My dogs loved these, just beware they are soft and make ...
581651
My dogs loved these, just beware they are soft and make a bit of a mess.  I will be treating them to these outside from now on (like kids with popsicles!)
924572
i actually had gotten a sample pack of these through another page when i ordered my kong bouncer (through entirely pet...i think im not 100% sure the receiving papers on the other side of the room and im here) but they small really good, they are extremely soft and it even came with a nice little card that says what kind of stuffs good in these little goodies! my dogs 10 months old so im more looking to tend to his play needs but in a couple years i will have to give these another try just because my dog enjoyed them so much!
2300941
I'm always trying out new treats with my 7 dogs to mix it up for them. So I tried these treats on them as well. My treat package arrive with these in small bit & pieces, so not much for my to hold onto and hand to them. So I just sprinkled the floor with some of them and my dogs ate them up. So my dogs loved them, I just don't like how they come in crushed up pieces.
1156976
Our dogs and cat love these liver treats. They are solid enough to keep their shape in training pouches, yet soft enough to break into smaller pieces. Unfortunately, because of their softness, when shipped in the larger-size container, the pieces breakdown into dust before arrival, so you really don't get too many more actual pieces than you get with the smaller container.

They are "real" rather than processed, and appeal more to the animals that way. They last a long time (at least 2 months). I heartily recommend them.
420925
I bought these at the grocery and they were soft. The packages I received of chic and salmon were hard and crunchy. A little difficult for my three small dogs with tiny teeth but they managed. When there's a will there's a way! They are good treats and they do love them, but I'll be buying them at the grocer so I can feel the texture. I love that they are made in the USA and REAL chic and salmon! Ingredients are very important to me.
4788263
Dogs love these! But be careful because they will chew on pieces and will swallow them. According to the package, this is non-edible.
75656
My daughter ordered these by accident. If you have an aggressive chewer I would not recommend these. Thankfully my dog has called down in that aspect. The kids and dog play tug of war with these. The dog was very happy when she received these.
2369015
The ones I got from the vet are soft and very easy to put a pill in, these are not.
3903165
My puppy loved them and they were the perfect size because he is a small breed. The only downside is that he got extremely hyper afterwards. I will not be giving him any more because that does not seem normal.
1059078
My pup loves these. I generally stuff them into her Kong toy and she goes berserk. I have to say they definitely give my pup soft poopies. Must limit the intact so there is no puppy mud butt. Other than that, we dig em.
3323559
my dog loves these, i however wish they were thicker.  My dog has learned if he drops them enough they split in two and it doesnt last as long.
3830268
My German shepherd loves these. They are on the softer side and a big enough treat for a large breed dog
4097301
Dog loves it. But its soft she  destroys it within a couple days of just playing fetch. Dont let them have it  unattended or will last minutes . Made out of a very soft material dogs teeth go right through it.  Not like they're small balls you cant destroy them , this one the dogs loves but beaware it will be destroyed. If it was tough like there small balls I would give it 5 Stars
865984
My dogs loved the cupcakes I made them, the only thing is I refrigerated them after they cooled down & they got hard so I had to microwave them for 5-10 seconds so it would be soft again but Id definitely purchase again! I added mini milk bones on top too!
2519769
Love these for my morkie! Very soft and small treats ( but they don't break apart like a lot of soft treats and larger than most soft treats)
2409091
My 2 dogs (13 yr old mini Poodle & 5 yr old Brussels Griffon) go crazy for these. They are soft & seem to be tasty to them. I like to give them treats that have some supplement value, are made in the USA & on the healthy side (rather than the junk food treats). Everything from Zuke's they love.
4267254
I give these to my dog as a special treat and he really enjoys them. He is 70lbs, medium chewer, and these typically last 1 night with a few nibbles left over for the next day. Please note that if you are concerned about splintering, these do splinter into medium sized chunks. My dog doesn't consume these so I don't need to worry, but if your dog does you may wish to avoid.