Decent Lightweight Flannel if it fits you
590246
I purchased several colors in this style. I was looking for a good set of flannel shirts for the winter. They were a lighter mid-weight flannel and the colors seemed nice. The fabric did feel "stiff" - something I don't normally see in a lighter flannel and that turned me off. It might have softened after a wash but keep reading and you'll see why washing wasn't an option. I got Smalls which I normally buy but also bought x-smalls since other reviews said to size down. I found that the X-small fit me perfectly. However, because they're 100% cotton I knew it would shrink out of my size after a wash. Rather than hope that the Small would shrink into the "right" size, I just decided to return them. With the Small, it was a little baggy for me everywhere. But the way it was cut felt like it had more room on top while narrowing in the waist and then fanning out again in the hips. I didn't feel comfortable moving my arms around. The top half just lifted up awkwardly and with that larger neck opening without a button to close it, it felt rather "exposing". Overall, they're decent shirts. If you find one that fits but has enough room to shrink down in the wash, I'd recommend them. They just didn't work for me.
570622
For me this is a one or two star item, I'm giving it three to acknowledge that it's probably fine for many other people.  I can sleep in it, or use it as a work shirt (i.e. yardwork, work around the house, etc.).  The stitching seems fine, the fabric is heavy enough.  I ordered the XL, and it is slightly tight in the chest, but if I was to order a size up, it would look terrible around my waist (would look like I'm wearing a giant cloth bell hanging from my shoulders).  (That's just how it is when you have a bigger chest than waist but live in a country where most men have bigger waists than chests and clothing is cut for the chubby masses).  So I've come to expect less-than-ideal fits in shirts.  My big knock is on the length of this shirt.  If I lift my hands over my head my belly button is exposed, and standing up with my arms down by my side there is *very* little overlap with the top of my shorts or pants.  I am 6'3", and believe I have an average torso length for that height (i.e. I have a typical torso length to leg length ratio).  If they offered an XLT, I probably would have ordered it, and it would probably fit well enough.  But since this shirt isn't offered in "Tall" sizes, be forewarned that if you are tall, or alternatively if you have a big belly to cover, this shirt is likely to leave you exposed.
3019635
Nice embroidery on sleeves and left chest; runs small and flannel will shrink in the dryer for sure; it's a 'goofy' shirt but kinda cool. I had plans to wear it as a warehouse work shirt. Rated 4 stars because of foreseeable shrinkage and the chest pocket is misplaced, it's real high on the front chest. Also, flannel is not a good choice for me - I thought it was some sort of cotton/polyester blend.
463370
got the 5x / fit is okay normally I take a m/l It is not long enough for me to wear with leggings/ but i guess would be okay for jeans. I am 5ft 6/ the material is good quality and the color is nice as well. For an everday flannel to throw on this will work
917960
Like the lightweight material - much better than flannel.  Just the right amount of warmth for an already well heated house.  I am short so am pleased that it is a nice long length for me - past the news.  May order another since I do want a nightgown with sleeves for winter.
2406222
I ordered this flannel top because I really liked the look of it.  I am 55 and weigh about 130lbs.  I ordered a medium and it fit ok, not great.  The shirt fits around, its just short.  The sleeves are short so I will have to roll them up and the body of the shirt is shorter than I like as well.  I think if I would have ordered a large it would have been too big around.

The material is soft and lightweight and the colors are really nice.  I will probably still wear the top but I will have to layer a cami underneath and roll the sleeves.  Overall this top is ok, but I really wish that it was longer.
I was given the opportunity to purchase this product at a discount in exchange for my honest and unbiased review.
1907111
Perfect lightweight flannel for wear over a t-shirt in the mild winters. The dark green color was really nice.
1331132
I like the material of this shirt. It's the thicker, soft, almost fuzzy feeling flannel that I wanted. The shirt did not fit how I wanted it to though. I purchased the L which was supposed to be a US size 4. I'm 5'4" and 115 lbs. I usually wear a size small or x-small in US sizes or a size 0-2. I sized up due to many reviewers suggestions and wish i wouldn't have. I'm not sure if it was actually too large, or if it just wasn't a very fitted or feminine cut. I have worn it under vests but I don't like the cut enough to wear it alone. It also has buttons on the sides and little straps inside that allow you to wear the sides gathered up if you prefer that look.
607729
****************UPDADE*******************

So I finally washed it and even thought the material feels good it definitely shrank. Before the wash it fit like a cholo flannel, and now after the wash it fits like a hipster flannel. I wear a xl sometimes L pending on the make. After the shrinking it still fit but I have long gorilla arms and the sleeves are too short now. I ordered a xxl and now imma order a xxxl and see if it shrinks to where it's comfortable.

I was a little hesitant to buy the shirt based on the reviews I was reading, but I took a chance on it and I do not regret this purchase. I am not sure what all of these crybabies or whining about, the feel is good the fabric is high-quality, and the overall look is exactly what you would expect in this kind of flannel shirt
648583
Very nice flannel. Like most flannels, it's a bit stiff until it breaks in. Not uncomfortably so though.

This is a pretty slim fitting flannel. Similar to a J Crew slim in the same size. Not very good for layering, but great for a modern and fashionable shirt. As is with most slim fit shirts, there is reduced range of motion. I would not recommend this shirt for doing any flannel-ly work like chopping wood. But for a casual night around a campfire, it's great.

If you want a flannel for layering or for working, try the traditional fit instead of the modern fit.
2046831
This fabric is very lightweight, more like a sweatshirt than a blanket. I plan to use it to make a fleece hoodie. It feels like a good option for lightweight, yet warm, garments.

EDIT (November 2015): I have now used the fleece and I'm happy as a clam. It is lightweight and very soft. I used it to make McCall 5252 hoodie for my brother (seen in photo). I ordered 3 yards and got slightly more than that. It was easy to work with, shows topstitching beautifully, and is very warm and cozy.

EDIT 2 (May 2016): My brother wore the heck out of this fleece all winter! It never got any holes, but it pilled up after four washes. The whole thing is covered with pills. I'm disappointed - I thought anti-pill would mean it would stay smooth, at least longer than a month of casual wear.
4819978
These are probably a lightweight shirt much more so than a mid-weight. I liked that there are no tags, the pocket is nice, the colors are good but I have two small problems that makes me go with 4-stras. The description states generous length but mine weren't any longer than a typical t-shirt in the XL size I purchased. Also, the collars are very thin and tend to droop in the front. Other than those two minor issues its a pretty decent set of shirts for the price and the overall fit is good.
176025
Nice flannel shirt for the price... and a nice balance of colors.  :)
944637
I like the jacket. It is warm, yet lightweight.  It is cut fairly slim around the waist, so will be difficult to layer with a heavier sweater or sweatshirt. Should have ordered a large.  Otherwise it fits like a medium , except in waist area.
3724067
Fits my wife quite well, with the exception that the sleeves are just a tad short, but that is rather common for her with standard size medium. Nice and lightweight, but a little too expensive for what it is. On the flipside it does look nice, if the crinkly-feeling windbreaker style of fabric is your thing for jackets.
2965279
This flannel is nice, a little smaller than I hoped it would be, but it still fits pretty nicely.  I love flannels, and for the price, this one is pretty great.  It looks really cute over a tank.
4823073
Like it. Medium weight. I usually wear a Large. Other posters stated they fit a little large so I got a Medium. It did seem about right on arrival but after the first wash it was a "Medium". It's okay but a little tighter than I like in a flannel.