There is one departure from the book that might put some people off but I found it it be fine in the general context and did not
340760
Well acted and kept to the key points in the book which explains why it is a little long (2.5 hours) but definitely worth it to keep all these elements in the film.  There is one departure from the book that might put some people off but I found it it be fine in the general context and did not take away from my overall enjoyment of the movie.
2238197
I would be considered a Bible scholar; therefore, I would read very few books about the Bible that I wouldn't find some flaw in.  It's a good book, though
4519249
It was interesting and amusing, at least to those who are not devotees of the Bible.  I would assume than many would find it extremely irritating and insulting, although it might give them a glimpse how others think.  It did not get 5 stars because his approach might be counterproductive in reaching people who did not agree with his point of view.
2528928
Normally, I don't feel the need to read the full version of a book after I've read the summary and analysis of it. However, after reading this, it had the exact opposite effect on me. The author does a good job portraying the book in an interesting way, which made me re-consider reading the full version. It's interesting to hear his perspective, as the many that I've heard before, weren't too positive because of how Atticus is portrayed completely different in this novel. Reading this gave me new perspective to think about.
4013924
Some of the ambivalence during a good part of the book was hard to take, but it doesn't mean it wasn't spot on.  That's exactly like what it can be for folks who aren't following what society says they should be doing.  It was neat to have a variety of different reactions to how lesbians are treated in our society.  And the ending was more than worth it.
4769041
The author was very effective at making his point without resorting to histrionics.
4078859
I will first admit not to being a tween and biased in my opinion of this book, but it was still a good read and I would recommend it  to others who are into the genre
3284277
Scalzi is one of those writers who doesn't hide what he's doing, but writes compellingly so that you don't even notice the scaffolding and wires - or indeed, they add to the story. I was very amused at the few people who didn't like the book. I understand why, and it's fine. This novel approach to a story may not be for everyone, but it was certainly for me.
3032321
I am not a typical reviewer and I don't normally like urban fantasy - whatever that is - but I bought this book and actually enjoyed reading it.  Some of the parts bothered me because I don't think it was completely developed, but generally speaking it was not a bad read and I would recommend it to someone who is looking for something new.
4491972
The design certainly doesn't smack you in the face but then again, it would appeal only to those in the know...
4714664
It is not often you read a title of a book ,(and agree with it) and wind up with the attitude of having a change of mind
2437422
I read this book looking for something "different" to try. After trying the sample on my kindle, and how it starts with an execution, I thought "Well, this is different".

Getting into the book however, it's really not that different from other mystery books I've read. It's still a mystery, it's just set in a different time, which I suppose in itself is different. While it wasn't "out there" as much as I thought, it was still a good read. If anything, it was interesting having a peek at what life in the mid 1600s was like.

It's title is a bit deceiving as it's not really about the Hangman or his daughter, but how the two work together with a doctor to find the real culprit of the crimes. The title doesn't say much or really match but I felt the description of the book was right on with the story so I didn't feel deceived.

While I wasn't on the edge of my seat, I did find myself looking forward to my next reading time in my schedule. And I was happy with how the story was written, flowed and ended. And I'd recommend it as a decent reading. Maybe it was different enough.
2267135
The book was written in a little more than I expected but it was okay.
3932951
Probably not completely accurate but it is though provoking.
1405533
I thought the book was better at some times than others, but I liked it. I did like the way it ended. It's not one I would push anyone to read because there are so many other books that are so much better but reading it would not be a waste of time. I guess I mean I thought it was a little bit better than OK.
4297537
It wasn't my kind of book and I had some issues with the writing style, but overall it wasn't bad.
2230226
I like it a lot but was led to believe, by review, that it would have less impact on exposure than it does. That being said, it's on the good side of normal.