Beautiful boots, not the same quality of most Frye boots
596164
I purchased these boots in maple. The color of the leather is gorgeous and the fit is good except the toe box is very narrow. I had mine stretched at a cobbler. I am somewhat of a Frye collector - so my only problem is I have a personal inventory to compare these boots to. These boots are made in Mexico not the USA or Spain where many high end Frye boots are made. The leather is much thinner than all of my harness boots as well as all of my knee high Frye boots which are lined inside. The zipper is a bit sticky. I think the price reflects the Frye name and not the quality of the boot. For about the same price, one could get Frye cavalry boots made of thicker leather which will probably last longer. However, you will note I didn't return the boots. The color is amazing, the outside zipper detail is beautiful and the lower heel is very comfortable. I also ordered an 8, down one size from my regular 9 - I should have ordered an 8 1/2 instead. I admit it, I loved these boots too....
3141604
This was my third pair of Frye boots.  I have to say these are not my favorite.  They bulk out by the ankle.  Although I am keeping them but don't think I would order them again
2102028
In general a really nice pair of boots.  I will definitely say they are very narrow in the arch.  My feet are very narrow and it felt tight to wear for the first couple of days.  They were also surprisingly tight around my calves but loosened up very quickly after wearing them for a day.  My only other complaint overall is that I guess for a $300 pair of boots I still expect to get something I can pass on to my grandchildren...I expect them to be very well made and take a beating like the original Fryes.  I have a pair of work harness boots that have held up great doing heavy duty farm work over the past five years and, while I know these are not work boots, I expected them to be of the same superior craftsmanship.  They are nicely made, but even after a month of pretty serious day wear (and that's just walking around town) there is some stitching that is coming loose and a place on one of the heels that is coming apart.  A little disappointing.  They are also NOT made for long periods of walking or being on your feet...after a day walking around the city I had some blisters starting on the balls of my feet.  Overall a really nice looking and feeling boot but not everything I would have hoped from from Frye and for a boot this expensive.
51040
These are a little looser than planned. But they are gorgeous! I will just have to wear them with thicker socks. I am madly in love with these boots! They are my first pair of Fryes and I am LOVE them.
1501466
These are exactly the type of boots I've been looking for! I love Frye, but I haven't liked the super structured leather in other boots. This soft leather is great, and the color of brown is a lot like cognac (not as bright), and I think goes better with my clothing options! Love love these boots and the button details and zipper!
2914507
Great boots that I get tons of compliments on (got the Saddle Tan). These aren't Allen Edmonds, the leather isn't great, the soles are decent, but poorly cut. I'm doubt they will last because I can't image they would take much polishing because of the leather thickness. For a sometimes look good boot, get it. For an office or everyday boot, keep looking.
2900350
Normally I need an 8 in Frye but they were a little smaller than other Frye 8s .... however I broke them in by continuing to wear them around the house on the rugs (in case I had to return) .. leather is thick and great quality; however it's pretty stiff.  It took me a while to break in but I am glad I did.  They are great quality boots that will last for years and have a great classic style.  I can now wear them all day with no issues.
3953257
I really wanted to love these boots.  I had been searching and searching for a high-end leather boot and Frye usually delivers.  I didn't mind spending $200-$300, but if I did they had to be perfect.  These were not.  I wanted a chunky heal (I am 5'1) and always like a little more of a heal.  When I received the boots, the leather was not as nice as I expected.  And they were too snug...they didn't look like $300 boots even though I got them on Sale for $160...around there.  The 'black' antique was what I ordered, but it looked very different in person.  They offer various 'black' colors, and this was not a 'rich' looking black leather.  I love the style of the boot, but for the money and quality I had to give it 2 stars.....was disappointed. My search continues!
3282324
I bought these boots elsewhere but felt the need to write a more thorough review than what has been provided thus far.

First off, these boots are GORGEOUS! I've received compliments from men and women alike. I LOVE the look. and how versatile they are. They can be worn with skinny jeans, leggings, or a dress. The size is on point. I wear a 6.5 to 7 and got the 6.5 with some reservations about how they would feel at the end of the day. I had plenty of wiggle room and was even able to put on super wool socks and they were still barely even tight. The inside is lined with some type of semi-fuzzy (read warm-ish looking) material. The tongue is attached at the bottom and by a loop in the mid section like you find on tennis shoes. The laces can be adjusted to fit different calf circumferences.

However, the black on the sole just rubs off. I noticed that some of it was gone when I tried them on but thought it to be a flaw. I got them for $20 less than Amazon is charging so, no big deal. I wore them for 20 minutes out of the store and the sides and bottoms are basically going on colorless now. The color scuffs up the boot and the synthetic leather is easily scratched. The sole has absolutely NO cushion. None. I wear super wool socks and water insoles and that makes it better though. The side zipper digs in to my shin and leaves me tender after. I'm hoping that will subside with being broken in. The laces in the boots feel like they're made from sort of imitation cotton. I'm pretty sure they'll last, but whatever the manufacturer did to make them look distressed made them feel weird and unpleasant.

