These boots are surprisingly comfortable out of the box
340006
These boots are surprisingly comfortable out of the box. I'm on my feet all day and the first day in new shoes is always brutal. I expected the same with these. Not so...I even continued to wear them into the night. Very pleased.
4097383
Way more comfortable than I expected! I've wore boots like this before, so I didn't expect them to be so comfortable. The foam in them cushions the foot so well, and keeps my feet warm.
1299372
I try to avoid boots and shoes of synthetic material, but that wasn't an option so I trusted the reviews and bought these.  They're completely true to size and surprisingly comfortable (though I'll probably get some gel soles to pad the balls of my feet).  We'll see whether they hold up, but for the price, I'm quite pleased.
2110289
Normally, I have a terrible time finding footwear that doesn't need to be "broken in," before it's comfortable -- and most often that includes the blisters that make me hesitate to wear them ever again. BUT, not so with these boots!  I was thrilled to receive them in the two days that Amazon Prime promised.  And, they felt sooooo good, right out of the box!  I wore them all day with no problems.  The soles are non-skid and work pretty well out there in the Montana ice and snow.  The heel is just the right height for comfort without causing problems for a high arch.  My toes aren't crowded, and there's enough room to put on a second pair of socks if I am concerned about my feet becoming too cold in our (sometimes) well-below zero temperatures.  The leather is soft, so they do slouch a bit, but so many boots are made that style anyway.  You can dress them up or down.  I have muscular calves and the boots are a little loose around the top, but the strap and buckle are adjustable, so that problem was solved easily, too.  I liked them so well, I got another pair and gave them as a gift to my daughter-in-law.  She loves them as much as I do!
1128718
I ordered these boots in black, size 8. I. Normally I wear a 7 and a half, but after reading the reviews I ordered a half size up. They fit perfectly, and they are way more comfortable than I anticipated. Yes, they do smell weird right out of the box. But as other the reviews said, a night or two outside or in the garage takes care of that. These boots are very cute, and surprisingly well constructed for the price. They do not look or feel cheap. I'm very happy with these boots.
4851351
I bought these for much-needed additional ankle support for an upcoming walking tour. They were comfortable right out of the box and so far so good as I break them in in various situations (walking, hiking, standing, outdoor work) and with different socks. I have high arches, wide feet, and problematic toes, so the more generous fit is wonderful. I would happily backpack in these boots.
4095054
I bought these boots from amazon at a bargain for $65, a fantastic deal.  These boots are very nice, quality construction and materials. The fit is spot on and surprisingly comfortable right out of the box.  If the black color goes on sale, i'd definitely buy another pair in that color, too.

I would like to add that the brown color of the stock photos on amazon is off.  The color of my boots are a medium brown and do not have the reddish tone that the amazon pictures have.  I prefer the basic brown color over the reddish brown color seen in the stock photo so I won't reflect this negatively in my review.

These boots really hit that sweet spot of a casual everyday boot in style, comfort and functionality.  Not too dressy and not too casual, you can wear them with jeans or slacks.  Not too bulky and heavy or flimsy and light,  they offer the perfect amount of support and stability.  The rubber sole with the light traction allows me to wear them in the rain, snow or ice.
2169322
These are the most comfortable out of the box boots I have ever bought. The color is spot on with the picture. They look awesome!
2579823
Having worn many brands of work boots over my 40 years, I really didn't know what to expect from these boots.  The reviews were great but I was cautiously waiting for the verdict myself.  After wearing them now for 2 days, I can honestly say they are the most comfortable boots out of the box that I have ever owned.  I've owned Wolverines, Justin's, Rocky's, Harley Davidson brand (which are mostly Wolverines), Dan Post, Ariat, Tony Llama, on and on, and no boots have ever felt like this.  Sizing is what I expected.  I wear an 11-11.5 on average (11.5 Nike, 12 Asics, 11 most boots, dress shoes usually 10.5).  I went with the 10.5 and they are perfect.  Leather is a little rigid around the moc toe flex point of the foot but nothing too uncomfortable.  I think they will break in very nicely.  Great boot at a great price on Amazon with the discount offered.  Highly recommend!  Going to buy a brown pair down the road.
1292089
I've purchased several pairs of boots at this price point over the past few years, and so far these exceed expectations. They are by far the most comfortable that I've had, including a larger opening at the top that allows pants to be tucked inside easily and allows for much more natural gait. Size seems pretty accurate - I wear a 9 or 9.5 shoe, and the size 9 in these boots is a tad snug with socks, but comfortable.
1021693
I was a bit hesitant to by boots online but these boots are not so bad considering I am still breaking them in.
2113686
very comfortable right out of box.i expected a stiff boot that would require a break-in of sore feet ,but they actually feel great.
3420340
This is the first pair of Muck Boots I've ever owned. We recently moved to a farm and I needed something that was easy and quick to get on and off but would also keep my feet warm and dry during daily chores. These boots fit all of that criteria. They are surprisingly comfortable with a cushiony insole that offers moderate arch support. They work well for ladies with muscular calves, there is substantial room. The only criticisms I have is that they aren't as warm as they claim to be. They've been fine for me thus far, but the temperature hasn't been below 20 degrees since I've owned them. I can tell that in colder temperatures they won't keep my feet as warm as I'd like, but I'll just double up on wool socks. I would also like to see a lip on the back heel of the boots to allow them to be taken off a little easier without having to use my hands. Being on a farm, things get on my boots that I don't necessarily want to be sticking my hands in when I try to slip them off. If there was a lip on the heel I could use my opposite foot to slip the boot off. All that being said, these boots are the definition of comfort, I never expected a boot like this to offer comfort at this level.
2234008
These boots needed no break in, comfortable right out of the box. They run very slightly bigger than my Ariats of the same size but this allowed me to wear them all day the first day.  I got these to wear at work in hospitals walking, standing and moving around for long days of up to 24hrs plus. So far Ive worn them for a 20 hr day and my feet felt better in these durangos than any other shoes i have.
2144558
I got these for gardening but have been pleasantly surprised by how comfortable they are.
2347569
I've only worn the boots once since I received them ( the weather is in the 70-80's), but they were very comfortable. I expected a breakin period, but that is not going to be necessary. They are heavier than what I'm used to. They were relatively easy to put on and take off - not as difficult as I expected.
I think I'm really going to enjoy them if it ever gets cold here!
2407139
I was pleasantly surprised with the comfort and design this sandal provides