Fit well, but the stitching/material made the skirt buckle ...
341092
Fit well, but the stitching/material made the skirt buckle on bottom no matter how much I ironed it. I finally resolved to tie front and side knots in it from now on.
2467322
I absolutely loved the dress until I noticed the poor stitching along the seams of the dress. I have attached photos of how the seam appears under the armpit and along the shoulder--there is white threading that is really unflattering along the black stitching. Overall, I was very satisfied with the fit. I'm 55, about 160lbs and chose the medium and it fit really well. However, if it weren't for the poor stitching, I would have kept it.
3938133
It fits properly and I like the style and length, but one of the belt loops came with loose stitching (pretty much about to fall off). The belt doesn't look the greatest either, it looks better without. The color is also slightly darker than I expected.
3604471
The skirt was accurate to the picture, and the sizing was as described.  The only problem I had was how the fabric was pieced together.  I chose the swan fabric because I liked it, but the seams ran right through the necks of the swans and the different pieces were not lined up, so the front of my skirt was decapitated birds.  On a smaller pattern or a solid I probably would have happily kept the skirt, but it did not meet my needs so I returned it.
2675729
My granddaughter loves her uniform skirt....especially since it has a skort underneath. The elastic in the waist was loose...so I reinforced it.
4641209
I liked the dress, but it had missed stitching where the knot in front is at. I'm fixing it myself. For the price, I kind of expected something like that. It fits well and looks good otherwise.
3602030
This skirt looks exactly as it was pictured in the add on Amazon.  I am nearly 6' tall, and weight roughly 146 lbs.  The skirt comes down just a bit below the knee on me.  I could take in the waist a bit, but had I ordered any smaller, the skirt would not have cleared my hips, so I'm glad I followed others' advice and went with the larger of the possible options (I ordered a medium). Unfortunately, there were some loose strings hanging from the seams on the outside of the skirt.  If not for that, based on the price and quality of the skirt I'd have given it 5 stars.
3981022
I had to remove the inner waste band due to it being sewn very wrong... I'm not sure how to even explain it but the band was bulging on the left side like rubbing into my hip. It was very uncomfortable. However the skirt material feels amazing so I will be keeping it. The slip underneath is very nice and light with a good amount of weight at the bottom to keep it from riding up. I would say the waist band was most likely a production error.
2597932
I bought two of these skirts (one in the red & green, one in the gray & pink) and really love them both. My one critique would be about the waist. I was bummed to find that what appeared to be an elastic waist out of the package was actually not true elastic, only crimped to give the appearance of being so. The tie in the front is also for show, there is no way to adjust the sizing on these without taking them in or out. But that was not a huge deal for me, just a small disappointment. There is a ton of fluffiness to these though, a great value for the price I thought. A note on the length, I am 5'6 and these hit about mid-thigh on me, so not SUPER short, but not full knee length.
2225795
This skirt has a nice hem versus the previous ones I purchased which were finished by zigzag stitching.
2791777
The stitching was not totally stitched all the way around.  I dealt with it. I also used my own Velcro.
1701474
This fit my XL frame pretty well so I have a hard time imagining how it would fit someone who wears a S. It's cute and comfy, but not made very well. It had loose threads from the first time I wore it. The hem is unraveling.
1241294
I was very excited to wear the two skirts I purchased. I received many complements. They can be difficult to match a top to, since the fabrics in the skirt sometimes don't go well together. At least there are two sides! The first skirt I got made it through two washings before coming apart, but the second one fell apart in the first wash. It was the better looking of the two, so I am very disappointed! The magic skirt is a better buy, since it's the seams of the patchwork that fray and come apart. My magic skirt is doing fine, and you can choose the one you want.

UPDATE: I have to add that I contacted the company, and they are sending me two replacement skirts. I was told that they should not be put in the washing machine, only hand washed. I admit that I did throw them in a load on delicate. It was not delicate enough! The seam on one was coming apart before I washed it though. I think some reinforcing is in order. They are very fun skirts, and fit perfectly. It's just too bad you can't pick what you get. Awesome customer service!!
4384748
Very nice fabric and design, good fit for my husband, but I had to sew up a seam after the first wearing.  That seems odd.  My husband is not heavy and it fit fine, but the stitching was not good.
4638861
I'm giving this item 4 stars because of the fact that when I went to buckle them the clasp got caught in between the Velcro and fabric. The Velcro and fabric on that part of the shoe was missing some stitching. It's not the end of the world for me so I won't be going through the hassle of returning the shoes.
767904
Not pleased with the stitching on this garment. Very untidy threads. I was hoping to give this to my daughter as a dress-up sort of elegantly casual outfit, but I guess she'll have to use it probably to run errands. The pic looks nice, but there raw elastic gathers at the waist ruined it. They should have included a sash to hide that
3329236
The buckle was a bit difficult to work as wasn't like most buckles! Very cute & good fit!