Datasets:

tasksource
/

corr2cause

Modalities:

Text

Formats:

parquet

Size:

100K - 1M

ArXiv:

Libraries:

Datasets

Dask

License:

Dataset card Data Studio Files Files and versions Community

Dataset Viewer

Auto-converted to Parquet

Split (3)

train · 411k rows

premise stringlengths 270 9.17k	hypothesis stringlengths 21 46	relation stringclasses 3 values	id stringlengths 75 93
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A directly affects B.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A influences B through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B directly affects A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=child__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B influences A through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A and B together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both A and B.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A directly affects C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A influences C through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C directly affects A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=child__prob=0.62
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C influences A through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A and C together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both A and C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A directly affects D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.50
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A influences D through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D directly affects A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=child__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D influences A through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A and D together cause some other variable(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both A and D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B directly affects A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B influences A through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A directly affects B.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=child__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A influences B through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B and A together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both B and A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B directly affects C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.50
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B influences C through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C directly affects B.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=child__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C influences B through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B and C together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both B and C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B directly affects D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=4__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B influences D through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=4__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.50
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D directly affects B.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=4__causal_relation=child__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D influences B through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=4__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B and D together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=4__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both B and D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=2__node_j=4__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C directly affects A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=1__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.62
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C influences A through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=1__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A directly affects C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=1__causal_relation=child__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A influences C through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=1__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C and A together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=1__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both C and A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=1__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C directly affects B.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=2__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C influences B through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=2__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B directly affects C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=2__causal_relation=child__prob=0.50
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B influences C through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=2__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C and B together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=2__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both C and B.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=2__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C directly affects D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=4__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C influences D through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=4__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D directly affects C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=4__causal_relation=child__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D influences C through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=4__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C and D together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=4__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both C and D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=3__node_j=4__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D directly affects A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=1__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D influences A through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=1__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A directly affects D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=1__causal_relation=child__prob=0.50
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	A influences D through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=1__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D and A together cause some other variable(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=1__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both D and A.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=1__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D directly affects B.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=2__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D influences B through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=2__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B directly affects D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=2__causal_relation=child__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	B influences D through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=2__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.50
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D and B together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=2__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both D and B.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=2__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D directly affects C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=3__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.12
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D influences C through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C directly affects D.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=3__causal_relation=child__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	C influences D through some mediator(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	D and C together cause some other variable(s).	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=3__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.25
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A correlates with B. A correlates with C. A correlates with D. B correlates with C. B correlates with D. C correlates with D. However, B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both D and C.	neutral	num_nodes=4__mec_id=9__node_i=4__node_j=3__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.38
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A directly affects B.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A influences B through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	B directly affects A.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=child__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	B influences A through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A and B together cause some other variable(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both A and B.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=2__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A directly affects C.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A influences C through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	C directly affects A.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=child__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	C influences A through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A and C together cause some other variable(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both A and C.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=3__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A directly affects D.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A influences D through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	D directly affects A.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=child__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	D influences A through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A and D together cause some other variable(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both A and D.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=1__node_j=4__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	B directly affects A.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	B influences A through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A directly affects B.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=child__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	A influences B through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	B and A together cause some other variable(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=has_collider__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	Some variable(s) cause(s) both B and A.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=1__causal_relation=has_confounder__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	B directly affects C.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=parent__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	B influences C through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-parent_ancestor__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	C directly affects B.	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=child__prob=0.00
Suppose there is a closed system of 4 variables, A, B, C and D. All the statistical relations among these 4 variables are as follows: A is independent of B. A and B are independent given C. A and B are independent given C and D. A and B are independent given D. A is independent of C. A and C are independent given B. A and C are independent given B and D. A and C are independent given D. A is independent of D. A and D are independent given B. A and D are independent given B and C. A and D are independent given C. B is independent of C. B and C are independent given A. B and C are independent given A and D. B and C are independent given D. B is independent of D. B and D are independent given A. B and D are independent given A and C. B and D are independent given C. C is independent of D. C and D are independent given A. C and D are independent given A and B. C and D are independent given B.	C influences B through some mediator(s).	contradiction	num_nodes=4__mec_id=0__node_i=2__node_j=3__causal_relation=non-child_descendant__prob=0.00

End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

https://github.com/causalNLP/corr2cause/

The HF dataset provided by the author cannot be directly loaded. We use the NLI subset, which is the most general task.

@article{jin2023can,
  title={Can Large Language Models Infer Causation from Correlation?},
  author={Jin, Zhijing and Liu, Jiarui and Lyu, Zhiheng and Poff, Spencer and Sachan, Mrinmaya and Mihalcea, Rada and Diab, Mona and Sch{\"o}lkopf, Bernhard},
  journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2306.05836},
  year={2023}
}

Downloads last month: 18

Size of downloaded dataset files:

11 MB

Size of the auto-converted Parquet files:

11 MB

Number of rows:

415,944

Models trained or fine-tuned on tasksource/corr2cause