is this knife better than the gerber prodigy
489238
It depends on the intended usage. The gerber will have a more durable handle/guard design. It would be better suited for survival. The SP-1 has a better steel, although that is a subjective to preferences. The 420HC of the gerber will hold up better to neglect and wet weather, but it wont hold an edge as well. as the 1095 steel in the SP-1. The SP-1 is an all around general purpose and fighting knife, just like the old kabar. Both the prodigy and SP-1 have similar uses and intents and either would work well for most applications that a large knife would be used. Because of the blade design, the prodigy would be better suited to building and craft work and skinning game in a survival environment. It depends on the intended usage. The gerber will have a more durable handle/guard design. It would be better suited for survival. The SP-1 has a better steel, although that is a subjective to preferences. The 420HC of the gerber will hold up better to neglect and wet weather, but it wont hold an edge as well. as the 1095 steel in the SP-1. The SP-1 is an all around general purpose and fighting knife, just like the old kabar. Both the prodigy and SP-1 have similar uses and intents and either would work well for most applications that a large knife would be used. Because of the blade design,... » Read More It depends on the intended usage. The gerber will have a more durable handle/guard design. It would be better suited for survival. The SP-1 has a better steel, although that is a subjective to preferences. The 420HC of the gerber will hold up better to neglect and wet weather, but it wont hold an edge as well. as the 1095 steel in the SP-1. The SP-1 is an all around general purpose and fighting knife, just like the old kabar. Both the prodigy and SP-1 have similar uses and intents and either would work well for most applications that a large knife would be used. Because of the blade design, the prodigy would be better suited to building and craft work and skinning game in a survival environment. « Show Less
489239
I dont have any experience with the Gerber Prodigy but in my opinion this knife is an awesome value. I would dare to say it is equal to that of a ka bar at half of the price. Just my opinion but I have owned and used it for about 6 months or so and I cant say anything bad about it. It doesnt come razor sharp but it is better this way for the type of blade as it is stronger and holds its medium edge longer. Knife people will know what I mean here. It is great at chopping, batoning, slashing of heavy fabrics, but would not suggest for fine knife work or small game dressing. Not made for that. Comes to life as a penetrating blade, this is the main design perk. It will go through very stiff barriers and thick reinforced fabrics. I would buy another or any of the sp blade line variants. I hope this in some way hopes you settle on a blade.
1705899
Surprisingly its pretty good. My friend has a Gerber knife with firestarter and this one showers more sparks than his.
2084898
There is no comparison, from the stainless steel blades to the tremendous amount of torque you can apply to the blades with the large handles. I have had mine over a year, I feed raw to my pups, so it cuts chicken backs and necks ten times easier then the huge so called poultry scissors. Depends what you use them for, but in the kitchen then are the last word in my book. I am using the white handle ones.
854768
I own the F1 and am absolutely pleased with it. The knife is very sharp and has consistently stayed that way. The only thing I dlnt like about it, is that it is so light that you cant chop with it. I do a lot of bushcraft work so this kind of a downside. Now on that note the S1 is a little bit heavier and longer, so it might be better at chopping. But I dont have any personal experience with the S1. But I believe no matter which you get, both will serve you well. Now as far as a sheath goes that depends on what you want. The zytel is nice in the fact that its maintenance free. But the blade isnt a snug fit so it rattles a little bit. The leather obviously wouldnt have the rattling problem. But leather needs to be cared for. Hope that helped you decide. Good luck. Both will serve you well.
2272868
I prefer Tac Force in both functionality and style. I've had this knife for a couple months now and it just suits my personal taste more. Kershaw does feel sturdier, yet my Tac Force is plenty strong itself.
665241
Yes, but it rattles around alot and is annoying. A way better knife now is the schf37. About same price. Wayyy better.
1094516
I'm sorry I'm not sure how to answer that question as this is my first gerber knife. It has the "G" symbol but I don't know if that is for Gerber or Bear Gylis (Spelling). The knife is nice but to be honest I'm not too impressed with the overall quality. I noticed after cutting up some cardboard boxes that the seraded teeth are folded back slightly like the metal isn't a very strong quality. I do like how light the knife is and the safety mechanism to keep the knife closed or open depending on the position it is in when the safety is engaged.
605309
they are the same knife. the only differences are the color and the sheath. But i have seen some price differences as well. But as functionality goes they are the same. I choose this one simply because it has a more natural color.
