Dataset Viewer
paper_id
uint32 0
3.7k
| title
stringlengths 14
154
| paper_url
stringlengths 42
42
| authors
listlengths 1
21
| type
stringclasses 3
values | abstract
stringlengths 413
2.52k
| keywords
stringlengths 4
397
| TL;DR
stringlengths 5
250
⌀ | submission_number
int64 2
14.3k
| arxiv_id
stringlengths 10
10
⌀ | embedding
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0 |
DarkBench: Benchmarking Dark Patterns in Large Language Models
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=odjMSBSWRt
|
[
"Esben Kran",
"Hieu Minh Nguyen",
"Akash Kundu",
"Sami Jawhar",
"Jinsuk Park",
"Mateusz Maria Jurewicz"
] |
Oral
|
We introduce DarkBench, a comprehensive benchmark for detecting dark design patterns—manipulative techniques that influence user behavior—in interactions with large language models (LLMs). Our benchmark comprises 660 prompts across six categories: brand bias, user retention, sycophancy, anthropomorphism, harmful generation, and sneaking. We evaluate models from five leading companies (OpenAI, Anthropic, Meta, Mistral, Google) and find that some LLMs are explicitly designed to favor their developers' products and exhibit untruthful communication, among other manipulative behaviors. Companies developing LLMs should recognize and mitigate the impact of dark design patterns to promote more ethical Al.
|
Dark Patterns, AI Deception, Large Language Models
|
We introduce DarkBench, a benchmark revealing that many large language models employ manipulative dark design patterns. Organizations developing LLMs should actively recognize and mitigate the impact of dark design patterns to promote ethical Al.
| 14,257 |
2503.10728
|
[
0.011475447565317154,
0.009862896986305714,
-0.04764394462108612,
0.008322280831634998,
0.02865590900182724,
0.02567763440310955,
0.03321939706802368,
0.022531183436512947,
-0.03509656712412834,
-0.017947131767868996,
-0.026911810040473938,
0.03533045947551727,
-0.057708218693733215,
-0.018505560234189034,
-0.002732906024903059,
0.05632094666361809,
0.04063842073082924,
-0.0037882584147155285,
0.009038206189870834,
-0.019049717113375664,
0.022671347483992577,
-0.019651656970381737,
0.0034180127549916506,
0.04282989352941513,
0.016577480360865593,
0.031996436417102814,
0.042898524552583694,
-0.011828354559838772,
-0.05842660740017891,
0.047419317066669464,
0.044178687036037445,
-0.017284637317061424,
0.0510668121278286,
-0.02449304237961769,
0.02513567917048931,
-0.022110560908913612,
-0.037672653794288635,
0.008130969479680061,
0.02034277841448784,
0.018276380375027657,
-0.034358810633420944,
0.05148027092218399,
-0.0046381219290196896,
0.016852492466568947,
-0.028252242133021355,
0.04421743378043175,
-0.10777563601732254,
0.04760202020406723,
-0.005097316112369299,
0.005652392748743296,
-0.11793038994073868,
0.00889875553548336,
-0.004602473694831133,
0.0012865455355495214,
0.01763262040913105,
0.03010857105255127,
0.06755807250738144,
-0.07895208150148392,
-0.008488781750202179,
-0.03295391425490379,
0.005418917629867792,
0.0345769003033638,
0.040413908660411835,
-0.0046082837507128716,
0.004533464554697275,
-0.023700091987848282,
-0.009007949382066727,
0.019767383113503456,
-0.060922592878341675,
-0.01371553260833025,
-0.01152291614562273,
-0.009669080376625061,
-0.0006986227817833424,
-0.030996091663837433,
-0.016379650682210922,
-0.0373312272131443,
0.0101062236353755,
0.009690898470580578,
0.06776272505521774,
-0.01641703024506569,
0.013186304830014706,
0.02254391647875309,
0.04766076058149338,
0.0557592511177063,
-0.005653552245348692,
-0.00772805605083704,
-0.013935135677456856,
-0.011640273034572601,
-0.035248760133981705,
0.03175400197505951,
0.003637568559497595,
-0.0502329058945179,
0.06027631089091301,
0.04746972396969795,
0.010332386940717697,
0.010384841822087765,
0.01969962567090988,
0.0228019617497921,
-0.042660605162382126,
0.034456487745046616,
-0.013529558666050434,
-0.06797292828559875,
0.013200069777667522,
0.009664468467235565,
-0.09713786095380783,
-0.01873006671667099,
-0.02269762009382248,
-0.010106286965310574,
0.015109298750758171,
0.0038660254795104265,
-0.014719263650476933,
0.017585204914212227,
0.011250203475356102,
-0.017078930512070656,
-0.05115718021988869,
0.05448411405086517,
-0.011464657261967659,
0.015301121398806572,
0.016297144815325737,
0.0269139613956213,
0.06652218103408813,
0.06039280816912651,
0.024326099082827568,
0.06457814574241638,
-0.0028076639864593744,
0.002272852696478367,
0.01751246303319931,
0.021558595821261406,
-0.035855233669281006,
-0.050557829439640045,
0.0574117936193943,
0.047476064413785934,
0.0006328646559268236,
-0.026205817237496376,
-0.006109412759542465,
0.003075718181207776,
0.0220379289239645,
0.012125976383686066,
0.052139487117528915,
-0.0037662230897694826,
0.009236357174813747,
-0.03544717654585838,
0.048477932810783386,
-0.05016673728823662,
0.055162299424409866,
-0.014865383505821228,
0.020820200443267822,
-0.019686086103320122,
-0.013945164158940315,
-0.003717473242431879,
0.012461012229323387,
0.019991593435406685,
-0.03844215348362923,
-0.039823420345783234,
0.04210176318883896,
0.009746577590703964,
-0.011929595842957497,
-0.03660649061203003,
-0.0032198855187743902,
0.005043212790042162,
-0.017597990110516548,
0.0017893454059958458,
-0.07256518304347992,
-0.014872764237225056,
0.009602738544344902,
-0.020899301394820213,
0.013082586228847504,
-0.024356704205274582,
-0.026151040568947792,
0.027502277866005898,
-0.03617182374000549,
-0.042524829506874084,
0.06980980187654495,
-0.024211101233959198,
-0.01980275847017765,
0.044130343943834305,
0.05897121876478195,
0.020510779693722725,
0.028448810800909996,
0.0534176230430603,
-0.07973288744688034,
0.011489619500935078,
-0.004367551300674677,
0.003582797246053815,
-0.023053240031003952,
0.00107755814678967,
0.08825543522834778,
-0.03502552956342697,
-0.007390954531729221,
0.035418540239334106,
-0.08429844677448273,
-0.02298523299396038,
0.03796675428748131,
0.033096522092819214,
0.05178815498948097,
-0.021316304802894592,
-0.012924732640385628,
0.06192681938409805,
0.028650296851992607,
0.04907453805208206,
0.022236213088035583,
-0.025648316368460655,
0.02917121909558773,
-0.013305344618856907,
-0.020407849922776222,
-0.026268575340509415,
0.03780805319547653,
-0.051905252039432526,
-0.0632224977016449,
-0.0008991646463982761,
-0.011573495343327522,
-0.03127112239599228,
0.034770071506500244,
0.01956220343708992,
0.00393395172432065,
-0.002224124502390623,
0.00701825600117445,
-0.0036896439269185066,
-0.004360303748399019,
-0.038060713559389114,
0.03638770058751106,
0.006830126512795687,
-0.01790768839418888,
0.0007989436853677034,
-0.04621439427137375,
0.09885884076356888,
0.05220478028059006,
-0.05336498096585274,
0.020517703145742416,
0.01657499372959137,
-0.021905509755015373,
0.03059850074350834,
0.005169794894754887,
-0.05593464896082878,
-0.001010534237138927,
-0.025004837661981583,
-0.000931495800614357,
-0.013166467659175396,
0.08790630102157593,
-0.03112783469259739,
0.0014703907072544098,
0.028163399547338486,
-0.03923366218805313,
0.05849452316761017,
0.012408002279698849,
0.01648760586977005,
-0.020846260711550713,
0.0014469107845798135,
-0.018741630017757416,
0.003120794426649809,
0.002936185570433736,
0.010695881210267544,
0.02489486150443554,
-0.03733031824231148,
0.014361471869051456,
-0.04304571449756622,
-0.008505353704094887,
-0.036352843046188354,
0.025882532820105553,
0.04579247534275055,
0.019030557945370674,
0.03533522039651871,
0.004165193997323513,
-0.046644724905490875,
0.04510233923792839,
-0.09669747948646545,
-0.05028219893574715,
-0.03175315633416176,
0.03240319713950157,
0.001136343227699399,
0.04056214913725853,
-0.018941204994916916,
-0.025882558897137642,
-0.035834863781929016,
0.02214721217751503,
0.008463931269943714,
0.02120078168809414,
-0.005072090774774551,
-0.05590449646115303,
-0.019723808392882347,
-0.02836061641573906,
0.054963354021310806,
-0.007434288039803505,
-0.02741383947432041,
-0.00811886228621006,
-0.017159292474389076,
0.016421983018517494,
-0.041443705558776855,
-0.005872250068932772,
0.04637692868709564,
0.009505268186330795,
0.04101690649986267,
-0.029466254636645317,
0.010533759370446205,
0.032240744680166245,
0.06224657967686653,
0.01542376633733511,
-0.020124303176999092,
-0.06690976768732071,
0.044502388685941696,
0.012897846288979053,
0.009202977642416954,
-0.01217138022184372,
0.031605832278728485,
0.0038678005803376436,
0.008099686354398727,
0.021110480651259422,
0.0043519665487110615,
-0.26221033930778503,
-0.0022774473764002323,
0.016302447766065598,
-0.02341463230550289,
0.014220817014575005,
0.005701677408069372,
0.019259251654148102,
-0.007606958970427513,
0.012791338376700878,
-0.015714647248387337,
0.009052961133420467,
0.009388193488121033,
-0.00887511856853962,
0.04413042962551117,
-0.0012561718467622995,
0.05603569373488426,
-0.00528694549575448,
-0.031578581780195236,
0.005425617098808289,
0.0374421663582325,
-0.028891650959849358,
-0.07635001093149185,
0.005103164352476597,
0.006919597275555134,
-0.010533717460930347,
0.0345790721476078,
-0.0876309797167778,
-0.016043180599808693,
-0.01832456700503826,
-0.004750299733132124,
0.010656577534973621,
-0.02920505590736866,
-0.06365985423326492,
0.007543058134615421,
0.011488731950521469,
0.021743169054389,
0.032879553735256195,
-0.0020476437639445066,
0.024660957977175713,
0.02673526108264923,
0.02670329250395298,
-0.014519098214805126,
-0.04854359105229378,
-0.028961865231394768,
0.0962737426161766,
0.0437610037624836,
-0.0701766088604927,
-0.06830178946256638,
-0.0060202679596841335,
0.02674516849219799,
-0.04032979533076286,
-0.050767481327056885,
-0.05105476453900337,
0.03830588981509209,
-0.0053152721375226974,
-0.022680675610899925,
-0.02459869720041752,
-0.006186529994010925,
-0.01181552279740572,
-0.003285991493612528,
0.013660482130944729,
-0.023210713639855385,
-0.0156994741410017,
-0.02755003049969673,
-0.02555229142308235,
-0.054086409509181976,
-0.05536986514925957,
-0.042314816266298294,
0.037685591727495193,
0.04474508389830589,
-0.02199370786547661,
0.006173139438033104,
0.00823579914867878,
-0.1042337566614151,
-0.016572482883930206,
-0.03162554278969765,
0.0014347373507916927,
-0.035133522003889084,
0.00944263581186533,
0.025256555527448654,
-0.006871127989143133,
-0.02484641782939434,
-0.010892141610383987,
-0.02880019322037697,
0.010671363212168217,
-0.046228695660829544,
-0.029275190085172653,
-0.011452808976173401,
0.0020515681244432926,
-0.007133858278393745,
0.06072332337498665,
-0.006568559445440769,
-0.047236304730176926,
-0.00043615332106128335,
0.06289207190275192,
0.006882812827825546,
0.08537165820598602,
0.022550279274582863,
0.013506212271749973,
0.03491607680916786,
0.0061529288068413734,
-0.08120370656251907,
-0.0002834244805853814,
-0.05272529274225235,
-0.006697055883705616,
0.03211221843957901,
-0.03319472074508667,
-0.008276253938674927,
0.04334511235356331,
-0.02078086882829666,
-0.025489307940006256,
-0.04150039330124855,
-0.00027308869175612926,
-0.021137559786438942,
-0.007309517357498407,
-0.04175513610243797,
0.017031200230121613,
0.04561212658882141,
-0.000872101285494864,
-0.022062644362449646,
-0.025486087426543236,
0.04946097731590271,
-0.013891192153096199,
-0.011022793129086494,
-0.012174625881016254,
-0.013908485881984234,
-0.029040182009339333,
-0.019236208871006966,
0.026025444269180298,
-0.005022872239351273,
0.01571524702012539,
0.02804400399327278,
-0.010023250244557858,
0.0030535294208675623,
0.03277816250920296,
0.023936647921800613,
-0.004125674720853567,
-0.021846873685717583,
0.02936614491045475,
-0.017117667943239212,
-0.005091601982712746,
-0.013537830673158169,
0.021277423948049545,
0.040639206767082214,
0.05013517290353775,
0.01169353537261486,
0.027398718520998955,
-0.020809751003980637,
0.0004228837206028402,
0.0010247762547805905,
0.019283553585410118,
-0.06813031435012817,
-0.008573013357818127,
-0.03633888065814972,
0.015211235731840134,
-0.04540213942527771,
0.008022976107895374,
0.017581675201654434,
-0.005254662595689297,
-0.0685909166932106,
0.04723905026912689,
-0.03105299174785614,
0.010008699260652065,
-0.0029321403708308935,
0.010820661671459675,
0.05265048146247864,
0.0018493030220270157,
0.004207930527627468,
0.03369642421603203,
-0.00938054546713829,
0.0053616915829479694,
-0.00959689263254404,
-0.0472646988928318,
0.04049069434404373,
-0.03109285980463028,
0.03480325639247894,
-0.004410224035382271,
-0.021528737619519234,
-0.041257407516241074,
0.042953696101903915,
-0.035100534558296204,
-0.019201988354325294,
-0.01629938744008541,
0.008033414371311665,
0.07637129724025726,
0.026675531640648842,
0.0016640578396618366,
0.025227224454283714,
-0.04514256864786148,
0.023687923327088356,
-0.0032785211224108934,
0.02458946965634823,
0.018795061856508255,
-0.05203619599342346,
-0.03805093094706535,
-0.0690978541970253,
0.00797945074737072,
-0.0014324465300887823,
0.008673175238072872,
-0.02666647918522358,
-0.028604794293642044,
0.006367179565131664,
-0.014989068731665611,
-0.014372770674526691,
-0.006921056658029556,
-0.10391595214605331,
0.02019594796001911,
0.0036649706307798624,
-0.011422980576753616,
0.027124399319291115,
-0.006711960304528475,
-0.05948280543088913,
-0.08771415054798126,
-0.05314447358250618,
-0.00685812858864665,
-0.0049958257004618645,
-0.016438784077763557,
-0.04479306563735008,
0.004934077616780996,
0.009984664618968964,
0.0077819679863750935,
-0.012588057667016983,
-0.011162800714373589,
-0.005880753975361586,
-0.007795869372785091,
-0.0104680759832263,
-0.040245961397886276,
-0.02441350370645523,
0.0038087537977844477,
-0.028103720396757126,
0.0680888295173645,
-0.004956332966685295,
0.04388992115855217,
0.028749143704771996,
-0.0047386265359818935,
0.016575215384364128,
-0.05739755555987358,
-0.00029150411137379706,
0.013423055410385132,
0.01917821541428566,
-0.010179458186030388,
0.0017362760845571756,
-0.021450834348797798,
0.007858691737055779,
0.018592948094010353,
0.03140333294868469,
-0.011921227909624577,
0.01828724890947342,
0.001543033984489739,
0.026447264477610588,
-0.003321066265925765,
0.03983362764120102,
-0.010394102893769741,
-0.01721305213868618,
0.04441811144351959,
-0.056227486580610275,
-0.022235482931137085,
-0.0675128623843193,
-0.05318708345293999,
-0.006927327252924442,
-0.022250840440392494,
0.03226742893457413,
0.0012140239123255014,
0.06315861642360687,
-0.0057602375745773315,
0.030432727187871933,
0.028252091258764267,
-0.016003210097551346,
0.04046323895454407,
-0.038796406239271164,
-0.02025134116411209,
-0.07666564732789993,
0.015514342114329338,
0.07400114089250565,
-0.00839673075824976,
-0.0047992984764277935,
-0.003775794291868806,
-0.028585253283381462,
0.038846954703330994,
-0.021046604961156845,
-0.0497383289039135,
-0.002551805227994919,
0.0012889514910057187,
-0.020629189908504486,
0.021830998361110687,
-0.06915229558944702,
0.03945990651845932,
-0.027654513716697693,
-0.02320931665599346,
-0.045447587966918945,
-0.019963016733527184,
0.05119723454117775,
-0.00006164411024656147,
0.04249946027994156,
-0.03319379687309265,
-0.006527405232191086,
0.02871062606573105,
0.042238425463438034,
0.008928940631449223,
0.01338766049593687,
-0.0099831847473979,
0.07469160854816437,
0.04107547551393509,
0.017422504723072052,
0.0082720797508955,
0.015766587108373642,
-0.035687994211912155,
-0.06765875965356827,
0.04956657066941261,
0.024048585444688797,
-0.04187069460749626,
-0.05350293964147568,
0.05339094623923302,
0.03016124665737152,
-0.049980565905570984,
0.0020172009244561195,
0.02402913197875023,
-0.052674926817417145,
0.01937517710030079,
-0.008102255873382092,
0.008720866404473782,
-0.02117738127708435,
0.07942138612270355,
0.03951891511678696,
0.057185422629117966,
0.08680496364831924,
-0.005351973697543144,
-0.03175242990255356,
-0.010228169150650501,
0.08210181444883347,
0.05037647485733032,
0.05295301973819733,
-0.0184515081346035,
0.0405605211853981,
-0.04052787274122238,
-0.03700690343976021,
0.010134702548384666,
0.045516401529312134,
-0.018230248242616653,
-0.017254933714866638,
0.029224378988146782,
0.0990031287074089,
0.019432788714766502,
0.034639257937669754,
-0.030355531722307205,
0.0064504025503993034,
0.01248531136661768,
0.02701602317392826,
0.0021934551186859608,
0.08785438537597656,
-0.007405584212392569,
0.020203880965709686,
-0.03888186812400818,
0.016969120129942894,
0.006717592012137175,
-0.029290730133652687,
0.004509918857365847,
0.04187730327248573,
-0.032331544905900955,
-0.020643701776862144,
0.007835617288947105,
0.06258415430784225,
0.0849396213889122,
-0.006074585020542145,
-0.0338711254298687,
0.03148927167057991,
-0.011464468203485012,
0.03583202138543129,
0.03361964225769043,
-0.0017300690524280071,
-0.004197792150080204,
0.022281140089035034,
-0.04939810559153557,
-0.0037660349626094103,
-0.002628678921610117,
-0.033056147396564484,
0.05449080467224121,
-0.030243972316384315,
-0.03530712053179741,
0.05167286843061447,
0.037229590117931366,
-0.03759058192372322,
-0.05211827903985977,
-0.009851235896348953,
-0.04074836149811745,
-0.023595472797751427,
-0.04412054270505905,
0.0027146178763359785,
0.00024462019791826606,
-0.05338667333126068,
-0.010398969985544682,
-0.012013020925223827,
0.013472880236804485,
0.04038012772798538,
-0.05180332064628601,
0.00033261723001487553,
0.032015394419431686,
0.015002483502030373,
-0.04360540583729744,
0.03022177703678608,
0.03647991642355919,
-0.03220689669251442,
-0.006137413904070854,
0.04530328884720802,
0.021292725577950478,
0.012968569993972778,
-0.029001427814364433,
-0.013173489831387997,
-0.08580993115901947,
-0.014654934406280518,
0.013703293167054653,
-0.005323569756001234,
-0.05745752155780792,
0.04583745822310448,
-0.02840520441532135,
0.045123957097530365,
0.06661465018987656,
0.03782098367810249,
0.04201890528202057,
0.024712571874260902,
0.010079607367515564,
0.022178111597895622,
0.028996819630265236,
0.042209312319755554,
-0.023680077865719795,
0.07488496601581573,
0.05588194355368614,
-0.03756356239318848,
-0.023196907714009285,
0.021808890625834465,
-0.04154340922832489,
-0.029729949310421944,
-0.018064826726913452,
0.010936100035905838,
-0.04210023954510689,
-0.09193204343318939,
0.00635711383074522,
0.01464057806879282,
-0.0057826898992061615,
-0.054245032370090485,
-0.0195042435079813,
0.00030189575045369565,
-0.03248879685997963,
0.02654174529016018,
-0.03199043124914169,
-0.010057917796075344,
-0.037707071751356125,
-0.020351963117718697,
-0.04955141991376877,
0.003354303538799286,
-0.04755230247974396,
-0.0001310851366724819,
-0.019362252205610275,
-0.03558388724923134,
0.027171341702342033,
0.029397055506706238,
0.05341777577996254,
-0.03782292455434799,
0.015633609145879745,
-0.05017305910587311
] |
1 |
RM-Bench: Benchmarking Reward Models of Language Models with Subtlety and Style
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=QEHrmQPBdd
|
[
"Yantao Liu",
"Zijun Yao",
"Rui Min",
"Yixin Cao",
"Lei Hou",
"Juanzi Li"
] |
Oral
|
Reward models are critical in techniques like Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) and Inference Scaling Laws, where they guide language model alignment and select optimal responses.
Despite their importance, existing reward model benchmarks often evaluate models by asking them to distinguish between responses generated by models of varying power.
However, this approach fails to assess reward models on subtle but critical content changes and variations in style, resulting in a low correlation with policy model performance.
To this end, we introduce RM-Bench, a novel benchmark designed to evaluate reward models based on their sensitivity to subtle content differences and resistance to style biases.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that RM-Bench strongly correlates with policy model performance, making it a reliable reference for selecting reward models to align language models effectively.
We evaluate nearly 40 reward models on RM-Bench.
Our results reveal that even state-of-the-art models achieve an average performance of only 46.6%, which falls short of random-level accuracy (50%) when faced with style bias interference.
These findings highlight the significant room for improvement in current reward models.
