Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: shut him up or shut him down

first off you used the wrong phrase, shut him up or toss him out it is shut him up or shut him down. if you screw that up alone you should not write star wars. and allston and stockpole may have done fantasy but at least they do a nice job at star wars unlike you salvatore who writes close to horror novels. yes its nice to have a new enemy besides the empire it about time. their like the hun or the turks not indians and romans. as for the death of chewbacca thats why you create other main characters yo kill off you always need a core of people. but yes th young jedi knights are for but the old crew still has alot of time in this universe.