228848
You are asking a question that is not easily answered. The Gerber Mark 2 and the Boker Plus V-42 Devils Brigade are two different knives. It is kind of like asking if a sports car is better than a SUV. The Gerber is all steel, the Boker has a leather wrapped handle like a Kabar. The Gerber has two serrated cutting edges higher on the handle, the Boker does not, but it has a thumb groove on the handle. The Gerber has a flatter pommel, the Boker has a spike. Booth cut well, both stab well, but what do you want to use it for ? Also the scabbard is slightly longer on the Boker, but still wears well. You are asking a question that is not easily answered. The Gerber Mark 2 and the Boker Plus V-42 Devils Brigade are two different knives. It is kind of like asking if a sports car is better than a SUV. The Gerber is all steel, the Boker has a leather wrapped handle like a Kabar. The Gerber has two serrated cutting edges higher on the handle, the Boker does not, but it has a thumb groove on the handle. The Gerber has a flatter pommel, the Boker has a spike. Booth cut well, both stab well, but what do you want to use it for ? Also the scabbard is slightly longer on the Boker, but still wears... » Read More You are asking a question that is not easily answered. The Gerber Mark 2 and the Boker Plus V-42 Devils Brigade are two different knives. It is kind of like asking if a sports car is better than a SUV. The Gerber is all steel, the Boker has a leather wrapped handle like a Kabar. The Gerber has two serrated cutting edges higher on the handle, the Boker does not, but it has a thumb groove on the handle. The Gerber has a flatter pommel, the Boker has a spike. Booth cut well, both stab well, but what do you want to use it for ? Also the scabbard is slightly longer on the Boker, but still wears well. « Show Less
127040
Mora knives are far more durable, in general, in relation to Gerber knives in my experience
1516556
I found that Ka-Bar knife is not as sharp as Gerber. Regardless of where they made, if the quality of the product don't deliver then you lose customers. I don't mind to pay a little extra more if the product uphold the quality.
1237635
I do not own the gerber dime but I know that the squirt and dime are pretty similar.if you look up knifehq on YouTube they do a head to head challenge comparing the two multi tools. And there are many other vids telling all about them. Hope this helps.
295507
New version of the same knife. If you go on gerber's website you will see the knife with the updated version. Check out esee knives though. I returned mine to amazon after getting two replacements from Gerber. I wouldn't recommend this knife
1404692
This is a little quicker and leaner than the Kramer knife. If the Kramer is what I am familiar with, the Reserve is easier to care for since it is not carbon steel. The carbon steel will rust " patina" if you don't wash immediately.
1284678
The Zero Tolerance Tactical Response and the ZT G10 are of equal materials and quality, the TR is somewhat bigger, the smaller G10 has the speed safe assisted opening which is a great feature, from my read of the ZTTR I do not think it has speed safe. So for everyday carry, I prefer a smaller knife with speed safe system so that would be the ZTG10 or the Kershaw Blur. The Kershaw blur is also an excellent knife, the speed safe system on my Kershaw (I have one too) is actually slightly better than the ZTG10. I think that is because the Kershaw blade is lighter and thinner than the ZT blade. The K Blur blade flips out easier and faster, both lock up equally well. Which one of those is "better" is a personal judgement. The Kershaw being lighter will carry better in a pocket, the ZTG10 will carry better in a belt pouch. Some people do not like belt pouches others do, The ZTG10 is a larger, thicker blade, heftier, tougher, stronger, more substantial, and more impressive knife, but if he is not used to carrying a relatively large folding knife every day, the slightly lighter and smaller Kershaw may be a better choice. Either way both excellent knives...if he already has a Kershaw Blur, this is a very similar knife as far as application, he may prefer the ZTG10, for the reasons above but carrying either one would negate much of the need for the other
595337
The Rambler is much sturdier than the Classic. The bottle opener is on the same 'blade' as the Philips screwdriver and is about three times thicker than the blade. At least twice as thick as the flat head screwdriver blade that doubles as a file. This is the only knife I carry on a daily basis - as a health care professional. I'm not on board ship or in a construction profession where you want a one-handed knife. This little knife has met my needs for years.
1627431
I like Spyderco - very good knife and may actually carry better when wearing dress slacks. For me, comes down to personal preference. I carry my ZT more often because I prefer the speed opening and it fits my hand better. Either knife is a great choice IMHO.