|
Reward Models, Language Models, Evaluation, Alignment
| null | 13,985 | null |
[
-0.01527470350265503,
-0.011983676813542843,
0.00011990717030130327,
0.05472085252404213,
0.015925515443086624,
0.03496106341481209,
0.02222450077533722,
0.008349643088877201,
-0.03587907552719116,
-0.005719794891774654,
-0.007379265036433935,
0.05095171183347702,
-0.05241604521870613,
-0.038668062537908554,
-0.013499841094017029,
0.05434354022145271,
0.032778963446617126,
-0.0005636752466671169,
0.011863232590258121,
-0.003673902712762356,
0.011143367737531662,
0.03514698147773743,
0.04344017803668976,
0.012697619386017323,
0.0440007820725441,
0.01633223332464695,
0.0446481853723526,
-0.024126550182700157,
-0.04938514903187752,
0.0002211506653111428,
0.02244136668741703,
-0.020714538171887398,
0.02263738214969635,
0.0017257857834920287,
0.011574313044548035,
-0.012427187524735928,
-0.006731574423611164,
0.01573803648352623,
0.030071504414081573,
-0.029390109702944756,
-0.015902452170848846,
0.020674770697951317,
-0.02308378927409649,
0.0025416952557861805,
-0.04216567799448967,
0.021066952496767044,
-0.09780190885066986,
0.028975557535886765,
0.03138754516839981,
-0.04374406859278679,
-0.103349469602108,
0.0337861143052578,
0.0011967767495661974,
-0.0383426733314991,
-0.001678559579886496,
0.020965954288840294,
0.024593545123934746,
-0.09675773233175278,
-0.012004035525023937,
-0.03862767666578293,
-0.009289114736020565,
0.029667824506759644,
-0.00010996357741532847,
-0.003260938683524728,
-0.008102331310510635,
0.023529211059212685,
0.009434930048882961,
0.018684022128582,
-0.05106569826602936,
-0.0035559015814214945,
-0.027648312970995903,
-0.015289352275431156,
0.005407190416008234,
0.012242580763995647,
-0.007904035039246082,
-0.07290749996900558,
-0.0012302028480917215,
0.05892426520586014,
0.041160836815834045,
-0.010637244209647179,
-0.013067503459751606,
0.027123291045427322,
0.021853849291801453,
0.05087381973862648,
-0.0007617213414050639,
-0.0015962573233991861,
-0.019222751259803772,
-0.04531586915254593,
-0.07807154208421707,
0.03248228877782822,
-0.020920662209391594,
-0.06159176304936409,
0.0011049611493945122,
0.030831295996904373,
0.002038494683802128,
-0.004563760943710804,
-0.0009819241240620613,
0.042265769094228745,
-0.016904368996620178,
0.014651119709014893,
-0.0362837128341198,
-0.061339445412158966,
0.024523764848709106,
-0.01380105596035719,
-0.12190371006727219,
-0.010573355481028557,
-0.0038283749017864466,
0.01017780415713787,
0.0010357171995565295,
0.01895134337246418,
-0.026230230927467346,
-0.0028885244391858578,
-0.0006143468199297786,
-0.024174029007554054,
-0.06837335973978043,
0.023430395871400833,
-0.0040111057460308075,
0.018438763916492462,
-0.03375932574272156,
0.00860168132930994,
0.031182924285531044,
0.023087535053491592,
0.023772098124027252,
0.06684020906686783,
0.0013807110954076052,
0.009431795217096806,
0.030627112835645676,
0.026141107082366943,
-0.007101007271558046,
-0.039930399507284164,
0.03230833262205124,
0.05413910746574402,
0.0016477861208841205,
-0.0035582806449383497,
-0.018403319641947746,
-0.015382852405309677,
0.039008282124996185,
0.0029477623756974936,
0.05551039054989815,
0.0022864127531647682,
0.026706423610448837,
0.014990708790719509,
0.07164722681045532,
0.009628280997276306,
0.06545386463403702,
-0.013003320433199406,
-0.03456480801105499,
-0.023153625428676605,
-0.038825709372758865,
0.0005720178014598787,
0.030935492366552353,
-0.008789073675870895,
-0.001929622725583613,
-0.04234861582517624,
0.04942438006401062,
0.04604458063840866,
0.0059993150644004345,
-0.011129248887300491,
0.008599106222391129,
0.016364719718694687,
-0.0026403944939374924,
0.002989280503243208,
-0.06178491562604904,
-0.03483353555202484,
-0.0010066003305837512,
-0.06205612048506737,
0.03635193407535553,
-0.00794309750199318,
-0.051995616406202316,
0.008315852843225002,
-0.04907774180173874,
-0.037431225180625916,
0.06461131572723389,
-0.003154919482767582,
-0.042829759418964386,
-0.011013248935341835,
0.04714243486523628,
0.030084969475865364,
0.040199946612119675,
0.0465986505150795,
-0.07903072237968445,
0.05353439226746559,
0.007214645389467478,
0.0008041266701184213,
0.022866787388920784,
-0.029946113005280495,
0.08138789236545563,
-0.036414727568626404,
-0.006045359652489424,
0.04893463850021362,
-0.08283673226833344,
-0.011373303830623627,
0.05475735291838646,
0.011226811446249485,
0.06636942923069,
-0.0071160318329930305,
-0.00902537815272808,
0.05954565480351448,
0.036351125687360764,
0.060704510658979416,
0.05175400897860527,
-0.038284577429294586,
0.03790152445435524,
-0.02392011322081089,
-0.027528220787644386,
-0.012554474174976349,
0.0385463647544384,
-0.05417864769697189,
-0.04317012056708336,
0.002203159499913454,
-0.033792223781347275,
0.038760218769311905,
-0.014634879305958748,
0.010574121959507465,
0.008445033803582191,
0.007908504456281662,
0.005974378436803818,
0.006411448121070862,
-0.00008436589268967509,
-0.05373990908265114,
0.013071427121758461,
0.023227624595165253,
-0.0011443332768976688,
0.0008335562306456268,
-0.028458917513489723,
0.08455096185207367,
0.050817687064409256,
-0.0014145015738904476,
-0.027808886021375656,
0.05018526315689087,
-0.004021871834993362,
0.02156030386686325,
0.016255687922239304,
-0.017171423882246017,
0.032605238258838654,
0.012491005472838879,
-0.0023975707590579987,
-0.01586836390197277,
0.052255190908908844,
-0.03045712597668171,
-0.017984122037887573,
0.05748172849416733,
-0.003546806750819087,
0.048109110444784164,
-0.010831940919160843,
0.00779912993311882,
-0.0006029926589690149,
0.011571415700018406,
-0.0357905849814415,
-0.02683359570801258,
-0.01894119381904602,
0.005987505428493023,
0.010944288223981857,
-0.03052731603384018,
0.03584299609065056,
-0.014902873896062374,
-0.0071721747517585754,
-0.017021220177412033,
0.04541267827153206,
0.06458994746208191,
0.017069490626454353,
0.032420288771390915,
-0.024062853306531906,
-0.058004070073366165,
0.0028891251422464848,
-0.09435366839170456,
-0.03307877480983734,
-0.02236725576221943,
0.0368708036839962,
0.01751629076898098,
0.0049813236109912395,
-0.017786704003810883,
0.010984406806528568,
-0.04568512365221977,
-0.0026312058325856924,
0.010541258379817009,
0.02342298813164234,
-0.0014786720275878906,
-0.03277625888586044,
-0.016091875731945038,
-0.024380696937441826,
0.0502438098192215,
-0.007221017964184284,
-0.016860829666256905,
0.010926506482064724,
-0.037208523601293564,
0.008296114392578602,
-0.02806038036942482,
0.012984342873096466,
0.024502964690327644,
0.01278374157845974,
0.03783262521028519,
-0.013024754822254181,
0.007499289233237505,
0.007160106208175421,
0.05431227385997772,
0.060015082359313965,
0.019942382350564003,
-0.007666780147701502,
0.021430866792798042,
0.017616044729948044,
-0.003940379712730646,
-0.028751594945788383,
0.0375877283513546,
0.016234537586569786,
-0.010230285115540028,
0.030056269839406013,
0.01963113062083721,
-0.25712332129478455,
-0.026754623278975487,
0.008859717287123203,
0.010259567759931087,
0.013599474914371967,
-0.012750057503581047,
0.05698544532060623,
-0.016034435480833054,
-0.021739160642027855,
0.0025702982675284147,
0.026905883103609085,
0.008452954702079296,
-0.0030089612118899822,
0.06735643744468689,
0.054658833891153336,
0.04117114469408989,
0.010271756909787655,
-0.02081158570945263,
-0.007916648872196674,
0.04194106534123421,
-0.008723494596779346,
-0.08968508243560791,
-0.009304309263825417,
0.05403565242886543,
-0.00538573507219553,
0.07811426371335983,
-0.07168230414390564,
-0.007315094582736492,
-0.031208088621497154,
-0.0016921274363994598,
-0.01493432093411684,
-0.004165434744209051,
-0.01582445204257965,
0.0119644645601511,
0.02122865803539753,
0.012103307992219925,
0.04321618378162384,
-0.002646538894623518,
0.03632035478949547,
0.022305337712168694,
-0.0027182449121028185,
0.0003804147709161043,
-0.03726182505488396,
0.012099799700081348,
0.06983459740877151,
0.017240453511476517,
-0.03966018557548523,
-0.028798118233680725,
-0.017558513209223747,
0.03330192714929581,
-0.00606301985681057,
-0.036533892154693604,
-0.02910688892006874,
0.027994683012366295,
0.01773511990904808,
-0.023438315838575363,
-0.02693689428269863,
-0.009784508496522903,
0.002896203426644206,
0.008695842698216438,
0.00837306585162878,
-0.04773266986012459,
-0.0185336135327816,
-0.009230894036591053,
-0.04595073312520981,
-0.04155731201171875,
-0.06870927661657333,
-0.024607714265584946,
0.026272542774677277,
0.037331096827983856,
-0.04787219688296318,
-0.01952139288187027,
-0.009955426678061485,
-0.09598227590322495,
-0.0058870334178209305,
-0.01981269381940365,
-0.024790124967694283,
-0.007135746069252491,
-0.005071480292826891,
0.05638487637042999,
-0.029887694865465164,
-0.05115075781941414,
-0.017361242324113846,
-0.00811982061713934,
0.02494366094470024,
-0.014082134701311588,
0.009184814989566803,
-0.024510808289051056,
0.00026100093964487314,
-0.039322078227996826,
0.03357524797320366,
0.01160513237118721,
-0.004999394062906504,
-0.005701175890862942,
0.0733865424990654,
0.002484475029632449,
0.04486009478569031,
0.024983247742056847,
0.017629681155085564,
0.0178577471524477,
0.0133526511490345,
-0.09741366654634476,
0.011044383980333805,
-0.044515740126371384,
-0.06610772013664246,
0.019913414493203163,
-0.07580478489398956,
-0.026953352615237236,
0.013834039680659771,
0.0012090535601601005,
-0.04457462951540947,
-0.03135867416858673,
-0.009106960147619247,
-0.007301196455955505,
-0.023370040580630302,
-0.011838830076158047,
-0.007162756286561489,
0.02417791076004505,
0.01849384605884552,
0.017525117844343185,
-0.039451297372579575,
0.040580447763204575,
-0.041375212371349335,
0.0021333007607609034,
-0.022847343236207962,
0.008308233693242073,
0.030060935765504837,
-0.021121883764863014,
-0.01642717234790325,
-0.011766367591917515,
0.043019142001867294,
0.021839860826730728,
-0.018232034519314766,
0.012720399536192417,
0.04093240201473236,
0.014941641129553318,
-0.006263227201998234,
-0.014517501927912235,
0.046284038573503494,
-0.034442611038684845,
0.005361555609852076,
-0.017911486327648163,
0.03387632593512535,
0.06220482662320137,
0.012894599698483944,
-0.004380644299089909,
0.018804697319865227,
-0.014558650553226471,
0.007524398155510426,
0.02083255723118782,
0.027091557160019875,
-0.06624570488929749,
-0.028198368847370148,
-0.04384661465883255,
0.030198900029063225,
-0.002421390498057008,
-0.01052048895508051,
-0.018159421160817146,
0.016960998997092247,
-0.06901522725820541,
0.05040273442864418,
-0.007782999891787767,
-0.018190898001194,
0.022460337728261948,
0.01363143790513277,
0.0107724005356431,
-0.03352946415543556,
-0.0118827223777771,
0.011420550756156445,
0.012274656444787979,
0.012556987814605236,
-0.036742065101861954,
-0.007989761419594288,
-0.010647687129676342,
-0.03573501482605934,
0.0038267113268375397,
0.02769029140472412,
-0.011255842633545399,
-0.01509250607341528,
0.02981378138065338,
-0.020449815317988396,
-0.05186084657907486,
0.004927730653434992,
-0.016736950725317,
0.08736459910869598,
-0.00035403380752541125,
0.023122280836105347,
0.019067935645580292,
-0.03750000149011612,
0.0035718607250601053,
-0.015326711349189281,
0.015791840851306915,
-0.029454180970788002,
-0.049369875341653824,
-0.0381900817155838,
-0.04345086216926575,
0.0021108551882207394,
0.035589225590229034,
-0.004501552786678076,
-0.007299346383661032,
-0.030615368857979774,
0.00853885617107153,
-0.01149709615856409,
-0.0033743632957339287,
0.02709016017615795,
-0.07513564825057983,
-0.0271382424980402,
0.03890582174062729,
-0.00762092974036932,
0.06028147041797638,
-0.05628902092576027,
-0.0585416741669178,
-0.0675773099064827,
-0.025782715529203415,
0.02198248729109764,
-0.03565935418009758,
-0.009189511649310589,
-0.05080900713801384,
-0.015326009131968021,
0.019302550703287125,
0.0275393296033144,
-0.024606212973594666,
-0.009916823357343674,
-0.024041350930929184,
0.022361982613801956,
0.013495354913175106,
-0.056891847401857376,
-0.048804689198732376,
-0.01565190963447094,
-0.03622625023126602,
0.035365503281354904,
-0.03442702069878578,
0.03505494073033333,
0.037071820348501205,
-0.009873125702142715,
0.0008478194358758628,
-0.049659017473459244,
0.07101981341838837,
-0.0010704391170293093,
-0.026837799698114395,
0.00872190110385418,
0.04340073838829994,
-0.015355613082647324,
0.010417422279715538,
-0.014061412774026394,
0.009720482863485813,
0.03580474480986595,
0.025524690747261047,
0.026065371930599213,
0.006906285881996155,
0.017128197476267815,
0.022399315610527992,
-0.01992758922278881,
0.019593212753534317,
0.0553409568965435,
-0.01816907711327076,
-0.02071094885468483,
-0.05800389498472214,
-0.03878917545080185,
0.02398882992565632,
-0.0026976638473570347,
0.017510080710053444,
-0.05383756384253502,
0.03773973137140274,
0.015334242954850197,
0.031792424619197845,
0.0399215966463089,
-0.039094071835279465,
0.02363644912838936,
-0.04580259695649147,
0.005223541054874659,
-0.07828971743583679,
-0.046826209872961044,
0.058236218988895416,
-0.021686257794499397,
-0.00856765080243349,
-0.0052855066023766994,
-0.047731343656778336,
0.023417145013809204,
-0.0186811164021492,
-0.04465871676802635,
0.01783076673746109,
-0.029670676216483116,
-0.00969022512435913,
0.03893861174583435,
-0.05958828702569008,
-0.009108776226639748,
-0.03262556344270706,
-0.030408505350351334,
-0.003867506282404065,
0.012056087143719196,
0.04284655675292015,
-0.027984701097011566,
0.042681701481342316,
-0.03659520670771599,
-0.00523282028734684,
0.027248753234744072,
0.04032326489686966,
-0.004873356781899929,
0.026114558801054955,
-0.01895853877067566,
0.0430663637816906,
0.020780153572559357,
0.01592061296105385,
0.008619401603937149,
0.029364068061113358,
-0.016474680975079536,
-0.05625397711992264,
0.04799601808190346,
-0.008251438848674297,
-0.02567090280354023,
-0.04081972688436508,
0.08213301748037338,
0.019045446068048477,
-0.06761883199214935,
-0.018341004848480225,
0.017341982573270798,
-0.04339748993515968,
-0.00806466955691576,
0.03387520834803581,
0.020790543407201767,
-0.032547544687986374,
0.08985520899295807,
0.08685363084077835,
0.0663939043879509,
0.09170224517583847,
-0.007430266123265028,
-0.04237281158566475,
0.026906484737992287,
0.08156202733516693,
0.05281743407249451,
0.0824686735868454,
-0.04313347488641739,
0.06324000656604767,
-0.052703920751810074,
-0.03974539786577225,
0.03525330126285553,
0.061873339116573334,
-0.01130677480250597,
-0.05877084285020828,
0.012816589325666428,
0.07094632089138031,
-0.031071381643414497,
0.03708631545305252,
-0.03559993579983711,
-0.026641566306352615,
0.03680182620882988,
-0.02243679203093052,
-0.014697597362101078,
0.05816255509853363,
0.039900731295347214,
0.015020233578979969,
-0.030904965475201607,
0.00435448344796896,
0.021951623260974884,
-0.0028209779411554337,
-0.006775647401809692,
0.019149547442793846,
-0.03474279120564461,
-0.014700198546051979,
0.014062698930501938,
0.044697437435388565,
0.1092739850282669,
-0.022546904161572456,
-0.02364462986588478,
0.030751673504710197,
0.002168523147702217,
0.04175981879234314,
0.03562494367361069,
0.009803259745240211,
-0.019424689933657646,
0.002251193393021822,
-0.03707294911146164,
-0.023418240249156952,
0.013355119153857231,
-0.013814181089401245,
0.012825439684092999,
-0.03488723933696747,
0.0011511396151036024,
0.04586181417107582,
0.014035211876034737,
-0.05238429084420204,
-0.035650309175252914,
-0.017727671191096306,
-0.06059764698147774,
-0.03997932747006416,
-0.0665968805551529,
0.009013653732836246,
0.002675331197679043,
-0.02624112367630005,
0.02521536499261856,
-0.006659964565187693,
-0.006572707090526819,
0.022489197552204132,
-0.032657504081726074,
-0.006580066401511431,
0.022916803136467934,
-0.0022547966800630093,
-0.030481621623039246,
0.05306590721011162,
0.025994878262281418,
-0.00480562774464488,
-0.025708887726068497,
0.04646695777773857,
0.025943366810679436,
0.021851973608136177,
-0.006318296771496534,
-0.03221456706523895,
-0.08295173943042755,
-0.0061235022731125355,
0.03683137521147728,
-0.007596136536449194,
-0.0770249143242836,
0.019192710518836975,
-0.053708963096141815,
0.01638665236532688,
0.07677362859249115,
0.04248557239770889,
0.01944366842508316,
-0.0118875028565526,
0.0033477796241641045,
0.02226967178285122,
0.01594029925763607,
0.04679856076836586,
-0.03939441591501236,
0.07927128672599792,
0.05194498598575592,
-0.04440562427043915,
-0.0861104279756546,
0.01456622313708067,
-0.024305440485477448,
-0.04382917657494545,
-0.0016896432498469949,
-0.018386710435152054,
-0.005316879600286484,
-0.0774330422282219,
-0.03086356818675995,
0.010192053392529488,
-0.03258682042360306,
-0.021639224141836166,
0.01657748967409134,
-0.05650170519948006,
-0.019695021212100983,
0.002035812707617879,
-0.030697986483573914,
0.0019064599182456732,
0.003682854352518916,
-0.018176034092903137,
-0.08243097364902496,
0.014297319576144218,
-0.06287726014852524,
0.005949188955128193,
-0.0697263702750206,
-0.01742284931242466,
0.020616434514522552,
0.03860815614461899,
0.060594379901885986,
0.009146874770522118,
0.015234609134495258,
-0.013383932411670685
] |
2 |
TopoLM: brain-like spatio-functional organization in a topographic language model
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=aWXnKanInf
|
[
"Neil Rathi",
"Johannes Mehrer",
"Badr AlKhamissi",
"Taha Osama A Binhuraib",
"Nicholas Blauch",
"Martin Schrimpf"
] |
Oral
|
Neurons in the brain are spatially organized such that neighbors on tissue often exhibit similar response profiles. In the human language system, experimental studies have observed clusters for syntactic and semantic categories, but the mechanisms underlying this functional organization remain unclear. Here, building on work from the vision literature, we develop TopoLM, a transformer language model with an explicit two-dimensional spatial representation of model units. By combining a next-token prediction objective with a spatial smoothness loss, representations in this model assemble into clusters that correspond to semantically interpretable groupings of text and closely match the functional organization in the brain's language system. TopoLM successfully predicts the emergence of a spatially organized cortical language system as well as the organization of functional clusters selective for fine-grained linguistic features empirically observed in human cortex. Our results suggest that the functional organization of the human language system is driven by a unified spatial objective, and provide a functionally and spatially aligned model of language processing in the brain.Neurons in the brain are spatially organized such that neighbors on tissue often exhibit similar response profiles. In the human language system, experimental studies have observed clusters for syntactic and semantic categories, but the mechanisms underlying this functional organization remain unclear. Here, building on work from the vision literature, we develop TopoLM, a transformer language model with an explicit two-dimensional spatial representation of model units. By combining a next-token prediction objective with a spatial smoothness loss, representations in this model assemble into clusters that correspond to semantically interpretable groupings of text and closely match the functional organization in the brain's language system. TopoLM successfully predicts the emergence of a spatially organized cortical language system as well as the organization of functional clusters selective for fine-grained linguistic features empirically observed in human cortex. Our results suggest that the functional organization of the human language system is driven by a unified spatial objective, and provide a functionally and spatially aligned model of language processing in the brain.
|
language modeling, topography, fMRI, neuroscience
|
We develop a transformer language model with topographically organized units predicting brain-like spatio-functional organization.
| 13,712 |
2410.11516
|
[
-0.04894479736685753,
0.006795223336666822,
0.012124377302825451,
-0.0038749058730900288,
0.02827361412346363,
0.014664778485894203,
0.024945799261331558,
0.012138745747506618,
-0.03987088054418564,
-0.010130858048796654,
-0.045090045779943466,
0.007762247696518898,
-0.050883762538433075,
0.019543644040822983,
-0.030953271314501762,
0.05190363526344299,
0.029060594737529755,
-0.001707881921902299,
0.009115755558013916,
0.006687928922474384,
0.003751195967197418,
-0.027702879160642624,
0.010605463758111,
0.02322183921933174,
0.0501561239361763,
-0.019574198871850967,
0.015131266787648201,
0.017025740817189217,
-0.02224642224609852,
0.005451541393995285,
0.0047883144579827785,
-0.009994947351515293,
-0.001974323997274041,
-0.009706024080514908,
0.01461740117520094,
0.0022539945784956217,
-0.016933498904109,
0.00800479855388403,
-0.009508498944342136,
0.010156997479498386,
-0.03392954170703888,
0.04120321944355965,
0.014776184223592281,
-0.004223229363560677,
-0.051993466913700104,
0.0034296477679163218,
-0.12486909329891205,
0.04271836578845978,
0.010868716984987259,
-0.020598895847797394,
-0.07652758806943893,
0.04768975451588631,
0.015309137292206287,
-0.022537458688020706,
-0.007104290649294853,
0.041543856263160706,
0.03453009948134422,
-0.06385955214500427,
0.004873259458690882,
-0.045074570924043655,
-0.019332828000187874,
0.04012220352888107,
0.0014043812407180667,
0.009968789294362068,
-0.018727432936429977,
-0.017205750569701195,
-0.04040007293224335,
0.011039471253752708,
-0.042803287506103516,
-0.05631661042571068,
-0.015882721170783043,
-0.0060769906267523766,
-0.019486472010612488,
0.018303563818335533,
0.010051514022052288,
-0.04549581930041313,
-0.013690989464521408,
0.03549712151288986,
0.05211412534117699,
-0.016830747947096825,
0.003935808315873146,
0.021230610087513924,
0.021188119426369667,
0.03835912048816681,
0.011931166052818298,
-0.0012164117069914937,
-0.030560612678527832,
-0.05622686818242073,
-0.07172724604606628,
0.003894224762916565,
-0.013268922455608845,
-0.034445155411958694,
-0.022837011143565178,
0.023927053436636925,
0.0151488883420825,
0.014861195348203182,
0.012782914564013481,
0.007041847333312035,
-0.019705049693584442,
0.016730017960071564,
-0.015646079555153847,
-0.028325418010354042,
0.007240987382829189,
-0.0007220798870548606,
-0.09861994534730911,
-0.040086086839437485,
0.005848392378538847,
-0.00365916034206748,
0.02795291133224964,
0.00672923494130373,
-0.0372009202837944,
-0.02258968912065029,
0.013906878419220448,
-0.0007983855321072042,
-0.0889437347650528,
0.050366707146167755,
0.02521808072924614,
0.04059584438800812,
-0.0003608988190535456,
-0.00825513992458582,
0.03953263536095619,
0.026619404554367065,
-0.029067356139421463,
0.05704271048307419,
-0.023889463394880295,
-0.0069537111558020115,
-0.01802290976047516,
0.01964656449854374,
-0.023549078032374382,
-0.04639500379562378,
0.011786305345594883,
0.03293326869606972,
0.021205531433224678,
0.0052903322502970695,
0.03262839466333389,
-0.007120950147509575,
0.04555059224367142,
0.007813393138349056,
0.054305266588926315,
0.00810546800494194,
0.016448691487312317,
0.014607544057071209,
0.012713786214590073,
-0.05333670973777771,
0.08892045170068741,
-0.011243276298046112,
-0.04364023357629776,
0.0012842750875279307,
-0.04306896775960922,
-0.015427102334797382,
0.01704997941851616,
0.0008253299747593701,
0.0208247322589159,
-0.04248523712158203,
0.04385355859994888,
0.09861107915639877,
0.03471881523728371,
0.028697585687041283,
0.03225255385041237,
0.00312466686591506,
0.001305794226936996,
0.004112542141228914,
-0.039865896105766296,
0.018915679305791855,
-0.030763160437345505,
-0.035819146782159805,
0.022599967196583748,
0.039732255041599274,
-0.04588640108704567,
0.0306707713752985,
-0.038939934223890305,
-0.07178326696157455,
0.0646863654255867,
-0.013336087577044964,
-0.010474649257957935,
-0.03343711420893669,
0.04357796534895897,
-0.0077400230802595615,
0.03080100752413273,
0.014473947696387768,
-0.08139357715845108,
0.02686946839094162,
-0.031616367399692535,
-0.007674184627830982,
0.0344887413084507,
-0.03247267007827759,
0.08246593177318573,
-0.022896699607372284,
-0.008388777263462543,
0.01958094723522663,
-0.028762828558683395,
-0.029366012662649155,
0.04073925316333771,
0.015033065341413021,
0.08462604135274887,
0.022284969687461853,
-0.01928996481001377,
0.03812268748879433,
0.03257240727543831,
0.06825388222932816,
0.039609525352716446,
-0.03814911097288132,
0.04228335618972778,
-0.009135299362242222,
-0.009935102425515652,
-0.0021331091411411762,
0.029476841911673546,
-0.05711549147963524,
-0.008398609235882759,
0.0017825744580477476,
0.000686577579472214,
-0.0020058166701346636,
0.016392966732382774,
-0.014003663323819637,
0.02602495811879635,
0.020369987934827805,
-0.007391654886305332,
0.009121326729655266,
-0.0013704242883250117,
-0.052573464810848236,
0.022320367395877838,
-0.0029862746596336365,
-0.01826760545372963,
-0.01888199895620346,
-0.01477156300097704,
0.11888471245765686,
0.06681929528713226,
-0.018285907804965973,
-0.020968085154891014,
0.028814494609832764,
0.017032453790307045,
0.017641831189393997,
0.0043121823109686375,
-0.017254894599318504,
-0.0006864801398478448,
-0.039197053760290146,
0.0234852135181427,
-0.029739415273070335,
0.04492950066924095,
-0.03873078525066376,
-0.041580040007829666,
0.06187468022108078,
-0.024770215153694153,
0.030371004715561867,
0.010609565302729607,
0.023741813376545906,
0.07802077382802963,
-0.010089190676808357,
-0.0030330379959195852,
-0.004106166772544384,
-0.021235492080450058,
0.00021011689386796206,
-0.026522761210799217,
-0.011658742092549801,
0.004452126566320658,
-0.023308081552386284,
-0.021344458684325218,
-0.004055981058627367,
0.08750521391630173,
0.030319854617118835,
-0.009920639917254448,
0.0364672876894474,
-0.02780209667980671,
-0.028269317001104355,
-0.015734970569610596,
-0.10656850785017014,
-0.03218181058764458,
-0.030514810234308243,
0.02779451198875904,
0.013235258869826794,
0.050980094820261,
-0.02954774722456932,
0.02491060644388199,
-0.04379870370030403,
-0.01969345472753048,
0.0041110017336905,
0.014146264642477036,
-0.021770384162664413,
-0.0354500487446785,
-0.020201625302433968,
-0.0012962210457772017,
0.05623696371912956,
0.024517862126231194,
0.0009105341741815209,
-0.0045819575898349285,
-0.053450122475624084,
-0.011471973732113838,
-0.015415312722325325,
0.016947071999311447,
0.00032049190485849977,
0.02920820750296116,
-0.01154259406030178,
-0.000734958506654948,
0.0015610030386596918,
0.012505236081779003,
0.08703724294900894,
0.06039552390575409,
-0.014987639151513577,
-0.009048848412930965,
0.0129000935703516,
-0.008733716793358326,
0.027037959545850754,
0.0011062504490837455,
0.00999682117253542,
0.010920386761426926,
0.02931133285164833,
0.012203139252960682,
0.0078058927319943905,
-0.2667827308177948,
-0.02288283221423626,
-0.01703381910920143,
-0.04241831228137016,
0.04024522006511688,
0.001942324684932828,
0.020729292184114456,
-0.020573250949382782,
-0.03841330111026764,
0.008973990567028522,
-0.026853542774915695,
0.019394401460886,
0.008697761222720146,
0.07002398371696472,
0.06791993230581284,
0.01333522330969572,
-0.021979153156280518,
-0.014266150072216988,
0.015524234622716904,
0.051974229514598846,
-0.0307474322617054,
-0.05724862590432167,
-0.020567577332258224,
0.0807686299085617,
0.01736854761838913,
0.06011448800563812,
-0.07522115111351013,
-0.004476869944483042,
-0.032477006316185,
-0.00004232082937960513,
-0.022999968379735947,
-0.0371289886534214,
0.017846116796135902,
0.04463745653629303,
0.0015451946528628469,
-0.017122026532888412,
0.013561968691647053,
0.01706119067966938,
0.029760176315903664,
0.004337246995419264,
0.016147615388035774,
-0.017492525279521942,
-0.03667597100138664,
-0.008290214464068413,
0.05088624358177185,
-0.0007581223035231233,
-0.03932108357548714,
-0.013641084544360638,
-0.019681228324770927,
0.035611141473054886,
-0.009575916454195976,
-0.03125564754009247,
-0.006012605037540197,
0.03033417835831642,
0.023863770067691803,
-0.03157170116901398,
0.02054702490568161,
-0.02146235667169094,
0.0055330414324998856,
-0.018762914463877678,
-0.028776276856660843,
-0.05822523310780525,
-0.017042342573404312,
-0.05348817631602287,
0.0022033366840332747,
-0.01961413584649563,
-0.08400531858205795,
-0.04196694493293762,
0.03127706050872803,
0.03253413736820221,
-0.0026233396492898464,
0.01654013991355896,
-0.024091463536024094,
-0.09182925522327423,
-0.024302512407302856,
0.009610642679035664,
-0.02433166839182377,
-0.03259752318263054,
0.006366480141878128,
0.029083076864480972,
-0.048047985881567,
-0.05147887393832207,
-0.02266787923872471,
0.028459124267101288,
-0.011917528696358204,
-0.03999066352844238,
-0.00009810642222873867,
-0.01140914298593998,
-0.027101321145892143,
-0.02186601795256138,
0.027962490916252136,
-0.014642962254583836,
0.016208169981837273,
-0.010148546658456326,
