Waterproof in ankle-deep puddle.
344689
I like it so much, I bought a second pair. I stepped in ankle-deep water, and my feet stayed dry. Nice and warm too.
351549
These boots are very nice except for the fact that I got wet feet every time I wore them. The boots were comfortable and fit just right I wear a 9 and the 9 fit great. I work outside as a landscaper so my #1 thing is boots must be waterproof. I walked in wet grass,I didn't even work in rain or standing water, my feet weren't soaking wet but wet enough for me to notice. They might have been fine if I coated them in mink oil but on the boot it says in 2 places waterproof so I shouldn't need to.
2981099
It's been raining in Florida for two weeks straight. This is not unusual. It is nasty on footwear. These are lightweight, like crocs, and ventilated. There's little holes in the soles of the shoes that let water though. This has made puddle jumping and soggy grass walking bearable. I got my husband a set of these in Black and mens. Well worth the value at the price Amazon is selling them at :)
495995
Sizes run a little larger than average. That's OK I just wear an extra heavy pair of socks, which helps for warmth as well. Soles have good traction & so far no leaks. Great for sloshing around outside during heavy rains.
4962599
I'm still wearing them and hope they will break in, as it's only been about a week. They are very sturdy and comfortable though. I haven't tried stepping in any puddles, so I can't attest if they are waterproof.
3506266
Purchased for my husband and he wore them today to work.  He said they're soaked and he can literally ring the water out of them.  I bought them because they were to be waterproof.
4125597
Waterproof on the outside, but if water comes in over the top, it takes a really long time to dry  out.  Also, it may not be apparent from the photos, but the toes of the boots are very asymmetrical.
4570475
These are comfortable, water proof to a good degree with easy to slide into zipper. Shoe laces are quite long. Love the color.
4173523
they seem to "leak". Even in dry snow his socks are wet around the area where the ankle strap is. This happens even if he wears snow pants over the boots. We had the same issue with kamik RAINboots. strange. His feet are always warm and cozy.
2814687
I have tried these on but have not worn them out in the weather yet. I ordered them in my regular shoe size based on reviews here. One foot rubs a little bit at the big toe but the other foot is fine (we all tend to have one foot that is slightly larger than the other). I expected this because these shoes are waterproof therefore; they do not stretch. You do not want them to be any larger because they would flop off of your feet. Once again it's to be expected with a  waterproof product.

I love the lining, my rain boots are not lined therefore; my feet tend to get cold even with socks so these will be better but you'd definitely want to wear thin socks.

This brand had the best reviews for a waterproof product at a medium price point.
3303237
They are a little large (I bought my regular size) but work with thick socks.  Great for sloshing around puddles and mud on rainy days and walking the dog!  Good value and workmanship.  I'd definitely recommend!
2037845
Bought these to contend with wet fall weather.  They are a little large without socks but still comfortable and seem to be waterproof.  They look nice enough to wear to work with skirts, casual dresses, and pants.
2854118
The boot is waterproof and holds up well to walking at the dog park, which is why I bought it
1932064
The low cut material on the front of the shoe allows moisture through. This caused my socks to get wet. This was from walking through 2-6 inches of snow.
645377
Waterproof short & tall boot. Beautiful color
403702
Terrible when it rains. The water soaks right through. Otherwise a really cute, comfortable shoe that goes with almost anything in my closet!
3690311
Nice and waterproof, accidentally watered my shoe while filling a bucket and my sock stayed totally dry. I have to wear thinner socks with these shoes as I think they're meant to be worn sockless which I do not prefer.  They have good arch support and my feet don't feel as tired after a long day at work. Highly recommend!