My bird cage has horizontal bars. This feeder only ...
342014
My bird cage has horizontal bars.  This feeder only fits a cage with vertical bars.  I can't use it at all.
748093
I liked this feeder because of it's being a different color than usual, but that could possibly be it's downfall.  My hummers wouldn't touch it.  I put the old red ones back up and they flocked to them.  I guess I'll just try again next year.
118220
The design is an improvement over an Audubon caged tube type wild bird feeder that it replaced. The method of holding the cap on is improved but some experimentation was required to understand its mechanism. I'm using a no waste bird food which flows well to the very bottom.
3933096
I am now feeding just the birds - not the squirrels AND the birds.  They squirrels still get into my old feeder but this one they stay out of this one.  I'm thinking of buying a second one and getting rid of the old run.
4000758
While I like the look of this bird feeder very much: appreciate how much seed/fruit/nuts it holds: and am amazed at the amount of birds it attracts, (perhaps because of it's size and color) we're not crazy about what else it attracts. This product states that it's squirrel proof. Not only is it not squirrel proof (since we go outside to find squirrels hanging from the side of the feeder and emptying it quite quickly)but it also seems to attract and feed rats. cringe worthy, but true....we evidently have a rat family living underneath our pond. They climb up the tree, across the branches and hang off the side of the feeder as well, having no trouble eating their breakfast, lunch or dinner. They have good taste because we only use high grade nuts, fruits & berries in the feeder. At first we couldn't figure out how a feeder of such large size could be empty within 4 or 5 days. Perhaps the "cage" around the feeder needs to be moved a bit further away from the holes in the inner plastic feed holder so animals can't reach it? In any event, the feeder does it's job and we've now become avid bird watchers in our own back yard. A bit of a redesign might be in order.
337618
Definitely an improvement over my previous feeder - but not totally effective. We have a wide assortment of birds we feed and if I set the tension so that doves can feed it also allows squirrels to climb down the feeder and eat. I added a baffle above the feeder and discovered that the raccoons can now access the feeder and turn it upside down to empty the seeds. I would welcome any solutions at mginsatx@outlook.com
3628349
It is a good product but I didn't realize my cage wire is horizontal not vertical... I had to improvise.
3952462
I have an arbor-like area on my deck where this feeder fit beautifully. I did not use water (I have a birdbath) but filled both sides with seed. One side sunflower, one side regular birdseed. Unfortunately, squirrels can easily access it and because it is made of plastic, it has gotten a bit chewed up. All my other feeders are squirrel-proof and hang from a tree. I wish there was a way to out-smart the squirrels so they would leave this feeder alone because it is very pretty from afar.
2949297
I already have a lucite bird feeder. It doesn't have a removable tray, and I thought I would like this one better.  However, the removable tray flips out if a squirrel even grabs at it mid-leap.  It's not a great window feeder.
1442572
I purchased this feeder as the other feeder I had was leaving a gigantic mess on my patio.  This feeder has been hanging for 2 weeks and the birds have not decorated my concrete with their bird-seed confetti.
4799801
This is a very nice looking feeder.  However, it doesn't have enough access holes in it and the birds pretty much ignored it when we first got it.  I drilled more holes (roughly tripling the original number) and now they use it all the time.  It still isn't as popular as another one we have that has a mesh construction.  This one is well made, easy to fill and clean.
3672
My only problem is that is could be a little sturdier.  You also have to be careful that you balance the different bird feeders on it well, of it starts to lean
1020908
I love this bird feeder.  Before making the investment, though, I checked reviews and sent in a question asking whether crows could access the ports, since they have been a major nuisance at my earlier feeder.  I got several prompt responses that generally reassured me, so I went ahead and bought the Classic. Every squirrel that tried to access it fairly quickly gave up, but the crows in my neighborhood are more clever, apparently, than those in the yards of the people who responded to my question, for they were quickly chowing down at the feeder.  After a little experimentation, however, I determined that adding a 2 oz. fishing sinker to the bottom of the Classic (using a paper clip to attach it) adds just enough weight to cause the additional weight of the crows to close the port, but not enough weight to prevent access by all the other birds.  I'll probably get a second one for my yard.
4663541
Birds really don't feel that comfortable getting under the clear umbrella to get their food.  Only the smallest ones even try but prefer other feeders.  On the positive side, no squirrels use it either.
79212
I agree with the statements about having multiple birds feed on this feeder.  We have had large bluejays, cardinals, small chickadees all on this feeder at the same time.  I have it in a tree that is small in size hanging with a hook.  Have not had any clinging birds yet.  I am in an urban area so that may have something to do with it.
924034
The cage is great, and holds the food bars I have which is what I wanted, but my birds here in southern California don't seem to like it!
3721980
Birds love this and half a dozen can feed at once!
The squirrels appear less comfortable with this feeder and they rarely are in it.