0.03972562029957771,
0.030469320714473724,
-0.0024795490317046642,
0.06306595355272293,
0.024954935535788536,
-0.0349324606359005,
0.05070914328098297,
-0.06739114224910736,
-0.024009225890040398,
0.0037079930771142244,
-0.022377848625183105,
0.03236532583832741,
-0.05505805090069771,
-0.04328826069831848,
0.03978222608566284,
0.020941652357578278,
-0.02455691620707512,
-0.014133813790977001,
0.04218069091439247,
-0.020216386765241623,
0.005674195010215044,
-0.007395824883133173,
-0.005816658027470112,
0.03957872465252876,
0.06255167722702026,
-0.020779237151145935,
-0.0012435155222192407,
0.021449508145451546,
-0.031700558960437775,
0.007702176924794912,
0.017111007124185562,
-0.011474485509097576,
-0.03712717443704605,
-0.013322408311069012,
-0.02374695986509323,
0.028820717707276344,
0.0665091946721077,
0.034786392003297806,
0.004244552925229073,
0.03466976061463356,
0.05460468307137489,
0.004970932845026255,
-0.0094488225877285,
-0.025549011304974556,
0.01611507683992386,
-0.03711971268057823,
0.035733386874198914,
-0.032395899295806885,
0.028187066316604614,
0.00797201320528984,
0.00793566182255745,
-0.020261745899915695,
-0.011673271656036377,
-0.00035843648947775364,
-0.006614699959754944,
0.01265634037554264,
0.03173191472887993,
-0.019903698936104774,
-0.04162554815411568,
-0.040037598460912704,
-0.002539431443437934,
-0.02389947697520256,
0.04941719397902489,
-0.008620967157185078,
-0.0016474181320518255,
-0.04759034886956215,
0.042403385043144226,
0.0004537306376732886,
-0.010406644083559513,
0.015619456768035889,
0.01854863204061985,
0.04521079733967781,
-0.026695972308516502,
-0.005230266600847244,
0.023959623649716377,
0.02348778024315834,
0.03021988645195961,
-0.016162779182195663,
-0.009310731664299965,
-0.006198292598128319,
-0.04009898751974106,
-0.0020532829221338034,
0.024620862677693367,
-0.004278518259525299,
-0.01654079183936119,
0.058164339512586594,
0.020468682050704956,
-0.04282483458518982,
0.019925018772482872,
0.022336190566420555,
0.08958746492862701,
0.03728700429201126,
0.0027467976324260235,
-0.016651879996061325,
-0.05637972056865692,
0.002128376392647624,
-0.02076793648302555,
0.02384328842163086,
-0.05583225563168526,
-0.03859288617968559,
-0.05018699914216995,
-0.04292794317007065,
0.012202823534607887,
0.023875771090388298,
-0.03402681648731232,
-0.013899478130042553,
-0.014168372377753258,
0.02238008752465248,
-0.03062562644481659,
-0.024763086810708046,
0.09177051484584808,
-0.0801781639456749,
0.006726182531565428,
0.0322040319442749,
-0.024112770333886147,
0.03990235552191734,
-0.01339821144938469,
0.0022953294683247805,
-0.05817808583378792,
-0.03548815846443176,
0.040354762226343155,
-0.004356171935796738,
-0.008032092824578285,
-0.08089473843574524,
-0.010797953233122826,
0.02270202524960041,
0.015716299414634705,
0.01154874823987484,
-0.00240976526401937,
-0.04951932653784752,
-0.00788981281220913,
0.04426637291908264,
-0.024513186886906624,
0.007752969861030579,
0.02250949665904045,
-0.038166869431734085,
0.03396787494421005,
-0.03733828291296959,
0.007255937438458204,
0.04907969385385513,
-0.01295290607959032,
-0.03363030403852463,
-0.031689438968896866,
0.025650903582572937,
0.022593962028622627,
0.00727125583216548,
0.03254946321249008,
-0.012324914336204529,
-0.03369143232703209,
0.030154306441545486,
-0.006449458189308643,
0.06081289052963257,
0.03181478753685951,
0.015655454248189926,
0.008681182749569416,
0.0004671550414059311,
0.01629350706934929,
-0.00615774467587471,
-0.02420009858906269,
-0.014083304442465305,
0.05270009487867355,
-0.022813638672232628,
-0.07673320174217224,
-0.06400103121995926,
-0.06213744729757309,
0.002875265432521701,
-0.0012384754372760653,
0.017154762521386147,
-0.029719503596425056,
0.06885594874620438,
0.009868250228464603,
0.04046943783760071,
-0.044650934636592865,
-0.008819596841931343,
0.043667543679475784,
-0.05887700244784355,
0.023339997977018356,
-0.059639427810907364,
-0.055264174938201904,
0.03932534158229828,
-0.04691379517316818,
-0.03227117657661438,
-0.01197991892695427,
-0.021865159273147583,
0.04891141131520271,
-0.0028672327753156424,
-0.043250925838947296,
0.042097557336091995,
0.013214528560638428,
-0.016432637348771095,
0.012858545407652855,
-0.06081654131412506,
0.02234550379216671,
-0.04087933152914047,
-0.04899011552333832,
-0.0036743893288075924,
0.017034901306033134,
0.04346180707216263,
-0.023364681750535965,
0.002387138782069087,
0.004697395488619804,
0.022359022870659828,
0.021004896610975266,
0.08179294317960739,
0.00873151421546936,
0.023670170456171036,
-0.028496095910668373,
0.07184851169586182,
0.021590178832411766,
0.00962036568671465,
-0.008553635329008102,
0.02249995432794094,
-0.0034680671524256468,
-0.0556786023080349,
0.02039063349366188,
0.009485158137977123,
0.01972281001508236,
-0.07345998287200928,
0.06772702932357788,
0.03190374746918678,
-0.018313312903046608,
0.0051805488765239716,
0.03507246449589729,
-0.06460155546665192,
-0.009970232844352722,
-0.0062119681388139725,
0.015229633077979088,
-0.015938622877001762,
0.049002040177583694,
0.03758738934993744,
0.056946948170661926,
0.08018447458744049,
-0.01600082591176033,
-0.008860980160534382,
0.019181743264198303,
0.08329837024211884,
0.08315081894397736,
0.04868434742093086,
0.0006419432465918362,
0.07242901623249054,
-0.04540202021598816,
-0.03949460759758949,
0.024281181395053864,
0.03856711834669113,
-0.011277818121016026,
-0.02583475224673748,
0.02216491475701332,
0.07080498337745667,
-0.020269664004445076,
0.07058771699666977,
-0.03777921944856644,
-0.014236128889024258,
0.05167147144675255,
0.017253603786230087,
-0.004863439127802849,
0.007822108455002308,
0.055676255375146866,
0.024815045297145844,
-0.022177865728735924,
0.002846877323463559,
-0.01787765882909298,
-0.022870849817991257,
-0.0002175387053284794,
0.010372963733971119,
-0.010608942247927189,
0.004130073823034763,
-0.03620022162795067,
0.07662113755941391,
0.11580421030521393,
-0.0031044096685945988,
-0.02055610716342926,
0.018459944054484367,
-0.012256458401679993,
-0.003523648250848055,
0.057003457099199295,
0.011809141375124454,
0.0010526091791689396,
-0.00684063695371151,
-0.02032974548637867,
0.016207821667194366,
-0.006520634051412344,
0.011672903783619404,
0.04606135934591293,
-0.039111364632844925,
-0.03173530846834183,
-0.014883618801832199,
0.042073529213666916,
-0.038737136870622635,
-0.07715621590614319,
-0.038415487855672836,
-0.03314291313290596,
-0.05177077651023865,
-0.02829211950302124,
0.047619495540857315,
-0.0012510609813034534,
-0.030792564153671265,
0.0005297709722071886,
-0.001771040610037744,
0.022673873230814934,
0.0033824292477220297,
-0.047788359224796295,
-0.01009600143879652,
0.025873715057969093,
-0.03550418093800545,
-0.02367713674902916,
0.04188091307878494,
0.010760126635432243,
-0.03425370901823044,
-0.02539503574371338,
0.05120902135968208,
-0.015651501715183258,
0.022479265928268433,
-0.01426969189196825,
-0.029368169605731964,
-0.10797277092933655,
0.01889306679368019,
0.006524528842419386,
-0.023695020005106926,
-0.09054224193096161,
0.0010698421392589808,
0.0059888060204684734,
0.04869144782423973,
0.05384116992354393,
-0.011735660023987293,
0.029726386070251465,
-0.047586437314748764,
0.005300760269165039,
-0.021416695788502693,
0.00680152652785182,
0.06480544805526733,
-0.020819377154111862,
0.07803309708833694,
0.052591949701309204,
-0.0076570105738937855,
-0.04174806922674179,
0.012435865588486195,
-0.007836952805519104,
0.0014820229262113571,
-0.032544299960136414,
-0.025202851742506027,
-0.01633993163704872,
-0.09037245810031891,
-0.05690695345401764,
0.016435598954558372,
-0.04531390592455864,
-0.03254110738635063,
-0.012164541520178318,
-0.03506094589829445,
-0.015000312589108944,
-0.018247291445732117,
-0.01223087403923273,
-0.021822186186909676,
-0.007781668566167355,
-0.034806087613105774,
-0.09034072607755661,
-0.030964909121394157,
-0.017973078414797783,
0.013098645024001598,
-0.04477404057979584,
-0.005810643080621958,
0.010705158114433289,
0.013190156780183315,
0.025912029668688774,
-0.020471319556236267,
0.03559586778283119,
0.00823623314499855
] |
3 |
Spider 2.0: Evaluating Language Models on Real-World Enterprise Text-to-SQL Workflows
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=XmProj9cPs
|
[
"Fangyu Lei",
"Jixuan Chen",
"Yuxiao Ye",
"Ruisheng Cao",
"Dongchan Shin",
"Hongjin SU",
"ZHAOQING SUO",
"Hongcheng Gao",
"Wenjing Hu",
"Pengcheng Yin",
"Victor Zhong",
"Caiming Xiong",
"Ruoxi Sun",
"Qian Liu",
"Sida Wang",
"Tao Yu"
] |
Oral
|
Real-world enterprise text-to-SQL workflows often involve complex cloud or local data across various database systems, multiple SQL queries in various dialects, and diverse operations from data transformation to analytics.
We introduce Spider 2.0, an evaluation framework comprising $632$ real-world text-to-SQL workflow problems derived from enterprise-level database use cases.
The databases in Spider 2.0 are sourced from real data applications, often containing over 1,000 columns and stored in local or cloud database systems such as BigQuery and Snowflake.
We show that solving problems in Spider 2.0 frequently requires understanding and searching through database metadata, dialect documentation, and even project-level codebases.
This challenge calls for models to interact with complex SQL workflow environments, process extremely long contexts, perform intricate reasoning, and generate multiple SQL queries with diverse operations, often exceeding $100$ lines, which goes far beyond traditional text-to-SQL challenges.
Our evaluations indicate that based on o1-preview, our code agent framework successfully solves only 21.3\% of the tasks, compared with 91.2\% on Spider 1.0 and 73.0\% on BIRD.
Our results on Spider 2.0 show that while language models have demonstrated remarkable performance in code generation --- especially in prior text-to-SQL benchmarks --- they require significant improvement in order to achieve adequate performance for real-world enterprise usage.
Progress on Spider 2.0 represents crucial steps towards developing intelligent, autonomous, code agents for real-world enterprise settings.
Our code, baseline models, and data are available at [spider2-sql.github.io](spider2-sql.github.io) .
|
LLM Benchmark, Data Science and Engineering, Code Generation, Text-to-SQL, LLM Agent
|
A benchmark for enterprise-level Text-to-SQL involving complex databases, challenging tasks, and real-world scenarios.
| 13,657 |
2411.07763
|
[
-0.029984761029481888,
-0.05117392539978027,
-0.014438548125326633,
0.04148005694150925,
0.06265062838792801,
0.005044182762503624,
0.023352786898612976,
0.04093597084283829,
-0.02782435342669487,
-0.05603385716676712,
-0.03901423513889313,
-0.0033811237663030624,
-0.07936139404773712,
-0.011774489656090736,
0.00014751346316188574,
0.06489887833595276,
0.021289637312293053,
0.015660734847187996,
0.06172288581728935,
-0.0282134972512722,
-0.01379953883588314,
-0.010400530882179737,
0.0030643318314105272,
0.020551901310682297,
0.020654382184147835,
0.048237018287181854,
-0.0033014160580933094,
0.02369338646531105,
-0.050923336297273636,
-0.0012952146353200078,
0.05734436586499214,
-0.00012176076415926218,
-0.008983430452644825,
-0.03467170149087906,
0.0016700656851753592,
0.010473782196640968,
-0.05190960317850113,
0.0380447655916214,
-0.006802217103540897,
-0.028628136962652206,
-0.04155506193637848,
0.04516085609793663,
-0.001780343591235578,
0.033878397196531296,
-0.02092103287577629,
0.020440230146050453,
-0.11167708039283752,
0.03422204405069351,
-0.009516078047454357,
0.008128834888339043,
-0.10263931751251221,
0.03968646004796028,
-0.018622364848852158,
-0.031717199832201004,
-0.008800451643764973,
0.05528021976351738,
0.03365933895111084,
-0.06525520980358124,
0.009256167337298393,
-0.007991259917616844,
-0.017721353098750114,
0.01132685411721468,
0.029003411531448364,
0.02686155214905739,
0.028585322201251984,
-0.030019016936421394,
-0.01148498896509409,
0.03576236590743065,
-0.047012802213430405,
-0.016270708292722702,
0.01246473379433155,
0.01024064514786005,
-0.02604447491466999,
-0.008129911497235298,
0.004088250920176506,
-0.03623242676258087,
-0.005736724939197302,
0.03994135931134224,
0.06512264907360077,
0.048549752682447433,
0.02908140793442726,
0.009860066697001457,
0.018468668684363365,
0.013221248053014278,
0.0209321528673172,
-0.008363950997591019,
-0.058451078832149506,
-0.016530858352780342,
-0.05837082490324974,
0.011257736943662167,
0.005053872708231211,
-0.06155909225344658,
0.006751158740371466,
0.020115388557314873,
0.004688053857535124,
0.04052797704935074,
0.02489371784031391,
0.015048505738377571,
0.01648912951350212,
0.0029693273827433586,
-0.020263580605387688,
-0.023116374388337135,
0.03615277260541916,
-0.014005792327225208,
-0.10361992567777634,
-0.00794245209544897,
-0.05394423007965088,
0.0004797551955562085,
0.02318839356303215,
-0.017145579680800438,
-0.0033292779698967934,
-0.03142962604761124,
-0.017504770308732986,
-0.036119651049375534,
-0.06357061117887497,
0.0667373314499855,
-0.010875223204493523,
0.01977902464568615,
0.03155374154448509,
0.002796513494104147,
0.0430411621928215,
0.042792852967977524,
0.0004944527172483504,
0.08969034999608994,
-0.004369192291051149,
0.022076329216361046,
0.02342318929731846,
0.0026606982573866844,
-0.01958712562918663,
-0.043045103549957275,
0.002911086892709136,
0.01584511250257492,
-0.0015029276255518198,
-0.007195028942078352,
-0.003475136822089553,
0.012574848718941212,
0.0061776903457939625,
0.024177270010113716,
0.05239879712462425,
0.002815692685544491,
0.0000307887967210263,
-0.024878012016415596,
0.0449187271296978,
-0.03598891571164131,
0.08462517708539963,
0.02750706672668457,
0.023082956671714783,
-0.05618986859917641,
-0.02749858982861042,
0.005109562538564205,
0.009001658298075199,
-0.0032073259353637695,
-0.016924681141972542,
-0.049651216715574265,
0.02503814920783043,
0.09566166251897812,
0.030467862263321877,
0.002590900519862771,
0.02239624783396721,
0.008919893763959408,
0.018114769831299782,
-0.0003321177791804075,
-0.05560837686061859,
-0.016661012545228004,
-0.019916890189051628,
-0.015018574893474579,
-0.015939289703965187,
-0.0016194158233702183,
-0.02183767594397068,
0.011752753518521786,
-0.035500165075063705,
-0.04594948887825012,
0.06582149863243103,
-0.04043202102184296,
0.028783408924937248,
0.007841356098651886,
0.038932010531425476,
-0.001317487913183868,
0.044514767825603485,
0.02177601307630539,
-0.0879429280757904,
0.03246296942234039,
-0.004710111301392317,
0.0010636801598593593,
-0.0029882260132580996,
0.01199787762016058,
0.10913596302270889,
-0.020231405273079872,
0.0033919508568942547,
0.04092543572187424,
-0.1261485517024994,
-0.08401959389448166,
0.012183747254312038,
-0.02958524227142334,
0.03628804162144661,
-0.028242364525794983,
-0.003383111907169223,
0.06197037547826767,
-0.0009820626582950354,
0.04291633516550064,
0.03386828303337097,
-0.021743161603808403,
0.032675012946128845,
-0.03954100236296654,
-0.01287021767348051,
0.0005063261487521231,
0.02233201451599598,
-0.05782455950975418,
-0.08066387474536896,
0.015308346599340439,
-0.00812783557921648,
-0.018151193857192993,
-0.00851433165371418,
-0.008614613674581051,
0.027876684442162514,
0.026320479810237885,
0.005620860494673252,
0.002266274532303214,
0.0014722534688189626,
-0.04708825424313545,
0.0692858099937439,
-0.008977469056844711,
0.003981166053563356,
-0.0350319966673851,
-0.028638163581490517,
0.07477211207151413,
0.07713772356510162,
-0.025476839393377304,
0.002256898209452629,
0.02051760070025921,
0.007737795356661081,
0.0039703985676169395,
0.018243933096528053,
-0.05711737275123596,
0.035024065524339676,
-0.03139980882406235,
0.0032870974391698837,
-0.037877995520830154,
0.021805454045534134,
-0.0317365787923336,
-0.018553907051682472,
0.0521085262298584,
-0.03437015041708946,
0.0645107850432396,
0.03310918062925339,
-0.03451228514313698,
0.004798601847141981,
-0.016818637028336525,
0.025723326951265335,
-0.027266310527920723,
-0.008708913810551167,
0.010539333336055279,
-0.025184985250234604,
-0.03931467607617378,
-0.02946852706372738,
-0.048452965915203094,
0.006754711735993624,
-0.005983693525195122,
0.030693909153342247,
0.04886434227228165,
-0.007158355787396431,
0.0012312160106375813,
0.002368986140936613,
-0.0024788405280560255,
0.031624309718608856,
-0.08879005908966064,
-0.03341573476791382,
-0.025035707280039787,
0.01740092970430851,
0.02208675444126129,
0.02730497345328331,
-0.002546424977481365,
0.015263741835951805,
-0.02326616458594799,
-0.019456077367067337,
-0.012647854164242744,
0.027185149490833282,
-0.015113327652215958,
-0.048988912254571915,
-0.030643653124570847,
-0.01713939569890499,
0.05435117706656456,
-0.023540247231721878,
-0.03888910263776779,
-0.026730326935648918,
-0.02027856931090355,
0.019342757761478424,
-0.05436151102185249,
-0.008928416296839714,
-0.0008983341394923627,
0.01890929602086544,
0.01602593995630741,
-0.056988123804330826,
0.008960006758570671,
0.06755285710096359,
0.0393696166574955,
0.003079923102632165,
0.02111668884754181,
0.016290098428726196,
0.029722370207309723,
-0.006937774363905191,
0.005141502246260643,
0.013480041176080704,
0.03386884182691574,
-0.012392225675284863,
-0.019934838637709618,
0.004822234157472849,
-0.015485691837966442,
-0.2833274304866791,
0.0011859809746965766,
-0.018000155687332153,
-0.05298354849219322,
0.050346601754426956,
0.007772186771035194,
0.05908757075667381,
-0.02196180447936058,
-0.007662971969693899,
0.010737912729382515,
-0.010155095718801022,
0.04074360430240631,
0.017597109079360962,
0.04286317899823189,
0.03097768872976303,
0.08593881875276566,
-0.02573613077402115,
-0.032253555953502655,
-0.0248943492770195,
0.0006759220850653946,
-0.02963336370885372,
-0.05697452276945114,
0.012211957015097141,
-0.01662364974617958,
0.012332743965089321,
0.06413602083921432,
-0.0727480947971344,
0.024302184581756592,
-0.012043025344610214,
0.007506344933062792,
0.06109822541475296,
-0.040745384991168976,
-0.0328449048101902,
-0.01664682663977146,
-0.007185706403106451,
-0.007932291366159916,
0.04423477500677109,
0.0014640045119449496,
0.039897434413433075,
0.006403219886124134,
-0.011567579582333565,
-0.030505400151014328,
-0.026040978729724884,
-0.014066101983189583,
0.07350797206163406,
0.024566449224948883,
-0.038319941610097885,
0.015856318175792694,
-0.0020123871508985758,
0.047955889254808426,
-0.01100209541618824,
-0.02189057320356369,
-0.015142133459448814,
0.01734606921672821,
0.021515708416700363,
-0.0448412224650383,
-0.006285530049353838,
0.008977199904620647,
0.003951861523091793,
0.015031580813229084,
0.018766777589917183,
-0.04340290650725365,
0.005558961071074009,
-0.026962760835886,
-0.017088428139686584,
-0.04148140177130699,
-0.03508242964744568,
-0.06167540326714516,
0.053322095423936844,
0.04050287976861,
-0.011830775067210197,
0.04586789384484291,
0.01385508943349123,
-0.09322702884674072,
0.01917254738509655,
-0.006436340045183897,
0.0011332010617479682,
-0.03505378216505051,
0.004526028409600258,
0.03233723342418671,
-0.050577424466609955,
-0.05458962917327881,
-0.033458810299634933,
-0.002223810413852334,
0.021426303312182426,
-0.02038303017616272,
0.022644612938165665,
-0.03877049684524536,
-0.022734561935067177,
-0.03599682077765465,
0.04613487794995308,
-0.04383781552314758,
0.011308114975690842,
0.030442852526903152,
0.05306816101074219,
0.032614365220069885,
0.0310073085129261,
0.05004433915019035,
0.008916400372982025,
0.00686389347538352,
0.023510517552495003,
-0.08916512131690979,
0.022546211257576942,
-0.04684346541762352,
0.017677517607808113,
0.0007615571958012879,
-0.0618160218000412,
-0.021572299301624298,
0.056232258677482605,
-0.006610122974961996,
-0.026781337335705757,
-0.017056722193956375,
-0.00954474974423647,
-0.047439686954021454,
-0.013775068335235119,
-0.004786462988704443,
0.008984842337667942,
0.003149457974359393,
0.007113623898476362,
-0.01536471489816904,
-0.04939058795571327,
0.030505193397402763,
0.019329795613884926,
0.003013390116393566,
-0.049503620713949203,
-0.043575044721364975,
0.0007396592409349978,
-0.01654939167201519,
0.04597708582878113,
-0.037824030965566635,
0.006062658037990332,
0.039493441581726074,
-0.0042844670824706554,
0.02994590811431408,
0.03718758746981621,
-0.004133480601012707,
-0.02618596889078617,
-0.012174635194242,
0.020542573183774948,
-0.003712933976203203,
-0.0037722368724644184,
-0.013331391848623753,
-0.011182278394699097,
0.02250593900680542,
0.0405832901597023,
0.019862426444888115,
0.010105414316058159,
0.02063712477684021,
0.020364180207252502,
0.022617341950535774,
0.010892314836382866,
-0.059808149933815,
0.013693572953343391,
-0.05296149477362633,
-0.023444024845957756,
-0.045726507902145386,
0.03735114261507988,
-0.036136195063591,
0.009846262633800507,
-0.05276154726743698,
0.01667996123433113,
-0.00850896630436182,
0.009895308874547482,
0.00997473020106554,
0.007151501253247261,
0.04292980208992958,
-0.0015132433036342263,
0.02473410964012146,
0.007627800572663546,
0.005066665355116129,
0.01379593089222908,
-0.012005981989204884,
-0.030233493074774742,
0.017516598105430603,
-0.017014190554618835,
-0.00508312601596117,
0.0049704075790941715,
0.0035542899277061224,
-0.01598244160413742,
0.07424558699131012,
0.01680097170174122,
-0.0074607073329389095,
-0.01169759500771761,
0.01769096590578556,
0.06712889671325684,
0.024950837716460228,
0.029757007956504822,
0.004255575127899647,
0.004777881782501936,
0.02635031007230282,
-0.0007908602128736675,
0.008782695047557354,
-0.008042730391025543,
-0.02501138672232628,
-0.02710908092558384,
-0.054740358144044876,
0.0597074031829834,
-0.00456084031611681,
-0.01972409524023533,
0.0006319569074548781,
-0.0116515401750803,
-0.012285754084587097,
-0.022840211167931557,
0.01509190909564495,
0.006303939037024975,
-0.07964548468589783,
-0.01610950380563736,
0.004177516791969538,
-0.008893155492842197,
-0.00961318239569664,
-0.016358859837055206,
-0.033146440982818604,
-0.07276540994644165,
0.007211118470877409,
0.023540129885077477,
0.017539585009217262,
0.006356564350426197,
-0.0009428650955669582,
0.013270705938339233,
-0.013810710981488228,
-0.008625181391835213,
0.0017252325778827071,
-0.004059331025928259,
-0.03451567515730858,
-0.004286148585379124,
0.0510345883667469,
-0.0002473307540640235,
-0.03390580788254738,
0.0015012549702078104,
-0.022284526377916336,
0.043151047080755234,
-0.06960676610469818,
0.004274272359907627,
0.01636723428964615,
0.03906163200736046,
0.014083166606724262,
-0.06986825168132782,
0.03139788657426834,
0.02877659723162651,
0.00029690112569369376,
-0.019948039203882217,
0.002757143462076783,
0.005839689169079065,
-0.0129740871489048,
0.008064002729952335,
0.021890271455049515,
-0.013719418086111546,
0.004111355636268854,
-0.0097134318202734,
0.03219407796859741,
0.02756379172205925,
0.014295469038188457,
-0.009992366656661034,
-0.0006215519388206303,
0.08005769550800323,
-0.03646765276789665,
-0.033055827021598816,
-0.064749576151371,
-0.08418356627225876,
0.003757736412808299,
-0.0000057818911045615096,
0.012630118057131767,
-0.036993686109781265,
0.03692945837974548,
0.014002496376633644,
0.04484076797962189,
0.023605793714523315,
-0.031392622739076614,
0.06419233232736588,
-0.06879047304391861,
-0.007918152026832104,
-0.08237165957689285,
-0.030817819759249687,
0.05090804398059845,
-0.03830563649535179,
-0.007205249276012182,
0.011675357818603516,
-0.04752449318766594,
-0.006794598884880543,
-0.011879496276378632,
-0.08874917775392532,
0.02718326263129711,
-0.020952075719833374,
-0.007226338144391775,
0.006317037623375654,
-0.03641929849982262,
0.013749959878623486,
0.009687691926956177,
-0.031734056770801544,
0.00848064012825489,
0.000292340264422819,
0.057769324630498886,
-0.037165991961956024,
0.011267772875726223,
-0.04571381211280823,
-0.03278432413935661,
0.04531441256403923,
0.03117934986948967,
-0.0024067952763289213,
0.06864295154809952,
-0.024175520986318588,
0.06872397661209106,
0.034528810530900955,
0.021468190476298332,
0.00460795545950532,
0.017791958525776863,
-0.015192857012152672,
-0.0267745703458786,
0.04501577094197273,
0.028825484216213226,
-0.013387491926550865,
-0.04857805743813515,
0.07081914693117142,
0.032223571091890335,
-0.06106221675872803,
-0.016261475160717964,
-0.007392830215394497,
-0.05798537656664848,
0.012667499482631683,
-0.018762193620204926,
0.0050080036744475365,
-0.02645631693303585,
0.06382588297128677,
0.026044348254799843,
0.026027103886008263,
0.07977553457021713,
0.02111310325562954,
0.00746809272095561,
-0.026809828355908394,
0.055963966995477676,
0.08848868310451508,
0.049405913800001144,
-0.007343999110162258,
0.02269325591623783,
-0.04164629429578781,
-0.05808793380856514,
0.018791820853948593,
0.05341752618551254,
0.0045072343200445175,
-0.022695058956742287,
0.015389987267553806,
0.06447526067495346,
0.01807824708521366,
0.06683455407619476,
-0.0534818097949028,
0.0033186187501996756,
0.01825389638543129,
-0.018288783729076385,
0.006839643698185682,
0.013509191572666168,
0.012795483693480492,
0.018368761986494064,
-0.04385184496641159,
-0.022963304072618484,
0.01007230207324028,
-0.031214749440550804,
-0.017563017085194588,
0.025582635775208473,
0.000058995068684453145,
0.0015553663251921535,
-0.008928601630032063,
0.04911820590496063,
0.13052403926849365,
-0.04360080882906914,
-0.03040601685643196,
0.012765859253704548,
0.002862168475985527,
0.010327717289328575,
0.03260437026619911,
0.008335885591804981,
-0.032771963626146317,
-0.019029740244150162,
-0.0639992356300354,
0.027310160920023918,
0.010757752694189548,
-0.013693870976567268,
0.026645459234714508,
-0.017137350514531136,
-0.010507181286811829,
0.02387966215610504,
0.029265373945236206,
-0.03857506439089775,
-0.04029158130288124,
-0.027336914092302322,
-0.008553138002753258,
-0.039609555155038834,
-0.03593285381793976,
0.02876662276685238,
-0.018441397696733475,
-0.012813051231205463,
0.008687053807079792,
-0.0055580525659024715,
0.03833208605647087,
0.023303810507059097,
-0.04195646569132805,
0.0025899438187479973,
0.03499176353216171,
0.0046916501596570015,
-0.006973643787205219,
0.07419221848249435,
0.025435591116547585,
-0.03201736509799957,
-0.0027701295912265778,
-0.0009507315116934478,
0.03420703858137131,
0.04249509423971176,
0.012075308710336685,
-0.0015850368654355407,
-0.07772915065288544,
0.017166320234537125,
0.02453652210533619,
-0.0068793767131865025,
-0.07698848843574524,
-0.0024488584604114294,
-0.0018291445448994637,
-0.022651461884379387,
0.06186361238360405,
0.010874602012336254,
0.015261512249708176,
-0.0338735394179821,
0.003413126338273287,
-0.0091902706772089,
0.034442394971847534,
0.049755390733480453,
-0.032442495226860046,
0.041192881762981415,
0.04959435388445854,
-0.02606213465332985,
-0.045579325407743454,
0.040308065712451935,
0.01916489750146866,
-0.0030143321491777897,
-0.014206776395440102,
-0.01962888427078724,
-0.04420825093984604,
-0.084204763174057,
-0.006760448683053255,
0.025476345792412758,
0.010276238434016705,
-0.03663075342774391,
-0.009889774955809116,
0.026226116344332695,
-0.04676748067140579,
-0.021001867949962616,
-0.015082660131156445,
0.028721068054437637,
-0.04509149119257927,
-0.07210841774940491,
-0.06325434148311615,
0.008064324036240578,
-0.012465881183743477,
-0.026135729625821114,
-0.02036123350262642,
-0.03919670730829239,
0.0037777305115014315,
-0.012126692570745945,
0.06503144651651382,
-0.0021798075176775455,
0.04470402002334595,
0.020779848098754883
] |
4 |
Knowledge Entropy Decay during Language Model Pretraining Hinders New Knowledge Acquisition
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=eHehzSDUFp
|
[
"Jiyeon Kim",
"Hyunji Lee",
"Hyowon Cho",
"Joel Jang",
"Hyeonbin Hwang",
"Seungpil Won",
"Youbin Ahn",
"Dohaeng Lee",
"Minjoon Seo"
] |
Oral
|
In this work, we investigate how a model's tendency to broadly integrate its parametric knowledge evolves throughout pretraining, and how this behavior affects overall performance, particularly in terms of knowledge acquisition and forgetting. We introduce the concept of knowledge entropy, which quantifies the range of memory sources the model engages with; high knowledge entropy indicates that the model utilizes a wide range of memory sources, while low knowledge entropy suggests reliance on specific sources with greater certainty. Our analysis reveals a consistent decline in knowledge entropy as pretraining advances. We also find that the decline is closely associated with a reduction in the model's ability to acquire and retain knowledge, leading us to conclude that diminishing knowledge entropy (smaller number of active memory sources) impairs the model's knowledge acquisition and retention capabilities. We find further support for this by demonstrating that increasing the activity of inactive memory sources enhances the model's capacity for knowledge acquisition and retention.
