I received a case in an open box, with ...
598030
I received a case in an open box,  with a fingerprint smudge and scuffs all up one side.  I didn't buy this used, but it obviously was.  It even has jimmy marks up the side where someone pried it off another phone! What the hell???
2835041
purchased as open, but in new condition.  small piece of plastic on top of case is cracked, but I kept it.  Next time I will spring for brand new product to avoid this.  You can't trust condition will be as it is represented.
4298153
Received the wrong case case, didn't feel like going through the hassle of return exchange.
2491762
After reading the review that was posted by the previous user, I became inclined to purchase this case. I did do some research about the case before purchasing it, and the same case turned up on new egg. Although the case wasn't "currently available" on newegg, however after looking at the pictures on there of the case...I purchased this. And obviously, what I received did not turn out to be what was displayed on the pictures. Everything was perfect as for the case I received (as the description says), but the bottom part is fully open, rather than just having a small hole for the mic.

So, if you do decide to buy this make sure to purchase it from newegg since they have pictures on there, just in case you need to return the case if it turns out to be something else. However, overall the case is fine so far, it covers the talk, end and back buttons as well as the volume rocker, the camera, and the locks buttons. And so basically the top and bottom parts of the case a pretty much fully open. Purchasing this case from amazon turned out to be completely different from what was shown on newegg.
100761
My box had been opened and there was a fold in the main piece at the top. I want new when I pay full price for something
2876108
I hope it works...received open package item...other sellers out there
4350123
This came in what appeared to be an open box and was not the product I purchased but something similar.
4696685
Looks like box had been opened. Machine looks untouched, but worthy of a side-eye
2664482
I received an unsealed product in a clear ziplock bag with no original packaging. There is product on the outside of the bottle, and I suspect it was previously used.
4152853
received a used product, parts unwrapped and box previously opened.
1878184
Not  as was displayed, and package was open, missing parts
1198604
That's not what was delivered. My case does not look like the one pictured.
4558814
I rarely post negative reviews but I am disappointed with the particular case that I received. If you receive one in perfect condition, you may very well give it 5 stars. The interior is plush and my daily driver guitar seems very snug and safe in there. I also like the way it _would_ look if mine were not defective. That is the positive portion of my experience.

This case has a very unsightly flap of extra material right along the edge which stands out from most angles (see pictures). It also appears to have a smattering of a clear sticky substance all over it, as if someone had dropped an open can of polyurethane nearby (also visible in close-up pictures). Lastly, one of the hinges is bent out of shape and needs to be jostled into position when you close it. Fixable, but annoying.

At the end of the day, I don't think the sellers deliberately sent me this sub-par unit, but I am upset with what I received. If it weren't such a hassle to return, I would exchange it without hesitation. Now I need to decide whether repackaging it is really worth the trouble, and investigate if it's going to cost me anything to return it...
1961419
I haven't opened this package yet.
Waiting on my motherboard and etc. to get here first.
But I know it will be awesome. :)

So, I did eventually get the package open. And I do love this case.
2503078
I purchased this case as a gift and apparently it fits just fine. The case came in a small cardboard box barely bigger than itself, shipped in a padded envelope, and it was in good condition.
2927135
When I took the case out the box it was oddly sticky for some reason and the box itself was damaged.
3766091
The case itself seems pretty sturdy. But, I paid for a brand new case and received one that has scratches on the back. Not going to bother sending it back for what I paid, but still seems like they should check these better before they ship them.