Company might want to test these cookies.
356587
Purchased Organic Animal Crackers at Costco. Each time I ate them, I experienced symptoms associated with mild ototoxicity, specifically a headache, a feeling of ear fullness (just short of a rushing noise in my ears), and mild loss of balance. By process of elimination, I determined that the symptoms were uniquely and consistently related to eating the cookies. The cookies tasted and smelled fine. They are probably the best tasting animal crackers I have eaten. They were not spoiled.  I have no food sensitivities. I have let Costco know. Some of the substances known to cause this are lead, manganese, and mercury. It does not say where the cookies are made. http://vestibular.org/ototoxicity
4076119
I've only opened 2 of the 6 packages of cookies.  One of the packages was fine, the other had some broken up cookies in it.

I'm not sure why or how they were broken, the package they were shipped in was fine and they were shipped carefully.  The 6 packages of cookies looked fine inside the box.  Nothing to indicate there was anything broken inside.

So, I've decided not to do anything more regarding complaining or shipping them back.  I'll keep them, they're delicious!

I figure for the extra $20 or so I paid, it's worth it as it is clear to me that the shipper went the extra mile in sending them with care.

If there is anyone to blame, I put it on Pepperidge Farm as there is no local grocery store that a poor ol' southernn boy can get them!
1415857
I use to always look forward to the girl scout annual cookie sell.  This year my co worker brought in the cookies and the recipe is different and the size is smaller.  Just a shame.  They should have left the recipe the same.  This year I won't buy them.  On the bright side I won't gain the extra pounds as I always purchase 36 to 48 boxes.  But I will miss the cookies.
4641041
Some cookie packs are smashed and the cookie crumbles when opened. We were also shorted 3 packs, can't find where or how to report that. The cookies themselves are ok. Not stale.
4632255
These are okay for packaged cookies. All of the different types were hard and not to thick. I wish they were a bit chewier but that is my preference. They tasted well with milk and I did eat them all..
I thought the flavor was good and it had enough chocolate and macadamias though.. And the oatmeal raisen had raisens. You could tell the ingredients were in there in a good way...
I would not say they are homemade.. I do not think I would buy these myself but someone who does not have time to bake may like them and if you like your cookies on the crunchy side. .
4324714
The cookies where melted and stuck together as one three large cookies.  The taste of the cookie was delicious.  I would buy them again but when the weather is colder.
2454592
<div id="video-block-R2J229G1BH2DO6" class="a-section a-spacing-small a-spacing-top-mini video-block"></div><input type="hidden" name="" value="https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/91tSyy-3OES.mp4" class="video-url"><input type="hidden" name="" value="https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/21v-jwgp0tS.png" class="video-slate-img-url">Update2: we continue to buy these cookies, and have yet to find another shard.

Update1: no more shards since then, so boosted the rating on the product. Company never responded to email to corporate, however. Also, Amazon price is climbing, cancelled the subscription as local price is good enough.

Original:
One of my family just found a piece of plastic in one of the cookies. It measures about a half inch long, and an eight inch wide, and is thin. It is stiff, and has sharp corners. Fortunately the person didn't get hurt.

We love these cookies and have eaten at least dozens if not hundreds this year. This is the first time we have found something in one of these cookies. The cookie came from a package of Ginger Cookies with Sliced Almonds just delivered this week, with the Expiration Date of 2011Jan06E.
4360934
But I like them enough to find them at amazon.com...so I ended up purchasing. They have more cookies
per container, better value than pepridge farms
1390094
I really liked these cookies.  Not sure if I did something wrong or not but in some bites the cookie was very salty flavored.  But over all I would buy this product again.  Not sure if anyone else has had this problem with the flavor or not.
12466
They are a nice tasting cookie. I don't think this is the market to buy fresh bakery items. Arrived in box half melted, we are in Florida. Not sure if I trust how hot they got, makes me wonder about the freshness.
3914691
I like the taste of these cookies but they contain a genetically altered ingredient and I do not eat any products that contain altered ingredients.
2647375
The Barnett's Holiday Gift Cookies is nicely packaged.  I plan to use it as a gift.  Will hopefully get feedback on the cookies
412341
They were okay.  I couldn't taste the toffee and there wasn't much flavor. This company has great cookies but this would not be my first choice.
2531991
This is a gift, but they seem to be a wonderfu idea, especially for someone who
bakes often.  Environmentally friendly.
2760130
This cookies are super olways love this cookies end so my kids like this cookies y thanks to tha workers at Amazon. My love .kises .& love amazon.
2948399
Some of the cookies were broken (not a big deal to me), they still tasted marvelous.

However, after I ate one I realized they were out of date by 3 weeks.

I called Amazon and they refunded my purchase price.

I think Amazon has great customer service.

There was no way Amazon could have known the sell by date, as the cookies were sealed in a Wild Oats box.
1383865
Loved the cookies but did not like that I had to pay more in shipping than I paid for the cookies.  But the person I bought them for is really enjoying them