Will this work with the otterbox commuter case on an iPhone 4S?
1830228
Not likely, the cradle is tight, and probably wasn't made to accommodate cases.
1830229
Not sure about Otterbox, but it will not work with LifeProof case... iPhone needs to be out of the case to sit in dock.
667032
Unfortunately this will NOT work with an Otterbox case. I like having my phone on the dock at night to charge and use as my clock/alarm clock. It is a pain to have to remove the Otterbox case each night.
924413
My guess would be yes. My wife and I both have iPhone 5 with Otterbox Commuter. My daughter has the "i 5" with the Otterbox Defender, both fit the case just fine. The iPhone 4 is a little smaller than the iPhone 5.
1726449
Yes. There are holes on both bottom corners. I have no problems putting it in or taking it out with my iPhone 4S with its Lifeproof case. I can see where the Otterbox will be a problem.
1394986
Works on 4s with otter box defender and on my wife's 5 th I guess it will work.
1253625
Mine worked with an iPhone 4 in an OtterBox. However, the Grip-It broke after a few weeks of use. I do not recommend this product. Big Lots sell a very similar one that works great.
1439689
I use it with a droid maxx with the commuter otterbox case. Its a little snug, and the top sticks out just a bit. But it fits.
1715787
Yes, and it works well. I like the ease of opening the case as opposed to a snap or clasp, because it's difficult enough to get my phone out of the tight pouch (iphone 4s with otter box cover on). This is not a complaint though because I wear this at work and can't risk the loss of my phone.
1500866
I have this dock for my iPhone 5S with an Otterbox Commuter case on and it didn't fit at all :/ Had to remove both the hard and soft case to get it to charge.
410658
There is a difference if the IPhone 5 and the 4s ,but if its 30 pin it should work. But if you have an Otterbox, it won't seat properly
294675
I found it to work great with the Defender case since ithe phone is completely inclosed, but the Commuter case would eventually push the screen protector up on the edges which would of course lead to the whole protector coming off.
741286
Yes it works with the 4S. It only works with the case that comes with it because of the attachment spot for the lanyard. I didn't have any problems with it coming out of the case
536147
For my iPhone it works perfectly. I have an Otter box "Armor" case on my 5s. I do NOT however have an Otter box case on my Galaxy S4, so can not speak to that.
1184613
I also bought a black iPhone 4S. The older Otterbox Defender iPhone 4 case fits and it functions just fine.
1955353
I have the otterbox commuter case and it does not work with that. But the case is pretty easy off and on so I don't mind. It does have a snap out plastic section so I think it is designed for a slim case. I friend of mine down the hall has this case:Spigen Slim Armor Case for Galaxy Note 3 - Infinity White (SGP10459)and with the plastic section out this dock connected to the phone with the case on without a problem.
1857930
Yes I believe it will. I have tried it on the Otterbox Defender case, and on the Seido hard case. Both work fine as I recall, but I didn't try to plug anything in, just tried the fit. However, the sockets were visible.
2252961
I wish I could tell you this, but I don't know. I know that it works with the Commuter Case and that it will NOT work with the Defender case. So unless it states that it does work with it, I'd be a little skeptical about purchasing it...