Looking at this shoe I ordered the 9 and it fits great. Am actually thinking about getting another pair in ...
581471
I can wear between an 8 to a 9.  Looking at this shoe I ordered the 9 and it fits great.  Am actually thinking about getting another pair in a different color.
415491
I would recommend ordering a size up. I have wide feet and it can be hard to find women's sizes that fit my feet so I buy men's shoes sometimes.  I had to return the first pair I got (a men's 8) because they were smaller than I expected. Once I got the 9's though, I think they're really cute, comfortable, quality shoes.
3883758
I wasn't sure about the shoe but I really like it. The only issue and reason for a 4 is that I ordered an 8 since I usually wear a 10, sometimes a 9 1/2, and they are a little large. However I'm not sure if a 7 (womens 9) would be too tight. If I keep them I'd definitely have to wear thick socks with them. Since Doc Marten's are heavier shoes it can become more of a problem if they are a little big, as they pull your feet down and I end up using different muscles in my feet to keep them on (similar to how you use your toes to keep flip flops on) which is not really a good thing for me.
Otherwise they are very nice looking, great quality, and soft inside.
Update:
I realize now that the feeling of the shoe slipping away is actually the style of the shoe (with the split down the top). I've actually gotten used to the feeling now. However I still think they are a little big on me but since there are no 8's to be found I'm keeping them. I'm going to try an insert to see if that helps but for now I've just been wearing thicker socks with them.  I think they look really nice with jeans and I've worn them with business casual pants.
1290587
I researched a few sites recommending what size I should get. I'm almost always a shoe size 8. But I found that the corresponding size 39 was too big. I then ordered a 38 and it seems to be just right, just need to return the 39's. I haven't worn them much yet but they seem pretty comfortable for teaching on my feet all day. And they look great.
1938666
usually a 9 fits fine but this shoe is a little short.....but the 9.5 would have been to big.  I am hoping they stretch some
1074419
This shoe fits true to size, Im 8.5 and purchased 8.5. Not sure why it has low reviews but its such a cute shoe. I can see this shoe might not be for you if you have wide feet
701278
This shoe looks great and fits wonderfully. I have really wide feet and am always happy when I find a comfortable shoe for my foot. At first my feet were killing me (usually my little sister breaks my shoes in) but after a couple wears they fit great so be patient.

You do need to order a half size down, I usualy wear an 8 and can ocassionally squeeze into a 7 1/2 but this 7 1/2 fits perfect.

The shoes looks really nice and holds its shape. It holds the shape because it's kind of stiff (which is why it hurt so much to break in) but it just looks so good.

Anyways, good shoe, GREAT price on amazon (it was on sale at a department store for $50, but got in here for $35 including shipping)
4610470
Very cute shoe!  I wear a size 9. I ordered a size 9, & it fits perfectly!
4958575
The shoe is awesome,I ordered a 11US it is a bit too big so I sent them back and reordered a size smaller. I love the look and feel of these!!!
3219895
I ordered a size 7 although my feet are a very normal size 8 and it fits perfectly.  So if you occasionally buy a half size smaller and rarely buy a half size above your normal size, then definitely go to a down a size.  My daughter has a pair of size 8s, so I ordered down because I had tried hers on and the sole seems more like a 9, but they will stay on because of the way they're made.
These are very flattering to my slightly wide in the toe feet.
One drawback is that they do hold the heat a little.  On the other hand, I like wearing them almost all year hear in the Pacific Northwest.
These are so comfortable I will need to order more patterns and solids so I'll have them to go with everything.
3656005
I really like this shoe a lot! I would have to say it fits too big though, if you're ordering this shoe be sure that you order it a half size smaller
4401074
I do love this shoe - howeverI first ordered a size 7 my true size and it was just too tight and I wasn't willing to pinch toes for this break end - so I returned( super easy had my cc refunded in 1 day) and bought them in a 7.5 I love them, they fit better but I find the 7.5 a little wide but I have a slender foot - other than that is comfortable and beautiful and the heel is a sexy height but still great for work. I will be ordering the black ones as well.
1206643
Bought a 9 like i do in most shoes and it fit. I have the gold pair as well in this shoe. Love them for work and everyday wear.
1310379
I wear US size 9 or 9.5, ordered this shoe in a 40, perfect fit.  I have them on right now, very pretty and comfortable.
2407974
I also got a 9, and it was just right. Some of us tend to wear a little smaller sandal than shoe. I often wear 9.5 in shoes but 9 was right for me in this shoe. It's not exactly a beautiful shoe, but it IS comfortable. I wear athletic shoes all winter and need support. These give me enough in summer in place of athletic shoes all the time.
2344900
This shoe is adorable...I wear size 9 bit when I read some of the reviews I decided to take a 1/2 size smaller....but when it came it was still big...so my advice would be to order 1 size smaller than your original size...
3229268
I usually wear a size 8 regular shoe,but found the last pair Hafs of 8 (39) too large.  this time I ordered size 7 (38) and its perfect.  great fit and comfort! don't know if one should size down, but in my case it worked.