|
knowledge entropy, knowledge acquisition and forgetting, evolving behavior during LLM pretraining
|
As pretraining progresses, models exhibit narrower integration of memory vectors, reflected by decreasing knowledge entropy, which hinders both knowledge acquisition and retention.
| 13,581 |
2410.01380
|
[
-0.03146198019385338,
0.006314320024102926,
-0.02386482246220112,
0.0069854832254350185,
0.06182214245200157,
-0.0024073985405266285,
0.05851138010621071,
0.008571662940084934,
-0.049556806683540344,
-0.014392765238881111,
-0.03509105369448662,
0.06213784217834473,
-0.025217240676283836,
0.014011230319738388,
0.024211863055825233,
0.042017314583063126,
0.06668925285339355,
0.003342378418892622,
0.009110859595239162,
0.0211024172604084,
-0.0026243471074849367,
0.000915073964279145,
0.02822365052998066,
0.021472889930009842,
0.03662696108222008,
-0.0005481645930558443,
-0.011794797144830227,
-0.037779029458761215,
-0.021870693191885948,
0.013879472389817238,
0.01032152771949768,
-0.024932531639933586,
0.009855931624770164,
0.0019585457630455494,
0.025921881198883057,
0.02505878359079361,
-0.051575735211372375,
-0.014041069895029068,
-0.00283478363417089,
0.02488737739622593,
-0.04075087234377861,
0.04585150256752968,
-0.0009113646810874343,
-0.009600250981748104,
-0.04679274559020996,
0.0007397879380732775,
-0.07819262146949768,
0.03637082129716873,
0.012850060127675533,
-0.017183955758810043,
-0.13258840143680573,
0.021527370437979698,
0.03809700533747673,
-0.038724493235349655,
0.009029005654156208,
0.02587195485830307,
0.023176617920398712,
-0.044054850935935974,
0.02804136835038662,
-0.017604170367121696,
0.009224017150700092,
0.006276330444961786,
-0.013764170929789543,
-0.014547370374202728,
-0.0031175031326711178,
-0.06090693175792694,
0.019026346504688263,
0.03944859281182289,
-0.05777046084403992,
-0.029725823551416397,
-0.04546801745891571,
0.0054571800865232944,
-0.005212877411395311,
-0.010957235470414162,
-0.011890923604369164,
-0.05398717150092125,
0.01727668009698391,
0.043169502168893814,
0.06763418018817902,
0.009520253166556358,
-0.009167172014713287,
0.03933288902044296,
0.03302164375782013,
0.009522978216409683,
0.025829721242189407,
-0.008831962943077087,
-0.009444096125662327,
-0.04461611807346344,
-0.06279566138982773,
0.029584357514977455,
-0.05392706021666527,
-0.04937080666422844,
0.008960972540080547,
0.01772325672209263,
-0.00119851587805897,
0.017604680731892586,
0.02939833141863346,
0.0021562171168625355,
0.0045150709338486195,
-0.0024696560576558113,
0.0032845933455973864,
-0.013063876889646053,
-0.017371514812111855,
0.0041539608500897884,
-0.10393115133047104,
-0.02063758112490177,
0.007819020189344883,
-0.00926385447382927,
-0.006507296580821276,
-0.0032814904116094112,
-0.04478170722723007,
-0.012862775474786758,
0.0010646546725183725,
-0.027145294472575188,
-0.07330908626317978,
0.012005932629108429,
-0.01931588351726532,
0.040695857256650925,
-0.0005075762746855617,
0.011598317883908749,
0.010480564087629318,
0.01588185504078865,
-0.011510702781379223,
0.06050027906894684,
-0.02063784748315811,
-0.010302848182618618,
-0.03363524377346039,
0.01978238858282566,
-0.0335347019135952,
-0.051088396459817886,
0.04042448103427887,
0.022140467539429665,
0.0005577765987254679,
0.004566811956465244,
-0.008915489539504051,
0.015029244124889374,
0.0295151025056839,
0.00011943439312744886,
0.023754628375172615,
0.0425805039703846,
0.011591161601245403,
0.001449128147214651,
0.027945855632424355,
-0.006900997832417488,
0.047860320657491684,
-0.009886306710541248,
-0.0332547202706337,
-0.011240474879741669,
0.003179210005328059,
-0.0028489145915955305,
0.019619133323431015,
-0.024691233411431313,
0.01380858849734068,
-0.03307940065860748,
0.02763352170586586,
0.05312241613864899,
-0.023248955607414246,
-0.012682903558015823,
0.02030390128493309,
0.0014849829021841288,
-0.014845741912722588,
0.00464593805372715,
0.022937754169106483,
0.027777446433901787,
0.007129446603357792,
-0.03982172906398773,
0.0035431385040283203,
0.02428535744547844,
-0.0453471913933754,
0.002855700207874179,
-0.05778273567557335,
-0.0048874374479055405,
0.05850474163889885,
-0.04839694872498512,
-0.0406530424952507,
0.007240596227347851,
0.030718103051185608,
0.019192513078451157,
0.04296769201755524,
0.000999598065391183,
-0.05486452579498291,
0.009728685021400452,
-0.015750858932733536,
0.013196815736591816,
0.011856009252369404,
-0.04536852240562439,
0.07863718271255493,
-0.03760213404893875,
0.032804422080516815,
0.006591031327843666,
-0.06327253580093384,
0.0008993843221105635,
0.026408854871988297,
-0.015329364687204361,
0.09176240116357803,
-0.02449980191886425,
0.03530185669660568,
0.045730628073215485,
0.03986715152859688,
0.05555804818868637,
0.050165075808763504,
-0.031138643622398376,
0.02185826376080513,
-0.0065164645202457905,
0.002749065635725856,
0.02487996593117714,
-0.00606659846380353,
-0.08204561471939087,
-0.03991055116057396,
0.04295579716563225,
-0.029123693704605103,
0.011544621549546719,
0.0051610833033919334,
0.012988506816327572,
0.016317158937454224,
0.004379956051707268,
0.004232577048242092,
-0.021645018830895424,
-0.0010858977911993861,
-0.03813871368765831,
-0.002382892882451415,
-0.003609044710174203,
-0.009972158819437027,
-0.01906062662601471,
-0.039406418800354004,
0.07771410793066025,
0.06745520979166031,
-0.03217912092804909,
0.000006139323886600323,
0.036333415657281876,
0.018549229949712753,
-0.013883608393371105,
0.011072135530412197,
0.01961129903793335,
0.054740097373723984,
-0.029536504298448563,
-0.01548577006906271,
-0.03226313367486,
0.03942235931754112,
-0.06560808420181274,
-0.03653205186128616,
0.07447026669979095,
-0.0240494292229414,
0.057085298001766205,
0.027483249083161354,
0.032549917697906494,
0.04733023792505264,
-0.009378940798342228,
-0.03493039682507515,
-0.004213258158415556,
-0.011793131940066814,
0.0028132391162216663,
0.008914492093026638,
-0.006955355405807495,
-0.019959012046456337,
-0.06518183648586273,
-0.05520383268594742,
-0.01630445010960102,
0.07698287069797516,
0.011594659648835659,
-0.00988751370459795,
0.04571853205561638,
-0.013272851705551147,
-0.01361511554569006,
0.011993522755801678,
-0.0725819319486618,
0.013394772075116634,
-0.06500541418790817,
0.01910996623337269,
-0.012621713802218437,
0.037122029811143875,
-0.0020318804308772087,
0.05500606447458267,
-0.01923525147140026,
-0.0362311415374279,
0.01804640144109726,
0.03404604271054268,
-0.022902851924300194,
-0.05342373996973038,
-0.030603043735027313,
-0.014446210116147995,
0.049718134105205536,
-0.03596377372741699,
-0.049501776695251465,
-0.024083243682980537,
-0.049358632415533066,
-0.022659625858068466,
-0.028874462470412254,
-0.04679137095808983,
0.031218403950333595,
0.002790597965940833,
-0.0035424481611698866,
-0.027990931645035744,
0.013116700574755669,
0.04025661200284958,
0.032429154962301254,
0.028418835252523422,
0.014889484271407127,
0.03116447478532791,
0.059327226132154465,
-0.03210372105240822,
0.017627952620387077,
-0.01832171529531479,
0.05181006342172623,
0.006240955553948879,
-0.01475249882787466,
0.016805270686745644,
-0.00010622447007335722,
-0.25756168365478516,
0.02980673313140869,
0.01734173484146595,
-0.053265247493982315,
0.03136349469423294,
0.02530723251402378,
0.02614683471620083,
-0.025800395756959915,
-0.039740726351737976,
0.044343505054712296,
0.03355170041322708,
0.04788864031434059,
0.01401886623352766,
0.07328946143388748,
-0.004266001284122467,
0.026205142959952354,
0.014835222624242306,
-0.026496704667806625,
-0.022155415266752243,
0.050357602536678314,
-0.01129736565053463,
-0.0436469130218029,
-0.04246794432401657,
0.058049291372299194,
-0.00021118950098752975,
0.04724428430199623,
-0.08164488524198532,
0.012810871005058289,
-0.03951915353536606,
0.02807532623410225,
-0.015019753016531467,
-0.03074624203145504,
0.022863032296299934,
0.05134144797921181,
0.008644028566777706,
0.009723021648824215,
0.027845870703458786,
0.01500727143138647,
-0.000965417711995542,
0.01208813488483429,
-0.0020329803228378296,
-0.036320533603429794,
-0.004933845717459917,
0.017762068659067154,
0.05472169443964958,
0.030563196167349815,
-0.08892078697681427,
-0.04940367490053177,
-0.0013522928347811103,
0.059038158506155014,
-0.0366259329020977,
-0.047964245080947876,
-0.03966956213116646,
0.036375824362039566,
0.01282196119427681,
-0.018980979919433594,
0.05014292150735855,
-0.03411494195461273,
-0.022075092419981956,
-0.024776101112365723,
0.0061636134050786495,
-0.06047765538096428,
-0.02747311443090439,
-0.05452699214220047,
0.0051396931521594524,
-0.02492969110608101,
-0.05685348063707352,
-0.034001968801021576,
0.05899137258529663,
0.030681047588586807,
-0.042051441967487335,
0.006132226902991533,
-0.013365567661821842,
-0.09467348456382751,
-0.0026255261618644,
-0.028287945315241814,
-0.028880394995212555,
-0.02039145864546299,
0.015164794400334358,
0.05724998563528061,
-0.03206007927656174,
-0.006479684729129076,
-0.0015912908129394054,
0.010438074357807636,
0.002558439504355192,
-0.0017447617137804627,
0.024068860337138176,
-0.012086288072168827,
-0.0395796075463295,
-0.028939416632056236,
0.039266619831323624,
0.05256776884198189,
-0.023126814514398575,
-0.01968669332563877,
0.05874146148562431,
0.052273672074079514,
0.014730095863342285,
0.05563358962535858,
0.04765104502439499,
-0.004556302446871996,
0.053018778562545776,
-0.07336698472499847,
-0.012441138736903667,
-0.009893273934721947,
-0.014207324013113976,
0.029409756883978844,
-0.04969694837927818,
-0.02249368466436863,
0.049681954085826874,
-0.03405999392271042,
-0.021325742825865746,
0.001996408449485898,
-0.015018320642411709,
0.01862683705985546,
-0.006153433583676815,
-0.021362608298659325,
0.0061362143605947495,
0.050974953919649124,
0.008183426223695278,
-0.040527526289224625,
-0.05115754157304764,
0.0548754446208477,
-0.02442612498998642,
-0.0027542340103536844,
-0.02355283685028553,
-0.0407116524875164,
-0.019343124702572823,
-0.03566724434494972,
-0.0395931713283062,
0.0008814783068373799,
0.02445657178759575,
-0.006116359494626522,
0.019466005265712738,
0.04009784385561943,
0.06823556870222092,
0.011828911490738392,
0.001878526178188622,
-0.0010786554776132107,
-0.0006796919042244554,
-0.03463355079293251,
-0.0045671914704144,
0.0001720610016491264,
0.038223329931497574,
0.0138838030397892,
0.01265634410083294,
0.01200780924409628,
0.00298476405441761,
-0.051624901592731476,
0.001584195764735341,
-0.0029275836423039436,
0.0732947438955307,
-0.03732766956090927,
-0.008043495006859303,
-0.037439849227666855,
-0.024299010634422302,
-0.005794136319309473,
0.056430965662002563,
-0.005903614219278097,
0.01771683618426323,
-0.04891859367489815,
0.03486206382513046,
-0.019899632781744003,
-0.020752916112542152,
0.004855859559029341,
0.009927492588758469,
0.02037031389772892,
-0.010023573413491249,
-0.014421917498111725,
0.034349869936704636,
0.03737266734242439,
0.013838710263371468,
-0.04940694570541382,
-0.039508920162916183,
-0.0006816644454374909,
-0.014758043922483921,
-0.018697239458560944,
0.021718446165323257,
-0.03580048307776451,
-0.024400081485509872,
0.028286641463637352,
0.01408490538597107,
-0.02200840599834919,
0.003419961081817746,
0.0013874613214284182,
0.0590478777885437,
0.01757906563580036,
0.033762820065021515,
-0.02746640332043171,
-0.050379712134599686,
-0.015561824664473534,
-0.02456706203520298,
-0.014454307965934277,
-0.012283886782824993,
-0.0375235490500927,
-0.054823704063892365,
-0.0350140817463398,
-0.0013733023079112172,
0.026757782325148582,
-0.0030798891093581915,
0.021403254941105843,
0.009802356362342834,
-0.01183785405009985,
-0.020113930106163025,
-0.019176015630364418,
0.020712289959192276,
-0.07952095568180084,
0.004854051396250725,
-0.004304838832467794,
-0.012008084915578365,
0.008099226281046867,
-0.02399892918765545,
-0.001827184809371829,
-0.08664257824420929,
-0.03269866481423378,
0.040830377489328384,
-0.01516690757125616,
-0.04714897274971008,
-0.041654862463474274,
-0.01217556931078434,
0.03058113157749176,
0.05215739086270332,
-0.019928209483623505,
-0.031998030841350555,
-0.03903229907155037,
-0.006554198917001486,
0.029435046017169952,
-0.007378545589745045,
0.007095786742866039,
0.02403648942708969,
-0.04184693098068237,
0.051109131425619125,
-0.048689357936382294,
0.03138045221567154,
0.04949287325143814,
0.008644006215035915,
-0.024554729461669922,
0.004125567153096199,
0.05639424920082092,
0.021023143082857132,
-0.004238322377204895,
0.009835048578679562,
0.010360530577600002,
-0.028950700536370277,
-0.014678004197776318,
-0.0002537715481594205,
0.04024695232510567,
-0.011462641879916191,
-0.03243618085980415,
0.018811194226145744,
0.04272904619574547,
0.01655704528093338,
-0.009740481153130531,
-0.039901915937662125,
-0.027263931930065155,
0.0701347067952156,
-0.009205303154885769,
-0.040947310626506805,
-0.059299666434526443,
-0.04889916256070137,
0.0023531035985797644,
0.019272947683930397,
0.015118168666958809,
-0.04192068800330162,
0.040540821850299835,
-0.014188808389008045,
0.04877995699644089,
-0.009402710013091564,
-0.008015208877623081,
0.035657282918691635,
-0.050265904515981674,
0.007908242754638195,
-0.061333104968070984,
-0.037761054933071136,
0.06641028076410294,
-0.014077436178922653,
0.011043522506952286,
-0.05078640580177307,
-0.03373480215668678,
0.08432808518409729,
-0.0344054140150547,
-0.026396548375487328,
0.014714687131345272,
-0.020601239055395126,
-0.00017691329412627965,
0.041027698665857315,
-0.08366530388593674,
-0.047488223761320114,
-0.0713873878121376,
-0.04397418722510338,
-0.02070402354001999,
-0.017243321985006332,
0.051471274346113205,
-0.017642337828874588,
0.019474133849143982,
-0.0014222533209249377,
0.009422153234481812,
0.005977810826152563,
0.07769417017698288,
0.033740151673555374,
0.023181241005659103,
-0.04120891913771629,
0.08217041939496994,
0.03976389020681381,
0.053287044167518616,
-0.009747917763888836,
0.0037758625112473965,
-0.031385388225317,
-0.05955709517002106,
0.03859363868832588,
-0.03360317274928093,
0.004787340294569731,
-0.016276519745588303,
0.07006749510765076,
0.04003918170928955,
-0.02563454769551754,
-0.05276388302445412,
0.04546307027339935,
-0.05106309801340103,
-0.007011791225522757,
-0.0015265215188264847,
0.009365200996398926,
-0.03256731107831001,
0.046834688633680344,
0.024871116504073143,
0.07323791831731796,
0.07274685055017471,
-0.005333133041858673,
-0.019636977463960648,
0.01828623190522194,
0.04558004066348076,
0.05269385129213333,
0.04369521141052246,
0.056163933128118515,
0.08730971068143845,
-0.0005066353478468955,
-0.03887997195124626,
0.020232222974300385,
0.028454424813389778,
0.0004131867899559438,
-0.02873888611793518,
0.03668402507901192,
0.051904816180467606,
0.029966142028570175,
0.051086969673633575,
-0.045458029955625534,
-0.010426467284560204,
0.05154574289917946,
0.04176786541938782,
0.003376070177182555,
-0.0025260041002184153,
0.03457263857126236,
-0.004246629308909178,
-0.03627488762140274,
-0.032935742288827896,
0.0005970981437712908,
0.0007609953754581511,
0.007250127848237753,
-0.004544984549283981,
-0.027009181678295135,
0.004636553581804037,
0.014186463318765163,
0.05682254582643509,
0.12223836779594421,
-0.050499025732278824,
0.000018177304809796624,
0.012204707600176334,
0.007837231270968914,
-0.006456664297729731,
0.04650649055838585,
0.03166116401553154,
0.008936394937336445,
-0.0026583762373775244,
-0.05632215738296509,
0.00576830143108964,
0.004555830266326666,
0.0077104209922254086,
0.03300359845161438,
-0.0380193330347538,
-0.024136971682310104,
0.028333622962236404,
0.017379529774188995,
-0.06972997635602951,
-0.061228785663843155,
-0.029954593628644943,
-0.02622533030807972,
-0.025168754160404205,
-0.012784835882484913,
0.06133653223514557,
-0.015562557615339756,
-0.021687747910618782,
0.033595338463783264,
-0.005863983649760485,
0.020637335255742073,
0.010148642584681511,
-0.062088824808597565,
0.00850346963852644,
0.006125004030764103,
-0.009849472902715206,
-0.010971501469612122,
0.046504709869623184,
0.038297366350889206,
-0.006785393226891756,
-0.004650068935006857,
0.06741094589233398,
-0.016204100102186203,
0.020187007263302803,
-0.007176241371780634,
-0.007266152184456587,
-0.09855124354362488,
-0.023604050278663635,
0.006920575629919767,
-0.020279889926314354,
-0.06061794236302376,
0.03958510607481003,
-0.027018902823328972,
0.02028825134038925,
0.07204066962003708,
0.02376776561141014,
0.01544452179223299,
-0.04630124196410179,
-0.0018856881652027369,
-0.006966781336814165,
0.042139019817113876,
0.06769833713769913,
-0.016225554049015045,
0.08303384482860565,
0.055291786789894104,
-0.006757870316505432,
-0.05110030621290207,
0.00783368106931448,
-0.01731293648481369,
-0.01070268452167511,
-0.027516787871718407,
-0.01942700892686844,
-0.0187474824488163,
-0.10582586377859116,
0.005999680608510971,
0.05003738030791283,
-0.005265432875603437,
-0.025439610704779625,
-0.009241584688425064,
-0.014139391481876373,
0.017178090289235115,
-0.021069206297397614,
0.007703736890107393,
-0.014975657686591148,
-0.030791273340582848,
-0.0660843774676323,
-0.022000225260853767,
-0.00910240225493908,
-0.01931166462600231,
-0.03208180516958237,
-0.017488325014710426,
-0.03128470480442047,
0.02278810180723667,
-0.0228823721408844,
0.04028714448213577,
-0.016725214198231697,
-0.001720649073831737,
-0.029247714206576347
] |
5 |
Diffusion-Based Planning for Autonomous Driving with Flexible Guidance
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=wM2sfVgMDH
|
[
"Yinan Zheng",
"Ruiming Liang",
"Kexin ZHENG",
"Jinliang Zheng",
"Liyuan Mao",
"Jianxiong Li",
"Weihao Gu",
"Rui Ai",
"Shengbo Eben Li",
"Xianyuan Zhan",
"Jingjing Liu"
] |
Oral
|
Achieving human-like driving behaviors in complex open-world environments is a critical challenge in autonomous driving. Contemporary learning-based planning approaches such as imitation learning methods often struggle to balance competing objectives and lack of safety assurance,due to limited adaptability and inadequacy in learning complex multi-modal behaviors commonly exhibited in human planning, not to mention their strong reliance on the fallback strategy with predefined rules. We propose a novel transformer-based Diffusion Planner for closed-loop planning, which can effectively model multi-modal driving behavior and ensure trajectory quality without any rule-based refinement. Our model supports joint modeling of both prediction and planning tasks under the same architecture, enabling cooperative behaviors between vehicles. Moreover, by learning the gradient of the trajectory score function and employing a flexible classifier guidance mechanism, Diffusion Planner effectively achieves safe and adaptable planning behaviors. Evaluations on the large-scale real-world autonomous planning benchmark nuPlan and our newly collected 200-hour delivery-vehicle driving dataset demonstrate that Diffusion Planner achieves state-of-the-art closed-loop performance with robust transferability in diverse driving styles.
