Easy to break in; once done, they are amazing
353058
I love these flip flops.  I buy a new pair every 6 months because I wear them all the time.  Very comfortable, fit your foot perfectly.  I have wide feet so can't wear some of the more trendy flip flops.  Good thing, too, as these Roxy's are way less expensive and very comfy.
1003106
I've had them a year and love them more.  Most shoes breakdown in a way you don't want them to.  These haven't.  I require a well-constructed shoe.  These didn't look like they were that well constructed, but they are.  When they arrived and were too narrow I thought about an exchange for wider shoe.  But I don't follow-up well.  So, I started wearing them without socks. Unbelievably they are excellent without socks, which I would never have believed someone, had I heard this in advance.  they stretched a little wider, I bought a half-size larger than my "shoe size" and I think getting the 1-size narrower than I might normally order because wider wasn't available.  they do lace up so I could wear socks now, but I don't.  Living in the South USA, that makes them a good year round shoe for knocking around indoors and out. Loosen the laces and they slip on and off.  Sand isn't sticking to the sole and then carried indoors.  Water runs off.  A light rub with a damp cloth will clean them -- I bought the brown (only choice) and am glad because the sand here makes everything look dirty.  pull out the insert and wash separately.  Use the damp cloth inside and they feel good as new on your bare feet.  I have to pick function and comfort over looks.  For me, function and comfort is difficult to find and you get that with these. I wear them everyday.  so I'm ready to buy these again. DUNHAM Brighton Oxford size 7N? Normally purchase 7M or W.
3424379
After breaking them in a bit, they become super comfortable and will easily be your favorite shoes.  This is actually the second pair I've owned, since I wore the first ones out over the course of 5 years of daily use!
3402961
You don't have to wait to break them in. I love this shoe!
1365873
My new NB's were not very comfortable at first. They took a month or so to break in. Now, I love them!
4893089
They need to be broken in, then they will be great.
717221
Fantastic boots,, comfortable, easy to break in...
1751675
These took a while to break in and were pretty uncomfortable during that process; the top section/strap was really stiff, and the foot impressions really need to line up appropriately to be comfortable. But, once they did break in, they were great. I use these all the time - from walks around the neighborhood, to running errands to casual dinners out. They're definitely casual, but they don't look sloppy at all. I've been surprised to have received compliments from strangers on them a few times (just never assumed sandals were something random people would stop and notice). Despite frequent use, they still look great.  Arch support is great, especially for a sandal.  I usually wear a 5.5-6, and I got a size 36.
953147
I mean this literally. The first time I wore them I did so for about 2 hours and my toes felt a little squished. The second time I put them on I could feel they had already stretched and after wearing them all day my feet felt fine-good actually! They are the type of shoe that feels not rigid, exactly, but definitely conforming to your foot. Some people say go a half-size or size up but I disagree because the heel is on the loose side already and a bigger size would certainly fall off my foot. The shoes look awesome on- really great with jeans but smart with other pants as well and I think they'd even work with certain skirts or dresses. The heel height is ideal, and the cushioning inside is nice. For comparison information, I am a size 7.5 (and that's what I ordered) with a high arch and a foot that's on the wide side while still being regular width.
257558
Unlike the Iron Rangers, these actually feel like you could do some real work in them.  They also look great with any casual outfit; however, remember that they're boots.  Lace them up tight and please don't wear them with skinny jeans.

I normally don't believe in sizing down too much from your Brannock measurement, since boots are meant to have toe room and be worn with thick socks (looking at you, skinny jeans wearing hipsters).  However, these have a massive toe box and are long and narrow.  I am an 11D on the Brannock but a 10D fits snugly yet comfortably with no heel slip.  A 10.5D was just a little too long for my foot, and would break in a little loose.

The lack of speed hooks is irritating; these boots require a total unlacing in order to squeeze your feet in.  They'll loosen up, but for now they're time consuming to put on (with both a 10.5 and 10, similar difficulty).  However, Red Wing will install speed hooks FOR FREE at any Red Wing store.  I plan to do this in the future.

In conclusion, these are terrific boots that are meant to be worn like boots.  They'll last a long time and look great doing it.  Pick up a pair and some quality boot socks and you're good to go.
1186619
These did require some gentle breaking-in--the seam that runs across the front of the foot is less flexible than on my other pair of Toms, probably because the front toe area has an additional layer of lining that the rest of the shoe doesn't have.  After a few wears they've become one of my go-to summer shoes. They're comfy, and flexible, and breathable, and they go with darn near everything. They have actually held up VERY well--I've worn them off and on for a couple months now, and I haven't noticed any snags in the lace pattern at all. That's about all you can ask for in a flat.
576538
These shoes are great, took about a week to two weeks or 3-4 very long climbing sessions to break them in as well as wearing them around the house for as long as possible. These shoes are very comfortable for a crammed shoe and once you get used to the downturned tow you can really climb hard on very small pieces. The rubber per evolv is good, but not great.

SIZING (very important) - I read countless websites and reviews to determine my size and orderd 3 sizes (11, 11.5, & 12). I have a pair of 12 evolv defy vtr's which originally fit great/comfy and stretched to be comfy but stretched too much for higher performance. As such I decided to size these down despite the fact they do run about a half size smaller in size comparison to the defy shoe. The 11's I could barely get my feet into and I knew right away this wasn't going to work, the 11.5 I could get my feet in, but my feet really hurt wearing them. Mostly my right foot which is slightly bigger. The pain was bearable sitting and standing still, but walking hurt most (these really are meant to be taken off between climbs, which is fine since the straps make it easy to easily remove). The 12 fit nice, they were tight and my toes were in the perfect position right out of the box. HOWEVER, after reading about the materials, these are synthetic uppers with a leather liner as such they will stretch slightly but not a lot as such you want to size these to the point were it hurts and if they stretched a 1/4 - 1/2 size they would be perfect so i went with the 11.5 and have been pushing through the painful break in period which appears to be paying off slowly. I don't know if mine have stretched very much yet, but once they loosened from use they definitely got more comfy as well as my feet adjusting.

Very happy overall!
1489367
I love how they look but it will take some time to break them in.
2697939
Hated these on day one but gave them an honest effort. took a few days to break in but they are now my absolute favorite
3519340
It took me 3-4 wearings to break these in. The first few times I could only go a few hours, and I did end up needing a couple of bandaids. But that's so normal with new dress shoes that I don't think anything of it. And now they're my new go-to shoe. Completely comfortable for a full day, including a fair amount of walking, and classy to boot. Plus easy to match to a suit or nice jeans and blouse. Would definitely buy again when I wear this pair out.
3945178
After getting used to the fit of these boots, they are my new favorites.  The calf and upper instep area is cut very wide, making them super easy to slip on and off instead of fussing with the zipper every time.  They do give a different silhouette, but are very comfortable and well made, typical of Naturalized.
3183162
I love the look of these boots. Their easy to slip on/off. I'll re-buy them as long as they make them. My only issue is the break in, and maybe it was because I ordered them as suggested a half size smaller than usual; I should've returned for a bigger size but thought that after I break them in it will be fine which was true as now their just a bit snug. I'll buy them again, but next time go with my actual size.