Go with the blu ray if you have it....
358284
apparently I ordered this movie on DVD as well? I ordered it on Blu Ray and I guess by accident I purchased this on standard definition as well... Still an amazing movie
2295553
This was the number one movie to watch in the summer 2007 and it sure as heck will be the number one movie to own in Blu-ray format. HD-DVD is [...] in disguise, buy the Blu-ray version instead.
4773992
This is another one of my upgrade decisions. I hoped that the Blue Ray version would be better than the DVD. Alas no such luck. It may have more special effects and extras but it is the movies I watch. Can't tell the difference. Still like having them in the box all together but wasn't the upgrade I had hoped for. Seller met all expectations.
2714042
Finally on Blu-ray at a good price, but don't get rid of your DVD copy!
The DVD has MORE Bonus features, so keep both disks (bonus feature are SD anyway, so no loss)
4817262
Looked this up on a very reliable website (ninwiki.com) and the only real difference between the releases is the following:

The Blu-Ray and HD-DVD version have full 1080p high-definition playback for the main playlist.

So... if you are making a decision based on content, I hope this helps out. Unless you have the proper equipment to play back 1080p high-def it will not really matter.
2899624
We just purchased a PS3 and I decided to get this movie for the holidays.  It's ok I suppose, but don't waste your money on the blu-ray.  Just get the regular one for an ok movie...
3509199
So as of now, this blu ray set is $215, and the limited edition blu ray is cheaper at $175, I am scratching my head to figure out why this is more expensive and comes with less stuff. No digi copy. I would suggest to anyone considering this to look at the other boxed set with digi copy.
4527437
Be careful which one of these you buy.  The Blue-Ray is the one that is restored, and the music is upbeat and matches the action of the movie. The Televista DVD is fuzzy, the picture is centered with much chopped off. The stereo doesn't fit with the action,  or the scene changes., and the mood of the music is more serious. It's unclear if the one advertised as 'dual format - BlueRay + DVD' will actually play on a regular DVD player.
2131807
The answer is yes. This time it's in Blu-ray!
This makes the 5th copy that I own. Also the most expensive.
They had to stretch to get extras, buy it you will see what I mean.
929225
From the perspective of a Star Trek fan (all series) that currently owns the complete Next Generation on DVD, viewers of this Blu-ray will notice a slight improvement in picture and sound quality.  The item was purchased to see if it would be worth while to replace the DVD versions of the series when the Blu-rays are released.  Some may choose to make the investment (again) but for me it isn't worth the expense.  I am glad it came out in a low cost sampler version and that my favorite episode of the series, "The Inner Light" was included.  Bottom line, buy this Blu-ray, watch it on your own system and then decide if it is worth to replace your DVD versions.
1124899
This is just a ploy to take advantage of the customer. We know Blu-ray has extended space (7x!) vs DVD and they could seemlessly branch from theatrical to extended version of the movie. I have seen the extended version in the theaters (one-time back to back) so I know it is not a case of the effects being rendered at DVD resolution. Hold out for the extended edition. I do not even own a blu-ray and will not buy one until LOTR: extended editions come out.
1338687
OK, I'm really glad they released this on DVD however I do not want to be forced into buying a blue ray player
just to own this film. Why not a blue ray/DVD combo??? The one star is NOT for the movie, it's for the lack of
respect shown to the public.
2010320
Classic Movie.  the original Blu ray was terrible.
Get the Blu ray from The Filmmakers Series, which is much better
3447756
Gojira BD has a great picture of scratchy lines, dirt and speckles covering good and not very good prints of what must have been a great cinema shoot. But, please have HD fun with my favorite monster and love the scratches. Aside from that, it looks and sounds better than the DVD. The disc is tuned for your system, the DVD isn't.
This Blu-ray is close to the print used on the DVD, adjusted a bit more than you can do on your TV;... and get it for that. But also/or buy the the DVD with the US Version with the Mythical Raymond Burr, who did a sequel!
Is it budget or creativity; this BD gives you a true 'retro' picture.
3822637
So let me get this straight: the 1 CD version leaves out the best music. I could pay over $60 (retail as of date of this review) to get the 2 CD deluxe "Illuminated Star Projection Edition" and have the music in 16 bit/44.1 Hz CD quality.  Or I could pay $19 for the blu-ray of the movie, and get access to the music in DTS-HD quality as long as I am willing to tolerate the occasional sound effect on top of the Zimmer score .... hmmmm? What to do? What to do? What to do?
4895280
Two of the best movies you might ever see, so don't be a fool, spend 6 dollars on the Blu-ray, it's a pretty good deal. I'm not selling for Amazon, for 6 dollars you get a transfer that looks just about as good as seeing these in the theater, in most projection cases better, and that ain't bad.
3961744
i love this movie but, it is not worth  paying $95 for... that almost 60x the  original price ...That's america  for you over  charging for something in a public  market place..

Blu rays  do  not  go up in value...