CREATE TABLE table_name_12 (year INT, regular_season VARCHAR, division VARCHAR)

Which Year is the lowest one that has a Regular Season of 5th, atlantic, and a Division larger than 4?
SELECT MIN(year) FROM table_name_12 WHERE regular_season = "5th, atlantic" AND division > 4
SELECT MIN("year") FROM "table_name_12" WHERE "5th, atlantic" = "regular_season" AND "division" > 4