Loose dirt, no problem
352166
Its ok, but of course you won't get any strong suction.  It will pick up sand, dirt and maybe a found French fry.
I would not buy it again though.
3617158
Great for high traffic areas...does not show lint or basic dirt.
2797503
What can you say  about a toilet brush ? Well does exactly what it is suppose to . It's small enough to neatly tuck away behind the "throne" and the  design works to get the whole bowl clean especially under the rim . I have no complaints .
2942970
I bought this so I wouldn't have to drag Rubbermaid Brute trash cans full of yard waste to the curb every week. It works fine, and I can put my other garbage cans on it, too.
622176
I bought this mat for the kitchen sink. It seems to work just fine; however, I've noticed that it collects all the dirt that ever was. I haven't really poured anything on it to test its absorbency, but it passes the comfort test; what else could you ask for?
783718
Bottom is not as grippy as I'd like it to be, but it does its job well at catching dirt
315237
No issues. It's done its job well since I've had it.  Rain, dirt, bird crap, random crap. You can hose it off to keep it looking clean. The zippers are a nice addition so you don't have to pull the whole thing off when you need to grab or add wood.
2227239
I haven't noticed any mud, dirt, or sludge in my coffee since using one of these, so they must be working.  (smile).  The packaging is kind of plain or strange - a bunch of filters arrive in a plain plastic bag.  Just the basics.  Enjoy.
2804822
This part fits perfectly and has functioned well.  I have no complaints about the product as it was reasonably priced and does what it is supposed to do (trap dirt) effectively.
3401338
It works the way that it should. It doesn't leave smudges or anything like that.
1124766
It picks up dirt like a dream and not a nightmare. Easy to use handle, with a cord long enough to do more than just one room and a hallway.
1569266
It fit and held dirt.  Well Done!!!
It's a good thing I knew the size and bag type or I might not be so happy.
447829
No problems. It gets the dirt out. Expect it to be like vacuuming but it takes a long time to do a room.
2852969
Collects extra dirt.  Not happy about that aspect.
855716
Problem with bag vacuums is replacement of the dirt bags - very necessary to find a source with replacement bags at a good price - these seem to fill the need nicely.  I order a lot of these at a time and have never had a problem. Also order other replacement bags for other vacuums I have.
3002025
Vacuum cleaner bags...what can one say except that they contain dirt, filter out dust, and don't rupture or tear. Pretty much a commodity item and these do the job at a decent price.
4194479
I've used this product for the two weeks now, and it works well. It covers a standard drain size well, and most, of not all, large articles are caught.
One thing to note is that it is extremely easier to keep clean compared to mesh products as it has flat edges and the holes don't retain soft material such as noodles, grains, or small produce bits.
The only down side I could see is that if you use ground material, like coffee, and want to use this to "catch" the grounds, it won't. Not a problem for us, but may be for others. If this is applicable, I'm sure you could put a finer mesh underneath to catch finer particulate matter.