The phone fits in it sooooo tight, that it ...
580609
The phone fits in it sooooo tight, that it will not come out... So u don't have to worry about it falling out ;)
4703949
It is handy, but very small and tight fit. I do like that it fits in my pocket. The case around the phone is thin too.
412264
Its very amazing it is very tight so it takes a while to put on the phone but it is good.
380784
If you're purchasing this case for use with Verizon's HTC Thunderbolt, you may be disappointed because it's an extremely tight squeeze.  It's also difficult to remove the phone from the case once you get the phone in it.
4129899
This case was touted to fit the iPhone 6 plus with a Defender case installed on the phone, well it fits but it is VERY tight and difficult to get the phone out of the case .
4638063
As several others have already noted, the case is way, way too small.  You CAN cram the S5 IS in there, but when you do get it in,  it's so tight the lens cover pops off and the zippers will probably split in no time. Not having a strap is also a big minus.
569017
The case is nice but the holder is so tight with the phone in that it is difficult to remove the phone!
1488961
An extremely tight fit. I had to bend the plastic way beyond what I was comfortable doing to get the phone past the middle prongs and had to almost break the bottom prongs to get the bottom of phone to fit. It is usable but sure not a Seidio or Otterbox. For the money, I will take the self modified product and be happy.
2820657
Great look for a family member's phone, but the two-part case fits so tightly that it's very difficult to put on and remove.  Concerned that we might damage the phone trying to remove the case.
581424
The case was so tight that it pushed on the power button when I inserted the phone. So if my phone was off, it would be on when inserted into the case. When my phone was on (even when it was locked) the case pushed down on the buttons, causing the screen to light up and the battery to drain in just a few hours.

When I attempted to e-mail them about the problem, Amazon said that their mailbox was full - (of complaints about this case, perhaps.)
2444188
This isn't SNUG, it's WAY too tight. I pushed and jammed and crammed to get my S5 into it, thinking I'd be able to use the pull tab to get it back out. No way, the pull tab does absolutely NOTHING and currently I'm trying to get the damn thing out without ripping the case apart and making it unreturnable.

UPDATE: The manufacturer contacted me and indicated that I must have gotten a bad one, and has voluntarily sent me a replacement. Unfortunately, it will not arrive in time for the trip I wanted it for, but I wanted to post an update reflecting his willingness to do the right thing before I left. I'm cautiously optimistic that the replacement will be better. If it's wonderful and I fall in love with it when I return, I'll post another update.
3028826
Such a tight fit on the phone I could not get it on without the power button being held down so long the phone crashed. Ended up buying a case in a store where I could try it out
2563405
This Case seems durable and useful, although if you're planning on buying it for a DROID 2, it fits, but very tightly. Very hard to get in and out.
4826799
It's exactly how it looks in the picture, but I wasn't expecting it to be as small as it is. I can't even fit my phone on the inside. The clutch is also has some weight to it.
2255445
I like it, but its really tight.  The case stays on by being incredibly tight around the phone.  Taking the case off was really hard.  I was worried I was going to break the phone.  Other than that, it looks nice, feels nice, and is slim.  For cheap it seems good.
2185607
The item was received promptly and well-packaged.  It is a very tight fit for the phone, making it difficult to extract the phone when a call is received.
4819399
The image online shows the phone fitting perfectly in the arm band case. What I received was obviously the case for a larger model phone that claimed to be for the droid mini in an otter box case. Yes, the phone fits, but there is so much extra room inside that it slides around - not at all secure like I need. It looks like I'm trying to wear a kindle on my arm...