Love the movies, hate not having Extended Verisons on Bluray
589482
Love the LOTR Movies, but releasing this without the extended cuts, is absolutely unacceptible.  This is what bluray discs were made for.  Will not buy theses.  Release the Extended Cuts together.  That is what all of the fans want.  In fact Demand. I hope George Lucas is paying attention as well.  Release both original and SE versions of Star Wars Saga on the same Blu ray discs as well.
2445563
I love all three of these movies. They are great comedies and I could watch them over and over again. But at the current ~$54 price tag, I would much rather purchase the three movies separately on Blu-ray at their current prices. $9.99 each for&nbsp;<a data-hook="product-link-linked" class="a-link-normal" href="/The-40-Year-Old-Virgin-Blu-ray/dp/B001CW7ZV2/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_rvw_txt?ie=UTF8">The 40-Year-Old Virgin  [Blu-ray</a>] and&nbsp;<a data-hook="product-link-linked" class="a-link-normal" href="/Knocked-Up-Blu-ray/dp/B001CW7ZUS/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_rvw_txt?ie=UTF8">Knocked Up [Blu-ray</a>]. $10.49 for&nbsp;<a data-hook="product-link-linked" class="a-link-normal" href="/Forgetting-Sarah-Marshall-Blu-ray/dp/B001C0JCBK/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_rvw_txt?ie=UTF8">Forgetting Sarah Marshall [Blu-ray</a>].

Don't get me wrong, the idea of having these three in a collection is great. Just try to make it completely worthwhile.
2136504
I'm disgusted with New Line releasing this version on BluRay when the format can have both versions on one disk.
Blatant attempt the bleed the market. I just hope there aren't too many stupid people around to fall for this.
***PLEASE DO NOT BUY THIS VERSION AND WAIT FOR THE EXTENDED VERSION***
606622
I'm sick and tired of buying movies in different formats and in different editions.  I've already bought this twice on dvd & I know an extended cut is coming so why waste more of my money on a movie I already own!
1046243
Blu-Ray is a premium format and there is no excuse for selling a product that is sub par. I will not buy these movies until they are released in their extended format.
503522
Nice to have so many great movies. Only drawback is that with the soon to be end of DVDs to try and get folks to switch to blu ray, there are only 2 discs in this buy, thereby cutting down some time in the films here and there. Mainly in Robin Hood, theres two scenes I feel help to add to the film. Otherwise, good buys.
3494091
I love this DVD set; the special features are amazing.  However I am disappointed because the film version is not the extended version.  That is not cool at all.  The first 3 films of the ultimate editions do include the extended version of each film in the first dvd.  I am not sure why the 4th one does not.  It sucks spending so much money on this set and I have to go to special features to view extended scenes.  :( :( :(
3187342
Please put these out on Blu-ray.  It's the way of the future, you know it.  The best would be the ORIGINAL versions of the movie all cleaned up for Hi-def.  (Perhaps a double disk with then "extended" versions with the new scenes).

You can even throw in episodes 1-3, I could use a few more coffee coasters.
3750047
We already owned the extended versions on dvd, was hoping the movies would be released as 4k but it doesn't appear that will happen.  Purchased the blu-ray set to improve the picture for our 65" screen.
4571413
One of my favorite movies, had to rent because my DVD box set skips :(. I guess it's time to get the BluRay version! Sad though, cause my late grandma bought me the box set. Still one of my favorite gifts to date.
3322043
might be a different story if the extended version had never been released on dvd. this is a shame and another slap-in-the-face to those loyal fans of lotr and bd. the trilogy was on tv this past weekend and my daughter and i watched them all.....again. when rotk ended, i didn't feel "less fulfilled" because of the reduction in quality. i am also on the list of those that will wait; and will be first in line for the extended version release.
1453026
The Blu-Ray capacity should be the platform to release ALL Flavors of these movies.

I would rather watch the "Laser Disc" versions of the 'originals'.

Han Shot First !!!
1124899
This is just a ploy to take advantage of the customer. We know Blu-ray has extended space (7x!) vs DVD and they could seemlessly branch from theatrical to extended version of the movie. I have seen the extended version in the theaters (one-time back to back) so I know it is not a case of the effects being rendered at DVD resolution. Hold out for the extended edition. I do not even own a blu-ray and will not buy one until LOTR: extended editions come out.
811951
no rentals!! Arguably best of the trio, but still can't rent extended edition :(
3968504
There's no way I make the same mistake twice.  This time I will wait for the extended version. But deceiving their customers in the same way they did with the DVD is unethical.  It is plenty of space in the blu ray for both versions of the film.
1602884
I already have the extended DVD trilogy, and by no means I'll buy the theatrical version on Blu Ray, No Way Jose!
Is either Extended version or nothing. If you want my money you should give me what I want!
480421
Only problem is they should have put the films on one disc. It is annoying having to get up half way through and change discs.

Other than that, great set.