 I'm in love with the look of the boot itself just not impressed with the quality of the materials.
4360294
These shoes are made with the same quality as the other Frye boots I have.  I loved them so much I kept them despite the fact that they are tight in the arch area.  I love the unique look, big buckles, worn look, zipper and perfect height heel.  I have plenty of room for my toes and they look super cute on.  I can wear them all day but I work at a computer for most of it.  I would not wear these if I was going to be on my feet for most of the day.  As far as shoe size goes, with thick Nike socks, they run slightly small in length and fit tight around the arch and heel area (I think this means they are narrow).  Going up a shoe size will not make a difference in the arch and heel area.  Now that I have worn them a few times, the leather is starting to stretch and they don't feel as tight.  So, once they are truly broken in, I don't think it will be a problem.  I like the zipper on these boots.  Frye tends to make the opening of the short boots too small to fit your foot.  With the zipper, there is no issue. They are made of a thick, stiff, leather so they will hold up for those of us that are hard on their shoes.  Also, the insoles are not removable.
866535
I have been wanting Frye boots for a few years, due to the high quality and timeless styling, but could not justify the price for the women's boot. After this winter, my two pairs of brown boots were ready to be donated to Goodwill,  so I took plunge when seeing that the girls pair were a third of the cost.  I was worried that the quality would be lacking, but WOW  These are beautiful, thick leather and sturdy sole.  I will be able to wear them for years and years to come.

I have ultra tiny feet (3-3 1/2 in girls, 5 1/2 in womens), so I bought the 3 1/2.  They are roomy, but not overly so.  They will fit well with thick socks and maybe an insert to add a little more cushion.
4902962
I bought these at a department store. Primarily, I wanted winter boots to wear in a city that gets some snow, but not a ton. I wanted shoes that I could wear to work but would still hold up in winter weather. I've worn these boots many times now, and am happy with my purchase. However, at first, my feet did slide uncomfortably forward in the footbed after walking a few miles -- the heel pushes the toes down into the front of the shoe. However, this is normal for a heeled boot. I bought a few ball of foot inserts at CVS and walked around in them more, and since they've been broken in, the problem has become less noticeable.

I do feel that the leather is not as resilient as I'd hoped. The leather panels are smooth and beautiful. After purchasing these boots, I wiped them clean with a dry, clean cloth, then applied leather cream to the exterior of the boot. After only a month or so of regular wear, the leather panels look significantly scuffed and worn. I'm disappointed, because my intention was to invest in a sturdy boot, but they already look like they are a year or so old. Any tips from fellow Ciera owners, or boot connoisseurs in general? Should I oil them again?

Besides this, I love these boots. They are beautiful on, with just the right amount of height, and the bolo is a fun detail that adds interest. Plus, the sole is shearling -- so comfortable.
1954948
Frye boots are the Supreme quality leather boots,  shown in the stitching,  smell and finish of the leather,  and overall craftsmanship.  I am extremely happy with this purchase, and even though they're a bit expensive,  they are definitely worth it!!
1766652
These fit a bit smaller than other Frye shoes, but I still found a half size down from my true size more comfortable. The elastic on the heel does push the foot forward, but as these get worn, I'm betting it will stretch to fit. The leather is stiff, and for some it may not be worth the time it takes to break them in. These shoes have such a dainty look and the color (cognac) is beautiful.
330598
This is my 4th pair of Frye boots and these are definitely one of my favs.  Take the advice from the other reviewers and order a half size down because they run only slightly large (ex. I normally wear a 9.5 but I ordered a 9.)  They pretty much formed to fit my feet by the 2nd wear. If I ordered the 9.5 they would have been too big by the time the leather stretched.  The leather is super soft and it's nice because you can wear these folded over-falling just under the knee or unfolded which ends up covering your entire knee pretty much.  They look great both ways!  These do look more brown than they do grey-or at least mine do, but they are still beautiful.
818155
I think a lot of people will like these boots. I would give them a 4.5/5 if I could. They are Frye's and very well made. The leather is buttery soft. I got size 9, in black, and normally wear an 8.5 or 9M. I would wear them with jeans underneath. I first tried them on my bare legs--as if I was going to wear them with a sweater dress and tights--they were very loose in the ankle and slouched a little on my calf (I'm 5'7/135lbs, with normal sized calves)). I was not crazy about the look at all. I will say that I think the calf area is smaller than most Frye's boots--so that's a plus for ladies with skinny calves.

I prefer slouch boots in suede, and stiffer boots to be in leather--maybe I'm just weird like that! However, these do look quite nice over jeans, though I tried them on with BOOTCUT jeans and not skinny jeans. That filled out the ankle area enough that the boot no longer looked strange. Additionally, there is not a whole lot of padding, so an insert would be a good idea if you plan on wearing them a long time. They are NOT uncomfortable, though, as is. Overall though, I do like them, and I will keep them. They will be a great wardrobe staple! They can easily go from day wear to night wear.
2437720
These boots are very high quality.  I am still breaking them in but have very little soreness after wearing them for 12+ hours.  The stitching around the top is a little rough and scratchy.  The height of the 12R is exactly what I wanted - mid calf with a gap.  It wasn't too hard for me to get the boots on, but my feet are kind of narrow.  The color of the gaucho and the leather are BEAUTIFUL.  This is my first pair of FRYE's and I can tell I will wear them all the time and they'll last.  Amazon is having a GREAT sale in my size.  I purchased them for $93.