Bought as a replacement and it is perfect.
599295
We had an accident with the original tray and ordered these as a replacement.  They are perfect and the replacement went smooth as silk.
2217183
worked perfect as a replacement. much easier to install than I originally thought it would be
2781859
It's a perfect replacement for my old similar one that was purchased over 20 years ago.  I didn't ever think that one would wear out but apparently it did.  The  old one cost $85.  What a difference from this one!
77238
Works well, perfect replacement fit, good price.
1481918
Perfect my my needs.  Replacing old one with same version.
113927
Perfect  bought as a replacement for one that was damaged in my kit . Exactly what I was looking for
130266
Ordered this to replace our ripped one and it fit perfect and is just as good as the original one.
4784197
Though I only really needed one, the gear fit perfectly and is working like a charm.  I will save the other 3 for additional replacements if needed.  It is the exact match to the original.
366031
Perfect replacement as I could not find refills locally in store.  I didn't have any issues with installation and have not had any problems with the new line.
560822
This is my 2nd attempt at a replacement.  It fit exactly and seems to work much better than my first one.  I am happy that Amazon and the previous seller allowed me a full refund of my first purchase.
3194286
i have lost my orignial one, this is the perfect replacement.
3913152
Replaced a beat up original.  No complaints.
3810200
Perfect replacement, good if not better than Orginal.
4274535
This was exactly what I needed as a replacement and it works just great--fit the way it should.  Thanks.
4518699
We broke our first Bullet mixer this size (large) and so this is a replacement. It's perfect. Exactly like the original. I'm really glad they sell these as this size was used every day in our house.
3814531
Perfect replacement after I broke my mother in-laws when helping her move. It is almost identical so she was happy.
3130391
When the original holder fell apart I needed a new one and this is exactly the right one. Fits perfectly and now I can move on.