... are a clog and very different than my other favorite Ariats. The shoe is dark but I can't ...
933080
These are a clog and very different than my other favorite Ariats.  The shoe is dark but I can't wear with black suits/slacks, too much brown.
4906116
I have 9 pairs of Frye boots and on a comfort level these rank in the top 2 as far as immediately feeling amazingly comfortable on my feet. The leather is so soft and supple. However, as far the shape and style goes, these are the ugliest shoes I have ever tried on. I'm sure it has more to do with my personal style preference than any design error made on Frye's part. I have seen images online of women in these shoes and they look so adorable but on me they look like bulky dutch clogs. It was just weird looking. The color (grey soft vintage leather) was exactly as it appears on the listing, a sort of grayish purpley taupe, which is okay looking. Hated to have to return them, because when I am not looking at the shoes, they feel awesome. :(
2230231
I was very pleased overall with this shoe.  However, beware that the professional clog and the Mary Jane fit very differently.  I wish there were a wide.  But the leather does stretch some.  I love them anyway, have continued wearing them and they are now almost as comfortable as my clogs!  I really like the color, too!
3131032
This boot is really SO DIFFERENT from what it appears to be in the illustration! The sole is not cut to fit the boot lower, it is Over sized. The color is NOT AS DEFINED as they make it appear.  Other than that the boots are  comfortable & I will keep them.
About 1 week prior to making this purchase I bought a pair of Giorgio Brutini Boots which I Absolutely LOVE!! I was impressed
w/ the color variation of the Dr Scholls Mens Landon boot so I got them too.

With that said,  Buy them if ya think you'll like them & Good luck!
955127
The boot is soft leather, tall and is basically as expected. It is about 1/2 size too large and there is no half size in this boot that would fit me, so I chose a size up. The black color is a soft black more like charcoal. I bought it for the flat heal and because I wanted a tall leather boot that I could wear with skirts. It works fine for me.
511509
I ordered the dark brown, which are shown in the picture with brown decorative stitching.  The boots I received have very light tan stitching that really contrasts with the leather.  I'm still on the fence as to whether I care for this look.  Other than that, they were extremely difficult to get on.  I had to resort to the plastic bag trick, which I used before with success on my Frye Melissa buttons.  Once on, the footbed seems true to size (8).  The leather is very stiff, but as I wore them around the house, they seemed to soften up a tiny bit.  The toe rounds up which creates a rolling gait.  They are pretty comfortable, and I suspect will get much more so with more breaking in.  I'm going to wear them around the house more tonight and decide if it seems like they will break in enough, plus make a decision on the stitching issue.  So, the jury is still out, hence the 3 stars!
4606281
I bought a pair of these boots from Nordstrom Rack and loved them. I liked them so much that i bought a second pair on Amazon. The pair i bought on Amazon were smaller length and width and the peanut color was totally different as well. Its like they were made from 2 different shoe companies. They were still nice boots but didn't fit me as well and the distressed color wasn't there either.
3909046
Normally, I'm a size 6.5 in boots but I ordered a size 6 for these and they fit perfectly including if I wear thick socks for the winter. It takes a few days to break in but after that they're pretty comfortable. I ordered the boots in black and I don't like how it turns all my socks black! It's gross so now I have to only wear dark socks to avoid ruining my other socks. With this price, I'm disappointed.. Also the boots are pretty heavy. I need to walk from the subway to work and after 10 minutes, damn am I tired! These are so HEAVY. But since the leather seems to be good quality and will last a long time, and I like the height of the heel. The pros outweigh the cons and I like how they're made in the USA!
924538
They look good, but not the square toe I was expected like my other pair. They aren't pointy and they aren't rounded, they are more of a rounded square toe. The inside of the boot is very comfortable. The leather seems very soft. Nice to look at, but I'm curious what they will look like after a couple of weeks of riding.
2074235
This is a big disappointment because the rubber on top of the left shoe is different from the rubber on top of the right shoe. This makes the left shoe look strange. Also the material is stiff and rubs against my skin. I hope that I can get used them. Truthfully I regret buying them.  I already purchased 6 pairs of leather beetle boots in black, gray and brown suede and the leather is soft and the shoes the most comfy that Ive had.
4160026
I wanted these boots because they are dark in color. I received them today and they are almost a completely different color. There is no color difference on the different textures. Same color throughout the boot.
4712369
This shoe is not nearly as comfortable as the same shoe in black.
3842504
The Ariat Women's Heritage Western J-Toe Boots were disappointing when I tried them on, and I ended up returning them.  The sassy brown color is an excellent choice because it works well with lots of different outfits (even a black skirt), but I found the boots uncomfortable and I did not like the way that they looked.  I have tried on a number of different Ariat boots (including the square toe Legend and the Rhinestone Cowgirl boots), and have found all of them to be very comfortable.  Unfortunately, the seam on these boots pinched me in the ankle and I could barely walk in them.  It might have been a defect in the particular pair of boots that I tried out, but they were definitely uncomfortable.  I also did not like the style of the boots because they are very long due to the point of the J-Toe.  The style of the toe on the boots adds a lot of length, and even though I wear a size 6.5 which fit me fine, the boots looked enormous.  I thought that I was being just overly critical, but when I showed my sister the boots, she also made the same comment (without any prompting from me).

These boots do have a nice "western" style to them, but the length and fit leaves something to be desired.  I ended up purchasing and keeping the Legend boot with the square toe, which was much more comfortable.
1186264
There's something rather odd about this shoe that I could not just put my finger on. It's okay size-wise, and comfort-wise. But when I tried it on, and walked on it, I find it a wee bit wobbly for me. I don't know if it's the platform, or the the heel was too wide that it kept falling off... I feel as if I were walking on clogs...
2555323
This clog is very unique with the floral  upper .  It is a size 39. Fit is smaller than the black one in same size.  Algeria shoes are the most comfortable for my foot problems. The clogs have a removable  foot bed to accommodate my orthotics.
1605774
sole of shoe is hard plastic, arch isn't as high as the dansko clog :(  I like my tennis shoes to fit a little snug and these are very loose (like the clog) so I may be able to wear the 36, however I fear they may be too short.  The fabric does not allow for easy lacing; no forgiveness.  Not my favorite and it disappoints me so.  I really need a good tennis shoe with high arch without putting insoles in
4432092
I like the dark brown color, but notice some differences from the same boots in black I bought elsewhere months ago. The black pair has much thicker and stiffer shaft, which is exactly what I expected from Frye. But this brown pair has very thin and soft shaft, which I don't like. The footbed is also different from the black one. I feel that it's not as well made as the black one. Not sure why.