Looks cool Cons: It's hard to get the controllers lined ...
591883
Pros: Looks cool

Cons: It's hard to get the controllers lined up and seated

Overall: I wouldn't recommend it.
1977132
This controller works reasonably well with my Windows 7 gaming rig (the fact that game support for this controller is uneven and inconsistent is a topic for discussion some other time), though the joysticks are quite stiff and the response curve so nearly vertical that subtle motion shifts are very fussy and difficult to achieve. The trigger buttons are stiff and their travel is excessive. The trigger should be a button with tactile feedback that has minimal travel; the effect of the current design is clumsy and unresponsive.

My second complaint applies to the whole gaming controller world: why isn't there a controller for lefties, and why isn't there an option to at least reverse the triggers and joysticks? The "programmability" option offered in the marketing blurb for this controller, which was the main factor that induced me to by this controller and not the Microsoft controller, turned out to be support for games with legacy joystick support and not at all what I expected, which was the ability to remap the buttons and sticks to suit my left handed preferences, in a similar way to the software for another Logitech product, the Marble Mouse.

As a result of these problems I seldom use this gamepad.
834042
I love the flexability it has for different profiles per game. I will say that it takes a learning curve to get used to it though, coming from an Xb_x 360 controller. It is definitely growing on me though
2570577
The charging cable is very hard to insert into the controller - but otherwise perfect.
424068
the one problem that I have encountered is that if you have recharage batteries for the controllers, than you have to remove these every time that the controllers need to be recharge, this can be a hassle to some people but they are well made.
3904203
slightly a pain in the a@@ to line up all the button and holes but fun once it was done.  My kids constantly try to steal my controllers rather then buy their own skins.
2865131
Hard to apply with no instructions and the controller skins look odd when on. Cool looking on the console though. I only used the stickers near my buttons and on the touch pad and it looked cool
1689186
This controller is for the Wii (plugs into the Wiimote where the Nunchuk normally goes) and gives you a GameCube controller look and feel. It's a real licensed Nintendo product but not actually designed by them, and that's the problem.

The ZL/ZR buttons are too recessed so your finger will hit the gamepad shell before the button is fully depressed. There's too much vertical travel compared to the GameCube pad.

Likewise the left analog stick is raised significantly higher than any of the other controls on the face of the pad. To move from the D-pad to the left analog stick you have to lift your thumb up a much higher distance than you did on the GameCube pad, where switching between the two was easy. Sounds minor but in practice it's irritating.

Overall this pad isn't terrible, and it works, but it's not as comfortable and ergonomic as the GameCube controller. It's easy to recommend as a cheap spare if your Classic Controller breaks someday, but it wouldn't be my main go-to controller unless I had no other options. Unlike a lot of no-name third party controllers I'd say it's better than most of them, but still a long shot from the GameCube design it is trying to represent.
4098777
It works just fine, but I didn't like the Xbox One Elite Wireless Controller at all, so I'm returning both, as I have no need for it now.

I also didn't like the software I had to download in order to save my configurations on the Elite.

The form factor is also a little out there in terms of it being a giant stick that juts out into everything. The provided cable is useful, but then it becomes a black box that lurks all over the place. It would have been nice to see someone do a little more design work on this so it wouldn't cover up 2 usb ports, too. (Yeah, if I use the cable, it only uses one, but if I don't, it uses 2.)
4743576
I like the charging station, but the system of how you put it on top of the Xbox is more complicated than it needs to be and not very functional... everything works well, so I'm giving it a 4-star review. However, the assembly process is made much harder than it needs to be. The docking station then doesn't stay in place well at all. It slides around on top of the Xbox whenever I put a controller onto the docking station. I wish the station was completely separate rather than on top of the Xbox, but it is what it is. I've enjoyed using it and don't like wasting money on batteries, so it gets the job done!
4418415
It looks just slightly better than composite cables for some games. Some games it causes wavy lines like when you look through a fire.
408788
It is very hard to juggle between the headphones, pigtails and the hair pieces. Other than that, it looks absolutely amazing!
738910
Bought these to cover the tearing plastic on my Xbox 360 controllers. They don't fit smooth and they often slip off during gameplay. To their merit, they are grippy but what's the point if they're uncomfortable and fall off constantly.
1859344
It does look nice, however, it doesn't stick too well. The flat sections hold fine, but in the front where it bends around the front angles the adhesive doesn't hold well and it keeps peeling off no matter how many times I smooth it down. I ensured to clean the Xbox first to remove any dust beforehand, but it seems like the material is too thick and keeps wanting to straighten out around the angles. I'll try bending it at those points.
Also, on the front of the Xbox where there is a cut out for the power button, the skin seems to be enough for the Xbox to think it is a finger press. Everytime I go to smooth out the skin on the front (with the Xbox plugged in) it keeps turning the device on and off repeatedly even though I am not touching anywhere near the button. I think the hole should be a bit bigger.
3586407
These fit okay on the joystick but I'm not very impressed. I also HATE how they rub against the controller. I have no idea how others avoid this issue because i have tried over and over to re-install them with the same issue. I even tried the "fold them inside out" technique which gets them on quick and easy but still causes them to rub on the sides. I will leave them on for now but will need to remove for fast paced games. Very disappointed.
4535945
Love how the controller looks with the pink paws for the analogue sticks :) however I have to take off a star because I cannot run in the games I play which is disappointing (hopefully it will just take some getting used to) but I still recommend :)
3370083
the buttons look great. just the only problem i had with them is the shape of them. i installed them into a legit microsoft controller. so its not an issue with the controller shell. i had to use a razor and shave down the sides of the button on a couple of them along with the guide tabs that keep them in the right position just so they could fit freely in the holes. if you aren't really picky like i am and don't mind possibly having to alter these to fit a controller then go for it. sadly this review is pretty much a copy and paste from the review i did on the smoke black button set. simply because the exact same issues happened with these. and i ordered both at the same time and did the install in the same sitting.

a plus is that they send you a free T8 tool to remove the screws with every order. thanks to them i now have 4 tools. hahah.