Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Good but not as good as the book.

All i can say is that the book, ofcourse, was alot better. However for what it was i thought it was a good flick. I wished they showed more interactions with Logan and his shepherd (like in the book). I think the chemistry the actors was very evident, alot of passion was showed in the movie. You can say that the "high school musical' star definitely has been busy polishing his acting skills since the beginning of his careeer.