Will a Galaxy S4 phone with Otterbox Commuter case fit? If so, is the fit comfortable (easy to remove) or like a glove (tight)? Thank you.
1660024
While I'll admit I've never used the otter box commuter case i have used this holster with a GS4 LifeProof. And I now have a GS5 with a UAG case. Both fit pretty easily (loosely). My only complaint with this holster is that it closes with velcro instead of a magnetic "snap".
599247
I have a Trident case, which seems to be about the thickness of an Otterbox commuter. It just fits my Samsung S5. I would think that a normal Otterbox would be a stretch to fit.
581542
My wife has a Samsung Galaxy and it fits well. I would think a Otterbox would be too big.
1887747
This is a great case, but NO it will not work well with your phone other than the case that comes with the phone. I have a smaller case that is no where as near the thickness of the Otterbox and though I can get it into the case, it may take me 2-3 minutes it "wiggle" it out of the case. When two of my friends saw me trying to use it they said "Give it up. Your phone is too big for the case!!". So I have put five thick magic markers in it trying to stretch it. It's been several month and just a little "give"...maybe a few more months, lol! Save your money!
1123168
I have the Otter box series above the commuter and it fits fine. It's tight but fits.
272345
This fits the Otterbox Defender perfectly - so it should fit the Commuter just fine. The case might be more roomy with the Commuter as it is not as thick as the Defender - but in my opinion you would be able to remove it more easily. My husband has had this case since January and it has held up well. It is made with a nylon material so imagine it will not last forever. His holster clip that came with the Otterbox broke after 3 weeks - this case secures phone much better and gives added protection.
32835
I have a droid ultra and struggle to get the phone in the arm band without a case on it. My son has the galaxy s4 with an otterbox on it and I can tell just by looking at it that it will not fit.
2221315
It fits the standard S4 perfectly. My company phone is also an S4, but with dark gray rubbery compound encasing it, and the Otterbox would not work for it, due to the rubbery compound making it several millimeters (1/16 of an inch or so) thicker in all directions. If you have a standard metal-cased S4 it should fit; if you have the metal case encased in a rubbery material, I would say no, it won't fit.
456011
When I ordered my Otterbox Commuter replacement I made sure it was the same thing, even to the color, that I had before. When I received it, it fit exactly. If you have a different size phone then you need to take that into account. I hope that helps.
32838
Hey josh! I dont have an otterbox but I think it would be a little too thick to fit comfortably. I have the mophie charging case and I can make it fit in the sport armband but that case is very slick and can slide pretty easily into the arm band.
1300463
It fits my S3 with an otterbox Commuter. The S4 is only 1mm wider and the same height so I would say you would be OK to purchase it.
317334
It is a tight squeeze, but it does fit. I do think the manufacturer should have allowed a little more room, with the number of people using cases the size of Otterboxes.
800686
Hi Robin,I have an HTC One and the Otterbox commuter fits perfectly and has saved my phone about 100 times by now.
747064
As of day 1 using the Spigen Tough Armor case, I would say its too "snug" as what Wladimir said. It's a little difficult to get out of the holster. Maybe the elastic bands will ease up with use. We will see.
881994
I have an iPhone 4 with commuter otter box, fits snug, not a lot of room along the edges.
1322083
I have a Galaxy S3 .. it fits perfect but I have to take off the protective shell that I bought to save my phone from accidental drops. Is the S4 the same size?
647001
This belt case is perfect for the Samsung Galaxy s4 with the Otterbox. Plus it gives you comfort and keeps your phone secure. Hope this helps