I would highly recommend seeing this to know what a good movie/script looks ...
356355
This movie is incredibly tight.  Practically everything is used, and many things come full circle.  I would highly recommend seeing this to know what a good movie/script looks like.
281110
Wish I knew it was as good as it is, I would have watched it a long time ago!
2584483
Try to see it in a theatre -- art houses should show this brilliant film. It's definitely worth seeing more than once. You should also check out books by Enki Bilal, particularly the Nikopol Trilogy from which this movie is loosely based.

I wanted to see this movie so much that I nearly flew to France when it was released there in March 2004. Instead I bought a regionless player so I could watch the Russian-subtitled version.

Enki Bilal's post-war apocalyptic graphic novels are layered with all kinds of emotion. He brings the same introspective theme to this film.

Thomas Kretschmann is an excellent actor to play Nikopol. Charlotte Rampling has a small but important role as the doctor. The CG characters are bizarre, scary and nothing like you've ever seen on screen.

Immortal's music score is also incredible; imbedded in my memory for weeks after seeing this movie.

I hope the Immortal DVD sales will renew interest in Enki Bilal's out-of-print previous two films, Tykho Moon and Bunker Palace Hotel.
1978451
I love the script, the acting, the story ...  just soo good.  Its brilliant when the scene makes you so uncomfortable but also fascinated at the same time =D
958405
For some reason I missed this movie at the theaters, and somehow I managed  to avoid learning about "the surprise ending."  The movie  captured my curiosity quickly and completely, and I agree with someone  else's post here that I had a sense that something was wrong or was  missing--the revelation at the end reveals that something IS missing, and I  think it was a wonderful technique to create a sense of suspense and  curiosity.  The kid (Haley Joel Osment) is really good; it's so rare to see  child actors who are that convincing. There is a scene in a car near the  end where the kid convinces his Mom that he really does "see dead  people," and it's done so well that it reduced the two grown men  watching the movie to simpering crybabies. (It's a very emotional scene,  especially if you've lost a family member any time soon.) I usually see  "surprise endings" coming a mile away, but I missed this one, and  enjoyed the process of its revelation--then the pieces fell together and I  realized why some earlier elements were so off-putting. There are also some  excellent "extras" on the DVD version, including scenes cut from  the final film with explanations why (I'm not sure I agree that some should  have been cut); and some early home-made movies by the director when he was  a kid that are hilarious while still indicating the talent that would bloom  later.
2614826
This is an odd movie to write a review for.  However, since most people reading this are looking for an answer to the question, "Should I watch this or not?" I'll give you a quick answer: Yes.  It's worth every penny- for a rental, at least.
"The Good Girl" is like no movie I've ever seen.  That's not a compliment, and it's not a criticism, it's just an observation.  I don't want to pigeonhole it into any one genre.  The movie has plenty of very funny moments, but it's not a comedy.  It's also rather depressing (at first) but it's not "black."  It's dramatic, but can't really be classified as a typical drama (although that's the section it's in at the video store).
In short, it's just a bunch of stuff that happens.
THE GOOD:
There are a lot of very funny moments that will have you laughing out loud- sometimes at moments that you're not sure you should be laughing.  The cast performs every character in "The Good Girl" superbly, from Jennifer Aniston's ramshackle Justine to Jake Gyllenhaal's sullen Holden to Justine's slovenly but affable husband Phil (played by John C. Reilly).  Of course, I must mention Zooey Deschanel as cynical cashier Cheryl, one of the funniest and all-around best supporting acting performances I've ever seen.  And yes, I am now officially a fan of Jennifer Aniston, even though I'm decidedly a non-fan of "Friends" (I tried watching it after seeing "The Good Girl," but couldn't get into it).
THE BAD:
Although the acting is great, it sometimes seems like they're acting in different movies.  Holden's movie is a bleak tragedy, Justine's is a finding-yourself drama, and Phil's is "Half Baked" (cheap joke, I know).  Justine is a hard character to empathize with, because you come to dislike Justine's paramour Holden more than her husband.
However, you do want Justine to find happiness.  But you know it's going to be hard for her to do so with any of the people in the movie.  She's not a heroine, she's not a villain; she's just a human.  She screwed up and she knows it.  It'll help to keep in mind while watching this movie that all it's characters should not be looked at as either protagonists or antagonists, they should be looked at as humans.
The movie left me a little depressed after watching it, but the more I thought about it the more I liked it.  It's a good cautionary tale.  One of the things that tells me if a movie is good or not is how much it sticks with me after I see it.  I rented this, watched it twice, and cannot get it out of my head.  I'm planning to buy it.
"The Good Girl" is good, and it's worth a rental.
3066417
I could tell that a lot of thought and work went into both the artwork and storyline; this movie is beautifully crafted and I would highly recommend.
3415156
All in all, I really liked this movie. It had several elements that were very good. I am not sure if they were trying to do too much, or if I had a hard time believing the script, but it was very good. I hope that the sequel is as good or better!
2834525
What makes this so great is the actors put so much into this being made.. if you get the chance check out the behind the scenes worth taking the time to see how it was put together..
3845047
With all the exceptional reviews written, why add another? This was added to my 'watch list' months ago and somehow it was missed. The storyline may have doubtful origins but the cast and cinematography add an interesting dimension to human nature. Definitely recommended from the first scene to the last . . . a beginning with an ending and all that is in between. Follow 'The Way Back!'

