Thighs and Calves too large!
354607
Waist was okay. From the thighs down to the calves the trousers were much, much too big. I cannot imagine wearing these in a work environment because they would like get caught on something and cause an accident. I will be returning these.
4370828
Made for fat legs. Should fit most American women with fat calves, but not those who are in shape and of proper weight.
2857554
The pants arrived in a timely fashion, and they appear to be good quality, however if you have curvy or thick thighs... steer clear! The pants are WAYYY too long (and I'm 6ft. tall) and they are HUGE everywhere besides the thighs where they are SO TIGHT I was afraid to sit down! I was a size 10-12 pre-pregnancy so, I ordered a Large/Tall... the fit is terrible. I'll DEFINITELY be sending them back!
832581
These boots were too way too large in the calf. My feet are long, but not wide and neither are my calfs. The assumption is always that if your feet are long, your calfs must be big. I want boots that fit my average size calfs.
2283582
I ordered a larger size to accommodate my hips and thighs. The 2XX size was HUGE! Had to send them back. I had to send them back, but I will try this brand again.
954690
If you have thighs, forget it. These are really clingy and make your thighs look huge!  I was hoping the wider leg would hide my thighs, not accentuate them!!
4975618
Got these to replace a pair of my BP over the knee boots that were ruined...no such luck. The entire boot was too big - the calf, the midsole and the heel.
1637302
They were too large this time! I've been buying Gold Toe Socks for more than 20 years and these extended up my leg when I put them on, even after washing and drying on hot.
1160404
Those boots are very long. I am 5ft 6 and do not have short legs but those boots came up on a weird lengths. They hit just under my knee and kept on wrinkling up in the front. Did not look nice. Also, they are very wide. I do have quite big calfs but they were still too wide
3676344
Three stars for overall style, zero stars for the calf fit. I'm the kind of person who does a ton of research before investing in a pricey item, so I read most of the reviews of this item here and on other websites, measured my calves (17 inches) against the measurements for the regular Penny (15 inches), and thought I'd be good to go with the wide calf boot. Not so much. It's not that the calves were HUGE, they were just too big for my liking. It looked like I was wearing over sized rain boots or something. I thought for sure I'd have been right with the measurements, but sure enough, I looked up the measurements for another pair of riding boots I have that fit me fine and they measured 14 inches. I'm returning these for the regular Penny boots.

Also - these boots are VERY tight in the foot. I really wish Amazon carried wide sizes for these boots!
1204121
calf size not for normal legs, at least 3 inch gap of extra fabric. If you have huge calves these are for you. Promptly returning. Love the look otherwise.
2076149
The item is too big got my legs. I intend to give it to a friend. In the future, the item description should talk about calf and generally leg size
1587968
ordered xxl sizing said it would fit the top of the thighs at 33 inches and i could only get it to mid thigh with ALOT of struggle from knee to toe it fit fine i have 18 inch calfs but thigh no go my ankles measure at 10 in calfs at 18 above knee at 20 mid thigh 24 and top of thigh 33 if you have big thighs don't order this it will not fit waste of money i will be tring to return these hopefully they don't give me issues with it
262439
Sadly, I couldn't post 5 stars. Just too big! I have 19" calves and they were swimming on me. When I tightened the straps the boot had an unsightly bulge. I could pull me foot right out. I had to return them. That's why the 3 stars. I really wanted to like them but they were too big even with thicker socks. I'll keep looking. The return with Amazon? Wow! I've shopped and had to return online a few times. Amazon's return policy is seamless!!! I will talk about Amazon with my friends and I'll keep shopping. Thanks folks.
4883007
Nice quality and nice looking boots, but they run a little big. Also, the calf is very wide and baggy looking. I would say these are meant for people with large calves. I wish the description of the item would include the shaft circumference. As much as I liked the look of these boots, they had to be returned.
1561156
The shaft around my calf was too big. Usually is. : / I am tall and do not have large legs - they are normal - but boots like this are made for bigger legs. Frustrating. They are super cute in appearance though. I was super bummed I couldn't keep them.
1259879
I swear to God there are no COOL looking boots out there that are made for women with fat calves! I seen the description "Wide Shaft Boot" and I measured my calves the week or two before and figured they might be a little snug, but should be able to zip up if I wear with bare legs and a dress. I got them and I can't get the top 4 inches zipped up! So Mad! I haven't decided weather or not to keep them. I really like the boots and I hope I'm not a fat person forever, but I might always be too fat and so they may never fit :(