. I rated this 4 stars because the soles are slightly worn, like someone had walked around in these already.
2068424
Based on other reviews, I was afraid they wouldn't fit, but they did fit just about right- if anything, just a bit on the larger side, but that's a good thing.  I thought the leather was a little stiff, but that's normal with a brand new pair of shoes.  The insole felt comfortable and provided more arch support than it looked like it was going to- the insoles appear very flat looking. I did have to return them because the heel on the left shoe was somehow collapsed below the insole, so it felt like my left heel was sunken lower than the rest of the shoe, which it was.  I am in the process of reordering another pair now.
1618597
I wear a 6.5 and have a narrow foot. Ordered the size 7 but was just too wide all the way around. Even tried putting the sloggers insert inside but was still too wide for me, fit sloppy. I didn't want to wear a thick sock either.  So I ordered the 6 and without additional insert that they suggest, the fit is just fine. Was a little short at the beginning, but just wearing them around the house for awhile, length has stretched. The heel still slips a little, but not an issue especially in the ankle boots. Non slip grip bottoms are great and they are comfortable. I would suggest if you are 1/2 size and have a narrow foot to size down, rather than up as suggested, it worked for me.
4742509
Nice shoes,  they should work just fine for what I'm using them for. They are a tad large....I usually wear 6.5 to 7 and the 7's seem almost like 7.5.  It isn't too bad though, and they are still very wearable.
2429848
It is quite possible that  7.5 is a better fit for me than the 8 I ordered The shoes are very comfortable but feel a bit loose on my feet..
753849
These fit great. I got 7.5 and that's my regular size. A bit wide in the toe box, but I have fairly narrow feet, and it's not a big deal. I really like the padding at the back of the heel. I can see myself ordering these in another color...or two ;).
3769057
Overall, great. The instep was just a little higher than what I'm used to. I've worn for a week or so and already getting broken in just fine :)
3093713
I wear size 7, so it was expected they'd be on the larger size
2309323
Looking for a new pair today. I've had the old ones about 10 years now, give or take. They are still wearable but the soles are starting to crack up and break apart. In street shoes or tennis shoes I wear a 10EE, but these are 10M and fit just fine. They don't smell too bad yet. I'll make up my mind in a little bit-- haven't finished shopping yet.
4325790
They fit as expected. I wear a 7 med width and they fit me just fine.
3183907
Probably a half size too big. I really like these, though the soles are a little cheap.
3357921
I normally wear a size 7 and they were a little short.  I did exchange them for a 7.5 and they are fine.  I haven't gone walking in them yet, but they feel fine when I tried them on.
2687198
They fitted a little larger than expected but they are fine. I do like them just as my old pair.
1887231
While the fit was somewhat a little large, it was not a big deal or an issue after one or two wears. I wear shoe size 9.5 and ordered size 8.5; I could have ordered a size 8 for a perfect fit.
3316965
Fit fine, Not as comfortable as my old, broken in, Crocs from 5 years ago, but I have hope for them.
499262
they fit and feel fine for me, a little snug on the width but then I usually wear a 4E width, think they will be better with age.
4839598
Fit was fine,  I am 10.5 and 44 fits perfectly.  The style is not ideal but the comfort and quality is there.