Nice warm boot when there is a few inches of ...
595935
Nice warm boot when there is a few inches of snow on the ground and you don't want to lace up your snow boots everytime you go outside.
1078466
Nice boots,  comfortable around my calves,  a little snug in the toe box.  Seem warm,  but we're currently in a heat wave, so that remains to be seen, lol.
2682388
Very comfortable boot. The heel has some kind of cushion that feels like a spring with each step. And it's also pretty warm. I've only had a chance to test it out in 30something degree weather but I'm sure it'll keep me warm in much colder temperatures as well. And no need for heavy duty thick socks. It's not the most stylish boot but cute enough, considering it's a serious snow boot. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is because I wish it was designed with a zipper. I hate having to tie laces but I like the shoe enough that no zipper is not a deal breaker.
404146
Generally liked the boot, felt warm but too small
3022759
Great Boots, pretty warm, but still too narrow to the front of the boot. Still would recommend for the warmth,
3444306
These boots are really cute with a pair of skinny jeans if it happens to be raining or snowing outside.  They have very little insulation, so they don't work as "snow boots" if you're going to be out in it for a while.  No 1/2 sizes, so go up one and wear a thicker pair of socks.  The soles are very comfy!
2035780
kinda small - I have large feet (8.5) and they do fit - snugly.  Also, the heating element is only a small square in the center of the paw - so while that keeps the soles of your feet warm - my toes and heels were quite cold.  had to keep scooching my feet around trying to hit a warm spot.
4681148
Little on the small side. Otherwise a good boot.
3337038
Bought these boot to wear during the Fall and Winter (and maybe spring) around the barn. It is extremely muddy around the horses stalls taking them into the arena . Previously, I was wearing rain boot however they do not provide adequate insulation to keep my feet warm like these MuckBoots do. They are very well insulated and have kept my feet warm when temperatures have been as low as 20 degrees. They run a little wide (I'm usually a medium width) but leave plenty of room for a nice pair of wool socks.
3826898
Boots are not a regular width size.  The boots are nice and warm.  The boots feel a bit tight toward the front of my foot.
3922888
These boots are great -- warm, fine with bare feet -- the wool IS different from that in UGGs, but still very comfortable.  As with everyone else, I ordered a size down from my normal shoe size.  The only unpleasant surprise was that in a photo, the tie makes it look like you cinch up the boot as you do with the lower hipper boot.  However, it is purely decorative. The actual boot fit rather snugly on my not quite 15" calf (never thought I had big calves till I started reading boot reviews).  While I feel confident that they will stretch a bit over time, be aware that if you are athletic and have definition in your calves, these boots will be snug.
2503626
These boots are very nice looking and very warm.  But, my feet do not get overheated.  In our recent cold snap, along with several inches of snow, my feet have stayed warm and dry in these.  My only complaint is that one of the little cloth gizmos through which the laces are threaded pulled off of the boot.  That is how I discovered that they are glued on, not sewn on.  I guess I'll get some super glue and fix the problem myself.  But, I would have been more impressed with these if those gizmos were sewn on.  Still, I'd buy another pair if they had my size.  I wear a 9 shoe and I bought these boots in size 10. They fit perfectly. I got the pewter and they look great with slacks or jeans.
2026514
The boot is a bit short but I still can wear each one in comfort. They are warm.
They arrived in good time and were well packaged.
3568743
Its warm on negative degrees its good when you use this shoveling and during at work, i got compliment on this boots :)
669480
Great, convenient boots for jumping in the car and going to work, snow blowing, grabbing some firewood, etc. for those of us that live in snow country. Quite warm, but no so warm that your feed sweat in them. I've ice fished in these for a few hours in single digits (F) and my feet started to get a bit cold after an hour or so but not terrible.

Why not 5 stars? I've noticed after 1 season some of the trim near the boot and sole attachment point is coming loose. I don't notice any leaks but it hasn't been that long.
592700
I purchased a 10 when I wear a 9. I can only wear a thin sock with this boot. The only part of the boot that is warm is the faux fur part from the ankle up to the top. The rubber foot part is not warm so how they got the warm rating I'll never know. I gave them three stars because they look nice but don't get them if you expect a warm winter boot.
3045658
These boots seem extremely warm for my Minnesota winters. They are well-insulated and the sole is nice and thick to provide traction on ice and snow. The gray color comes with purple laces, which makes them cuter. They're still not super attractive, but how cute can winter boots be?! The size 9 slipped off my heel even with thick socks, and the size 8 pinched my toes. If these came in half sizes, they would be great!