Not bad, very warm though....
581543
It gets super steamy in this jacket but it is totally waterproof as the water just rolls off. Just wish it was a bit longer as it rides up back.
4324824
They fi wear about a half size smaller so I am glad that I ordered a 9 instead of an 8.5. They are fairly comfortable. A bit stiff but I am hopeful they will soften up a bit. Will report back after I have worn them about 100 hours. They are quite warm and that is coming from someone that normally has cold feet. I got these at a very good discount, so I can't really complain, well worth the 60 dollars I paid.
3540532
The good:  The boots fit great, and are very comfy.  In the summer I like to wear minimal shoes, so in general I can't stand huge clunky winter boots.  While these obviously aren't anything close to minimal, they've got some give to them, especially some flex to the soles, which makes them much more comfortable than I was expecting.  (Maybe that's typical for any Mukluk/Sorel-style boot, but anyway these feel great.)  They also seem durable enough -- I'm halfway through my second winter with these and they still seem in fine shape.

The bad:  The "-40F" rating is on these is a marketing joke.  I consider myself to have decent cold-weather tolerance (I still ride my bike in 0 degree chicago winters, and I've gone backpacking at -20F).  These boots are toasty down to around 10 to 15F.  At 0F, they're still tolerable only if you're moving around a lot.  I tested them out by sitting totally still outside in 5F weather, with a thick mountaineering sock inside, and my feet were freezing after 15 minutes.  From what I read, these have about half the insulation you'd typically find in a real -40F boot.  That said, they're slightly warmer than my previous winter boots, and cheaper than the other (warmer) options I looked at.

The verdict:  If you want to be comfortable at 10F, these are great boots, and very affordable, and I'd highly recommend them.  If you really need to be comfortable at negative temperatures for long periods of time at low-activity, spend the extra cash on something warmer.
923802
Really warm and toasty...It lost a star from me...because it's a lint magnetic. But I bought to wear just around the house when I get cold.
4976938
The sweater is very warm but a little bit on the tighter side in my opinion -with relation to my body type. Overall, it was a good purchase.
668484
I was expecting my backpacking trip on the SHT to be much chillier that 80 degree days and 50 degree nights, but this still served me well. I consider myself someone who gets cold very easily and struggles with being cold at night, but this was too warm for me in the 50 degree nights so I used it as a blanket unzipped the first night, and the second night had it zipped to my mid torso. I am 5'10" and a 240 lb female and it fit well, plenty long and enough room around the head. It is a bit difficult to maneuver in and out of while laying in a tent but I imagine that is just the nature of mummy bags.
3443263
I like the style, and the fit is good. They're not as warm as they could be. I was outside in some probably 20 degree weather and my hands were a bit chilly.
4897845
Crinkly sounding but extremely warm!! It took my husband a few nights to get used to the noise. It didn't bother me. For those in the South, you won't be able to use this one year round
2334030
Very warm. Almost too large to fit into my snowshoes. The top drawstring could be better designed. Overall not bad.
3726402
Very warm and lightweight. Tags inside are itchy so you need to cut them out.
2131784
So warm! :} a little bit big on me but nothing problematic. Probably just my personal fit
1957382
Very warm, not transparent at all. These do start to pill pretty quickly in the wash, but I've also been wearing these every day this winter. They might hold up better to less heavy/frequent use and washings.
1105554
These are quite nice for the price, but they are warm.  We cannot use these unless it is very cold out otherwise we sweat on them.
4372836
The good? I wore this for 20 days in China at 0 to 7 degrees C and it kept me warm as much as I expected. I even wore it inside the house, because the heaters didn't work that well there, so I had to wear this constantly to keep warm and it did the trick.

The bad, but not so so bad? It was easy to snag some of the threads. I read other reviews that said the feathers came out a lot. This is also true. My fianc had to work with a tooth pick to push some back in so it didn't make matters worse.

I'd recommend this to anyone who's going to be in weather down to freezing temperatures, but not below freezing. I did get the chills when it dropped below 0 C.
4619277
Very warm, mildly itchy, pretty tight on my head.
1756687
Very warm, not as waterproof as claimed though (or it could be my sweat because they are THAT warm, I cannot tell)
3691488
Overall I am pleased with this blanket. I don't know what the other reviewers are talking about when they say the heat is not adequate....I set the blanket on 3 and have to stick my foot out. On super cold nights....& upstate NY can get VERY cold....I bump it up to 5 and it is almost too hot. Only one thing keeping this blanket from being perfect....I wish it was a little thicker.  Otherwise a very nice, super soft blanket.