which one is better for the 40 cal 17lb or the 20lb recoil spring
327656
i put the 20lb spring in my sw40ve and my gun is awesome . . highly recommended
327657
The 17 pounds spring gave me nothing but problems I would opt for the 20lb recoil spring assembly
327658
Personal preference, intended use, type of ammo... all factors. I prefer a lighter recoil spring and would like a progressive spring rate ideally, but use the 15# with my sd40. If its 17 or 20, i'd opt for for the 17.
327659
I would say the 20lb one is better for the .40 caliber for sure. The 17lb one is more for the 9mm.
327660
... with the heavier caliber and greater energy loads I would go with the 20lb
60158
You have to consider the physical weight and spring weight of the rod. These rods aren't that heavy and doesn't feel to add any weight towards the front end. I would go with 17 lb spring. Not too much stress to mess up any parts, not too little for failure2feed. Hope this helped.
2011959
There was no question to answer. 17-40 is smaller and lighter but less range. Buy what YOU need.
1971562
I have found steel is much better. Stays in place much better from the vibration of the recoil
1158168
Not a good choice. I bought a stock that has a internal spring system. Firm enough to steady the shot but does relieve the recoil. I have it on an AK-47, but I think it would be more effective for a shotgun. Not cheap. Over $100 but not cheaply made.
112336
It makes the trigger smoother & easier to pull it averages about 4-5 lb trigger pull once installed. Yes the one with the trigger does the same as above but it also takes up to 20% pre-travel out so I'd say yes to the one with the trigger.
258031
Works good on my ar15 not sure about spring air that is a different type of recoil
99553
Either one will work in my opinion. I would suggest you select the standard model which I believe has sufficient tension to securely hold a light firearm like the Ruger LCP.
370817
generally relates to shooting heavier or lighter loads so the action cycles properly; unless you're doing hand loads, use the recommend spring weight for your caliber.
1038615
My .22 cal pellet gun probably has more recoil than your 17 or 22 mag. I have had no issues with it at all.
591608
Both are fine. As to which is"preferred" that's up to you. I like the 20mm personally.
1436391
We used this one last year & were not pleased with it. We got the one with the springs on the end this year & it did alot better job. So yes, definitely go with the one with springs.
60159
The spring corresponds with the load. If you're loading weak target rounds, you can use a light spring so the action still cycles. Similar with the heavy weight spring for hot loads. If you're shooting standard factory rounds, use the recommended standard weight.
650043
No noticeable recoil difference, I personally feel the monte carlo stock is more padded, which is a little more comfortable to shoot, the added weight gives you a little more control, recoil is the same bc u have same barrel and same round, felt recoil is about the same as well, it just doesnt beat ur shoulder up as much, 30 rds in will still be sore though
1659204
The largest caliber rifle I have used this on is a 7.62x39 AK47. No problem with recoil on that rifle.
772057
Yes..I put one of these and a steel recoil spring guide rod in mine and it made it very nice to shoot. Accuracy was improved greatly as well. Both of these upgrades are well worth the money spent. You wont be disappointed.
68964
yes if it is a slip on one. Amazon has them for sale that have the sizes in inches specified for each stock. I like it on mine because the felt recoil and muzzle rise is almost non existent on my 20 gauge. I find it really helps while aiming long distance with slugs and follow up shots for home defense.