Is chlorinating granules better than the bromide system?
471584
I can't give you a good answer. What I have been told is that to use Bromide, you should have an installed system to feed the bromide. May or may not be true. I used the granules because they work and it's simple. About a table spoon every 7-8 days. I use the test strips to validate and check balances. So far, after 11 years with the hot tub, things are still working as expected. Also, since water is relatively cheap in my area (about $10 to fill the Hot tub), I change the water completely typically every two years.
471585
its in what you prefer i like the bromide tablets best with tablets i can check on hot tub only once a week and everything stays good.with the granules i usually need check it more often and it seems i use more.
471586
I have personally found chlorinating granules to be better than bromide. I feel they do a better job. I just sprinkle a little bit in (about a teaspoon) each time we use the hot tub.
471587
Yes, I have two pool men that live on the same block as I, they explained that chlorinating granular kill germs better then the bromide does. But make sure that you use only one and not to mix them. I only use one cap full at a time and my spa is clear and clean
471588
Yes I believe so, I've been using for 3 years now and like it better, clearer water
471589
In pools the chlorine is better, more efficient because it works better in the cooler water. But technically, bromine works better for killing germs in the environment of a hot tub. The advantage of bromine is being able to put the tabs in and forget about it for a while. We do use the chlorine because the "leftovers" from the bromine killing germs can cause an odor, and if you put in the proper amount of chlorine, you will barely smell it. If you're smelling the chlorine strongly, you shouldn't be in the tub...could be at toxic levels. Of course it could also depend on one's sensitivity to the various chemicals. In pools the chlorine is better, more efficient because it works better in the cooler water. But technically, bromine works better for killing germs in the environment of a hot tub. The advantage of bromine is being able to put the tabs in and forget about it for a while. We do use the chlorine because the "leftovers" from the bromine killing germs can cause an odor, and if you put in the proper amount of chlorine, you will barely smell it. If you're smelling the chlorine strongly, you shouldn't be in the tub...could be at toxic levels. Of course it could also depend on one's... » Read More In pools the chlorine is better, more efficient because it works better in the cooler water. But technically, bromine works better for killing germs in the environment of a hot tub. The advantage of bromine is being able to put the tabs in and forget about it for a while. We do use the chlorine because the "leftovers" from the bromine killing germs can cause an odor, and if you put in the proper amount of chlorine, you will barely smell it. If you're smelling the chlorine strongly, you shouldn't be in the tub...could be at toxic levels. Of course it could also depend on one's sensitivity to the various chemicals. « Show Less
1230783
Had same pool. 1-2 tabs per week along with chlorine tabs have done it for over 5 years. The arm n hammer makes the difference. Sometimes threw in some chlorine granules Always stayed clear. Def gotta vacuum n skim pool too
1679476
Michael, None that I'm aware of based on personal experience. Now I mostly use a combination of the granules and the liquid form of Pramitol at the same time so if you're finding the granules alone aren't strong enough, start spraying with Pramitol liquid at the same time and you should see enhanced results. Cheers, Jonathan Customer Care U-Spray Bugspray
171970
Do not reuse the granules for any reason or after any treatment.... I have one florida redbelly water turtle in a 60 gal setup... I change my media in rotations to avoid any tank shock or jump or fall in pH... Typically, I change the ammonia remover granules at the same time as the ZeoCarb media about once every 5-6 weeks depending on observable water changes and or pH level change. Hope this helps... Sarah Baker
1897300
yes, we have an ionizer and have used common supermarket chlorine for 14 years now. Our pool man recommended it all those years ago and it has been useful to us. Our first liner lasted 11 years and we are on our second liner now. It is holding up well using the ionizer \ chlorine combination.
1023741
I don't know what is in NeverScrub but the Kaboom product seems to contain bromine as is used in indoor hot tubs. I refill with the much less expensive bromine tablets from the pool supply store. Chlorine is undesirable in closed spaces but bromine is supposed to be OK. Any bleaching cleaner can interfere with the action of a septic tank but the amount supplied by this product is probably no enough to make a noticeable difference in the septic tank.
1124325
Hi, this is Steve at aqua Products. Our units work well in salt water pools but like standard chlorine pools, it's best if you do not leave them in longer than necessary - a good fresh water rinse is always welcome too.
791355
My pool is salt. I also have a mechanically run cover that keeps it very clean. I only use this and muratic acid. I find that pool stores push a lot of products that are not necessary. Like conditioner/cyanuric acid is only needed at very low levels to prevent chlorine loss.Research it and you'll see 2-20 is range to do its job...not 30-50 like pool companies recommend.
274893
In my opinion is dependent on the volume of water. I attached another in-line filter for everything else except chlorine which reduced the volume and the vitamin C powder last much longer now
1477247
I should think so. It is very sturdy. I have been storing my garden fertilizer in it and it has kept it very dry.I think what you need to consider is the humidity in your area as I know that chlorine tablets absorb moisture (my past experience) and can then crumble. I live in California so it is very dry here and my fertilizer granuals have not gotten moist or spoiled from the humidity in the air.
1849440
I have used this product for many years in two houses that have septic system and have had no problem. The amount of chlorine put into the system is so small that it will not upset the balance of bacteria in the septic tank.
745424
You can get a filter that is specifically set up for salt and not chlorine like the standard option. I personally have the standard chlorine option, but supposedly the salt water system saves money in chemicals and does not burn the eyes like chlorine can.
1483012
It is not recommended...we tried years ago and found the chlorine we bought dissolved much quicker. Our pool had algae for the first time during the season.
272033
Not familiar with Pristine products either. Our hot tub is non-chlorine. These chemicals work great.
2000687
Yes. I alternate this product with chlorine. Bromine doesn't seem to work as effectively in my hot tub. As a long time hot tub owner, I have noticed the actual tub accepting or rejecting certain chemical combinations at different times during ownership. I use an oxy product like this (I bought this specific brand because it was easy through Amazon), the Nature 2 cartridge, and occasional chlorine in my 2001 Vanguard Hot Springs tub. I do have an ozonator and I installed a UV in-line sterilization system using a standard Pondmaster UV filtration light. If you have any other question just ask. - Kris Yes. I alternate this product with chlorine. Bromine doesn't seem to work as effectively in my hot tub. As a long time hot tub owner, I have noticed the actual tub accepting or rejecting certain chemical combinations at different times during ownership. I use an oxy product like this (I bought this specific brand because it was easy through Amazon), the Nature 2 cartridge, and occasional chlorine in my 2001 Vanguard Hot Springs tub. I do have an ozonator and I installed a UV in-line sterilization system using a standard Pondmaster UV filtration light. If you have any other question just... » Read More Yes. I alternate this product with chlorine. Bromine doesn't seem to work as effectively in my hot tub. As a long time hot tub owner, I have noticed the actual tub accepting or rejecting certain chemical combinations at different times during ownership. I use an oxy product like this (I bought this specific brand because it was easy through Amazon), the Nature 2 cartridge, and occasional chlorine in my 2001 Vanguard Hot Springs tub. I do have an ozonator and I installed a UV in-line sterilization system using a standard Pondmaster UV filtration light. If you have any other question just ask. - Kris « Show Less
2228198
Even though this filter helps to soften water in your house, still a regular softener is more efficient. I would suggest to start with this filter anyway because it is better for your health to remove chlorine, and then add a softener if your water remains hard.
1650636
It actually works a bit better on plastic. Should not affect your chlorinization.