Good, sturdy tray - the reason for the 3 ...
591693
Good, sturdy tray - the reason for the 3 stars is that it is not the right size.  I measured the old tray 3 times before I ordered and it is an extremely tight fit.  I will keep it as I don't want to go through the hassle of sending it back and it does fit - it is just so tight that I am afraid of it getting stuck and breaking when I try to take it out to clean.
4294534
Document tray organizer

This is a three-tray wire document organizer with a narrow basket along the edge for writing utensils. Assembly of the basket is easy and intuitive and you likely will not need the included instructions. That being said, there was one major issue that I had with this which I couldn't figure out how to fix and made the organizer far less sturdy. That issue was that, if the screws were relatively tight (not overly tight or super tight, but just secure), the basket would not stand evenly. One of the feet would be off the desk while the other made contact and it would see-saw.

The only way that I could get it to sit evenly was to leave the screws on the loose side. That makes the whole thing less sturdy and the bars shift a little if you need to pick the whole organizer up to move it. I don't know if this is an issue with mine alone, or if there was something about how I put it together, but there was nothing in the instructions to guide me on how to deal with this issue. I tried loosening all of the screws and tightening them slowly and incrementally on one side or the other and, not matter what I did, the issue of an imbalanced tray couldn't be avoided. In the end, I gave up and just left the screws slightly loose as needed to keep it sitting flat. You can have it tight and it will wobble or you can leave it loose and it will sit, but it's a no-win situation.

Other than that, this is a pretty good tray organizer, though the metal is a bit on the thinner side and feels a bit flimsy. Fortunately, the box this comes in is very good so it didn't get bent or damaged in transit. I just expected firmer metal for the price point at the time of this review (around $24). It is a good-looking organizer and the basket on the side for pens and pencils is handy. I am just not happy with how it came together and how it feels.

Note: I received a free sample for my assessment.
491327
This product is actually very good and seems sturdy. My ice cubes comes out pretty flawless with no residue and no weird taste (I use filtered water). The dimension of the tray also makes it very easy to fit into tighter spaces in my freezer. The tray holds up well and do not 'wiggle' when filled with water. I subtracted one star because it is pretty hard to pop out the ice cubes, especially the first ice cube of the tray. Once you get the first cube out, the rest are a little easier. I think this is because  this tray has a very slim lip/edge, so there isn't much for you to grip onto when removing the cubes. I would be willing to sacrifice a little bit of the space the tray takes up if they modify it and put a slightly larger lip/edge for grip.
2177784
Trays are flexible enough to allow cubes to pop out with just a slight twist. I bought 4 of these about 2 years ago and they holding up well.
4747569
Great Tray! Have to fill from front and work to the back as it will get hard to put the last one in if you fill the other way.
301811
I have one of these and, like all Ginger products, it is well made and easy to install and mounts sturdily. HOWEVER, beware of the porcelain tray. It is relatively fragile and not suited for rough use. It's great for storing small items like jewelry or cologne or a bar of soap, but if you drop a heavy item on it like an electric razor or a glass, it WILL break. I know, I just ordered an open box item for a reduced price so I can replace the tray. As far as I can tell, you can't buy a replacement from the manufacturer.
1505215
I ordered several of these. The tray is sturdy and looks nice. However, in the ones I received the grooves were not squarely cut in the glass -- if you look closely they run diagonally. Also, one of the trays had scratched glass despite it being perfectly packaged. I suspect it left the factory (made in china) this way...
1296728
This is a well built, sturdy keyboard tray. Easy installation, it took me about 15 minutes with hand tools. I would have given it five stars, but once installed, the tray is very difficult to pull out from the under the desk position. I tried silicone spray and finally automotive grease to the slide which didn't help. Too bad, as this tray is ergonomically perfect.
80653
It's amazing how difficult it is to find a keyboard tray that fits a natural keyboard. The pitch on trays isn't only convenience, but ergonomics, so why do so few fit ergonomic keyboards? Who knows. Anyway, this tray is excellent, but it would be five stars with two modifications: 1) tilt lower and away from the user, and 2) swivel even slightly left or right to allow more flexibility with positioning. I ended up drilling too many extra holes in the bottom of my desk trying to get the whole thing aligned.

One more thing: The mounting template (i.e., the piece of paper that you tape to the underside of your desk to drill pilot holes) is designed by default for non-natural keyboards so Kelly can use the same template for all of their trays (I would assume). I discovered the hard way that you need to move it back a good 2.5 inches for it to accommodate the extra depth of the Natural Keyboard Tray. It says this in the fine print on the template, but I would guess that the majority of folks who installed this particular product made the same mistake that I did.
4182449
Sturdy and nice design: I have bought these to reorganize my super messy drawers for cutlery.

My aim was to find something NOT PLASTIC , easy to clean and holds enough stuff. So far, I am very happy with this tray.

What I did like the most is small details of design: they have rounded the corners of the tray hence not only I am safe from occasional hurting my hand when doing stuff in a rush bit also it becomes easy to carry , change place with it. Another design factor is the density of the metal mesh: I can put small stuff in it and I do not worry about things falling from it. I am putting here some pictures and On the second one you can see the difference between this one and the one I got from TJ maxx. The second one is more underwhelming:  I cannot put small things in it and they left the mesh open ended .

I am very happy with this tray ! very good design. very sturdy with a good form
4579913
This tray is really nice but I sure wish it was cheaper.  I've got a stack of accumulated hard drives for various purposes here (including some older SCSI drives from my UNIX workstation days), using this to organize & protect instead of my former "piles on the shelf" method!  Eventually need to get a few more.

It's not clear from the listing, but it does come in a suitable, usable cardboard box which helps store things in case you're not putting it directly into a drawer or the like.  I'm looking for a nice plastic file box it will fit, no luck yet.
3483747
I like this tray and it works well, but I would have just liked to be able to choose the color of tray that I received.
553354
Simple and sturdy rack tray with ventilation slots. We used it to hold an NVR.  It is perfect for racking an item that doesn't have brackets or screws.  The perforations allow for velcro securing.  To accommodate additional hardware that we wanted to secure, we drilled our own holes very easily.

Will likely purchase again.

Pros:
-Cheap!
-Accurate width & hole placement
-Sleek

Cons:
-Flaky spray coat
524472
Beautiful, Sturdy, Well Finished, and "Right Sized" - many trays are too wide to be used in your lap in an easy chair!!!
4585298
The Table Mate is a great design idea. The frame is good quality steel, easy to assemble. Just 2 cons for this product. The plastic the tray is made from is soft and warps slightly. Of the 3 adjustable positions only the horizontal position is useful. The other 2 positions are angled too steep.
1296393
Perfect as tray, but also using it as a cutting board.
3967772
Tray should lift and hold as in picture but is obviously missing a very important piece - the piece that holds it up