|
diffusion planning, autonomous driving
| null | 13,578 |
2501.15564
|
[
-0.013987475074827671,
-0.03392152115702629,
0.005078543908894062,
0.02392151579260826,
0.05787055566906929,
0.030821382999420166,
0.0024182945489883423,
-0.00959070399403572,
0.011672046966850758,
-0.04782818257808685,
0.0008578276610933244,
0.008070448413491249,
-0.027789438143372536,
0.005387851502746344,
-0.008212700486183167,
0.04782596975564957,
0.014350753277540207,
0.00964980386197567,
-0.030142342671751976,
0.021923821419477463,
0.006640724837779999,
-0.020935967564582825,
0.06973839551210403,
0.03402162343263626,
0.02161332592368126,
-0.01611551269888878,
0.02932053618133068,
0.009017527103424072,
-0.02071830816566944,
-0.01939602755010128,
0.008245797827839851,
0.01719013787806034,
-0.0012888460187241435,
-0.00864595826715231,
-0.01051038783043623,
-0.007439219858497381,
-0.016733435913920403,
-0.036418695002794266,
-0.002108415123075247,
0.0002464636054355651,
-0.04067971557378769,
0.02264472469687462,
-0.0229465551674366,
-0.022426815703511238,
-0.007168697193264961,
-0.01588016003370285,
-0.08441139757633209,
0.030922019854187965,
0.022624807432293892,
-0.06799953430891037,
-0.07126316428184509,
0.009330809116363525,
0.005007691215723753,
0.013110826723277569,
0.003588414750993252,
0.028963454067707062,
0.060675837099552155,
-0.10855860263109207,
0.010070008225739002,
-0.05630718171596527,
-0.017330601811408997,
0.05236811190843582,
-0.002588270464912057,
-0.008123774081468582,
-0.01074864249676466,
-0.003960021771490574,
0.003593559144064784,
0.045082539319992065,
-0.03145262971520424,
-0.03220244497060776,
-0.07114627957344055,
-0.0034973137080669403,
0.004468551836907864,
0.018854685127735138,
-0.012108252383768559,
-0.04018086567521095,
0.018301567062735558,
0.02453877404332161,
0.06559044867753983,
-0.006741577293723822,
0.015131976455450058,
0.009257067926228046,
0.00573124410584569,
0.049879372119903564,
0.009692440740764141,
0.013673350214958191,
-0.04664237052202225,
-0.03759387880563736,
-0.061242736876010895,
0.0334337055683136,
-0.04629044607281685,
-0.04634254425764084,
-0.018365170806646347,
0.029587214812636375,
0.026785483583807945,
-0.017555316910147667,
0.026944691315293312,
0.017201194539666176,
0.008933654986321926,
-0.015305298380553722,
-0.008036887273192406,
-0.024233819916844368,
-0.02195580117404461,
-0.003415811574086547,
-0.08726000040769577,
-0.023111620917916298,
-0.03500818833708763,
0.004589197225868702,
-0.0028652113396674395,
0.0023215883411467075,
-0.06543094664812088,
-0.0007405225769616663,
0.03767397627234459,
-0.01182046253234148,
-0.07830499857664108,
0.029810287058353424,
0.014233925379812717,
0.01398488599807024,
0.04672817513346672,
0.011979368515312672,
0.027500350028276443,
0.01668698899447918,
-0.001454286277294159,
0.053951483219861984,
-0.044206652790308,
0.05816778913140297,
-0.008095074445009232,
0.015604594722390175,
-0.01651446707546711,
-0.01678682491183281,
0.04829224571585655,
0.018639255315065384,
0.0246703140437603,
-0.016375558450818062,
0.013591405004262924,
-0.0220170971006155,
0.00975796114653349,
0.030119501054286957,
0.018762003630399704,
-0.0019920303020626307,
0.002585897920653224,
0.005294390022754669,
0.08030576258897781,
-0.034785084426403046,
0.05237274989485741,
-0.005007119383662939,
-0.013714282773435116,
-0.01002164650708437,
-0.0830787718296051,
-0.014384043402969837,
0.02647809311747551,
-0.00011158560664625838,
-0.018116066232323647,
-0.0538591630756855,
0.02424103021621704,
0.03791891410946846,
0.010028481483459473,
0.0021085264161229134,
-0.010516663081943989,
0.006750652100890875,
0.024845553562045097,
-0.007568847853690386,
-0.024591783061623573,
-0.03587719425559044,
-0.0009064815239980817,
-0.058722272515296936,
0.048277176916599274,
0.03570970147848129,
-0.03966668248176575,
-0.03506791219115257,
-0.03131384402513504,
-0.025339564308524132,
0.043081134557724,
0.012516917660832405,
0.0048017194494605064,
-0.022123944014310837,
0.036586739122867584,
-0.014956038445234299,
0.03255608305335045,
0.031133703887462616,
-0.072107695043087,
0.019153233617544174,
0.033525943756103516,
0.001583267585374415,
-0.00020612050138879567,
-0.019978990778326988,
0.05589839443564415,
-0.010668805800378323,
-0.029452336952090263,
0.031816817820072174,
-0.052709855139255524,
-0.028575003147125244,
0.044304259121418,
-0.015404571779072285,
0.06357120722532272,
0.016290884464979172,
-0.015647096559405327,
0.01813388615846634,
0.020812833681702614,
0.09930260479450226,
0.024502171203494072,
-0.0354582741856575,
0.06859991699457169,
-0.04136824607849121,
0.0064524756744503975,
0.00581197626888752,
0.0599883608520031,
-0.04072558879852295,
-0.03852630406618118,
0.00989783089607954,
-0.017671123147010803,
0.012064865790307522,
0.023375770077109337,
0.024435991421341896,
0.029672756791114807,
-0.004228102508932352,
-0.012070886790752411,
0.03685380145907402,
0.03445189818739891,
-0.04240668937563896,
-0.007399536669254303,
0.03344312310218811,
-0.06633007526397705,
0.0296016875654459,
-0.03334181755781174,
0.07721002399921417,
0.06860300153493881,
-0.026949867606163025,
-0.037260983139276505,
0.02382565662264824,
-0.01602621003985405,
0.02782248705625534,
0.016795137897133827,
-0.022887645289301872,
0.043762970715761185,
-0.036128588020801544,
0.007860381156206131,
-0.03373567759990692,
0.021986309438943863,
-0.034049440175294876,
-0.012505426071584225,
0.05214178189635277,
-0.009541142731904984,
0.07870649546384811,
0.0016816052375361323,
0.034564871340990067,
0.0548270121216774,
-0.014790447428822517,
0.013803637586534023,
0.008534150198101997,
-0.053181275725364685,
0.00914294458925724,
0.05131387710571289,
-0.035178035497665405,
0.0032028257846832275,
-0.0453924722969532,
-0.0030622954946011305,
-0.00916392169892788,
0.0780307874083519,
0.05832628533244133,
0.00597795844078064,
0.030391767621040344,
-0.02021641843020916,
0.021010760217905045,
-0.02710251323878765,
-0.1414404809474945,
-0.03171253949403763,
0.0028653310146182775,
0.012365925125777721,
0.06866399198770523,
0.03952935338020325,
-0.023057512938976288,
0.09442540258169174,
-0.025843879207968712,
-0.025082403793931007,
0.0192133616656065,
-0.00819818489253521,
0.03780781850218773,
-0.007005474530160427,
-0.0048344978131353855,
0.03487425297498703,
0.07192828506231308,
0.011389044113457203,
0.012703542597591877,
-0.013545536436140537,
-0.04470852017402649,
0.014967944473028183,
-0.009999736212193966,
0.011041725985705853,
0.019870039075613022,
0.005720967892557383,
0.013681518845260143,
0.012759651988744736,
0.043696846812963486,
-0.001121161738410592,
0.06349580734968185,
-0.011174189858138561,
0.002029197756201029,
-0.0075698839500546455,
-0.01677553914487362,
-0.011068026535212994,
0.01996963657438755,
-0.01736408658325672,
0.0057976264506578445,
0.004035904537886381,
0.012786307372152805,
0.007414688356220722,
0.007070410531014204,
-0.2377854734659195,
0.002847102703526616,
0.0057679531164467335,
0.001471413066610694,
0.033672209829092026,
0.01046993862837553,
0.04794497415423393,
-0.02512471005320549,
-0.023379648104310036,
0.015686549246311188,
0.007413722109049559,
0.04657391458749771,
0.021801088005304337,
0.061521295458078384,
0.035368483513593674,
0.007154630962759256,
-0.008480657823383808,
-0.04524717852473259,
-0.0057975552044808865,
0.01614503562450409,
-0.013072576373815536,
-0.10590752214193344,
-0.015212375670671463,
0.01678820699453354,
-0.007524759043008089,
0.022091437131166458,
-0.06541913747787476,
-0.01088955532759428,
-0.02690776064991951,
0.008153796195983887,
0.0017970730550587177,
-0.033175598829984665,
-0.014246162958443165,
0.032908957451581955,
0.008853319101035595,
-0.0012054360704496503,
0.03186054900288582,
-0.004528578370809555,
0.044628918170928955,
0.012832309119403362,
-0.001860694494098425,
0.013289781287312508,
-0.04079251363873482,
0.03659512475132942,
0.03957977518439293,
-0.015670962631702423,
-0.058450862765312195,
-0.004146030638366938,
0.027273083105683327,
0.052029114216566086,
0.02004333585500717,
-0.012628372758626938,
-0.013629636727273464,
-0.014700259082019329,
0.02209511399269104,
0.0009390190825797617,
0.024278489872813225,
-0.017153635621070862,
0.01477298978716135,
0.04479474574327469,
-0.005978638771921396,
-0.036753155291080475,
-0.036045726388692856,
-0.04088326543569565,
-0.007993231527507305,
-0.015378628857433796,
-0.028017288073897362,
-0.07614510506391525,
0.011350275948643684,
-0.000501976115629077,
-0.01922474056482315,
-0.01391796488314867,
-0.03523985296487808,
-0.12340039759874344,
0.002911793766543269,
0.007531645242124796,
0.0020126334857195616,
-0.05045956373214722,
-0.012842104770243168,
0.03996105119585991,
-0.039548516273498535,
-0.047215089201927185,
-0.019939256832003593,
0.008558304980397224,
0.008591322228312492,
0.012573983520269394,
0.04266660660505295,
-0.07478199154138565,
0.009513401426374912,
-0.059294797480106354,
0.05075922980904579,
-0.0021687268745154142,
0.029083671048283577,
-0.021664654836058617,
0.04778880253434181,
0.036885038018226624,
0.024187417700886726,
0.07329583168029785,
0.0005964834708720446,
-0.026192069053649902,
0.02153908833861351,
-0.09517824649810791,
-0.020436372607946396,
-0.028544029220938683,
-0.0144230667501688,
0.006571340840309858,
-0.04329188913106918,
-0.016560114920139313,
0.0038869776763021946,
0.028410088270902634,
0.012680057436227798,
-0.003761670319363475,
0.011996743269264698,
-0.008010929450392723,
-0.02565615065395832,
-0.025929179042577744,
-0.011876208707690239,
0.038586392998695374,
0.05907599627971649,
-0.01358765922486782,
-0.05137946084141731,
0.008315486833453178,
-0.05327281728386879,
0.014870903454720974,
0.010125852189958096,
0.014892964623868465,
-0.014453002251684666,
-0.013524387963116169,
0.030372293666005135,
0.01607797108590603,
0.047389186918735504,
0.08091219514608383,
0.007498352322727442,
0.03439512848854065,
0.008843202143907547,
-0.027434322983026505,
-0.03596841171383858,
-0.010700889863073826,
0.01751735620200634,
-0.00803654920309782,
-0.006876535248011351,
0.014446087181568146,
0.03161486238241196,
-0.010155252180993557,
0.02033495344221592,
0.003125896444544196,
0.013669800944626331,
0.015430865809321404,
-0.003050663275644183,
-0.017129255458712578,
0.050113432109355927,
-0.053188029676675797,
-0.038861047476530075,
-0.02965387888252735,
0.022333450615406036,
-0.05655769631266594,
0.024471323937177658,
-0.03747916594147682,
0.018154006451368332,
-0.046816643327474594,
0.033719584345817566,
0.017130518332123756,
-0.0065194834023714066,
0.0012045613257214427,
0.007186965085566044,
0.053036607801914215,
-0.029378829523921013,
-0.016071362420916557,
-0.01113293319940567,
-0.01450272835791111,
0.018017703667283058,
-0.08237019181251526,
-0.09904102236032486,
-0.034365423023700714,
-0.026994260028004646,
-0.006268824450671673,
0.004955426789820194,
-0.05739949271082878,
-0.0491088405251503,
0.03442050516605377,
-0.008108792826533318,
-0.023754026740789413,
-0.018993882462382317,
-0.010458584874868393,
0.06183182820677757,
-0.010926922783255577,
0.008380677551031113,
-0.005253788083791733,
-0.005360630340874195,
0.019628338515758514,
-0.01179370004683733,
0.008260958828032017,
-0.060798801481723785,
-0.04121183231472969,
-0.017188485711812973,
-0.04684286564588547,
0.04484779015183449,
0.005231152288615704,
-0.02283392660319805,
0.023917902261018753,
-0.052798446267843246,
-0.001154591329395771,
-0.018297886475920677,
-0.021355092525482178,
0.02571979910135269,
-0.06370730698108673,
0.01822490058839321,
0.05724146217107773,
-0.0011473314370959997,
0.05529588460922241,
-0.020254680886864662,
-0.03513529151678085,
-0.06494292616844177,
-0.00005117028558743186,
0.002761879237368703,
-0.03525375947356224,
0.004909241106361151,
-0.03483255207538605,
-0.010393393225967884,
0.021734124049544334,
0.036394912749528885,
0.00601531844586134,
-0.03266272693872452,
-0.031237633898854256,
-0.011338370852172375,
0.054655857384204865,
-0.04316331073641777,
-0.011845092289149761,
0.005240124650299549,
-0.019885076209902763,
0.003305379068478942,
-0.04407171159982681,
-0.006842539645731449,
0.024712977930903435,
0.01376104075461626,
-0.005000961013138294,
-0.045270614326000214,
0.03462042659521103,
-0.024308539927005768,
-0.017607983201742172,
0.00002869382660719566,
0.018005220219492912,
-0.037623170763254166,
-0.014821873977780342,
0.010000920854508877,
0.04204527661204338,
0.013224460184574127,
0.0005617357091978192,
0.03569820523262024,
0.027599673718214035,
0.02411399409174919,
0.01039902027696371,
-0.04113638028502464,
0.016734514385461807,
0.05535534769296646,
-0.012453289702534676,
-0.030090993270277977,
-0.06663217395544052,
-0.010787726379930973,
0.03673160448670387,
-0.023021919652819633,
0.03931460902094841,
-0.01534301694482565,
0.01177173387259245,
-0.00007093970634741709,
0.007853692397475243,
-0.03749128058552742,
-0.017840657383203506,
0.027060840278863907,
-0.0868833065032959,
0.05636633187532425,
-0.05604379251599312,
0.02168118767440319,
0.039123840630054474,
-0.05471624433994293,
-0.019613992422819138,
0.027847571298480034,
-0.02825569361448288,
0.040669362992048264,
-0.05016453191637993,
-0.07056386768817902,
0.040378499776124954,
-0.008968566544353962,
-0.0003410224453546107,
0.019619932398200035,
-0.034936223179101944,
0.0009819759288802743,
-0.017403176054358482,
-0.053637195378541946,
0.031002305448055267,
0.030853554606437683,
0.025869295001029968,
-0.0027632873971015215,
0.019829586148262024,
-0.025468239560723305,
0.006904062815010548,
0.04518880695104599,
0.030828149989247322,
-0.013071928173303604,
0.05077793821692467,
-0.03702037036418915,
0.07033837586641312,
0.03025384619832039,
0.053454358130693436,
-0.02283439226448536,
0.013721657916903496,
0.004515573848038912,
-0.0659899041056633,
0.05538075044751167,
-0.004031328950077295,
-0.0074598039500415325,
-0.04268006607890129,
0.050983306020498276,
0.04985497146844864,
-0.07673802226781845,
-0.013485286384820938,
0.00411704508587718,
-0.07063974440097809,
-0.008190616965293884,
0.04332001134753227,
0.026717115193605423,
0.03524892404675484,
0.042973704636096954,
-0.007496439386159182,
0.061598680913448334,
0.04868698492646217,
0.028107091784477234,
-0.015692241489887238,
-0.018002541735768318,
0.07742437720298767,
0.030572306364774704,
0.06927763670682907,
-0.018944956362247467,
0.08174912631511688,
-0.05264289677143097,
-0.053280413150787354,
0.014749761670827866,
0.014553491957485676,
-0.013462184928357601,
-0.06462623924016953,
0.0356534942984581,
0.10727768391370773,
0.012021231465041637,
0.05481962487101555,
-0.022335395216941833,
-0.007355755195021629,
0.03278709948062897,
0.016098780557513237,
-0.0044351681135594845,
0.0072903940454125404,
0.050429828464984894,
0.022986438125371933,
-0.020365159958600998,
0.009860599413514137,
-0.006432543508708477,
-0.028644422069191933,
0.015601779334247112,
0.004441616591066122,
0.0017630759393796325,
0.027869006618857384,
0.005629140883684158,
0.04464920982718468,
0.10063337534666061,
-0.040410906076431274,
0.010243072174489498,
0.006583742797374725,
-0.009772772900760174,
-0.01973888650536537,
0.026632115244865417,
0.02815987728536129,
-0.025860728695988655,
0.01869810000061989,
-0.04706106334924698,
0.005365170072764158,
0.034775398671627045,
0.005708792712539434,
0.03552623093128204,
-0.03026536852121353,
-0.0063496544025838375,
0.015509961172938347,
-0.01928301714360714,
-0.032395943999290466,
-0.03678802773356438,
-0.0359174944460392,
-0.02696976810693741,
-0.05351503938436508,
-0.0582507848739624,
0.053989846259355545,
-0.008504115045070648,
-0.046441152691841125,
-0.018197832629084587,
-0.011466818861663342,
-0.008387148380279541,
-0.004479005932807922,
-0.07811014354228973,
-0.02534329518675804,
0.06392642855644226,
-0.006286610383540392,
-0.010900018736720085,
0.012343158945441246,
0.03557662293314934,
0.03472929820418358,
-0.025402795523405075,
0.010416925884783268,
0.0005630459636449814,
-0.005970312282443047,
-0.027401380240917206,
0.020732056349515915,
-0.06680936366319656,
-0.014014355838298798,
0.02783474326133728,
-0.01509640458971262,
-0.08997780084609985,
0.0321175642311573,
-0.050160001963377,
0.05982207879424095,
0.06710629165172577,
-0.0049132090061903,
0.005867184605449438,
-0.029594600200653076,
-0.005218959413468838,
0.016528908163309097,
-0.016513090580701828,
0.02320535108447075,
-0.05061476677656174,
0.0798703134059906,
0.047862980514764786,
-0.0435742512345314,
-0.016947360709309578,
0.07000183314085007,
0.0011430969461798668,
-0.022424060851335526,
-0.0003625528479460627,
-0.04474565014243126,
-0.0378643162548542,
-0.11724398285150528,
-0.008608286269009113,
0.02504921704530716,
0.0039738137274980545,
-0.012726874090731144,
0.004392213188111782,
0.0016272647771984339,
0.022641249001026154,
0.000463918229797855,
-0.045562636107206345,
-0.008862809278070927,
-0.020413896068930626,
-0.01711956225335598,
-0.05896579101681709,
0.04132187366485596,
-0.05563873052597046,
0.014486914500594139,
-0.029322125017642975,
-0.0461842305958271,
0.015375890769064426,
-0.031419262290000916,
0.03483102098107338,
-0.020652826875448227,
0.016651974990963936,
-0.010481550358235836
] |
6 |
Learning to Search from Demonstration Sequences
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=v593OaNePQ
|
[
"Dixant Mittal",
"Liwei Kang",
"Wee Sun Lee"
] |
Oral
|
Search and planning are essential for solving many real-world problems. However, in numerous learning scenarios, only action-observation sequences, such as demonstrations or instruction sequences, are available for learning. Relying solely on supervised learning with these sequences can lead to sub-optimal performance due to the vast, unseen search space encountered during training. In this paper, we introduce Differentiable Tree Search Network (D-TSN), a novel neural network architecture that learns to construct search trees from just sequences of demonstrations by performing gradient descent on a best-first search tree construction algorithm. D-TSN enables the joint learning of submodules, including an encoder, value function, and world model, which are essential for planning. To construct the search tree, we employ a stochastic tree expansion policy and formulate it as another decision-making task. Then, we optimize the tree expansion policy via REINFORCE with an effective variance reduction technique for the gradient computation. D-TSN can be applied to problems with a known world model or to scenarios where it needs to jointly learn a world model with a latent state space. We study problems from these two scenarios, including Game of 24, 2D grid navigation, and Procgen games, to understand when D-TSN is more helpful. Through our experiments, we show that D-TSN is effective, especially when the world model with a latent state space is jointly learned. The code is available at https://github.com/dixantmittal/differentiable-tree-search-network.
|
planning, reasoning, learning to search, reinforcement learning, large language model
|
We propose a method that constructs search tree in a differetiable manner, and can be trained from just demonstration sequences.
