The leather top makes them look better than most Croc styles
585528
I have had these in the past and flat wore a pair out.  Bought them again, so they must be alright, don't you think?  The leather top makes them look better than most Croc styles.  I swore I would never wear these, but now around the house and in the yard, there's nothing better!
2445744
Best looking pair of boots I have.  I've been wearing them every other day for over a month.  I've noticed no unusual wear or other flaws.  The shoestrings appear to be a bit small and delicate for a boot, but they seem to be doing the job without fraying.  The matte dark red/brown color oiled leather sets a perfect casual but upscale tone.  They are comfortable, but don't have strong arch support.  Easy to get on and off and they don't make your feet hot.
3430813
Bought these to replace my beloved traditional crocs that were so old, the soles no longer had any ridges and they got slippery. This different version looks better, more like regular clogs, so you can wear it more places. The inside is very comfortable once you get used to the fact that  it's not smooth. One this the picture doesn't show: unlike with traditional crocs, there are NO holes for ventilation (it looks like there are holes on the sides, but they're just indents made to look like holes. So they would be less comfortable in super hot weather and won't dry as quickly after getting wet. The strap in the back is too tight to just slip your foot through, so if you like to just "step into" your shoe, you need to flip it to the front. OTOH, it keeps the shoe on better when you're walking, which is needed because they're so WIDE. At $19.50 it's a good deal but I wish the fit were better.
1005695
Just worn for a few hours now. I can tell these will need a lengthy break in and definitely some insoles. That said the leather is moist and supple yet tough (coming from a leather-worker this is high praise). The cardboard inside showed signs of oil so these boots are oiled before sent off from factory so that the leather doesn't dry out sitting in some stockroom with god knows what climate. IT shows forethought and pride in my opinion.

 The toe room is honestly much better than I was expecting in a non- steel toed boot. Like a steel toe minus the steel area being taken up. my toes have room to move, and my foot can spread properly unlike some other brands which pinch your foot inwards with a medium width boot. the heel area feels a bit tight but I'm not used to loggers so this may be part of the design differences. So long as the stitches hold they should last a long time.

If anything changes I will update
4001187
I have these shoes in black, red and teal. I wear the black and red ones most often. I don't like how the teal color looks on me. I'm not a fan of the other style of crocs, but these are really cute and go well with jeans and different tops, making them look dressy or casual. They are very versatile that way. I ordered my regular size and they fit perfect.
They eventually rub the back of my ankle if I wear them walking long distances. Probably not a good travel shoe. I haven't had a problem with them not staying on. The material starts to wear and looks dull after a lot of use, but they are easy to wash. They sometimes squeak if rubbed together or if adjusting your foot, that doesn't bother me. I even got my mom some red ones that she likes for easy slip on shoes.
4522411
I really like this style of distressed leather, which is the main reason for purchasing them. They arrived on time and I usually wear a 8.5 in dress shoe and these fit almost perfectly. They are a little snug in the toes as my feet are slightly wider than normal but I know that after breaking them in this will not be an issue. However, I will warn you that this leather is very stiff and the break-in process is painful. I highly suggest putting mink oil on them and once they dry, break them in, as your feet will thank you. Also, there is little to no arc support so if you have high arches, then getting the correct insert would be beneficial. Overall, even with the painful break-in of about 2 weeks without the mink oil, I really like these shoes and get compliments on them ever since I started wearing them.
4413741
It was way past time for me to get a new pair of Crocs, which I use as house shoes, with the occasional excursion to the mailbox. However, our nearby Crocs outlet no longer sold the style which has no holes on the top. I prefer this to avoid anything that might spill on top of them from entering through the top, especially hot liquids. I still wanted side holes for ample aeration for my sweaty feet. I found these--and bonus-- with some nice styling with the leather uppers. I could even get away with wearing them in public, if I wanted. Yes, there are slits on top at the dorsum of the foot, but I can deal with that as the upper is otherwise without the usual large Croc holes. Fit is as roomy as my old Crocs. I wear a size 10, and the size 10 model fits just fine, and will accommodate very thick socks (I'm thinking my alpaca wool socks) for winter wear around the house. While I appreciate the ability to resize the ankle strap, I'm unsure of the velcro method to do so. If adjusting for a tight fit for when you may go somewhere beyond your home with them, the excess velcro strap exceeds the available hook area and does not lay flat, possibly catching on something. That's the only reason it wasn't five stars for me. Otherwise, I'm perfectly  happy with them, having worn them for about a week, now.
52848
Bought for my husband, he even wears them to work. The leather on top makes them look a lot more attractive, he's happy.
4972101
I haven't wore them a lot yet, but so far so good.  Since they are leather, initially they are very tight but loosen as you wear them.  Very attractive look.  The leather is textured instead of smooth, so sadly I already managed to put a small ding in the leather surface.
3434590
Other reviews pegged them as kinda small, and advised to order a half size larger... I found them to be the right size just not as soft(across the top where the leather is attached) as regular(all rubber) Crocs. No matter what size you order there's probably going to be a break in period to soften the leather. I wear them with ankle socks so the break in wasn't a problem. I run a small HVAC business so I can't wear my Crocs during work, so any Crocs day is a good day!! possibly some leather softener would eliminate the need to break in, either way these Crocs are really nice looking and in my opinion well worth any break in period.
4599972
Could be more spectacular; if it had the sole leather
3627544
What I don't like is that it is a pull on and by nature that means it's more generous in the ankle, which leads to a little less stability. What I like is I got it on sale and it's all leather. Although it is a little baggy in the ankle (which they have to do so you can push your foot in), it is not way too baggy, so it looks fine, although certainly not the snug fit look. The ankle has a little less stability but these are not sky high heels so I haven't had any trouble walking in them. These boots would in my opinion be improved by the addition of a side zipper so the loseness could be taken out of the ankle area. I wear a 9B and these felt true to size to me.
2586226
The shoes are a bit snug, I hope the leather gives with use. They look great!
3339750
Fit well for a chukka, definitely needs a little breaking in. The top of the heel is very stiff which caused some blisters because I was dumb enough to put them on then have to take my son trick or treating that evening. The perforated leather look I was somewhat questionable about when ordering based on the pictures. However when I got these they look awesome and are very stylish, great to wear casually,but you could possibly dress them up with some skill.
1595697
CROC SHOES ARE THE MOST UNATTRACTIVE SHOES MADE BUT FROM TIME TO TIME I FIND SOME THAT ARE ACTUALLY PRETTY, THESE ARE IT. VERY COMFORTABLE. BULKIER THAN MY OTHER CROCS THAT ARE THE SAME SIZE AND WIDTH. I GET MANY COMPLIMENTS ;)
1623918
The toe area IS narrow, but it stretches since the material is leather. These shoes look very nice.
3438524
These are beautiful shoes and you can they will last a long time. They are made from very high quality leather and the tassels give them some style.