A boot and a shoe -but not wrong-footed
357191
There are some prickly reviewers out there. Some people obviously didn't like this -which is fine, but they sound like they didn't like it for all the wrong reasons. Sam is no longer Leslie and Leslie no longer Sam and vice-versa (although they are the same). This is an interesting album, and Sam Phillips writes twisty and intruiging lines. The musicianship is impeccable and there's a late-night kind of feel to it. While it doesn't possess the lighter moments that highlight "Fan Dance", it's probably reflective of her own troubles at the time of writing. The song 'Help is coming' (one day late) is my favourite track. It sounds like a sad song and probably comes from pain but seems to be suggest that answers do come but not according to our demands, or notions of punctuality. I guess it's a believing persons version of clouds with silver linings.
2269153
A fine boot bag, does what it is supposed to do.
2456932
There is something sharp in the toe of one of the boots. A bit of a defect. Not super happy. One bit is a bit deformed
1623272
The Vine newsletter calls these "Fashion Boots" but that doesn't appear anywhere in the Product page. To me, this suggests things like Uggs or oversized hip-hop Timbs, or Nike's sneaker/boots, meaning tall footwear that provides little support.

Also, just looking at it, with that big bold N on the side, and the unique spoiler-thingy on the back, you expect this to be more like a sneaker than a boot.

But surprise surprise, this would be a fine boot for duty if your uniform policy allows for subdued branding. I got the all-black boots and the logo and triangle on the toe are black, but shiny and somewhat reflective, so definitely not subdued enough to wear in my case, but policies vary. In all probability, this was intended for casual urban wear probably with loose pants. More on that later.

They're very supportive with a nice rigid but well padded upper (AKA shaft) that doesn't bite into the shin or calf. No hot-spots.

They're not terribly wide or narrow, very middle-of-the-road.

They're a generous length compared to sneakers, but pretty par for a boot which typically gives more allowance for thick socks.

The soles have an aggressive tread pattern that's excellent on rough level surfaces like concrete or asphalt, which is one reason I said it would make a good duty boot rather than a hiking boot. It would probably do well on trails and dry stones, but I'd be concerned on loose surfaces and wet stones.

Insulation is nice. It's noticeably warmer than non-insulated boots, but breathes well and doesn't get too sweaty. That WILL change with age. All of my insulated boots have gotten caked and no long breathe, leading to sweatier and sweatier feet. These will suffer the same fate, but hopefully not too soon, since they're quite nice.

And the clever "spoiler" on the back of the boot looks peculiar to say the least when you look at the photos. OK, let's just call it what it is, hideous. But when it's worn with loose fitting pants (i.e., a normal pair of jeans, not parachute pants and not skinny hipster jeans) you can't see the spoiler. The pant cuff hides the shaft and spoiler and it just looks like black sneakers. The spoiler keeps the back of the pants from dragging on the ground, which leads to dirty torn cuffs and premature wear. So, it's not meant to be a designer feature, but a practical feature.
3859221
nice leather,fits a bit small, but overly satisfied with this boot.
2192664
The boot is very confortable, but at the same time it's a little too wide, it might take a few times wearing it to get more used to it.

Pleased!
327275
The boots are geat, however, it is a little bit bigger than my feet even i ordered the right size. I give it 5 stars anway.
1895548
So far after using these boots for about a week I am favorably impressed. I am not a huge fan of the insoles that come with it, but as with any shoe it is an easy fix. Once Laced comfortably these are some of the best boots I have had. Though it is worth noting that they are heavier than a lot of boots. (I am thinking of Jungle Boots, and some random boot in a similar style whose brand I forget) The sole is also quite thick, I found this to not really influence my opinion of these boots, but I am sure thoughts will vary.
4947543
Box had slight external damage on outside corner.  No injury to boots.
4310499
Had a kind of funny fit especially the top of the shoe.
1469495
I liked the boot style and it is comfortable even though its a little large. Nothing that a pair of socks could not take care of. Nice arch support.
924538
They look good, but not the square toe I was expected like my other pair. They aren't pointy and they aren't rounded, they are more of a rounded square toe. The inside of the boot is very comfortable. The leather seems very soft. Nice to look at, but I'm curious what they will look like after a couple of weeks of riding.
4248924
These boots are good. They aren't too expensive, they aren't too flashy and they have a bit of a heel. They fit the size expected, although I would like to warn you that they do require some breaking in. When I cracked open the box the shoelaces seemed to small and the boots seemed a bit tight, but all you have to do is tie them and untie them a few times and wear them for a few days and theyll fit perfectly. Also not that the zipper is fake and although it does zip up and down it doesnt help you get into the shoes.
741680
Not your ordinary snow boot. They and cute, stylish, feminine and rugged at the same time. I can shovel my front walk, take a stroll and go out to dinner all in the same shoe. So that alone makes up for them being a bit on the pricier side. If you think about it really they are three shoes  in one.
1794451
It's a nice looking boot, but not very comfortable until I added a foam insert with arch support. The boot is roomy enough to allow for an insert for extra cushioning.
92492
Perfect to use as a work boot but able to be a little dressier.
1094724
First off, a little info:
1.  Contrary to what another reviewer has said, the shaft is real leather, and the lining is real shearling.
2.  The shearling covers the shaft and footbed, but it does *not* extend over the top or sides of the foot beyond the shaft.  I'm not sure why they did this, other than the fact that they would have needed to make the rubber part bigger to accommodate the wool.  There *is* a soft fabric lining there, with what feels like some insulation.  Another reviewer wrote to say that her feet were cold in very chilly temps--this may be why.
3.  This boot does not have Crocs' clogs squishiness in the insole.  It has quite a bit less give, at least out of the box.  It may break in after some wear, though.  Just don't expect that kind of cushiness.
4.  As others have written, it is more "shoe sized" than the clogs--closer-fitting in all dimensions.  I ordered the same size in the boot as I wear in the clog.  It fits, but my toe is quite close to the end, where it's considerably looser in the clog.
5.  The proper way to wear shearling-lined boots is barefoot.  The lining both keeps feet warm and allows them to breathe.  My fully-lined leather mukluks keep my feet toasty no matter the temp.  Because these aren't *fully lined* I may have to add socks in colder weather.  We'll see...
6.  The folded part of the shaft does stand up--BUT the tongue does NOT extend, so the laces will not go all the way to the top to hold the unfolded shaft in place.  Weird.

I ordered these to have a warm, lightweight boot to slip on and run outside, walk the dog, etc., even when it's yucky out.  My old duck boots were heavy and unlined, so I thought I'd check these out.  Because of #2 above, they may not be perfect, but the waterproofness, shearling lining and ease of putting on/taking off make them a better choice than some other, lower-cost boots.  And they're actually surprisingly cute (and who thought they'd live to say that about Crocs?).  I may replace the laces with elastic, if I can find something I like, to make the boots completely pull-on.
The one uncomfortable aspect of these boots involves the fold where the tongue is sewn to the shaft.  When the laces are loose, the unfinished leather of the seam may rub uncomfortably against your leg.  Once the laces are snugged, the shearling keeps it away from your skin (or your sock).  I may sew a piece of fleece over this area, or get my cobbler to do it.