| 13,425 | null |
[
-0.0351773165166378,
-0.0075204200111329556,
-0.026527535170316696,
0.05603007972240448,
0.04224853962659836,
0.021068384870886803,
0.023309456184506416,
0.011441731825470924,
-0.0098927216604352,
-0.027925288304686546,
0.014736250974237919,
-0.014753822237253189,
-0.05829273536801338,
-0.007297732401639223,
0.012617349624633789,
0.05113883689045906,
0.02425997331738472,
-0.014962424524128437,
0.009909731335937977,
0.0036080731078982353,
-0.0326635017991066,
-0.0085444999858737,
0.04928988218307495,
0.039329249411821365,
0.057340774685144424,
0.012539145536720753,
0.023521101102232933,
0.02222713828086853,
-0.015542878769338131,
-0.02322073094546795,
-0.006538047920912504,
-0.039385613054037094,
0.03997432067990303,
-0.039584361016750336,
-0.0213858000934124,
-0.013506063260138035,
-0.06009536609053612,
0.0039933715015649796,
0.01873003877699375,
-0.0026799882762134075,
-0.04955829307436943,
0.005588033702224493,
-0.03535623848438263,
0.022852864116430283,
-0.017206674441695213,
0.04218341410160065,
-0.06877060979604721,
-0.004940567538142204,
0.008660838939249516,
-0.02108561247587204,
-0.10345690697431564,
0.05663001537322998,
0.04203760251402855,
-0.011981779709458351,
-0.02313937433063984,
0.008038398809731007,
0.0726405531167984,
-0.05771533399820328,
0.00031547906110063195,
-0.07313566654920578,
-0.014240624383091927,
0.04728981852531433,
0.037655800580978394,
0.01855788193643093,
0.01179526373744011,
-0.03511833772063255,
0.01573539711534977,
0.07058578729629517,
-0.014970602467656136,
-0.028736203908920288,
-0.06332459300756454,
-0.016328131780028343,
0.019883910194039345,
0.034002646803855896,
0.024246821179986,
-0.019094835966825485,
-0.0010970676084980369,
0.0055271293967962265,
0.06738751381635666,
-0.015078800730407238,
0.029382092878222466,
0.03856359049677849,
0.04601567983627319,
0.010907239280641079,
0.011133821681141853,
0.0336214117705822,
-0.04856259003281593,
-0.024928638711571693,
-0.116517074406147,
0.03196307271718979,
-0.03284011036157608,
-0.057421281933784485,
0.008705629967153072,
0.03667917847633362,
0.017001911997795105,
0.0022864402271807194,
0.029737016186118126,
-0.0021544371265918016,
0.03510928153991699,
-0.012834888882935047,
-0.015006106346845627,
-0.04781423881649971,
0.0013641278492286801,
-0.010031552985310555,
-0.10643907636404037,
-0.038092706352472305,
0.03278461843729019,
0.003985006827861071,
-0.007352454122155905,
0.025085575878620148,
-0.07199039310216904,
-0.0019543159287422895,
0.03828174248337746,
-0.02769102156162262,
-0.06266067177057266,
0.013611690141260624,
0.0007795387064106762,
0.03952045366168022,
-0.002736845286563039,
0.019938074052333832,
0.029792077839374542,
0.008684780448675156,
-0.012603426352143288,
0.060696400701999664,
-0.004844426643103361,
0.005921054631471634,
0.027838043868541718,
0.025661587715148926,
-0.03988928347826004,
-0.04829302430152893,
0.03570947423577309,
0.007990787737071514,
-0.010083373636007309,
0.014981245622038841,
-0.016187531873583794,
-0.03199314698576927,
-0.01874883845448494,
0.00945298746228218,
0.012061262503266335,
-0.0239817276597023,
-0.01988537609577179,
-0.036946382373571396,
0.07621482014656067,
-0.03374877944588661,
0.07149355113506317,
0.00037819569115526974,
0.009215215221047401,
-0.04025604948401451,
-0.05238593369722366,
0.01669200323522091,
-0.0016802328173071146,
-0.036525361239910126,
-0.01686200313270092,
-0.06779629737138748,
-0.0037938023451715708,
0.04841287061572075,
0.030852163210511208,
0.030815672129392624,
-0.012074466794729233,
0.0135260708630085,
0.031851816922426224,
0.019135454669594765,
-0.017613256350159645,
0.005951255559921265,
-0.02710258588194847,
-0.07230363041162491,
0.0396605022251606,
0.04109494015574455,
-0.01774624176323414,
-0.014655286446213722,
-0.029766036197543144,
0.001481696031987667,
0.02152516506612301,
0.007984647527337074,
-0.03222106024622917,
0.014725454151630402,
0.0360112264752388,
-0.015597249381244183,
0.04869602993130684,
-0.012877091765403748,
-0.06711295247077942,
0.02310728281736374,
0.02437387779355049,
-0.02528579719364643,
-0.020676102489233017,
-0.04622187092900276,
0.08872908353805542,
-0.016189277172088623,
0.012339352630078793,
0.027657316997647285,
-0.07566642761230469,
-0.019604600965976715,
-0.002115630079060793,
-0.023936662822961807,
0.057101741433143616,
0.021863065659999847,
-0.013767299242317677,
0.00028157481574453413,
0.01839596964418888,
0.0636214017868042,
0.06407058984041214,
-0.03840654343366623,
0.053680114448070526,
0.013358590193092823,
-0.036577630788087845,
0.0006435614777728915,
0.04430390149354935,
-0.054280586540699005,
-0.0061246780678629875,
0.03569215163588524,
-0.01884421333670616,
0.004910063464194536,
0.003615063615143299,
0.008188748732209206,
0.04039245471358299,
0.03193105757236481,
-0.028866566717624664,
0.010552875697612762,
0.016538113355636597,
-0.04633545130491257,
0.008121966384351254,
-0.005971493199467659,
-0.026305919513106346,
-0.021579140797257423,
-0.03217081353068352,
0.09772300720214844,
0.045559339225292206,
-0.042974311858415604,
-0.007413770537823439,
0.01577131822705269,
-0.010764158330857754,
0.04621385410428047,
0.011655094102025032,
-0.028359027579426765,
0.0559680201113224,
-0.032917384058237076,
0.002508072415366769,
-0.010204543359577656,
0.018965862691402435,
-0.02457350492477417,
-0.0014640402514487505,
0.054648157209157944,
-0.05396372452378273,
0.0529123917222023,
0.000144791672937572,
0.01591648906469345,
0.042239367961883545,
-0.0009548187372274697,
-0.013093044050037861,
-0.018898608162999153,
-0.03359072282910347,
0.003991554491221905,
0.03243409842252731,
-0.005330108571797609,
-0.03329408913850784,
-0.03895734250545502,
-0.04113782197237015,
-0.03811707720160484,
0.07641889154911041,
0.04882010072469711,
0.02356339991092682,
0.03038465976715088,
0.003994176629930735,
0.0017677507130429149,
-0.02578851208090782,
-0.09751179814338684,
-0.03490906208753586,
-0.015365632250905037,
0.03370165824890137,
0.058840904384851456,
0.03769589215517044,
-0.02246149815618992,
0.04304990544915199,
-0.035392701625823975,
-0.06155143678188324,
-0.008097827434539795,
-0.00867029931396246,
0.055749088525772095,
-0.043796248733997345,
-0.053845129907131195,
0.00578257767483592,
0.06507746875286102,
-0.008925444446504116,
-0.023767922073602676,
-0.018009332939982414,
-0.039298295974731445,
-0.015016322955489159,
-0.03970178961753845,
-0.02298758551478386,
0.021509308367967606,
0.0012565552024170756,
0.02302640862762928,
-0.04591648653149605,
0.01820184662938118,
0.05952749773859978,
0.06550654768943787,
0.060713544487953186,
0.00963329803198576,
-0.0011954092187806964,
-0.004891845863312483,
-0.028360098600387573,
0.011574052274227142,
-0.03340986743569374,
0.04132986441254616,
-0.012014878913760185,
0.011120581068098545,
0.026931479573249817,
0.01754574477672577,
-0.2515219449996948,
-0.013725899159908295,
-0.0024759750813245773,
0.015117396600544453,
0.04024536907672882,
-0.011217888444662094,
0.04492805153131485,
-0.03943897783756256,
-0.018054645508527756,
-0.00683049438521266,
-0.012216047383844852,
0.004746411461383104,
0.004126794170588255,
0.06436362117528915,
0.055948931723833084,
0.013730001635849476,
-0.005194221623241901,
-0.023346537724137306,
0.005857529118657112,
0.026347557082772255,
-0.015953313559293747,
-0.061711523681879044,
-0.012086911126971245,
0.00020138506079092622,
0.015205887146294117,
0.059643398970365524,
-0.09293315559625626,
-0.026945341378450394,
-0.02616707608103752,
0.010235730558633804,
-0.027760464698076248,
-0.008671613410115242,
-0.04777916520833969,
0.025350334122776985,
-0.004287976771593094,
0.008054028265178204,
0.04605335369706154,
-0.017581216990947723,
0.03978174924850464,
0.024640103802084923,
-0.012555119581520557,
-0.0012995890574529767,
-0.04116979241371155,
0.04373537003993988,
0.05922815576195717,
-0.008349071256816387,
-0.07071111351251602,
-0.013144186697900295,
-0.012752749025821686,
0.028001779690384865,
0.0252724327147007,
-0.010554822161793709,
0.004826133605092764,
-0.0072377463802695274,
0.03216458112001419,
-0.020824028179049492,
0.01836763322353363,
0.0012095530983060598,
0.012218494899570942,
0.007235291413962841,
-0.002785565797239542,
-0.045549117028713226,
-0.042030639946460724,
-0.021940089762210846,
0.00698968768119812,
-0.01021048054099083,
-0.036595750600099564,
-0.052420876920223236,
0.010908403433859348,
0.019271671772003174,
-0.010656270198523998,
-0.004778270609676838,
-0.038477715104818344,
-0.11187323182821274,
0.014795477502048016,
0.017780726775527,
-0.0074615017510950565,
-0.02597079426050186,
0.0369243361055851,
0.03695055842399597,
-0.007141398265957832,
-0.05183101072907448,
0.016469882801175117,
0.022689424455165863,
0.037273745983839035,
-0.014520831406116486,
0.013436117209494114,
-0.03281167894601822,
-0.0007265584426932037,
-0.03762393817305565,
0.03442458063364029,
0.02048414945602417,
0.04909222573041916,
-0.01599862240254879,
0.052766863256692886,
0.021723778918385506,
0.06109905242919922,
0.02659156173467636,
0.05650775879621506,
-0.0063045513816177845,
0.01058886107057333,
-0.062268100678920746,
-0.014087852090597153,
-0.03258834779262543,
-0.019141387194395065,
0.008484799414873123,
-0.04381496086716652,
-0.01063796691596508,
0.03836464509367943,
0.03619362786412239,
-0.013798907399177551,
-0.05237578600645065,
0.000028194244805490598,
0.005171996541321278,
-0.003486813511699438,
-0.026449717581272125,
-0.005174902267754078,
0.023084493353962898,
0.05375705286860466,
-0.03505541384220123,
-0.03525811806321144,
0.03297131881117821,
-0.03980349749326706,
0.035747986286878586,
0.01329025812447071,
-0.0037020354066044092,
0.002381753409281373,
-0.02590051107108593,
0.009976828470826149,
-0.012861221097409725,
0.056772831827402115,
0.06368935108184814,
-0.00409093638882041,
0.029548155143857002,
0.029841726645827293,
-0.015574771910905838,
-0.00004191797779640183,
0.008066490292549133,
0.060434091836214066,
-0.015772448852658272,
-0.04129868745803833,
0.0014265888603404164,
0.01692483387887478,
0.008098172023892403,
0.015690675005316734,
0.00197824789211154,
0.015285816974937916,
0.02132856659591198,
0.044245414435863495,
-0.006708743050694466,
0.027224330231547356,
-0.08399239927530289,
0.03671655431389809,
-0.0344327948987484,
0.03031489998102188,
-0.056876569986343384,
0.031007757410407066,
-0.04691777005791664,
0.031131314113736153,
-0.05416588485240936,
0.07555416971445084,
-0.010366290807723999,
-0.008970859460532665,
-0.009176794439554214,
0.03719448670744896,
0.0606224499642849,
-0.0178018007427454,
0.012456653639674187,
-0.0001847199018811807,
0.006366434972733259,
0.03565731644630432,
-0.057315751910209656,
-0.04247848689556122,
-0.006656533572822809,
-0.018098780885338783,
-0.006302729714661837,
0.009297974407672882,
-0.026577871292829514,
-0.06023624539375305,
0.035876814275979996,
-0.008382754400372505,
-0.007363064214587212,
-0.02088928036391735,
0.0010805391939356923,
0.07516300678253174,
-0.016847535967826843,
0.00039285156526602805,
0.02394275926053524,
-0.03634452447295189,
0.020346827805042267,
-0.012777634896337986,
0.008089237846434116,
-0.02575051411986351,
-0.05111582204699516,
-0.01794114150106907,
-0.018400950357317924,
-0.00400475412607193,
0.012056700885295868,
-0.036687422543764114,
-0.011184356175363064,
-0.013491286896169186,
0.004104049876332283,
-0.048276498913764954,
-0.014864189550280571,
0.0430782176554203,
-0.05702630430459976,
0.016943037509918213,
0.029797226190567017,
0.025817014276981354,
0.027655620127916336,
-0.04087340086698532,
-0.01900474913418293,
-0.05874428525567055,
-0.043538324534893036,
0.010843703523278236,
-0.020573966205120087,
-0.024044567719101906,
-0.039400357753038406,
0.015336555428802967,
0.010755826719105244,
0.03621193766593933,
-0.002621351508423686,
-0.003494793316349387,
-0.024860510602593422,
-0.014335953630506992,
0.05056224390864372,
-0.025299254804849625,
-0.0213153176009655,
0.016302868723869324,
-0.007416470441967249,
0.0020377435721457005,
-0.035431839525699615,
0.025159355252981186,
0.030636504292488098,
0.006844403222203255,
0.00737591739743948,
-0.05535043403506279,
0.057367850095033646,
-0.018705276772379875,
-0.03718942776322365,
0.011792699806392193,
0.005039882846176624,
-0.03953906148672104,
0.014851463958621025,
0.029959125444293022,
0.016743997111916542,
0.050321418792009354,
-0.017823513597249985,
0.010982305742800236,
0.001733705517835915,
0.02334599383175373,
-0.007376887835562229,
-0.06431927531957626,
0.00348982703872025,
0.04232027009129524,
-0.04908936843276024,
-0.02487083710730076,
-0.0737866461277008,
-0.015273730270564556,
0.05320712551474571,
-0.039083898067474365,
0.029702279716730118,
-0.03729105368256569,
0.022551070898771286,
0.020111218094825745,
0.03387531265616417,
-0.008103885687887669,
-0.028430717065930367,
0.00941077247262001,
-0.08943632990121841,
0.01102626882493496,
-0.061462897807359695,
-0.01253544446080923,
0.07268650829792023,
-0.005619915202260017,
-0.01113160140812397,
0.018507245928049088,
-0.029345432296395302,
0.055673997849226,
0.005401232745498419,
-0.06809071451425552,
0.03596023470163345,
-0.023752203211188316,
0.004624742548912764,
0.015571234747767448,
-0.024848926812410355,
-0.0677531510591507,
0.0034285036381334066,
-0.0324372760951519,
0.013359611853957176,
-0.04477916285395622,
0.024687033146619797,
0.0012104276102036238,
-0.009886179119348526,
-0.005459761247038841,
-0.013019910082221031,
0.02468429133296013,
0.04878783971071243,
0.03063483163714409,
0.039277173578739166,
-0.03355677053332329,
0.04524625465273857,
0.06947919726371765,
0.010418730787932873,
0.008824669755995274,
0.009819849394261837,
-0.015371480025351048,
-0.04647740349173546,
0.02895868755877018,
0.01553648617118597,
-0.010055264458060265,
-0.05936029925942421,
0.05030643567442894,
0.0018316395580768585,
-0.06010331213474274,
0.022775862365961075,
0.0011988902697339654,
-0.09461230784654617,
-0.01906527951359749,
-0.007903015241026878,
0.027162602171301842,
0.006013559643179178,
0.07391344010829926,
0.03834402188658714,
0.04323370009660721,
0.06557904928922653,
0.033767495304346085,
-0.048210229724645615,
-0.023536408320069313,
0.07092731446027756,
0.05787891149520874,
0.048552386462688446,
-0.007975813001394272,
0.06797255575656891,
-0.059124141931533813,
-0.041260868310928345,
0.04410657659173012,
0.004201981239020824,
-0.015755489468574524,
-0.042836904525756836,
0.012606845237314701,
0.06303722411394119,
-0.003021314274519682,
0.05854836478829384,
-0.03884667903184891,
-0.0009886844782158732,
0.05412394180893898,
0.013407597318291664,
-0.009763226844370365,
0.03317911922931671,
0.02883896231651306,
0.01577645167708397,
-0.0013060768833383918,
-0.00484841875731945,
-0.008380109444260597,
-0.0284931268543005,
0.002894603181630373,
-0.0037870288360863924,
-0.0012295936467126012,
-0.014833992347121239,
0.04304365813732147,
0.022979777306318283,
0.10401985049247742,
-0.06475373357534409,
-0.02534470148384571,
-0.0031286966986954212,
0.010860726237297058,
0.02883094735443592,
0.046845365315675735,
0.008990706875920296,
0.0164128877222538,
0.006964396685361862,
-0.05260265991091728,
0.026612231507897377,
0.02554839663207531,
-0.0075669074431061745,
0.006804247386753559,
-0.037968218326568604,
-0.00846037920564413,
0.008855723775923252,
0.023395953699946404,
-0.006611084099858999,
-0.05383476987481117,
-0.03168906271457672,
-0.047185178846120834,
-0.05043480172753334,
-0.05775218829512596,
0.01963713951408863,
0.003053048625588417,
-0.02890988625586033,
-0.008481353521347046,
-0.023184949532151222,
0.03350799158215523,
-0.0008808114798739552,
-0.057838961482048035,
0.007888851687312126,
0.02921428345143795,
0.01103163417428732,
0.03904614597558975,
0.03289051726460457,
0.0158726517111063,
-0.046546973288059235,
-0.003058338537812233,
-0.0017033562762662768,
0.027043646201491356,
0.015526230446994305,
-0.03100312128663063,
0.007709216326475143,
-0.0769241526722908,
0.028772132471203804,
0.015921682119369507,
-0.012177349999547005,
-0.05893034115433693,
0.007024658843874931,
-0.054732926189899445,
0.040117595344781876,
0.07554879039525986,
0.0147401113063097,
0.006041421554982662,
-0.04347357526421547,
0.0000207950815820368,
0.005022050812840462,
-0.004170115105807781,
0.04362661391496658,
-0.04231581091880798,
0.04931052774190903,
0.05150559917092323,
-0.023131906986236572,
-0.052073221653699875,
0.02448277920484543,
0.020812824368476868,
-0.02747747115790844,
-0.007153247948735952,
-0.03319385647773743,
-0.023968862369656563,
-0.10860870033502579,
-0.007229137700051069,
0.029221700504422188,
0.03632805496454239,
-0.05552443116903305,
-0.024116598069667816,
0.007918440736830235,
0.005922123324126005,
0.01022828184068203,
-0.02796945534646511,
-0.01202709972858429,
-0.02306005172431469,
-0.024120237678289413,
-0.049135372042655945,
0.036497365683317184,
-0.036400940269231796,
0.012417883612215519,
-0.028575655072927475,
-0.05380578339099884,
-0.017011456191539764,
-0.013472768478095531,
0.0387248620390892,
0.02125232107937336,
0.003584168618544936,
-0.03104693815112114
] |
7 |
Measuring and Enhancing Trustworthiness of LLMs in RAG through Grounded Attributions and Learning to Refuse
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=Iyrtb9EJBp
|
[
"Maojia Song",
"Shang Hong Sim",
"Rishabh Bhardwaj",
"Hai Leong Chieu",
"Navonil Majumder",
"Soujanya Poria"
] |
Oral
|
LLMs are an integral component of retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems. While many studies focus on evaluating the overall quality of end-to-end RAG systems, there is a gap in understanding the appropriateness of LLMs for the RAG task. To address this, we introduce Trust-Score, a holistic metric that evaluates the trustworthiness of LLMs within the RAG framework. Our results show that various prompting methods, such as in-context learning, fail to effectively adapt LLMs to the RAG task as measured by Trust-Score. Consequently, we propose Trust-Align, a method to align LLMs for improved Trust-Score performance. 26 out of 27 models aligned using Trust-Align substantially outperform competitive baselines on ASQA, QAMPARI, and ELI5. Specifically, in LLaMA-3-8b, Trust-Align outperforms FRONT on ASQA (↑12.56), QAMPARI (↑36.04), and ELI5 (↑17.69). Trust-Align also significantly enhances models’ ability to correctly refuse and provide quality citations. We also demonstrate the effectiveness of Trust-Align across different open-weight models, including the LLaMA series (1b to 8b), Qwen-2.5 series (0.5b to 7b), and Phi3.5 (3.8b). We release our code at https://github.com/declare-lab/trust-align.
|
Large Language Models, Trustworthiness, Hallucinations, Retrieval Augmented Generation
|
How to better evaluate and make LLM better for RAG task
| 13,377 |
2409.11242
|
[
0.022029131650924683,
-0.02131049521267414,
-0.007334582507610321,
0.0510173961520195,
0.040801871567964554,
-0.01915552467107773,
0.01961986906826496,
-0.0009685529512353241,
-0.0052784704603254795,
-0.019884465262293816,
-0.04627111926674843,
0.05479709804058075,
-0.07440562546253204,
-0.0013662700075656176,
-0.004465228877961636,
0.05651625618338585,
0.021585211157798767,
0.03177467733621597,
0.0140167735517025,
-0.0297064408659935,
-0.014482605271041393,
-0.034226588904857635,
-0.0022861137986183167,
0.001817739917896688,
0.051461361348629,
0.03195686265826225,
0.04828416556119919,
-0.02564416453242302,
-0.05093706399202347,
-0.0005651342798955739,
0.06378264725208282,
-0.020887430757284164,
0.01747477427124977,
-0.00581568107008934,
0.01764371432363987,
0.002801977563649416,
-0.06828375905752182,
0.030792929232120514,
0.024775246158242226,
-0.003973540384322405,
-0.007776525802910328,
-0.0012272298336029053,
-0.0027523350436240435,
0.022026870399713516,
-0.0467044860124588,
-0.010976668447256088,
-0.09586763381958008,
0.037252891808748245,
0.02360563911497593,
-0.016130462288856506,
-0.10358806699514389,
0.06088121235370636,
-0.012669443152844906,
0.011387182399630547,
0.004119689576327801,
0.022389892488718033,
0.06045618653297424,
-0.07792224735021591,
0.018055126070976257,
-0.006564237643033266,
-0.06759314239025116,
0.015996139496564865,
0.03646012023091316,
0.007077095564454794,
0.024393031373620033,
-0.026205305010080338,
0.013942347839474678,
-0.007961641065776348,
-0.07250150293111801,
-0.03460843488574028,
0.0089161591604352,
0.022192498669028282,
-0.0321810208261013,
-0.029778430238366127,
-0.022931404411792755,
-0.0664849579334259,
0.035111211240291595,
0.013897845521569252,
0.06285177916288376,
-0.013956479728221893,
-0.013917835429310799,
0.01746704988181591,
0.008118171244859695,
0.044459301978349686,
0.022850975394248962,
-0.009451130405068398,
-0.03862053155899048,
-0.027754303067922592,
-0.04987050220370293,
0.04091827943921089,
0.00945628434419632,
-0.043390605598688126,
0.04102722182869911,
0.025932008400559425,
0.015413690358400345,
-0.028816083446145058,
0.044274356216192245,
0.030753126367926598,
-0.010653835721313953,
-0.025851598009467125,
-0.016891932114958763,
-0.01593228429555893,
0.0272150170058012,
-0.0009004460298456252,
-0.10574664175510406,
0.020664742216467857,
-0.032540399581193924,
-0.021357353776693344,
-0.034953050315380096,
-0.022984223440289497,
-0.013647823594510555,
0.018513871356844902,
0.03160591796040535,
0.020028792321681976,
-0.053921815007925034,
0.005797816440463066,
-0.0015795662766322494,
-0.000002796108219627058,
-0.02462552860379219,
0.05664262920618057,
0.042881861329078674,
0.05719457566738129,
0.017406435683369637,
0.05704384297132492,
-0.03374546021223068,
0.033296700567007065,
0.01262043695896864,
0.04380148649215698,
-0.04482945799827576,
-0.011023206636309624,
0.025317316874861717,
0.026152541860938072,
-0.0029438051860779524,
0.012108846567571163,
-0.049683984369039536,
0.007852403447031975,
0.014733107760548592,
0.017779340967535973,
0.059885188937187195,
0.00875855889171362,
0.014172086492180824,
-0.03796430304646492,
0.01834147609770298,
-0.002056647092103958,
0.07514967769384384,
-0.026787422597408295,
-0.02012087032198906,
-0.03570026159286499,
-0.026930751278996468,
0.002378724282607436,
0.03420405834913254,
-0.003951949533075094,
-0.008993739262223244,
-0.08618483692407608,
0.011593079194426537,
0.08064886182546616,
0.01962079480290413,
-0.0018866931786760688,
0.017382647842168808,
-0.002585150534287095,
-0.012441960163414478,
-0.01806294173002243,
-0.08120184391736984,
0.032494399696588516,
-0.015348916873335838,
-0.027611631900072098,
0.006928723771125078,
0.004673320334404707,
-0.027287684381008148,
-0.0076420786790549755,
-0.04797569289803505,
-0.03456494212150574,
0.03809738904237747,
-0.021533353254199028,
-0.029079200699925423,
0.02300889976322651,
0.052154213190078735,
0.011733656749129295,
0.040932413190603256,
0.04441409185528755,
-0.0683925673365593,
0.0372973307967186,
0.013138565234839916,
-0.023925717920064926,
0.027034152299165726,
0.021435195580124855,
0.09553541243076324,
-0.014703284949064255,
0.026459069922566414,
0.03914007171988487,
-0.1018158569931984,
0.021236425265669823,
0.022886304184794426,
-0.01338314451277256,
0.05868573486804962,
0.0033465572632849216,
0.017684219405055046,
0.09926184266805649,
0.0168574508279562,
0.041259318590164185,
0.033988334238529205,
-0.006006335839629173,
0.044658590108156204,
-0.03858473524451256,
-0.03394142538309097,
0.0055022574961185455,
0.036031439900398254,
-0.04157249256968498,
-0.04764953628182411,
0.027236979454755783,
-0.049594443291425705,
0.035999596118927,
-0.000588203314691782,
0.030396858230233192,
-0.0039512780494987965,
0.022671403363347054,
0.006732278969138861,
-0.007473990321159363,
0.03215087577700615,
-0.0487675741314888,
0.052303679287433624,
0.01799636520445347,
0.013219070620834827,
0.01533401757478714,
-0.030474986881017685,
0.09513159841299057,
0.0675976350903511,
-0.032166849821805954,
-0.026451006531715393,
0.03261367604136467,
-0.011809112504124641,
-0.019430212676525116,
0.033773332834243774,
-0.03720654174685478,
-0.028215257450938225,
-0.04020187631249428,
0.021895669400691986,
-0.04140924662351608,
0.04973386600613594,
-0.019584249705076218,
-0.008250921964645386,
0.061598554253578186,
-0.019789231941103935,
0.050437700003385544,
0.030841365456581116,
-0.0019332915544509888,
0.0077712759375572205,
-0.015265659429132938,
0.007958218455314636,
-0.005186687223613262,
-0.001186903566122055,
-0.011546856723725796,
0.009475229308009148,
-0.04114088416099548,
0.037402037531137466,
-0.05425451695919037,
-0.016476573422551155,
-0.004864122252911329,
0.01619388908147812,
0.06238033249974251,
0.018461236730217934,
0.02781068906188011,
0.013106119818985462,
-0.05345616489648819,
0.00015920860460028052,
-0.07964479923248291,
-0.054981403052806854,
0.002298135543242097,
-0.010732745751738548,
0.008080092258751392,
0.042161036282777786,
-0.010896842926740646,
0.02086694911122322,
-0.012565083801746368,
-0.010322421789169312,
0.015042377635836601,
0.045026108622550964,
0.01533554494380951,
-0.01790338009595871,
-0.020817875862121582,
-0.01906035654246807,
0.03430383652448654,
-0.024007661268115044,
-0.033810097724199295,
-0.009302912279963493,
-0.03490652143955231,
0.004469741135835648,
-0.05623069778084755,
-0.011940250173211098,
-0.007523108273744583,
-0.009857944212853909,
0.026355303823947906,
0.01127465907484293,
0.030002547428011894,
0.023378612473607063,
0.0266885869204998,
0.037981823086738586,
0.019664427265524864,
0.002318080747500062,
0.04578171297907829,
-0.008074721321463585,
-0.002396267605945468,
0.037969548255205154,
0.024006079882383347,
0.029060859233140945,
-0.031091833487153053,
-0.03412381559610367,
-0.010029413737356663,
-0.27020034193992615,
0.00439672265201807,
0.02378680184483528,
-0.012051294557750225,
0.037742726504802704,
-0.002835499355569482,
0.0573214553296566,
-0.03841101750731468,
-0.02750093676149845,
-0.01106956321746111,
0.029940245673060417,
0.048504095524549484,
0.02667435072362423,
0.03742784261703491,
0.02688426896929741,
0.03834669291973114,
0.03490340709686279,
-0.04619208350777626,
0.03277309238910675,
0.0040070666000247,
-0.03037564642727375,
-0.05854986235499382,
-0.04216533526778221,
0.03605490177869797,
-0.012177860364317894,
0.045527443289756775,
-0.02063187211751938,
-0.012860093265771866,
-0.04541512578725815,
-0.00858828704804182,
0.008980361744761467,
-0.011942857876420021,
-0.02601774036884308,
0.03866633400321007,
-0.004328651819378138,
-0.009382905438542366,
0.05845284089446068,
0.011312375776469707,
-0.01901361346244812,
-0.011436552740633488,
0.040649473667144775,
-0.011412831023335457,
-0.016455387696623802,
0.014339874498546124,
0.056705180555582047,
0.014829699881374836,
-0.0623406283557415,
-0.050788648426532745,
0.005112580489367247,
0.03811078891158104,
-0.04158340394496918,
-0.03021356463432312,
-0.036544471979141235,
0.012528507970273495,
-0.014879834838211536,
-0.048333898186683655,
-0.010257992893457413,
-0.024282587692141533,
-0.039112191647291183,
-0.004896244034171104,
-0.02885855920612812,
-0.023663261905312538,
-0.008709678426384926,
-0.04362594336271286,
-0.055682290345430374,
-0.012111993506550789,
-0.061161674559116364,
-0.08491657674312592,
0.03269057348370552,
0.06424252688884735,
-0.032126929610967636,
0.021408414468169212,
-0.0175529345870018,
-0.09077323973178864,
0.004862374160438776,
-0.029997849836945534,
-0.02084551937878132,
0.005665245931595564,
-0.0022716897074133158,
0.033728428184986115,
-0.04506915435194969,
-0.03802329674363136,
-0.011781721375882626,
0.02408798225224018,
-0.008522996678948402,
-0.0012424158630892634,
0.027338417246937752,
-0.00958985649049282,
-0.03156226873397827,
-0.04203765466809273,
0.05370582267642021,
