Decided to try the waterproof socks out after just receiving ...
590401
Decided to try the waterproof socks out after just receiving them and after 5 seconds water came through most expensive regular  socks i ever purchased
238939
Loved these boots at first site. I went to an outside event where I stood or walked around for 3+ hours. Warm, comfortable and attractive. Grand slam...until I wore them on a walk through the snow.  Not waterproof. Within 30 minutes I could feel the wet seeping in. I did not walk through any water or puddles just fresh snow. So disappointed. These were advertises as waterproof but proved not to be so. Bottom line, ok for warmth, comfort and looks just don't expect to keep dry if snowing or raining. If purchased locally from a well-known store I would return.
4815819
I have only worn them twice since receiving them earlier this week.  Based on the "short" time wearing them they are fine.  I can only give them four stars as I have not had an opportunity do any hiking or test them for being waterproof.
2639644
The boots are comfortable and the fit was good, however they was not waterproof for me. It only took afew hours for me in morning dew grass for my socks to get wet. I was very disappointed and returned them.
634715
I was very skeptical at first buying these socks. The reviews seem good, but I have never heard of this brand before. I would say this particular style is very niche, but I did enjoy. I wear them throughout the day going between business wear, gym wear, and casual wear.

Note that they say for sizes 6-11. I am a size 12 and they fit me well. They do not recommend drying them, which I think a lot of people ignore and then leave poor reviews about fit. I have washed them and air dried, and they still fit well.

Pros:
- fit my size 12 feet
- silicon strips on the heel are a life changer
- have a moisture wicking feel to them
- cool patterns and colors

Cons:
- cannot be machine dried with the rest of my socks
- they seem well sized for my feet, so I would be wary if you're size 6-7
2874186
I didn't know socks could make such a difference
4490968
I was hesitant to purchase these boots because I have another pair of Timberland hiking boots that are extremely rigid and uncomfortable. I took the risk because I liked the look of the shoe, all of the features it comes with, and reviews were mostly positive. I'm happy to be able to add to those positive reviews, no regrets about this purchase whatsoever.

I work in operations at a theme park so I needed safety certified shoes but it was also important for the boots to be comfortable, water-resistant, and cute. Here are my observations so far:

Water Resistance: Since Florida weather is just as stormy as it is sunshiny I was looking for something that would protect my feet from rain puddles. I've had to walk around all day in shoes that just retained water, and it was AWFUL. With these shoes I'm not concerned about having water logged feet at all. In order to break them in faster I stood in a bathtub of hot water for five minutes. The water was only able to penetrate my boots when it got up to where the laces start. At that point water did fill my shoes and pooled around my toes. Afterwards I walked around and within ten minutes my feet felt dry again. The only moisture in my shoes is the water that my socks are still holding onto. It's a miracle.

Slip Resistance: Tried to slide my feet over chemicals dropped on smooth tile and there wasn't any give. The boots are indeed slip resistant.

Comfort/Longevity: I walk anywhere from 10-30 miles during my shift, some if it over cobblestone paths which would send shooting pains up my shins in my old shoes. These shoes have a thick rubber heel which absorb most of the shock of walking on uneven terrain. The sole itself is not cushioned. When I put the boots on for the first time I was wearing thin socks so the soles felt like they might be uncomfortable after a while. Now that they are broken in, and with moderate thickness athletic-type socks, they are the most comfortable shoes I have. Even after 18 miles in them at work, I am not desperate to take them off when I get in the car.

Fit: I was nervous about this since I've never ordered shoes online. My other Timbs are 5.5 in boy's sizes, so I ordered the 7.5 wide since I know Timberlands run narrow. When I first put the shoes on they felt roomy, maybe a little too roomy. After I laced them up properly and wore slightly thicker socks they were PERFECT. Formed right around my feet. I wouldn't say they are true to size since I'm normally an 8 regular.

Steel toe: Can't say I've dropped anything on my feet yet but I do kick sticky doors that won't open without hurting my toes. I can't even have tell they have steel toes because they are so comfortable, but they are definitely there and I'll trust these shoes to protect my feet if anything drops.

Style: The reason I ultimately went with these shoes and not another pair advertised as waterproof came down to the style. These are cute and versatile. They don't look wonky with my uniform and they're also pretty fashionable with some of my regular clothes so I don't have to wear them just for work. They're somewhat chunky, that was the look I was going for, but they're not bulky.

Other pros: It's a hundred degrees out right now and my toes aren't roasting, so that's a great thing. They're hefty but they don't feel heavy. Apparently there's some protection against electrical shock built into the bottom of the shoe. I'm not walking over circuits so I don't mind but maybe it will help me not get struck by lightning, haha.

