should I get this knife or the one with the black coating?
1865872
the steel used for this knife is very corrosion resistant so I dont think the coating is necessary. it really just comes down to cosmetics. also, I have read that if using the knife for food prep, you should stay away from the coating. the coated knives I have are carbon steel where the coating is beneficial but since I take pretty good care of my steel, it probably doesnt matter anyway. I like the looks of this knife without the coating.
1865873
Mine is the uncoated version. I don't see the value of a black coating - it just makes woodcraft harder with a knife that is not easy to see. I don't know the nature f the coating, but most will wear off in time, and you will keep this knife for generations.
1865874
Only if you are really concerned about any light reflecting off the body of the blade for any stealth work you may be doing or may do in the future. I will be buying the A1 in black coating soon for my collection anyway. Fallkniven is a great knife. Good to know that you appreciate blades as much as I do. Thanks.
1865875
I personally like the satin finish. You will be able to see the lines where the VG10 steel is laminated with the other steel. It's quite beautifully to see if you into that sort of thing. However, it's really up to the individual who's buying and what they're preferences are. If you are buying this knife for tactical purposes for yourself or someone in the Armed Forces, you should get the black one.
1865876
I thought about getting the coating on my knife when I purchased it, but decided not to after some research that the coating will come off after some use. With a little care, the non-coating knife will last a lifetime and still look good.
1865877
The coating is most likely going to wear away with heavy use unless you plan on using it to cut mostly soft materials. I have the non-coated A1 and its held up great over the years with no rust issues. I also have a pilot with the coating and most of the black coating has worn off around the cutting edge. IMO I don't really think a coating is needed if your worried about rust. If your batoning through chunks of wood the black coating seems to have a slight sticky feel to it as well. I personally like the A2 and A1 non-coated.
1865878
I personally prefer the stainless blade. It doesn't take much to mess up the black covering and the knife looks ratty. But with the stainless it always looks good!
1865879
Short answer... that depends. How will you be using the knife? Over the life of the knife with the black coating it will start to "rub off." With heavy use the black coating will rub off faster, and in my opinion, make the knife less "aesthetically pleasing." However, if you are using the knife in a combat situation a shiny knife can be a liability. For general camping/survival use, I would go with the uncoated knife. It is easier to clean and I think it looks nicer over it's life.
956400
Depends on if you prefer the thumb stud to the thumb hole for opening. Both knives are high quality with good construction. I own the black handle Rat 1 with the satin stainless blade and love it.
1582302
The 8848 has a satin finish on the blade and the 8846 has a black finish. This is only difference between the knives. Both have a plain edge (no serrations) and both have a black handle. Keep in mind, with the 8846, the black finish WILL wear off with use. Hope this helps
369817
Bk22 or the bk10... If you're looking for a great knife at a reduced price look at the schrade schf9... I have all three and all of these knives are beasts
1310232
bought mine at an establishment that sharpens for lfe if purchased through them... sorry i can tell ya its a hhelluva knife i believe bests the famous bk2 covers more of the combat side of things
429951
The whole knife is black. The image is not the correct knife, but is the plain steel blade version.
1421605
yes, the black looks way better in my opinion and it is easier to keep it clean...hope this helps :)
1858057
Both are grey/black the image contrast just looks exaggerated. It's a great knife though well worth the money.
956398
Both are quality knives.The tenacious is usually a little more expensive.It just comes down to which one has the look you prefer.Hope this helped.
1307789
No there is no difference it just looks really good it's not as slippery as you think but there are good knives.
1253679
Black but I could never get mine to get an edge like my spyderco knifes I dont even use mine One day ill send it back see if zt can get it sharp
1025451
Seki City Japan. Using VG-10 steel, FRN handle scales. It's a good quality knife and I did a lot of research before buying it, but at the end I bought it mostly because I loved how it looked. If it were me, I would buy an Ontario Rat Model 2. It looks more simple, but the craftsmanship is way better, zero blade play and built like a rock. And it is half the price. Also look at the Benchmade Mini Griptilian.
911950
I believe it is but I've never physically owned one or compared the two. This one however is a great knife and I recommend it.
792122
The overall quality is excellent. I own 22 different knives in this same class and this one is my "go to" knife. Over time, Yes, the sheath will wear on the blade and dull the black finish. Two ways you can prevent this...1.) buy a leather or nylon sheath...or, 2.) keep the blade lubed. The dulling of the black finish does not affect the performance, durability, or functionality of the knife.
69663
Boyfriend, this knife WILL be your OFFICIAL GO TO knife! Meats, veggies, a watermelon, even soft fresh bread cuts like butter. Please remember to use your knife steel after a good amount of use like I do and it will continue to impress you. For a long time my go to was the Forschner Victorinox, suggested by Cook's Illustrated.....I think the Wusthof Nakiri has it beat big time. Hope you love it like I do!
1136905
I emailed Cold Steel and they explained about the gring,flat vs hollow.I never really noticed before,now it's easy to spot but it still does not stop sellers from listing both and or using a picture different than what their actoally selling. I already have a SK-5 knife and was thinking about buying another for a present.I will be in contact with the seller before I make a purchase to be sure what I am getting. Frankly I would not want the stainless version.
314749
First of all there ar two different sets one has a black handle and the more expensive one is all steel, both are very good and stay very sharp, on the box it does not show the two 3" paring knife, or plastic juice extractors, be careful these knifes can cut through frozen meat.