loved clumping, did not like smell of the litter ...
582075
loved clumping,  did not like smell of the litter itself though it controlled pee & poo odor
3636278
I scoop my cest litter every day.  After scooping, the laundry room smells terrible for a long time.  I've never had a problem with odor from my previous litter.  I will never buy this litter again.
2546282
I love having alternative to clay litter and when I first started using I loved this product. However, i now notice that the clumping factor is diminishing with each bag. The last bag I received it takes me 10 minutes to get all the minute clumps out. I don't know which is better the yellow or the red bag but it seems from the reading that they are basically the same. I went from yellow to red this last time. You wind up using twice as much because there is no way to remove all the minute clumps and it gets messy in the box so much faster. I clean my box out twice a day without fail, so it is not deliberate residue I am leaving. Please make this product live up to its advertisement. This is very disturbing.
600479
This clumps well and has very little dust, however, the reason you don't smell the cat "remains" is because of the heavy, noxious perfume in the litter itself.  If you like the heavy perfume smell, this would have a 5 star rating.  However, there is excellent litter out there that controls odor without adding all that horrid perfume to the product.  I have to open the windows whenever I clean the litter box because the perfume is so overpowering and it doesn't dissipate with time. I won't be buying this litter again.
3048827
I like the litter a lot, much more natural than the other stuff I usually get BUT there's no odor control. We keep the litter box downstairs in our storage room (doors open) and we can smell when the cat has done a #2 and the ammonia from #1 isn't masked either. We have two large litter boxes (one for each cat). Basically you really have to keep up on cleaning the box every day or every other to keep the stink down.

Having said that, It does clump pretty good. I love that it's dust free.  I love that my 2 cats aren't being exposed to the chemical crap from the other litters that contain the smell better. And I love the natural corn smell of the litter (before they go in it).
652508
I really like this litter. I don't like litters that have a fragrance added. This clumps very well and doesn't seem to track the way others have. Having UPS put it on my doorstep means I don't carry it either!
3631755
I really liked that it clumped my 2 cats' pee, but after a couple of days, the kitty litter started smelling. I didn't like that.
1607735
Like another reviewer,my husband purchased this,thinking the baking soda coated granules were a plus. I am sensitive to odors and I can tell you,I would rather smell a litter pan that has not been changed in a month rather than this stuff. My husband is not sensitive to odors and he said it gave him a head ache. At least one of my cats will not use it,they are going on the floor next to it. It does not clump,it sticks to the bottom of the litter pan....I am going to contact Arm and Hammer about this product.
4686771
Initially I was happy with this litter because it's totally flushable and created less odor than the attraction litter that I trained my kitty on, plus it was cheaper than the attraction litter. I found that with enough perfumed baking soda and scooping twice a day the smell wasn't that noticeable. It is very scoopable and didn't have the clumping agents that vets warn are dangerous for a kitty's GI tract.

But some things left me unsatisfied with Swheat Scoop. The tracking was terrible and I started dreading going into that bathroom, where the litter box is. I couldn't keep a rug on the floor, I would wear flip flops to go in and I was vacuuming three or four times a day at that. I was able to keep this down by ceasing the use of liner bags, putting a tent over the litter box with a track mat at the opening so the kitty had to step on the mat, and this helped a lot. But I also kept noticing when I would come home from work this lingering smell like spoiled milk or trash that the baking soda just couldn't mask. I started burning candles and incense more. My roommate said she could only smell the incense, but I could still detect a stench. Also, it started to bother me that the clumps crumbled when I scooped them, as the tiny bits that slip through the sieve are probably what's causing the smell. Then one day recently I was vacuuming the tracked litter around the box and I found where it collected the most some mouse droppings. Last night I laid the traps and the kitty kept vigil, he flushed the mouse out of its hiding place and into the trap. After reading other reviews on Amazon I am suspecting that the Swheat Scoop attracted the mouse. We recently moved to the country, it was a little field mouse, and those love to eat wheat as it is.