If I had to find a con I would say that the leather around the opening of the shoe feels too rigid but I can tell they will break in fast. In summary, I would absolutely recommend these and plan to buy them again when this pair wears out.
2508437
I purchased 4 pair of these socks and they were used by 4 different people on an 8 day trip to the BWCA in southern Canada. We all quit wearing them after the first day because they did not work at all. We had to wade in knee deep water to load / unload our canoes as many as 6 times a day and they filled with water the first time they were in the water. The water did not even have to be over the top. This is very disappointing as we spent a lot of money on them and they are useless. We found that our feet were warmer and felt better simply wearing wool socks since the water could drain off of them. The seal skins held the water and our feet were soaking all day.<a data-hook="product-link-linked" class="a-link-normal" href="/Black-Seal-Skinz-Waterproof-All-Season-Socks-2190-Size-L/dp/B001D4JQPW/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_rvw_txt?ie=UTF8">Black Seal Skinz Waterproof All Season Socks 2190 Size L</a>
1815872
and quickly tore open the box, took my socks on, and breathed a sigh of instant gratification as i slid my feet in :o) I've been needing a pair of warm boots to wear daily to work, since my office is cold, as well as just daily period for these northeast winters but can't get past the ugliness of UGGs or the flat bottoms - BUT, shearling was calling. So, when I came across these, and especially at the lowest price, knowing Amazon has great customer service, I gave them a shot and so far, I am thrilled! I ordered my normal size, 8.5 and they seem to fit beautifully. I have wider feet that swell by the end of the day so I can tell that they will be a little loose in the morning but that is fine by me! The wide toe box is a great fit for me as well and my toes do not hit the front of the boot - however, I think i have short feet, so its possible that someone with a longer foot may have to size up. If you have a narrow long foot, it may be difficult to find the right size.

The sand color is as portrayed in the pic and for I do feel some of the seaming between shearling panels inside, which can be a little rough. I'm hoping that with normal wear, these areas will soften a bit but if not, they would be easy to trim down. I gave the boots 4 stars since I just received them tonight but will be back with an update in a week or month or so.

And yes, they are WARM and perfect for not wearing socks! I can definitely tuck skinny or straight jeans in - boot cut can be pushed in on the top and just stick out in that comfortably haggard way. Or wear the boot cut or flares over the boot. I don't think you could do this with the tall ones, which are DEFINITELY next on my list! I love the regular boot bottom as opposed to a flat bottom and the sole does look like it will provide good traction. But like I said before, I will be back later once I've given them a good wearing in - which starts tomorrow!
4185162
They were not waterproof... When I stepped in water outside (puddle) I felt my sock was damp (and toes). That's why I returned.
410647
Preparing to return boots; feet got cold within 10 minutes despite two pairs of socks -
4615271
I've only had them a few days.  Felt terrific first time I put them on and went for a hike.  Got pretty wet, but have dried out well and I'm headed out again.  So far, so good.
3868834
Advertised as Waterproof.  Once they arrived I went to clean my pond filter to test out this claim.  Once the fingers are submerged water starts rushing in.  These are diving gloves?  I'm a student and purchased these for my Streams & Wetland course.  I believe I will continue in my search for a decent pair of water-resistant diving gloves.
571422
Fits my womens size 11 in length fairly well.  First time using them both sides, on both boots, where the black rubber meets the white pulled away and allowed moisture/water to seep in.  I'm so bummed that these are such a cheap boot and I ended up with wet socks.  I thought they'd at least last a season, however they didn't even last 2 hours.
4260709
I used these riding my bike in heavy rain. I've got fenders which helps keep water from hitting my shoes directly, but it was raining hard and my shoes were definitely wet. The socks kept my feet dry for about 10 min but in another 10 minutes my feet were soaked. By the end of my hour ride the socks were like bags of water around my feet. When I took them off I poured about half a cup of water out of each. The wetness seemed to come in from the soles of my feet which may relate to the repeated pressure there during cycling, which basically pushed water into the socks. On the other hand, they were comfortable and looked great. They might be good for keeping your feet dry in lighter conditions like if you have wet shoes from walking in dewy grass, but they definitely did not keep my feet dry when cycling in the rain with soaked shoes.
1611528
I purchased cute boat shoes and wanted no-show socks to wear with them.  I wore the shoes and socks to work on casual day and was unpleasantly surprised when I experienced discomfort around the heel of my foot.  By midday I had to put band-aids on my heel due to the rubbing.  I attributed the discomfort to the shoes and felt I could I have just worn heels that day if I was going to be uncomfortable.  Toward the end of day, I removed the Sakya socks and felt bliss!  I thought the shoes were cutting into my heel, but it was actually the elastic on the socks.  From now on I will wear the shoes with no socks.  They may not last as long, but will be comfortable.
3690311
Nice and waterproof, accidentally watered my shoe while filling a bucket and my sock stayed totally dry. I have to wear thinner socks with these shoes as I think they're meant to be worn sockless which I do not prefer.  They have good arch support and my feet don't feel as tired after a long day at work. Highly recommend!