Both dogs LOVED  these
582250
Both dogs absolutely loved these. After just two days my one dog with the worst breath ever had a great improvement and I'm hoping after more use her breath will continue to improve.
410597
Both our dogs love these things!  One is 10 lbs and the other 17, and these balls are a perfect size for them.  The squeak is strong sounding and the bright colors make it so my blind dog can find them easily.  We've had them for a few months and they still look new.  I'll get more in the future!
3936243
My dogs reallllly reallllly liked these. I am not sure how well they honestly "cleaned" their teeth as they claimed to do but these were their favorite bed time treat. They even liked them more than the over processed gooey beefy treats I offered as an alternative. My larger dog (lab/ terrier mix about 40-50lbs) wolfed them down like they were actual treats so they may have been a little small for him but my other dog (pug about 20lbs) chewed them slowly as intended.
1531656
My dog loves these!!! He likes the gigantic ones too - he's a 75 lb Husky mix. My very sweet old black lab loved them too. Both dogs are big and avid chewers... so these don't last a really long time but are still a favorite. My dogs have definitely gotten excited anytime they see one coming out of the package - and they get plenty of satisfaction even out of the small ones despite finishing pretty fast. I like to give my dog one of these after our long afternoon walk - between the walk and the treat he's a super happy guy the rest of the afternoon. These seem to help keep teeth shiny too!
3235078
My dogs love these, and I love them too! Both dogs have sensitive stomachs and allergies, it can be tough to find something that works for both of them. But these fit the bill!
4155380
My two fur babies loved these. They are a perfect size for my small breed's. Our kids loved putting them into their toys that shoot the treats in the air to them also. They are the perfect snack for a reward treat as well. A small way to say good job to our pups. I would definitely buy these again as our dogs were clearly overjoyed with the product!  If you have found my review to be helpful at all, please click "yes" that it was helpful so that I may continue to review products and share my opinions of them with the public to assist in their choice to purchase or not purchase a product.
1087755
Pets enjoyed these treats.  Would re-order if I have a need.
3805248
Both dogs seem to love these.  The ingredients are acceptable and that they are made in the US a plus!
3067388
Our dog LOVED these -- ate them right up -- and wanted more.  I liked them because they didn't smell too icky or beefy, and they were dry and not at all unpleasant to touch.  I'm not one to monitor our dog's diet too carefully, so I won't offer an opinion on whether they're actually nutritious or healthy or have other redeeming qualities -- just that the dog loved them and they seem to be reasonably priced.
1565385
Our dogs loved them the whole 2 days they had them.  They were too easy to chew up
1832375
Arrived as promised and both my dogs love them. Wish they were a bit less money but they are high quality.
3085424
The dogs loved them and they went fast.  I highly recommend these for your dogs.
2315499
Dogs loved these. They went perfectly in their stockings. They enjoyed them so much, I caught them stealing them off the coffee table!
2868262
We have offered twice now. My dogs loved them. I will be ordering again in the future. They last long time. My dogs are stong heavy chewers. Good quality
3053062
My smaller dog, fully grown at ten pounds, has a small skull for his breed and some " small dog" treats are way too big for him to chew, even the soft center ones.  Both dogs love these treats which smell very tasty and have a soft chewy consistency.  This is my first time buying them, so I will look into the nutritional value later, but sometimes for a special treat, nutrition doesn't matter.  Both dogs love them and Charlie, the smaller dog has no trouble chewing them.  Heck, both dogs swallowed the first few whole and they had just eaten breakfast.  I'll be keeping a couple of jars in the cabinet from now on.
4325357
Both dogs love this recommended by my vet and about $10.00 cheaper than vet.
588624
My girlfriend's dogs really seemed to enjoy this.  I'm sure we'll buy more.