After the smell, the tracking and now the mouse I am done with Swheat Scoop.
2998448
I like the faint scent of walnut and the litter clumps well and absorbs odors, BUT my particular group of mau, Maine Coon, and half-Aby uses it as a litter pan of last resort.  They do use it, but it's not their first choice.  Their first choice, unfortunately, is clumping sand, which just is NOT environmentally sound.
2412549
A year ago I went to the pellet litter, mostly because of the tracking of traditional clumping litter tracking.  Very happy with this litter, great order control, low tracking.  UPDATE, it's been a week & the smell of the litter is horrid.  It's not the waste itself, but the litter develops a horrible smell.  I bought three box's after the first couple day's of really liking it.  I am going to try mixing it with something else.
2185236
I became a first time pet owner this year and adopted two kittens. When the kittens arrived we continued with the arm and hammer multi-cat clay litter the volunteer said they were used to.  I couldn't stand the smell of the clay and it would go everywhere (including the smell).  We went to Petco to explore other options where we were introduced to pellet litter.  The smell wasn't as bad but I noticed my kitten's paws were suddenly dry and flaky.  The pellet litter also didn't clump well.
  Frustrated we went back to Petco and this time it was suggested we try walnut-based litter.  Since then we've been very happy with this litter.  The litter itself doesn't have much of a smell, it doesn't deodorize much, but I don't mind because then I know when to clean the litter (we transfer the clumps into a small waste bucket that has a lid until it's time to take out the trash).  As far as tracking is concerned, we have an upright litter box with a mat underneath so it's not too bad (I always find myself cleaning around the litter box regardless of litter type).  I've only ever seen "mold" in our waste bucket for clumps, which  I've never seen with other litter types.  I don't have to use as much litter as I did with the clay and pellets, but that might also be because we switched to an upright litter box.  When I clean the box I find that there is a fine litter dust on the inside.
  My kittens are now nine months old and this litter works well for our household.  My kittens no longer have paw issues.  I'm sure it's not for everyone, but I'd give it a try especially if you had the issues we had.  I'm also not opposed to trying other natural clumping litters.  I'd like to see how they compare.
140702
Not as good as other Clump & Seal. Litter seems to get all over the house, maybe because it is larger pieces - doesn't stick together. Smells weird too. I'm sticking with the original which is great!
475373
My aim was to get a less dusty litter that was made from recycled material  Well, that much was a success!  However, what good is kitty litter that has particles SOOO large as to be unable to sift through the openings in the litter scoop?!  Also, unless there was a significant amount of time from pee to cleaning the pan, the particles of litter never clumped at all.  I really wanted to like this litter, and I think the situation may be salvageable.  This would be a very acceptable product if the particle size was 1/2 to 1/3 the present size.  If that ever happens - I'll be back!
573205
Our cars took their time to adapt to this product, but within two weeks the old litter tray was gone. By then it was pretty disgusting. This is easier and love the 'diaper' idea since it keeps the tray easier to clean and seems mired hygienic. My main gripe is, that, after the cat has used it to excrete it stinks, because they cannot cover it adequately with the larger granules. You have to clean that away immediately if you don't want the entire area to stink. My daughter is taking care of her cats, but I cannot stand it and often find myself removing the waste long before she would consider it necessary. We are in an apartment and it is bad otherwise.

This was written about two years ago, so we have been using it now for that long with two cats.  As soon as I notice poop I scoop it out.  I use a diaper genie for cats, the smell is minimised that way. My only real complaint is that the little pellets fit exactly into the holes at underneath, there for the urine to seep through. They are really hard to remove. A slight change in design would eradicate this nuisance, and it really us a pain. Makes cleaning much harder. Apart from that, this system is good, but expensive.
4158743
I hate this cat litter! These are the reasons why:

1)  Extremely Dusty!
2)  Does NOT absorb odor! Leaves ammonia smell.
3)  Heavy! Feels like dipping cement.

For years I had used Arm & Hammer Essentials Natural (unscented). It was great! It's not available at my local stores any longer. Online it's very expensive. Precious Cat had 4 plus stars, great reviews & a great price so I tried it. It's hard to believe people really like this cat litter. I quickly began searching for a new litter. I found Tidy Cat Pure Nature & I love it!
4905757
The cat's used it and didn't mind transitioning to it, but it didn't hide the smell as well as the pine litter. Also, it was difficult to tell WHICH litter had been peed on, so we ended up scooping out most of the catbox, until we didn't smell pee anymore. Won't buy again.