This is the only eye liner that won't transfer, ...
348719
This is the only eye liner that won't transfer, but also comes off when washing your face. The tip makes sharp and thin lines as well. Also, it is actually bold black that comes out instead of it being faded. It lasts me months!
2478129
I have deep set eyes and so it's hard to find good eyeliner.  This one transferred onto my brow bone, even with primer under my eyeshadow.  I don't feel that it's a very good value, I usually use Clinique liquid eyeliner and don't have that problem.  I do have trouble with kohl eyeliner though too so it's less the product and more my eye shape :)
717585
I don't typically like felt tip liquid liners. I prefer the brush types because they give deeper color, but they take a lot of time and skill to use. I tried Stila liquid liner based on the great reviews I found while searching for an excellent waterproof liquid liner. This eyeliner was definitely wonderful at first. It was easy to apply, had rich color, and was waterproof, yet easy to remove with soap and water at the end of the day.  However, I only got 3 good uses out of it before it started drying out.  I got another 2 uses, but the color deposit was not even. So I had to use a few tricks to try and fill in spots where the color was barely showing.  After day 5, I could barely get the color to come out at all.  Mind you, I stored the eyeliner in the recommended fashion, upside down, fully capped. I always shook it vigorously before use.  I even tried warming it up by letting the base of the eyeliner pen soak in some hot water.  Nothing helped. I ended up having to dip the tip of the pen in some water, blot it, and a bit of the color came out before it stopped again. It was not even enough to finish one eye lid.

I'm extremely unhappy with this purchase because this is the most money I've ever spent on eyeliner, and this is the least use I've ever got out of one.  I absolutely do not recommend this product until the company fixes the deficiency.  It's a huge waste of money.
1409318
This is my "go-to" eyeshadow and I've used it for years. It is quality makeup that has a pretty shimmer, matches anything, and stays on all day. My only major complaint here is the case it comes in. It is not tight or protective enough and as soon as I travelled with this eyeshadow it cracked into a million pieces. The case is also broken now, the lid will no longer stay on, resulting in a big mess every time I carefully pry it open (aka every morning) to apply the shadow. It's not like I threw this around or anything, it sits in one place all day, every day. I had to buy another today to replace it when my current one is not even halfway used yet. For the price of this shadow, the case should be better!  I expected better from Stila.
2384667
One of the very few eyeliners that stays put and doesn't cause my eyes to turn red or itch later in the day.
3792950
This product fails to prevent glare. I purchased it because I have eye problems and needed an anti-glare filter for my desktop. I have a different brand at work that works great. This one was much more money and doesn't do the job! Very sad to say I had to spend over $8 to ship this junk back but I won't disregard others comments in the future! So much for Prime Membership saving me money :(
4423232
I originally got this product as a sample in my IPSY subscription box and I loved it and now its the only eyeliner I use.
1326144
It is definitely not waterproof at all..a eyeliner by ulta is much better.....will not purchase again..very disappointed
59124
Eyeko is such a great line.  This liquid liner is amazing!  It goes on smooth and stays put all day.  I've tried other liquid liners and by 3pm I look like a racoon and my eyes are all smudgy.  This product does not smudge.  Be warned ladies that liquid liner can smell fear and applying this takes practice.  That being said, I started off by just "dotting" this liner over my lashes and connecting the dots to make sure I didn't mess up.  I'm currently on my 3rd liner as I use this daily.  Also - it does take some work to get off every night.  I use an oil-free eye makeup remover, but it still takes me a few minutes to get it all off.  This product won't come off by washing your face alone, or swimming.
1612423
I really like Blinc Kiss Me Mascara so I decided to try their Eyeliner. I ended up throwing the Eyeliner away because for me it was too hard to apply and I could never get it to look right.
483942
It is what it is... and it is the best eye liner
4134740
Worth every penny! Goes on smoothly and stays on all day! The tip is very fine so application is very precise. I have used other more expensive liquid eyeliners to achieve a cat eye look and this is by far my favorite!
1763373
I have extremely oily and hooded eyelids, and I can't tell you how many "smudge-proof" mascaras I've tried unsuccessfully.  At the end of the day, I always had raccoon eyes.  No matter what.

That all ended the day I tried Blinc. Seriously, not a SINGLE smudge.  EVER.  It's been a makeup miracle for me.

The only tricky part is getting it off.  It comes off easily with water, but doesn't rub off like typical mascaras.  It comes off in "chunks" or "tubes" as others have described.  Not a big deal, just make sure you don't get any in your eye during removal.
2437805
Fabulous, does not smudge or come off. I lost my eyebrows years ago and this is the only product that stays on all day
3520091
After reading some of the one star review, I know I am not the only one. This eyeliner is my all time favorite brand, until I bought one from here. I trusted Amazon so that I did not pay attention to the package. But I notice the difference the first time I used it. It's much harder to apply than all my previous ones. Its like an used one that most of the ink is gone, or something like that. I shakes it , pressed it, but nothing helped. I only used for few weeks and it drove me crazy every morning. Stila never had products like this before, so I decided to read reviews to find out why. I guess this is faked product or expired ??? I donot know , but just donot buy it from hete. This is not the same stila!!! Be aware!!
1575351
This review only applies for the liquid eyeliner since I felt it was a great deal to spend $5 more to get a mascara and an eye shadow palette with it. This eyeliner is hands-down THE best eyeliner I've ever had, doesn't smear nor fade. The only thought I had about purchasing this package is that it comes unwrapped already but still in the box. I can't help but wonder if the included products have been tampered with prior to my purchase, however, my eyeliner drew on like brand new. Only time will tell if I will purchase the eyeliner on Amazon again, since I usually purchase at ULTA but they sell out fast.
1966736
I can't get the decal to stay on the transfer paper, so it's pretty much useless. Yes, I have applied decals before. It would be an awesome decal if I could actually use it!