Does this provide good hold for medium to shorter fine hair without making it to greasy? Or should I go with another Gatsby, if so, which one?
187368
the green one is just for defining, or how you want it shaped, this one is for like tips, and no gastby period doesn't make your hair greasy just makes it look like a blade of grass or something, but what i use for medium short hair, for anime hair style, shampoo, conditioner, dryer, straightner, green gatsby for shape, purple for spike tips etc, then hairspray, may seem like a lot but looks awesome :), if you already have straight hair then skip those steps, my hair is naturally curly so it doesn't go well, but this is spike hair style, dont put to much or your gonna see white :) only recomm on tips of fingers to create spikes the green one is just for defining, or how you want it shaped, this one is for like tips, and no gastby period doesn't make your hair greasy just makes it look like a blade of grass or something, but what i use for medium short hair, for anime hair style, shampoo, conditioner, dryer, straightner, green gatsby for shape, purple for spike tips etc, then hairspray, may seem like a lot but looks awesome :), if you already have straight hair then skip those steps, my hair is naturally curly so it doesn't go well, but this is spike hair style, dont put to much or your gonna see white :) only... » Read More the green one is just for defining, or how you want it shaped, this one is for like tips, and no gastby period doesn't make your hair greasy just makes it look like a blade of grass or something, but what i use for medium short hair, for anime hair style, shampoo, conditioner, dryer, straightner, green gatsby for shape, purple for spike tips etc, then hairspray, may seem like a lot but looks awesome :), if you already have straight hair then skip those steps, my hair is naturally curly so it doesn't go well, but this is spike hair style, dont put to much or your gonna see white :) only recomm on tips of fingers to create spikes « Show Less
187369
This Gatsby is the best for hold in short hair, but it is also the most greasy of the line. That being said, "greasy" in Gatsby terms is probably way less greasy than most other products. If you are unopposed to a more dry waxy feel, you may want to consider Gatsby Grunge Matte.
187370
The pink (matte) and purple (shinier) are the strongest holds. It never feels greasy but it feels a bit waxy. I wouldn't buy the other because they don't have strong enough holds for short fine hair. The green one would make your hair feel like you had nothing in it (it wouldn't work).
988536
I have very fine hair too, and these things do not work well for me. It isn't the product, but most likely the user at fault. Very soft, fine hair is difficult to keep curled or styled. Sorry I can't help you more. I would love to go back to my younger days and wear pigtails.....
371114
I have short hair and chose the 3/4 inch size instead. With the brush feature, it holds the hair easily while you curl it. I guess if you like more body than curl, it may work.
1722412
I've used when I have had both medium and short hair and have been happy with it. My hair is fine, but I do have a lot of it. Hope this helps.
479956
I have short hair that's pretty thick. It does a good job for me. I liked the one I bought for travel so much, I ordered another for home use.
654783
I have not tried the firme hold, but the regular pomade works great, it holds but doesn't get crunchy at all (and my hair is normally dry).
426915
I have medium length natural curly coarse hair. I have tried many brushes over the years for my blow outs. This one is great in that it grabs my hair without pulling and I can dry my hair faster. Also I don't have use a curling iron (flat iron) afterwards either. My hairdresser suggested and I'm so glad she did.
1540032
absolutely! This stuff is he best. And you dont need to use anywhere near the amount directed. 2 pumps is all I use for my short fine hair! Make sure you order from the correct source though as some versions use a cheaper non effective formula. Order from Chaz.com
2018596
Sounds like you have a lot of hair. I would go for the bigger one (1.5). It's going to grab more in the bristles with the bigger surface area on the brush, and likely cut down on the amount of time it would take to style. I always find a bigger barrell easier to wield than a smaller one with these dryers, curling irons, etc. My hair is just past shoulders, layered, fairly thick and wavy and this works wonderfully!
846966
I'm not sure I've used the volumizing tonic unless you mean Invaldi??? But the style prep does a lot of things. Acts as a detangler on wet hair. Absolutely cures the frizzies... I even use it on dry hair if the humidity gets to me. And yes I use mousse with it. I wouldn't do without style prep ever!
1440433
I have thin baby fine hair on top, and I use this instead of mousse for some volume. It works pretty good but try it both ways....I am not looking for hair that is weighted or attracts dirt or gives me the greasy look as my hair is also oily. Must shampoo every other day.
384059
I have a spray for hair and it works awesome. Never tried the masque. The formula for hair is light-weight so it doesn't make your hair greasy. I only use a few sprays each time.
161215
I have fairly thin hair so I would recommend you going with the Extra Rich version for sure. Hope this helps!
105872
The American Crew is an excellent styling gel, but in my opinion, not strong enough for the modern slicked back styles. If you need a super strong hold, I would try something else.
1600100
You might try something that has a pump or aerosal used very sparingly at first. Paul Mitchell has one. I think it's called "Shine". I wouldn't use this on fine and/or thin hair. It's pretty heavy
366062
I find it better than the American Crew stuff. For someone like me who has wavy hair more on the curly side, the FIRME hold lasts all day, and it does keep a great hold. I apply it while my hair is almost dry, not to damp. Hope this helps
729828
I think it depends on the thickness and natural curliness of your hair. My hair is very thick and curly. It will coil into Shirley temple like curls. When I use suavecito, it helps give my hair shape and place my hair in the direction I want but it doesn't hold it tight in place and during the day my hair will do what it wants. I would not be abe to do a 6 in pomp with height with saUvecito. I use layrite super hold instead for things like that and use sauvecito for a medium hold. Hope this.helps.