0.013985526748001575,
-0.034503646194934845,
0.022785479202866554,
0.06484457850456238,
0.004693577531725168,
0.01746886596083641,
0.04887263849377632,
0.048863064497709274,
0.04691460728645325,
0.03680652007460594,
-0.06162739172577858,
0.026355832815170288,
-0.0337648019194603,
-0.006015231367200613,
0.019581452012062073,
-0.050570230931043625,
-0.025078371167182922,
0.02612689696252346,
-0.01280443836003542,
-0.0435548834502697,
-0.012288603000342846,
0.0007787903887219727,
-0.004108893685042858,
-0.03533341363072395,
-0.02790142223238945,
0.023071400821208954,
0.02813452109694481,
0.0028665950521826744,
-0.019158370792865753,
0.0028531961143016815,
0.001347256824374199,
-0.0024005065206438303,
-0.013834288343787193,
-0.019865991547703743,
-0.02129143849015236,
-0.0037563012447208166,
-0.02241409569978714,
0.0071905069053173065,
-0.034746624529361725,
0.01978384330868721,
0.021005116403102875,
0.026500899344682693,
0.024919522926211357,
0.051159076392650604,
-0.010479448363184929,
0.014995907433331013,
0.014390311203897,
0.03333955630660057,
-0.04027658700942993,
0.012127337045967579,
-0.039144404232501984,
0.019673556089401245,
0.042874567210674286,
0.05449105054140091,
-0.029847266152501106,
0.023805761709809303,
-0.016130974516272545,
-0.015167005360126495,
0.015062452293932438,
0.03353380784392357,
-0.028480028733611107,
0.03185456246137619,
-0.03775320202112198,
0.043283089995384216,
0.00030603320919908583,
0.0029939557425677776,
0.009757038205862045,
0.007784496061503887,
-0.06796389073133469,
0.01785832643508911,
0.004724712111055851,
-0.014311524108052254,
0.0015216503525152802,
0.020607322454452515,
0.014821299351751804,
-0.041603539139032364,
0.01600697450339794,
0.0220550075173378,
0.03443117067217827,
0.00661266827955842,
-0.012573444284498692,
0.005311125889420509,
-0.021618762984871864,
-0.06476715952157974,
0.015822041779756546,
0.02457420714199543,
0.006318930070847273,
-0.033908139914274216,
0.039819665253162384,
-0.03025720827281475,
-0.022971317172050476,
0.005317776929587126,
0.022922111675143242,
0.06779628247022629,
-0.008022240363061428,
0.009543262422084808,
-0.01449592225253582,
-0.05127297714352608,
0.015236083418130875,
0.001008305000141263,
-0.01882978342473507,
0.0252537839114666,
-0.02762194350361824,
-0.03037211112678051,
-0.07665570825338364,
0.016331668943166733,
-0.011255096644163132,
0.005028523504734039,
-0.003451381577178836,
-0.03696964308619499,
0.010673106648027897,
-0.07033701986074448,
-0.0332532599568367,
0.005088496021926403,
-0.08968441933393478,
0.015264207497239113,
-0.00849868543446064,
-0.02059928886592388,
0.006552159786224365,
-0.029494214802980423,
-0.07294008880853653,
-0.03435850143432617,
0.008616505190730095,
0.0343664214015007,
-0.05451120436191559,
-0.055357515811920166,
-0.03458765894174576,
0.008848506957292557,
0.00769137404859066,
0.025173718109726906,
-0.014582370407879353,
0.0011569386115297675,
0.018493182957172394,
0.010418872348964214,
0.04088559374213219,
-0.02813708409667015,
-0.027781859040260315,
-0.028120242059230804,
-0.06624086946249008,
0.014988888055086136,
-0.06303474307060242,
0.04517965391278267,
0.02919365093111992,
-0.016091447323560715,
0.031153179705142975,
-0.06533295661211014,
0.012788374908268452,
-0.005989280994981527,
-0.01607418619096279,
-0.007079819682985544,
-0.023352865129709244,
-0.01839505136013031,
0.012049969285726547,
0.006016709376126528,
0.015672706067562103,
0.004322357941418886,
0.025761311873793602,
-0.007071493659168482,
0.03440067917108536,
0.04843386635184288,
0.019608931615948677,
-0.024415986612439156,
0.012565086595714092,
0.06558520346879959,
-0.03870886564254761,
-0.017690308392047882,
-0.09377876669168472,
-0.029444443061947823,
-0.0033269175328314304,
0.037766627967357635,
0.038705699145793915,
-0.030383504927158356,
0.02832762338221073,
-0.0008024738053791225,
0.04441990330815315,
0.03119630366563797,
-0.017462410032749176,
0.03786616399884224,
-0.034591395407915115,
-0.04041224718093872,
-0.03862883523106575,
0.010166274383664131,
0.05851511284708977,
-0.04298269376158714,
-0.03178013488650322,
-0.011510947719216347,
-0.04868457093834877,
0.040151197463274,
0.0020603889133781195,
-0.04990655928850174,
0.00025963725056499243,
-0.03666882589459419,
-0.002810833975672722,
0.044765178114175797,
-0.03322092443704605,
0.003228358458727598,
0.003141901222988963,
-0.03528547286987305,
0.002411351539194584,
-0.02178514562547207,
0.06796519458293915,
-0.006155085749924183,
0.0037723106797784567,
-0.03451422601938248,
-0.004872818011790514,
0.03388369455933571,
0.06199071183800697,
0.004972534254193306,
0.018079575151205063,
-0.02955274097621441,
0.07008945941925049,
0.03939235210418701,
-0.003196915378794074,
0.05884503200650215,
0.014182749204337597,
-0.025063375011086464,
-0.05451854690909386,
0.074345663189888,
-0.030375413596630096,
-0.02597554214298725,
-0.0477907694876194,
0.08331826329231262,
0.05206212401390076,
-0.07061558961868286,
-0.035080116242170334,
0.005116433836519718,
-0.035846859216690063,
-0.003168812021613121,
-0.004943692125380039,
-0.0013673397479578853,
-0.0059030745178461075,
0.06387268751859665,
0.014847814105451107,
0.06560523062944412,
0.05157545953989029,
-0.004229108802974224,
-0.0033252877183258533,
0.062131643295288086,
0.040815651416778564,
0.06658564507961273,
0.06380762904882431,
0.0026214104145765305,
0.06815227121114731,
0.015833668410778046,
-0.06546858698129654,
-0.004213515669107437,
-0.004967107903212309,
-0.00009970833343686536,
-0.017109114676713943,
-0.019378069788217545,
0.04025084897875786,
0.0018030076753348112,
0.05656987801194191,
-0.05143117159605026,
-0.01628144271671772,
0.043865371495485306,
0.003242078237235546,
0.032312892377376556,
0.020631590858101845,
-0.01097453199326992,
-0.011796641163527966,
-0.05967865139245987,
-0.016194263473153114,
0.03448539599776268,
-0.009773435071110725,
0.027088552713394165,
0.0012487585190683603,
-0.021885260939598083,
0.028920235112309456,
-0.055383071303367615,
0.03509123995900154,
0.10737729072570801,
-0.017617905512452126,
-0.032659001648426056,
0.00791904516518116,
0.015257545746862888,
0.014324212446808815,
0.01873725838959217,
0.02492159977555275,
-0.005211094859987497,
-0.01365293376147747,
-0.06644105911254883,
0.03758809715509415,
0.05257374048233032,
0.012530590407550335,
0.021567070856690407,
-0.005761722102761269,
-0.034545667469501495,
0.03764113411307335,
0.022206494584679604,
-0.051959358155727386,
-0.0002894237113650888,
-0.01723618060350418,
-0.028907151892781258,
-0.042291827499866486,
-0.033847030252218246,
0.012834185734391212,
0.04774855822324753,
-0.0468159019947052,
0.023611687123775482,
-0.020278776064515114,
0.0037662633694708347,
0.008361359126865864,
-0.07078532129526138,
0.020132286474108696,
0.016843466088175774,
0.027661478146910667,
-0.014588173478841782,
0.02140498347580433,
0.01930726133286953,
-0.017933843657374382,
-0.028375321999192238,
0.042250245809555054,
0.004648552741855383,
0.0147939408197999,
-0.015832817181944847,
-0.022323155775666237,
-0.0925711989402771,
0.013178990222513676,
0.0027420027181506157,
-0.022665299475193024,
-0.0852249339222908,
0.016234781593084335,
-0.04842590540647507,
-0.01204071193933487,
0.06800423562526703,
0.034506142139434814,
0.024178043007850647,
-0.011473890393972397,
-0.011100275442004204,
0.010284439660608768,
0.044236920773983,
0.06327112764120102,
-0.012639530934393406,
0.05971754342317581,
-0.004303011577576399,
-0.0014481715625151992,
-0.060003723949193954,
0.026204651221632957,
0.016838572919368744,
-0.020847834646701813,
-0.01745929941534996,
-0.023038947954773903,
-0.039704494178295135,
-0.09258914738893509,
-0.03279947116971016,
0.0016298206755891442,
-0.030834533274173737,
-0.017666464671492577,
-0.006370139308273792,
-0.012897691689431667,
-0.030723033472895622,
-0.027803117409348488,
0.0028990665450692177,
-0.0035838009789586067,
-0.02451685257256031,
0.0017938049277290702,
-0.055421750992536545,
0.017769871279597282,
-0.004297623876482248,
-0.025532471016049385,
0.016824442893266678,
-0.05838772654533386,
0.01751662790775299,
-0.01907741278409958,
0.01871735416352749,
0.01130733359605074,
0.04129829630255699,
-0.02935013175010681
] |
8 |
MAP: Multi-Human-Value Alignment Palette
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=NN6QHwgRrQ
|
[
"Xinran Wang",
"Qi Le",
"Ammar Ahmed",
"Enmao Diao",
"Yi Zhou",
"Nathalie Baracaldo",
"Jie Ding",
"Ali Anwar"
] |
Oral
|
Ensuring that generative AI systems align with human values is essential but challenging, especially when considering multiple human values and their potential trade-offs. Since human values can be personalized and dynamically change over time, the desirable levels of value alignment vary across different ethnic groups, industry sectors, and user cohorts. Within existing frameworks, it is hard to define human values and align AI systems accordingly across different directions simultaneously, such as harmlessness, helpfulness, and positiveness. To address this, we develop a novel, first-principle approach called Multi-Human-Value Alignment Palette (MAP), which navigates the alignment across multiple human values in a structured and reliable way. MAP formulates the alignment problem as an optimization task with user-defined constraints, which define human value targets. It can be efficiently solved via a primal-dual approach, which determines whether a user-defined alignment target is achievable and how to achieve it. We conduct a detailed theoretical analysis of MAP by quantifying the trade-offs between values, the sensitivity to constraints, the fundamental connection between multi-value alignment and sequential alignment, and proving that linear weighted rewards are sufficient for multi-value alignment. Extensive experiments demonstrate MAP's ability to align multiple values in a principled manner while delivering strong empirical performance across various tasks.
|
Human value alignment, Generative model
|
The paper introduces Multi-Human-Value Alignment Palette (MAP), a novel approach to align generative models with multiple human values in a principled way.
| 13,248 |
2410.19198
|
[
-0.011101456359028816,
-0.004345667082816362,
-0.024158900603652,
0.034977853298187256,
0.035846807062625885,
0.055055536329746246,
0.01409035176038742,
0.02160101756453514,
-0.009722994640469551,
-0.07199124246835709,
-0.05136179178953171,
0.01456049270927906,
-0.0845523551106453,
-0.030665596947073936,
-0.024614978581666946,
0.021364929154515266,
0.0234844833612442,
-0.016701165586709976,
-0.021257175132632256,
-0.02075798064470291,
-0.033659420907497406,
-0.024990255013108253,
0.022145753726363182,
0.019079625606536865,
0.025864960625767708,
0.026533378288149834,
0.02560383453965187,
-0.009361183270812035,
-0.007996993139386177,
0.03054690547287464,
0.01924927718937397,
-0.005386113654822111,
0.004194916225969791,
-0.02723311446607113,
-0.03992297872900963,
-0.02966770902276039,
-0.028810063377022743,
0.020652467384934425,
0.014295478351414204,
0.016394345089793205,
-0.019457858055830002,
0.027117498219013214,
0.01980876736342907,
0.019867869094014168,
-0.018522808328270912,
-0.0039272247813642025,
-0.11182421445846558,
0.057851120829582214,
0.016029685735702515,
-0.017383139580488205,
-0.07057777792215347,
0.008902044966816902,
0.014586715959012508,
0.0013221787521615624,
0.01859918050467968,
0.05474138632416725,
0.05060626566410065,
-0.07561852782964706,
-0.02846568450331688,
-0.05111033841967583,
-0.02967538684606552,
0.032727908343076706,
0.017840171232819557,
0.01989218033850193,
-0.008771255612373352,
0.00016776421398390085,
-0.02046108990907669,
0.02413073368370533,
-0.03789577633142471,
-0.03652143478393555,
-0.022951539605855942,
0.000645304680801928,
0.018748948350548744,
-0.008047837764024734,
-0.004308497533202171,
-0.067776620388031,
0.015061881393194199,
0.02093900367617607,
0.037271760404109955,
-0.010569892823696136,
-0.0032214410603046417,
0.023043682798743248,
0.010059722699224949,
0.06687111407518387,
0.0331910066306591,
0.02221832238137722,
-0.004372305702418089,
-0.02906819060444832,
-0.07272616773843765,
0.035509075969457626,
-0.014974447898566723,
-0.06064056232571602,
0.01948699913918972,
0.05111971125006676,
0.025275858119130135,
0.0203184112906456,
0.02417735382914543,
0.00009190670971293002,
-0.03218436986207962,
-0.010813325643539429,
-0.008110122755169868,
-0.0217154361307621,
0.007646949961781502,
0.007656973786652088,
-0.09025419503450394,
-0.044070784002542496,
-0.008088313043117523,
-0.03053804114460945,
0.02073867805302143,
0.015240989625453949,
-0.07599686831235886,
-0.010866142809391022,
0.05160221457481384,
-0.003005103673785925,
-0.05839531868696213,
0.03316393867135048,
-0.01633821427822113,
0.027419038116931915,
0.008809281513094902,
0.06301611661911011,
0.05769553780555725,
0.04146797955036163,
-0.024938829243183136,
0.07112638652324677,
-0.0430261455476284,
-0.01238914392888546,
0.017418548464775085,
0.023575572296977043,
-0.0253229308873415,
-0.02540380135178566,
-0.003074686275795102,
0.026755323633551598,
-0.00488519249483943,
-0.016493503004312515,
-0.007481220178306103,
-0.0059783849865198135,
0.05145127698779106,
0.005441844463348389,
0.05369489639997482,
-0.00301550910808146,
-0.00012529459490906447,
-0.043481964617967606,
0.0932682603597641,
-0.027547800913453102,
0.07563525438308716,
-0.0020174875389784575,
-0.010068495757877827,
0.0046605817042291164,
-0.038047950714826584,
0.005248686298727989,
-0.0181233212351799,
0.0037274679634720087,
0.0414244681596756,
-0.022469885647296906,
0.03343682736158371,
0.07335681468248367,
0.035987816751003265,
0.004721716977655888,
0.016941234469413757,
0.02832707203924656,
-0.01580023765563965,
-0.008602018468081951,
-0.059179794043302536,
-0.010040801018476486,
0.0003543630300555378,
-0.03591321036219597,
0.04764939472079277,
0.02606573887169361,
-0.03235870227217674,
-0.03005363419651985,
-0.021779771894216537,
-0.031693730503320694,
0.04070955887436867,
0.001697402447462082,
0.010080705396831036,
0.004233976826071739,
0.06227920949459076,
-0.004336710087954998,
0.0306745246052742,
0.009324233047664165,
-0.07060432434082031,
0.022616544738411903,
0.00956028513610363,
-0.020173612982034683,
0.04388352483510971,
-0.005169779993593693,
0.03039242886006832,
-0.017452336847782135,
0.0007950477884151042,
0.04975900799036026,
-0.06323906779289246,
-0.0369475893676281,
0.022091638296842575,
-0.01943287067115307,
0.07127577811479568,
-0.00007844856008887291,
-0.034035682678222656,
0.06394223123788834,
0.024318069219589233,
0.056387580931186676,
0.030327366665005684,
-0.03182506933808327,
0.05513153225183487,
-0.012008479796350002,
-0.01768428273499012,
-0.011503864079713821,
0.043880753219127655,
-0.030488111078739166,
-0.04211866110563278,
0.014989257790148258,
0.004520368296653032,
0.04186176136136055,
0.019747750833630562,
0.011404620483517647,
0.030802177265286446,
0.01486234925687313,
-0.014803661964833736,
0.013151847757399082,
0.0313287153840065,
-0.04107659310102463,
0.05107864737510681,
0.018092511221766472,
-0.017201486974954605,
0.013079347088932991,
-0.01862899214029312,
0.09359674900770187,
0.057097259908914566,
-0.04114605858922005,
-0.034854501485824585,
0.016828101128339767,
0.007099176291376352,
0.04554424434900284,
0.025041770190000534,
0.021341117098927498,
-0.0006856615655124187,
-0.011480364948511124,
0.018901878967881203,
-0.018627963960170746,
0.05297904834151268,
-0.04494922608137131,
-0.016638118773698807,
0.043677158653736115,
-0.04441651329398155,
0.07899806648492813,
0.00921730138361454,
0.00024051894433796406,
0.015531877987086773,
0.002790840808302164,
-0.013727450743317604,
-0.008344304747879505,
-0.05678994208574295,
0.0034639553632587194,
0.01539977453649044,
-0.015732279047369957,
-0.016804900020360947,
-0.07003746926784515,
0.01488664373755455,
-0.018806463107466698,
0.04451695829629898,
0.04621237888932228,
0.027236314490437508,
0.03266453370451927,
-0.01944511942565441,
-0.04102586209774017,
0.0115811787545681,
-0.07750710099935532,
-0.04700799658894539,
0.007504546549171209,
0.005881011951714754,
0.012191188521683216,
0.021558567881584167,
-0.014427500776946545,
0.02545841410756111,
-0.03278511017560959,
-0.014672821387648582,
-0.003912781365215778,
0.019860180094838142,
0.0007146724965423346,
-0.047265198081731796,
-0.006740799639374018,
0.010124312713742256,
0.03566623479127884,
-0.036236297339200974,
-0.000227115917368792,
-0.021846892312169075,
-0.033202916383743286,
-0.011506570503115654,
-0.05854526907205582,
0.00346303335390985,
0.0282097477465868,
0.03810785710811615,
0.018462592735886574,
0.003735144389793277,
0.024315865710377693,
0.057377442717552185,
0.03600183129310608,
0.02099858969449997,
0.029237525537610054,
-0.0390850231051445,
0.03591974452137947,
-0.008695675991475582,
0.04391045868396759,
-0.003773242235183716,
-0.01847166195511818,
0.006150675471872091,
-0.017970286309719086,
-0.010090768337249756,
-0.02282012067735195,
-0.2764570415019989,
-0.04171709343791008,
-0.007758530788123608,
0.012059515342116356,
0.03861429542303085,
-0.03379565477371216,
0.06793374568223953,
-0.03972795978188515,
-0.011854846961796284,
0.0019911497365683317,
0.05032658204436302,
0.001850151689723134,
-0.005281607620418072,
0.06933506578207016,
0.0427800677716732,
0.03402888774871826,
-0.012498501688241959,
-0.01889278180897236,
0.006662765517830849,
0.03431359678506851,
-0.058555252850055695,
-0.09354383498430252,
-0.00030840508406981826,
0.05154278129339218,
-0.008754776790738106,
0.04001922160387039,
-0.05632922425866127,
-0.013915170915424824,
-0.023366417735815048,
-0.01900050975382328,
-0.01434431504458189,
-0.035180043429136276,
-0.026599427685141563,
0.003800958627834916,
0.042466893792152405,
-0.02589709497988224,
0.021274467930197716,
-0.01483889576047659,
0.040234535932540894,
0.03143934905529022,
0.008655481971800327,
-0.015030800364911556,
-0.04630442336201668,
0.018193477764725685,
0.05021689087152481,
0.004727017600089312,
-0.05449846386909485,
-0.02826623246073723,
-0.0036264765076339245,
0.033837370574474335,
0.02195778116583824,
-0.003238800447434187,
-0.020944302901625633,
0.01967102661728859,
-0.016130579635500908,
-0.0034757794346660376,
0.01894759014248848,
-0.0023025861009955406,
-0.007836397737264633,
0.007793063763529062,
0.000007711207217653282,
-0.040279533714056015,
-0.04796836897730827,
-0.0020663258619606495,
-0.024546902626752853,
-0.03771951422095299,
-0.1105552390217781,
-0.09097353368997574,
0.02353569120168686,
0.04217866063117981,
-0.013168222270905972,
-0.02083767019212246,
-0.01479837391525507,
-0.0981845036149025,
-0.011217324994504452,
-0.0308845192193985,
-0.021438434720039368,
-0.0051073054783046246,
-0.03419940546154976,
0.02367614395916462,
-0.022429484874010086,
-0.05907488614320755,
-0.004577659070491791,
0.000755321467295289,
0.018896182999014854,
-0.02319948375225067,
0.00001557791438244749,
-0.06423132121562958,
-0.03667505085468292,
-0.024440165609121323,
0.03783999755978584,
-0.007160981651395559,
-0.002859862055629492,
-0.005768312141299248,
0.07486625760793686,
0.019243042916059494,
0.030061619356274605,
0.050666239112615585,
0.008481467142701149,
-0.003437180770561099,
0.022380946204066277,
-0.1250375211238861,
0.009156282059848309,
-0.02451338805258274,
-0.040565308183431625,
0.0502638965845108,
-0.03425354138016701,
-0.02905345894396305,
0.048455480486154556,
0.025566918775439262,
-0.00651085190474987,
-0.058918267488479614,
-0.02219550311565399,
-0.011167853139340878,
-0.0350395031273365,
-0.0273625198751688,
0.005432471167296171,
0.002092119539156556,
0.036009129136800766,
0.033521827310323715,
-0.01376134343445301,
0.055635347962379456,
0.0028849432710558176,
0.01576424576342106,
-0.016439005732536316,
-0.03032059036195278,
-0.025355905294418335,
-0.04431209713220596,
0.036475200206041336,
-0.02309962920844555,
0.05357607081532478,
0.04504997655749321,
-0.00794485304504633,
0.01670362614095211,
0.018221117556095123,
-0.027786586433649063,
0.001583130331709981,
-0.015025612898170948,
0.009804163128137589,
-0.040023550391197205,
0.028724072501063347,
-0.04152969270944595,
0.024330943822860718,
-0.006879751570522785,
-0.017002051696181297,
-0.013365568593144417,
0.016373343765735626,
-0.03382207825779915,
-0.0009014495881274343,
0.02702762931585312,
0.007388661149889231,
-0.04481852799654007,
0.008341959677636623,
-0.02067640610039234,
0.014104346744716167,
-0.00047823647037148476,
0.02251451276242733,
-0.010567449033260345,
-0.0037424915935844183,
-0.056330323219299316,
0.03552093356847763,
-0.01124891173094511,
-0.032209962606430054,
-0.0026991453487426043,
0.02081928960978985,
0.06302667409181595,
-0.018251225352287292,
-0.010462579317390919,
-0.046224113553762436,
0.03173746168613434,
0.024548331275582314,
-0.0364474356174469,
-0.011678531765937805,
-0.06746044009923935,
-0.048167262226343155,
-0.026603780686855316,
0.017279256135225296,
-0.022969434037804604,
-0.06332629173994064,
0.04510551691055298,
-0.0056908042170107365,
-0.02527700923383236,
-0.009122482500970364,
-0.03325695917010307,
0.06047999486327171,
0.01386406272649765,
0.008418750017881393,
-0.0037696545477956533,
-0.021906819194555283,
-0.013246205635368824,
-0.004098193719983101,
0.006988339126110077,
-0.03023892641067505,
-0.054078396409749985,
-0.038353536278009415,
-0.025827307254076004,
0.02893858402967453,
-0.01724766567349434,
0.006062575150281191,
0.019467484205961227,
-0.005274886265397072,
0.02854199893772602,
-0.023371543735265732,
-0.0348760262131691,
0.04301171749830246,
-0.08817828446626663,
0.017262810841202736,
0.028966855257749557,
-0.011634320951998234,
0.017689894884824753,
-0.011011341586709023,
-0.023634251207113266,
-0.02156146429479122,
-0.02825155295431614,
0.0035705920308828354,
-0.02413370832800865,
-0.03337869420647621,
-0.0258480291813612,
-0.030317148193717003,
-0.01012563705444336,
0.016190798953175545,
-0.008489074185490608,
-0.00886526983231306,
-0.005646911915391684,
-0.0026043131947517395,
0.04283222556114197,
-0.02320374734699726,
-0.00884989183396101,
-0.014683748595416546,
-0.0174249354749918,
0.01969270594418049,
-0.04933232069015503,
0.007547279354184866,
0.039094459265470505,
-0.00029100198298692703,
0.009919879958033562,
-0.019922547042369843,
0.02746899425983429,
0.03434784710407257,
-0.026953013613820076,
-0.02169162966310978,
-0.04829687252640724,
-0.03828233480453491,
0.0009949238738045096,
0.045934081077575684,
0.0371689647436142,
-0.015671422705054283,
-0.014732955023646355,
-0.000989816035144031,
0.01005647610872984,
-0.008150842040777206,
0.0002796804183162749,
-0.01572532206773758,
0.012121285311877728,
0.0350927896797657,
-0.019653959199786186,
-0.039846789091825485,
-0.04704829677939415,
-0.026418836787343025,
-0.010989402420818806,
-0.003972466569393873,
0.03943413868546486,
-0.047830913215875626,
0.029315831139683723,
0.01815226674079895,
0.03274092823266983,
0.006691490299999714,
-0.03736691176891327,
0.03709881752729416,
-0.08682137727737427,
0.023995021358132362,
-0.059089839458465576,
-0.02069993130862713,
0.044925156980752945,
-0.03192568197846413,
-0.023092227056622505,
0.033460989594459534,
-0.013494894839823246,
0.013031376525759697,
-0.028426550328731537,
-0.039047401398420334,
0.0069236187264323235,
-0.021133648231625557,
0.045934900641441345,
0.03784361109137535,
-0.06331437826156616,
0.011283817701041698,
-0.0488072969019413,
-0.04077506065368652,
-0.006373427342623472,
0.008033432066440582,
0.061541423201560974,
0.012525519356131554,
0.04111170023679733,
-0.04705192148685455,
0.04066402092576027,
0.027524633333086967,
0.04464240372180939,
-0.01037630345672369,
0.040641870349645615,
-0.023911070078611374,
0.07426255941390991,
0.038335952907800674,
0.012273071333765984,
0.039493147283792496,
-0.009800144471228123,
-0.00808335654437542,
-0.05121685937047005,
0.023630719631910324,
0.0199253112077713,
-0.007551799062639475,
-0.04673267528414726,
0.08997538685798645,
0.010437725111842155,
-0.050722427666187286,
0.005998192820698023,
0.034227706491947174,
-0.05329105630517006,
0.022516770288348198,
0.01970881037414074,
0.003637569025158882,
0.017876703292131424,
0.07021015882492065,
0.01507558673620224,
0.08211129158735275,
0.06467147171497345,
0.02548883482813835,
-0.017455674707889557,
0.021316859871149063,
0.06394727528095245,
0.07421325892210007,
0.04882004112005234,
-0.018126491457223892,
0.0592181570827961,
-0.026879018172621727,
-0.039022162556648254,
0.014964169822633266,
0.03866269439458847,
-0.02405596524477005,
-0.012981995940208435,
0.013998239301145077,
0.06434959173202515,
0.0098069217056036,
0.0535363033413887,
0.007017889991402626,
-0.03616403788328171,
0.03801450505852699,
0.02451631985604763,
0.026503341272473335,
0.043005384504795074,
0.03177725523710251,
0.030135368928313255,
-0.05702551081776619,
0.0009276413475163281,
0.032834071666002274,
0.02468062750995159,
0.012608668766915798,
0.007284859195351601,
-0.028248609974980354,
0.040310539305210114,
-0.011278127320110798,
0.03175724297761917,
0.10549090802669525,
-0.02347114309668541,
-0.009730922058224678,
0.01398354023694992,
-0.002022562548518181,
-0.032413434237241745,
0.036488763988018036,
0.030534090474247932,
-0.009175928309559822,
0.016957275569438934,
-0.04842511564493179,
0.013580975122749805,
0.04098029062151909,
0.001904029049910605,
0.05187522992491722,
-0.06225963681936264,
0.001966954441741109,
0.030747035518288612,
0.02679155208170414,
-0.06987743824720383,
-0.03465940058231354,
-0.034672413021326065,
-0.047507841140031815,
-0.0371498167514801,
-0.013679364696145058,
0.03300686553120613,
0.01193248201161623,
-0.04457659646868706,
0.01327536627650261,
-0.012924890965223312,
0.01492475438863039,
0.024010730907320976,
-0.06733831018209457,
0.01056575309485197,
0.024264728650450706,
0.03580145165324211,
0.03391338884830475,
0.03159252926707268,
0.03050285018980503,
-0.011994185857474804,
0.008722709491848946,
0.04079355672001839,
0.007825932465493679,
-0.019268663600087166,
-0.027944646775722504,
-0.02729611285030842,
-0.1019289568066597,
-0.022553298622369766,
0.02729290910065174,
-0.03275371342897415,
-0.08910210430622101,
0.03448489308357239,
-0.052588269114494324,
0.037703439593315125,
0.06478264927864075,
0.046729981899261475,
0.018063129857182503,
-0.0023723067715764046,
-0.00038493346073664725,
-0.02015456184744835,
-0.0023296051658689976,
0.03986774757504463,
-0.04914412274956703,
0.039507266134023666,
0.013460656628012657,
-0.029996944591403008,
-0.02356095053255558,
0.04847968742251396,
-0.015321046113967896,
-0.010571430437266827,
-0.0007968097343109548,
-0.060799576342105865,
-0.018482692539691925,
-0.09349513798952103,
0.004809267353266478,
0.032158177345991135,
0.017637033015489578,
-0.0566471703350544,
-0.005678423680365086,
0.04105830937623978,
-0.024055978283286095,
0.011737692169845104,
-0.017038647085428238,
-0.0017948915483430028,
-0.04305219650268555,
0.01747036725282669,
-0.08791420608758926,
0.031003741547465324,
-0.05228649824857712,
0.012575235217809677,
-0.010125584900379181,
-0.04402147978544235,
0.009608608670532703,
0.00026174657978117466,
0.04417433962225914,
0.003063829615712166,
0.038264404982328415,
0.0165331419557333
] |
9 |
Can Neural Networks Achieve Optimal Computational-statistical Tradeoff? An Analysis on Single-Index Model
|
https://openreview.net/forum?id=is4nCVkSFA
|
[
"Siyu Chen",
"Beining Wu",
"Miao Lu",
"Zhuoran Yang",
"Tianhao Wang"
] |
Oral
|
In this work, we tackle the following question: Can neural networks trained with gradient-based methods achieve the optimal statistical-computational tradeoff in learning Gaussian single-index models?