Just in case you don't get past those first subtitles, the majority of the dialogue is in English!
2358624
The writing - all Mr. Martin's - is some of the wittiest, and the entire production is top notch.  I wish more of Steve Martin's output were of this caliber; the only other I hold the same view on is LA Story, and for the same reason.  You need to be paying attention because you'll miss something good if you're not.  I like this movie well enough to have upgraded from DVD to Blu-Ray to appreciate it that much more.
836031
The script is outstanding. There is a reason why he won awards for his screenwriting. If you want to learn how to write scripts, I suggest looking at the format of this script.
17426
This is a fine example of what can be done outside the studio system. Good screenplay and struggled for funds to complete. Recipe for a great movie.  Original and intellegent. Funny in a subtle way with a cast that is top notch. I work in a similar field so the take on this was interesting. Rather true too.

I thought I read where this was Braff's THX1138 (aka college idea). Hope there is more coming. Scrubs was very good and now over. His second film had the independent feel but was unremarkable enough for me that I don't remember the name. I thought he might have been coasting with Scrubs for the last 2 yrs or so and I don't blame him. Time to step up Zach!

Cast was perfect. Can Portman be any more attractive or interesting? No plastic needed for her beauty. Smart and pretty. Sarsgaard's semi dark role was spot on. Dude in the suit of armor was surreal. Not a clunker in the lot.

Soundtrack is a real plus. Very good and integrated well. I bought the CD too.
This is on my favorite list for sure.
2548138
I really enjoyed this movie.  The story is unique and moves along at a good pace.  The FX on the bombing mission are some of the best I have seen.  If you remember that this is a movie and not a documentary or history lesson I think most will enjoy it too.  Look for the positives, there are enough critics in the world already. :)
4378659
one of the best in this genre that i've ever seen
1357310
The ending is quite possibly the greatest example of movie producing I've ever seen, and the two hours after it don't leave me with any complaints either.
This movie is incredibly intelligent, and I presume it will go underappreciated - much like what I tried to achieve with my introductory sentence.  The acting, cinematography, and above all else, writing in this movie is unparalleled.
If you have difficulty following plots, I hate to say this, but you should probably avoid this one - no offense, but I have friends like you.  However, if your intrigue being grabbed forcefully and used to pull you towards the screen until your butt is about to fall off the chair is what you think movie watching should be all about, then you NEED to see this one ... because that's exactly what it does.
1667705
Fantastic movie with one of the best acting performances I have ever seen!