Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: timeless westie

These books about McDuff are timeless. Our 23 mo. old grandaughter has an old, born well before she was born, Westie named Charlie. She loves these books! The illustrations are so clear and the expressive dog 'faces' are perfect for a Westie. Another plus is that adults enjoy reading them too....This helps when you are asked 'read again' over and over.