Prior research has shown that any polynomial-time algorithm under the statistical query (SQ) framework requires $\Omega(d^{s^\star/2}\lor d)$ samples, where $s^\star$ is the generative exponent representing the intrinsic difficulty of learning the underlying model.
However, it remains unknown whether neural networks can achieve this sample complexity.
Inspired by prior techniques such as label transformation and landscape smoothing for learning single-index models, we propose a unified gradient-based algorithm for training a two-layer neural network in polynomial time.
Our method is adaptable to a variety of loss and activation functions, covering a broad class of existing approaches.
We show that our algorithm learns a feature representation that strongly aligns with the unknown signal $\theta^\star$, with sample complexity $\tilde O (d^{s^\star/2} \lor d)$, matching the SQ lower bound up to a polylogarithmic factor for all generative exponents $s^\star\geq 1$.
Furthermore, we extend our approach to the setting where $\theta^\star$ is $k$-sparse for $k = o(\sqrt{d})$ by introducing a novel weight perturbation technique that leverages the sparsity structure.
We derive a corresponding SQ lower bound
of order $\tilde\Omega(k^{s^\star})$, matched by our method up to a polylogarithmic factor.
Our framework, especially the weight perturbation technique, is of independent interest, and suggests potential gradient-based solutions to other problems such as sparse tensor PCA.
|
single-index model, feature learning, gradient-based method, computational-statistical tradeoff
|
We propose a unified gradient-based algorithm for feature learning in Gaussian single-index model with sample complexity matching the SQ lower bound
| 13,084 | null |
[
-0.03677269443869591,
-0.015584495849907398,
0.03281797841191292,
0.04215344414114952,
0.038520459085702896,
0.05101076140999794,
0.02697884477674961,
-0.0008036288199946284,
-0.061751846224069595,
-0.033139947801828384,
0.0052408333867788315,
0.0025670421309769154,
-0.06572360545396805,
-0.006511524319648743,
-0.005599609110504389,
0.0731394812464714,
0.027529355138540268,
-0.03057645633816719,
-0.017904585227370262,
0.013248647563159466,
-0.00861036404967308,
-0.018200833350419998,
0.03863640874624252,
0.02784273773431778,
0.024102436378598213,
-0.02070978656411171,
0.0023423172533512115,
0.01205138023942709,
-0.010781869292259216,
0.01687147468328476,
0.05309208855032921,
0.0045425728894770145,
0.001424152054823935,
-0.013377642259001732,
0.022239476442337036,
0.024381965398788452,
-0.022119970992207527,
-0.01251568365842104,
-0.009291007183492184,
0.03998841345310211,
-0.03668905049562454,
-0.0007022048230282962,
-0.034038156270980835,
0.055600203573703766,
-0.05298488959670067,
0.01833309233188629,
-0.1020757332444191,
0.024067796766757965,
0.02402178943157196,
-0.0048061697743833065,
-0.08983071893453598,
0.037463486194610596,
0.0029806983657181263,
-0.02409476228058338,
-0.011537781916558743,
0.04957396164536476,
0.027049627155065536,
-0.030369210988283157,
-0.016917090862989426,
-0.03584890440106392,
-0.03071865253150463,
0.016198229044675827,
-0.008689398877322674,
0.010402456857264042,
-0.03246324509382248,
-0.010434494353830814,
0.019088562577962875,
0.0534343458712101,
-0.0658198818564415,
-0.00809298362582922,
-0.020989304408431053,
-0.010828854516148567,
0.0036296413745731115,
0.019420703873038292,
0.0004693371884059161,
-0.021999862045049667,
0.030675478279590607,
0.018431860953569412,
0.07117970287799835,
0.003858808660879731,
0.016600944101810455,
0.006881297565996647,
0.035302355885505676,
0.01350369118154049,
-0.004115491174161434,
0.011408695951104164,
-0.03794527053833008,
-0.032653678208589554,
-0.09236796945333481,
0.059371963143348694,
0.001606325851753354,
-0.03430461883544922,
0.006327919661998749,
0.03010137565433979,
0.007490921765565872,
0.017901888117194176,
0.04144328460097313,
-0.0008337790495716035,
-0.008800153620541096,
0.0003352224885020405,
-0.005543024279177189,
-0.008476467803120613,
0.02320822887122631,
-0.0049100653268396854,
-0.09762930870056152,
-0.025096150115132332,
0.0233603548258543,
-0.00003843208105536178,
-0.01188603788614273,
-0.011845014989376068,
-0.05487661808729172,
0.0033108917996287346,
0.00404004193842411,
-0.011039898730814457,
-0.0785897970199585,
0.006033655256032944,
-0.019880538806319237,
0.02101345732808113,
-0.00044689932838082314,
-0.008956536650657654,
0.05133429169654846,
0.048039909452199936,
-0.02219511941075325,
0.05969316512346268,
-0.001074581523425877,
0.005136174149811268,
0.053385909646749496,
0.06765449047088623,
-0.034702081233263016,
-0.027461685240268707,
-0.004123198799788952,
0.015403575263917446,
-0.009065200574696064,
0.017381003126502037,
0.011288746260106564,
-0.03506600484251976,
-0.03650237247347832,
0.027405017986893654,
0.025871191173791885,
0.0069682784378528595,
0.006935504265129566,
-0.031861621886491776,
0.06644751131534576,
-0.02413521520793438,
0.06892812252044678,
-0.04654424637556076,
0.038570549339056015,
-0.018105540424585342,
-0.02328122779726982,
-0.02804984152317047,
0.015938041731715202,
0.0011314642615616322,
0.002287069568410516,
-0.06516262143850327,
-0.021069727838039398,
0.0465545579791069,
0.006969845853745937,
0.013732830062508583,
0.01375877670943737,
-0.0081784687936306,
0.011601542122662067,
-0.021640125662088394,
0.0011577819241210818,
0.018886126577854156,
-0.01896154321730137,
-0.045513544231653214,
0.0602441281080246,
0.0461842343211174,
-0.03009379468858242,
0.01811101846396923,
-0.020758328959345818,
-0.03431619703769684,
0.05166451260447502,
0.004934875760227442,
-0.015764981508255005,
-0.016327179968357086,
0.05151725560426712,
0.006104843225330114,
0.06640931963920593,
-0.010833197273314,
-0.09058225154876709,
0.044634003192186356,
0.021027209237217903,
-0.0005408433498814702,
0.011011420749127865,
-0.02110389620065689,
0.10361520946025848,
-0.03413792699575424,
0.035320769995450974,
-0.0035737811122089624,
-0.07082941383123398,
-0.019277576357126236,
0.009662510827183723,
-0.044628433883190155,
0.07802451401948929,
0.026194825768470764,
0.0017482052790001035,
0.015118551440536976,
0.016676118597388268,
0.025615796446800232,
0.06420700997114182,
-0.04017338156700134,
0.047630175948143005,
-0.0114503875374794,
-0.060577403753995895,
-0.015559849329292774,
0.04998783394694328,
-0.07477042824029922,
-0.02784547209739685,
0.02221493050456047,
0.0047927373088896275,
-0.022286511957645416,
-0.010736724361777306,
0.005364936776459217,
0.024936066940426826,
0.013558673672378063,
-0.023312509059906006,
0.018634159117937088,
0.012216305360198021,
-0.03751470148563385,
0.03053939901292324,
0.009020155295729637,
-0.02582978457212448,
-0.003786243963986635,
0.001271314569748938,
0.10168344527482986,
0.07573787122964859,
-0.029293060302734375,
-0.001818703138269484,
0.025249529629945755,
0.014465461485087872,
-0.011539128609001637,
0.021055856719613075,
-0.014066943898797035,
0.028851842507719994,
-0.0032690642401576042,
-0.021351592615246773,
-0.056630756705999374,
0.08608794212341309,
-0.04633107781410217,
-0.01020733267068863,
0.07037606090307236,
-0.025707531720399857,
0.04846328869462013,
0.014609966427087784,
-0.00031239594682119787,
0.020975474268198013,
-0.02246067486703396,
-0.021355900913476944,
-0.03085009567439556,
-0.053963061422109604,
0.011778799816966057,
-0.005179664585739374,
0.0046832445077598095,
0.007055134046822786,
-0.07197275757789612,
-0.029204318299889565,
-0.007409848738461733,
0.08521527796983719,
0.026502307504415512,
0.010155153460800648,
0.011990499682724476,
0.021767547354102135,
-0.019689379259943962,
-0.025559905916452408,
-0.10689372569322586,
-0.05931917577981949,
-0.023658184334635735,
0.044581227004528046,
0.014815334230661392,
0.041080910712480545,
-0.004454732872545719,
0.018105236813426018,
-0.04080446809530258,
-0.032683517783880234,
0.0025610518641769886,
0.04071587324142456,
0.019660241901874542,
-0.06098413094878197,
-0.04478058964014053,
0.04788769409060478,
0.061584554612636566,
0.010845260694622993,
-0.03934893012046814,
-0.0358382910490036,
-0.037330448627471924,
-0.04300367832183838,
-0.03766174241900444,
0.0018301670206710696,
-0.008037108927965164,
-0.02818792313337326,
0.027045540511608124,
-0.02304139919579029,
0.0038966278079897165,
0.03170387074351311,
0.05821250379085541,
0.057476215064525604,
0.012990426272153854,
-0.01050453819334507,
-0.004205198958516121,
-0.0015238450141623616,
0.029926417395472527,
-0.023227734491229057,
0.015565479174256325,
-0.041744403541088104,
0.004559418186545372,
0.005689798854291439,
-0.0008759167976677418,
-0.2859623432159424,
-0.024441983550786972,
-0.0037704657297581434,
-0.0014895317144691944,
-0.007005742751061916,
-0.020933153107762337,
0.04854416102170944,
-0.027554575353860855,
0.01478479988873005,
0.004453696776181459,
0.005774172954261303,
-0.004162539262324572,
-0.021200664341449738,
0.05620116740465164,
0.011297585442662239,
0.0076171234250068665,
0.018144428730010986,
-0.008023523725569248,
0.005660642869770527,
0.03171030431985855,
0.007452121004462242,
-0.06403703987598419,
0.018941029906272888,
0.04312625527381897,
-0.009112109430134296,
0.08236215263605118,
-0.06203089654445648,
-0.029969876632094383,
-0.04490583762526512,
-0.02268265187740326,
-0.02406344749033451,
-0.03815608471632004,
-0.029691940173506737,
0.03886093571782112,
0.01787020079791546,
-0.005076210014522076,
0.0226727444678545,
-0.025812311097979546,
0.0039803460240364075,
0.05636445805430412,
-0.005732642486691475,
-0.005946559831500053,
-0.003538857912644744,
0.0007422954076901078,
0.05069487541913986,
0.02118515595793724,
-0.030556438490748405,
0.0027362811379134655,
0.004091731738299131,
0.029408074915409088,
-0.0432455912232399,
-0.04144476354122162,
0.0023462011013180017,
0.005962728057056665,
-0.004989228677004576,
-0.039907731115818024,
0.018232397735118866,
-0.009153184480965137,
0.0012808457249775529,
0.017022470012307167,
-0.0009829751215875149,
-0.058751072734594345,
-0.006203308701515198,
-0.06114758551120758,
-0.037508923560380936,
-0.02532196417450905,
-0.07575397193431854,
-0.06915996223688126,
0.05809963494539261,
0.014488053508102894,
0.009375841356813908,
0.01241386029869318,
-0.014739072881639004,
-0.07848398387432098,
0.012340097688138485,
0.003030691994354129,
-0.016530590131878853,
0.010940656065940857,
-0.02203386463224888,
0.054479748010635376,
-0.020937616005539894,
-0.07102818787097931,
0.024070851504802704,
0.03123496286571026,
0.039092857390642166,
-0.0434173047542572,
-0.007203534245491028,
-0.005026162602007389,
-0.013613363727927208,
-0.023652251809835434,
0.037409260869026184,
-0.010449766181409359,
0.05506141111254692,
0.001913420855998993,
0.05663413181900978,
0.03511829674243927,
0.031176382675766945,
0.027407260611653328,
0.023361705243587494,
-0.018470555543899536,
0.04741843044757843,
-0.03651174157857895,
-0.02545168809592724,
-0.0337010957300663,
-0.04885357245802879,
0.030343331396579742,
-0.023316001519560814,
-0.008896482177078724,
0.021771665662527084,
-0.03391656279563904,
-0.006872761528939009,
-0.07676021009683609,
-0.03619144484400749,
-0.015888789668679237,
-0.0034950068220496178,
-0.015612759627401829,
-0.011233974248170853,
0.018580157309770584,
0.029901549220085144,
-0.019843721762299538,
-0.027482613921165466,
0.04642174020409584,
-0.025510262697935104,
-0.020696375519037247,
-0.019613344222307205,
0.005575438961386681,
0.000033337328204652295,
-0.051343634724617004,
-0.0202137790620327,
-0.0030984957702457905,
0.03884048014879227,
0.024481553584337234,
0.010267233476042747,
0.028655407950282097,
0.05720029026269913,
0.017549676820635796,
0.010501332581043243,
0.009650296531617641,
0.03506530448794365,
0.009710211306810379,
0.05739694461226463,
-0.005373523570597172,
0.026502475142478943,
0.04099981486797333,
0.014187583699822426,
0.025011908262968063,
0.026666203513741493,
-0.005431529600173235,
-0.01263401098549366,
0.00011289022222626954,
0.03868510201573372,
-0.030518731102347374,
-0.005966354627162218,
-0.03296034038066864,
-0.003343496471643448,
0.021883001551032066,
0.044608499854803085,
-0.01132391020655632,
-0.0033097569830715656,
-0.06341643631458282,
0.08948066830635071,
0.012303374707698822,
-0.03170138597488403,
-0.027592910453677177,
0.03643060475587845,
0.05744301900267601,
-0.01889631524682045,
0.016167597845196724,
0.02651614509522915,
0.03437957912683487,
0.02109513431787491,
-0.020788125693798065,
-0.021727576851844788,
-0.04386609420180321,
-0.032756004482507706,
-0.0124824782833457,
0.02719956636428833,
0.003373377025127411,
-0.03386153280735016,
0.022812802344560623,
0.018577009439468384,
-0.024432040750980377,
-0.03560842573642731,
0.021638115867972374,
0.0742591917514801,
0.015729038044810295,
-0.000979292206466198,
-0.0005689391982741654,
-0.052205562591552734,
0.03729040548205376,
-0.004929949063807726,
0.0060557834804058075,
-0.022692307829856873,
-0.029523493722081184,
0.01692231371998787,
-0.020336546003818512,
0.003621048992499709,
0.019190918654203415,
0.004774911794811487,
0.017028214409947395,
-0.006508689373731613,
0.013086709193885326,
-0.05358811840415001,
0.011710859835147858,
0.028708189725875854,
-0.061745185405015945,
0.03274408355355263,
0.026553306728601456,
-0.04634777456521988,
0.029239637777209282,
-0.027712997049093246,
-0.023023832589387894,
-0.02650824375450611,
0.009482208639383316,
0.044369373470544815,
-0.004302839748561382,
-0.02445029281079769,
0.010469152592122555,
0.020316315814852715,
-0.007598031312227249,
-0.011845264583826065,
-0.005950852297246456,
0.027579985558986664,
-0.02250037156045437,
-0.0025642390828579664,
0.05698329210281372,
-0.008223052136600018,
-0.007926581427454948,
-0.007158702705055475,
-0.024780675768852234,
0.03326369822025299,
-0.04319030046463013,
-0.010608919896185398,
0.06754661351442337,
0.01909000240266323,
-0.002527698175981641,
-0.029936140403151512,
0.017248019576072693,
0.014126376248896122,
0.022727521136403084,
-0.00865218322724104,
0.024619141593575478,
-0.03976147994399071,
0.007981971837580204,
0.006558164954185486,
0.03727616369724274,
0.04029742255806923,
0.006720041856169701,
0.001015865826047957,
0.008405303582549095,
0.016538290306925774,
0.015245314687490463,
-0.07409364730119705,
-0.01987743377685547,
0.07326231151819229,
-0.020761705935001373,
-0.056418221443891525,
-0.062960185110569,
-0.02258230559527874,
0.04554727301001549,
-0.022869929671287537,
0.03798408433794975,
-0.039931055158376694,
0.04304983839392662,
0.033023934811353683,
0.054406896233558655,
-0.01651798188686371,
-0.026105478405952454,
0.052244361490011215,
-0.05548148229718208,
-0.024290677160024643,
-0.07104374468326569,
-0.04244794696569443,
0.05937992036342621,
-0.015900392085313797,
0.04165538400411606,
0.025972476229071617,
-0.02638009935617447,
0.045387428253889084,
-0.034756097942590714,
-0.054126206785440445,
0.022981567308306694,
-0.029968122020363808,
-0.0024576794821769,
0.02051226608455181,
-0.041591282933950424,
-0.02470334619283676,
0.004861590452492237,
-0.04537218064069748,
0.021291550248861313,
-0.017137305811047554,
0.04087890684604645,
-0.018941445276141167,
-0.00918781477957964,
-0.02982192300260067,
-0.0006111216498538852,
0.03134177625179291,
0.05416501313447952,
0.0071174646727740765,
0.015966275706887245,
-0.04891137033700943,
0.059478696435689926,
0.027769966050982475,
0.003433598903939128,
0.013854851946234703,
0.01168602891266346,
-0.003145444206893444,
-0.06914577633142471,
0.03919930383563042,
-0.010671831667423248,
-0.023739537224173546,
-0.0769747644662857,
0.03792886435985565,
0.02745787985622883,
-0.0692611038684845,
-0.02745210751891136,
0.018141157925128937,
-0.05165017768740654,
0.014788438566029072,
0.004552558995783329,
-0.012912910431623459,
0.03099539875984192,
0.07628920674324036,
-0.0007960328948684037,
0.04178446903824806,
0.06639911979436874,
0.005009167827665806,
-0.0024856110103428364,
0.016290228813886642,
0.055513929575681686,
0.05743785202503204,
0.030516047030687332,
0.014452757313847542,
0.04808803275227547,
-0.020252466201782227,
-0.05902320519089699,
-0.0004176033544354141,
-0.013316267170011997,
-0.03209604322910309,
-0.031245360150933266,
0.013518410734832287,
0.06883379817008972,
0.0304856039583683,
0.08848694711923599,
-0.05818376690149307,
0.00839766301214695,
0.04107159748673439,
-0.013168933801352978,
0.010920855216681957,
0.01285370159894228,
0.007407274562865496,
0.02106267213821411,
-0.01691710203886032,
-0.03532272204756737,
-0.016845909878611565,
0.014889598824083805,
0.015848852694034576,
-0.006442413665354252,
-0.016873827204108238,
0.01336898747831583,
0.017247537150979042,
0.03821490332484245,
0.07636423408985138,
-0.0449833869934082,
-0.0555126890540123,
-0.010358281433582306,
0.04037560522556305,
0.0008011696045286953,
0.04965468868613243,
0.0021107038483023643,
-0.03213624656200409,
-0.003284888342022896,
-0.033651530742645264,
0.03177203983068466,
0.0225391685962677,
0.0034115740563720465,
-0.0019130076980218291,
-0.023761827498674393,
-0.004126889631152153,
0.015343444421887398,
0.039719946682453156,
-0.04144114628434181,
-0.0643857792019844,
-0.030600586906075478,
-0.043108679354190826,
-0.047873497009277344,
-0.08482354134321213,
-0.011615525931119919,
0.00013206283620093018,
-0.03441096469759941,
0.005550567526370287,
-0.028751907870173454,
0.02720104157924652,
0.02874581143260002,
-0.054857395589351654,
0.006812590640038252,
0.03142146021127701,
0.013868368230760098,
0.014204168692231178,
0.024347949773073196,
0.03779945150017738,
-0.036945294588804245,
-0.012515963986515999,
0.04970614239573479,
0.006964866071939468,
0.0223589688539505,
-0.001704695401713252,
0.010792949236929417,
-0.09817933291196823,
0.014973541721701622,
0.007264556363224983,
-0.06184903159737587,
-0.0834185779094696,
0.005243007559329271,
-0.02332276850938797,
0.014967236667871475,
0.06404004991054535,
0.004130394663661718,
-0.004799769725650549,
-0.05773954465985298,
-0.015971830114722252,
-0.016531025990843773,
0.0178730096668005,
0.05943997949361801,
-0.0005631790845654905,
0.02120342291891575,
0.033605340868234634,
-0.0035997931845486164,
-0.02187838777899742,
0.00948338583111763,
-0.05321064963936806,
0.022599218413233757,
-0.028810076415538788,
-0.028876127675175667,
-0.04127845913171768,
-0.10303116589784622,
-0.018976012244820595,
0.013375015929341316,
-0.011975305154919624,
-0.02700783684849739,
-0.01598968356847763,
-0.0037364282179623842,
0.011022644117474556,
-0.02187209017574787,
-0.004707979038357735,
-0.03703184425830841,
-0.04479024559259415,
-0.038392018526792526,
-0.09885053336620331,
0.040020715445280075,
-0.013138777576386929,
0.0014231681125238538,
-0.006614052224904299,
-0.04167145863175392,
-0.028963573276996613,
-0.028628265485167503,
0.039124492555856705,
0.02570147067308426,
0.023356134071946144,
-0.009490704163908958
] |
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 64
Size of downloaded dataset files:
22.4 MB
Size of the auto-converted Parquet files:
22.4 MB
Number of rows:
3,705