Does anyone know from experience the difference between Sambucus and this the original Sambucol?
2028980
Yes, Sambucol is the original extract formulated by Dr. Madeleine Mumcuoglu based on her (and others) research. It uses the whole berry in a proprietary extraction process that preserves the benefits of the berry. If you review the literature you will see that Sambucol was the elderberry used in the vast majority of the clinical studies. "Sambucus" (there are several brands, but will address the Natures Way version) uses a standardized extract, which is fine, except that no one knows where exactly the benefits come from in the berry, so it may be that they are missing some key pieces, and to the best of my research has never been used in any study. Yes, Sambucol is the original extract formulated by Dr. Madeleine Mumcuoglu based on her (and others) research. It uses the whole berry in a proprietary extraction process that preserves the benefits of the berry. If you review the literature you will see that Sambucol was the elderberry used in the vast majority of the clinical studies. "Sambucus" (there are several brands, but will address the Natures Way version) uses a standardized extract, which is fine, except that no one knows where exactly the benefits come from in the berry, so it may be that they are missing some key... » Read More Yes, Sambucol is the original extract formulated by Dr. Madeleine Mumcuoglu based on her (and others) research. It uses the whole berry in a proprietary extraction process that preserves the benefits of the berry. If you review the literature you will see that Sambucol was the elderberry used in the vast majority of the clinical studies. "Sambucus" (there are several brands, but will address the Natures Way version) uses a standardized extract, which is fine, except that no one knows where exactly the benefits come from in the berry, so it may be that they are missing some key pieces, and to the best of my research has never been used in any study. « Show Less
2028981
I've read the closer you stay to the original, kosher, the better the effects, and that is the Sambucol recipe. From research I have done in the past, and reviews I've read, I concluded that Sambucol is better than Sambucus, because the company making the latter has changed the extraction method, and many people feel it is less effective than Sambucol. Experience seems to be this way also.
2028982
One is short-hand for Sambucus nigra, the plant that produces the fruit. The other is a branded extract and processing of that fruit. As with any natural organic product, the quality of the raw material and the way it is handled and processed makes a big difference; certainly in taste, but also probably the concentrations of the bio active components. Think "Merlot Grape Vine" versus, say Blankiet 2004 Napa Valley Merlot.
2028983
I've used both products. I would use Sambucous again if necessary but I'd take Sambucol every time if I had the chance. The only thing I'll add to what arc369 said is ... Sambucol (this product) tastes VERY much like homemade elderberry syrup (I've made it from scratch), and Sambucous is noticeably sweeter. Since I'm after the power of elderberry and not looking for a sugary drink, when I'm buying instead of making, Sambucol (this product) is what I use for myself, my family, and my friends.
2028984
I never really noticed a difference. I started using Sambucus when, for some reason, Sambucol became unavailable. When it again became available I switched back to it since it was the original which I knew most of the time worked. I don't haven any definite examples, but I felt like the original worked a tad better. Nothing's 100%, but I think it does help.
1307544
I prefer original. It is the scent that put Old Spice "on the map" a long time ago.
1873132
I would believe the only difference is the formulation content on the mederma adult is much more stronger and secondly would be the fragrance...
1295680
Yes, they feel exactly the same. Sammel Yeom is incorrect. Source: I have both.
2020535
I was satisfied except with one of the products, which looked like it had been opened and watered down. It came from another seller,,,not the same as the syrum. I think you just have to be very careful who you buy from
1532485
I think that it is a different brand. I'm very satisfied with this one, and have reordered as well as given a couple to family. My advice is to read reviews for both types.
1746545
They are the same thing, just different packaging, and this one is the newer (the one in the link is the old version). Sometimes people see the word "super", it is actually just the translate from the japanese katakana on the bottle label, I got confused a little bit at first, but I tried to read the label (I know a bit Japanese) and figured it out. Have a look at this website http://www.hadalabo.com.my/product_content.html?catid=1&id;=0 <- Hada Labo offial website in Malaysia and they updated the new packaging (not like the website for US which still uses the old ones). Hope this help :) They are the same thing, just different packaging, and this one is the newer (the one in the link is the old version). Sometimes people see the word "super", it is actually just the translate from the japanese katakana on the bottle label, I got confused a little bit at first, but I tried to read the label (I know a bit Japanese) and figured it out. Have a look at this website http://www.hadalabo.com.my/product_content.html?catid=1&id;=0 <- Hada Labo offial website in Malaysia and they updated the new packaging (not like the website for US which still uses the old ones).... » Read More They are the same thing, just different packaging, and this one is the newer (the one in the link is the old version). Sometimes people see the word "super", it is actually just the translate from the japanese katakana on the bottle label, I got confused a little bit at first, but I tried to read the label (I know a bit Japanese) and figured it out. Have a look at this website http://www.hadalabo.com.my/product_content.html?catid=1&id;=0 <- Hada Labo offial website in Malaysia and they updated the new packaging (not like the website for US which still uses the old ones). Hope this help :) « Show Less
2190973
I don't know. I read the info on both and no differences were indicated. Made me wonder if it was different suppliers.
1399918
Honestly-I cannot tell much difference.I never really understood the difference in the two blends.
747074
I dont know the difference. This is a very good product in the 6 months Ive had it. I had a different type previously ... heavier, gave a different type of massage ... but i cant say it was better or not. I do like this one.
926261
I looked at it and I'm going to say no. Based on the differences in the price. Both 1oz but bug difference so I'm going to assume the other is not nearly as strong. I hope I'm looking at this the way you are.
530227
The imported one has a crappier taste! It's not as cheesy, less nutritional value, not as yellow and more bitter. The store I buy this one from (the non-imported one) was out, so I bought the imported one and now I'm stuck with crap...boooo!
405604
This is the original. I know this to be true because I had an original bottle and began to run low. Same smell and ingredients. This is the only concrete fact I have to on. U will love it.
1522815
Yes it is the original but, these folks are selling it for overinflated prices. You could buy this directly from Melaleuca for about 10 + S/H
1807272
No difference. It is the same fragrance. I think it depends on where and/or when it is packaged.
757765
I am not aware of any differences. To me, Shalimar by Guerlain is always just Shalimar. Sorry I could not be of more help.
995493
It's the same product, but I think it was older. The powder was darker than the stuff I ordered from the actual company that makes Splendyr. It seemed to work the same, however.